o{]:)

Fr. Z is also Moderator of the Catholic Online Forum and the (now dormant) ASK FATHER Question Box. The WDTPRS columns appear weekly in The Wanderer. Fr. Z is available for retreats and conferences.

* E-MAIL
* TWITTER: @fatherz
LOGIN or REGISTER



ShareThis





RSS FEED...
RSS

   Fr. Z on WDTPRS

↑ Grab this Headline Animator


Recent Posts
  • Benedict XVI to speak to youth about his Hitler Youth experience
  • On Twitter we have "#followfriday"; why not "#anathemasiturday"
  • RECENT POSTS OF INTEREST
  • WDTPRS Collect 23rd Ordinary Sunday - from bondage to true freedom
  • St. Moses, prophet
  • Nice views!
  • WDTPRS: Collect 15th Sunday after Pentecost: hard sailing to our safe port
  • REVIEW: "Crucifixion" by artist Daniel Mitsui

  • Recent Comments:





  • The Z-Cam in the Sabine Chapel is ON AIR!Z-Cam and Radio Sabina: LIVE


    Visit the WDTPRS Stores!
    Buy WDTPRS stuff!





    Calendar



    Subscribe to ...
    The Wanderer

    Subscribe to ... The Catholic Herald - UK





    This blog is hosted by

    Joyent

    Thanks for the support!

    2009 Catholic New Media Awards Winner

    * Best Blog by a Cleric
    * Best Written Blog
    * Most Informative Blog
    * People's Choice Blog
    * Best Podcast by a Cleric
    * Best Podcast by a Man
    * Best Podcast by a Religious
    * Best Produced Podcast
    * Best Video Podcast
    * Funniest Podcast
    * Most Entertaining Podcast
    * Most Informative Podcast
    * Most Spiritual Podcast
    * People's Choice Podcast
    * Best Overall Catholic Website


    2008 Weblog Awards Winner

    2007 Weblog Awards Winner



    * Best Apologetic Blog
    * Best blog by Clergy
    * Best Individual Blog
    * Most Informative Blog
    * Best Insider News Blog
    * Smartest Blog
    * Most Spiritual Blog
    * Best Written Blog






    My site was nominated for Best Religion Blog!


    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Add to Google Reader or Homepage

    Add to My AOL

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Powered by FeedBurner

    Fr. Z's Facebook page



    Where Fr. Z will be:

    July 2010
    S M T W T F S
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    25262728293031
    August 2010
    S M T W T F S
    1234567
    891011121314
    15161718192021
    22232425262728
    293031EC
    September 2010
    S M T W T F S
     1234
    567891011
    12131415161718
    19202122232425
    2627282930EC
    Upcoming Events:
  • Events
    • No events.
  • Buy Fr. Z a cup of coffee!





    Your support makes it possible for me to continue with this blog.




    Will you help?
    Progress toward SEPTEMBER's target...


    -->

    SORRY! Users of Goggle Chrome will find that the Hamster "Basil" has gone on pilgrimage. A cousin may be visible with IE.
    The is on presently on pilgrimage to Rome






    Scan from your mobile using I-NIGMA...



    Updated from time to time.


    I hope you bought Fr. Z a cup of coffee. Do you need some coffee for yourself? Buy coffee from these guys and help build their monastery!

    Help build a monastery.



    30 July 2010

    WDTPRS: COLLECT - 18th Sunday of Ordinary Time - authentic inculturation

    CATEGORY: Our Catholic Identity, WDTPRS — Fr. John Zuhlsdorf @ 1:03 pm

    COLLECT - (2002MR):
    Adesto, Domine, famulis tuis,
    et perpetuam benignitatem largire poscentibus,
    ut his, qui te auctorem et gubernatorem gloriantur habere,
    et grata restaures, et restaurata conserves
    .

    This Collect was not in any previous edition of the Missale Romanum.   In the ancient Gelasian Sacramentary our prayer is present but in slightly different form.  The Veronese Sacramentary reveals that a close cousin of our Collect was used by our ancestors during the month of September.  Our modern version simplified the grammar.  In looking for possible sources for this Collect I found some similar key vocabulary combinations in the works of M. Tullius Cicero (+ B.C. 43 – Ep. ad fam. 2.6.4), the writings of Milan’s great bishop and doctor Ambrose (+397 – Hexameron Day 1.2.7) and in the sermons of the grand Augustine (+430 – s. 293d, 5).   When we hunt for sources for our prayers we verify how deeply interwoven the Church and culture have been over the millennia.  

    The Latin Collects we are given each week have a magnificent content.  When the alter Christus, the priest, lifts these prayers on high in the context of the sacred mysteries of Holy Mass, the words have power to shape us. 

    Christ, the Head of the Body, is speaking.  As Catholics we should long to be formed according to the mind of the Church so that we can understand ourselves to be one Body and then shape our world as a result.  As Christ’s Body it is our solemn duty to bring the content of these prayers (namely Christ Himself!) into every corner of the world we affect.  Once society and our culture are properly shaped and informed, then that culture has something worthy to give back to the Church. 

    This is a dynamic exchange: the Church shapes us; we shape our world around us; we give our holy gifts, good and true and beautiful, the very best we can conceive, back to the Church who integrates them into herself.  The favors God offers through Holy Church must always have logical priority in the interchange between the Church and the world, even though the two-way process is unceasing and simultaneous.  This is authentic inculturation!  This is a critical feature of the Congregation for Divine Worship’s document Liturgiam authenticam which lays down translation norms.  

    Two weeks ago we looked in depth at famulus, a “servant” who was seen in antiquity as part of a household, the extended family.  This word appears frequently in our prayers.  Adesto is the “future” imperative from the verb adsum, “be present” in both the physical and the moral sense.  By logical extension, adsum means, “to be present with one’s aid or support; to stand by, to assist, aid, help, protect, defend, sustain.”  You can understand that a word pointing to the concept of “presence” can have many levels of meaning.  It can also mean, “to be present in mind, with attention, interest, sympathy; also, with courage; to give attention to something, to give heed, observe, attend to; also, to be fearless, be of good courage.”  “Adsum!” is a famous word for Catholics.  In the Rite of Ordination for Bishops, Priests and Deacons, men are ritually “called” to receive Holy Orders.  The names of the ordinands are called out one by one and they respond, “Adsum! …  I am present!”  There is much talk of a “calling” or “vocation” to the priesthood.  While men can have inklings and interior experiences of being called by God, this moment in the rite is the formal moment of a “calling” – vocation.

    We are into the nuts and bolts of our prayer.   Largire is an imperative form of largior which is deponent (active meaning, but passive in form).  According to the always useful Lewis & Short Dictionary, it is “to give bountifully, to lavish, bestow, dispense, distribute, impart.”  The deponent verb glorior means “to glory, boast, vaunt, to brag of any thing, pride one’s self.” Glorior is constructed with the accusative object (as it is in our prayer with an accusative with infinitive) or with the ablative either absolutely or with a preposition.  Something which is gratus, a, um is “beloved, dear, acceptable, pleasing, agreeable” while someone who is gratus is “thankful, grateful; thankworthy, deserving or procuring thanks.”   I am going to translate grata as “favors”, which I hope gets both at the sense of being thankful for something we longed for done for or given to us as well as the beneficial dimension of what God does.

    Many of our Collects at this time of year use similar vocabulary, not just the usual sort of words standard for a Roman prayer, but slightly unusual words which perk up our attention. 

    For example, last week we saw dux (“leader, guide, commander”) and rector (“ruler, leader, governor; helmsman”).    This week we have gubernator, which is “a steersman, pilot” or “a director, ruler, governor”.   Thematically, these terms are equivalent.  

    During the Ordinary Time of our liturgical year there are little groupings of modern Collects linked by vocabulary or theme.  Themes and vocabulary might be, for example, military or agricultural or judicial.  

    The Collects in the Novus Ordo are mostly prayers derived in some way from ancient sacramentaries even if they were also in previous editions of the Missale Romanum.   While they are grouped together now, they were taken from different times of the year.  I cannot help but think that the choice to group them together was a conscious choice.  

    LAME-DUCK ICEL (1973 translation of the 1970MR):
    Father of everlasting goodness,
    our origin and guide,
    be close to us and hear the prayers of all who praise you.
    Forgive our sins and restore us to life.
    Keep us safe in your love
    .

    Some concepts of the Latin found their way in here, but this “Opening prayer”, while undeniably expressing nice thoughts is pretty detached from what the Church wants us to hear. 

    But wait… what’s this I see? 

    Uncharacteristically, ICEL allowed the word “sins” into their version!  

    Our weekly examinations demonstrate that, way back when and with the complicity of many, ICEL consistently expunged references to sin and grace, our own needy humility, God’s majesty, the possibility of hell for the unrepentant, etc., from the prayers we are compelled to use today.  Therefore, I am elated to find in today’s ICEL prayer a reference to sin! 

    It is all the more amusingly ironic that the original Latin does not talk about sin. 

    Would it not be wonderful if the forthcoming translation corrects these blatant mistakes? 

    This might be one of the grata we ask God to restore to us who believe in Him. 

    LITERAL TRANSLATION:
    Be present to Your servants, O Lord,
    and grant Your unending kindness to those seeking it,
    so that You may restore favors to those who
    glory in having You as author and guide,
    and You may preserve them once restored
    .

    My main problem with the ICEL prayer, as nice as it is, is that it has nothing of the urgency and earnestness of the Latin.  It lacks something fundamental in its attitude. 

    Our recognition of who we are and who we are not together with who God is, is fundamental to this Collect. 

    Take note of the different status of those to whom the Latin prayer refers.  On the one hand, God is our creator.  He directs our paths.  He is eternal and kind.  He gives gifts.  He can be present to us.  On the other hand, we are servants and needy seekers.  We need favors and things for which we must be grateful.  They are unattainable apart from God’s kindness.  We do not deserve them apart from Him.

    Some of us have lost God’s favors.  We are incomplete until He restores them to us.  We are weak and incapable of retaining God’s kind gifts unless He Himself preserves them in us once He has given them back.  He will not restore them unless we beg Him in His kindness to do so.  Our lowly status of servant is the key to everything received or regained. 

    The clear, crisp and cold reality of our neediness is masterfully juxtaposed with the warming, healing and reassuring confidence to be found in God’s presence.

    • • • • • •

    11 Comments

    1. What I hear from your words Father Z, is that we need consolation, but also desolation, in order to recognise our everlasting need of God’s mercy, and also His presence. He removes this ( or our ability to sense it) in order for us to seek Him out again. Personally speaking, too much consolation makes me spiritually sluggish. Not that I’m inviting pain Lord! (just incase God thinks that last sentence was a prayer request for a spiritual boot kick!)

      Comment by shadowlands — 30 July 2010 @ 3:20 pm
    2. “Keep us safe in your love” :( I presume that was how they mangled that beautiful final construction “et grata conserves…”. Mental image of a 70s lounge singer, vile-coloured shirt with airplane collar open to the navel, medallion and 16” flares, belting out “Keeeep us saaaafe in yoooour luuuurve. At a “folk” Mass. Pass the sickbag.

      Comment by jaykay — 30 July 2010 @ 3:59 pm
    3. God looks at the heart, not at the flares. Speaking with the tongues of angels can resemble clanging cymbals in heaven, if the heart is not adorned properly.

      Comment by shadowlands — 30 July 2010 @ 4:15 pm
    4. The agenda-driven translations of the original ICEL are a scandal. Vide Prof. Eamonn Duffy’s address to the 1996 Oxford Liturgy conference, and more recent scholarship by a lady whose name I just can’t access now (using a mobile browser). Your comment is valid if those people were starry-eyed innocents with little grasp of liturgical history. They weren’t. They knew what they were doing. But we shan’t have to put up with their roadkill English for too much longer. Deo gratias.

      Comment by jaykay — 30 July 2010 @ 4:36 pm
    5. The lady’s name is Lauren Priestas, if memory serves. Excellent in-depth analysis. I do take your point, Shadowlands, but we haven’t exactly been using the tongues of angels for the last 40 years in our public prayer, whatever about the internal disposition.

      Comment by jaykay — 30 July 2010 @ 5:30 pm
    6. This (literal) translation is a particularly timely and pertinent prayer for me since today I deliver my firstborn to Wyoming Catholic College [HURRAY!] and am (thereby?) more painfully cognizant than ever of my shortcomings as a person and a parent—and how unused I am to asking God for help.  And that such unchild-like habits are hard to break. How spiritually destitute I am because I need His help in order to even ASK for His help!  

      St. Ignatius, pray for us! AMDG . . .

      Comment by q7swallows — 31 July 2010 @ 1:26 am
    7. Jaykay…my childhood contained lots of folk Masses and my precious father wore flares ( slightly flared anyway). Hearing some of the stuff on blogger attacking everything spiritual from that period of my youth, makes me feel I was spiritually aborted at times, as if I am not part of the kingdom, because of my early formation in the Catholic faith. I went through this type of thing before, from fundamentalist protestants that I got involved with, as a teenager, who almost had me convinced that I was damned, due to my being a Catholic. Now it is my own people apparently seeking to put me back under condemnation. This is why I stick up for Catholics formed in the Vatican two era. I became suicidal and in despair through the fundies condemnation. It was a folksy Mass Priest that brought me back to spiritual health, although I still have a long way to go, due to other defects that keep exposing themselves. Prayer does that, doesn’t it (exposes the parts other? Anyway, you may be reassured to hear I went to Prinknash Abbey for Lauds this morning. Don’t understand it, but apparently as a lay person, that’s OK. I just need to listen and meditate. I like listening to Latin, being sung or spoken.

      Comment by shadowlands — 31 July 2010 @ 7:51 am
    8. q7swallows said:

      “How spiritually destitute I am because I need His help in order to even ASK for His help!”

      I call that being spiritually aware, not destitute!!

      Comment by shadowlands — 31 July 2010 @ 7:53 am
    9. “Now it’s my own people apparently trying to put me under condemnation”. No, actually, I wasn’t. You’re reading too much into what I said. Waay too much drama as well. My actual comment centered on the ICEL mangling of that beautiful phrase: “et grata restaures et restaurata conserves”. Their sub-Hallmark rendering of that is truly toe-curlingly awful.

      Comment by jaykay — 31 July 2010 @ 10:53 am
    10. jaykay: I wasn’t referring to you particularly. But I have experienced what I spoke of. Please don’t tell me I am using way (or waaaaay) too much drama. It sounds very patronizing, if not a tad hypocritical, considering the emphasis of emotion you use when describing your own personal grumps.

      That last paragraph of mine all sounds a bit unfriendly when I read through it. Basically, and you will hear me comment this regularly, I do not see, how we, as Catholics can proclaim a Saviour reconciling God to man, when we are not reconciled with each other, within the Catholic Church. This viewpoint is not directed at you jaykay, it is a general observation when visiting different Catholic blogs.

      Comment by shadowlands — 31 July 2010 @ 3:16 pm
    11. It was’t an emphasis of emotion. It’s called humour. Or a (probably) poor attempt at it. Enough already. Rabbit hole.

      Comment by jaykay — 31 July 2010 @ 11:24 pm

    Comments RSS

    Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

    Powered by: Luke 5:1-11 and WordPress