From a reader…
QUAERITUR:
If a priest explains away a mortal sin in confession in such away that neither the priest nor the penitent believes any more than the mortal sin is even a sin, is the confession still valid as long as the priest absolves with the required form?
So, objectively, it is a mortal sin. What is the subjective dimension?
Would the absolution be valid, as described above? Not necessarily.
The correct form of absolution alone does not guarantee a valid absolution. The penitent must have at least imperfect contrition (attrition – fear of Hell rather than more perfect sorrow for offending God) and a genuine purpose of amendment (according to the Council of Trent).
If a priest wrongly assures a penitent that an objectively grave sin is not sinful, two possibilities might be teased out.
First, the penitent acts in good faith, genuinely repents of other sins, and has a firm purpose of amendment. The absolution could still be valid despite the erroneous moral advice. (I’d hate to be that priest at judgment time.)
Second, the penitent – not really being wholly convinced but because of what the priest said knowingly doesn’t repent of the grave sin, intending to continue committing it – oh my. The necessary disposition is absent, and absolution is invalid.
NB: A priest cannot make a sin permissible by declaring it so. (Neither can a priest or a pope make something permissible into a sin by declaring that it is.) Father’s erroneous counsel does not automatically invalidate absolution, but neither can the correct formula compensate for a penitent’s deliberate refusal to repent.
As for a priest who deliberately explains away grave sin in the confessional, he has grotesquely misunderstood his office. The confessional is a tribunal of mercy for the guilty, not a white washing service. The confessor is charged with helping sinners obtain forgiveness, not persuading them that they have nothing to be forgiven for. Such a priest risks sending souls away falsely informed, malformed, in spiritual peril.
I am mindful of the dense and ever useful Act of Faith:
O my God, I firmly believe that Thou art one God in Three Divine Persons, Father, Son and Holy Ghost. I believe that Thy Divine Son became Man, and died for our sins, and that He will come to judge the living and the dead. I believe these and all the truths which the Holy Catholic Church teaches, because Thou hast revealed them, Who canst neither deceive nor be deceived.
God cannot be deceived! If a person has a doubt about whether or not what he is thinking about doing is a good thing to do, he shouldn’t do it.
Let’s spin that out a bit, because it is at the heart of this scenario.
We should not deliberately act while entertaining a genuine, unresolved practical doubt about whether the contemplated action is sinful. To do so is shows a willingness to offend God, even when one is uncertain whether the particular action actually violates His law. St. Paul gives us the scriptural foundation: Omne autem, quod non est ex fide, peccatum est….For all that is not of faith is sin.” (Romans 14:23) In context, Paul is discussing someone who doubts whether he may lawfully eat certain foods. The moral principle extends beyond dietary questions, of course. When conscience warns that an action may be sinful, one must resolve that practical doubt before proceeding.
St. Thomas Aquinas explains the binding character of conscience, including an erroneous conscience (STh I-II, q. 19, aa. 5–6). Someone who chooses to act against what he judges to be God’s law sins by that very choice, even if his understanding of the particular law is mistaken.
So, we mustn’t knowingly act with an unresolved practical doubt of conscience. Neither do we have to reach absolute certainty about every moral decision. Moral certainty, including that attained through sound moral principles and trustworthy counsel, suffices.
There is an important spiritual point here, especially if someone is tempted to shop around for a confessor who will give the desired answer. The question must be, “What does God require of me?”, rather than “Which priest will tell me that what I want to do is not a sin?”
A confessor who dispels genuine doubt by sound teaching serves the penitent well. One who merely silences the warning of conscience, without establishing the truth, risks becoming an accomplice in self-deception.
When there is a genuine reason to suspect that a contemplated action offends God, establish its moral lawfulness before doing it. That is ordinary, applied prudence, grounded in reverence for God and concern for one’s eternal salvation.





















Thank you for your comments on this question.
Consider another scenario. [I don’t want to get into a rabbit hole of “what if’s” involving stranger and stranger scenarios.] The penitent is truly and sincerely unsure if a particular act is a mortal sin. He approaches the confessional with a sincere willingness to stop doing it if the confessor tells him it is truly a sin, even a venial one, and has no intent to stop if he is told by the confessor it is not any sin at all.
In that case, is the absolution valid, and is he subjectively committing a mortal sin? [What you left out is whether or not it is objectively sinful. Please don’t specify. Thanks in advance!]
Extend it further… even after being assured it is not a sin, the penitent still is unsure, and over time confesses it to numerous other well-formed priests, who also assure him it’s not a sin. Finally, he stops confessing it altogether when he goes to confession, even though he is still uneasy about it. [Now you are veering into scrupulosity, which is a different kettle of bean soup.] He chooses to trust the Church and her ministers over his own conscience. Sometimes he even performs the act as an explicit act of trust and faith in the Church. [That’s strange.]
Oh! What a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive.n
In the questioner’s scenario, could it also be possible that the penitent mistakenly believed that something was a sin, but the priest correctly explained that it was not a sin? [No. That’s not what the question was: “explain away”.] Also, if the penitent is sincerely relying in good faith on the counsel of their priest with respect to something potentially morally ambiguous, not shopping around for what they want to hear, should they not be free of blame even if the priest is objectively incorrect? [I think I answered that. No?]
Please don’t try to come up with odder and rarer situations. We know that there were/are priests who tell/have told people that certain things that are intrinsically evil aren’t sins. That is not a far fetched scenario. We know that that could confuse a penitent and leave him/her unsure about what to do. Thus, my reponse.
Is confession the time to discuss the “theology of sin” or moral theology? Should we priests not simply give absolution with love and mercy to penitents in need of an experience of God’s love and mercy in time of need?
[I’m sure you will agree that if a penitent asks for a clarification about something being sinful, you would give him a correct answer, which will either put him at ease or confirm his determination to confess it and amend his life. And, of course, a good confessor knows that he shouldn’t unduly delay absolution once he is morally certain of his sorrow and firm purpose.]
Someone I know confessed to making no sacrifice or other observance of a Friday (outside of Lent) and was told that “we don’t do that anymore.” Another person I know confessed to using artificial contraception and was told by the Priest that doing so is not considered sinful anymore. A friend told me that when this latter Priest was her pastor, he almost destroyed her faith by his unorthodox views. Of course, this errant Priest became the long-term Vicar General of our Diocese.
Of course, thanks for the clarification. Like you I would not want to discuss specific cases such as scruples.
I think a very timely instance of the original question is if someone were to attend an SSPX chapel for Mass one Sunday. Does going one Sunday constitute a mortally sinful act? Perhaps the person has heard so many different opinions on whether such a thing is mortally, or even venially sinful, there is legitimate confusion. The person wishes to confess the act if it is a sin, and if it is, intends never to go to the SSPX again, however, if it is not, they would like to go there more regularly. If the person is wavering, thinking the SSPX is preferable to the Mass they currently attend, but hesitates because there is legitimate doubt in their mind if it is a sin, and and truly does not want to offend God, it would be important to know. (This is a real scenario people I know are currently struggling with.)
I think Fr. Z provided very clear guidelines for any penitent: barring scrupulosity, when in doubt, don’t do the thing; confess it sincerely if you have done it, and have a firm purpose not to do it again.
This happened to me, maybe about ten years ago. I asked for absolution “Just in case you’re mistaken, Father?” The next Sunday, the same priest was “handing out” hosts in a bowl! I mean, you were just supposed to reach into the bowl and grab one? I shook my head and walked away. Never went back.
If this sin in question were against the VI Commandment, would this amount to solicitation? Fr. Z has covered this before, that the wording of canon 1387 “is not limited to themselves.”
Asking for purposes of completeness in the explication of possible errors by the priest in the original question.
fac, your example is precisely the kind of thing I was getting at. My wording was poor at the end. I said “He chooses to trust the Church and her ministers over his own conscience. Sometimes he even performs the act as an explicit act of trust and faith in the Church.”
I should have said something closer to this: “He chooses to trust the Church’s judgment, as expressed through her ministers, instead of acting as his own judge, and continues to perform the act with faith in the Church’s judgment.”
I tend to avoid asking questions during my confession. Most priests don’t seem equiped to handle it or maybe they think folks are looking to be let off the hook and they either say no or have a vague response that leaves you hanging. None of the priests I experienced this with were necessarily “bad” priests. No priest ever stopped me during my list; it’s only when I asked that things got murky. Even so in my heart I included that sin in my heart when I stated “for these and all my dins I’m sorry”. I don’t ask any more.
And I’ve subsequently taken Fr Z’s advice : Figure it out. If I think it’s a sin, I confess it. If in doubt , I do some praying and reading before the next confession.