From a reader…
QUAERITUR:
Please send me the definition and the duties of a pastoral associate.
A pastoral associate is an ordained minister, assigned by the bishop, as distinguished from a lay person with some parish job, paid or volunteer, who serves at the will of the pastor.
The associate is a discreet priestly operative charged with preserving the Catholic Faith in a parish whose pastor is determined to improve upon it.
His duties include rescuing discarded statues, hiding tambourines, and introducing Gregorian chant as an exciting innovation recommended by the latest synodal (“walking together”) session.
He must tactfully intercept absurdities from the liturgy planning committee, protect elderly ladies who still pray the Rosary, defend the last useable confessional against conversion into a broom closet, and persuade the pastor that incense is both environmentally sustainable and pastorally inclusive.
Essential qualifications include orthodoxy, a working knowledge of canon law, the ability to smile for long periods of time, and the ability to endure interminable meetings about radical hospitality without throwing anything.
A pastoral associate exercises no authority whatsoever, although he is personally responsible for everything that goes wrong. He may offer suggestions and must remain cheerful when the pastor attributes anything he does to himself and the Renewal Committee.
His compensation consists principally of opportunities for heroic virtue.
His sole recognized right is Christian burial, although even that is not guaranteed, since the pastor of whatever parish he is buried from may prefer a Celebration of Life featuring balloons and interpretive dance.
Note: While in some places the fancy title “parochial vicar” is employed, also heard in the wild are the terms “associate” and “assistant”. There should be no confusion about these last two, because, in any event, the first three letters are the same.





















Like any vice-president or vice-provost or vice-dean, there to take the blame for anything which goes wrong, but to make sure that the one in charge gets all the credit when things go well. Question: do auxiliary bishops and episcopal vicars function in the same way?
When was the good old term “curate” abandoned?
Spot on. My understanding is that the standard term per Canon Law 545 is “parochial vicar” and that the other terms for this position are informal. Another interesting position in Canon Law, besides the “pastor” himself is the parish “administrator” who administers the parish until a pastor is appointed. That is what we have now after our pastor retired. My understanding is that his position is rather tenuous since he has no stated term of appointment and serves completely at the bishop’s discretion. It’s a very difficult position for him to be in and he certainly has his work cut out for him. He’s following a very traditional, financially successful and well loved pastor. He was a refugee from Vietnam as a child and is truly an excellent and holy priest.
I have a question. Did the Catholic Church use the terms rector or vicar before Vatican II. I always thought it did because Episcopalians called their priest in charge rector or vicarious. Indeed it was my experience the more high church they were the more likely they would prefer to be called vicar and the more low church rector. I just assumed they inherited these terms from the Catholic Church.
A humorous but accurate description of the life and duties of a lowly parochial vicar, also once called an “associate pastor,” or a “curate.” Also commonly called a “peon” by those who ” need to speak to the pastor.”
But I have seen parishes that employ something entirely different, with the exalted title of “Pastoral Associate,” (usually pronounced as Pas–TORR- i-al).
She (invariably a woman) is a highly paid busybody, employed by the pastor to implement his pastoral vision for the parish, and for the universe, to do the hard work traditionally done by the pastor and by the parochial vicar (who is now also known as the “third wheel on a bicycle”). She is completely trusted by the pastor, who hired her, unlike the parochial vicar, who was assigned to him by the bishop.
Her qualifications are that she reads the same periodicals and websites as the pastor, and she attends the same weekend “workshops.” She may be an aging woman religious who no longer teaches in a Catholic school, or else a lay woman who attended a workshop on “St John of the Cross and Native American Religion.”
and the ability to endure interminable meetings about radical hospitality without throwing anything.
Especially: UP. (Not throwing, that is.)
While this was a delightful description of “the other guy” in the rectory, Fr. Z, I feel that with a little more effort you could have turned up a definition worthy of Ambrose Bierce. Or several, as there’s plenty of material to go around.
On a slightly more serious note, I saw mickeyfitz’s comment about the parish administrator (as in contrast to the pastor):
My understanding is that his position is rather tenuous since he has no stated term of appointment and serves completely at the bishop’s discretion
and realized we seem to have turned some sort of full circle here: the office of pastor is SUPPOSED to be a stable one with powers and rights, meaning the bishop can’t just do whatever he feels like about him. In theory. I doubt a single pastor in America feels like he has 1/10th of the stability, power, or independence those words might have had some 100 years ago. The pastor may get to act on his own discretion and make his own judgments…just as long as nobody tattles to the bishop, and then the bishop is just as likely to issue orders without asking questions or any consultation, running roughshod over any prior standards, commitments, or customs, and demand obedience or the pastor risks being cancelled. (Or a fate even worse, laicized – again without any recourse by the priest.) The problem is that Canon Law may seem to have rules by which a pastor can “appeal to Rome”, but (from what I hear of the scuttlebutt, somebody please correct me if I’m wrong) there’s little chance that Rome will actually rule in a pastor’s favor (regardless of how good his position is). And of course, if a bishop went off-reservation enough for a pastor to appeal to Rome, there’s little chance that such a bishop will treat a pastor (who appealed over his head to Rome) in an unbiased manner after that. So, an attempt at an appeal is virtually putting his head on the chopping block, metaphorically speaking, with almost no chance of a successful appeal to begin with, and a pyrrhic victory even if he does win.
ProfessorCover: yes, rectors are appointed to lead cathedrals and seminaries and the like. There are various sorts of vicars. Parochial vicars are priests who minister at a parish under the authority of a pastor. Vicars forane are what we commonly call Deans (senior pastors overseeing regions within a diocese). These terms all pre date VII.
My cathedral has a Rector, a Vice Rector, and then a few Parochial Vicars.
@TonyO said, “The problem is that Canon Law may seem to have rules by which a pastor can “appeal to Rome”, but (from what I hear of the scuttlebutt, somebody please correct me if I’m wrong) there’s little chance that Rome will actually rule in a pastor’s favor (regardless of how good his position is). And of course, if a bishop went off-reservation enough for a pastor to appeal to Rome, there’s little chance that such a bishop will treat a pastor (who appealed over his head to Rome) in an unbiased manner after that.”
You are right, as exemplified in the case of Fr. Paul Kalchick of Chicago, who was pastor at Resurrection Catholic Church in Chicago, who was removed as pastor of the parish for burning a rainbow banner that had been hung in the church by a former pastor, (see a synopsis of the backstory here:https://www.theamericanconservative.com/persecution-father-paul-kalchik-white-martyr/
(For the record, I was baptized, received my First Confession and First Holy Communion, and confirmation at what had been St. Francis Xavier Church, which was later renamed Resurrection Church in 1991. This was my neighborhood parish church.)
Fr. Kalchick appealed to Rome, twice, and won both times. The verdicts meant he was to be restored in his position as pastor of the parish. Cardinal Cupich’s response? He modified the status of Resurrection parish, using “extinctive union” (a.k.a. amalgamation), whereby Resurrection parish was subsumed into Our Lady of Mercy parish, located some two miles north, as a “mission” chapel. So, there was no more parish for Fr. Kalchick to return to.
Isn’t that special?
Fr. Kalchick is currently living in another state (I’m not sure where.) Here’s an update on him from 2025. https://www.corpuschristiforunityandpeace.org/project/fr-kalchik/
So, yes, TonyO, a pyrrhic victory, to say the least. The only consolation to me is that the name St. Francis Xavier has been restored to the church, thereby blotting out the horrific name that brought such scandal to current and former parishioners.
TonyO: I suspect that the stability of a pastor’s appointment ultimately depends upon the good faith of the bishop and we don’t have to search very hard to notice that at least some bishops can be very heavy handed in their demands and woe to any priest, whatever his position, who dares to cross him.
This is spot on. In the Archdiocese of Cincinnati, as part of a draconian regional realignment begun a little over 4 years ago, the then-ordinary decided to cut the number of pastors in half, and create mega- regions of multiple parishes with one pastor and (often) several parochial vicars. Previously, most of the priests had been pastors. As part of our current “synodal” / walking together process, the current ordinary is inviting groups of people to listen to each other in the Spirit or some such — and inviting pastors, staffs, parish council members and parishioners at large to participate. But the parochial vicars are something of an afterthought in the invitations, often excluded from the communications. So the ‘chain of command’ is roughly The ordinary -> Deans (Vicars forane) -> Pastors -> Regional parish council leaders – > Staff members -> aging Baby Boomers complaining about Latin and ad orientem -> parochial vicars.
Essential qualifications include […] the ability to smile for long periods of time, and the ability to endure interminable meetings about radical hospitality without throwing anything.
There goes my chances of being a pastoral associate.