From a reader…
I know [having artificial flowers by the tabernacle] is wrong and I shall speak with the flower arrangers. Could you please give me some advice that I can pass on.
Well… my first piece of advice is not to talk to the flower arrangers about artificial flowers unless they are ugly…. that is… the flowers are ugly, not the arrangers. Ehem.
There is nothing wrong, in se, about the use of artificial flowers in church for the altar, etc. As a matter of fact, the older Caeremoniale Episcoporum (I, xii, 12) expressly allowed vases of flowers made of silk between the altar candlesticks. The old Catholic Encyclopedia, commenting on the rubric, took the reference to silk as an indication of the quality expected and urged that flowers of inferior material be kept off the altar.
That might clear out the priest along with some extraordinary ministers, too, come to think of it.
The liturgical object called a portapalma illustrates the principle well. A portapalma (plural portapalme) is a decorative vase or stand used on traditional Italian altars, often between the candlesticks. The name literally means “palm holder.” The “palma” it holds is sometimes palm branch-shaped or else a stylized bouquet of flowers and foliage made of silk, worked metal, or carved wood. The word portapalma can also refer to the whole ornament, vase and spray together. At The Parish™, Santissima Trinità dei Pellegrini in Rome, you may sometimes see among the candlesticks on the high altar what look from a distance like bouquets: the stems, leaves, and blossoms are worked in metal. There are photos of various portapalme HERE, at NLM.
For the Novus Ordo, GIRM 305 says that there can be floral arrangements around the altar but not on the mensa. GIRM is silent about the material of the flowers. I see no reason that portapalme or other artificial flower couldn’t be use at the altar, provided that they are not ugly… the flowers, that is, sorry about your hideous Cranmer table. Maybe use it ad orientem as an instant improvement?
In the Chapel of the Two Trinities here at SOUTHCOM, I use as portapalme four gold plated bouquets of roses which have crystals embedded in the blooms. Gifts from readers all the way. I occasionally swap them out for a small artificial silk arrangement. When I was a bit more flush with regular donations I used to get real flowers, usually alstroemeria, which last a long time out of direct light. So, my gold portapalme fill a great gap.
Anyway, if you do decide to approach the flower arrangers, I’d begin by thanking them for taking care of the sanctuary. Then I’d suggest fresh flowers when they’re available. They may respond that they don’t have the budget or that they are too much work or that this is what “Father wants”. Don’t start a fight. And don’t say that all artificial flowers are always wrong. I’d frame the conversation around what is worthy of the place and helps people turn their attention to Our Lord.




















