ASK FATHER: Gaining indulgences and “the Pope’s intentions”. Prayer for the Pope, or for what the Pope designates?

From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

The people in the chapel I attend – lay people and even the priests – insist on saying that the rules for indulgences include praying for the pope. [No.] I have tried and failed to instruct them that the proper rules are to pray for the pope’s intentions, [Yes.] not the pope himself, although that is also good to do, of course.

My question is, can praying for the pope merit the indulgences or are they negating their prayers’ indulgence graces by not using the exact form?

The Church gets to prescribe, with Christ’s own authority, how the treasury of the merits of Christ and the Saints are to be applied.  Hence, we do it the way the Church says to do it, not the way we make up.

The Church says that we are to pray for the intentions which the Pope designates, not for the Pope himself.

To be crystal clear, when we read “for the Pope’s intentions”, that means to gain indulgences we do not pray for the Pope, we pray for the intentions which are designated by the Pope.

Since the time of, I believe, Paul VI, Popes have designated intentions each month of the year, usually a “general” and a “missionary” intention.  These days, there seem to be one intention only.  They are posted at the beginning of a calendar year.  For 2019, the USCCB posted Francis’ intentions for the year.  HERE

If you don’t know the specific intention for some month, just pray for the designated intentions in a general way.

If a person in true inculpable ignorance prays for the Pope rather than the intentions designated by the Pope, does that person gain an indulgence?  I hope so.  I don’t know, but I trust that God will be … ehem… indulgent.

However, there is a problem of culpable ignorance.  Priests cannot claim inculpable ignorance about these matters because, by their office, they have a responsibility to know these things.  It is incumbent on priests and bishops constantly to review, broaden, deepen their knowledge about the Faith.  If it is important for, say, dentists to do this about dentistry, how much more important is it for priests, who deal with souls, not mere teeth?  Priests ought to know these things.  Period.   And they should strive also to find out what they don’t know so that they can know it!   

This is a big problem these days.  Many wonks and pundits out there don’t know what they don’t know.   But I digress.

A priest who tells people the wrong thing – pray for the Pope in the matter of indulgences rather than for his designated intentions – is not only not gaining indulgences on his own but is racking up for himself a longer term in purgatory… where he will long for people to get it right about indulgences when praying for him!  (IF… IF… they remember him kindly at all.)

Also, for the sake of those who are legitimately impeded from performing the prescribed work, and it could be either a physical impediment or a moral impediment, confessors (priests who have faculties to receive sacramental confessions) are able to commute – change to something else – both the work prescribed and the conditions required except, for plenary indulgences in particular, detachment from even venial sin.  Authors are divided somewhat on the question of whether any confessor can commute a work for any person outside of the confessional.  It is best to deal with this with one’s own regular confessor in the confessional.

Say a person is somehow physically impeded through illness, distance, weather, whatever, from going to a cemetery or a parish church for some action, work, designated to gain the indulgence.  The confessor can commute that aspect to something else.

Say a person – and this might be more and more the case these days – has a serious problem with the intentions the Pope has designated.  That would be a moral impediment, rather than a physical impediment.  One’s regular confessor could commute that part of the designated work to some other work, for example, praying for intentions consistent with what Popes have always designated and what tradition has enshrined.

I can hear the bleating of the papalatrous even now, “But Father! But Father!”, they squee like fangirls, “You are doing something horrible!  How dare you suggest that everything that this Pope…. this Pope designates isn’t the embodiment of perfection?   His immaculate authority has been demonstrated through the wisdom of synodality and … and non-judgmentalism!  His expansive foresight and unbounded perspicacity is revealed even in his embrace of Mother Earth in the shape of Pachamama!   But YOU… with your judgmental Earth-despising patriarchalist climate-change denial, clinging to those outdated ‘indulgences’ that the Pope mercifully allows you to … to… to… cling to – for now – can’t see his expansiveness because YOU HATE VATICAN II!”

Now that that’s out of the way,

What might such commuted intentions look like… theoretically?

Say, for example… and this is entirely theoretical… a person is truly stymied by Francis’ intention last September 2019: “That politicians, scientists and economists work together to protect the world’s seas and oceans.”   Yes, that really was the intention.  One might legitimately wonder why that has anything to do with what Popes have traditionally designated.

So, you get into the confessional and talk with your confessor about this.  You really want to get an upcoming indulgence for your late grandfather, but…. OCEANS?  He calms you down and says that he can commute that aspect of the work to be performed to pray for some other intention, something which the Church perennially designated to gain indulgences.  Eagerly, you ask what they might be!  Happily, the priest has been broadening his knowledge and has a good idea.

There are also the traditional intentions that were perennially designated.

Click

Because we are Unreconstructed Ossified Manualists, and we love our old dependable compendia of theology with their sober and thorough analyses, we turn to the manual by Prümmer.

Prümmer says that the intentions of the Holy Father for which we are to pray have a tradition of five basic categories which were fixed:

1. Exaltatio S. Matris Ecclesiae (Triumph/elevation/stablity/growth of Holy Mother Church)
2. Extirpatio haeresum (Extirpation/rooting out of heresies),
3. Propagatio fidei (Propagation/expansion/spreading of the Faith)
4. Conversio peccatorum (Conversion of sinners),
5. Pax inter principes christianos (Peace between christian rulers).

These five categories were also listed in the older, 1917 Code of Canon Law, which is now superseded by the 1983 Code.

They remain good intentions, all. I’ll leave it to you to determine whether or not the more recent intentions in any way resemble the classic intentions.

In the theoretical scenario I sketched, above, it could be that the confessor would tell that penitent,

“To fulfill the work to gain the indulgence you desire, pray for the extirpation of heresy from the local seminary.  Can you do that?”

“Oh, yes, Father! Gladly!”

“And for your penance, say one chaplet of the Rosary using the Sorrowful Mysteries because it’s a Friday. Can you do that?”

“Yes, Father.  Thank you.”

“Very good. Make an act of contrition for all your sins and be resigned to the holy will of God in order to gain the plenary indulgence.” ‘O my God…'”.

“Father, can I say it in my native Bulgarian?”

“Of course.  Направи акт на скръб за всичките си грехове и се примири със светата воля Божия, за да спечелиш пленарното снизхождение. Боже мой ….”

We should be diligent in performing the works described by the Church.  We also can be more at ease in accomplishing good works through the flexibility Holy Church provides in her laws.

Please share!
Share

About Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

Fr. Z is the guy who runs this blog. o{]:¬)
This entry was posted in "But Father! But Father!", "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to ASK FATHER: Gaining indulgences and “the Pope’s intentions”. Prayer for the Pope, or for what the Pope designates?

  1. Liturgy Lover says:

    The last couple of pastors at my parish never got it totally right when explaining how to gain plenary indulgences. It’s always been a bit distressing to hear them attempt to explain it and either muddle it up, or leave out some of the requirements. They both knew one had to perform the indulgenced act, and go to Confession and Communion, but they were a lot hazier on the rest of it. Neither, to my knowledge, ever mentioned needing to be free from all attachment to sin. I’m fortunate enough to have been clearly taught all the conditions for gaining plenary indulgences, but I doubt if most of our other parishioners know those things.

  2. William says:

    These were the pope’s intentions for October:

    “A Missionary “Spring” in the Church
    That the breath of the Holy Spirit engender a new missionary “spring” in the Church.”

    Would that he pray for his own intentions.

  3. Bev says:

    It is a good idea to clarify that we aren’t praying for anything crazy the pope might publish as intentions. The perpetual intentions of the office of the pope are–

    i. The progress of the Faith and triumph of the Church.
    ii. Peace and union among Christian Princes and Rulers.
    iii. The conversion of sinners.
    iv. The uprooting of heresy.

  4. ProfKwasniewski says:

    I published an article on this at LifeSite not long ago that might be helpful, especially to those who are troubled at the thought of praying for this pope’s intentions:

    https://www.lifesitenews.com/blogs/should-we-pray-for-our-holy-fathers-intentions-even-if-a-pope-has-bad-intentions

    [Okay.]

  5. The Cobbler says:

    To be fair: actually taking care of the ocean is a good thing, the question is whether the self-appointed planet saviors are really doing any such thing or are just using it as an excuse to extort votes or worse (give me the power I demand or the world will end)! Likewise, praying to Jesus Christ for the good of humanity’s home is good, whereas praying to the oceans themselves (as the Pachamama types would have us do) is very much not good!

    That said, the traditional intentions seem a bit more important and even, in light of certain recent events, decidedly more urgent; this on top of the fact that you can’t go wrong with them anyway!

  6. SemperServusDei says:

    Thank you for clarifying what it means to pray for the Pope’s intentions… I was wrestling with this question under the current Pontificate, and so was praying instead for the conversion of the Pope. I had almost given up on gaining plenary indulgences under Francis…

  7. I feel more comfortable praying something like this “I pray for the intentions of [the pope] that are in accordance with your Holy Will”. I don’t know if that invalidates the prayer for the pope. Does anyone?

  8. swvirginia says:

    I stopped praying for the intentions of the Pope a long time ago as I doubt his intentions are completely trustworthy. Instead, I pray for “The needs of Holy Mother Church” and assume God knows what the Church needs….and has a plan.

  9. Josephus Corvus says:

    I find ignorance being useful. The Church asks that you pray for the pope’s intentions, so you do. “For the intentions of the Holy Father – Our Father….” When I first learned about indulgences, I didn’t even know there were formal intentions. I thought that requirement was for Divine assistance in whatever the pope happened to be praying about that day – health of friend, a major decision, whatever.

    Another way of looking at it is that you are just praying for the intention and you are letting God decide whether that is “in favor of” or “opposed to”. As an example, during my OF parish weekday Mass, they have the shout out petitions. Somebody says “For Zerubbabel’s cancer, we pray to the Lord.” The Lord knows that we aren’t in favor of the cancer, even though that’s we are saying.

  10. acardnal says:

    What I usually say when praying my rosary is, “for the Pope’s intentions if they are in accord with Your will Lord.”

  11. THREEHEARTS says:

    Mike Hurcum writes,
    The most important indulgenced promises are the first friday and perhaps the divine mercy that accompanies them. I am amazed that the FSSP treats the latter differently and I have never heard, in recent times, any priest tell of the importance of confession in the reception of the First Friday devotions. For those facts and with the absolute dearth in the use of the confessional, admitted to quite readily, by the Church Authorities, I ask if there are many indulgences earned?

  12. Mightnotbeachristiantou says:

    I think the key to answering other people’s question is two fold.
    1. Pray for both. Pray for the Pope and pray for the Popes intention. Does it really take so much time to do both? One is for an indulgence and one is just good.
    2. Don’t give them your option or words. There is a list of indulgences and how they are attained. Give people a written resource(official) where they can check it for themselves. So they know that is not just your opinion.

    NOVEMBER
    Universal: That a spirit of dialogue, encounter, and reconciliation emerge in the Near East, where diverse religious communities share their lives together.
    https://www.popesprayer.va/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/English-2019-def.pdf

    1 Timothy 2:2 (KJV)
    For kings, and [for] all that are in authority; that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty.

    There is not really a problem with praying for any of the Pope’s intentions. It is only a matter of perspective.

  13. mo7 says:

    I’ve taken to this: For Pope Francis and his holy intentions…
    With this I’ve prayed for him and with respect to oddball intentions leave it to divine wisdom to sort it out.

  14. Fr. Kelly says:

    Here is another thought.
    To pray for someone really has two meanings.
    1 Pray _for_Pope Francis in order to benefit him in some way.
    2 Pray _for_ (on behalf of) Pope Francis in order that the prayers he should be saying are being said at least by me.
    This second way opens the door to becoming a victim soul …

  15. JanetL says:

    I always add a Saint Michael prayer for the integrity of the papacy and the spiritual protection of the Holy Father.

Think, proof read, preview BEFORE posting!