Archbp. Wenski @ US Bishops meeting: Young people’s search for “re-enchantment”. You see it in those who insist on kneeling to receive Holy Communion, on going to the Latin Mass.

During the annual November plenary meeting of the US Bishops, Archbp. Wenski of Miami said (except video below, but HERE is the link to the whole session near that time stamp):

Well, in all this presentation, nobody mentioned Charles Taylor or his account of secularism, which is something we’ve been dealing with for a generation or more.

I think Adam Smith* defined secularism as the disenchantment of the West. And what we’re seeing, I think, in these young people is a search for re-enchantment. You can see it in any number of ways. You see it in those who insist on kneeling to receive Holy Communion. You see it in the young people who insist on going to the Latin Mass. They’re looking to rediscover the magic, if you will, the enchantment that the Catholic Church has in such abundance.

And so I was surprised that the word “secularism” never came up in the presentation, and that “re-enchantment” was never suggested as a way of understanding what these young people are looking for. That struck me as a lacuna.

There’s a word in that intervention worth lingering over. Rediscovery.

A young Catholic kneels to receive Holy Communion. QUAERITUR: What does he believe he is doing? For that matter, what does he believe he is receiving? (Is it “what” or “Who”?) The two questions go together. If the Host is truly the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ, then getting down on one’s knees seems a perfectly sensible thing to do.

We might even ask why anyone (who isn’t stupid) should find it peculiar.

Pushing beyond what ought to be done in the Novus Ordo, we might ask something similar about young people who choose to attend the Traditional Latin Mass. Quite a few of them are discovering something their grandparents were harangued that they’d be glad to see the last of. They discover silence which gives them time to pray.  They discover kneeling which teaches them about what is happening at the altar.  The discover that they can follow the action of the Mass even when the priest’s words are in Latin or are too quiet to hear. Then they keep coming back.

They are rediscovering what their forebears discovered as if by osmosis as they grew up in the deep running waters of the Roman Rite, as if by breathing in its air whether is was at times clear or not so clear, carefully attended or maybe no so much but nevertheless … there all around them until it was part of their marrow and blood.   They are rediscovering what was covered over with “a technical production—with a construction, a banal on-the-spot product” brutally and abruptly imposed often by people who had their own agendas rather than those of the Council documents.

This last point ought to interest anyone who has ever sat through a meeting on how to get young people to come back to church.

While we all understand what Archbp. Wenski is getting at with imagery of “enchantment” and “magic”, I would have preferred a word we already have on ancient Christian liturgical foundations. Mystery. Christian Latin used both mysterium and sacramentum to render the Greek μυστήριον. In the sacraments Christ uses visible signs to confer invisible grace.  “Enchantment” can take us down the rabbit hole of what is happening in a secularized society that is flailing around for something and winding up in the spiritual tar pit of even the occult… which we see in popular culture.  Sticking to mystery, we must remystify what the post-Conciliar liturgical debacle demystified.   Rediscover transformative Mystery.

Some young Catholics are discovering at the traditional Latin Mass something that years of talk and activity have covered over. When the priest begins the Roman Canon, his voice falls away. From where they kneel, they may catch only a glimpse of what he is doing at the altar. They have to stay in one place for a while. Once they have got over the feeling that someone ought to say something, they may find that the silence itself has something to teach them.   It is a tension of the kataphatic and apophatic.  The late and greatly lamented Extraordinary Ordinary Bp Morlino said once “you can’t unveil something else it is first veiled”. We can speak truly of God, though He always exceeds what our words can say and what our minds can grasp. When Moses asked to see God’s glory, the Lord set him in a cleft in the rock and covered him with His hand as He passed by. Moses was granted a glimpse after the Lord had passed, while His face remained hidden (Exodus 33:18–23). Even the shelter of the cleft was part of the gift. God gave Moses a place to stand and showed him as much as he could bear.

The Roman Rite gives us a place to kneel. It gives us the cleft in which we do without hearing every word or seeing all gestures.  The priest raises the Host. The eyes of faith see beyond the veil of the appearance of bread as the Holy Spirit informing our minds and hears unveil the Lord Himself, giving Himself to us, transforming and divinizing us, as St. Gregory of Nyssa might say. St. Augustine writes that it was as though he heard the Lord say from on high,

“I am the food of the mature. Grow, and you will eat me. You will not change me into yourself as you do the food of your flesh, but you will be changed into me”.

Tu mutaberis in me.  Augustine is recounting an encounter with God in the course of his conversion. Benedict XVI applies the passage to Holy Communion in Sacramentum caritatis 70, where he explains that Christ draws us into Himself.

That is what is at stake in the silence, in the partial view of the action, in the time spent on our knees. The liturgy should give us the conditions for an encounter with Mystery. It should give us room to adore the Lord who makes Himself known as He wills and who, in giving Himself to us, makes us more like Himself.

Bishops can talk for hours about programs for evangelization, catechesis, and getting young people back to church. We’ve all heard the blah blah blah. The bishops might use some of their precious with the young people are making the rediscovery, who are being not “reenchanted” by “remystified”.

We are our rites.   We come to reflect inwardly and in our words and deeds what we believe and how we pray.  The Vatican II calls the liturgy “the summit toward which the activity of the Church is directed” and “the font from which all her power flows” (SC 10). That has consequences for every program on the agenda. We begin at the altar, where Christ gives Himself to us, and we return to the altar with the work we have done. If we want our efforts to bear any fruit we have to recover sacred worship as an encounter with the Mystery that changes us.

Our bishops would do better to spend time learning the Roman Rite and spend time with those who frequent it.  Perhaps then they won’t be so “mystified” by why they desire it.

*The phrase “disenchantment of the world” is associated with Max Weber (“Entzauberung der Welt”). Charles Taylor develops the theme in the 2007 book A Secular Age asking how the modern West went from a society in which belief in God was taken for granted to one in which faith is one possibility among several? Wenski probably had in mind James K. A. Smith who wrote a commentary on Taylor.

Play video

About Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

Fr. Z is the guy who runs this blog. o{]:¬)
This entry was posted in Latin, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Save The Liturgy - Save The World, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, The future and our choices, Turn Towards The Lord and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply