QUAERITUR: Holy Communion at an SSPX chapel

I got a question from a reader. This comes up once in a while.  I guess I really need a better blog template with a search feature.

Dear Father,

First of all, I want to say that I love your blog.  It’s really informative and a great source of Latin Mass information!

However, I’ve been wondering about receiving Communion at SSPX Masses — I saw your blog post from a while back where you basically said you’d advise anyone attending an SSPX chapel for Mass not to receive Holy Communion.  I agree with this.  But you also seemed to say that ultimately, the choice to receive Holy Communion was up to the individual.  I apologize if I misunderstood, though.  At any rate, I know a lot of people who think that it’s ok to receive Holy Communion there (these individuals might go to SSPX chapels on very rare occasions).  But even so, since their Masses are illicit, that would make their sacraments sacrilegious (despite their validity), wouldn’t it?  And so wouldn’t anyone receiving Communion from an SSPX priest (unless in danger of death) objectively be committing sacrilege?  Why don’t people seem to be aware of that?  Would it reduce their culpability by not knowing?  And I guess the bottom line here is, why don’t things seem to be so cut-and-dry regarding this situation?

The choice to receive Communion is always an individual choice, even if a person is under censure or in the state of mortal sin.  Only in rare circumstances is it up to the minister of Communion not to administer It.

Under normal circumstances if people attend Mass at a chapel which not in explicit union with Rome, or which Rome has identified as okay for inter-Communion, I advise that they do not receive Communion.

Yes, even if the Mass is valid.  Manifest unity with the Bishop of Rome is very important.  The SSPX, if it is not a schismatic group – and we are told by high authority they are not – does not have manifest unity with Rome.

However, there may be those circumstances in which a person is impeded, physically or morally, from attending an approved Catholic church or chapel and from receiving Holy Communion. By a "moral" impediment I can envision that either there is a personal reason why a person can’t go to parish X, or that the Mass there is celebrated with so many abuses that one can’t overcome repugnance, etc.  By physical impediment I mean something like distance.   In any event the impediment must be real, not just an excuse.  God cannot be fooled.

In those cases, when a person has been without Holy Communion for a grave reason, and for a long time, and it is a burden, or there is the obligation to receive Communion according to the Church’s law (at least once a year), then a person could receive at such a chapel.  This would be similar to a person in a country where there are few or no Catholic churches, such as in Greece, where one would have a preponderance of Orthodox churches.  Optimal? No.  But the good of one’s soul requires some leeway.

I hope and pray for greater manifest unity between Rome and the SSPX.  These folks can do a great deal to accelerate the good changes which will occur as a result of Summorum Pontificum and the efforts of our Holy Father.  It is time to start effecting change from within.

Are their Masses "sacrilegious" because they are not celebrated in perfect union with the Roman Pontiff?

No, I don’t think they are.  They are certainly irregular.  But in most cases I think they want, they tend to unity with Pope even if they don’t manifest that desire through obedience.   If they were sacrilegious, I would say no one could ever go.  So, I think we have to set aside the category of "sacrilege".  Not everything done in disobedience is automatically sacrilegious.

It is far more likely that you could find a Mass celebrated in a sacrilegious manner, because of liturgical abuses, where the Novus Ordo is being twisted beyond recognition.  And there are such Masses, as that video from Call To Action demonstrated. 

There just aren’t easy answers to any of this.  Indeed, so much could be cleared up by a softening of hearts, an opening of minds, and clear, unequivocal submission to the Roman Pontiff.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
50 Comments

Tallahassee TLM – 8 June

Here is a little promotion.  I got some new via e-mail:

Hello Fr. Z!

Things continue to form well on our upcoming inaugural Tridentine Latin Mass.  It will be held on Sunday, June 8th, 2 pm (Eastern Time) at the Co-Cathedral of St. Thomas More in Tallahassee, Florida.  It is a one-time mass, but if successful will lead to other TLMs in the future, and then hopefully a permanent one for our eastern section of the Diocese.

If you are within striking distance of Tallahassee you might consider participating in this Holy Mass according to the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Question about TLM’s in the the Portland area

I got this question from a reader in Alaska:

Father Z,

I’ve been reading your blog in the effort to find this myself and it sounds like the Portland, OR area might work out for me (?)  I still pray for the return of the traditional Mass up here, but don’t think it will happen soon.

I have enough frequent flier miles to go to Portland about once a month for Mass and sometimes, Alaska Air has last minute discount fares for the weekends.  I don’t, however, know exactly where to start looking – I’m not rich enough to go wandering around the state of Oregon at random.

Suggestions?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

From a reader about the PRAYERCAzT audio projects

I got this from a reader (edited):

Dear Father Z,

I’ve recently gotten our pastor to start the TLM, and we had our second  monthly mass this Sunday.  (Trinity Sunday)  We’re now getting grief from the bishop, but that’s another story.

I was contacted by a woman in the parish that wanted to learn more about the Latin and what it sounds like.  I recall you had several posts where you went through the prayers at the foot of the altar, etc. but after hours of searching, I cannot find them.

Would you please direct me to the proper place on your site where I can find these and help this dear lady.

I’ve commented under ___ and also ____.  I didn’t want to ID myself, since I was working with the pastor to start this mass and he wanted to keep it a secret until we were ready and got it underway.  We’ve done that and are now getting the grief.

God bless you for all the wonderful work you are doing for the TLM and the church.

The audio PRAYERCAzT projects are all listed on this page, and there is a link to this page on the left side bar (at least as long I we have this template for the blog, that is)

You might let us know what sort of grief you are getting from the bishop.  Remember: keep copies of every piece of correspondence and notes of your conversations.

About the PRAYERCAzTs: I stopped doing them because there seems to have been too little interest in them to merit my effort to make them.  They were originally intended to help priests get the Latin into their ears, and therefore their tongues, but they could also have been useful to help lay people in the congregation prepare to participate more fully at Holy Mass.

I would make them again if there was enough support, but I didn’t have enough evidence that many people were actually using them.

Posted in PRAYERCAzT: What Does The (Latin) Prayer Really Sound L, SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

QUAERITUR: Fatima prayer in Latin

I got this via e-mail:

A friend of mine … wants to know if there is a Latin version of the Fatima prayers, specifically the one say during the Rosary: "O my Jesus, forgive us our sins. . ."   Can you help?

I am sure this good, but optional, prayer is originally in Portugese. I don’t recall ever having seen an official or approved translation.

There must be any number of translations into Latin floating around out there.  I am sure some readers will provide variants… and maybe even their own Latin versions!

 

Let start with this.

Iesu mi, dimitte nobis peccata nostra, salva nos a flammis inferorum, duc in caelum omnes animas, praesertim misericordia tua maxime indigentes.

This will work in a pinch. 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
27 Comments

Diocese of San Diego and Summorum Pontificum: not very friendly

His Excellency Most Reverend Robert Brom, Biship of San Diego in California has issued a statement to priests about the implementation of Pope Benedict’s Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum.

But there is an interesting twist in it.

A kind reader transcribed the memo and so I can share it with you.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.  The underscore is in the original.

May 16, 2008

To:       Priests in the Diocese of San Diego

Fr:      Bishop Robert Brom

Re:      Latin in the Liturgy

Enclosed you will find a slightly revised version of the Application to the Diocese of San Diego of the Apostolic Letter of Pope Benedict XVI, Summorum Pontificum.

After discussion with the Presbyteral Council, I have decided to form a committee of the council to assist me with the proper implementation of this Motu Propio. Members of this Latin in the Liturgy Committee [Nota bene: This concerns Latin, the Latin language.] will be Bishop Salvatore Cordileone and Fathers Bruce Orsborn (chair), Matt Spahr, John Dickie and John Proctor.

The committee will help me in the following ways:

1.         to assure the competency of priests who wish to celebrate in Latin either the Mass (whether in the extraordinary or ordinary form) or other sacraments (whether according to the older or present ritual);  [So, this concerns both the older and newer forms of both Mass and all the other rites for which you need to use the Rituale Romanum, in the older or newer forms.  The point is Latin.  However, this also demonstrates that the training priests have received has a huge gap in it.  They should have been trained in Latin in seminary.  At least the Code of Canon Law says so.]

2.         to evaluate [not quite sure what "evaluate" means here] with pastors the conditions required for celebrating the extraordinary form of Mass in their parish when they have received such a request;  [First, we don’t know what "evaluate" is.  Are they simply going to offer advice?  Will they attempt to approve of deny implemenation of the Motu Proprio?  Priests who are pastors don’t need any advice from a committee.  According to Summorum Pontificum, the pastor, not a committee, makes these decisions about the parish.  Also, this assumes there are requests.  Card. Castrillon Hoyos (Pres. of the P.C. "Ecclesia Dei", recently said that priests can and should provide the older form of Mass even if people have not yet requested it.  He indicated that this is also the will of the Supreme Pontiff.  I still want to see that in a document, however.  Still, you can sense, in this point #2, that the powers that be in San Diego want to continue as if Summorum Pontificum didn’t exist.]

3.         to evaluate requests for regional, interparochial or non-parish-based celebrations of the extraordinary form of Mass;

4.         to evaluate with pastors requests made to them for the administration of other sacraments in Latin according to the older ritual;  [Surely pastors can evaluate these things on their own.]

5.         to ensure that responding to the good of those who desire the extraordinary form of Mass or the celebration of other sacraments according to the older ritual will not undermine the unity of the Church.  [HUH?  How will celebrating a sacrament with the older Rituale undermine the unity of the Church?  I should think that not using the Rituale when requested would more likely drive people toward some chapel that was not in union with Rome or the local biship.]

Consequently, I am asking [I am not sure what this means.  Is this request a requirement?  If so, it seems to fly in the face the legislation of the Supreme Pontiff.] every priest in the Diocese of San Diego to respect the following protocol:

1.         Competency to celebrate the Mass or other sacraments in Latin will not be presumed but verified by the Latin in the Liturgy Committee before any such celebrations are attempted.  [Here is a problem.  I think that because someone stood up and announced to the bishop at the time the men were being ordained, that those candidates were worthy, the assumption has to be made that they are in fact competent, unless they demonstrate they are not.  So, this seems like a tourniquets looped around the necks of the priests.]

2.         Pastors will consult with the Latin in the Liturgy Committee before they schedule Mass in the extraordinary form or other sacraments according to the older ritual.   [This is a "request", apparently.  But who knows what this means, in practical terms.]                          .

Our collaboration in this matter is extremely important since, as you know, bishops with their priests are to be the directors, promoters, and guardians of the entire liturgical life in the church entrusted to them.

SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM

Apostolic Letter of Pope Benedict XVI

APPLICATION TO THE DIOCESE OF SAN DIEGO

Priests

According to the Apostolic Letter, Summorum Pontificum, priests are authorized to use the Roman Missal of 1962 in the celebration of Masses without the people on any day except in the Sacred Triduum (art.2). The faithful who spontaneously request it may be admitted to these private celebrations (art.4).

Notwithstanding this authorization, priests should not attempt celebrating Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 without competence as regards both the rubrics involved and the Latin language required (cf. the cover letter of Pope Benedict to his Apostolic Letter).  [We are back to the big question of what idoneus means in the Motu Proprio.  Also, the cover letter of Pope Benedict is not the actual legislative document.]

They may do so in churches or chapels only with permission of the appropriate authority, and may not advertise these private celebrations.  [Did you get that?  This is saying that Summorum Pontificum doesn’t apply to the Diocese of San Diego.  Priests still need permission of the bishop, or whomever, to say Mass publicly.  Is that not clearly contrary to the Motu Proprio?  Correct me if I am wrong.  Notice there is no citation of the Motu Proprio or the Pope’s cover letter here.]

Religious Communities

Religious communities may have celebrations of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 as authorized by the Apostolic Letter (art.3).  [So, religious priests can enjoy their proper rights as outlined in the Motu Proprio, but diocesan priests, or religious who are pastors, cannot?  Great.]

Pastors and Parishes

In any parish, a stable group of parishioners who are attached to the older form of the Roman Rite may request the celebration of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 on weekdays or even on Sundays and feasts (art. 5.1 & 5.2).

Pastors may accede to such requests only when they come from their own parishioners and when a competent priest is available to preside.  [So… are they going to stand at the door and check identification cards?   "Dein Ausweis, bitte!  Sorry, you may not enter.  You belong to St. Ipsidipsy down the street.  Away with you!  Also, notice that there is no citation here of any paragraph of Summorum Pontificum, as there is in the point before and those which follow.]

Pastors must see to it that the good of these parishioners is harmoniously reconciled with the overall pastoral care of the parish, under the governance of the Bishop according to Canon 392, always avoiding discord and fostering the unity of the whole Church (art. 5.1).

Subject to these same conditions, pastors may permit celebrations of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 in particular circumstances such as weddings and funerals (art. 5.3).

As the good of souls may suggest, pastors may grant permission to use the older ritual in administering the Sacraments of Baptism, Matrimony, Penance and the Anointing of the Sick, i.e., Extreme Unction (art. 9.1).  [But do they have to call the committee first?  "Hey guys, I have someone about to die here.  Can I consult with you about the use of the old Rituale?]

Again, pastors may grant such permission only to their own parishioners, and when there are celebrants available with rubrical and linguistic competence. [Again, no citation from the Motu Proprio.  Interesting.  This begs the question of how competently many priests celebrate the Novus Ordo in the vernacular.  I think there would also have to be committees set up for every language in use in San Diego.  I am guessing there might be a few.]

Just as in the celebration of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962} there may be no intermingling of parts from the new Roman Missal, so in administering the other Sacraments according to an older ritual, there may be no intermingling of parts from the new rituals.

Special Permission

Permission of the pastor is required for any other priest to preside at a parochial celebration of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 or at a parochial celebration of the other Sacraments according to older rites.

Permission of the Bishop [!] is needed by any priest who wishes to preside at a celebration of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 or at a celebration of the other Sacraments according to older rites outside of a parish church, for example, in chapels. [Really?]

Permission of the Bishop [!] is also required for individuals or groups of the faithful who desire interparochial or non-parish-based celebrations of Mass according to the Roman Missal of 1962 or celebrations of the other Sacraments according to older rites.

May 15, 2008

It strikes me that the Holy Father’s Motu Proprio was not give a very warm reception in the chancery of the Diocese of San Diego.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

ALERT: Go give John some encouragement

I ask all you WDTPRSers to take a couple minutes from your busy day, go over to Orbis Catholicus, and leave a note to encourage my friend John Sonnen to continue to post his good photos from life in Eternal City.

Alright… GO!

Go on, already!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on ALERT: Go give John some encouragement

Prayer request

Please pray for a woman friend of mine in Rome who is finally getting married!

I couldn’t be happier for this good outcome.

Also, they have chosen to keep things rather low key, which emphasizes that the SACRAMENT, not the photos, is the most important thing.

I wish I could be there.  I would be able to observe my anniversary back in Roma Eternal as well.

A huge donation …. but I digress.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Crazy day

Today I solved problems.

Problems. Problems. Problems.

Then, work out time.

I listened to an audio book version of The Surgeons’ Mate at the same time as I played through a level of Halo II on legendary and burned calories on a machine. 

Talk about multitasking!

Supper.  I harvested some of the first good herbs from the garden for some sauce for pasta.

Twins beat the Rangers in a pretty strange, full moon, game.  It seemed an NL game.

Toward the end of the day, I check stats for the blog.

It was crazy weird today.

Crazy day

Pretty strange spike.  Dunno why.

They must be looking at bird photos.

Still, thanks!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Podcast Awards

Have any of you heard of this?

http://www.podcastawards.com/

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments