ASK FATHER: Our choir is scheduled to sing something that seems blasphemous

From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

You’re probably the only priest who can properly help me navigate this, given your knowledge of the fine arts, particularly classical music, as well as being solid on Catholic morality. You’re also the only priest whom I know is familiar with Carmina Burana (I saw you mention it in very old posts).

I’m slated to perform Carmina Burana along side my city’s philharmonic orchestra in its chorus. I’m feeling uneasy because of the subject matter and the piece that parodies the Ave Maria.  I want to sing it because it’s a major piece of the Canon of Western Music, but I also don’t want to sin and blaspheme Our Lady or anything else sacred. Frankly, the subject matter makes me want to vomit.

Navigating the arts, particularly secular choral music that is questionable, has proven to be difficult and anxiety provoking for me because I don’t know when it becomes sinful. Can you give me some pastoral guidance on this subject matter?

Thanks for the front-loaded kind words.  I am sure there are many priests out there who could help you out with this.  As a matter of fact, I bounced this off a priest friend just to be sure I was not drifting.

Firstly, it has been a long time since I looked at the texts of the Carmina Burana used by Orff.  And it is Cármina, not Carmína.

However, the work by Orff is part of a set of three pieces often performed together.  The other two are poems from the ancient Neoteric author Catullus, famous for some raunchy stuff.   I assume that you may be asking about those.

You mention the canon of western music.  There are works in the accepted canon which respect the rules of beauty and thus reflect reason and truth.  They certainly can be played and heard by conscientious Catholics.   On the other hand, there are works which do not respect these rules and our involvement with them becomes murkier.

Moreover, St. Thomas Aquinas tells us that all art and science should lead to adoration.

Hence, the guiding questions for all art and science, is whether or not it pleases God and whether or not it can be offered to Him.  We may not act on an uncertain conscience.

If the texts you are being asked to sing parody what is sacred, then it can hardly be a worthy offering to God.

That said, I recall an amusing video which provides the most famous of the Orff Carmina Burana (which is used in snippets all over the place – very drammmmatic!).   The video has “misheard” lyrics.   I’m sure everyone here knows the idea: the lyrics of some song are a little garbled and we mishear them, get them wrong, and pretty soon they are the words we remember.  You might remember the Monkey’s singing “Then I saw her face, now I’m gonna leave her.” A related phenomenon is mis-learned prayers by phonetics, as in “O God, I am hardly sorry for having offended Thee”. Here’s the video with the misheard lyrics of O Fortuna from Orff’s riff on some medieval poet or other. Orff… not my fav, but this made me laugh a couple of times. I’d pay to go to a concert with these lyrics.

YouTube thumbnailYouTube icon

 

O Fortunavelut lunastatu variabilis
O Fortune
like the Moon
you are changeable
Gopher tuna!
bring more tuna!
Statue of a big dog with fleas
semper crescisaut decrescisvita detestabilis always growing
always shrinking
detestable life
Some men like cheese
hot temperate cheese
green chalk can taste like hippies
nunc obduratet tunc curatludo mentis aciem,egestatem,potestatemdissolvit ut glaciem.

[…]

now oppresses
and then heals
as the fancy games it
poverty or power
she melts them like ice[…]
You caught two rocks?
Pet two cool rocks!
You don’t get cheese or chicken.Play chess all day.
Hold his sock tip.
She sold me good hot chicken.[…]
Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged
4 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1053

Photo from The World’s Best Sacristan™.

Meanwhile, it is black’s move.  What to do?  How would you proceed?

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Daily Rome Shot 1053

This interview underscores their unbounded contempt for you.

At the Italian site Messa in Latino there is an English translation of an interview about matters concerning the Vetus Ordo and – especially – the people who desire it, with Andrea Grillo (aka Mister Cricket).     HERE

As MiL says:

“In the view of many in the Roman Curia, for Pope Francis, Prof. Grillo is on liturgy what Fr James Martin, S.J., is on homosexuality.”

You should read this.

Virtually everything he says is false, including “and” and “the”.  That’s not the point.  This fellow is a key influencer right now.

I’ve been saying for eons that the people who want to destroy the Vetus Ordo don’t hate and fear just the Vetus Ordo, they hate and fear the people who want it.  They don’t like the people.

This interview underscores their animus in spades.  You can sense the hostility pouring out.  His contempt for you is unbounded.

 

Posted in Pò sì jiù | Tagged
29 Comments

Yes, I’ve seen the assertions about rumors, etc.

I have seen them.  You don’t need to send me links.

It is no surprise that the Vatican’s liturgical Einsatzgruppe is flecked with spittle about the Vetus Ordo.  It’s summer and they need to hurt someone.  That’s how they roll.

Remember, it is not just about the content of the prayers of the Vetus Ordo, which is the real issue.  It reminds people of the eternal consequences of their actions and it tells us how to attain Heaven, not just to long for it.   The real problem, as they see it, are the people who want the Vetus Ordo.  They don’t like the people.

However, be cool.   Resist the temptation to run after every doom and gloom YouTube video which will whip this into a click bait froth.  “Look at MEEEEEE!  MEEEE!”

The best things you can do are

1. GO TO CONFESSION

Be sure your good works and prayers are meritorious.

2.Get down on your knees, literally, and pray. 

Rosary is good.  Fast.  Give alms.  These work effectively against demons.

3. If you can, start organizing/networking with laypeople and priests about when and where the TLM will be celebrated.

4. Start approaching bishops, perhaps with spiritual bouquets in hand.

Yes, a lot of these guys have ice in their veins, but not all of them. It is said that it takes 3-4% of a population which is activated to make real changes. Be the change.

5. Home altars and Mass items.

Have you gotten everything together?

6. Ask yourself if you really care.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Amusing choice in The Chosen

I watched the most recent episode of controversial The Chosen.  A recurring Pharisee character has on his robe braiding/trim which you can get at Gammarelli in Rome for your Roman (and other) style vestments.   I sure some Smarticus Pantsicus will come up with a witty remark.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
8 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1052 – St. Benedict Medal info

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

I received an advance copy of a book to be released tomorrow, 18 June: The Cross and Medal of Saint Benedict: A Mystical Sign of Divine Power edited by Fr. Robert Nixon, OSB.   You can “pre-order”.

US HERE – UK HERE

This is a handy volume.  There are quotes from famous saints and writers about Benedict, there’s a quite hagiographical account of the life of the great saint (miracle stories, etc., always fun and edifying), a brief account of the Order and then a detailed look at the St. Benedict Medal.

As a side note, whenever I bless a St. Benedict Medal or Cross (there is a Cross in the design), all sorts of nasty things happen to me.   This chapter describes the origin and variations.  However, the definitive – and I didn’t know this – design was approved by Pope Benedict XIV (a favorite of mine) in 1741.

What I also didn’t know is that the meaning of the letters, the abbreviation of the Latin poetic inscription with powerful content, faded from memory.  It was rediscovered in a centuries old manuscript in the Abbey of Metten in Bavaria.   I have a personal connection to Metten because this was the Abbey of my great friend and mentor the late great Augustine Card. Mayer, OSB, who had been Abbot there and then was in the Curia for a long while.  He was perhaps the holiest man I’ve ever met.   I still reflect on the object lessons he gave me in life.  Metten was also the Abbey of the monk who founded the huge St. John’s in me native Minnesota.

Here’s a taste from the book…

In the Year of Our Lord 1647, the cross of Saint Benedict, which was by then already in widespread use and had been revered for some centuries, began to shine forth with a new and radiant splendor. This came about in the following manner. In a certain town [in Bavaria] called Natternberg, a coven of wizards and witches had been discovered. Once these vile and viper-like malefactors were arrested by the authorities, they were placed in chains and carefully questioned as to their nefarious activities and practices. In the course of their confessions, they revealed that their black arts were utterly powerless wherever they encountered a particular type of cross or medal [i.e. that of Saint Benedict.] For, wherever it was painted or engraved, it served as an invincible shield against the forces of evil which they employed. They went on to say that they had found that their works had no effect in the monastery at Metten in Bavaria, for many such crosses were located there.

[…]

This story goes on to recount how by then no one knew the meaning of the Letters.  Then a manuscript was discovered in Metten’s magnificent library – and if you haven’t seen photos of this library… wow.   With this ancient parchment in hand, it was possible again to read the medal.

There’s a lot more too this, also.  But you can find that in the book when you get a copy!

There is also a section on the documented powers of the medal and how to use it.  A couple of them were a surprised to me.

When I would visit Card. Mayer when he was at his Abbey (away from Rome during the summer) I had a chance to wander about in the library and grounds.

Quite the place.

I don’t recall seeing chess puzzle books, however.

White to move and mate in 2.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

Right now, for a few days, there is a big sale for FATHER’S DAY at Remote Chess Academy. 75% on some things.
Interested in learning?  Try THIS.

Posted in Just Too Cool, REVIEWS, Saints: Stories & Symbols | Tagged
5 Comments

R.I.P. Al Kresta

I was sorry to read today of the death of Michigan-based Catholic radio personality Al Kresta at the age of 72.  He succumbed to liver cancer.  Read of him at the National Catholic Register HERE.

He was a good fellow.  When I was in Detroit or at Acton University (in Grand Rapids) Al tried to have me on his program.  He was a good interviewer.

May he rest in peace.

Posted in Four Last Things | Tagged
2 Comments

Your Sunday Sermon Notes: 4th Sunday after Pentecost (N.O. 11th Ordinary) 2024

Too many people today are without good, strong preaching, to the detriment of all. Share the good stuff.

Was there a GOOD point made in the sermon you heard at your Mass of obligation for this 4th Sunday after Pentecost, or the 11th Sunday of Ordinary Time?

Tell about attendance especially for the Traditional Latin Mass.

Any local changes or (hopefully good) news?

A couple thoughts about the sign of the cross: HERE  A taste…

[…]

Many of us surely resonate with Peter’s great cry of self-discovery, the recognition of unworthiness, our sins.  Yet, again and again, from nothing God makes marvels.  He created the physical cosmos and spiritual realm of angels when, before, there was nothingness.  He took dirt and made man.  He took dirt-made-man and made woman.  He took our Fall and made of it the felix culpa, the “happy fault”.  In the Epistle readings from Romans 8 Paul describes the groaning under the effect of Original Sin of all creation, which awaits release from that bondage.  In fact, we have a foretaste of the liberation of all creation in the sacraments.  In instituting the sacraments, Christ raised matter to a new dignity in view of our sanctification.  In our Gospel, Christ takes empty efforts of men on their own, laboring in the darkness, and fills their nets with superabundance.  This is accomplished, at Christ’s word: “at Your word I will let down the nets” (v. 5).  Christ’s word then led to another down-letting, that of Peter.  “He fell down at Jesus knees”.  The verb is prospípto, “to fall forward, prostrate one’s self, to rush upon or against”.  Peter threw himself to the ground and bent down towards the Lord’s knees.  This is truly the beginning of freedom.

[…]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
1 Comment

Daily Rome Shot 1051

Hey ad************38@twc.com! My email notifications to you have been blocked. New email?

Welcome registrant:

pestolover

Procession for St Anthony’s feast at Santa Dorotea in Trastevere.  The Archconfraternity of the Most Holy Trinity is there for solidarity.  The Archcon has been inspiring other old confraternities to get going again.

The confraternities played a huge role in daily life in Rome for a long time.  Now people think the “state” is everything.  It was not always so.

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

Meanwhile, what would you do? White to move.

This was my position in OTB the other day.  The engine says we are equal, though it didn’t feel that was at the time.

No spoiler warning today.  Jump in.

Interested in learning?  Try THIS. Right now, for Fathers Day, there are discounts.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Daily Rome Shot 1050

Some of you have sent donations for my travel to the conference for priests to be held by the St. Paul Center for Biblical Theology.  Many thanks to: WH, LD, MM, BMR, JK, DC, AR, DM, JMcG, KM and today, MH, BF, and GG.  I have my expenses covered now.  That doesn’t mean that you have to stop!    o{]:¬)   This afternoon I will offer Holy Mass (BVM Sabbato) for the intention of my conference donors, to whom I am grateful.

UPDATE: Also thanks to MF, RM (73!), and LP (I couldn’t find an email address for you).

UPDATE: A link to the sermon from today’s Mass, offered for my kind conference donors.  It is excerpted from the live stream and then slightly edited, to cut out some comments about votive masses on certain days of the week.  The Mass today was of the Blessed Virgin on Saturday.

Hey s******b31@gmail.com! My thank you note was kicked back. New email? Let me know!

White to move. Mate in 2.

NB: I’ll hold comments with solutions ’till the next day so there won’t be “spoilers” for others.

In chessy news, I finished today an OTB game I started yesterday against the club president.  I prevailed, digging myself out of a jam.  Plugging all the moves into an engine for analysis is sobering.

At the St. Louis Chess Club the Cairns Cup is ongoing, a tournament for women, named for Dr. Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield. Dr. Cairns, wife of Rex Sinquefield, also announced an award of $100K, to be awarded each year for five years to US women who achieve the title of Grand Master. Incentive! I’m rooting for Alice Lee. World wide there are only 42 female GMs, 2% of all GMs.

Remote Chess Academy has a Father’s Day sale going June 16th to June 20th, offering up to 75% OFF on our entire shop, including the “Super Pack.”

The Benedictine monks of Le Barroux live stream (and on demand) the singing of the hours. They also make great wine. Try some and support them.

Please remember me when shopping online and use my affiliate links.  US HERE – UK HERE  WHY?  This helps to pay for health insurance (massively hiked for this new year of surprises), utilities, groceries, etc..  At no extra cost, you provide help for which I am grateful.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
Comments Off on Daily Rome Shot 1050