WDTPRS – 5 November: Feast of the Holy Relics. These bones shall live again. Wherein Fr. Z rants.

WDTPRS - 5 November: Feast of the Holy Relics. These bones shall live again. Wherein Fr. Z rants.

The arm of St. Francis Xavier

Today, 5 November, in our traditional liturgical calendars, we find a feast which might surprise many Catholics: the Feast of the Holy Relics.

No, this is not a special day set aside to celebrate your aging pastor, although some of them may seem to qualify.

A relic, from Latin reliquiae, “remains”, is a tangible connection with a saint or blessed. First class relics are bodily remains, such as bones, hair, blood, or ashes. Second class relics are objects personally used or worn by the saint, such as clothing, books, or instruments of martyrdom. Third class relics are objects, usually pieces of cloth or holy cards, rosaries, touched to a first class relic or a saint’s tomb. Relics of Our Lord’s Passion, such as fragments of the True Cross, occupy a special place of honor.

Authentic relics deserve reverent treatment, never commercial exploitation.  Alas, one does see that.

As far as concerns this feast, look in the back of an older Missal, among the Masses pro aliquibus locis, “for certain places”. There you may find the formulary Multae tribulationes, a Mass with red vestments in honor of the sacred relics preserved in churches, dioceses and religious communities. The feast was celebrated on various dates according to local calendars, frequently on 5 November. It never belonged to the universal Roman calendar as an obligatory observance.

Some context.

During November, Holy Mother Church directs our attention to prayer for the dead and the Four Last Things.   We have just celebrated All Saints and All Souls. On the former we looked toward Heaven and the glory of those who have attained their eternal reward. On the later we prayed for those who have died in God’s friendship but who still require purification. Now, with the Feast of Holy Relics, we turn our attention to the earthly remains of the saints, whose souls enjoy the Beatific Vision while their bodies await the general resurrection.

While I outlined, above, that there are different “levels” of relics, and that even among the first class relics there are different kinds, I’ll focus for a moment on… bones.

The Introit of this special Mass begins with Psalm 33 (34):

Multae tribulationes justorum, et de his omnibus liberabit eos Dominus: Dominus custodit omnia ossa eorum: unum ex his non conteretur.

Many are the afflictions of the just, and out of them all the Lord will deliver them. The Lord guards all their bones; not one of them shall be broken.

“Wait a minute”, you might be thinking, “The saints certainly suffered. Some were tortured, mutilated, burned, beheaded, exposed to wild beasts. Their bones were broken, their bodies destroyed, their ashes scattered. Yet the Psalm proclaims that God guards their bones.  How can this be?”

The answer is found, I think, in the resurrection of the dead. No violence done to a martyr’s body, no decomposition in the grave, no scattering of ashes can frustrate Almighty God. What men destroy, God can restore. The body which was the instrument of a saint’s fidelity, which fasted, prayed, labored, suffered and received Holy Communion, remains destined for glory.   In the general Resurrection, our souls (the form) will once again inform a body (the matter).  What was seemingly destroyed shall rise again.   I have in mind the incredible fresco in the Cathedral of Orvieto in which Signorelli depicts the  rising righteous drawing their new bodies out of a perfectly flat white plain (prime matter, waiting to be informed).  They start as bones, skeletons and are enfleshed anew as perfect 33-year olds (the years of Jesus on Earth).

WDTPRS - 5 November: Feast of the Holy Relics. These bones shall live again. Wherein Fr. Z rants.

With that in mind, here is the…

COLLECT

Auge in nobis, Domine, resurrectionis fidem,
qui in Sanctorum tuorum reliquiis mirabilia operaris:
et fac nos immortalis gloriae participes,
cuius in eorum cineribus pignora veneramur. 

LITERAL VERSION:

O Lord, increase in us faith in the resurrection,
You who work wonders through the relics of Your Saints,
and enable us to be sharers in immortal glory,
the pledges of which we venerate in their ashes.

The imperative auge is from augeo, “to increase, enlarge, augment”. Wit polite boldness we ask God to increase our faith specifically in the Resurrection. We readily profess in the Creed, “I await the Resurrection of the dead.”

That’s an article of the Creed.  It might be a good idea to reflect on what it means.

The Collect gives the reason for our confidence: God is working wonders in the relics of His saints. The verb operaris is present tense. God is working. The souls of saints have departed this earthly life, but God’s power remains active. Their bodily remains can become instruments through which His goodness is manifested.

The petition of the Collect is that we ask to share in “immortal glory”, of which we venerate pignora in the ashes of the saints.

Pignus, plural pignora, means “a pledge, something given as a guarantee of future fulfillment”.  A holy relic of a saint is a pledge of the Resurrection. We reverence these remains because of what God has promised to accomplish. The bones of the saints (as well as other kinds of relics) point like a pledge beyond the grave toward the glory which awaits the whole person, body and soul.

Note the contrast between cineribus, “ashes”, and immortalis gloriae, “immortal glory”. The most apparently perishable, indeed already perished things are through the eyes of faith signs of what cannot perish.

Our secularized “culture” is uncomfortable with death. We disguise it, sanitize it, remove it from ordinary sight. We prefer celebrations of life to the sober Christian recognition of death, judgment and eternity.  Think about how graveside rites usually cover over the waiting dirt pile.

The Church, meanwhile, puts a bone of a dead person – sometimes the entire remains – in a golden reliquary, surrounds it with candles, incenses it, and invites us to kneel.

Which approach takes the human body more seriously?

One modern view of the body is that it is just a vehicle I ride around in, something I own, like a car.  I can do what I want to the thing I own.  It’s not really “me” after all.  Right?  The problem with that is that if your body isn’t really you and it is something you can “own” and do with as you please, then so can someone else.  After all, it’s not really “you”, right?  If someone wants to do terrible things to you, well… too bad.  It’s not really…. “you”.  No.  We humans are both soul and body.  I am my body, also.  Hence we can never mistreat the bodies of others (at least the innocent).  Bodies reflect the image of God, who works His mighty will through us.

Scripture teaches us that God works through material things. In 4 Kings 13:21 (2 Kings in modern numbering), a dead man is restored to life when his body touches the bones of the prophet Elisha. In Acts 19:11-12, cloths which had touched St. Paul were brought to the sick, who were healed. In Acts 5:15, the sick were placed where even St. Peter’s passing shadow might fall upon them.

Our religion is incarnational. God took flesh. The Eternal Word entered our material world and made use of material realities to communicate divine life. Water becomes the instrument of baptismal regeneration. Oil is used in Confirmation and Anointing. The Eucharistic Lord gives us His true Body and Blood under the appearances of bread and wine.

The veneration of relics makes perfect sense within this sacramental, incarnational framework.

The Council of Trent (25th Session), taught that the bodies of the saints, once living members of Christ and temples of the Holy Ghost, are destined to be raised and glorified. Therefore they are rightly venerated. God bestows many benefits upon men through them.

The honor given to saints and their relics is veneratio, not the latria reserved to the Most Holy Trinity. We adore God alone.  Relics possess no magical power independent from God. God is the source of every grace and authentic miracle. Nor should genuine devotion be confused with indiscriminate enthusiasm for every purported relic that turns up on the internet.  BEWARE of “trafficking” in relics, which, if they are real is sacrilege and if false is blasphemous.  “Trafficking” creates a self-perpetuating market.

Since I write this on my last full day in Rome, there is a particularly Roman dimension to this Feast of Holy Relics.

Rome is filled with relics. Beneath its altars lie martyrs who shed their blood for Christ. In its churches we encounter the mortal remains of apostles, popes, confessors and virgins whose lives shaped Christendom.  From where I sit as I write this, within a, say, 15 minute walk there are the tombs of dozens of saints, well-known, and literally thousands of reliquaries.  To focus on just one aspect of church’s here, most of them have side altars.  Your parish church may have as well.  If consecrated, they have relics in them, sometimes whole bodies.  Otherwise, there will be an altar stone for the celebration of Mass containing a relic.

The ancient custom of celebrating Mass over the tombs of martyrs, and subsequently placing relics within altars, unites the Sacrifice of Christ with the witness of those who followed Him even unto death.

Considered just from this characteristic, the altar itself is a sermon.

Which … when we see some modern altars makes you wonder what they who built it believe.

At Santissima Trinità dei Pellegrini here in Rome, The Parish™, there is a beautiful custom of solemnly exposing the relics preserved in the church around the time of All Saints. I have previously written about this and provided video of the ceremony. I have video from this year, too, but I have to wait to get back to the USA to edit it together.  The relics are brought forward and presented to the faithful, with the saints identified as the reliquaries are displayed.

It is an impressive reminder of the Communion of Saints.  In relics, our communion with the heavenly blessed is made more tangible, a pledge (pignus) that it is attainable.

How many parishes possess relics which have languished for decades in cupboards, sacristy drawers or forgotten cabinets? These venerable treasures should once again be displayed reverently, accompanied by sound catechesis. A parish – convent – diocese – entrusted with relics has a responsibility to preserve and honor them.  If the relics are not in good repair, they can be repaired but ONLY by someone who knows what he is doing and has the backing and oversight of proper authority, such as the diocesan bishop.  Do NOT fiddle around with reliquaries on your own, except, perhaps to give them a little cleaning.  Do NOT open them up.

I digress.

There are some practical considerations that flow from this feast and from veneration of relics in general.

When you venerate a relic, remember that the saint whose remains are before you was once as you are now. He fought temptations. She struggled with distractions in prayer. They experienced fatigue, discouragement, fear, physical suffering and the difficulties of living faithfully their state of life in a fallen world. Their sanctity was accomplished through cooperation with grace amid the ordinary circumstances of human life.  Some of them in a flash evidenced through grace heroic virtues in the moment of their martyrdom.

Their bodies were instruments of that cooperation.

Our bodies, too, are meant to serve God. The hands with which we work, the eyes with which we look upon the world, the knees upon which we pray, the tongue with which we receive the Blessed Sacrament, all are destined, if we persevere in grace, to share in the glory of the resurrection.   In one of those churches near to where I sit, the Gesù, there is the arm of St. Francis Xavier, the spectacular Jesuit missionary.  When you see that arm, you see beyond it also to the thousands of converts who were baptized by it.   In another direction, at San Salvatore in Lauro, is the arm of the Apostle St. Jude, patron of impossible causes…again, probably not your aging relic of a pastor.  All things are possible with God according to His will.

These remains preserved in reliquaries remind us that God’s promises are trustworthy.

You might ask your parish priests if your parish possesses relics. Ask if they can be exposed for veneration on an appropriate occasions.  Learn about the saints whose relics are preserved there. Teach your children why we honor these sacred remains.   Perhaps you might make a pilgrimage to visit the tomb of a saint or a well-known relic near where you are when you have the opportunity, and ask for his intercession.

Moreover, as the Collect for the Feast of Holy Relics prompts, pray for an increase in faith in the resurrection:

Increase in us, O Lord, faith in the Resurrection.

I wonder, in the face of all the truly alarming, sometimes horrifying things going on in the secular world but also, it must be said, in the Church, an increase precisely in belief in the Resurrection – pledged by God – might not be at least in part both a shield and a field dressing for us of the Church Militant.  Those who are faithful to Christ have a future far more glorious than the grave, making less burdensome the vicissitudes of this life.

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ACTION ITEM!, Hard-Identity Catholicism, Just Too Cool, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Save The Liturgy - Save The World, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged
Leave a comment

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: Penultimate

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: PenultimateTomorrow is my last full day in Rome.

Today, however,  06:44 saw the sun rise over the Seven Hills.

Sunset was 17:03.

It was the Feast of St. Charles Borromeo… an incredible saint who gave his all and died young.  What he accomplished is astonishing.  Shall we see his like again?  Ask God to raise up great saints for our day.  How this might come to pass must be left to God, given that the sort of human formation at work in the 16th c. is unthinkable now.

Recently I had supper with a Notable Catholic Commentator Well-Known To You™ at a regular haunt.  I glad to say that, while the amatriciana was good, the saltimbocca was the best I’ve had for a while.  They are really on their game right now.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: Penultimate ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: Penultimate

Check out Elle Effe… and tell them “don John” sent you.

On the way home.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: Penultimate
White to move and mate in 4.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 35: Penultimate

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Meanwhile,…

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

Germans… “for many” in the Consecration formula, rather than “for all”

The problem is… as I see it… the approval of translation of sacramental forms is reserved to the Roman Pontiff alone. It is not an option for bishops conferences. While Benedict, probably reluctant to come down hard may have used the language of invitation, when he determined what the translation should be, that was that. If the Germans get away with this… it undermines the authority of the Roman Pontiff in the matter of the regulation of the Church’s sacraments.

 

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Save The Liturgy - Save The World | Tagged
3 Comments

WDTPRS: A charming translation for the Feast of St. Charles Borromeo – 4 November

Today, 4 November, Holy Church honors St. Charles Borromeo (+1584), the great Archbishop of Milan and champion of the Catholic Counter-Reformation.  His heart is “warded” not far from where I write, in the great church San Carlo al Corso.

WDTPRS: A charming translation for the Feast of St. Charles Borromeo - 4 November

WDTPRS: A charming translation for the Feast of St. Charles Borromeo - 4 November

The Collect for his feast asks that the pastoral solicitude which distinguished Charles in life may continue to benefit the Church through his heavenly intercession.

Ecclésiam tuam, Dómine,
sancti Cároli Confessóris tui atque Pontíficis
contínua protectióne custódi:
ut, sicut illum pastorális sollicitúdo gloriósum réddidit;
ita nos eius intercéssio in tuo semper fáciat amóre fervéntes.

When I looked at the office of Lauds for St. Charles at the wonderful Divinum Officium I found a charming English rendering:

O Lord, give unto thy Church for an unsleeping warder thine holy Confessor Bishop Charles; upon earth his carefulness did make him glorious as a shepherd, there where he is may his prayerfulness make him effectual as a bedesman, pleading with thee to make us to love thee more.

Delightful.  This is attributed to John, Marquess of Bute (+1900), whose translation of the Roman Breviary first appeared in 1879.  It strays from the literal meaning but that’s okay.

There is something evocative about an “unsleeping warder” and a “bedesman”.  The latter is an old English word for one who prays on behalf of another, from bede, meaning prayer. Our English word “bead” comes from the same root, since prayers were counted on beads. A “warder” is a “guardian, watchman, sentinel, or keeper; one charged with protecting or guarding a person, place, or institution” from Middle English “to ward” meaning “to guard, protect, or keep watch.”  Hence, in the Collect the Latin “continua protectione custodi… guard by (his) continual protection”, is converted into “unsleeping warder”.

Pastoralis sollicitudo is his “pastoral care” becomes “prayerfulness” and his intercessio is morphed into “effectual as a bedesman”.

I suppose this can be counted as a “dynamic rendering” which presents the sense of the prayer without being confined to the Latin literally.  Effective?  I think so, but I am a sucker for archaic language and imagery.

The final Latin petition deserves attention: “in tuo semper faciat amore ferventes… may (his intercession) make us always fervent in Your love.”    Ferveo is “to be boiling hot, to boil, ferment, glow”.  English “fervent” obviously comes from this.

Ferventes!  Would that we were as we beg to be, through the intercession of St. Charles Borromeo, truly “glowing” in our state of life with the love of God.

 

Posted in Saints: Stories & Symbols, WDTPRS | Tagged
1 Comment

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 34: Requiem for deceased benefactors

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 34: Requiem for deceased benefactorsFor this 307th day of 2026, the sun rose at 06:43 over the Eternal City.

The days here are not eternal, however, and the sun set at 17:04.

The “Ave Maria” Bell for the Curia remained in the 17:30 cycle, though, as the days grow shorter the solar time for its ringing draws closer to that cycle.  The solar time for the “Ave Maria” Bell was 17:34.  Expect a change of cycle.

There were 59 days left in the year and 3 full days of my sojourn.

Mass today was a Requiem celebrated for the intention of my deceased benefactors.  Sometimes people will let me know when one of my donors has passed away and I mark them down lest I forget.  Of course, there are surely quite a few who pass and I don’t receive word.  In any event, today’s Mass was for all of them who have left this vale of tears.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 34: Requiem for deceased benefactors

Meanwhile,…

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Leave a comment

CQ CQ CQ – EWTN shut down its shortwave radio service on 31 October. Understandable, but I have some reservations.

There is something splendid about the thought that, somewhere in the dark of night a person with a simple radio could turn a dial and hear a voice crackling across the layers of atmosphere from Rome or Alabama and discover the Catholic Faith.

It has been a while since I have been very active with amateur radio.  The logistics of where I live presents challenges for a decent antenna.   Also, on the digital side – which is really interesting and useful but which is also sort of “cheating” – I don’t have the skills to keep all the different modes we used for ZedNet working together.  We had to depend on one elmer for that.

CQ CQ CQ - EWTN shut down its shortwave radio service on 31 October. Understandable, but I have some reservations.Old ZedNet participants… drop a line!  Maybe we can kick start our activity again.

That said, we saw some years ago the Holy See shut down some of its shortwave Vatican Radio services, but they still maintain  significant services in many languages.  Now we see that EWTN has ended its own shortwave service, WEWN, after 34 years.   HERE   31 October.  Gone.

The decision is understandable from a financial standpoint. EWTN cites declining listenership, aging transmitters, large maintenance costs, and new digital alternatives.

Nevertheless, something important is now gone.

Shortwave radio can do what the internet can’t.  It can cross national borders without permission from governments, telecoms, internet service providers, or other digital gatekeepers. A relatively inexpensive receiver and a bit of wire can bring a distant voice into an isolated village or a country whose government would prefer that certain things are never heard.  Shortwave transmission can be jammed, of course, and reception is subject to atmospheric conditions. Still, its independence from a local digital infrastructure gives it a strategic value that cannot be measured simply by counting the number of listeners.

That matters particularly for the Church. The Gospel is intended for everyone, including people who don’t have other methods of modern communication or whom political authorities seek to isolate.  WEWN’s English broadcasts served Africa and the Middle East and its Spanish language service reached Latin America (where Protestants are making gains as the Church bleeds members).

A Catholic shortwave station capable of reaching distant continents was precisely the sort of audacious undertaking one associates with Mother Angelica’s boldness, willingness to tackle improbable projects, and confidence in divine Providence.   Of course the flip side involves the virtue of Prudence.   They had to measure the return on their investment in deteriorating equipment for an increasingly small audience.

Still, I have reservations about shutting down such a service.  Sure, newer technology has in effect replaced the advantages of older technology.  Now we have live video streaming, podcasts, mobile apps which reach enormous audiences.  The problem is they all depend on a massive infrastructure which can be interrupted, interfered with, even hijacked.  Shortwave offers a measure of redundancy and independence.

Perhaps it would be possible to preserve some emergency or missionary broadcasting capacity.

I don’t know the state of the question for Protestant shortwave concerns, or those of other false religions.

There is a lesson here beyond EWTN. The Church ought to be wary of becoming entirely dependent upon communication systems controlled by institutions that may not be friendly to the Faith.   New means of evangelization are welcome and they should be exploited. Nevertheless, sometimes an old technology has virtues that become apparent precisely when the new technology fails.

Some results outweigh the cost per listener bottom line.

73

PS: I received a note from AllStar that the recent PHP problems has effected it.  Nodes can be exposed.  This is something that needs attention if you are active on AllStar.

PPS: I was able to connect to our ZedNet Echolink and AllStar Node with my phone!  I’ll keep it on for awhile.

Echolink: WB0YLE-R
AllStar: 28868

Posted in New Evangelization, Semper Paratus, The Coming Storm, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged , , ,
5 Comments

ASK FATHER: “Is it proper to pray for the repose of souls who died before the Resurrection and the harrowing of Hell?”

From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

Given it is near All Souls Day, is it proper to pray for the repose of souls who died before the Resurrection and the harrowing of Hell?

The short answer is, yes, it is permissible to pray for those who died before the Resurrection of Christ, but we should make some important distinctions.

Before Christ’s redemptive Death and Resurrection, the souls of the just who died in God’s friendship could not yet enter Heaven. They awaited the Redeemer in what tradition calls the limbus Patrum, the Limbo of the Fathers, or else the Bosom of Abraham (Luke 16:22).

When Christ descended ad inferos, into the realm of the dead, He liberated these righteous souls and opened Heaven to them. The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains in par. 633:

It is precisely these holy souls, who awaited their Saviour in Abraham’s bosom, whom Christ the Lord delivered when he descended into hell.

Thus, Abraham, Moses, David, the prophets, and the other righteous figures of the Old Testament who were among those liberated by Christ have already attained their heavenly reward. They do not need our prayers. Indeed, we can ask their intercession.   As a matter of fact, these great figures of the Old Testament are counted among the saints and they have their own feast days in the Roman Martyrology‘s calendar.

That said, those who died in the state of mortal sin and definitive separation from God cannot benefit from our prayers, whether they died before or after Christ. Their judgment is settled.

This leads to another point, related to the first.

What about the countless people who died before Christ whose eternal destiny is unknown to us?

The saving merits of Christ’s Sacrifice extend to the righteous of every age, including those who lived before the Incarnation. God is eternal, and His providence encompasses all human history.  We should commend them to God’s mercy.

Another distinction is helpful.

We should distinguish a) praying that God’s mercy was extended to someone at his particular judgment from b) praying for the release of someone who is presently undergoing purification in the state called Purgatory.  We have no reason to suppose that the righteous who were liberated by Christ at His descent remain in the Limbo of the Fathers, or that prayers offered today could change the definitive judgment of those who were lost.  Again, our prayers cannot help a soul separated from God through mortal sin.

Hence, although there is nothing improper about commending the ancient, pre-Resurrection dead to God’s mercy, the ordinary purpose of our prayers for the faithful departed, especially on All Souls’ Day and the days that follow, is to assist souls presently undergoing purification in Purgatory. They can benefit from our suffrages, especially the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.  It is a work of mercy to pray for the dead and to have Masses said for them when possible.  Moreover, from 1-8 November, we can gain plenary indulgences for the Poor Souls.

To sum up, pray for the unknown dead of antiquity if you wish, entrusting them to God’s eternal mercy. However, keep in mind that the holy patriarchs and prophets, as well as the righteous who died in God’s friendship, whom Christ led forth during His glorious descent are already numbered among the blessed in Heaven.

November is the traditional month when we pay special attention to prayers for the so-called Poor Souls. When we pray “Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine” we perform a work of mercy for souls who can benefit from our charity.

We should be generous with those prayers. They may have no one else to pray for them.  I’m sure that you hope, as do I fervently, that someone will pray for you.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Four Last Things | Tagged , ,
1 Comment

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All SoulsIn Rome the sun rose at 06:42

19:05 is when it set.

Curial “Ave Maria” Bell, still 17:30

Commemoration of All Saints.  What a roller coaster from yesterday.  But logical.

And therapeutic.

Interesting. Asymmetrical tactic.

A few images from tonight’s Solemn Requiem:

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 33: All Souls

This was followed by the sermon and absolution and then the singing of the Office of the Dead.

Meanwhile… about USS Wisconsin, mothballed at Norfolk.

Makes me want to watch “Battleship!” again.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

ASK FATHER: “Why isn’t the Male Only Holy Orders a Dogma?”

From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

There’s something I’ve been wondering about for years. Why isn’t the Male Only Holy Orders a Dogma? It seems like since 1994 it’s been declared that all Catholics must accept this. Could a Pope come along and eventually declare that it’s a Dogma of the Catholic Church?

You are perhaps reacting to the latest antics of the “walking together” in Ireland and the appointment of women who support the ordination of women to certain Vatican entities.  [UPDATE: I just received a link to a piece at Ad Vaticanum in which the Archbp. of Vienna openly supports the ordination of women to the priesthood.]

Short answer. It. Can’t. Happen. As Lumen gentium clarifies, the Sacrament of Holy Orders is one sacrament, not three. If women cannot be ordained to the priesthood, they can’t be ordained deacons either, much less bishops.

We can spin this out a bit more.

There is a distinction between dogma, doctrine, and infallibility. A teaching does not have to be solemnly defined ex cathedra by a Pope to be infallible and irreformable.

In his 1994 Apostolic Letter Ordinatio sacerdotalis, John Paul II said:

“I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful.”

Note the wording. The Pope did not say that the Church chooses, for the time being, to ordain only men. He said that the Church has no authority whatsoever to ordain women. The matter is beyond the Church’s competence to change.

Should anyone try, that’s a sure sign that something is deeply wrong.

Subsequently, in 1995 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith under Cardinal Ratzinger answered a formal dubium (question) about the authority of Ordinatio sacredotalis. It explained that the doctrine requires definitive assent because it has already been taught infallibly by the Church’s ordinary and universal Magisterium.  In other words, it is not necessary to make, now, a formal pronouncement that it is infallible teaching, because it has always been infallible.

NB: There are truths formally proposed as divinely revealed (de fide credenda) and teachings definitively to be held (de fide tenenda). Both require assent, although their precise theological classifications differ.

Could a future Pope formally define the reservation of priestly ordination to men as a dogma of divine and Catholic faith?

Yes. Absolutely.  It isn’t necessary, but sure.

In fact, the CDF’s 1998 Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei (par 11), explicitly addresses this possibility:

“This does not foreclose the possibility that, in the future, the consciousness of the Church might progress to the point where this teaching could be defined as a doctrine to be believed as divinely revealed.”

Such a definition would give the doctrine a further formal clarification concerning its status as revealed truth. It would not make the teaching any more binding, nor would it introduce something new into the deposit of faith.  The restriction of priestly ordination to men is already infallibly taught, definitive, and irreformable.

It cannot be overturned by a future Pope or by an ecumenical council, much less a season of “walking together”.

In short, a future Pope could solemnly define what the Church already holds definitively, but he could never legitimately declare the opposite.

The Pope is the guardian of the sacraments instituted by Christ, not their master. He cannot rewrite their essential constitution according to the theological fashions of the day.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Priests and Priesthood | Tagged
11 Comments

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All Saints

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All Saints

For this 305th day of the calendar year, the Feast of All Saints – which bumps the Sunday though in the Vetus Ordo it gets a commemoration (something the Novus Ordo does not have) the sun rose over Rome at 06:40.

It set at 17:07 while we were singing 2nd Vespers, a rather long affair tonight because at the Magnificat all 8 of the side altars (including those in the transepts) were to be incensed.

The 17:30 Ave Maria Bell cycle is still indicated for the Curia.

Thus we begin the month dedicated to prayers for the dead.

Before Vespers we had a solemn exposition of the sacred relics which The Parish lovingly guards.   I made videos from two directions of the whole thing and, along with some still photos, hope to get it edited together soon.   There is, by the way, in the traditional calendar, coming up a Feast of Holy Relics.

This morning many of the relics were on the St. Matthew altar in the transept, ready for the afternoon.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All Saints

Getting a deacon ready for Mass this morning.  Rather like how they dress astronauts.

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All Saints

I just got a photo from The World’s Best Sacristan™ who is setting up altars for tomorrow morning when priests will be able to celebrate THREE Requiem Masses (but only keep one stipend).

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All Saints

ROME 26/10-11 – Day 32: All SaintsPlease remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance, utilities, groceries, and now also my late mother’s place.  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.  

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Leave a comment