Some think that AI is here to stay. If that is so, then I am not convinced that we are (cf. Skynet).
In the meantime, AI is bringing us bread and circuses: great memes and videos, etc.
That’s what the interwebs did, then our phones did more of, then Twitter and other platforms multiplied and now AI is taking to another level.
With each level of progress we perhaps can detect in more and more people shorter attention spans, diminished interest in remembering things, ignorance about how to look things up with concrete tools.
That’s a preamble.
This is from a reader….
I just asked the brand new Chinese AI “DEEPSEEK”, about the priest’s posture during the consecration in the Traditional Latin Mass—
It’s Reply…..
Leaning over the elements and speaking the words of consecration—carries deep symbolic and theological significance. This posture can be understood as a profound reflection of divine action, particularly when compared to God the Father breathing life into Adam in Genesis 2:7. Here’s how the two are connected:
1. **Divine Humility and Intimacy**: In Genesis, God stoops down to breathe life into Adam, demonstrating His intimate involvement in creation and His desire to share His life with humanity. Similarly, the priest, leaning over the bread and wine, embodies a posture of humility and reverence, reflecting Christ’s own humility in the Incarnation and His willingness to offer Himself for humanity. This leaning posture signifies the priest’s role as an instrument of Christ, bringing divine life to the faithful through the Eucharist.
2. **The Breath of Life and the Words of Consecration**: Just as God’s breath in Genesis imparts physical and spiritual life to Adam, the priest’s words of consecration—”This is My Body” and “This is My Blood”—bring about the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. The act of speaking these words while leaning over the elements can be seen as a symbolic reenactment of God’s life-giving breath. The words themselves, like the divine breath, are transformative, changing the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ.
3. **Creation and New Creation**: The priest’s posture and actions during the consecration also evoke the themes of creation and new creation. In Genesis, God’s breath initiates the first creation, while in the Eucharist, the priest’s words, through the power of the Holy Spirit, participate in the new creation brought about by Christ’s sacrifice. The leaning posture signifies the priest’s role in mediating this new creation, bringing the life of Christ to the Church.
4. **Sacrificial Offering**: The priest’s leaning over the elements also reflects the sacrificial nature of the Eucharist. Just as Christ offered Himself on the Cross, the priest, in persona Christi, offers the Eucharistic sacrifice to the Father. This posture of leaning over the altar can be seen as a gesture of offering, presenting the gifts of bread and wine to be transformed into the Body and Blood of Christ.
5. **Mystery and Reverence**: The posture of leaning over the elements underscores the mystery and reverence of the moment. The priest’s physical closeness to the bread and wine signifies the profound mystery of the Real Presence and the sacredness of the act being performed. It is a moment of deep communion between heaven and earth, where the divine life is made present in the midst of the congregation.
In summary, the priest’s posture of leaning over the elements and speaking the words of consecration during the Traditional Latin Mass is rich with symbolic meaning. It reflects the humility, intimacy, and life-giving action of God in creation and redemption, drawing a parallel between the breath of life given to Adam and the transformative words of consecration that bring Christ’s presence into the Eucharist. This posture highlights the priest’s role as a mediator of divine life and the Eucharist as the source and summit of Christian life.
So, those were Chinese AI answers. I am curious to know what books that information was mined from, or what sites. I’d like to have those books.
Probably an English translation of the CCPA books. Some of the English translations of that bible version are shocking
Could such a – whatever – be ‘programmed’ to provide accurate documentation of sources, or does its ‘preparation’ effectively ‘always’ preclude such a possibility?
A relevant and timely post on DeepSeek here. https://www.komando.com/tips/artificial-intelligence/deepseek-told-me-some-weird-things/?utm_medium=nl&utm_source=thecurrent&utm_content=2025-01-30
I wish I had had these insights, even though it came via AI (which I never use voluntarily) for my paper in my first theology class last spring. I, too, would like whatever texts this comes from.