Musings of excomm’d SSPX Bp. Williamson

On a blog called Dinoscopus there are entries which perhaps are posted by the excommunicated SSPX Bishop Richard Williamson.

I haven’t been able to verify for sure that this is Bp. Williamson’s blog, but it seems reasonable that it is.

On today’s entry we find this (my emphases and comments).

Stick Again
Eleison Comments LII)

Rumors abound once more: before the end of June, in other words in a few days’ time, either the Society of St. Pius X will begin to give way to Rome’s demands to conform to Vatican II and the New Mass, or Rome will declare to Church and world that the Society and its followers are in formal schism and out of the Church.  [So the writer assumes that the Five Conditions offered by the Holy See to the Superior Bp. Fellay, are indeed for the whole Society.  Of course it has to be that way, no?  And I suppose this is a bitter thing for the writer, since he has been one of the most acrimonious of the major figures of the SSPX.]

As to rumors of the Society taking any action that would imperil the defense of the Faith, [Interseting: they are the defenders of the Faith.] I think they are to be wholly discounted. On May 5 of 1988 in particular, Archbishop Lefebvre went as far as [watch for this idea as you read] the Faith would allow him, and even a little bit further, to come to terms with the Church authorities, but their terms finally persuaded him that they could no longer be trusted to look after the Church’s immutable Tradition, which is why he went ahead with the episcopal consecrations of 20 years ago. [That was then.   This is now.  Is their perspective so focused on the past that they cannot clearly judge the hinc et nunc?]

Similarly, ever since the Society’s Jubilee Pilgrimage to Rome in 2000, the Society has gone as far as it could to correspond to the goodwill gestures of Cardinal Castrillon, and even a little bit further, [Really?]  but in eight years it has never given to the Cardinal that abandonment of the Society’s stand on Tradition that he wanted. On the contrary, the latest Letter to Friends and Benefactors of the Society’s Superior General reiterated firmly that stand, which is surely where the rumors come from of the Cardinal losing patience with his eight years of carrot, and turning once more to the stick.

[A couple things here.  First, the Five Conditions do not concern matters of Tradition, beyond the undoubtedly Traditional point of showing respect for the Roman Pontiff and some positive will for unity – as Christ desired at the Last Supper.  The Five Conditions don’t lay down anything about Vatican II or the Novus Ordo or Religious Liberty, etc.  All they ask for is respectful behavior.  Is that what troubles Williamson?

Secondly, note that in Winona Bp. Fellay mentioned that the Benefactors (read MONEY) of the SSPX were upset.  Here again we have a reference to the Benefactors (read MONEY) who support the SSPX.  It is easy to understand how these men feel strong pressure to tune their rhetoric so that they keep up morale.  But at a certain point they will have to exercise real leadership and move the Benefactors to a new point of view.  It is easy to whip people into a froth when they are already convinced of something and they have invested money to support it.  It is quite another thing to preach a hard but true message, as Christ did in John 6, and run the risk of losing followers.]

Catholics should in no way be frightened by any threat [Subtle fearmongering?] of being declared formally, i.e. properly and officially, in schism, or out of the Church. Proper Catholic officialdom  [Who would that be?] would judge, like Our Lord tells us to judge (Jn. VII,24), by reality and not by appearances. The reality is obvious: it is the Conciliar "Renovation" and not Catholic Tradition that has broken with the Catholic Church.  [There it is folks.  This is one of the reasons why those Five Conditions lay down that Bp. Fellay ought not speak in such a way that give the sense he or the SSPX has a Magisterium, etc., superior to that of the Roman Pontiff.]

However, when in the next few days the Society makes no gesture towards Rome sufficient for Rome’s purpose of dissolving the resistance of Catholic Tradition, I am for my part not at all sure that Rome will really go ahead with any declaration of formal schism. [Calling Rome’s bluff, in other words.   He is saying that Rome’s Conditions have no teeth, that rome will do nothing, there will be no consequences.]  Maybe after eight, or 20, or 38 years of the Society’s resistance they really are losing patience, but does not all past experience tell them that each time they use the stick, it stiffens rather than dissolves that resistance?

And if they did go ahead with such a declaration, Catholics should rejoice, [Oh… my… God!   In praise of schism, of which the Father’s of the Church had such a horror, which Paul preaches against, which is blatantly against the will of Christ as He taught at the Last Supper.]  because after several years of some ambiguity there would once more be some clarity ! Twenty years ago, all Society Superiors gathered in Econe rejoiced in their bishops’ "excommunication". Would not the same thing happen this time round if Rome also cast priests and laity into its outer darkness ? Not that any of us would rejoice in Rome’s self-abasement… [Riiiight.] Kyrie eleison.

Munich, Germany
Posted by Bishop Richard Williamson at 2:50 PM 

Very misguided.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
84 Comments

Congratulations Archbp. Burke!

I was sadly happy to read this morning that Archbp. Burke has been, as I suspected he would be, named by His Holiness as Prefect of the Signatura.

Sadly happy, I say, because the loss of Archbishop Burke as an ordinary in the USA will be the Universal Church’s gain.

I am also happy because now Archbishop Burke will be made, God willing and soon, a Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church.  Being fairly young yet, he will perhaps have a say in the next conclave – though I hope that that will be many years from now.

Also, I suspect he may show up from time to time to pontificate at Ss. Trinta dei Pellegrini!

Congratulations, Archbishop Burke!  Ad multos annos!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
39 Comments

Sleepless at the moment – PRAY!

I can’t sleep.  It is 0130 right now and I am hoping I can get back to the land o’ nod.

In the meantime, I will ask your continuing prayers for the sake of the greater unity of the Church.

Think of what a gift it would be.  

But the Enemy is crafty and strong.

Pray, therefore. 

Perhaps there is some penance you can perform for this good intention, namely, that during this turning point of great potential God strengthen and enlighten all those concerned who serve the Holy See and those who are members of the the SSPX, especially Bp. Fellay.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
41 Comments

PODCAzT 62: Interviews with and by Fr. Z; What has Bp. Fellay really said?

PODCAzT 62: Interviews with and by Fr. Z; What has Bp. Fellay really said?Today we have some interviews! 

First, I interview a young Nigerian priest, Fr. Paschal, about how he introduced Latin into the worship of his parish.  Great stuff!   This fellow has his head screwed on in the right direction and many priests could learn something from him.

Also, I have audio of an on air interview from 13 June with Al Kresta of Ave Maria Radio.  We talk about liturgical translation and what Pope Benedict is up to.

I also describe the origins of this blog, in case you ever wondered why I started this.

Then there is another on air piece with syndicated talk show host Hugh Hewitt, about what is going on between the Holy See and the SSPX.  He had me on for two segment, which I splice together.

Then we dig into the famous Five Conditions offered to Bp. Bernard Fellay,  Superior of the SSPX, looking at them through the lenses of his sermon in Paris on 1 June, which we hear a bit of, and then his 20 June sermon in Winona, MN, wherein he talks about Rome’s "ultimatum". 
PODCAzT 62: Interviews with and by Fr. Z; What has Bp. Fellay really said?
I add my own analysis along the way.    For example, we have to clarify some things about what Summorum Pontificum really does and also drill into what Pope Benedict is really interested in.  Does he want to suppress objections to the Novus Ordo or the teaching of the Council?  What is he after?  I think that perhaps Bp. Fellay is not characterzing the situation correctly when he speaks about it.

Background:

Conditions resulting from the 4 june 2008 meeting between Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos and Bishop Bernard Fellay:

       1. A commitment to a proportioned response to the generosity of the Pope.
       2. A commitment to avoid any public speech which does not respect the person of the Holy Father and which can be negative for ecclesial charity.
       3. A commitment to avoid the pretense of a Magisterium superior to the Holy Father and to not put forward the Fraternity [SSPX] in opposition to the Church.
       4. A commitment to demonstrate the will to behave honestly in full ecclesial charity and in respect to the authority of the Vicar of Christ.
       5. A commitment to respect the date – fixed at the end of the month of June – to respond positively.  This will be a required and necessary condition for the immediate preparation for adhesion to have full communion.

Isn’t this basically a papal "offer you can’t refuse"?

https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/08_06_26.mp3


Posted in PODCAzT, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
35 Comments

Kerfuffle! Wisconsin parish nixes altar girls – predictable outrage ensues before sanity prevails

This story from the Capital Times of Madison, WI came to my attention through the intermediary of a kind reader.  My emphases and comments:

Mazomanie church nixes altar girls

Pat Schneider  —  6/25/2008 5:07 pm

Members of St. Barnabas Parish in Mazomanie say they are stunned to learn that the priests leading their Catholic community will no longer allow their daughters to be servers at Mass. From now on, only boys will be able to assist priests in the ancient religious rite.  [Do you catch a tone of outrage yet?]

The new policy was announced at a meeting with parents Tuesday by Rev. John Del Priore, who was assigned to the parish on June 1.  [Wow.  He moved quickly!]

"It’s an outrage," said Tammy Parks.  [As I mentioned, "outrage", which I wrote above before I even read this line.  Heh heh.] "They said it was a good way for boys to be indoctrinated  [HAH!] into being a priest."

After letting her 11-year-old daughter know that she would no longer be allowed on the altar, Del Priore asked her 8-year-old son about his interest in becoming an altar boy, Parks said in an interview.

"Not only is the priest discriminating against my daughter, he’s teaching my son that that is appropriate behavior," she said.  [I see.  For Tammy this is about social engineering.  Tammy doesn’t understand that no lay person has any RIGHT to server in the sanctuary.  No one is being discriminated against.  It is possible there could have been more tact, but let’s not forget the facts and underlying issues.  Service at the altar is not a right.  No priest can be forced to have altar girls or women serving.  The custom of service by boys and men is to be given first priority and fostered.]

Parents at St. Barnabas are so distressed that there is talk of having the boys boycott altar duty.  ["Having the boys boycott".  That means instrumentalizing the boys for political purposes.  Nice parenting.]

The Catholic Church broke with centuries of tradition in 1994, when the Vatican said girls would be allowed to join "altar boys" in assisting priests at Mass.

It is up to the local bishop to decide whether to allow lay women, or girls, to serve when needed, said Brent King, director of communications for the Madison Diocese. Female servers have been allowed in the Madison Diocese, King said, but it is ultimately up to each individual priest to decide whether he needs help at the altar. Priests may ask whomever they wish to assist them, so long as that person is a Catholic in good standing, King said.  [You know, I am liking this Bishop Morlino more and more and more.]

He stressed that servers take on the duties of acolytes, traditionally a low clerical rank.

"Neither lay women nor lay men have the right to carry out the function of acolyte," King said.  [I like this guy.  He gets it.  I hope he has been reading WDTPRS!  o{];¬)  ]

Altar service is being reserved for boys to promote vocations to the priesthood, Rev. Jared Hood, one of a group of priests that serves the St. Barnabas cluster, said in an interview. Hood said he is a member of the Society of Jesus Christ the Priest, a religious order that ministers to boys to inspire them to become priests. The order offered its services to the Madison Diocese, which is consolidating parishes because of a shortage of priests.

"Very many priests began as altar boys," Hood said. "Without contact with a priest it’s difficult for boys to even think about a vocation as a priest." He first learned about the order of which he is now a member as an altar boy in New Jersey, he said.

Four priests from the order now oversee a cluster of five parishes: St. Barnabas, St. Aloysius in Sauk City, St. Norbert in Roxbury, St. John the Baptist in Mill Creek, and St. Mary in Merrimac. Hood said boys only will be servers for each of the parishes.

That’s been the case at St. Aloysius for more than a year, and the furor that met the change in policy has evaporated, said Ann Cicero, a secretary for the parish whose sons serve as altar boys.  [Of course.  Fluctus in simpulo!]

The commitment by parish boys to altar service is proof that it’s right to reserve it for boys, she said. When girls were allowed to be servers, it became less popular among boys. Now that it’s a thing for boys only, they revel in it.  [Of course!]

Besides, having girls on the altar is misleading about what the church is about, she said.

"Women are not ordained," Cicero said.

The boys meet weekly with priests for training, spiritual growth and outings as the group, St. Michael Altar Guild, a practice that strengthens their ties to the church and parish community, she said. Girls, too, meet regularly and do things "more appropriate for girls."

Cicero said several young boys have begun to talk about vocations to the priesthood.  [Of course!  They may not ultimately choose that direction, but at least they will have considered it!]

Jim Schmitt of Mazomanie said that for his 11-year-old daughter, being an altar girl was a way to give back to the church.  [There are other ways.]

Today a Madison firefighter, Schmitt said he was an altar boy at Queen of Peace parish in Madison. He took pride in that role, but never thought of it as preparation for a vocation as a priest. It was a tradition, though. His father, grandfather and great-grandfather all had served as altar boys.  [Fair enough.]

"If someone has a vocation, how does serving with a girl interfere with that?" Schmitt asked. "I don’t see why we’re regressing."  [Partly because of the way boys develop and what their needs are.]

Parks, [remember Tammy from above?] an attorney, [Yah… that’s about right.]  said discrimination is significant issue for her personally.

"To have it in my own by parish, by my own priest, is repugnant," she said. 

 

I think Tammy should be the recipient of the special WDTPRS Sour Grapes Award for putting the worst possible spin on what has happened, having imposed exactly the wrong criteria on the Church’s worship and our active participation.

The Sour Grapes Award

At the same time, huge WDTPRS kudos, with gold star, to the priests in those parishes.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
145 Comments

New Haven, KY: weekly TLM established

I got this by e-mail:

Just wanted to let everyone know that Fr. Leger at St. Catherine’s in New Haven, Ky will be offering his first Traditional Latin Mass this Sunday, June 29, 2008 at 1PM EST.  I hope everyone will consider joining him and show their support.  This will be a High Mass with a choir.  This Mass will be offered every Sunday.  Please share this information with anyone who may be interested.

St. Catherine of Alexandria Parish
174 N. Main Street
New Haven, Ky
Parish Mailing Address:
413 First Street
New Haven, Ky 40051
Parish Office: 502-549-3152
Email: stcatherine@bardstown.com
Pastor: The Reverend Jeffrey P. Leger
Sunday, June 29, 2008
Traditional Latine Mass
1:00 PM EST

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

An argument for lengthening Communion fast to 3 hours again

Over at In the Light of the Law, canonist Edward Peters has a proposal.

Be sure to go over there and spike his stats.

Here is his piece, with my emphases.

Proposal: Extend the Communion fast

I have just published a short article proposing that the Communion fast (1983 CIC 919) be calculated from the start of Mass (instead of from the reception of Communion) and that the fast be extended to three hours (instead of the current one hour). See Edward Peters, "The Communion Fast: a Reconsideration", Antiphon 11 (2007) 234-244. Briefly, my reasons are:

1. A one hour "fast" is physically insufficient to bring the human body into a fasting state, meaning that the spiritual benefits long associated with corporal preparation for Communion are lost.  [We are both body and soul, according to our human nature. To be properly disposed to receive Holy Communion requires a spiritual preparation but also a physical preparation.  That is one reason, not the only, why we fast before Communion.  Remember that the physical dimension is very important.  We are not merely ghosts in a meat machine.  Think about the importance of the physical manner of reception of Holy Communion: standing does something different to us than kneeling.]

2. Making reception of Communion relevant to calculating the fast leads to distracting cogitations about the liturgy itself (e.g., worrying about whether the length of the homily or sung responses or angling to the end of the Communion line might allow one to complete the fast in time).

3. Calculating the fast from reception of Communion reinforces the assumption of many that "going to Communion" is the only important thing about Mass (rather than helping them see, e.g., the Sunday obligation as a liturgical one fundamentally oriented to worship [Rather than merely getting your obligation ticket validated.]).

4. A fast oriented only to reception of Communion diminishes the faithful’s appreciation for the Liturgy of the Word as an encounter with Christ worthy of preparation in its own right (see Mk VI: 34-42 on Jesus’ example of teaching hungry people before He fed them). [Related to the previous point.]

5. The brevity of the current fast means that Catholics with guilty or doubtful consciences have no discrete way to refrain from going up to Communion without attracting attention, resulting in pressure on them to approach the Eucharist under conditions that risk profanation.  [I think this is one of the most damaging things that resulted from shortening the Communion fast.  I have written on this many times and am very glad Peters has too!  Well done.  There is too much psychological pressure on people at Mass to get up and go forward.  Row by row Communion does this too, I think.]

6. Imposing as a requirement of law what is scarcely impossible to avoid doing anyway (how many people really eat and drink on their way to Mass?) makes legal norms seem like empty exercises, in turn fostering a diminished respect for the role of law in ecclesiastical society.  [Hmmm.. subtle, but good.]

My article outlines these problems in light of the history of the Communion fast and demonstrates, I think, that reforming the Communion fast as proposed above would resolve each of these issues quickly and completely.

We’ll see who might agree. [I do.]

PS: If you don’t already know the Society for Catholic Liturgy, publisher of Antiphon, check it out today!

 

Remember, the present law is one hour before the reception of Holy Communion.  That is the law.  You can fast longer if you wish.

However, Peters has a longer view here.  He is considering big picture issue, such as

What do we think Mass is?
What do we think the Church’s law is for?
What do we receive at Mass?

I think these questions, and therefore the proposal, is also bound up with Pope Benedict’s efforts to revitalize our Catholic identity in the modern world, ruled by secular relativism.

If we don’t know who we are, we have nothing to say to or give to the world. 

Our Catholic identity was once shaped by many traditions, often codifed in law.  We not only knew more about ourselves as Catholics through these things, but non-Catholics recognized us as well out there in the world. 

For example, meat-less Fridays: everyone knew this about Catholics.  Women and girls wearing veils, even on the way to Church.  Fasting.  I am sure you could come up with other things.

I think we have lost too much.  

Good proposal.

 

 

Posted in Classic Posts, SESSIUNCULA |
69 Comments

Reuters: “Bp. Fellay says No” story is NOT the end of the story!

I just saw this.  The writer has based himself on something B. Fellay said last week.

But the time frame set by the Holy See isn’t over yet.

Catholic rebel snubs pope call to rejoin Rome   [I don’t think this is the end of the story.]
Thu Jun 26, 2008 6:25am EDT

By Tom Heneghan, Religion Editor

PARIS (Reuters) – The leader of a breakaway traditionalist Catholic group has rejected a Vatican offer to rejoin Rome, accusing Pope Benedict of trying to silence dissenting voices.

Bishop Bernard Fellay, head of the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) that broke with Rome 20 years ago, said conditions set by the Vatican amounted to muzzling the traditionalists who claim to be the only true Catholics since Church reforms in the 1960s.

Keen to end this schism, Benedict agreed last year to their demand to restore the old Latin Mass. [That is not the only reason he released Summorum Pontificum.]  But he insists they must accept the reforms of the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965) before he can lift excommunication decrees against them.  [Umm.. I am not sure that this is the case, at least in the way it sounds here, black and white.  There is a lot of theological room to debate many points of what Council documents mean.  I don’t think Pope Benedict would ever want to stifle theological discussion.]

"Rome is telling us, okay, we are ready to lift the excommunications, but you cannot continue this way," Fellay said in a sermon last Friday now posted as an audio file on the U.S.-based Voice of Catholic Radio website.  [However, that was a sermon last Friday.  This isn’t the end of the story.]

"So we have no choice… we are continuing what we’ve done," the Swiss-born Fellay said in English at an SSPX seminary in Winona, Minnesota. "They just say ‘shut up’ … we are not going … to shut up."

The Milan daily Il Giornale reported on Monday the Vatican had told the SSPX it must pledge to respect the pope and accept him as the Church’s final doctrinal authority.

Vatican spokesman Rev. Federico Lombardi told the Paris Catholic daily La Croix: "The pope wants to extend his hand so they can return, but for that to happen, this offer must be received in an attitude and spirit of charity and communion."

Lombardi did not spell out the consequences of rejecting the offer, but Il Giornale’s well-informed Vatican expert Andrea Tornielli wrote: "Such favorable conditions for a return to full communion will in all probability not come again."

TIP OF THE ICEBERG

The SSPX claims about a million followers worldwide, many of them in France. It split off when its founder, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, consecrated four traditionalist bishops — including Fellay — in 1988 against orders from Pope John Paul.

Since then, it has regularly appealed to the Vatican to withdraw the excommunications and allow it to return to the 1.1-billion strong Church. But its leaders often publicly denounce the pope.

Fellay said the pope must restore other Church traditions besides the old Latin Mass before the SSPX could return. It is particularly critical of the Vatican Council’s reconciliation with Judaism and call to cooperation with other Christians.

"The new Mass is the tip of the iceberg of Vatican II and of these modern ideas." Adding the old Mass to the "iceberg of Vatican II" did not change the reforms hidden below, he said.

Vatican watchers say the ultimatum could split SSPX into a hard core of rebels and a larger group ready to return to Rome now that it has allowed wider use of the old Latin Mass.

"Most people want a reverent Mass and sound preaching. They care little for the loftier theological arguments," Rev. John Zuhlsdorf, a prominent conservative Catholic blogger, wrote in an analysis. "The identity of the SSPX is at stake now."

The ultimatum’s deadline of June 30 is the 20th anniversary of the bishops’ ordinations that sealed the schism.

 

This story tries to leave you the impression that the whole thing is over, Fellay said "No", and that’s that.

I wonder.  I don’t think so.

Keep praying.  We haven’t gotten to the end of the month yet.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
80 Comments

PRAY! PRAY NOW! – 2

Can we really even for a moment delude ourselves that Old Scratch is not going to try to sabotage closer ties between the Bishop of Rome and the SSPX?

Spiritual warfare is being waged constantly for our souls.  The enemy, fallen angels, desire our downfall and division with so much malice that they will never relent until the Coming of the Lord.

Think about it, people.  We are not talking about mere insurgents or terrorists or guerrilla fighters.  We are talking about angels.

They will attack Christ’s Church which he gave us for our salvation.  They will tear at her unity and undermine her visible head, Christ the true Head’s Vicar, the Bishop of Rome.

They will lie in wait with angelic patience, ingenuity and powers beyond human imagining to attack the Church especially through her priests … and their discord.

But we have angel guardians and the saints in heaven.  We have our baptismal character and the sacrament of confirmation.  We can be strong in the face of these attacks. 

You can be strong for bishops and priests who are in need.

And lest there be any doubt, WDTPRSers have at least one priest who will say Mass for the good outcome of what Pope Benedict has initiated.

Tomorrow morning at 1230 UTC – 1430 CET – 0830 EDT I will say Mass inviting you all, as I did today, to pray in a special way for about 40 minutes or so after that starting time.  Ask your angel guardians to be present and also to defend Bp. Bernard Fellay and anyone else in his confidence from the attacks of the Enemy. 

He must be in a terribly difficult position and in need of spiritual support.

O God our Father, merciful and almighty,
whose Only-begotten Son took up our human nature
to save us from our sins and to teach us who we are,
under the protection of Holy Mary’s mantle
and the vigilant aegis of Your holy angels,
bring all your priests into closer unity with the Bishop of Rome
in the one, holy, Catholic and apostolic Church.
Amen
.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
41 Comments

Just got off the air

I just got off the air with Hugh Hewitt, talking for two segments about the 5 Conditions and what is going on with the SSPX.

Just got off the air

Please check out Mr. Hewitt’s site.

I’ll try to put up some audio from this along wiht a recent hit with Al Kresta.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments