MUST READ! Why do heretics remain in the Church instead of just being honest and getting out?

At Crisis there is a MUST READ piece by Jennifer Bryson

Why Do Heretics Remain in the Church?
The counterfactual optimism of heretics keeps them in the Church while working to destroy it.

A perennial question. She breaks it down with the help of Fr. Joseph Ratzinger who developed three hypotheses in the 1970s about why heretics and destroyers stayed in the Church instead of breaking off in some way. He made distinction between hope and optimism. What was going on back then, by the way, is still going on now. So Ratzinger’s examination of the destruction of the Church’s institutions and teachings still applies. However, Ratzinger was at the time in correspondence with someone who also had an idea about why the destroyers didn’t leave, and it also rings true. The example they were working with what Holland, now nearly completely devastated.

The gentlemen in Holland are surely clever enough to know that, officially detached, they would sink into the abyss of uninteresting insignificance, whereas this way, they, of course, go on and on playing a splendid sensational role and yet, at the same time, do what suits them.

Germany to Holland: Hold my beer!

This piece is short and it is a must read.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Fr. Z KUDOS, I'm just askin'..., Our Catholic Identity, The Coming Storm, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged ,
15 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 700

Welcome new registrant:

TheKid

Use FATHERZ10 at checkout

Meanwhile, …

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Interested in learning?  Try THIS.

Your use of my Amazon affiliate link is a major part of my income. It helps to pay for insurance, groceries, everything. Please remember me when shopping online. Thanks in advance.  US HERE – UK HERE

Help the Dominicans of Summit!

American Cup FINAL is today. HERE It is do or … not… today for Wesley So (yay!). If he loses it is over and Hikaru takes the prize. If Wesley wins they go at it again on Sunday. Diminutive Alice Lee playing with white against Irina Krush.

In my OTB chess news from this morning, I … I don’t even want to talk about it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

“Only what is true can ultimately be pastoral”.

This is it.

Fr. Z KUDOS

Posted in Fr. Z KUDOS, Hard-Identity Catholicism, Just Too Cool | Tagged ,
7 Comments

24 March – Feast of St. Gabriel, Archangel – images

Today, the day before the Feast of the Annunciation, is the Feast of the announcing Archangel Gabriel.  He is one of three holy angels whose name we know from Holy Writ.  His name means roughly “God is my strength”.

Gabriel shows up in Daniel and helps to interpret his visions.   Gabriel later announces the birth of John the Baptist to Zacharias (Luke 1:5-7).  Then he announces the birth of the Lord (Luke 1:21-25).  He is named in some apocryphal works as well.  He is sometimes associated with the angel in Revelation who will sound a trumpet for the resurrection of the dead.

There are innumerable depictions of Gabriel before the Annunciate, sometimes more glorious and sometimes more humble.  All interesting.  Do you have a favorite?

Here are a few of mine.

Sandro Botticelli has Gabriel placing himself below the Annunciate.  Note the colors of their robes and the position of their hands, the echo of the tree and lily, the perspective created with the flooring.

I have a soft soft for Barocci and his colors, and his tenderness and depiction of awe. Here the angel seems to be in awe even as he announces. Dove-winged Gabriel is in the very moment of explaining while pointing to the prayer book, Scripture, in her hand.  And there’s a cat, ignoring the whole thing, which would be the usual thing for a cat to do in such a moment, for in paintings cats are often symbols of infidelity and fickleness.  I also dig Mary’s hat, hanging up.

Years later we have this.   From Glyn Warren Philpot, early 20th c.

Mary is not even seen except in the eyes of the angel.

No longer groveling below, he swoops in from above…

This is in the Scuola Grande di San Rocco. I once knew the Maestro Grande and had a private tour to all the nooks there. Fascinating. Tintoretto emphasizes the poverty of the Holy Family and sense of surprise. Heaven suddenly pours into the wreckage of human living.

And Caravaggio with that light and that characteristic hand

Henry Ossawa Tanner, “The Annunciation,” 1898

Gabriel is more like himself, I think. He reminds me of the “pillar of fire by day”. Mary would become in this moment the tabernacle of the presence foreshadowed by the tent of meeting in Exodus.  The angel is like the fire in the bush.

George Hitchcock… here the angel is the most like himself.  He cannot be seen.   This isn’t one of my favorites, but it is thought provoking.

Many will emphasize the dialogue.  Could this be the most famous?

San Marco, Florence.  Beato Angelico.  I like the raptor wings and the lovely hortus. Note the hands of the Announcing and the Annunciate.   I think you can right click and get a larger.  You need it.

Leonardo seems also to emphasize the dialogue.  Again with the hands.  The Annunciate Virgin seems to be marking her place for reading when the interview is done.  If not for her raised hand there seems to be little surprise, only slightly enigmatic attention.  The raptor-winged angel is all business.

One could multiply these nearly beyond count.

Perhaps you have your favorites.

Posted in Just Too Cool, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
8 Comments

From “The Private Diary of Bishop F. Atticus McButterpants” – 23-03-24 – Priests retirement home

March 24th 2023

Dear Diary,

Gave an afternoon of recollection at the retired priests’ home yesterday. During drinks before dinner, ancient Msgr Hinckley motioned for me to come over. Wasn’t sure I wanted to do that, since he’s been picking on me for well over forty years, since seminary. But I thought maybe he’s mellowed with age. I go over. He takes my hand, patting it, says, “I see they’re feeding you well, Francis!” Dang! He always gets me. He’s been lobbing that zinger at me since I was 20! And all the guys all picked up on it. Years of, “Oh, Francis!” He’s half the reason I dropped Francis and started to go by Atticus, leading to the inevitable.  Didn’t even see it coming.  Too late now.  Might as well embrace it.

The coordinator of the retirement home was telling me about the recent increase in costs. Astronomical! Why can’t we get some nuns or something to help out? Would be cheaper, that’s for sure. What happened to all the Sisters who taught in our schools anyway? I had them when I was a kid, and they were great.  The schools weren’t free, but they didn’t cost anywhere near what they charge now! The few nuns we have are as old as Hinckley, so that’s not gonna work. How do you get some of those young gals like Jude has in his diocese? It’s like they want to go there.  Must investigate.  NOTE: Ask Fr Tommy if any of his friends over there have a clue.

Posted in Diary of Bp. McButterpants | Tagged
6 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 699

Welcome new registrant:

KCF

Your use of my Amazon affiliate link is a major part of my income. It helps to pay for insurance, groceries, everything. Please remember me when shopping online. Thanks in advance.  US HERE – UK HERE

Meanwhile… White to move.  Find the mate!

Use FATHERZ10 at checkout

In chess news…. alas I was not able to watch since I was with a big group of priests, some diocesan, some of a certain priestly fraternity for super chow and great chat.  His dictis, Wesley dealt with Levon with a tie breaker yesterday to take the lower bracket. On the women’s side, diminutive 13 yr old Alice Lee seesawed against Paikidze and rose to victory in their lower bracket.  Some of the written commentary was fun: “In the tiebreaker, Lee understandably decided to avoid a return trip to Shabalov Land, an amusement park she clearly didn’t enjoy nearly as much as her more experienced opponent.”

In college hockey news, the noble scholar athlete Gophers of MN (1) sounded defeated the Griffins of arrogant-effete Jesuit-founded Canisius (4).  Griffins are, of course, a symbol for Christ while Golden Gophers are, of course, a symbol of the 13-Stipped Ground Squirrel.  And yet, we don’t care because everything Jesuit must be defeated.  Ite Rodentes!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 698

Photo by The Great Roman™

Use FATHERZ10 at checkout

Meanwhile,…

White’s move.  Find the net!

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Interested in learning?  Try THIS.

Your use of my Amazon affiliate link is a major part of my income. It helps to pay for insurance, groceries, everything. Please remember me when shopping online. Thanks in advance.  US HERE – UK HERE

The wonderful nuns of Gower Abbey, the Benedictines of Mary, Queen of Apostles, have a new disc and digital download:

Tenebrae at Ephesus

US HERE – UK HERE

These are the RESPONSORIES of Tenebrae for all three days of the Triduum.  They are, arguably, the most beautiful chants of the entire liturgical year.

In chess news, alas Wesley So fell to Hikaru last night in the American Cup.  Wesley drops down to the lower bracket to face Levon Aronian who ousted Lenier Domingeuz.  If I understand correctly the winner of the lower bracket then pops back up to the upper bracket to tackle Hikaru for all the skittles.

On the women’s side, alas my favorite, little Alice Lee (like Wesley also of my native place and only 13 years old) didn’t hang on against Irina Krush. So, with the same geometry as the men’s bracket, Lee faces Nazi Paikidze to pop back up to face Krush.

All of this today, Thursday. HERE And YouTube’s St. Louis Chess Club. And HERE

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

Pig hearts over altars in Austria, pagan Mayan Mass rite in Mexico, but people who want the Traditional Latin Mass must be ghettoized and railroaded to oblivion.

I’m not making this up.

Bishop Hermann Glettler of the Diocese of Innsbruck installed the so-called ‘lenten cloth’ in the 18th century Innsbrucker Spitalskirche. The giant cloth bears a photo of a a pig’s heart. Over the altar. HERE

I’m not making this up.

A 31-page long document outlining the proposed new Mayan rite highlights the institution of lay leadership during Mass and ‘the relationship with sister mother earth,’ including prayers to the four directions of the earth. If you guessed that this new rite with “indigenous adaptations” might contain pagan elements, you’d be right. HERE

But the people who desire the Traditional Latin Mass must be placed in ecclesial ghettos and eventually “railroaded” to oblivion.

Posted in Liberals, The Coming Storm, The Drill, The future and our choices |
22 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 697

Use FATHERZ10 at checkout

Photo by The Great Roman™

Meanwhile, black to move.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Please remember me when shopping online. Thanks in advance. US HERE – UK HERE

This is from Day 5 of the American Cup. Look at this low time rush to the end. Whew.

YouTube thumbnailYouTube icon

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

VIDEO: Glimpses of Forty Hours

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. The practice of Forty Hours Devotion should be revived.

Forty Hours originally evolved to ask God’s protection from external threats, such as invasion or disease. Now, it should be undertaken because of internal menaces to the Faith.

Here is a fine, brief video of Forty Hours at one of my favorite places, the Brompton Oratory in London.

Posted in Just Too Cool, Our Catholic Identity, Save The Liturgy - Save The World | Tagged
4 Comments