Papyrus fragment gone wild!

Remember the ridiculous “Mrs. Jesus” papyrus fragment flap?

L’Osservatore Romano, taking a break from commentary on The Simpsons, has offered a view.  This time, however, the editor, they seem to be on target.

A papyrus adrift

“Harvard scholar’s discovery suggests Jesus had a wife”. With this title Fox News continued the reporting on the conference held on Tuesday evening, 18 September, by Karen L. King during the 10th international conference on Coptic studies at the Institutum Patristicum Augustinianum, only a few metres away from Vatican City. Of similar tenor, but with variations of tone and critical understanding, as well as, the barely pertinent references to Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, was the news buzzing around the European and Italian media in the following days. The news was quickly reported. In the course of the conference the scholar presented a fragment of a papyrus which bears phrases, translated from Coptic, of a dialogue between Jesus and his disciples about a woman, Mary, whom he describes as “his wife” (ta-hime / ta-shime, which in Coptic corresponds to what we call “woman” or “wife”). There is nothing unusual about this for a scientific congress. However, in this case, the excessively direct link between research and journalism – that makes short shrift of the long periods required by more serious scientific discussion – had already occurred before the conference, given that the very premature news in the American press on Tuesday depended on an an interview that the Harvard academic had already given before leaving for Italy.

In spite of the drift in the media marked by tones which are quick to shock, unlike so many other items presented at the conference, the papyrus was not discovered in the process of excavation but came from an antiquarian market. Such an object demands that numerous precautions be taken to establish its reliability and exclude the possibility of forgery.

Alberto Camplani

My mother has a small papyrus bed growing in her back yard in Florida.  Maybe I could put something together.   Hmmm….

Posted in Linking Back | Tagged ,
21 Comments

“He was going to be a major leaguer, absolutely”

The writing is a bit scrambled, but have a look at this story of a fellow who gave up a promising career in baseball (the sport God loves best) for a vocation with the Norbertines in Orange, California:

SILVERADO, Calif. – On the morning Grant Desme ceased to exist, he was at peace. He spent years searching for serenity, convinced it was coming soon, next, now. It never did. Life was a blaring stereo, and he had become numb to its noise. The sound finally abated when he arrived here. He believed God muted it.

So on Christmas Eve two years ago he and seven other men marched into the church at St. Michael’s Abbey and readied for a transition the church considered spiritual death. Grant Desme would go by another name. His plainclothes would become a head-to-toe white habit. For the next two years, he would commit to the dual life of a priest-in-training and a monk in the Norbertine Order. The naming ceremony bound him to the virtues of chastity, poverty and obedience.

[…]

On the afternoon Grant Desme retired from baseball, he was at peace. The world in which he had immersed himself was shocked and dumbfounded, of course, that a strapping 23-year-old center fielder with power, speed, smarts and just about everything baseball teams want in a player would quit. Sports is a place of great myopia, insular thinking and exaggerated accomplishment that conflates excellence and holiness. In baseball, God is the home run. And Desme knew that God well.

He hit 31 of them during the minor league season and another 11 in the prospect-laden Arizona Fall League, where he won the Most Valuable Player award in November 2009. He emerged as the talk of the league, and the team that drafted him in the second round and signed him for $430,000, the Oakland Athletics, started dreaming on Desme’s future.

“He was going to be a major leaguer, absolutely,” A’s general manager Billy Beane says."He was going to be a major leaguer, absolutely" [BTW… I have found the movie Moneyball (the Billy Beane connection) to be an interesting source of reflection on, mutatis mutandis, how we might try to get some spheres of the Church functioning again.] “He looked like he’d gotten over that hump. And he could’ve been a lot more. A great talent.”

People in the game scrambled to understand why Desme would give up the riches and the platform baseball affords to spread the word of God. The decision wasn’t met with derision as much as wonderment. Athletes leave when their talents or bodies or something tangible betrays them. Desme left ascendant.
“I had everything I wanted,” he says, “and it wasn’t enough.”

[…]

Read the rest there.

Posted in Just Too Cool, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
10 Comments

AP’s cheap shot coverage of the Pope’s Butler’s unbelievably unimportant Vatican Trial of the Century!!!

The Trial.  Nay rather… the Trial of the Century!  The earthquake provoking butler-who-done-it in the Vatican!

The trial of the Holy Father’s document-leaking former-valet (keep repeating: the Butler, in the Office, with a Copying Machine), is comparable to what the ancient Romans called a fluctus in simpulo, “a wave in a ladle”.  There is no there there.

But newsies are having a nutty … because they can.

A case in point is a really bad article by AP’s Nicole Winfield.

Winfield doesn’t usually go off the rails, but this time the trolley slipped in an embarrassing way.  Perhaps all the vapid gas being vented about this in the Italian press gave her a temporary case of the vapors.

Given that readers scan the beginning and the end of pieces like this, and given that writers know this, it was pretty clear what Winfield was trying to get a across.  You decide.

The middle section of her article involved some reporting.  The opening and the close were distracting, frivolous.

Have a look:

Pope’s ex-butler goes on trial for leaked papers
By NICOLE WINFIELD, Associated Press – 1 hour ago

VATICAN CITY (AP) — There was a time when a Vatican trial could end with a heretic being burned at the stake. [?!?  This is how she starts her report after today’s briefing?  Really?] Paolo Gabriele doesn’t risk nearly as dire a fate, but he and the Holy See face a very public airing [“very public” as opposed to a little bit public… ] over the gravest security breach in the Vatican’s recent history following the theft and leaking of the pope’s personal papers.  [Desperation, like a zombie, stalks the press corps, waiting to eat warm brains.]
Gabriele, the pope’s once-trusted butler, goes on trial Saturday, accused of stealing the pope’s documents and passing them off to a journalist — a sensational, Hollywood-like scandal that exposed power struggles, intrigue and allegations of corruption in the highest levels of the Catholic Church.  [For pity’s sake. They just don’t have enough to do.  The Holy See isn’t blameless. The Press Office doesn’t give them much to work with.  When they get a whiff of chum, they have a little thrash in the water.  Maybe if there were, I dunno, real engagement by the Holy See …  But I dream… I digress…]
Gabriele is charged with aggravated theft and faces up to four years in prison if convicted by the three-judge Vatican tribunal. He has already confessed and asked to be pardoned by the pope — something most Vatican watchers say is a given if he is convicted — making the trial almost a formality.

[…]

[…  in fairness Winfield does some reporting in the rest of the piece which might be of interest…]  

[… skipping to the end…]

There has been no such vote of confidence for the Vatican’s onetime Congregation for the Holy Roman and Universal Inquisition, [?!?] the commission created in 1542 that functioned as a tribunal to root out heresy, punish crimes against the faith and name Inquisitors for the church.  [Just in case you didn’t catch that whole “Inquisitor” thing, she made sure to repeat it.]

One of its more famous victims was Giordano Bruno, burned in Rome in 1600 after being tried for heresy.  [From this stupid trial to Giordano Bruno?  Really?]

The Inquisition?  That’s the lead?  That’s the closure?

I guess we should put this in perspective.  The writer also put some effort into the far more important story about the topless photos of Prince William’s wife Kate.

“But Father! But Father!”, you might be saying.  “That last thing was a cheap shot!”

Riiiight.  I think you grasp the essential point.

Cheap. Shot.

Even ridiculous stories deserve better.

 

Posted in Biased Media Coverage | Tagged , , ,
17 Comments

Political cartoon distorts the Minnesota Marriage Amendment

My fellow Minnesotans will have the opportunity on election day this November to vote in favor of an amendment to the Minnesota state constitution which would define marriage as being between one man and one woman. Minnesota is ground-zero for this nationwide battle over nature versus distortions of nature provoked by appetites or errors about true friendship.

In the local press (liberal) there is a telling political cartoon. It is telling because it reveals either that the cartoonist is ignorant of the issues and players involved and is simply waving his arms around, or that he is adopting – maybe consciously – a page from the tactics of Saul Alinsky, namely,

RULE 12: Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.” Cut off the support network and isolate the target from sympathy. Go after people and not institutions; people hurt faster than institutions.

Political cartoon distorts the Minnesota Marriage Amendment

The cartoon is an attack on the institution (of marriage, of the coalition of groups supporting the amendment).  It targets Archbp. Nienstedt as a way to attack support for the amendment.

This cartoon is pernicious for various reasons, not the least of which is that it falsely asserts that the Minnesota Marriage Amendment is Archbishop John Nienstedt’s project.   Note that “HIS marriage amendment”.  He supports it, but it isn’t “HIS”.

Minnesotans: GO to the polls in November.  When you vote the pro-abortion, pro-infanticide, anti-liberty Pres. Obama out of office, also vote in FAVOR of the Marriage Amendment, not … not… not… because this is a politically partisan issue, but because the laws of the land ought to be in conformity with the laws of nature and of nature’s God.

Perhaps some Minnesotans will chime in to explain how people all over the country can help the effort.

Begin by praying for Archbp. Nienstedt, who is taking it on the chin.  Taking it pretty well, too!  No glass jaw.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Liberals, One Man & One Woman | Tagged , , , , , , ,
34 Comments

November is coming swiftly

From my email:

November is coming swiftly

The Religious Liberty battle is NOT over.

Posted in Lighter fare, Our Catholic Identity, Religious Liberty, The future and our choices, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged ,
18 Comments

Some thoughts about the Pope’s Lebanon trip

Because of my travel and the need for a little down time, I didn’t do much with the Holy Father’s visit to Lebanon.
Some thoughts about the Pope's Lebanon trip
However, a few things have come to mind after some recent conversations and some reading.

First, even though there were a lot of risks, the Holy Father did not once consider not going on this trip.

After the terrorist attacks in Egypt and Lebanon, there were rapid press releases from the Holy See’s Press Office (which I didn’t especially care for at the time). The first of the releases aimed at the Middle East, surely made it possible for the Pope to go on that trip to Lebanon.

While I was not entirely pleased with the statements that came from the Holy See’s Press Office after those terrorist attacks, and while some might say that the Holy See should use a less temporizing voice, the Pope’s trip to Lebanon had a very important objective: let Christians of that region that they are not completely alone.

Christians there are vastly outnumbered, virtually forgotten, and in danger of the loss of their very lives. Christians are fleeing the region. Those who remain are in a tenuous position. Governments don’t give a damn about the basic human rights of Christians anywhere, much less in that region.

The only person those poor people have in their corner is Pope Benedict XVI and he traveled to be with them, even if briefly and under tight security.  The trip was an act of physical and moral and pastoral courage.  Some high level chess made it happen.

Some retrospect prompts me, again, to breathe deeply and read the press releases again and consider broader views.   Not all press releases need to be subject to a deeper consideration, but these did.

Posted in Benedict XVI, Just Too Cool, The Drill, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged , , , , , , ,
10 Comments

Recycling

This image is clearly aimed at discouraging panhandling.

However… could it have another application?

Recycling

Posted in Lighter fare, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
14 Comments

Personal stroll




Personal stroll

This morning I decided to take a bit of a stroll rather than go out to Castel Gandolfo for the Audience and other events.  Instead, I went to look at a few places I hadn’t seen for a while and are of note in my life’s stroll.

Is it possible that I have developed a shred of sentimentality?

Breakfast was in the Borgo Pio, at a very good old fashioned bar.  My usual.

Personal stroll

My stroll brought me past the shop where I had my chalice made.

Personal stroll

The shop happens to share the palazzo where Pius XII was born and grew up.

Personal stroll

Around the corner to the Chiesa Nuova.

Personal stroll

To consult with Pipo Buono, St. Philip Neri, a patron.

Personal stroll

Down the street to Sant’Andrea della Valle

Personal stroll

After admiring Pius II, the great humanist, in the church which is the setting for Act I of Tosca…

Personal stroll

… into a back chapel to consult with another saint, Giuseppe Maria Tomasi (di Lampedusa).

Personal stroll

Around the corner, past where invader soldiers had carved their names into the bricks of the building during the Sack of Rome, to the street where my Roman seminary is and, beyond it, the place where Julius Caesar was killed.

Personal stroll

Then I headed over to the Ghetto on my way to another church.

Here I had a great experience.  I was walking past the doorway to one of the synagogues (not the big one).  The synagogue was very busy today, as you can imagine, since it is Yom Kippur.   There was a bench full of old Jews outside.  Men were going in and out, with their shawls and tzitzit.  One of the old men on the bench hailed me, and we had a long cordial conversation about a variety of things, back and forth.  I asked some questions about Yom Kippur and their prayers.  I could see directly into the building, could see the ranks on ranks of men praying in their shawls, could hear the chanting of the prayers.  I listened for a while.  There was huge security in the area.  The police and other services were not letting people into the main street of the Ghetto but they had let me pass through.  Thus, I had this great experience.  I really couldn’t take photos, alas.

And so I continued on to San Nicola in carcere, where I was ordained to the diaconate and where I directed an all-female Gregorian chant schola.  They sang chant ethereally.
Personal stroll

Off then to the Capitoline Museums.  Here is a view from the opening arches of the ancient Tabellarium.

Personal stroll

The section of the museums where the paintings are is dreadfully behind the times, primitive compared to great museums of the world.  There are some interesting paintings, however.

Among the collected works, here are two by Guido Reni, a Lucretia and a Cleopatra.  I think I have mentioned before how during a certain period there Cleo, Lucretia and Mary Magdalene can often receive a similar treatment.  This is a good example: knife v asp.  You decide.

Personal stroll

If memory serves, a nice Annunciation by Dosso Dossi.

Personal stroll

A gallery.

Personal stroll

By now I am hungry.  I went to another favorite old haunt, l’Angoletto.

Caprese.

Personal stroll

Spaghetti alle vongole.

Personal stroll

At this point a “certain Roman curial prelate” came by and we had a nice long talk about the inner workings of some places.  Nice to see him and catch up.

After lunch, I stopped at Sant’Agostino and had a chat with St. Monica, whose bones are interred here.  I have no doubt that she was remembered at the altar by her son.

Personal stroll

Down the Via dei Coronari, my old neighborhood, I stopped to visit the great guys at the best bonsai shop you will ever see.  These men are experts.  They still have my bonsai, too!  I had a bonsai for years, perched high above the Piazza Navona, and it spent a lot of time in my window.  Whenever I left Rome, they would take it and give it TLC in my absence.  Very dedicated.  Truly nice men.  I hope all the seminarians from the NAC and any priests or religious living in Rome would stop by.  I used to give bonsai’s as gifts when I was here.

Via dei Coronari 16 – alberoantico.it

Personal stroll

At San Salvatore in Lauro there was/is a display of relics of St. Pio.  A shot of his stole.

Personal stroll

The Blessed Sacrament was exposed, and therefore I stayed to consult and adore for a bit.  Some neighborhood women had a litany going, but the point, the constant phrase after each invocation was “Send us more priests, send us holy priests”.  Humbling.  Inspiring.  I don’t doubt but that the Lord will reward them.




Personal stroll

This evening I went to have some supper nearby at a favorite place.  I settled into a plate of bucatini and read some of a novel on my Kindle.  And before someone asks, yes, I have two mobile phones.  Actually, I have three.  I feel like a drug dealer.

Personal stroll

At this point, three priests came in, two of whom I knew.  There was a priest from a big city on the East Coast, a fellow who works in Rome in a great role (which I rather envy) and a “certain highly placed Curial official”.  We got caught up and/or acquainted.   It was pleasant to hear their views and find out what they were up to and exchange some ideas.  Along the way I heard some things that actually left me feeling rather uplifted, which I did not expect.

My first full day back here was pretty good, all in all. It was full and it was fruitful.

In my prayers at the tombs of saints I did not forget to keep in mind Your Urgent Prayer Requests. I especially asked the saints to intercede for the special needs of those of you who have been benefactors along the way.

Since I am in Rome for a few more days, and since I will be saying Mass, and since I will be visiting the tombs of many saints, I will start another Urgent Prayer Request thread HERE. I’ll look at it as I am going about my day. I ask a prayer for myself.

Posted in On the road, What Fr. Z is up to | Tagged
35 Comments

YOUR URGENT PRAYER REQUESTS

Please use the sharing buttons!  Thanks!

Continued from THESE.

YOUR URGENT PRAYER REQUESTSI get many requests by email asking for prayers. Many requests are heart-achingly grave and urgent.

We should support each other in works of mercy.

As long as my blog reaches so many readers in so many places, let’s give each other a hand.

YOUR URGENT PRAYER REQUESTS

If you have some prayer requests, feel free to post them below. You have to be registered here to be able to post.

But, registered or not, please take a moment to pray for the people about whom you read here below.

Finally, I still have two serious needs.  It seems repetitive, but… it looks like prayer may be the only way to bring help, even if it isn’t as swift as I had hoped.

Posted in Urgent Prayer Requests | Tagged
88 Comments

Now THAT’S Basil!

This is too cool not to post.

You might remember that I posted about blessing basil in honor of the Cross?  Basil is from the Greek word for “king”.

A priest reader breathing mainly from the Eastern lung sent me great photos of the blessing of basil.  I will share three.

Now THAT'S Basil!

Now THAT'S Basil!

Now THAT'S Basil!

Think of the smell of the church, with the candles and incense and basil.

 

 

Posted in Just Too Cool, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged ,
8 Comments