Bp. Fellay interview by Radio Svizzera: didn’t totally reject the Conditions

On Saturday 28 June 2008, twenty years to the day after his illicit episcopal consecration at Econe, Switzerland which resulted in his excommunication and the split between the SSPX and the Catholic Church, Bp. Bernard Fellay, now Superior General of the SSPX has given an interview to Radio Svizzera, in Italian. 

I captured the audio, lest it cycle off of that website and become too hard to dig up. 

In the past few days some media outlets have picked up on something that Fellay said in his rambling sermon in Winona, MN on 20 June, as well as hard line comments of two of the other excommunicated bishops, Williamson and Galaretta, and have made the assumption that the SSPX, Fellay in particular, have rejected the Five Conditions offered them by the Holy See as a preamble to continuing fruitful dialogue.

I think the usual media suspects are somewhat misreading the situation.  For example, I parsed the report from AFP and from Reuters.  The Reuters story is a good example of how some reporters have misread the situation.

When I parsed Bp. Fellay’s sermon in Winona in this PODCAzT I gave my opinion that Bp. Fellay, under tremendous pressure from the hard liners both in the SSPX and from the "benefactors" (read: money), takes a hard line in sermons and public addresses to keep spirits high. 

Also, he is prone to ramble a bit in his preaching and, at a certain point, he works himself up and takes a swipe at the Pope and Curia.  This is probably well received by some listeners. 

Furthermore, Fellay is between a rock and a hard spot.  Or rather, several hardcore hard spots and the Rock who is Peter. 

Also, what he said at Winona, though it sounds very defiant and resolved, didn’t actually go so far as to violate explicitly any of the Conditions Rome offered and which Fellay and the SSPX haven’t still publicly renounced in an official way.

Then we learned yesterday that the Fellay and the SSPX decided they would write a letter to Rome to respond that they weren’t going to respond to the Conditions. 

Effectively, I think what this means is that they won’t accept the premise that they are doing anything wrong (big surprise there!) but that they still want dialogue.   In the future we will see if in action they change they style of speech about the Pope and their position on reunion in a more positive way. 

That is to say, though they are afraid to cause a split in the SSPX were they to sign off on those conditions openly, perhaps they could skirt the issue by saying they wouldn’t accept the premise of the conditions but then begin to modify their style a bit anyway.  

This is my speculation, now that it seems that we are not going to hear much more from them.

Now we have this Radio Svizzera interview.

I do not have a transcript of the interview and won’t make one myself.  But here are the essential points.

Bp. Bernard Fellay had an interview on the Radio Svizzera:

The interviewer put the first question in terms of the SSPX having rejecting the offer, that on Friday for an ordination, it was announced that the SSPX rejected the ultimatum. But Fellay corrected him saying that that is not quite accurate.  Fellay said that it is perhaps false to say that "reject".

"Maybe it is false to say so directly that I reject, that I have made a complete refusal.  That’s not true.  Rather, I see in this ultimate something very vague and confused.

But isn’t this the last chance to reunite with Rome, during this favorable time with Pope Benedict XVI?

Fellay repeated that this ultimatum makes no sense (non ha senso) because they do, in fact, have a dialogue with Rome,even if it is slow.  Rome wants to speed things up.

Fellay claims that they want to continue dialogue.  SSPX wants to continue the dialogue.  For Fellay dialogue might be "chilly" right now but it is not over.

The interviewer asked if Rome will lose patience, is the the SSPX at risk, will be it more and more marginalized?

Fellay said that more more people are coming to the SSPX.  They don’t want to break with the Church.  They desire to be accepted into the Church and do good for the Church.  They are defenders of tradition.

This interview is in Italian.  Maybe someone will make a transcript.

The bottom line:

The leadership of the SSPX are afraid of an internal rupture more than anything else.   They can’t explicitly reject the Conditions offered by the Holy See.  Therefore they are trying to steer a middle course by rejecting a seconday premise of the conditions which was explicitly state (Don’t speak disrespectfully about the Pope and put on airs about their own "magisterium") without rejecting the true premise underlying them (Who is the Bishop of Rome and who are you without him?).

The code language to listen for in future comments by the leadership of the SSPX will be things like "the conditions don’t make sense – we do have dialogue even though it is slow – what’s the hurry".

UPDATE 14:54 UTC

I got this from our friends at Rorate:

(Translation by Rorate Caeli)Bp. Fellay interview by Radio Svizzera: didn't totally reject the Conditions

Fellay: "I have already written a response
and we will see how Rome will react"

…
[17:45][Fellay:] Perhaps it is false to say, in such a way, directly, that I reject, that I propose a total rejection [of the conditions], that is not true. Rather, I see in this ultimatum a very vague, confused thing. But, in fact, I have already written a response and we will see how Rome will react.
…
[18:53] [Fellay:] For me, this ultimatum has no sense, because we have relations with Rome which go forward in a certain speed, which is truly slow. And it is true, on the other hand, that both the Cardinal [Castrillón Hoyos] and the Holy Father would wish for a rather accelerated speed. For me, the only meaning of this ultimatum is the expression of this desire of Rome to give it a little bit of hastiness. And for me it is not a reconsideration of all our relations.

[Interviewer:] "Then, you expect to continue in the dialogue, still?"

[Fellay:] Yes, yes, it is possible that there will now be a time of more, of coolness, but, frankly, for me, it is not over, no.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
138 Comments

Liverpool! First “personal” TLM parish in the UK!

Here is a great piece!   As I was telling a journalist on the phone today, things are picking up speed.

Take a look at the Catholic Herald.

Archbishop Patrick Kelly of Liverpool is preparing to create Britain’s first parish dedicated to celebrations of the traditional Latin Mass.  [HUZZAH! HUZZAH! HUZZAH!]

The archbishop is planning to revive an ailing parish [YES!] in Liverpool’s inner city by turning it into a centre for traditionalists.

He is following the example set by the Diocese of Rome, [Better and better!] which set up a parish dedicated exclusively to Mass in the extraordinary form earlier this year.

The Church of St Vincent de Paul, St James Street, Toxteth, will become a traditionalist parish as early as September if the plans are approved by the archdiocese.

It is one of four churches in the city centre overseen by Fr John Southworth and attracts a weekly congregation of about 25 to 30 people.

Fr Southworth is reported to have announced the change to parishioners on Sunday.

The church’s new priest will be Fr Simon Henry, who was previously parish priest at St Cuthbert’s, Wigan, Lancashire, for nine years.

Fr Henry has been in talks with Archbishop Kelly for some time over how the diocese can do more to offer the traditional Latin Mass.

At present the Latin Mass Society organises a weekly Mass at St Anthony’s Church, Scotland Road, Liverpool, celebrated by a rota of different priests.

The Sunday afternoon Masses draw congregations of about 40 to 50 people but as the church is not very central many worshippers find it difficult to get to.

St Vincent’s Church, designed by E W Pugin in 1856, is considered to be more suitable for traditional liturgy because it has not yet been re-ordered.

The church is located next to Chinatown [Good Chinese food after Mass?  Can’t get better than that!] and near to the city docks. It was founded by one of Liverpool’s first bishops, Bishop Bernard O’Reilly, who raised the money for it and commissioned Pugin to design it when he was still just a priest.

John Medlin, general manager of the Latin Mass Society, said he was "very pleased" at the news. "In fact, we have heard from our sources that some other dioceses may be working on similar plans," he said.

He explained that St Vincent’s was a "beautiful and appropriate" church for the extraordinary form Mass and that very little re-ordering would be needed.

He said that the archbishop should be "congratulated" [Huzzah!] for heeding the words of Cardinal Castrillon, president of the pontifical commission Ecclesia Dei. The cardinal said on a visit to London this month: "It is… important to find a centrally located church, convenient to the greatest number of the faithful who have requested [the extraordinary form] Mass."

The cardinal said earlier this year that an exclusively traditionalist parish in Rome was an "example" for dioceses around the world. The parish of Santissima Trinità dei Pellegrini, which celebrates Mass only in the extraordinary form, is overseen by the Priestly Fraternity of St Peter. It was designated a traditionalist parish by Cardinal Camillo Ruini, the Vicar of the Diocese of Rome, in May.

A spokesman for the Archdiocese of Liverpool hinted that plans to widen the provision of the traditional Latin Mass extended beyond just one parish.

He said: "The archbishop is considering some proposals regarding the ministry of churches in the city. These proposals would be centred on the Metropolitan Cathedral but will also include the Church of St Vincent." The planning was still at an "early" stage, he added. In July last year Benedict XVI issued a Motu Proprio which granted priests much greater freedom to celebrate the traditional Latin Mass.

The decree said priests could celebrate the Mass publicly without the permission of a bishop and that it should be offered in parishes whenever a "stable group" of the faithful requested it.

Earlier this month Cardinal Castrillon, who is responsible for implementing the Motu Proprio, celebrated Mass in the extraordinary form at Westminster Cathedral. At a press conference he told journalists that the Pope wanted the traditional Latin Mass to be offered in every parish "so that everybody knows this way of celebrating the Eucharist".

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

Archbp. Burke’s presser for his new assignment

Watch the presser Archbishop Burke gave about ceasing to be Archbishop of St. Louis and becoming Prefect of the Signatura.

This is wonderful.

Also, Archbishop Burke made a statement, posted on the Archdiocesan website.

(This video is no longer available.)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
24 Comments

12 July: Fota International Liturgy Conference – the Music!

Sacred Music Alert!  Below is the prospectus for the music to be at the Mass in Cobh Cathedral for the Fota International Liturgy Conference to  be held on 12 July 2008.

Fota International Liturgy Conference

Holy Mass at St. Colman’s Cathedral, Cobh,

Saturday, 12 July 2008 at 11am

The following are the musical arrangements for this Mass which will be celebrated by His Eminence Jorge Maria Cardinal Mejia.

Ecce sacerdos (Tomas Luis de Victoria)

Introit: Magnificat Octavi toni (Orlande de Lassus) alternating with plainchant

Kyrie (Missa Papae Marcelli: Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina) Gloria (Missa Papae Marcelli: Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina)

Responsorial Psalm: ‘In domum Domini laetantes ibimus’ Ps 121 Alleluia Common of the BVM Tone VIII Verse: ‘Paradisi portae quas Eva clausit ..

Credo III

Offertory: Ave Maria (Tomas Luis de Victoria) Sanctus (Missa Papae Marcelli: Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina) Benedictus (Missa Papae Marcelli: Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina)

Pater Noster – plainchant

Agnus Dei (Missa Papae Marcelli: Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina)

Communion: Lauda sion (Tomas Luis de Victoria) Ave verum (Orlande de Lassus)

Blessing

Recessional: Salve Regina (Plainchant)

Great stuff!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Anglican Bishop(s) – swimming?

From Damian Thompson’s blog Holy Smoke.

C of E bishop will defect to Rome
Thursday, June 26, 2008, 08:13 PM GMT [General]

At least one Church of England bishop will defect to Rome
soon after the Lambeth Conference, I gather from Anglo-Catholic sources. And there could be more to follow.

I can’t tell you much more than that at the moment, because the negotiations with Rome are so sensitive – and the Catholic Bishops of England and Wales, who distrust Anglican traditionalists, are quite capable of throwing a spanner in the works.

It’s shaming to have to admit that the bishops of my own Church are the chief obstacle to a significant move of Anglo-Catholic clergy and lay people into full communion with the Holy See – but that’s the way it was last time, in the early 1990s, and it’s still the case today.

Fortunately, Pope Benedict XVI is more open to experiment than Pope John Paul II.  [YES!  And this is a good point.  He is open to new structures and ideas.] He is taking a close interest in the progress of the rebel Traditional Anglican Communion towards reunion – a process which is under the control of the Congregration for the Doctrine of the Faith, not the Vatican’s woolly-minded ecumenists.

I can’t betray confidences, but my advice is: look at the new church structures, such as Old Rite parishes, that the Pope is already encouraging, and ask yourself how those models might be adapted for the use of former Anglicans.

But I’ve already said too much…

What is going on here?

There is a huge conflict brewing in the Anglican Communion at the big meeting at Lambeth.  More on this later, though some of you well informed readers can chime and and start fleshing out the story, players and issues.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
59 Comments

2001 – Bp. Fellay: “If he calls me, I go.”

I find this interesting.  I was tipped to it through a comment under another entry.

30 Days magazine managed to obtain a long interview with the Superior General of the SSPX, H.E. Bishop Bernard Fellay.  Although the written interview omitted certain reservations made by Bishop Fellay, one sentence resounded in the Vatican corridors: : "If he calls me, I go. Right away. Or rather, I run. This is certain. Because of obedience. By filial obedience with regard to the head of the Church."

 

Quoted from Newsletter of the [SSPX] District of Asia of  Jan-Jun 2001, "Roman talks – An Update", by Fr. Pierre-Marie Laurençon SSPX, Superior of the French District taken from Letter to Priests, no.9, March 2001.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on 2001 – Bp. Fellay: “If he calls me, I go.”

Thoughts on the SSPX opportunity

I am convinced that there must now be a dramatic gesture of humility on the part of the SSPX. 

Everyone involved in this dispute, on both sides of this split, SSPX and Holy See alike, are good people. 

They all have convictions and zeal. 

They all love Jesus and the Church.

Mistakes have been made on both sides over the years.  The consecrations and continuing defiance was just plain wrong.  The attitude of many in the Roman Curia and the hostility to tradition was just plain wrong.  [I do not mean by this that I think there is a moral equivalence between the SSPX and the Church here!  That is not the case.]

Lot’s of people have been hurt.

It is time to let that go, turn around, and take another direction.

The Holy Father has extended a firm but gentle hand in the direction of the SSPX and waits for them to come to him.

I have no doubt that this Pope, the man best situated in the entire Church to grasp the issues involved and the history of the conflict, will respond with expansive generosity… if only the SSPX would budge, even a little.

I believe that even small positive moves by the SSPX will be greeted with even more lavish concessions, canonical and other. 

Thoughts on the SSPX opportunityThe parable of the Prodigal Son comes to mind (cf. Luke 15 in whatever translation you prefer) as a lens, a hermeneutic, for reading what is possible.

If you read what the Lord says carefully, you find that the father of the fallen lad saw his son at a distance, returning, coming up the road. 

That means the father was watching for him.  He longed for his son and in hope watched for him. 

Then, once the father caught glimpse of his boy from afar, he ran to meet him. 

He ran to meet him. 

Even if the son didn’t also run, and the Lord doesn’t focus on him, look at what the father did. 

Please, God, let there be humility on both sides of this present endeavor. 

The Holy Father will, I am sure, kill the canonical calf once some real dialogue has begun and lift the excommunications. 

I have little doubt but that he will cloth the SSPX in a precious garment of a juridical structure so that they have a renewed identity in the Church. 

He will place rings on their fingers, in a sense, and let their bishops be bishops for the group. 

Gestures of humility will be the cause of thousand fold rejoicing.

Posted in Classic Posts, SESSIUNCULA |
91 Comments

AFP: Lefebvrites – no intention of “responding” to Vatican ultimatum

The spokesman of the SSPX is reported by the Agence France-Presse about the Five Conditions.  This is reported in Le-Croix.com.

Here is my translation with by emphases and comments.

PARIS: 27 June 2008 (AFP) – The Lefebvrites have no intention of responding to the Vatican’s ultimatum.

The Fraternity of Sain Pius X [SSPX], founded by [Archbishop] Lefebvre, has no intention of responding to the "ultimatum" which was put to the Vatican to bring to a conclusion the schism provoked twenty years about for the traditionalist movement, the spokesman for the SSPX indicated. 

"The SSPX has no intention of responding to this ultimatum", SSPX spokesman Fr. Alain Loran declared by phone from Ecône (Switzerland) to the AFP.  [Okay… pretty clear: we are not going to respond.]

"We do not envision any practical or canonical accord before treating doctrinal questions which have arisen since Vatican II", the one in charge [blah blah blah]…

"[Bp.] Bernard Fellay (Superior General of the SSPX) is surprised by the existing discrepency between the ultimatum’s procedural character and the ultimatum’s content, which is very imprecise, Fr. Lorans added.

The Italian daily Il Giornale [blah blah blah… review of what has been reported]…

The Vatican had given to the SSPX until 28 June to respond positively to these questions.

These five conditions posed by the Vatican deal with the recognition of the authority of the Pope and the committment to say nothing against the Church,  but the contain no reference to the Second Vatican Council

According to Fr. Lorans, the Superior General of the SSPX, [Bp.] Fellay wrote a letter to the Vatican authorities on Thursday.  [Ummm… isn’t this a response?]

Okay… there might be a  nuance to "répondre" I am not getting.  I know there is an idiom "répondre aux conditions" which suggests "satisfy requirements".   On the other hand, later in the article I read "répondre positivement à ces questions", which suggests that the use of "répondre" above doesn’t automatically hint at a positive response. 

Still, what I am getting from this is that they responded to say they aren’t going to respond. 

Also, a long time ago I began explaining that whereas some in the Vatican wanted the big family photo with the group hug right away (which has its merits, believe me), the SSPX wanted to discuss theological issues first, and worry about the group photo later.

Still, what is required now, more than ever… right now… is a dramtic gesture of humility on the part of the leadership of the SSPX, even at the risk of alienating their benefactors (read: money).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments

For students of St. Augustine, a great tool in paperback

For students of St. Augustine, a great tool in paperbackI am very happy to announce a matter of great joy.

One of the best books on St. Augustine in the last 20 years is now in paperback, and therefore more affordable.

Serious students of late antiquity, of theology, of patristics, of politics.

Check out Robert Dodaro’s excellent, Christ and the Just Society in the Thought of Augustine.

Dodaro, an American, is the President of the Augustinianum, the Patristic Institute in Rome.

This is not a book on Augustine for beginners.  If you are interested in a first look at the great Bishop of Hippo look at Serge Lancel’s Saint Augustine or else the old standby by Peter Brown Augustine of Hippo: A Biography (New Edition, with an Epilogue).  Avoid James O’Donnell’s risible book as a waste of time and money.   And you can’t go too wrong with Augustine (Past Masters) by Henry Chadwick, who died recently.  RIP.

Posted in Patristiblogging |
7 Comments

PRAY! PRAY NOW! – 3

In a few minutes, at the bottom of this hour, I will say Mass, again for the intention of the closer unity of the SSPX with the Roman Pontiff.   Join your intentions to this Mass.

Remember, as Augustine says, where there is charity there are no distances.

Ask your angel guardian to be present.

Pray that God’s holy angels will protect all those involved from the incessant attacks of the Enemy.

O God, Who settest straight what has gone astray,
and gatherest together what is scattered,
and keepest what Thou hast gathered together:
we beseech Thee in Thy mercy to pour down on Christian people,
the grace of union with Thee,
that, putting disunion aside and joining themselves to the true shepherd of Thy Church,
they be able to render Thee worthy service
.

(From the Mass for the Unity of the Church (1962 MR) translation from the Roman Catholic Daily Missal – Angelus Press)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments