WDTPRS – Pentecost: “We can’t read/savor/grasp them without knowing these things.”

Pentecost Sunday’s Collect is the same as we recite after chanting the Veni, Sancte Spiritus.

COLLECT – (1962MR):

Deus, qui corda fidelium Sancti Spiritus illustratione docuisti: da nobis in eodem Spiritu recta sapere, et de eius semper consolatione gaudere.

I am pretty sure that this ancient prayer, from at least the time of the Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis and probably older, survived the Consilium’s expert scalpels to live in the Novus Ordo only as the Collect for a Votive Mass of the Holy Spirit. ­

Sideline: What on earth is the Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis, or Gellone Sacramentary (LSGell hereafter).

There is a critical edition of the LSGell in the Corpus Christianorum Series Latina edited by A. Dumas, the guy who reedited Albert Blaise’s handy dictionary of Liturgical Latin I call Blaise/Dumas.

The manuscript of the LSGell is in the Bibliotèque National in Paris and dates to around 780.  It is part of the super complicated web of manuscripts descending from what we called the Gelasian Sacramentary, the source of so many of our ancient prayers found in the Roman Missal.

There are two types of Gelasians, “old” and “new”, which in turn descend from the far more ancient Roman Libelli.  The some dozen 8th century Gelasians that survive can be used to reconstruct a lost archetype sometimes called the Roman Sacramentary of King Pepin (+768 King of the Franks, son of Charles Martel and father of Charlemagne), thus showing the blending the Roman and Frankish influences in the Church’s prayer life. One of the keys to rebuilding the archetype is a manuscript called the Gellone Sacramentary, our LSGell, written perhaps in Meaux between 790-800.

King Pepin wanted a sacramentary, or missal, for use in his territory to promote liturgical unity. But this was later supplanted by what we call the Gregorian Sacramentary, a more prestigious book, which Pepin’s son Charlemagne obtained directly from Pope Hadrian in Rome between 784-791.  The Gregorian, put together by Pope Honorius (+638), was originally the book used by the Bishop of Rome.  It later developed into different versions, including the Hadrianum type, which Hadrian sent to Charlemagne.  In any event, the 8th century “new” Gelasians were later used to fill in gaps in the Gregorian.

So, Frankish developments from the more ancient Gelasians are exemplified in the LSGell which has 3024 prayers divided in two parts, the first mainly for Mass, and the second for other rituals.  The LSGell seems to have been an attempt at a complete book for liturgical services.  And now you know.

In any event, our old Pentecost Collect from the LSGell was shoved to the back of the bus in the Novus Ordo in favor of two Collects from the Gelasian, also existing in the Hadrianum version of the Gregorian.  See how those references make more sense now?  Maybe?

There is nothing especially challenging in the Latin vocabulary of the collect. The source of Latin consolation and wisdom, Messrs. Lewis & Short’s dictionary, says that sapio (infinitive sapere) means first of all “to taste, savor; … to have a taste or flavor of a thing”. Logically it is extended to “to know, understand a thing”.  It is often paired in literature with the adverb recte, “rightly”, when wisdom is indicated.  Think of the English word “insipid” (the sap- shifts to sip-) for something without flavor and also a person without taste or wisdom. I suppose a homo sapiens is someone of “good taste”, who knows the savor of life, as it were.  Sapiens is thus connected with Greek sophos, or “wise”, or “sage” (also a savory herb!).  Sapientia, “Wisdom”, is a figure for the Holy Spirit as well as one of His Gifts.  The Holy Spirit, Parácletus, is our Counselor, leading us rightly, and Comforter, bringing us consolation.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:

O God, who taught the hearts of the faithful by the light of the Holy Spirit, grant to us, in the same Spirit, to know the things that are right, and to rejoice always in His consolation.

What leaps to my mind, steeped in the literature of late antiquity, is the connection of wisdom, inherent in the phrase recta sapere, with consolation.

There was a genre of consolation literature in classical times and late antiquity into the medieval period.  This was part of the province of philosophy (“love of wisdom”).  This literature was used as a moral medication for the soul.

In the famous work of the imprisoned Boethius (+525) before his execution, the Consolation of Philosophy, Lady Wisdom, Philosophy, comes to the author in his cell and diagnoses the true nature of his sickness of sadness.  She does this in a dialogue, so that Boethius can understand things rightly (like our recta sapere), and therefore be consoled. Lady Wisdom descended so as to raise Boethius up to God.  This is our pattern too, both in creation and in our renewal when we have sinned.

In explorations of various orations, I’ve told you how they contain influences of the ancient philosophical concept of that all creation proceeds from God (exitus) in and then turns (conversion) to thus take determinate form and return again to God (reditus). These prayers of late antiquity are echoes of these ancient philosophical concepts.

We can’t read/savor/grasp them without knowing these things.

Think now of our prayer and also the Veni Sancte Spiritus with which it is connected:

“Come, Holy Spirit, fill the hearts (corda) of Thy faithful and kindle in them the fire of Thy love.

V. Send forth Thy Spirit and they shall be created

R. And Thou shalt renew the face of the earth.”

In the Holy Spirit, who breathed life into the Body of Holy Church on Pentecost, may we all be renewed.  May He help us to return to God when we have strayed – GO TO CONFESSION! – and to return to each other, reconciled in the embrace of our Holy Catholic Church.

Pray for those who are tearing the Church and her unity to pieces and committing grave scandal.  May grace illuminate their minds and hearts before more damage is done.

 

Posted in WDTPRS |
Comments Off on WDTPRS – Pentecost: “We can’t read/savor/grasp them without knowing these things.”

Some not Vatican news notes

Today things keep rolling along and I, uncharacteristically, am paying some attention.

In regard to the terrific speech that Harrison Butker made for commencement at Benedictine College, as the lib world has a spittle-flecked nutty, I was sent these two screenshots…

What do you suppose is their average age?

Here’s something to think about…

Gower Abbey, in Gower, MO, is there the Benedictines of Mary, Queen of Apostles are.  They have so many vocations that they have to found daughter houses.  They are building a huge new place in Ava, MO and a bishop in England is helping them take over an old abbey.

The Benedictines of Mount Saint Scholastica are associated (how much is hard to tell) with Benedictine College in Atchinson, KS.   These two communities, one at death’s door and the other bursting life, are about 45 minutes apart by car.

A look at the website of the lib sisters is enlightening.  They have a photo gallery!

The shot of sister carrying the Blessed Sacrament on Holy Thursday, with a humeral veil, is striking.

The Benedictines of Mary, at Gower Abbey, also have a photo gallery.

Compare and contrast.

Meanwhile, a friend informs me that Butker’s jersey is now among the top sellers in NFL jerseys.

And there’s this from the NYPost… it’s good to know that Archbishop Naumann is still a priest.

He is still a deacon too.

About the diaconate, I saw this at The Pillar….

[…]

This week marked the deadline for the world’s bishops’ conferences to submit feedback ahead of this October’s session of the synod on synodality, and several reports claimed significant support for the admission of women to the diaconate.

Australia, Austria, Luxembourg, and Switzerland all posted their reports online and, as Luke Coppen noted this morning, claimed “widespread agreement” for a female diaconate.

[…]

According to the German bishops’ portal, the teaching on sacramental ordination being reserved to men alone “isn’t infallible doctrine,” and the cardinal appeared to agree, saying “It can be changed. It needs arguments and time.”

[…]

Maybe the Benedictines of Atchison can get involved!

UPDATE:

Meanwhile, somehow this fits right in…

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Some Vatican news notes

For big Masses with Popes the Vatican’s  Office for Liturgical Celebrations issues a booklet.  We find in the booklet for Pentecost (19 May 2024) that, in the text for the consecration of the chalice, there has been a reversion:

Thus, at least for the sake of this Sunday, the choice was made to force a a Latin word to mean something it has never meant in the history of that language because a Greek word (polloí) had been made by Lutheran Scripture scholar Joachim Jeremias to mean something it had never meant before. All this was based on Jeremias’ guess about a word Jesus might have said in yet another language read through a lens designed correct an offense to Protestants implicit in the Church’s consecration formula. That’s what ICEL did back in the 70’s, though it was corrected by Benedict XVI in the wake of Liturgiam authenticam. ICEL and others set aside the probability that Evangelists and Paul knew what they were doing and meant what they wrote (with the Holy Spirit’s help). Never mind the Fathers of the Church. Never mind the explicit teaching in the authoritative Catechism of the Council of Trent, Part II, 4, which states that the Church cannot say pro universis.

It’s Back To The Future.

In other news, the document with the new Norms of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith for proceeding in the discernment of alleged supernatural phenomena has been released. HERE It was announced on 13 May, last Monday, the Feast of Our Lady of Fatima. That immediately set of the spidey senses of molti (maybe not tutti). Some suspected that this move was designed to reduce criticism of the Holy See aroused by negative implications in the messages of apparitions. Some alleged Marian apparitions have not been positive about what’s going on. One is, of course, forced to wonder why the Mother of God would appear just to say, “Everything’s fine. Keep doin’ whatchyer doin’! You’re okay just the way you are.”

The last norms were issued by Paul VI in 1978.

Some suspected that the move was designed also to cast doubts, or undermine, previously studied and approved apparitions, perhaps because they, too, were not wholly positive about what is going on.

Indeed, the new norms do not provide for approval of apparitions or messages, etc. They merely provide for a nihil obstat statement, that something is free from error. There is to be no determination that some event is of divine origin.

As I understand the norms, the role of diocesan bishops has been attenuated.    In effect, the diocesan bishop is no longer free to make a determination on his own without, first, consulting the Holy See and, next, agreeing with what the Holy See concludes.  The bishop can investigate and so forth, but in the end his hands are pretty much tied.

Also, I read at CNA that Francis did an interview for 60 Minutes (the long-running CBS interview/investigative show).   That piece posted a tweet (yes, I know it’s X now).  Apparently this is what the producers of 60 Minutes wants us all to take away:

Conservatives are suicidal!

“Because one thing is to take tradition into account, to consider situations from the past, but quite another is to be closed up inside a dogmatic box.”

The comments under that tweet express some disagreement with Francis.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1023

White to move and mate in 2.


NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

In chessy news, something interesting is developing.    There is going to be a “poker” style “buy in” tournament.  Four players each must pitch in $1 million.  Each would play six games of rapid against the others.  1st place $2 million, 2nd place $1.5 million, 3rd place $0.4 million, and 4th place $0.   It would be at the same place where the G.O.A.T. Challenge was, a luxury resort in northern Germany. I think the players are Nodirbek Abdusattorov, Fabiano Caruana, Ian Nepomniachtchi, and the disagreeable Hans Niemann whom I believe would not fare well. It should be great viewing, especially with beer from the traditional Benedictine monks of Norcia!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1022: “laymen, vagabonds or dirty people”

From: Instructiones Fabricae et Supellectilis Ecclesiasticae, I, 23 by St. Charles Borromeo:

Even in the most modest church there must be at least two, to keep men distinct from women. If there are many officiants, as in cathedrals and collegiate churches, there will be one for each, always distinct between those reserved for one sex and the other. It must be made of wood, closed on five sides but open on the front, with the possibility however of locking it with a gate or a grate so that “when the confessor is not there, lay people, vagabonds or dirty people cannot sit there and sleep idly, with irreverence of the ministry that is exercised there. It must be divided vertically into two areas, one for the priest and one for the penitent, and must be placed so that the priest is always towards the high altar and the penitent towards the door. The partition between the two areas must be opened by a door which towards the confessor will have a curtain and towards the penitent a rather thick grate with holes the size of a chickpea. On both sides there will be reminder signs for the respective functions.

[…]

Nice people! Great service!

In every parish church there will be two confessionals so that the men, often displaying a certain amount of irreverence regarding the holy place or the holy action and not without offence to the pious objects, will not be intermingled with the women, nor crowded together with them when there is a large number for confession, but separated. In this way the men confess in one confessional, the women in the other; as is the case in many of the churches in this province, in which there are distinct parts for men and women; in those cases where the distinction has not been confirmed by a provincial decree, one confessional will be for the use of the parish priest, and the other for that of another confessor priest if, with the permission and approval of the Bishop, it is at times necessary to have him called in when there are a great number of penitents.

[…]

The prescribed form to be used in building the confessional is described below. Once this has been observed, some decoration may be added, such as carved moldings on the front or some other type of suitable ornament. First of all the confessional will be made entirely of worked wooden panels, either walnut, or some other type of wood. These will enclose it on both sides and on the back and will cover the upper part, while it will be completely open in the front part, and must not be closed in any way. It can however have, above all in the more frequented churches, a latticework door or a wooden gate, the parts of which are about four ounces apart, furnished with lock and key so that, when the confessor is not there, laymen, vagabonds or dirty people cannot idly sit or sleep therein, with irreverence of the sacred function there exercised.

Black to move and mate in 3.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

I’d rather not report on the disappointing results of the Chess.com Classic 2024. Everything changed on a single blunder.

On a happier note, help the traditional Benedictine monks of Le Barroux. Get some of the wine they make from the revived vineyards of the Avignon Popes in southern France.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

Each day it is a little harder to recognize our world.

Each day it is a little harder to recognize our world.

Here are a few of scary items.

First… just watch…

Right?

Then there is this. I am reminded of the work of many modern painters who clearly hated their subjects. What’n tarnation is goin’ on in this?

And…

And then there is this, just for fun.

Abundant observations are welcome.

Posted in TEOTWAWKI, The Coming Storm, The future and our choices, What are they REALLY saying? |
22 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1022: different kinds of matches

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

Hey s*******31@gmail.com! My thank you note was kicked back as undeliverable. New email? Drop me a note, please, so I can update.

White to move. Mate in 2.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Click!
Code CCT24 for 50% off on premium membership right now

In chessy news, Maxime Vachier-Lagrave (MVL) won Division II of the Champions Chess Tour Chess.com Classic 2024 ($15K) defeating, alas, my guy Wesley So who had fought his way back through 6 opponents in matches in the lower bracket. Wesley even fought back hard against MVL, winning an Armageddon and forcing a reset. Division I concludes today with, I hope, Magnus mopping the board with Alireza Firouzja.

My attention was caught by the new of a the 2024 Speed Chess Championship which will be held 25 July to 9 August. However the final will in Paris 6-8 September and people can be in the e-area to watch in person. This is all e-sport, not over the board. 5+1 and 3+1 blitz with 1+1 bullet in a double-elimination knockout format tournament. They will be present, but with screens between them (I think). That should make for faster play, although it is rather fun to see pieces flying and clocks banging rather than mouse slips and pre-moves. It looks like Magnus and Hikaru (speed rivals who have really battled in the past) will be in it, along with world #2 Fabiano Caruana, Firoujza (who must be defeated), MVL, world champ Ding Liren and, yay, Wesley So who is quite the dangerous speed chess player. More qualifications will be filled through chess.com Titles Tuesday dust ups.

In my own life.  I was at OTB yesterday.  Pain.  I analyzed one of my games and found that I was doing quite well into the middle game.  Then, disaster.  Not only did I completely miss my opponent’s hanging piece, I made a move that allowed him to gain tempo and get me reacting.   I did, however, use a zwischenzug effectively.  I been trying to work on in between moves.  I have a small book in a graduating series, containing puzzles which a reader sent from my wishlist.  The complier directs us to set up the position on a board and give it about 10 minutes.  I’m feeling quite sluggish.

In any event, Lord, thank you for this day.

Meanwhile, have you been following the “chess match” between “Beans” and Bp. Barron and his World On Fire empire on account of Bean’s ghastly piece in lib Commonweal?  It has Fishwrap‘s (aka National Sodomitic Reporter) full attention.  The puzzling Larry Chapp even stuck his nose into it, opining in an embarrassing way at Catholic World Report.  I can’t figure him out.  Anyway, Beans, in his usual tedious style of bomb-throwing and non sequiturs linked conservative Catholics with “Trumpism” (whatever that is… I think it is mostly patriotism, which completely confounds and terrifies the Left).  Beans smeared Bp. Strickland and Bp. Barron with the same besmirching brush, provoking Word on Fire to threaten a defamation lawsuit if Commonweal didn’t amend Bean’s piece.  I suspect that this can’t go anywhere in the courts because the bar is really high for public figures.  This will probably wind up in mutual zugzwang and a draw.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1021

Welcome registrants:

JohnintheLAT41015
ForemanJa

White to move and mate in 2.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

You might have seen this already, but… just in case.

The kicker for the Kansas City Chiefs, Harrison Buttker, is a devout Catholic who attends the Traditional Latin Mass. He gave a dose of reality to the graduates of Benedictine College.

YouTube thumbnailYouTube icon

In chessy news… the European Senior Team Championships 50+ and 65+ are currently being held in Terme Catez (Slovenia). Over 50 teams! I can appreciate that.

Otherwise, in the Champions Chess Tour Chess.com Classic 2024 Division I Grand Final it’ll be Magnus Carlsen against Alireza Firouzja. Now that the Candidates is over and Firouzja was somewhat humiliated, especially after his underhanded and ignoble machinations to bump Wesley So in the last days of December, I have relented in my irritation… a little. However, I still want Magnus to wipe the floor with him. If they exhumed the corpse of Paul Morphy to play against Firouzja, I would root for the corpse of Paul Morphy to beat him too.

My guy Wesley lost his first match in Division II, but he has clawed his way back up the ladder the lower bracket. He will face Maxime Vachier-Lagrave in their Grand Final. Go Wesley! Beat MVL!

Priestly chess players, drop me a line. HERE

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
4 Comments

From “The Private Diary of Bishop F. Atticus McButterpants” – 24-05-12 – Bp. Fatty v. Confirmations

I trust the readership will understand that while I was on my recent Roman Sojourn, I was unable to frequent the usual series of secret dead drops. Therefore collection of entries from the diary were suspended. It is good to do that once in a while anyway, just to relieve any suspicions. Hopefully, we can get the flow of entries going again.


May 12th, 2024

Dear Diary,

Confirmations coming up. Gave out even more delegations to our priests this season for confirmations, since I still gotta conserve my energy. “Long Covid” they said….all I know is that I’m already pooped halfway through the day. Some days I wake up pooped. I feel like Chester looks.

Sure missing my mom on Mother’s Day. Whenever I was sick she’d march me upstairs and put me to bed and bring me all the best stuff — her soups were amazing, and I could have hot tea with honey and arrow root cookies, toast slathered with marjarine and cinnamon, you name it.

But I’m looking forward to getting out to at least some parishes. All those young folks in our great programs.  Well, not much makes me feel better than to wisk that great smelling chrism oil onto their foreheads and say “Receive the seal of the Holy Spirit!”

I know God will look out for these kids. They are so committed to their faith. Sister Randi said she had a lot of them “disappear” on her the last few years once they were confirmed, but that’s probably still just a Covid thing too. Last year was great – not too many kids but the ones who showed up were really into their faith.

Fr. Tommy kept shoving the book in front of me and stabbing his finger at the page.  Like I’ve never done these things before?  I’m the bishop, for crying out loud!  He’s also coughing up a storm again.  This year I’m taking Fr. Gilbert with me instead.

Posted in Diary of Bp. McButterpants | Tagged
10 Comments

13 May – Our Lady of Fatima: Three points, one that worries, one that consoles, one that puzzles

On this Feast of Our Lady of Fatima, I give you three points to consider.

First, in today’s Bollettino (daily Vatican Press Office announcement) there is a notice of a presser on 17 May for the presentation of new norms for the investigation of apparitions and other phenomena. Is it a little cynical to connect such a presser with Our Lady of Fatima. After all, it is a Monday. However, it was announced today. And the document itself? There is a penchant recently for signing or release documents that are troubling on certain days. Wasn’t Taurina cacata… sorry Traditionis custodes (Jailers of Tradition) released on the Feast of Our Lady of Mount Carmel?

Some have opined that this document, coming from the Dicastery (Congregation) for the Doctrine of the Faith may be intended to cast doubts on even previously approved apparitions. That’s worrisome.

Next, Fr. Longenecker posted a close-up photo of the bullet that nearly felled John Paul II on this day in 1981.

 

That round was full metal jacket (FMJ). THANK GOD it wasn’t a hollow point or modern self-defense round designed to “mushroom”. FMJ tends to go straight through until energy is spent. Mushrooming rounds do more damage and transfer more energy on impact.

That’s a consolation.

Meanwhile, something was made known to me a while back that I have been pondering.  It involves the enigmatic Third Secret of Our Lady of Fatima.  It vexes me.

A refresher:

The three children who were the seers at Fatima, received three secrets from Our Lady.  Carmelite nun Sister Lúcia, who as a little girl was one of the three children to whom Our Lady appeared, revealed two secrets in 1941.  She did not disclose the third secret until 1943 at the command of the bishop.  She wrote it down and sealed it in an envelope and indicating that it should “opened and read to the world upon her death or in 1960, whichever would happen first.”  It was eventually sent to Rome in 1957 where it was stored away securely.    The text of the description of the vision of the Third Secret was released by the Vatican in 2000.   We have the explanations offered by Our Lady of the first two secrets.   We only have the description from Our Lady to Lúcia, but not the explanation.  Why is that?

There is controversy about the Third Secret.  Firstly, the timing of its release was a problem.  Also, the other secrets have explanations from Mary.  Where’s Mary’s explanation of the Third?

More in this book, CLICK.

Also, the Third Secret was kept in both the archive of the Holy Office and also in a safe in the papal apartments in the Apostolic Palace… so it was divided.   That’s consistent with the first two: description and explanation.  Also, there are indications that Popes read the Third Secret for “first time”… twice.  How do you do that if it is one thing?   Was one the text and the other the explanation?

In 2000 Card. Ratzinger gave a theological explanation.  Frankly, his explanation didn’t resolve the questions.  And, with due respect, if I have to choose between Ratzinger’s explanation and what the Mother God might have to say… well…..

In any event, we return to the element in the text of the description of the Third Secret vision that bothers me the most.

Here is the whole text.  The part in question is in bold.

“I write in obedience to you, my God, who command me to do so through his Excellency the Bishop of Leiria and through your Most Holy Mother and mine. After the two parts which I have already explained, at the left of Our Lady and a little above, we saw an Angel with a flaming sword in his left hand; flashing, it gave out flames that looked as though they would set the world on fire; but they died out in contact with the splendor that Our Lady radiated towards him from her right hand: pointing to the earth with his right hand, the Angel cried out in a loud voice: “Penance, Penance, Penance!” And we saw in an immense light that is God: “something similar to how people appear in a mirror when they pass in front of it,” a bishop dressed in white. “We had the impression that it was the Holy Father.” Other bishops, priests, men and women religious going up a steep mountain, at the top of which there was a big cross of rough-hewn trunks as of a cork-tree with the bark; before reaching there the Holy Father passed through a big city half in ruins and half trembling with halting step, afflicted with pain and sorrow, he prayed for the souls of the corpses he met on his way; having reached the top of the mountain, on his knees at the foot of the big Cross he was killed by a group of soldiers who fired bullets and arrows at him, and in the same way there died one after another the other bishops, priests, men and women religious, and various lay people of different ranks and positions. Beneath the two arms of the Cross there were two angels each with a crystal aspergillum in his hand, in which they gathered up the blood of the Martyrs and with it sprinkled the souls that were making their way to God.

What bothers me?  Not the part about persecution.  That’s a given.

Note that reference to seeing an image like to that of an image in a mirror.

When you see someone pass in front of a mirror, you see two of them, the real one and the image.  Two.

Hence, in this case, the vision involved seeing two figures dressed in white, one being the real one and the other being the image of the real one.  And, according to the description, Lúcia says she saw whom she took to be the Pope and a figure that was not the Pope but an image like the Pope.

Puzzling.

I am one of those who believe that we have not received the entirety of the Third Secret.  We have the description of the vision and I do not doubt its accuracy.  However, I strongly suspect that there is an additional part, Mary’s own explanation of the vision.  She explained the other two, after all.

People speculate about what the vision of the Third Secret means.  If the Holy See wants to reaffirm that we are not bound to believe in even approved apparitions of heavenly things, even less are we bound to believe human explanations of those apparitions.

Posted in Our Solitary Boast | Tagged
9 Comments