The Catholic Spirit of Archd. of St.Paul/Minneapolis on older Mass

The newspaper of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis has an article about the older form of Mass.   

My emphases and comments. 

South St. Paul parish welcomes Tridentine Mass directive
Pope loosens restrictions on celebrating Latin language pre-Vatican II liturgy, but it’s unclear what the demand may be

By Pat Norby
The Catholic Spirit

The first thing a visitor may notice at the 11:30 a.m. Sunday Mass at St. Augustine is the silence, said Father Bryan Pedersen, associate pastor of the South St. Paul parish. At that time each week, the parish celebrates the Tridentine Mass, the Latin-language liturgy that predates the Second Vatican Council.

“The church is pregnant with silence during the eucharistic prayer. There is an expectation of the mystery of the consecration and transubstantiation,” he said.

About 350 people from across the state and Wisconsin and North Dakota attend the Mass, said Father John Echert, who has been pastor of St. Augustine for the past two and a half years and has celebrated the Tridentine Mass there for five years.

New rules

Father Echert and Father Pedersen have a deep love of the Tridentine rite, which was effectively replaced by the new Roman Missal in 1970. In 1984, Pope John Paul II granted an indult, allowing the Tridentine rite to be used if the local bishop gave his permission.

The new directive issued July 7 by Pope Benedict XVI gives priests the freedom to celebrate the Mass beginning Sept. 14 without asking for special permission.

Father Echert will begin offering two weekday Tridentine Masses beginning in September.

“We are one of only three indult parishes in the state of Minnesota, so people travel from other dioceses and from great distances to be here,” he said. “I think this will raise awareness among Catholics that the traditional form of the Mass exists, that it is available to them, and I expect our numbers to increase.”

For the past eight years, John and Teri Dick and their seven children have traveled 45 minutes from Buffalo, where they are members of St. Francis Xavier, to attend the Tridentine Mass at St. Augustine about three out of four weeks each month.

“The Tridentine Mass is more reverent,” said John. “We just felt that it was something that was worthwhile to make that long of a drive. . . . Having something that’s closer would be really nice.”

Although Father Echert expects other parishes to make the Mass available, he said it will take time to train new priests to properly preside at the Mass, which has detailed instructions about prayers and physical movements. It also requires proficiency in Latin, and seminarians will need to be sufficiently trained, Father Echert said.

About six other priests help serve the Mass at St. Augustine, which has about 650 households, most of which do not attend the Tridentine Masses, Father Pederson said.

Few requests

Dominican Sister Dominica Brennan, chancellor for canonical affairs for the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, said the pope’s document and accompanying letter, do not require priests to learn Latin or the rubrics required for the old Mass.

“The word used very specifically by the Holy Father is ‘extraordinary.’ This definitely implies that it will be unusual [I don’t think it implies that at all.  The English word "extraordinary" gives that impression, but if we go back to the meaning of the Latin term extraordinarius we find that the older rite is merely described as "out of the common order".  It has nothing to do with prevalence or frequency.  Furthermore, let us not forget that there is a Latin adverb extraordinarie which means "with excessive frequency"!  If anything, if you are going to draw some conclusion about prevalnce or frequency of "extraordinary" it strikes me as more natural to assume "often" rather than "rare".] to have this rite,” Sister Dominica said in a written response to questions from The Catholic Spirit. “The seminary may or may not offer instruction in this area. But there is no requirement that they do so.”  [On the other hand, Canon Law requires that seminarians be very well trained in Latin.  A priest must be idoneus for his ministry.  A priest must know to celebrate the liturgy in his Rite.  If there are two forms of the Rite, it is reasonable that the seminary teach two forms.]

There have been only two or three requests in the past 15 years for an additional Tridentine Mass, she said.  ["two or three"?]

Father Andrew Cozzens, theology instructor and worship director at St. Paul Seminary School of Divinity, said that seminary leaders have not discussed adding classes or instructors regarding Tridentine Masses, nor has the archbishop directed the seminary to do so.

Although Pope Benedict said in his apostolic exhortation “On the Eucharist” that he wants future priests to understand and celebrate Mass in Latin, he did not specify the Tridentine Mass, Father Cozzens said. Based on that document, the seminary will occasionally celebrate the “Novos [sic] Ordo” Mass in Latin, which is different than the Tridentine Mass.

“As for the future of the Tridentine Mass, my guess is it would be based on how great the pastoral need is, and at this point I don’t see a large groundswell,” he said. In addition, he said, the archdiocesan pastoral needs lean in another direction.

“We have a proven pastoral need for priests to say Mass in Spanish, and do pastoral care in Spanish,” he said. “That would be a much higher priority for us at the seminary,” Father Cozzens said.  [I am not sure why this would be a zero-sum game.]

Father Pederson said that besides local and long-distance parishioners, some old rite worshippers “float between the Society of St. Pius X and our church.”

The Society of St. Pius X, which is made up of priests who broke away from the church with the late French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre over the new Roman Missal and other issues, has a chapel in St. Paul.

“With the new ruling, there is hope that those people and priests would return to the church,” he said.

Comparisons

Father Pederson said he fell in love with the Latin Mass while attending St. Agnes School and parish in St. Paul.

“In the old Mass, the silence can be deafening at times,” he said. “That is the reverential silence that exists in the old Mass.”  [I think he likes the silence.]

All of the eucharistic and consecration prayers are said in silence by the priest. In the new Mass, the eucharistic prayer and consecration is spoken or sung out loud.

Other differences he noted are:

• In the old rite, the epistle is read by an ordained minister [ugh!] at one side of the altar and the Gospel at another side, in Latin, although they may be read in the vernacular. In the new Mass, readings are proclaimed in the vernacular at the ambo by a lector, [a real Lector is always male] who may be a lay man or woman. The Gospel is still proclaimed by a priest or deacon.

• In the old rite, there are preparatory and penitential prayers at the foot of the altar that are not prayed in the new Mass.

• In the old Mass, the priest usually faces away from the people. The rite allows him to face them, although there would be a crucifix at the center of the altar.

• The old rite has a one-year calendar that uses the same yearly epistle and Gospel readings. The new Mass has a three-year cycle of Old Testament and Gospel readings.