EWTN’s Raymond Arroyo reacts to comments about coverage of the Papal Visit

EWTN has posted something about their coverage.  Since WDTPRS spoke of it many times, I think it only fair to include what Raymond Arroyo postedwith my emphases and comments.

THE AFTERGLOW: HANDICAPPING OUR COVERAGE
Tuesday, April 22, 2008
________________________________________
We are still receiving hundreds of e-mails to our papal visit box every hour and I am delighted. The vast majority of correspondents were ecstatic about our coverage of the Papal visit. [And with good reason, I think.]  Below is just one of the thousands of kudos that I think captures the spirit of what we were trying to accomplish with our broadcasts:

"Raymond, I want to thank you, and EWTN for bringing our Catholic family this wonderful coverage of the Holy Father’s Journey to the USA. Listening to you, Father Neuhaus, Carl Anderson, and Joan Lewis was lovely. I felt like I was enjoying a great big family reunion. The family was gathered. The uncles were telling stories and the children were listening with rapt attention, soaking up every detail of each story. There were prayerful moments, musical moments, poignant moments, anxious moments, moments of good natured joking and serene moments of ineffable joy and thanksgiving as together our family celebrated the most marvelous event any family could hope to celebrate with their beloved Papa. "

Still there were those irked by some of our commentary, particularly during the Masses. Since I can’t possibly respond to every cranky e-mail (some of them downright nasty) I will do so here.   [If those e-mails were anything like the nastiness sent to me by the habitually sour, then I am in great sympathy.]

Firstly, there are obligations that BROADCASTS make upon us. One of those is narrating for our international and domestic radio audience for whom silence is not golden, but death. Many radio listeners wrote to us wondering "what was happening" when long areas of silence prevailed. So that explains some of the "scene setting" that we at times engaged in.  [That is a tough tight rope to walk and this deserves our comprehension.  At the same time, would it not be wonderful to have access to an audio feed that was just that?  Just the feed?  But I digress…]

Regarding commentary: our job is to put these papal events in context. That means evaluating them and explaining them in the context of Magisterial teaching and the writings of the Holy Father. Other broadcasters this past week imposed their pop culture perspectives on the visit (focusing on the need to ordain women, the Pope’s fashion, and polls which found that no one believes what they should believe to be considered believers). I think for the general public (even the average Catholic) there is great lack of understanding. Few have had time to read the Pope’s writings with any attention and even fewer have had occasions to watch him with any frequency. What we tried to do, delicately I think, was to reveal the thinking behind this or that speech (or event), connecting it to what has gone before.  [I think they did very well with this!  The content was good.]

Commentary was inserted into pockets of events consciously avoiding stepping on the key parts of the Mass etc. Still some felt we should be entirely silent during the Masses–a papal C-Span. So we made a decision to say NOTHING during the St. Patrick’s Mass, and in flooded a torrent of viewer protest. "What happened to your commentary?" "Please don’t stop commenting. It’s like being left alone," our e-mail screamed. I have learned my lesson, we will continue to split the difference with due deference to the sacrality of the events we are covering, but we shant be silent.  [They took the risk to be silent and they got feedback.  I suppose this will help them make decisions for coverage in the future.  Frankly, I think their coverage has improved over the years.]

It is important for all of us to realize that what EWTN offers is a BROADCAST of the papal Mass, not the Mass itself. [Yes. This is true.] This does not fulfill a Catholic’s Sunday obligation and should not be viewed as a liturgy substitute. [Though I am sure shut-ins see it slightly differently, but…] It is a televised representation of the Mass with inherent challenges and professional requirements. For those who were annoyed, I am sorry. But for millions of viewers, the commentary helped them make sense of what they were watching and sort through the reactions they were experiencing. And that’s what we were trying to do.

Thank you all for being with us for this truly amazing visit, and I hope you’ll watch the World Over this Friday for more analysis of the trip… Gratefully, Raymond
 

I am very glad that Raymond Arroyo posted this.  He is a stand-up guy for that.  I do get the sense, nevertheless, that the negative e-mail got under his skin a little…. but it will sometimes do that. 

I am among those who like to hear the live sounds without people talking over them.  This is why I hope someday that there can be a raw feed.  I also fully understand the need to comment… that is why they are there and the comments are very helpful, nay rather, critical for 95% of the viewers.  Still, perhaps there may be ways in the future to improve the timing of the commentary.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

Some thanks to you readers and a penjing report

Coming back to the Sabine Farm after this last trip was a bit like coming home for Christmas.

Piled up on my counter were loads of mail and…. BOXES!  People had been busy with my Amazon wish list and I am very grateful.

Some thanks to you readers and a penjing reportThere was a very small 320GB external hard drive which will be enromously useful for travelling.  I can load my resources and reference library onto this.  It had gotten to big for the old drive.  Thanks to RM for this!

JM was kind enough to send Season 3 of Battlestar Galactica (the gritty new version which has just begun Season 4).  I can’t read Ambrose and Augustine all the time and this was great.  Thanks JM!

RR sent Redeeming Time: T.S. Eliot’s Four Quartets by Kenneth Paul Kramer. 

AD sent the Michael D. O’Brien book Island of the World.  I have read his other books and found them to be very engaging and useful.  I dare say in some respects they are also prophetic (though I hope not, in some ways).

Not on the Amazon list, but was sent to me by the publisher, I found waiting for me Priestblock 25487: A Memoir of Dachau by Jean Bernard.  I hear this is now a movie, too.

Finally, a penjing report

Penjing (the bonsai a reader sent me from the Amazon list) did not fare perfectly during my absence. 

I am afraid my guy fell down on his penjing sitting. 

I found its soil nearly dry when I got back. 

There were quite a few yellow leaves, too.  Grrrr. However, that could be in part from its exciting voyage across the Land of the Free to the Sabine Farm, change of light, water, etc.  Still, I was hardly pleased.  I also noted that the spray bottle hadn’t been used, and penjing like that sort of thing, to get moisture through their leaves.

Some trimming is in order, I think, and then some strong sun for a little while each day…. when I get some sun, that is.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

QUAERITUR: Putting the Church back into my life – Differences between a Novus Ordo Latin and TLM?

When I got home to the Sabine Farm, I found that the birdfeeders had been absolutely picked clean – chickadees can be greedy little things – and I had 1241 e-mails waiting for me.

I get lots of news and lots of questions. Most of them… well… I cannot even think of answering.

Especially when they are like this:

I am asking for your help in ascertaining the differences between a Novus Ordo Latin and an Extraordinary Form Latin Mass.  I fell away from the church over forty years ago and have finally decided that it’s about time that I put the church back in my life.  I used to be familiar with the High Mass and a regular Latin Mass, is it the same difference? 

This is job for WDTPERers!

The question is both really involved (it would take a year to answer) but really good, especially in light of this fellows desire to return to the Church.

Help him out with useful comments.

I will first add this.

The major differences can be found in the attitude and content of the actual texts of prayers for Masses, especially on Sundays.  After that, the greater room given to silence and the greater emphasis on the "vertical" dimension of Mass.

Now I think you readers can take over.

Really think about this for a while.  The stakes are rather high.   Don’t be disrespectul of him or either form of Mass. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

FLORIDA ALERT: TALLAHASSEE – TLM 8 June

More good news, this time in Florida.  Since what was sent in the hated pdf format, I will simply refer you to the note I got.

Hello Fr. Z!

My name is Stephen Mozier, a layman and Oblate of St. Benedict from Tallahassee, Florida. I am writing to you today to let you know that we are going to be having a Tridentine Latin Mass at the Co-Cathedral of St. Thomas More here in Tallahassee on Sunday, June 8, 2008 at 2 PM.  Here is the link to our parish bulletin, announcing the TLM (it’s on page 3).

It would be wonderful if there was a good turnout for this mass!  [Indeed… for every Mass.] It is a one-time shot, though if successful it may lead to more TLMs being held here in our eastern area of the diocese (of Pensacola-Tallahassee).  May God bless this endeavor, and if you will, please spread the word! 

Sincerely yours in Christ,

Stephen Mozier, OblSB

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Beaune, France: monthly TLM

If it can happen in France it can happen at your parish.  Here is a nice note from a reader:

Beaune, France: monthly TLMDear Fr Z,

I am writing from France where I check your blog daily.

I thought you might be interested to know that as of the 4th May there will be a monthly Mass in the EF on the first Sunday of every month at 18:30 at the High Altar of the magnificent Basilique Notre Dame in Beaune, capital of Burgundy Wine.

The Mass will ordinarily be a Missa cantata.

Yesterday the young priest who will celebrate the Mass organized a practice for the servers and we had seven keen young boys who came.

If you have some time would you be able to publicize this Mass on your blog as I have seen that you have people in our area who read WDTPRS.

I have attached a photo to give you an idea of how splendid the Basilica is.  By the way the sanctuary was much improved at the practice by the removal of the forward facing altar.

Many thanks for all that you do.

In caritate Christi,

Capital of Burgundy wine, you say… hmmm… maybe I should check out the TLM in Beaune.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

A priest teaches his flock about the TLM – this guy gets it!

This great news begins, as it so often does, with a nice note from a reader:

Fr. Zuhlsdorf,

Long time reader, first time partaker.  I know you’re extremely busy so I’ll try to keep this short.  While doing some research on the TLMs offered in the Connecticut area (not my home region but a place I may be visiting) I found this message from the Parish Priest, Fr. Greg Markey, of St Mary’s Church, found in this week’s bulletin.  Here is clearly a young priest who “gets it” as you would say.  He says:

“Personally, I would like to say that one of the greatest graces I have received from the Lord since my ordination was to learn the Traditional Latin Mass.” 

He plans on speaking at all of the Novus Ordo masses this coming weekend about the TLM and offering a weekly, 4 part instructional class on the TLM. 

You may have already covered this parish (although a Google search on your site yielded nothing) but in case you hadn’t I figured I’d make you at least aware of these happenings since a) this priest deserves to be recognized for his attempt to bring tradition and beauty back to the church in line with what you’ve called Pope Benedict’s “Marshall Plan” and b) you’d like to be informed of another priest who’s helping to “change the tide” so we say.

Words cannot express how immensely your blog has helped me in my understanding of the liturgy and therefore, my understanding of the fullness of the faith.  Truly, “Save the Liturgy, Save the World.”  May God continue to bless you and your work,

I went to the website of St. Mary’s Parish to find what Fr. Markey had to say:

Week of April 13, 2008  

            A priest teaches his flock about the TLM - this guy gets it!Next week will be a historic moment for the Catholic Church in the United States when Pope Benedict XVI visits for the first time as the Holy Father.  Here we have the Vicar of Christ proclaiming the Good News, a message of hope and reconciliation, to the religious and governmental leaders of our nation.   We pray that that many fruits will come from this trip as we joyfully await his arrival.
            In anticipation of the Pope’s visit the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life released some telling statistics about the state of Catholicism in the United States which in many ways reflects the demographic changes within Norwalk.  "No other major faith in the U.S. has experienced greater net losses over the last few decades as a result of changes in religious affiliation than the Catholic Church," the Pew report notes. Citing the extensive survey the Pew Forum explains that "roughly one-third of those who were raised Catholic have left the church, and approximately one-in-ten American adults are former Catholics."
            Nonetheless despite the wholesale exodus of "cradle Catholics," the Catholic proportion of America’s overall population has remains constant, according to the report, thanks to the large number of Catholic immigrants, primarily from Mexico. Hispanics now account for 29% of the Catholics in the US, and nearly half of those under the age of 40.  This is clearly reflected here in Norwalk and at St. Mary Church.
            While we are pleased to help Catholic immigrants, the decline of American Catholics is disheartening.  For example, a Gallup poll showed that in 1958 three out of four American Catholics attended Sunday Mass regularly; by 2000 the figure was closer to one out of four.  These are only a small portion of the painful statistics that show a Church in dramatic decline.  While we are still seeking to implement the authentic documents of the Second Vatican Council, it is clear that Vatican II has yet to bear the fruit that so many had optimistically prophesied.
            So what happened to the Catholic Church in the United States over the past few decades?   The writings of Pope Benedict indicate that he is very much aware of this crisis of faith, and his visit gives us an opportunity to reflect on his mission as the Vicar of Christ.
            Firstly, Pope Benedict XVI is arguing for a “hermeneutic of continuity” with the Second Vatican Council, an interpretation of the Council which sees its implementation rooted in the Tradition of the Church.  Pope Benedict states that any essential break or discontinuity with the Church’s doctrine would be contrary to the intentions of Pope John XXIII, who called the Council, and contrary to the Faith.
            Secondly one can reflect on the issue that has defined Pope Benedict’s papacy more than any other up to this point: his motu propio Summorum Pontificum.   Pope Benedict made the Traditional Latin Mass acceptable in the main stream Catholic Church practically overnight in one of the few dramatic papal initiatives since the Second Vatican Council.  Pope Benedict has become convinced of Traditional Latin Mass’ enduring beauty as well as the necessity of restoring authentic Catholic worship.  As he wrote, “I am convinced that the crisis in the Church that we are experiencing today is, to a large extent, due to the disintegration of the liturgy.”  [This priest gets it!]
            We are very blessed to have the Traditional Latin Mass here at St. Mary Church, the Extraordinary Form, every Sunday at 9:00 am.   Personally, I would like to say that one of the greatest graces I have received from the Lord since my ordination was to learn the Traditional Latin Mass.  To me it expresses both the mystery and fullness of the Catholic Faith like nothing else, and I would like to share this grace with as many people as possible.  [Yes… he gets it.]
            In order to help people understand the Mass I have included a stuffer in this week’s bulletin on the Traditional Latin Mass.  Please take some time to read it.  Like many treasures in life, this Mass takes time [brick by brick] to appreciate and understand, but is well worth the effort.
            Furthermore, I will be preaching all of the English Masses next weekend, April 19th and 20th, specifically about the Traditional Latin Mass.   Then I will then be having classes on the Traditional Latin Mass beginning Monday April 21st, in the evening, based a new excellent book on the topic, Sacred Then and Sacred Now, by Thomas Woods.  Books will be sold after Mass next weekend at a discount price.
            It is my sincere desire that more people in our parish will become exposed to this gift of the Traditional Latin Mass.  I also hope to bring the Mass up from St. Patrick Chapel to the main church every Sunday.  St. Mary Church is the “Mother Church of Norwalk”, with a history of leadership in the community.  This is another opportunity for us to show leadership, and to truly implement what the Holy Father is praying for, a renewal in our Catholic Faith.

Sincerely in Christ,

Fr. Greg J. Markey
Pastor

 

Fr. Markey also has a interesting FAQ section:

Questions relating to the Liturgy

    * Why does St. Mary’s sometimes have the Mass in Latin

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments

Church Signs on Papal Visit

You should check out Kansas City Catholic from time to time.  Here is their latest church sign exchange:

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

PCED clarifies: Summorum Pontificum 6 allows vernacular readings instead of Latin

There is an interesting development in the matter of Summorum Pontificum and the use of the vernacular in celebrations of the TLM.

The Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei reponded to a questions proposed concerning Art. 6.

The questions were: "Can readings be given in the vernacular in the context of the Liturgy?  Does Article 6 uphold the practice of duplicating the readings reading them in the context of the Liturgy in Latin, then before a homily in the vernacular, or does it allow them to be read from the Altar in the vernacular?

Also, can local editions of the Missal that refer back to the 1962 Missal could be used for this purpose (i.e. the one that came out in the US in early 1964.  For example, a Missal faithful to the rubrics of the 1962 Missal, but with a vernacular proper.  This was given approval for use in the US by the Holy See.

The responses:

1. Article 6 of the Motu Proprio summorum Pontificum forsees the possibility of proclaiming the readings in the vernacular without having to proclaim them first in Latin.

2. The readings may be proclaimed in English according to translations approved for liturgical use by the Holy See and the Bishops of the United States.


PCED clarifies: Summorum Pontificum 6 allows vernacular readings instead of Latin

I remember when the text of Summorum Pontificum was issued, I suggested that Art. 6 did in fact bear the interpretation that vernacular readings could be used instead of Latin.  Lot’s of people pretty much freaked out and did everything but promise to dig up my mortal remains, try me and throw me in a river.

It seems I was right after all.

Don’t get me wrong: I do NOT think that what is permitted here should be imposed on congregations.  That would be a terrible idea, if people didn’t want such a thing.  However, Summorum Pontificum permits this, according to the PCED.  I can think of some occasions when I might be good to do.  I bet you can too.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
148 Comments

Domincan Liturgy blog

I want to alert the readers to a new site focused on Dominican liturgy:

Aptly, this site is called … Domincan Liturgy.

It is run by a WDTPRS friend, Fr. Augustine Thompson O.P.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Help from the readers: Eucharistic procession

I got a question from a reader:

This summer I’ve been assigned to a small rural parish in the diocese … and my pastor and I have been talking about doing a  Corpus Christi procession.  He’s excited by the idea, and I’m gently trying to convince him to do a procession around the downtown block where the church is, rather than just the parking lot … more of a witness to our neighbors.  :)

My question: is a canopy required for a Eucharistic procession?  Every photo I’ve seen online seems to imply yes.  You’re the best person I could think of to ask.  Sorry to bother you with this question … I know you get tons of email and so on.

Secondly (ok that’s two questions!): Is there any official rite for a Eucharistic procession? 

Some of you will have specific information for this questioner.

What I am also interested are stories about how you may have gotten a Eucharistic Procession organized at your parish or chapel.  Let’s have some stories and practical pointers.

Less Chatter – More Processions

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments