New Study: 29% of Catholics believe in Real Presence in Eucharist. Wherein Fr. Z rants.

At LifeSite: New study shows just 29% of Catholics believe in Real Presence in Eucharist

In short, a  survey of Catholics in September of 2025 shows that 28.8% of 1,049 self-identified U.S. Catholics affirmed that the bread and wine truly become the Body and Blood of Christ at Mass. Another 58.8% said they were merely symbols, and 12.4% were unsure. Belief was more common among weekly Mass goers, at about 60%.  After the US bishops launched the National Eucharistic Revival several years ago crisis of Eucharistic faith persists.  LifeSite’s headline suggests a decline but the study found no statistically significant change from Pew’s Study 2019 of 31%. The effect of the Revival itself is a separate question.

Some bits from the article:

[…]

In 2024, what is believed to be the largest-ever survey of lay Catholics conducted by the Real Presence Coalition (RPC) with a whopping 16,000 sample size of faithful, [NB: This is not the same survey as the main point of the LifeSite piece, Sept 2025.] showed that the top five reasons respondents attributed to the massive decline in belief in Our Lord’s True Presence in the Eucharist is the modern practice of receiving Holy Communion on the hand while standing, Communion scandalously being given to public sinners, a lack of reverence toward the Eucharist on the part of both faithful and clergy, some clergy’s “casual attitude” toward the Blessed Sacrament, and a failure of catechesis, i.e. priests simply don’t teach the faithful about the Real Presence.

Those surveyed also chose their one preferred piece of advice for bishops to foster belief in the Real Presence. The most popular (29 percent) was encouraging the older practice of receiving Holy Communion on the tongue while kneeling. The runners-up were “Catechize the faithful” (24 percent) and “Encourage greater reverence for the Eucharist” (10 percent).

Notably, more than 97 percent of respondents said they attended Mass at least once a week, and that same percentage said they believed in Christ’s Real Presence; meanwhile, 79 percent of respondents also said they primarily attended Mass celebrated according to the Novus Ordo Missae.

However, the U.S. bishops largely declined to even discuss the survey results with the RPC.

“One would think that the ‘listening Church’ would be bending over backwards to ‘listen’ to the voices of thousands of lay Catholics on why they felt there had been a loss of faith in the Real Presence and their recommendations on how this problem could best be addressed,” a member of the coalition, who preferred to remain anonymous, previously told LifeSite.

[…]

So much for listening and “walking together”.

None of this is a surprise.  It is, however, suggestive.

First, yes, there is a crisis… at least the vast majority of readers here will see lack of belief in the Eucharist a crisis for the Catholic Church in these USA.   It was apparently seen as a crisis by US bishops several years ago, or they wouldn’t have attempted that Rival.

I am firmly of the view that “we are our rites”.  The way we carry out our sacred liturgical worship will inevitably have its knock-on effect on the faithful.  There are surely powerful effects from outside the Church, secular culture.   However, I believe that proper sacred liturgical worship is even more powerful with those who regularly participate.

I’m mindful of what a now elderly priest friend – one of the 5 most brilliant men I’ve ever known – described the Traditional Roman Rite as a “suit of armor which could stand on its own”.  The Novus Ordo, celebrated in the manner of the TLM, is also quite effective.  I remind the readership that in was the Novus Ordo as it was celebrated at the legendary St. Agnes in St. Paul which drew deeply secular me into the Church.   I believe that the TLM is superior in many ways.  However, the Novus Ordo properly celebrated at St. Agnes was the hook and line that pulled me in.  Using another image, it was the nourishment of the moment which worked and which prepared me for even more solid food later.

There is an Italian proverb, popularized by Voltaire: Il meglio è l’inimico del bene, literally, the better is the enemy of the good.  We shouldn’t pass up the good we can accomplish because we insist on perfection.  The Italian also suggests that a genuine improvement can cost us a good which we already possess.  Something which truly isn’t an improvement is even more counter-productive.   I am reminded of Sacrosanctum Concilium 23: There must be no innovations unless the good of the Church genuinely and certainly requires them.  As St. Thomas Aquinas points out (STh I-II, q. 97, a. 2), following Aristotle, changing a law weakens the force of established custom. A proposed change may improve the law on paper, yet the benefit must be sufficient to make up for what the change itself costs.   The proposed liturgical reform in the 1960s may have seemed good in theory but subsequent “lived experience” shows that they weakened the life of the Church.

Some will counter that the lots of parishes in these USA are doing really well with good and faithful people and they have only the Novus Ordo. Moreover, some places in the world having a growing Church.  I respond with something I can’t prove with stats but can only suppose with confidence to be true: Think of how much better they might be if they also had the TLM.  My confidence is based on what many of us have perceived: the more the Novus Ordo is celebrated in the style of the TLM – including what it already has, that is, antiphons sung in Gregorian chant as the Council Fathers mandated – the better it seems to be.

Changing the Church’s worship the way it was changed – not merely the black and red on white but also the way it was implemented – was a tragic mistake.  Tragedies are not accidents.  A tragedy involves serious and often sorrowful events provoked by a noble or admirable character whose downfall is brought about by a combination of personal flaws and external forces. So, too, the results we see today about Eucharistic faith have come from the flaws compounded by external and internal forces which otherwise admirable churchmen wrought in haste with the guidance of some badly motived advisors who duped them.  It wasn’t an accident.

That said, this is the situation we are in.  It is not rational to deny it.  Moreover, we are the team which God called into existence at this time and place, which He knew before the creation of the cosmos.  We all have our own state in life, with its responsibilities.   If we carry out our state in life the best we can, God will give us all the actual graces we need because we are playing our role in His unfathomable plan.   Our lives have their own knock-on effect through the Church.  Sometimes that effect is direct and concrete as when we perform works of mercy.  Otherwise, I think the effect can be more like a mysterious ripple effect that radiates out through the whole fabric of the Mystical Body.  To use an analogy, a rising tide raises all boats, from the canoe to the aircraft carrier.

Our small impacts collectively make ever larger impacts.

Sure, it is clear that we need to return, in the Novus Ordo, to reception of Communion on the tongue while kneeling, ad orientem worship, the eventual phasing out of extraordinary ministers – hopefully through an increase in vocations to the priesthood.  It is regrettable that those very things are being warred upon by bishops.

Meanwhile, how much can we do in the parish where we are, with the people God has put around us? A priest can preach plainly about what happens at the consecration, and the care with which he offers Mass – his ars celebrandi – will give people reason to remember and believe what he preached. Parents must teach their children why we genuflect before the tabernacle, and then let the children see them do it when they think nobody is looking. Someone who is involved in Eucharistic adoration can ask a friend to come along. My mind reaches back to my home parish of St. Agnes.  Most of the people who took such care with the liturgy there had little or no idea what was going on in the soul of the young guy who had wandered in. God knew.  He had been setting me up for that moment for years.

If we want a Eucharistic revival, we need a revival of the Sacrament of Penance.

The Eucharistic revival will be less effective if confession remains an afterthought if it is thought of at all. In some parishes, the schedule is a farce.  St. Paul tells us to examine ourselves before we eat of the bread and drink of the cup (1 Cor 11:28). Anyone conscious of mortal sin should ordinarily go to confession before receiving Holy Communion.  But how many people understand what mortal sin is?  Understand anything about grave matter, circumstances, the effects of sin and the effects of the Sacrament?  That means that priests have to preach about sin and grace, explain how to make a good confession, and spend enough time in the confessional that people can actually get to us. There may be someone in the pew who has been away from confession for … who knows how long?  He may be afraid he won’t remember what to say. Tell him to come. Invite someone to go with you.  We can help him with the words. Think of what it will mean for him to receive Our Lord again, in the state of grace, perhaps at the very next Mass.  Over the years I’ve written on this blog – my force multiplier – I’ve receive many notes from readers that something they read here prompted them to go to confession, to get their marriage straightened out, to make some hard change.  We don’t know what effect we will have.  God knows.

Go to confession.   Maybe go a little early and spend time before the Lord as you complete a good examination of conscience.   If you go regularly, you might invite someone who has fallen away to come along and then go to lunch or supper after.   Bring people who have fallen away with you in your heart when you go to Mass and, when the priest puts those small drops of water into the chalice at the offertory, put them in together to be raised and transformed.  When the Host is raised, pray with St. Thomas the Apostle, “My Lord and my God.”  The Lord to whom you say those words is the same Lord who drew you to the altar in the first place.

You make a difference.

About Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

Fr. Z is the guy who runs this blog. o{]:¬)
This entry was posted in Be The Maquis, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Save The Liturgy - Save The World, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply