I tip my biretta to MG who alerted me to the differences in the wonderful John XXIII cope used by His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI for the 1st Vespers ceremony the other day.
Here is the cope as worn by Pope Benedict.
Here is the cope worn by Pope Paul VI.
Notice anything different?
Keep in mind that Pope Paul was fairly tall, and Pope Benedict is not. Also, remember that the cope is generally help up by deacons when moving, so the length was not a problem for either Paul or Pope John.
Coat of Arms by D Burkart
A Daily Prayer for Priests
Nota bene: I do not answer these numbers or this Skype address. You won't get me "live". I check for messages regularly.
WDTPRS
020 8133 4535
651-447-6265
on The “trowel” and the “sword”. That’s what is needed now.: ““You who desire our traditional sacred liturgy need to work with your trowels in one hand and your swords in…”
on #ASonnetADay – Sonnet 146. “Poor soul, the centre of my sinful earth…”: “Thanks, as always, Fr. Z.”
on The “trowel” and the “sword”. That’s what is needed now.: “Yes, is it any wonder the parishes are in trouble when at the doors holy water has been replaced by…”
on The “trowel” and the “sword”. That’s what is needed now.: “In my Novus Ordo diocesan parish, we have a Sunday TLM which appears to now be the most attended Mass…”
on Sudden, so far unexplained departure of Philadelphia Carmelites: “Hi NB, I appreciate the conversation; unfortunately we do not share the same perspective or level of optimism. To your…”
on LIVE VIDEO – 16 April 2021 – 1200 NOON CST – Traditional Latin Mass – Votive of the Sacred Heart: “C’mon, Father! Don’t you know this “unreformed” liturgy is supposed to “disappear”?! Get with the program! ?”
on A Jesuit’s brilliant notions about needed liturgical reform. What could go wrong?: “Consider: The liturgical changes were pushed for “pastoral” reasons–those in the pews would rejoice at the changes. Parish priests would…”
on One year ago, today: Card. Pell acquitted: “Fr. Perrone’s case sounds like a straight-out case of disobedience by the archbishop, which should be investigated by the Vatican.…”
on A Jesuit’s brilliant notions about needed liturgical reform. What could go wrong?: ““The church might also allow Catholics’ spouses to share Communion if they share our faith in the Eucharist.” WOW. Just…”
on One year ago, today: Card. Pell acquitted: “The Vatican might have asked Beijing for permission to be critical of the Australian High Court.”
on A Jesuit’s brilliant notions about needed liturgical reform. What could go wrong?: “albinus1 they could simply rule that TLM’s be held at an inconvenient time such as 10 AM on a weekday…”
on A Jesuit’s brilliant notions about needed liturgical reform. What could go wrong?: “One thing came to mind as I read Fr Reese’ whole piece: How does this man succeed in holding priestly…”
on One year ago, today: Card. Pell acquitted: “Note too that any profits from Cardinal Pell’s journals are being used to pay off his legal fees – contrary…”
on One year ago, today: Card. Pell acquitted: “And Fr Gordon MacRae https://beyondthesestonewalls.com/about https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2014/01_02/2014_02_08_TheseStone_StoryBuried.htm”
PLEASE subscribe via PayPal if it is useful.
That way I have steady income I can plan on, and you wind up regularly on my list of benefactors for whom I pray and for whom I periodically say Holy Mass.
In view of the rapidly changing challenges I now face, I would like to add more $10/month subscribers. Will you please help?
For a one time donation...
My "challenge coin" for my 25th anniversary of ordination in 2016.
Want one? I do exchanges with military and LEOs, etc.
Loading ...If you travel internationally, this is a super useful gizmo for your mobile internet data. I use one. If you get one through my link, I get data rewards.
Loading ...
They find you a pro-life agent in your area who commits to giving a portion of the fee to a pro-life group!
Help Monks in Wyoming (coffee – UPDATED LINK) and Norcia (beer) and the wonderful "Soap Sisters" of Summit, NJ!
Please follow me on Twitter!
Visits tracked by Statcounter
since Sat., 25 Nov. 2006:
Got to love those Italian tailors.
And thank goodness Pope Benedict XVI is not so short that the tailor had to remove the Stemma! Fr. Guy would have cried!!
–Guy (naw…. I’m the other Guy)
Aw, come on…why did they shorten it?
The cope when it was used by Paul VI was actually called a “papal mantle,” and I guess it was only used on more special occasions (that was at Vatican II when Paul VI was wearing it). I’m going to guess Don Guido wanted it shortened so it would just be a cope and so it could be used in more ordinary liturgical functions like Vespers, etc. According to the wikipedia, its use ended under (*gasp*) Paul VI after the post-VII reforms.
The other major difference between the two pictures is that Benedict doesn’t have a dour Cardinal Ottaviani standing next to him, which would definitely make his picture way cooler.
I think Paul VI and Benedict XVI are about the same height, the long papal mantle just made Paul VI look taller. I hope they just folded the hem inward rather than cutting off.
Actually, papal mantles are supposed to reach from 7 up to 10 feet in length,
so I was wondering why the cope worn by Pope Benedict XVI was, well, short
as a modern cope, even though it was John XXIII vintage.
It would have been nice to have seen him attended by two Cardinal Deacons,
but it was wonderful all the same!
From the pictures where the cope is held open for walking (e.g. http://i264.photobucket.com/albums/ii186/kjk76_96/BenedictXVIaa.jpg?t=1199313419 ), you can see that it was not folded in, but really cut off, a pity. However, in comment on Hallowedground (where this was originally discussed), latinmass1983 said: “Someone told me that it was Paul VI who shortened it to its current state, but still, there are other Manto’s in the Papal Sacristies waiting to be used.”
Well there are differences, but viewers ought note that Card Ottaviani, next to
Paul VI is not wearing an alb while he is wearing the deacon’s vestment. Why is
this so? Half dressed perhaps and you would not see that today. Also, paul VI
was not that tall either. I have stood next to Paul VI at an audience in the
vatican when he was alive and he was only about 5ft 9ins at the most, not much
taller than Benedict. But the old vestments are being brought out of
storage by Marini II since he took over in late october. The big change though
was the raised dais at Vespers last Sunday which is a throwback to Paul VI
time. So, this could now be a solid restoration which is good for St Peter’s
and ought be in regular use. Semper fidelis…
The cope was shortened by Paul VI. Ottaviani is wearing a rochet rather than an alb because the deacon and sub-deacon of honour in a Pontifical Mass from the Throne wear that in the old rite. In the New Rite equivalent they should wear albs like the first deacons. That said, if one goes to ‘Orbis Catholicus’ and sees pictures of some of the better Cardinals taking possession of their churches (ie. in the context of a full Pontifical Mass in the New Rite) their deacons of honour are wearing rochet as if it were the Old Rite. I must say… I am not complaining!
It has been observed many times on these blogs that the Deacons at the Throne
at a trad. Pontifical Mass, Papal or otherwise, do not wear an alb, but the dalmatic
directly over the surplice or rochet. To do otherwise is unrubrical.
What I always notice in these “close to the end” pictures from the early
60’s is how sad Cardinal Ottaviani looks. I never neglect an op-
portunity to say ‘Laudetur semper nomen eius a nobis omnibus’.