Is the needle moving?

There is an interesting seesaw going on between an Algerian Cardinal and an American Bishop.

First, you may have noted that Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco, the archbishop of Algiers, Algeria, said: “We are the Church of this people. Not a proselytizing Church, not a Church that is there to convert, but a Church that aspires to be one of the components of this people.” He further asserted that “in monotheistic religions, proselytism is poison, because it implies considering the other person’s religion false.” “Do we see ourselves as a besieged fortress? Or do we choose fraternity?” Vesco asked. “For me, it is the only worthwhile option.”

Bishop Robert Barron, who needs no introduction, pushed back saying:

“Last time I checked, the Founder said, ‘All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you.’ Sure sounds like conversion to me,” Barron noted.

“When St. Paul came to Corinth or Athens or Thessalonica, his purpose was not to listen or to form a discussion group but rather to declare an unnerving message: the euangelion (glad tidings) that Jesus Christ is risen from the dead.”

Is the needle moving?“So impassioned is he for this work that he says, ‘I have become all things to all people, that I might by all means save some. I do it all for the sake of the gospel’ (1 Cor. 9:22); and ‘If I proclaim the gospel, this gives me no ground for boasting, for an obligation is laid on me, and woe to me if I do not proclaim the gospel’ (1 Cor. 9:16)!”

“Moreover, the entire thrust of the Second Vatican Council was toward bringing the Light of Christ to the peoples of the world (Lumen Gentium),” he continued. “And this missionary élan has given rise in the last few decades to the idea of a ‘new evangelization,’ which is to say, a fresh declaration of the Lordship of Christ.”

“Quite obviously, no one thinks that this work of evangelization should be done in a browbeating, overbearing, or disrespectful manner (proselytization), but for God’s sake, let’s not throw the baby out with the bathwater,” Barron wrote.

“If I really thought that the Church does not exist to bring people to Christ, then I would resign and get an honest job,” the bishop of Winona-Rochester, Minnesota, concluded.

For which Barron has been awarded a Gold Star.

Vasco has returned the volley with more contradictions.

In an October 30 social media post responding to Bishop Barron, Vesco highlighted the actions of recent popes, including John Paul II’s Assisi meetings, Pope Benedict XVI’s building closer ties with Muslims, Pope Francis’ Abu Dhabi declaration, and Pope Leo XIV’s prayers inside a mosque.

Citing these recent interfaith examples, Vesco declared that believers from the three monotheistic religions (Christians, Jews, Muslims) have “better things to do than try to convert one another” and should instead “respect one another.”

This back and forth is perhaps more revelatory than it could seem on the surface.

We have in one corner the (Francis) Cardinal Vesco and, in the other corner Bp. Barron, malgrè soi, approaches Fidei Defensor. But this is more interesting now because Vesco responded to Barron.

Now we have more than a public disagreement between two hierarchs.  Now we have a public debate, a disputatio. The Leonine and non-Leonine bishops are now coming into the ring and punching and punching back.

This is excellent! And what’s at stake is not parva res, not small stakes. Redemptoris missio of John Paul II is at stake, not to mention the Great Commission.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but although some few like Bp. Schneider have publicly criticized Francis’/Leo’s decisions (e.g., TLM, Synodality – “walking together”), we have not yet had a public debate involving these issues, wherein two principals have criticized each other so specifically. It reminds me of Burke v Kasper some years ago, where the “current magisterium” was at issue and even Ratzinger v Kasper.  Remember when Sodano went after Ratzinger on Dominus Iesus and John Paul had to referee it, I think in an Angelus address?

The venerable and ancient practice of ecclesiastical disputatio, such as what St. Augustine engaged in, helped to clarify Church teachings (and purge heresies). Recently this has been curtailed. Card. Burke criticized the organization of consistories under Leo for this particular missing element. Sitting around tables with the contemporary equivalent of newsprint redolent of seminary formation and clergy conferences is no way to bring sharp, sometimes even intelligent debates to the forefront. Instead decisions and outcomes are hyper-managed by men pulling levers behind the curtain.

If public debates, albeit through social media, are going to become more frequent and vociferous, then the needle is moving.

About Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

Fr. Z is the guy who runs this blog. o{]:¬)
This entry was posted in The Drill and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

26 Comments

  1. KerryH says:

    “Carthago delenda est!”

  2. NickD says:

    Reminds me of Goofus and Gallant.

    Vesco is either very uncreative or very poorly formed, since he creates a dichotomy between “trying to convert one another” and “respecting one another.” Anyway, it’s like he’s never read any part of the New Testament, but he was a made a Cardinal in 2024, so that’s no surprise.

  3. fac says:

    Wadda ya wanna bet Baron backs down? After listening to his Word on Fire programs and some of his other productions, (the PBS series “Catholicism” comes to mind) I’ve never thought of Baron as anything other than heterodox, trying to make a bridge from Apostolic doctrine to the “new theology.” In this clash between him and the Cardinal, I think Baron will be told offline the Cardinal is correct in his pronouncements regarding the New Direction of the Church, and Baron needs either to modify his first statements (likely) or simply let it go. And in the future, if he’d like to remain Bishop of Anyplace, never, NEVER, come out with Apostolic pronouncements without checking with the bosses first.

  4. CasaSanBruno says:

    Cardinal Vesco is putting all the Masonic talking points on display. He ought to give up his post, cardinalate voting rights, and go to a monastery to do penance or get laicized. Whatever he chooses, he’ll have to pay for this in this life or the next – or both.

  5. exNOAAman says:

    @BishopB..:”When St. Paul came to Corinth or Athens or Thessalonica, his purpose was not to listen or to form a discussion group …”..OR A SYNOD.
    A few years ago I never would’ve thought Barron would defend the faith enough to get a Fr Z gold star. (Maybe the Z-Man is right about that needle)

  6. Amateur Scholastic says:

    > Vesco highlighted the actions of recent popes, including John Paul II’s Assisi meetings, Pope Benedict XVI’s building closer ties with Muslims, Pope Francis’ Abu Dhabi declaration, and Pope Leo XIV’s prayers inside a mosque.

    I’m not on Twitter — I’m far too weak-willed for that — but I’d be interested to hear how Barron responds. We need to reach a point where bishops are willing to respectfully criticize such papal actions publicly, as any good Catholic may do.

    Popes can say, or do, bad things. They can even be condemned as heretics (yes, actual heretics, not merely negligent in containing heresy) by multiple ecumenical councils.

    The current crisis is, IMO, as much a crisis of Vatican I as it is a crisis of Vatican II. (By this, I mean the ‘reception’ of V1, not its actual text — obviously.)

  7. B says:

    “The work of the devil will infiltrate even into the Church in such a way that one will see cardinals opposing cardinals, bishops against bishops.”

    -Our Lady of Akita message from October 13, 1973 and received by Sister Agnes Sasagawa in Akita, Japan

  8. Archlaic says:

    Hmm – over the years I have consistently heard from my Jewish friends that their religion does not proselytize, does not seek converts, and seeks to be a part of the community… perhaps the good Cardinal has overdosed on ecumania, has he been hanging-out with the Chabadniks lately? One would expect more from a Dominican… perhaps he is a Jesuit “plant” in the OP’s? In secular terms, this man is committing fraud by continuing to hold his teaching office in the Catholic Church while communicating the direct opposite of the Church’s beliefs! Not that this is anythng new, but – “Bravo!” to Bishop Barron for calling him out; in times like these I wonder whether we don’t need more of this – bishop vs. bishop – with the actual, functioning Catholics exposing the modernist hirelings!

  9. Dan says:

    I have noticed a slight change in tone in Bishop Baron gradually over the last few years. There is only so much polishing of a turd you can do before you realize it is a turd. It seems to me he is reaching that point and all the facade is falling away and he has a genuine desire to simple proclaim the Gospel message of Jesus Christ.

  10. maternalView says:

    There’s hope for Bishop Barron yet.

    Keep praying folks.

  11. amenamen says:

    Proverbs 27:17.

    Iron is sharpened by iron; one person sharpens another.

  12. Lurker 59 says:

    One of the problems with Ratzinger’s, and thus that wing of Catholicism, is to treat the debate as an academic one, whereas the other side, the progressive Spirit of Vatican II^tm side, treats it as an existential one. Another way to look at it is that the Ratzingerian side of things allows the progressive side as a legitimate (if academically wrong) mode of “being” Catholic. The progressive side does not offer legitimacy to the Ratzingerian side, let alone the neo-Thomistic side — though it will do so hand-waving when not in power.

    Has the needle moved? No. It is just rhetorical posturing while the other side is out there “doing things” to ensure that they continue and that their existential opponents are buried.

    //
    @Amateur Scholastic Exactly. It is a VI problem not just a VII problem. The Spirit of VI leads to the Spirit of VII. Both are false spirits plaguing the Church.

  13. EAW says:

    @Archlaic:
    Father Schillebeeckx was a Dominican, and at the time he was far from the only modernist within their ranks. Where I live, and I hope in other places too, the younger Dominicans are generally orthodox and traditional (they wear their habits again, which older generations had discarded), but it is good to bear in mind that this doesn’t mean that the Order of Preachers has been purged of all Modernism. Cardinal Vesco’s words seem to be proof of that.

  14. Francisco12 says:

    This is absolutely bizarre coming from the Cardinal. And truly, a little infuriating. To double down on this is a bad look, and I hope to God Bishop Barron responds. He was well-deserving of the gold star. But if he backs down now, that would not be good. I pray he has the courage to respond respectfully, yet forcefully.

    But to his statement, look what he actually said. Maybe bizarre is an understatement:

    “Please dear brother, stay bishop but the Church that gives life to me is the Church of Saint John Paul II and the interreligious declaration of Assisi, whose 40th anniversary was celebrated in recent days and which Pope Leo had planned to attend; the Church of Pope Benedict, who, together with Cardinal Tauran, developed more ties with the Muslim world than any pope before him; the Church of Pope Francis, with the Abu Dhabi Declaration on Human Fraternity, signed with the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar on February 4, 2019; and the Church of Pope Leo, with his visit to Algeria and his silent prayer at the Great Mosque of Algiers, shoulder to shoulder with the rector.

    “Yes, I believe that the believers of the three monotheistic religions have better things to do than to seek to convert one another. Rather, they should accept that there is a measure of what they cannot know about the faith of the other, and respect one another in their respective faiths. Our world needs believers who are deeply rooted in their own faith and who recognize one another as brothers and sisters in our one sacred humanity.”

    What better things do we as Catholic Christians have to do but bring about Christ’s Name to all and pray that they enter His Catholic Church?! The only thing better is giving glory to God through the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass… but don’t we also give glory to God when we fulfill the Great Commission? Again, what else OUGHT we be doing? I shudder to think what the Cardinal think of non-Catholic Christians. He went ahead and just lumped in all Christians together, alongside Judaism and Islam. It would appear that he doesn’t think that non-Catholic Christians NEED to enter the Catholic Church; nor does it appear that he believe the Catholic Church is necessary for salvation. If he doesn’t want us bringing the Muslims and the Jewish people to Christ and His Sacraments, then I can only imagine he does not think it necessary to bring a Baptist or Methodist to receive the Holy Eucharist. I also wonder what he thinks of St. Josaphat as we approach his feast in a few weeks… was he wasting his time when trying to convert the Orthodox? Was his martyrdom in vain? Again, given his response to Bishop Barron above, I don’t see how the answer could be something other than “yes”. A true shame…

    I could say so much more… But one last thought: I find it interesting that the Name of Jesus still could not be used in the Cardinal’s Facebook post. He mentions the Church of St. John Paul II (who I love), and the Church of the other popes (who I also love). But truth be told… I don’t want THEIR Church. Goodness gracious, I don’t think any of them would want their OWN Church! I belong ONLY to the Church of Christ, and that is synonymous with the Roman Catholic Church. Would the Cardinal say the same? That he belongs to Christ’s Church and only Christ Church?

    May God have mercy on us all.

  15. Clinton says:

    Color me astonished at His Eminence’s flippant remark that Christians should have “better things to do” than to try to convert others. I cannot imagine Christ giving the Apostles the Great Commission, only to have them reply “we have better things to do”.

  16. ProfessorCover says:

    In response to “fac”, Bishop Barron has an independent power base, lots of loyal consumers who support his ministry. The Church uses its power, when it has it, to “discipline successfully” those whose livelihood depends on Its tacit consent. Bishop Barron will lose all respect he has earned if he backs down. And if he is censored in some way or removed from his position he has sources of income and communication that he can rely on. In fact it might make him more influential.
    Everybody knows Bishop Strickland was right, but few supported him openly when the Church’s powers that be removed him. Why? Because they considered him a nobody Bishop, as if any of the 11 faithful apostles could be a nobody. The USCCB or whatever the acronym is ought to be ashamed.
    Years before I took a job at the university where I taught for 37 years, there was a dispute between a faculty member and the local Teamsters union that represented the cleaning staff. The faculty member wrote a letter to the student newspaper in which he complained about the sloppy work the cleaners in the business school building had been doing. The union went on strike and said it would not return to work until they received an apology. Eventually the university asked the faculty member to write a letter of apology. He complied by writing a letter in which he “apologized for stating the sloppy cleaning work was sloppy.” Every one was happy until the university decided to outsource cleaning which allowed them to dismiss those who did not do their jobs. I would expect Bishop Barron to do something similar, such as apologize for stating the Cardinal’s incorrect theology is incorrect. But also, please note Bishop Barron put himself in a cage fight. He said he would resign if the salvation of souls, i .e. conversion of sinners, is no longer the goal. Maybe he is not an Aidan Nichols or a Scott Hahn, but Bishop Barron is an intellectual giant.

  17. JonPatrick says:

    Seems to me that if you truly respect someone you would want them to be saved, and the only sure way to salvation is through the Catholic Church. But what do I know I’m just a lowly Catholic with a smartphone.

  18. Not says:

    When it was decided to ask 6 Protestants to compose a “Mass” that would be acceptable to Protestants , they thought that Catholic conversions would be no more. Instead the youth are flocking to the One True Church and the TLM.
    The “I’M OK YOUR OK’ has failed.

  19. Kathleen10 says:

    Cdl Vesco speaks for Leo et al. Its appealing to think of the church as willing to dialogue about the Great Commission, never in doubt in the history of the church until now. Now the men who are in charge think that’s outdated. They are well on their way in changing the entire church including purpose. No one’s changing anybody’s mind, no one is going to be convinced to revisit that purpose. It is about Bp Barron ultimately deciding how hard he will push against the rock. He surely has zeal for God but he is likely to stop pushing when he gets that communication from on high, stop or else. Rome isn’t playing. They’re going to get what they want, barring divine intervention. It would be excellent if Bp Barron kicked off divine intervention.

  20. Saint110676 says:

    Three cheers for Bishop Barron!

    When I studied theology in the 1970s, the notion of the “anonymous Christian,” associated with Karl Rahner, was very much in vogue. I must confess that I never warmed to the concept, and I had assumed that it had long since faded from theological fashion.

    But theology, it seems, is not so different from economics: bad ideas have a remarkable capacity to resurface, often dressed up in new language.

    I am reminded of the wise counsel an older priest gave me when I was young: **“Keep the faith, and spread the faith.”** That advice has lost none of its relevance today.

  21. mickeyfitz says:

    A few of the comments here have been unnecessarily mean spirited and unfair to Bishop Barron. While I would probably categorize him as a “mainstream” or “moderate” bishop and not either really strongly “traditional” or certainly not “progressive”, I do respect his clearly documented fidelity to the teachings of the Church. Also, we all should respect his willingness in this situation to clearly and forcefully defend a fundamental doctrine of Christ and his Church.

  22. jhogan says:

    There is no need to convert non-Christians to Christ if you believe the heresy of universal salvation. (It is ironic that, for those Church leaders who indulge this heresy, this essentially means there is no need for the Church or them! They should just resign and rejoin the laity!)
    Our Lord himself told us, “Enter ye in at the narrow gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in thereat. How narrow is the gate, and strait is the way that leadeth to life: and few there are that find it!” (Matt. 7:13-14) One of the reasons the Church was founded to bring as many as possible to that narrow gate.
    Pray for our Church leaders that they all evangelize and seek to convert all people!

  23. ProfessorCover says:

    Saint110676 writes:
    “But theology, it seems, is not so different from economics: bad ideas have a remarkable capacity to resurface, often dressed up in new language.”
    I cannot speak about theology, but as an economist I am willing to assert the part about economics. Indeed, Leland Yeager, my dissertation director wrote a paper in which he argued that doctoral students should be required to study the History of Economic Thought for this very reason: Bad ideas keep reappearing.
    Several weeks ago the NO parish priest at my NO parish stated that we should always be thankful for VII because we can now read the bible. I mentioned to him that the Church has always encouraged reading the Bible as long as people did not distort the meaning. He said he had never heard that. All he knew was his family, which was devoutly Catholic, never read it.
    But perhaps it is clear that many modern seminaries don’t want seminarians to study church history lest they learn that the VO was not so bad after all.

  24. TonyO says:

    Says the Cardinal:
    but the Church that gives life to me is the Church of Saint John Paul II …the Church of Pope Benedict… the Church of Pope Francis… and the Church of Pope Leo,

    I have one thing to say to this:
    One of you says, “I follow Paul”; another, “I follow Apollos”… Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Were you baptized in the name of Paul?

    I am of the one Church, the one Jesus Christ died for. If Cdl Vesco isn’t, then he should have the honesty to get out, stop pretending to be a cardinal, and put his money where his mouth is. If he is, he must do what Christ said: “Those who keep my commandments love me” “Make disciples of all nations.” It’s plain, there’s no nuancing this into oblivion.

    fac asks:
    Wadda ya wanna bet Baron backs down?

    I am not a great fan of Bp. Barron, but I doubt it. Now that he is the bishop of a diocese, he has (just) enough traction to not feel it obligatory to yield to pressure. Pope Leo, unlike Francis, is not the sort to chuck Barron over something like this: as long as Leo doesn’t put his OWN oar in publicly, Barron’s not knuckling under to Vesco doesn’t imply “disobedience to the pope” publicly, and there’s no need for Leo to do ANYTHING about it: let the boys play at fisticuffs if that’s what they want.

    Lurker notes:
    One of the problems with Ratzinger’s, and thus that wing of Catholicism, is to treat the debate as an academic one, whereas the other side, the progressive Spirit of Vatican II^tm side, treats it as an existential one. Another way to look at it is that the Ratzingerian side of things allows the progressive side as a legitimate (if academically wrong) mode of “being” Catholic. The progressive side does not offer legitimacy to the Ratzingerian side,

    This is SOOO true! Paul VI, JPII, and Benedict all appointed men to the episcopate (and red had) that had no business in the posts, who were progressives that wanted a different Church. (Cardinals Danneels and Marx!) It’s almost like, being pope, that meant they didn’t need to listen to Pius X and Pascendi Domenici Gregis. But Francis didn’t return the favor. They may have thought they weren’t “free” to only appoint solid holy priests with solid, orthodox theology, to decline the offerings of the bureaucracies and nuncios – but Francis proved that kind of thinking is bunk. I wonder what they think now?

  25. moon1234 says:

    SO, a debate between truth and error.

  26. prayfatima says:

    Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco’s writing is too vague. I can’t understand what is being said. He needs to break it down in simpler terms. A good rule of thumb when writing is to consider your audience basically ignorant. Writing: “We are the Church of this people….a Church that aspires to be one of the components of this people” doesn’t make someone understand more of what you mean. It’s too open to interpretation. It’s like the Common Core version of Catholicism. The Catholic faith though, like math, is not vague or complicated. It’s just different. You have to learn it properly. The way it is taught matters.

    The Catholic Church has so many offshoots because the faith has not been taught well. If people think that anything goes, then it makes sense that they’ll find an easier way to live and start their own church. People need to know that Jesus was clear: not just anything goes. He has said, “I am the way.”

    Writing should be clear, unique, enjoyable to read and be an expression of an individual’s thoughts. If you happen to be wrong in your thinking, that is one thing, but it should at least be your own thoughts and not just some vague or catchy phrases.

    Bishop Robert Barron’s writing is bold and easy to understand. I like his style and that he includes quotes from Scripture. Quoting Sacred Scripture is helpful because we are essentially educating people when we try to convert them and Scripture has its own unique force because it is the inspired Word of God. Jesus said, “Every one that is of the truth, heareth my voice.” Lack of knowledge is a very common problem, but thankfully it’s easy to fix.

    I enjoy debates and think they are a type of intellectual art. I think these types of exchanges should happen more. Especially in this age of AI, we need to promote the God-created human brain and all that it is capable of. Debates can help people learn the faith and come to understand Catholic teachings in an enjoyable, non-confrontational way. People will witness others wrestling with concepts that they otherwise would know nothing about. It may be the future of entertainment and evangelization.

Leave a Reply