Obedience and being a “restorationist”

At Crisis there is a must read piece by Anthony Esolen.

Here’s how it starts…

Hello. My name is Tony. I am a restorationist.

I wasn’t always this way. I grew up in the 1960s and the 1970s, and we all took for granted everything the priests and bishops said we had to do according to the directions of the Second Vatican Council. None of us had read the documents, but we figured that our leaders had, and we obeyed. They counted on it.

When our pastor removed the marble communion rail with its mosaic inlays of Eucharistic symbols (a basket of five loaves, two fish, a bunch of grapes, the Lamb of God), we figured he knew what he was doing, and we submitted. When he whitewashed the church walls, eliminating stenciled patterns of the fleur-de-lis, so that what had been warm and shady was now bare, with no color connection between the stained-glass windows, the mural paintings of figures from the Old Testament, and the painted ceiling above, we figured he knew what he was doing, and we obeyed. When he covered the hexagonal floor tiles, white and dark green in cruciform patterns, with a bright-red carpet, we wiped our feet and obeyed.

[…]

A lot of people are going to resonate with this.

Esolen describes – through self-examination – the effects of creeping incrementalism and then… waking up.  Not woking up.

Posted in ¡Hagan lío! | Tagged
16 Comments

ROME 22/06 – Day 19: At a snail’s pace

5:32

20:51

21:15

It has been so hot here, it is hard to have an appetite.  Not many food posts, as a result.

A great inscription from the church where we had the first Benediction yesterday during the procession.

The famous eatery that serves only baccalà at the little Dar Filettaro da Santa Barbara.

One of my favorite shops in Rome.  A cartoleria on the V. Arenula.

According to a tweet the Vatican office for “Integral Human Development”, the Church “sta nel digitale… is in the digital world because people “live” there, and the Church is where men and women who live and work are.

Yeah, I when I worked in a Vatican office I used to say that the Church updates her tech every 75 years, whether it needs it or not.

Here’s the photo with the tweet, showing how integrally humanly developed the Church is in the digital world, which sounds a little like Tron.   And that’s about the right year, too.  My additions in red.

Tell me that logo doesn’t look like a snail rushing towards the future.

No?  The Future!

Which is to the Left.

And look at that painting in the background.  I suppose the painter wanted to depict Pius XI, of happy memory, with a microphone apparatus – early lavalier, perhaps – but… sheesh, they managed to make him look like Davros.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Really?

The new Vatican 20 Euro silver coin. HERE

In the past, these coins and the annual medals have been used to make statements.  Some have been pretty dramatic, such as the famous Paul VI medal of 1973.

But this?   Apart from the cartoonish quality… the jab?

Posted in You must be joking! |
12 Comments

ROME 22/06 – Day 18: Honoring the Blessed Sacrament

On this fine, sunny, hot, Roman June day the sunset occurred at 5:32.  Sunset, 20:51.  Ave Maria, you already know….21:15.

Today in many places there was the “external” celebration of Corpus Christi, or Corpus Domini, or Corpus et Sanguis Domini, or Solemnitas Corporis et Sanguinis Domini Nostri Iesu Christi, depending.  At the traditional parish in Rome, Corpus Christi was celebrated on Thursday, according to the Vetus Ordo calendar.  However, it was celebrated also on Sunday for the sake of El Pueblo… er um… the people.   This is NOT the same as transferring Ascension Thursday to Sunday, or Epiphany.

There were many restorationists present at the Sunday Eucharistic celebration.  Quite a few of them were restored to the state of grace in the confessional before and during Mass.  Fourteen of them became a new kind of restorationist by the reception of 1st Holy Communion, thus not only restoring but also reinforcing and complimenting their baptismal character.   Other restorationists were honoring their mothers and grandmothers by wearing lace in Church.  And there was one cleric present who wore a biretta for the first time, I think.  He got the hang of it.  That’s the mark of a restorationist: being able to learn new things.

There was a procession after the Mass in the streets of Rome, through the neighborhood, across Piazza Farnese to a little church where St. Philip Neri started some of his work.  Then back to the mothership.

The procession Cross.

The decoration of the altar.  Note the position of the throne for the monstrance…

YouTube thumbnailYouTube icon

The reaction of some cardinals when they heard the new red hat list.

Posted in On the road, What Fr. Z is up to |
9 Comments

Your (Corpus Christi) Sunday Sermon Notes – POLL

Far and wide the celebration of the Feast of Corpus Christi, which properly fell last Thursday, has been transferred to this Sunday.

Was there a good point made in the sermon you heard for your Mass of Sunday Obligation?  Let us know.

Also, tell us about the procession you had with the Eucharistic Lord.

Let’s have a POLL.

Anyone can answer.  Only registered and approved participants can post comments.

For Corpus Christi 2022, on either Thursday of Sunday...

View Results

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, POLLS, Save The Liturgy - Save The World | Tagged
20 Comments

ROME 22/06 – Day 17: SPLAT!

In Rome the sun rose at 5:32 and it will set at 20:51.  The Ave Maria is to be rung at 21:15 for the Curia and 21:21 for the rest of Rome. Today is the Feast of Santi Marco e Marcelliano, who were Roman martyrs in the 4th c.  Their bodies are in San Nicola in Carcere, where I served as a seminarian and was ordained a deacon.

I was in the neighborhood where guys play chess in the afternoon.  No, I still haven’t stopped to play yet.  They set up outside a bar which has a large and shady fig tree.  Thus, the place is called the Pizza der Fico.  As I was watching a game, I caught odd, vertical movement out of the corner of my eye followed by a distinct *splat*.

Ripe figs were falling off the tree about every minute or so.   All around us and among us.

I did not, as the Lord did, curse the fig tree, since it is clearly doing its job.  I did, however, back out from under it.

You would need to wash up after getting fig-splatted.  So…. remember the wonderful Dominican Soap Sisters in Summit!

And, please, if you are shopping online with Amazon, use my links to enter. Thanks in advance. It really helps me out.  US HERE – UK HERE  I haven’t been mentioning often these days some of the groups I really like to help out, the monks at Norcia and Le Barroux, etc.  And the earnings this month from the Amazon affiliate have been way down. Thank you if you are remembering without prompting.  I’d rather not have to mention it at all.

Also, for those of you who contributed to my Rome Sojourn for June, I have been regularly saying Holy Mass for your intention as special benefactors.  I also have the intention at the altar of all you who are so kind as to donate and pray for me.

A member of the chess club had planted the fig.  I find it charming that these guys went to the effort to put a plaque up, even such a humble one, perhaps homemade by a member.   I hope they pray for him too.  Perhaps in your goodness you would right now.

When I go into the churches here in Rome and see the funerary monuments and inscriptions, I often pray for the person.   Sometimes there are specific requests. Yesterday we saw one in the inscription at the Ponte Sisto.  Here is one that talks directly to you, as they sometimes do…  The angle was a little hard.

A D G
LECTOR SISTE
NEC VIVVS NEC MORTVVS
HIC HAEREO HIC MOEREO
FILIO ERAM DESTITVTVS
CONIVGEM AMISERAM
HIC
FILIO REDDOR
ET A CONIVGE NON SEIVNGOR
ET DVM
MORTVOS SPECTANS
MORTEM EXPECTO
PRAE TIMORE LAPIS
HVNC LAPIDEM ERIGO
NEC SENSV CAREO
NAM ET IPSI LAPIDES
SVAS LACRYMAS HABENT
GABRIEL PRATVS ASTENSIS

SAECVLO XVI
POST MORTEM REGIS VITAE

To the glory of God.
O, reader, stop! / Neither alive nor dead / Here I am stuck, here I grieve / I had been left by my son / I had lost my wife / Here I am returned to my son / And I am not separated from my wife / And while / Looking at the dead / I await death / like a stone out of fear / I erect this stone / But I’m not without feeling / In fact even these very stones / have their own tears / Gabriel Prato from Asti
In the sixteenth century / after the death of King of life

Speaking of Kings…

In the afternoon I caught part of Round 1 of the Candidates Tournament in Madrid.  The winner will face Magnus.

There was a lot of drama yesterday.  I really felt for poor Ding Liren, who had such a hard road to get into this competition.  He wasn’t at his best and lost to Ian Nepomniachtchi … with white! I don’t really mind when Nakamura loses, as he did to Caruana. I’m pulling a bit for the Hungarian, Richard Rapport, though he is unlikely to emerge on top unless something extraordinary happens.

There was exciting action, of course.  High drama.

Supper involved telline and lupini.

Oil, wine, garlic.  I like to let it simmer for a while to get all that garlicky goodness.

Get the parsley ready for chopping.  There may be traces of a singular Gin and Tonic in this photo.

I soaked and purged the little beasties for about 8 hours, changing the salty water a couple of times.

Put them into the hot pan, cover, wait a little while.

At this point I carefully left them out and into a bowl, leaving the liquid behind in the pan, which I reduce, with just a touch of starchy pasta water.

Telline are smaller than lupini, which are a kind of vongola, though vongole are a little bigger.  They also siphon differently, but that doesn’t matter much once they are in the pan.

Meanwhile, here are a few cool things.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

YOUR URGENT PRAYER REQUESTS

PLEASE use the sharing buttons! Thanks!

Registered here or not, will you in your charity please take a moment look at the requests and to pray for the people about whom you read?

Continued from THESE.

Let’s remember all who are ill, who will die soon, who have lost their jobs, and who are afraid.

I get many requests by email asking for prayers. Some are heart-achingly grave and urgent.

As long as my blog reaches so many readers in so many places, let’s give each other a hand. We should support each other in works of mercy.

If you have some prayer requests, feel free to post them below.

You have to be registered here to be able to post.

I ask a prayer for myself.  I’m dealing with a particular challenge right now.

Also, please pray for “A” and her family.  She is having a really tough time.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

A look at Peter’s Pence

I just saw the Vatican’s Annual Disclosure about Peter’s Pence or Obolo di San Pietro for 2021.  The collection is taken up around the world around the Feast of Sts. Peter and Paul.  It is intended to provide means for the special projects of the Roman Pontiff.

Last year, Peter’s Pence amounted to

It seems that spending outstripped income.

Who gave?

Peter’s Pence is intended to provide means for the special projects of the Roman Pontiff, charitable works, operation of the Holy See, etc.

However, Peter’s Pence was also, according to Corriere della Sera, reported by National Catholic Register, used to fund a movie about the loudly homosexual Elton John which included, apparently, homosexual acts, so much so that it was censored in some countries.

Contributions to Peter’s Pence has dropped 40% over the last few years. HERE By 15% in 2021. HERE

That’s quite a drop.   And now we are entering a global economic downturn.

Given the disdain that Francis and his closest advisors have for the United States and for us its citizens, the largest contributors to Peter’s Pence, I’d like to ask:

May we, please, have it back?

Posted in The Coming Storm, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged
12 Comments

ROME 22/06 – Day 16: A video stroll and a Vietnamese hero

You know how this goes… 5:32 – 20:50 – 21:15.

I went into Trastevere today over the Sistine Bridge, the Ponte Sisto, my favorite Roman bridge.

My goal was to visit S. Giovanni de Matha (closed), S. Dorotea, S. M. della Scala, S. M. in Trastevere, and circle back to Campo de’ Fiori to buy clams for supper and a few other supplies.

Some shots from the morning.

These saints saw the consistory list and just rolled their eyes.

And even in a different church, St. Rita is still sad!

Pius X turned positively gray when he read it!

The relics of St. Dorothy, Virgin Martyr, are here.  She was beheaded in the time of the Emperor Diocletian.  Sixtus IV, same guy as the bridge, restructured the church dedicated to S. Silvester by Callixtus II in 1123.

Next, Santa Maria della Scala, a Carmelite church.

Just inside the door is a list from the time of Paul VI of the schedule for Forty Hours Devotion.

Santa Maria in Trastevere

A really fun funerary monument. Tell me this isn’t either a huge joke or a little creepy.  Or both.

And here is a super fun monument… get this!  A guy named Stanislaus Hosius (1505-1579, so he has on his coat of arms. He was Card. Priest of this church and also Major Penitentiary.  Polish… actually Prussian.  A fierce opponent of the Protestant Revolt.

Look what’s on his tomb:

Fantastic.

I wonder what Hosius would have thought of Archbp. Roche’s latest comments.

Not bad.

A modern Roman still life… “natura morta”.

Off to the shops.

Getting telline and arselle.

YouTube thumbnailYouTube icon

Posted in On the road, What Fr. Z is up to |
4 Comments

Worship Prefect interviewed.

At Vatican News we find an interview with the Prefect of Worship, whom Francis designated as a Cardinal, Archbp. Arthur Roche, once of Leeds and less-than-successful head of ICEL.

Roche is an inveterate enemy of the Roman Rite, the Vetus Ordo, and has peculiar notions about what the Second Vatican Council mandated for liturgical reform.  He reads into documents curious things.  However, Roche is exemplary, in that he is one of those who wants to make Vatican II the only lens through which the whole of the Church’s history, doctrine and practice, including worship, must be reinterpreted.

The interview deals with more than just his war against his idea of the present day use of the Vetus Ordo.  That section, however, is probably the most important.

You get a sense of the depth of view of the Prefect concerning the use of the Vetus Ordo and the what the Novus Ordo is from a few items.

First, Roche said:

But one of the problems, challenges, of our age is the growth in individualism and in relativism, that ‘I prefer this.’ Well, the celebration of the Mass is not something to be a matter of personal choice. We celebrate as a community, as the entire Church and the Church throughout the centuries, has always regulated the form of liturgy that it has come to believe is more pertinent for a particular age.

But then, concerning what is going on liturgically in the Amazonian region he said:

[T]he inculturation of the Roman Missal into the Amazonian culture. Well, that is something that is being worked on. But first of all, it has to be worked on by the so-called Amazonian Bishops in Brazil and in Peru, etc… So, they have established a Commission which is beginning to think about that.

I suppose they are waiting to hear what the Amazonians “prefer”.

Next, there is Roche’s claim that the Council Fathers mandated a “new liturgy”. Matthew Hazell capably destroys that at LifeSite.

Roche: “It was clear that the Council, the Bishops of the Council, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, were putting forward a new liturgy….”

If this “Holy Spirit” argument is the underpinning of his claim, then is Roche also going to campaign for returning Gregorian chant to having pride of place in the Latin Church’s worship?  That’s SC 116.

The Second Vatican Council said: “The use of the Latin language is to be preserved in the Latin rites.” That’s SC 36.

The Council Fathers instructed – under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, mind you – that no changes were to be made that were not organic developments, no innovations unless the good of the Church truly needs them and that changes come from existing forms. That’s SC 23. Does that mean that Roche is going to campaign for a return in the Novus Ordo to the offertory prayers of the Vetus Ordo? The Novus Ordo prayers don’t have much to do with the Roman Rite and people haven’t been overly edified by priests ad libbing whatever they prefer at that time.

You get the point.

Also, Roche speaks of the liturgical scholar Josef Jungmann. “Father [Jozef Andreas] Jungmann, an Austrian Jesuit who only died at the beginning of this century, was someone who, in his studies, showed how over the centuries the Mass has been changed in this way in order to fit the needs of the day.” Others have shown that Jungmann went way off the rails in his work on the Roman Rite and his aims for the Liturgical Movement. He essentially became like a 16th Protestant.

However, note that, “an Austrian Jesuit who only died at the beginning of this century“.

Fr. Jungmann died in 1975.

Posted in B as in B. S as in S., The Coming Storm, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged
10 Comments