“doctrinal discussions” betwixt SSPX and the Holy See?

The formerly excommunicated SSPX Bishop Richard Williamson says on his blog Dinoscopus that some particulars of the necessary talks between the SSPX and the Holy See have been hammered out.

The Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, the terms that the Holy See issued to the leadership of the SSPX last year, and the lifting of the excommunications of the four bishops were necessary steps to reach the next step: theological discussions.

You can see the logic of associating the PCED more closely with the CDF.  That move, when it comes, will not be a punishment (as the liberal Catholics and their dour press wanted to paint it because they are full of fear-born hate for Catholic Tradition).  It is a necessary move to keep the process directed to a positive conclusion.

The SSPX has problems with the documents of the Second Vatican Council.  They have the right to present their concerns.  Holy See, in turn, has the right to present responses.

Let’s see what Bp. Williamson said with my emphases and comments.

From Bishop Tissier de Mallerais speaking in Paris we hear that terms have been fixed for the doctrinal discussions due to take place between the Society of St. Pius X and the Church authorities in Rome. The discussions are to be in writing, which is wise, insofar as there is less room for passion and more time for careful thinking. [It is also far safer for the SSPX since they have fewer resources.]  Also they will not be made public, a provision which at best eliminates "grand-standing" by either party, otherwise known as playing to the gallery, because there will be no gallery present.  [A good idea, since the SSPX does have a base to be worried about.]

From Rome we hear that the impetus towards a Rome-SSPX understanding which was generated by the Pope’s January "re-incommunication" [odd word play… figure it out…] of the four SSPX bishops, was seriously slowed down by the distrust generated by the media uproar  [is that what we are calling it?  Distrust?] of January-February, which is what that uproar was designed to achieve[probably] Yet subjectively speaking, there is certainly still good will on the part of the Pope towards the SSPX, [Good grief man!  Of COURSE there is!  And he took a huge hit for you guys.  Do you think for a moment he didn’t know he would have to take a hit?] and there is no lack of good will on the part of the SSPX towards the person of the Holy Father. [QED… good]

The problem for these discussions is that, objectively speaking, as on either side there may be some reluctance to admit, we are in the presence of an irreconcilable clash between the religion of God and the religion of man. [hmmmm] Vatican II mixed the two together, which was too much of the religion of man by half. Let us then say that Benedict XVI wishes to combine Vatican II with Catholic Tradition. That is still too much of the religion of man by a quarter. Let us now suppose that the SSPX and Benedict XVI were to agree to come half-way towards each other. That would still represent one eighth of the religion of man mixed with seven eighths of the religion of God, which for the purposes of Almighty God would still be one eighth too much.  [Sorry… but this is silly.  I am reminded of the futility expressed by Eliot’s coffee spoons.  But that is not how these things work.]

For just as it takes a disproportionately small amount of water mixed with a tank full of gasoline (or petrol) to stop a car engine dead, so it takes only a small admixture of idolatry to stop dead the true religion of God. [So… we can understand by that the Bp. Williamson thinks that .. well.. at least he is the arbiter of what is the True Catholic Faith.  Is this going to be the position of the leadership of the SSPX?  Thus, does this signal a break between Williamson and Fellay?] The Lord God Himself tells us that He is a jealous God (Exod. XX, 5; etc.), and will not endure any false gods beside Him. To anybody in the SSPX who might be tempted to worship with the neo-modernists, as to any neo-modernist who might wish to share worship with the Catholics, the Old Testament prophet Elias would say as he said to the hesitating Israelites, "How long do you halt between the two sides ? If the Lord be God, follow Him: but if Baal, then follow him." Scripture (III Kings, XVIII, 21) then says, "The people did not answer him a word".

Subjectively, the Israelites wanted to have it both ways. Objectively, that was impossible. For ourselves too. Kyrie Eleison.

 

This offering of the formerly excommunicated and now "re-incommincated" SSPX bishop –  who really ought to be living out a quiet retired life – raises a few questions.  I included a few of them above.

However… I think the way to sort this out is to remember that people of good will on both sides should be able to disagree about those things which are not able to be nailed down with clarity… and still remain in communion with each other.

 

Posted in Brick by Brick |
87 Comments

QUAERITUR: Gift for a transitional deacon

From a reader:

My question is what would be appropriate gifts for a young man to be ordained to the transitional diaconate?  He is a convert and like most of us, very much enjoys the traditions and physically beautiful aspects of the Faith.   He does not have family in our area, so our women’s groups have sort of mothered him along.  As a group and individually, we will want to provide him with suitable, tangible gifts to accompany the graces he will receive.  I know once a deacon always a deacon, but would an ordained priest appropriately wear a dalmatic if assisting as a deacon?   We don’t want to presume on his ordination to the priesthood, but want our gifts to be made with that hope in mind. 

 

No, I wouldn’t get him a dalmatic.

Being a transitional deacon is not a guarantee that he will be ordained a priest, but it is fairly sure.  Thus, it would be best to get him things useful for his priesthood, or at least his newly minted clerical state. 

Does he have a cassock?  Biretta?  If he has a cassock does he have a fascia?  Clerical clothing or gift certificate for the same… a black suit perhaps from a men’s store.  In the liturgical line, a priest’s nice stole… which for his remaining time as a deacon he can wear in the manner of a deacon.  Breviaries, if he doesn’t already have them.  A very nice alb according to his tastes or a nice surplice.  For ordinations I often have given a very nice rosary (and there are hints about how to choose one for a priest/deacon, btw.)  Cash is always welcome.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
34 Comments

Brick by brick in Bordeaux

Do you remember that I wryly posted that it will be a pleasure to see priests of the SSPX attending deanery meetings and being elected to presbyteral councils?

Our friends at Rorate are vigilant.  They posted this good brick by brick news!

On Holy Thursday, Cardinal Jean-Pierre Ricard, archbishop of Bordeaux, hosted all the priests of his diocese for dinner. Taking to heart the recent decision of the pope (the lifting of excommunication of the bishops of the FSSPX on January 21st), he invited all Catholic priests and priors who exercise ministry within the Archdiocese of Bordeaux and Bazas, including the prior of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X – marking the first time he’s dined with his Diocesan confreres or other communities, especially those dependant on the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei. The Cardinal recalled the speech made by Benedict XVI in France last September:

"No one is too many in the Church. Everyone, without exception, must be able to feel at home and never feel rejected."

Posted in Brick by Brick |
17 Comments

“Rejoice, Father; they are paying attention!”

You know the old phrase in commercials… "Do not attempt this at home!"

Here is an exception to the rule.

From a reader:

Another fun photo! 


 
This is what our 8-yr-old decided to make today after serving his first two Traditional Latin Masses this week.
 
Note that the “hosts”–made of flour and water and cooked lightly in a frying pan–were clearly imprinted with the raised writing from the bottom of the salt shaker.  The words?  “Made in Taiwan.”   ( ! )  [ROFL! Not exactly "IHS" or "ALLELUIA", but the theory is good.]
 
He asked only my permission for the ingredients and to use the stove this morning. Everything else was done on his own initiative and per the recipe told to him last summer by the priest who turned us on to your website.  
 
Then, out came the children’s miniature brass Mass kit that has never failed to interest boys 
 
[Here is the point…] Rejoice, Father; they are paying attention!  The leaven is working! [well… not in those hosts!]  The Extraordinary Form of the Mass is the best thing to come along since, well . . . Hosts! 
 
God richly bless the Holy Father for releasing the EF and all the bishops and priests who make it possible.

A great e-mail!  Thanks for that!

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool, Lighter fare |
20 Comments

When only images can convey our sorrow

Some things are simply too tragic for words.  Only images can convey our sorrow.

Disaster barely averted… but only through a self-less, chilling sacrifice.

Play

Posted in Lighter fare |
25 Comments

EXSULTET: WDTPRS and audio

The EXSULTET is one of the most spectacular moments of all the Church’s liturgical life.

When it is sung well in Latin the Church is in her glory!

I have fond memories of singing the Exsultet. The first time, I was a deacon on retreat at a monastery in central Italy, where the largest community of Benedictine nuns in Italy sing every word of their office and Mass in Gregorian chant in their 12th c. abbey. Another time, I was asked by my bishop (of an ancient Roman Suburbicarian diocese) to sing the Exsultet in Latin. We started outside in the deep night in the square before an enormous fire. It took over 10 minutes to get everyone inside, with long pauses between each “Lumen Christi!” The candle was the size of a Scottish caber. Though there was still much movement and exuberance I started singing, and when they heard the rarely use Latin and chant the great crowd quieted. As I sang about the “red-glowing flame” being “divided into parts” I could see a thousand candles and hear the fire still crackling outside as it cast flickering glows through the main door.

Most precious, however, are the times I sang the Exsultet in my home parish.

Here is my rendering of the 1970 Missale Romanum version of the Exsultet. Alas, there is no space to give you the Latin also. The Exsultet is also called the Praeconium Paschale. Paschale is an adjective of a Latinized Hebrew word pascha, for the Passover meal of the lamb. The sure and certain Lewis & Short Dictionary says the adjective praeconius, a, um is “of or belonging to a praeco or public crier” while the substantive praeconium is “a crying out in public; a proclaiming, spreading abroad, publishing.” In a Christian context this of course also infers the Good News! A praeconium is simultaneously a profession of faith and a call to faith extended to all who hear.

The Exsultet is a poem, elements of which go back to St. Ambrose (+397). It is to be sung by a deacon (or priest or cantor) during the Easter Vigil as a hymn of praise to God for the light of the Paschal Candle. The text became part of the Roman liturgy around the 9th century. The text is theologically packed. It contains a summary of Easter’s mystery. Christ is risen: we too can rise in Him. This was prepared for from the fall of man, directed by a loving Father, and awaits only the end of the world, although our baptismal character allows us to live the reality now: Already, but not yet!

There is an introductory invitation to “Exult!” (whence its name) given to three different groups: the angels, the Church on earth, and the whole Church together. There follows an account of works of God in the Paschal Mystery and the history of salvation. It begins with a dialog just like a Preface during Holy Mass.

Like a Eucharistic Prayer the Exsultet is a remembrance (anamnesis) which makes the past mysteries present to us. The singer deacon begs the congregation to pray for him as he tells the story of our family history of salvation with all the foreshadowing and “types” of our redemption. So great is God’s ability to turn evil to good that the deacon dares to call Adam’s fall our “happy fault… felix culpa” since because of it we were sent the gift of our Savior. You hear of the work of bees and the shattering of chains of sin. All evil is driven away.

The constant refrain is that this is a blessed night when heavenly and earthly realities merge together and become one.

Finally, there is a humble petition that God the Father will accept our Paschal candle, our evening sacrifice of praise, and make it into one of the lights of the heavens.

This poem/hymn/prayer is too much to grasp all at once. But year by year we have the chance to hear it renewed in the heart of the Church’s greatest night. The mysteries within it do not change, but we do. Each year we are a little different. We can hear it each year with new insight and understanding.

Consider the setting.

For forty days we have done penance. We participated at the anniversary of Holy Mass and the Priesthood on Holy Thursday with the mandatum and the procession to the altar of repose, Christ in agony in Gethsemane. On Good Friday, the day with no Mass, after our humble prostration before the Crucified Lord we stood for the singing of the Passion. Now we are in a dark church. The fire was kindled and the “Light of Christ” was thrice announced. The faithful have little candles sparked to life from the single flame of the Paschal candle, the “Christ candle”, now lighted as the symbol of His resurrection. The candle is incensed and then:


2002 Missale Romanum

Exult now O ye angelic throngs of the heavens:
Exult O ye divine mysteries:
and let the saving trumpet resound for the victory of so great a King.
Let the earthly realm also be joyful, made radiant by such flashings like lightning:
and, made bright with the splendor of the eternal King,
let it perceive that it has dismissed the entire world’s gloom.
Let Mother Church rejoice as well,
adorned with the blazes of so great a light:
and let this royal hall ring with the great voices of the peoples.
Wherefore, most beloved brothers and sisters,
you here present to such a wondrous brightness of this holy light,
I beseech you, together with me
invoke the mercy of Almighty God.
Let Him who deigned to gather me in among the number of the Levites,
by no merits of mine,
while pouring forth the glory of His own light
enable me to bring to fullness the praise of this waxen candle.

Deacon: The Lord be with you!
Response: And with your spirit!
D: Raise your hearts on high!
R: We now have them present to the Lord!
D: Let us then give thanks to the Lord our God!
R: This is worthy and just!
Truly it is worthy and just
to resound forth with the whole of the heart, disposition of mind,
and by the ministry of the voice,
the invisible God the Father Almighty,
and His Only-begotten Son
our Lord Jesus Christ,
Who, on our behalf, resolved Adam’s debt to the Eternal Father
and cleansed with dutiful bloodshed the bond of the ancient crime.
For these are the Paschal holy days,
in which that true Lamb is slain,
by Whose Blood the doorposts of the faithful are consecrated.
This is the night
in which first of all You caused our forefathers,
the children of Israel brought forth from Egypt,
to pass dry shod through the Red Sea.
This is the night
which purged the darkness of sins by the illumination of the pillar.
This is the night
which today restores to grace and unites in sanctity throughout the world Christ’s believers,
separated from the vices of the world and the darkness of sins.
This is the night
in which, once the chains of death were undone,
Christ the victor arose from the nether realm.
For it would have profited us nothing to have been born,
unless it had been fitting for us to be redeemed.
O wondrous condescension of Your dutiful concern for us!
O inestimable affection of sacrificial love:
You delivered up Your Son that You might redeem the slave!
O truly needful sin of Adam,
that was blotted out by the death of Christ!
O happy fault,
that merited to have such and so great a Redeemer!
O truly blessed night,
that alone deserved to know the time and hour
in which Christ rose again from the nether world!
This is the night about which it was written:
And night shall be made as bright as day:
and night is as my brightness for me.
Therefore the sanctification of this night puts to flight all wickedness, cleanses sins,
and restores innocence to the fallen and gladness to the sorrowful.
It drives away hatreds, procures concord, and makes dominions bend.
Therefore, in this night of grace,
accept, O Holy Father, the evening sacrifice of this praise,
which Holy Church renders to You
in the solemn offering of this waxen candle
by the hands of Your ministers from the work of bees.
We are knowing now the proclamations of this column,
which glowing fire kindles in honor of God.
Which fire, although it is divided into parts,
is knowing no loss from its light being lent out.
For it is nourished by the melting streams of wax,
which the mother bee produced for the substance of this precious torch.
O truly blessed night,
in which heavenly things are joined to those of earth,
the divine to the human!
Therefore, we beseech You, O Lord,
that this waxen candle, consecrated in honor of Your name,
may continue unfailing to dispel the darkness of this night.
And once it is accepted as a placating sacrifice,
may it be mingled with the heavenly lights.
Let the morning star meet with its flame:
that very star, I say, which knows no setting:
Christ Your Son, who, having returned from the nether realm,
broke serene like the dawn upon the human race,
and now lives and reigns forever and ever.

Posted in EASTER, PODCAzT, PRAYERCAzT: What Does The (Latin) Prayer Really Sound L, WDTPRS |
54 Comments

Your Easter Customs

In most cultures and families there are wonderful Easter customs.

They could be communal as bring food in baskets to church to be blessed by the priest.

They could be as simple and intimate as preparing a special meal in the family home.

What are some of your customs?

Posted in Just Too Cool |
70 Comments

Monastery of San Benedetto in Norcia – mp3s and photos

I received this from the Monastery of St. Benedict in Norcia, Italy… the birthplace of St. Benedict.

Salve! [F]rom the Benedictine Monastery of San Benedetto in Norcia.

Thanks to some generous donations from our patrons, we’ve wired up our Tenebrae services and made podcasts and mp3s of everything. There also some amazing photos from a very solemn, very Latin and very awe inspiring Tenebrae service.

We’re a young monastery, with more than a dozen vocations from all over the world (and all young guys!) but with a huge amount of talent and focus on leading the Church by following Her teaching and wisdom. Also, the monks celebrate all roman rites with great reverence.

Seeing as we start at 5:00AM, it takes a couple of minutes for the monks to "warm up". There are some sick monks in the pews– please disregard the coughing. However, you will find the later parts and especially today’s service especially beautiful.

You can see pictures and all the music at http://www.osbnorcia.org, and click "Tenebrae ’09"

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool |
22 Comments

QUAERITUR: giving a gift anonymously to a priest/confessor

From a reader:

Perhaps I am being overly scrupulous, but I have a difficult time giving gifts to my Priest, much as he deserves them.  I do not want him to think that I am currying favor and want to avoid even the appearance of simony.  More importantly (and I recognize that I am likely “projecting”) I do not want him to sub-consciously attempt to return the favor.  I know that when people give me gifts, I tend to give them a pass on behavior and I do not want my Priest to do that, especially in the confessional. 

So, is it appropriate to give him gifts, say at Easter and Christmas anonymously, or should I just suck it up and sign the thing?

 

I don’t think you have much to worry about on this score, but it is perfectly acceptable to give the priest a gift anonymously especially if he is your regular confessor.

At the same time, if you are inclined to be scrupulous, I would caution that in doing so against then having subtle expectations – leading to not so subtle disappointments – if he thereafter doesn’t conform or respond to something in a way you hope for.

If you are troubled by this, you might think carefully before you give him anything, anonymously or not.  There are ways to show your support, perhaps around the parish, that might not involve a personal gift.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
Comments Off on QUAERITUR: giving a gift anonymously to a priest/confessor

Passover

Passover begins at sunset.

Related issue here.

Posted in Linking Back |
17 Comments