Amy Sullivan and the Father of Lies

UPDATE:

Lifesite has a piece entitled:

Time Piece Blasting Archbishop Burke Also Refuted by John Allen, Robert Royal
Alan says, contrary to Time assertion, Burke’s influence in Church "set to grow"

Including:

Princeton Professor Robert P. George told LifeSiteNews.com (LSN) that the quotes he had given Sullivan were used "selectively" and gave the erroneous impression that he did not oppose the lavish Kennedy funeral that became a hotspot of scandal in the US Church and abroad.

Also this:

Noted Princeton Professor Robert P. George says he is "not pleased" with TIME’s Amy Sullivan’s "selective" use of a quotation from him in her article "A Tale of Two Priests."   … George responded to LifeSiteNews that he "was quoted accurately, though selectively." He also  revealed he had expressed concerns via email at the beginning to Sullivan about how his comments might be presented. As a result of Sullivan’s response, he told LSN, he "accepted what I took to be her assurance of fairness and non-partisanship in her message of October 5th.  I should not have been so trusting."

Prof. George said:

Here is what she did not include in the article, but readers should, I think, have been told:  I said that I thought Archbishop Burke was right to deny pro-abortion politicians communion pursuant to Canon 915 of the Code of Canon Law. I also said that I thought Cardinal O’Malley made an error of judgment in permitting a large public funeral for Teddy Kennedy and personally participating in it.  The error was precisely in failing to see the scandal that would be given.  I am disappointed that she omitted these points and mentioned only my surprise at learning (from her) that Archbishop Burke has taken the position that Kennedy should not have been given a Catholic funeral at all — even a private one.

Amy Sullivan plainly lied.

If you subscribe to Time… CANCEL IT NOW.

_________

Again and again we see once great instruments of the old printed media devolve into liberal snake-oil peddlers.

So it is with Time.  

I have picked about peices by Time‘s immensely biased Amy Sullivan before.  Amy Sullivan was a legislative assistant to pro-abortion Catholic former Senator Tom Daschle (D-SD).  That should tell you pretty much all you need to know.  She is a convinced acolyte of Moloch.  If memory serves Amy also wrote that tax payer funding abortion in the House health care bill was a myth.  She wants you to live with her in her fantasy world, cavorting with the saline injecting gnomes and little forceps wielding pixies.
 
Ms. Sullivan is at her worst when she writes about anything Catholic.  Let’s have a brief look at the hit piece she did on Archbishop Burke.  My emphases and comments.

Priests Spar Over What It Means to Be Catholic  [Which doesn’t prevent Amy from butting in with her liberal kant.]
By Amy Sullivan Sunday, Nov. 08, 2009

The leaders of the Roman Catholic Church traditionally couch even the harshest disagreements in decorous, ecclesiastical language. But it didn’t take a decoder ring to figure out what Rome-based Archbishop Raymond Burke meant in a late-September address when he charged Boston Cardinal Seán O’Malley with being under the influence of Satan, "the father of lies."  [I think she needs a new decoder ring.  The writer offers this with no quote or link to a text.  You are simply supposed to believe that the gentlemanly Archbp. Burke said this about a sitting Cardinal.  Does that sound likely?  I believe this is the speech to which Moloch acolyte Amy referred.  This is what Archbp. Burke said:

"If there has always been the danger of giving scandal to others by public and seriously sinful actions or failures to act, that danger is heightened in our own time. Because of the confusion about the moral law, which is found in public discourse, in general, and is even embodied in laws and judicial pronouncements, the Christian is held to an even higher standard of clarity in enunciating and upholding the moral law. It is particularly insidious that our society which is so profoundly confused about the most basic goods also believes that scandal is a thing of the past. One sees the hand of the Father of Lies at work in the disregard for the situation of scandal or in the ridicule and even censure of those who experience scandal." 

It seems that Amy might have misrepresented Archbp. Burke.  In doing so, she has emulated a daughter of the Father of Lies.]

Burke’s broadside at O’Malley [that’s a misrepresentation] was inspired by the Cardinal’s decision to permit and preside over a funeral Mass for the late Senator Ted Kennedy. And it has set the Catholic world abuzz. Even more than protests over the University of Notre Dame’s decision to invite President Barack Obama to speak, [Another slippery misrepresentation.  The protest was not so much about the invitation to the President to speak, it was about the decision of ND to bestowed an honor on him, an honorary doctorate of law given to the most agressively pro-abortion politician we have ever seen.  Sullivan is trying to deceive.] disputes over the Kennedy funeral have brought into the open an argument that has been roiling within American Catholicism. The debate nominally centers on the question of how to deal with politicians who support abortion rights. ["nominally"?] Burke and others who believe a Catholic’s position on abortion trumps all other teachings [That too is a misrepresentation.  Catholics believe that for us to have a proper and consistent approach to all social justice issues, we must first get the issue of the right to live straight.  Otherwise, all other social justice solutions will be empty.] have faced off against those who take [get this] a more holistic view of the faith. But at the core, the divide is over who decides what it means to be Catholic. (See pictures of Pope Benedict XVI visiting America.)

A Bull in a China Shop  [I think see doesn’t want you to have any respect for Archbp. Burke.  What do you think?]

It strikes no one as surprising that the 61-year-old Burke is at the center of the current fight. The former Archbishop of St. Louis made national headlines in 2004 when he became the first Catholic leader to say he would deny the Eucharist to Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry. He led an unsuccessful drive to bar Communion for politicians who support abortion rights. [That is also a misrepresentation.  This reflects the way Sullivan thinks, not the way Burke thinks.  Archbp. Burke articulated what is found in the Church’s law and laid out the position.  He did so in a compelling way.  His logic was clear and arguments inescapable.  To a liberal, who dislikes arguments based on objective criteria, that must come across as a "campaign".  She frames it in political terms.] And as Election Day approached in 2004, Burke issued a warning to Catholics in the key swing state of Missouri that they should not present themselves for Communion if they voted for pro-choice candidates.  [Which was not a political statement.]

The Archbishop’s outspoken comments did not go unnoticed in Rome. In June 2008, Burke was unexpectedly transferred to the Vatican. [Unexpected for people who know very little about the Church and what is going on.  Bingo!  Amy Sullivan!] The move was widely interpreted [again, by people without the slightest clue…] as a way to put some distance between Burke and the political contest in the States. "It was not unrelated to issues of political timing," observes Mark Silk, a professor of religion at Trinity College.  [Prof. Silk is wrong.]

Burke’s new assignment came with an impressive title: Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura — essentially chief justice of the Vatican’s highest court. But the job, which involves hearing appeals of lower-canon-court rulings on issues like annulment requests, did not stop him from commenting on American politics. [Nor… was… it… intended… to!] In January he charged that the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops was responsible for Obama’s victory because it overwhelmingly approved a document suggesting that Catholics could consider issues besides abortion when deciding how to vote. The conference’s in-house news service, he added, failed to highlight Obama’s moral failings in its campaign coverage. And he called Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, a pro-choice Catholic, a "source of deepest embarrassment to Catholics." (See the top 10 unfortunate political one-liners.)  [That wasn’t a political statement.  But liberals want to convince you that opposition to their immoral agenda is really political.]

Burke’s confrontational approach doesn’t always mesh with the more discreet diplomacy favored by his Italian colleagues. "He’s seen as a bull in a china shop," says an American priest and longtime Rome resident. "I’ve seen Italian bishops roll their eyes."  [Suuuuure you have.  Archbishop Burke has strong and numerous supporters as well.]

In retrospect, it should have been obvious [Amy must have missed the debate leading up to the funeral.] that the funeral plans for Kennedy would reignite a lingering dispute within the church. The question of whether the Senator should even be described as a Catholic because of his support for abortion rights and his checkered life history was hotly debated on Catholic blogs and religion websites like Beliefnet.com. Right-wing Catholics lobbied the Boston archdiocese to refuse the Kennedy family a church funeral. Robert Royal of the Faith & Reason Institute called O’Malley’s decision to go ahead with the Mass a "grave scandal" on a par with the sexual-abuse crisis.  [Some writers were not so much against the idea of a funeral as they were against the sort of "funeral" they actually had.]

But it’s one thing for partisans and bloggers to disparage a Mass for a dead Senator; it’s quite another for a Vatican official to do so. [It is also another thing to misrepresent Archbp. Burke.] Even some leading conservative Catholics may find they cannot support Burke’s latest salvo. [Oh?] When told [who by?] of the Archbishop’s assertion that pro-choice Catholics should not be permitted funeral rites, Princeton professor Robert George was taken aback: "That’s a very different, and obviously graver, claim than that with which I would have sympathy. I haven’t heard before any bishop say that pro-abortion politicians should not be given a Catholic funeral."  [I wonder if Robert George was quoted correctly.  Given Amy’s tendency to mislead the reader, I don’t believe this.  Where did this quote come from?]

My summation:

B as in B.  S as in S.

If you subscribe to Time… cancel it.

Who is Amy Sullivan?

BeliefNet has this little bio about the writer, Amy Sullivan with my emphases:

Amy Sullivan is an editor of The Washington Monthly. She has written about religion and politics for publications including the Boston Globe, Los Angeles Times, The New Republic, and The Washington Post, and has served as a commentator for The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer, NPR’s Morning Edition, and other news outlets. Previously, Sullivan served as a legislative assistant to U.S. Sen. Tom Daschle and as editorial director of the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life. She holds degrees from the University of Michigan and Harvard Divinity School.

Washington Monthly has this little bio:

Amy Sullivan is the nation editor for TIME magazine, where she directs political coverage and the magazine’s polling operation. Her book on Democrats and religion, The Party Faithful, will be published in February 2008 by Scribner. Sullivan’s work has appeared in publications including the Los Angeles Times, The New Republic, The New York Times, and The Washington Post, and was included in The Best Political Writing 2006. She is a frequent guest on radio and television talk shows. Previously, Sullivan served as editor of the Washington Monthly, and as editorial director of the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life. She holds degrees from the University of Michigan and Harvard Divinity School, and pursued doctoral studies in sociology at Princeton University.

Her liberal pedigree thus established, did you see what she wrote in TIME about the "quiet faith" of late Sen. Edward Kennedy?  It is a paen to the privatization of one’s faith, shelving of one’s faith when acting in the public square.

 

Posted in Green Inkers, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , ,
23 Comments

Brick by brick in the Netherlands

In the Brick By Brick department:

Just today I came across an announcement which I believe would fit very well in the ‘ brick by brick’ category on your website. One of the seminaries in the Netherlands is going to offer a course in the Extraordinary Form of the Mass, for priests and seminarians. This is the first seminary to do so in this country. Here is the link.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
Comments Off on Brick by brick in the Netherlands

NCR’s editors have a nutty – attack Card. Rode, Benedict XVI

The editors of the ultra-liberal fishwrap The National Catholic Reporter had another little public nutty yesterday.

My emphases and comments.

Nostalgia is not a path to the future
Nov. 10, 2009
An NCR Editorial

NCR's editors have a nutty - attack Card. Rode, Benedict XVI

CAPTION: Detail of text from the 1962 Roman Missal, commonly known as the Tridentine Mass (CNS photo/Nancy Wiechec)

Editorial

[Take note of the premises the editorial wants you to embrace…] It has been an open secret [Because there is some sort of conspiracy, right?] that powerful forces in the church’s leadership [NCR hates the Pope and the new sort of bishops being appointed and they feel impotent.] have strongly opposed the reforms set in motion by the Second Vatican Council [Which is an entirely specious claim.  Show us just one thing that the Holy Father has done contrary to the Second Vatican Council’s actual documents.] and have worked quietly yet assiduously during the past 40 years to roll back what has been accomplished. [What a weird thing to say!  The traditional view of things was nearly completely repressed.  And they are claiming that all along it was so powerful that the Council was being undermined?  Dopey.] The regression is usually couched in Orwellian churchspeak, [Oh how rich, coming the the chief expounder of liberal buzz words!] which lavishes praise on the council even as its intentions are reversed. Or sometimes in this parallel universe the argument is made that nothing really happened during the gathering of the world’s bishops over a four-year period to redirect the church and its mission.  [Okay… at this point I am sure you, like I, would like the help them softly to the floor and put something between their teeth until their little nutty is over.]

Then along came Cardinal Franc Rodé, head of the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, who has vaulted to notoriety as the person overseeing the investigation of U.S. women religious. He is quoted in this issue, from a talk he gave in September 2008, as blaming the problems of Vatican II on a misguided “hermeneutic” or interpretation, which he calls “a hermeneutic of rupture and discontinuity.”  [ROFL!  I wonder if the editors are purposely this obtuse?  That little phrase isn’t just a throw away or even an adage of Card. Rode.  This is straight from that "powerful force in the church’s leadership" called Benedict XVI.  But watch what follows.   This is one of the dumbest things I have read in days….] That is a rather elaborate way of saying that one believes nothing really happened at the council.  [?!?  Who believes THAT?] To Rodé’s credit, in more recent comments to John Allen (NCR, Oct. 30), he changes tone. In his latest pronouncement, it wasn’t the interpretation, but the council itself that was the problem. In his conversation with Allen, he credits the council with some muscular intent, and sees its documents holding the language of significant change. Otherwise why would he make the shocking charge that the council caused “the greatest crisis in church history … the first truly global crisis” in the church?

No doubt he spoke for other Roman curia members who would never utter such a brash assessment publicly.  [See how they attempt to isolate him?  If anyone bothered to read the NCR in Rome.  Well… they will see this because they read WDTPRS.]

What is it, though, that the cardinal finds so disastrous? What would he have us return to? Would he want to go back to the days when the church condemned separation of church and state?

Would he want us to return to a condemnation of religious liberty? [One wonders how the NCR would define "religious liberty".] Three popes since the council have upheld the principle of religious liberty as a fundamental human right, an assertion that would have been unthinkable before 1965.  [Three Popes… how would they be counted.  Paul VI, John Paul… I? John Paul II…  or do we leave out John Paul I, who really didn’t have much time, and include Benedict XVI?   Remember: the ultra-liberals will lump this whole discussion together with ecumenism.  But they only want dialogue with people who already agree with NCR’s agenda.  Pope Benedict, on the other hand, is the true exponent of true ecumenism, of true religious liberty.  He is the Pope of Christian Unity.]

Maybe his objection is to Nostra Aetate, the document on church relations with non-Christian religions. [Watch this….] Perhaps he would want us to return to the days of open hostility toward Jews in our prayers and sermons.  [HA HA HAH HA HA… ho ho ho…. sigh…  They have as high an opinion of your intelligence as some translation focused bishops.]

Or does he feel that modernity and ecumenism have so infected the church that we should return to those days when Catholics were prohibited from attending the funerals of friends if held in a Protestant church, or when we were barred from attending a non-Catholic college without the permission of the local bishop?  [Remember: liberals want to define what ecumenism is.  They want to determine for you what religious liberty is.  However, I think we will have a clearer idea of religious liberty means once the talks between the Holy See and the SSPX have progressed.  Oddly, they won’t include the views of the editors of NCR.]

Does he want a return to the 19th-century papal condemnation of freedom of conscience?  [Okay… this is getting boring.]

[Now watch.  When liberals start thinking they are very clever, they will trot out the old "dress up" card.] Or is he upset that most do not prefer, as he does, dressing up in the trappings of royalty, the yards of silk in the cappa magna, the canopies and throne chairs and all the rest — being attended by his minions, younger priests in lacy surplices, birettas and old-fashioned vestments encrusted with gold thread and jewels — all the while speaking in a dead language, facing a wall, his back to the people?  [Wow.  Pure hatred.  Pure frightened, nutty hatred.  They hate our past.  The advancement of a hermeneutic of continuity truly frightens them.]

All of this was the preconciliar church. Which elements does he want restored?

Or possibly he regrets the fact that laypeople have wide access these days not only to the scriptures but also to the documents of Vatican II, and thus can say with authority that his version of church, dependent on a thin culture of nostalgia, holds no promise of the future.

Against that culture, the people of God can say convincingly that our worldwide church, in elaborate deliberation, has decided to go forward, not backward, and that the authors of that change wrote compellingly of the need for new and more inclusive ways of conducting ourselves as 21st-century Catholics.  [What a peroration!]

Sad.  Very sad.

I wonder what Bishop Finn of Kansas City thinks about this open attack on a Cardinal of the Catholic Church, tasked with the Apostolic Visitation?  I wonder if His Excellency has any opinion about the use of the word "Catholic" in the title of this paper, published in his diocese?

Nuntiatrix delenda est. 

Posted in Green Inkers, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged
36 Comments

The Feeder Feed

The Chickadees and the Nuthatches are firmly in control these days, but there is a strong contingent of various finches.

Here are some male House Finches.

The Feeder Feed

The Feeder Feed

There are many Goldfinches, scrabbling on the ground right now for their favorite black nyger seed (I haven’t filled their seed socks for a while).

The Feeder Feed

Also, as it gets colder, they are poking around at the high fat suet.

The Feeder Feed

Nuthatches like to be upside down… a lot.

The Feeder Feed

The Finches like to scope things out before zooming down to the feeder.

The Feeder Feed

The Missus.

The Feeder Feed

The Chickadees like the black sunflower seeds.  They grab one and usually fly off with it to a nearby branch or perch near one of the feeders.  They hammer away at it until they get the seed out.  Sometimes they do their prying hammering thing right at the feeder itself.

The Feeder Feed

These guys can really eat.The Feeder Feed

The Feeder Feed

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

On Freedom’s Ground

With thanks to the Laudator:

Richard Wilbur, from On Freedom’s Ground, III (Like a Great Statue):

    Mourn for the dead who died for this country,
    Whose minds went dark at the edge of a field,
    In the muck of a trench, on the beachhead sand,
    In a blast amidships, a burst in the air.
    What did they think of before they forgot us?
    In the blink of time before they forgot us?
    The glare and whiskey of Saturday evening?
    The drone or lilt of their family voices?
    The bend of a trout stream? A fresh-made bed?
    The sound of a lathe, or the scent of sawdust?
    The mouth of a woman? A prayer? Who knows?
    Let us not force them to speak in chorus,
    These men diverse in their names and faces
    Who lived in a land where a life could be chosen.
    Say that they mattered, alive and after;
    That they gave us time to become what we could.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Oxford, UK: 40 Hours Devotion this weekend

From a reader:

A real uplifting occasion in store this weekend in Oxford, England.  The Oratory Catholic Church of St Aloysius, on Woodstock Road, is holding its Forty Hours Exposition of the Blessed Sacrament, with the special intention for the Year for Priests.

Friday 13 November

    6.00pm                        Solemn Mass of Exposition and start of Exposition.
    12 midnight                 Compline followed by Benediction
   
Saturday 14 November

    12 midnight to 6am     All night Vigil
    5am –                            Matins and Lauds of the Blessed Sacrament
    6am                               Mass
    10am                             Mass
    6.30pm                          Mass for Peace
    11.45pm                        Compline

    Church closes at midnight

Sunday 15 November

    8am                             Latin Mass (Extraordinary Form)
    9.30am                       Parish Mass
    11am                          Solemn Mass of The Sacred Heart
    5pm                            Vespers, Procession, and Benediction to conclude the Forty                                             Hours 

I can’t think of a better way to spend a weekend.

Posted in The Campus Telephone Pole |
Comments Off on Oxford, UK: 40 Hours Devotion this weekend

Fermoy, Cork, Ireland – 28 Nov – Solemn Requiem TLM

From a reader comes this TLM notice:

St. Colman’s Society for Catholic Liturgy
Solemn Requiem Mass in Latin

The annual Solemn Requiem Mass for deceased members of  St Colman’s Society for Catholic Liturgy and for all the faithful departed will be celebrated at 11 am on Saturday, 28 November 2009 in St. Patrick’s Pro-Cathedral Church, Fermoy, Co. Cork.

The Mass will be celebrated in Latin according to the Roman Missal published by Blessed  Pope John XXIII  in 1962.

The Gregorian propers of the Requiem and Gabriel Fauré’s Pie Jesu and In paradisum will be sung by members of the Lassus Scholars, Dublin under the direction of Miss Ite O’Donovan.

All are welcome to attend.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

REMINDER: Bp. Trautman’s jihad against the new translation

I want to bring back to your minds that His Excellency Most Rev. Donald W. Trautman will try to derail the new translation during the upcoming meeting of the USCCB in Baltimore (16-19 Nov.).

I wrote about that here.

I have a WDTPRS POLL.

I asked for your e-mail feedback.

I invited other bloggers to write about this issue.

n

{democracy:33}

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Veterans & Remembrance

Veterans & Remembrance

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Thanks due to readers

Thanks due to readersMany thanks are due to some of you readers who have not only use the donation button, but who have also used my amazon wish list to send things for my recent birthday and other.

MA sent a volume of an English translation of St. Augustine’s newly discovered Dolbeau and the Etaix sermons.  This is a helpful research tool!

I don’t know who sent Vol. 8 of The Complete New English Hymnal music CD, but thanks a million!  This is a disk recorded at Keble College, Oxford.   I now have 1-5 and 8.  Some of these CD’s are hard to get or pretty expensive.  I did, however, find them on iTunes.  If someone wants to send more of this series, maybe designated donations will save money.  For example, Vol. 7 is very expensive to buy as a CD, but on iTunes it is far less.  Go figure.

Thanks due to readersTE of NY sent a volume about the ancient Roman writer Cicero on oratory and orators and a bottle of the exquisite colatura!  Yum.  I brought a couple small pots of parsley into the house before the freezing began, and so with fresh garlic on hand I am all set to enjoy the another kind of power lunch!  You can get your own bottle of this stuff here.  I chop some garlic and parsley, and put a couple tablespoons of colatura over it all in a bowl to macerate.  Then I toss through it still hot but very well drained vermicelli, sprinkling into it red pepper. Easy and very good.  Thanks due to readers

I don’t know who sent the copy of The Reform of the Liturgy (1948-1975) by the late Annibale Bugnini, but many thanks anyway.  I can’t say I look forward to reading this, of course.  Reading autopsies isn’t exactly fun.  But we do need to know what people were thinking when they started to wreck the Roman Rite.  In any event, the book came without an indication of who sent it.  It will be useful.

Finally, I am grateful to JL who sent my the Windows 7 upgrade.  I have detested Vista ever since I got it.  Now, however, I will have the terror of going down the Microsoft rabbit hole again, hoping against hope that their upgrade won’ ruin my installation, forcing me to go through the same hell I had a couple months back.  Yes… I know… some of you will say "switch to Mac".  If I could determine what system to get, I would put that on my wish list too.  Until then, it’s repairs with Microsoft’s equivalent of twine and 100 mile an hour tape.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments