UK Bishops considering priest bloggers?

First things first.  Click here.  Spike those stats!

What is this about?   A friend of mine in the UK who has the blog Mulier Fortis posted an interesting piece which deserves some thought.

My emphases and comments.

Bishops Contemplate A Bit Of Blogger…

Finally, I get to post something original… and I haven’t caught even a smidgeon of this in the blogosphere, so this could even be a Mulier Fortis exclusive. Please remember this little fact when you see it later on more famous (and more interesting) blogs… it would be nice to have a busy com-box for a change…
;-)

I have heard a rumour or two (no names, no pack-drill) that the Bishops of England and Wales discussed the blogging phenomenon during their Low Week meeting this year. [If they didn’t, they are even farther behind the curve than one might have imagined.]

Nothing too surprising (or noteworthy) in that, you might think. Practically everything on the planet, if it possesses a pulse, has heard of blogging. It’s even been mentioned on BBC Radio 4.  [LOL!]

The interest arises from the further rumour that their Lordships discussed the "reining in" of several priestly bloggers in their dioceses… allegedly. I think there may even have been mention of some sort of "imprimatur" being required…  [Yah… that’ll work.]

This is hugely entertaining, in view of the fact that almost no publications bother with the imprimatur these days, not even RE textbooks produced for use in Catholic schools… and, in reality, it is possible to be promoted in Catholic Cathedrals while publicly dissenting from Catholic teaching…  [Exactly.]

For some strange reason, the phrase "Come and have a go, if you think you’re hard enough!"  [Or, in American: "Go ahead!  Make my day!"] keeps flitting through my consciousness… I have a sneaking suspicion that one or two priestly bloggers of my acquaintance would smile seraphically at whoever attempted to deliver the gagging order and boot the whole issue straight "upstairs" ! I don’t know which Vatican Department deals with such appeals, but I have little doubt that the priests in question would get a favourable hearing. [About that I am not so sure.  But… it would simply drive the bloggers to anonymity, increase their traffic, and no bishop would benefit in the long run.]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

NCRep: ‘No’ to women priests is definitive, Vatican consultor says

Here is an interesting piece from the ultra-lefty NCReporter. 

The original piece is in L’Avvenire, the daily of the Italian Bishops Conference (CEI)

My emphases and the questions are also in bold:

‘No’ to women priests is definitive, Vatican consultor says
Posted on Jul 11, 2008 09:54am CST.

NOTE: The issue of women’s ordination is again generating headlines, in part due to a recent decision of the Anglican synod in England to open the door to female bishops, in part due to a disciplinary action in St. Louis against a religious sister who attended a women’s ordination ceremony. The July 11 issue of L’Avvenire, the official newspaper of the Italian bishops’ conference, featured an interview on the issue with Monsignor Antonio Miralles, a consultor to the Vatican’s doctrinal office. The interview was conducted by Italian journalist Gianni Cardinale. The full text appears below in an NCR translation.

By GIANNI CARDINALE
Rome

The decision of the Anglican Synod of England to open the door to the nomination of female bishops has generated ample media coverage. On the subject of why the Catholic church admits only men to the priesthood, Avvenire put certain questions to Monsignor Antonio Miralles, of the clergy of Opus Dei, and an ordinary professor of sacramental theology at the Pontifical University of the Holy Cross. A Spaniard from Salamanca who has spent 47 years in Rome, Miralles is a consultor of the Congregation for the Clergy and, since 1990, of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Monsignor Miralles, why does the Catholic church not admit women to the priesthood?

In 1975, the Archbishop of Canterbury at the time, Donald Coggan, informed Pope Paul VI that the Anglicans were on the verge of admitting women to the priesthood, which they later did. Pope Montini wrote him a letter to explain that the Catholic church does not feel authorized to do the same, because it is constrained by the choice made by Jesus, the Lord, to choose only men as his apostles. In that context, the pope asked the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to prepare a document that provided the reasons for this position, which was how the declaration Inter insigniores, published in 1976, was born. In it, the argument given by Paul VI is explained more fully. In May 1994, this position was confirmed in a definitive way with the apostolic letter of Pope John Paul II, Ordinatio sacredotalis.

But some object that the choice of Jesus may have been determined by the historical context, the mentality of the epoch.

It’s an objection that does not have any foundation. Jesus demonstrated that he felt free from the conditioning of the society in which he was born. He demonstrated this freedom, to take just one example, when he opposed the custom of Jewish society of his day, as well as of Greco-Roman society, permitting men to repudiate their wives … in other words, divorce. Certainly, women were among the most faithful followers of Jesus, beginning with his mother, the Blessed Virgin Mary – at the foot of the Cross there were several women, but only one disciple! Nevertheless, Jesus deliberately and freely chose only men as his apostles. This choice cannot be anything but binding for the community that wants to be his church.

Why did Jesus make this choice?

Theologians try to answer this question, which is their duty. But all the explanations that can be given in response to this question always remain secondary with respect to the choice itself made by Jesus, which the church must follow. The church can’t change that choice to suit its own tastes, or on the basis of the desires of sectors of public opinion, however large they may be.

Isn’t the exclusion of women from the priesthood an offense against their dignity?

The dignity of women in the church certainly does not depend upon access to the priesthood. The history of the church, from the Blessed Virgin Mary to so many saints and beatified women, makes the point.

Why did the magisterium wait until 1975 to solemnly proclaim that women cannot be admitted to the priesthood?

Simply because prior to that moment, the fact that the priesthood is reserved to men was an uninterrupted praxis that had not been placed into discussion for almost 2,000 years, not even when the church began to expand in cultural and religious contexts where there were already forms of female ‘priesthood’ (I’m thinking, for example, about the Greco-Roman world), and not even in the face of vocational scarcity or a shortage of clergy. The magisterium normally does not intervene to resolve a dispute when a given truth is peacefully accepted and not under discussion.

Is it possible that in the future the Catholic magisterium, having reflected more on the question, could arrive at a different conclusion and thereby open the door to women’s ordination?

This possibility is excluded. That’s because the all-male priesthood is a truth considered part of the inviolable deposit of faith – in other words, it belongs to Tradition with a capital “T”. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith underscored the point in a formal way with its document ‘Response to a doubt concerning the doctrine of the Apostolic Letter Ordinatio sacerdotalis’ published in October 1995, with the approval and at the request of Pope John Paul II. Some Catholic authors have insinuated that the ‘no’ to women’s ordination should be considered provisional and open to future reconsideration, but in fact that’s not how things are.

Monsignor Miralles, will the decision of the Anglican Synod to admit women to the episcopacy further distance it from the Catholic church??

Relatively. The dramatic rupture occurred with the Anglican decision to admit women to the priesthood. The choice to admit them also to the episcopacy is, in itself, a secondary consequence, which cannot help but worsen a situation that has already deteriorated.

A final ‘secondary’ question. What’s the status quaestionis on the issue of the ordination of women to the diaconate?

On this issue, there has not yet been a pronouncement from the magisterium as there has been on women priests. The current norms, however, and ecclesiastical practice restrict the diaconate to men. It’s true that in the early centuries of Christianity there were references to ‘deaconesses,’ but it would seem that they were not simply a female equivalent of male ‘deacons.’ For now, the permanent diaconate is restricted to men, but the question is still under study.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

QUAERITUR: concerning Notitiae and the 5th vol of the Liturgy of Hours

Recently I have had a couple questions which mention Notitiae.

Notitiae is the official publication of the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments.  In Notitiae the Congregation publishes editorials, scholarly studies, new liturgical texts, reports of plenary meetings, speeches or writings of the Holy Father pertaining to liturgy or liturgical law, official responses to questions called dubia.

Here is the first:

I was wondering if there are any online or otherwise searchable databases for the Notitiae from the CDW.  I’m doing some research this summer on the sacramental role of the deacon in the context of Mass, and wanted to see if any questions pertaining to my particular topic have been addressed by the Congregation.  I already know what the answers are to may of my questions, but I need to cross-check that with anything that has been officially stated by the Church.  Any thoughts?

My thoughts?  I wish there were a searchable database of Notitiae.

Don’t forget to consult the Holy See’s Directory for Deacons and also the searchable indices of the CD-ROM disks of L’Osservatore Romano.

This question also came by e-mail:

Dear Father,

Do you have any sense of when 1) the Liturgia Horarum 5th volume, currently in proof form according to Notitiae, might see the light of day, and 2) if there are any plans for a new edition of the basic 4 vols.?

My set is worn and weary from years of use and I am planning to purchase another, but would hold off if anything new is coming down the pike.

The questioner is referring to a volume which will be a supplement to the Latin edition of the post-Conciliar Liturgy of Hours, which replaced the Breviariarium Romanum.  Clerics, most religious and consecrated virgins are obliged to recite this each day.  Many lay people are beginning to recite it also, alone or in groups, to unite themselves in their own way with the Church’s official daily prayer.   You might think about prayer as divided into three types, liturgical (ecclesial), communal, and personal.  When the Liturgia horarum or Breviarium are used, people unite themselves with the entire Church which prays incessantly chasing and running before the sun in our planets whirlin’g sweep.

 

The old Breviarium and the newer Liturgia horarum are in four volumes, dividing the year but all having the same structure.

The Office of Readings, after the hymn and three psalms, has two readings, the first from Scripture, and the second from sub-Apostolic, Patristic, Conciliar texts, or works of doctors, saints and other spiritual writers.

The "5th" volume of the Liturgia horarum has been in preparation for some years.  It will not be so-much a further division of the liturgical year (I believe the Ambrosian volumes divide the year in 5 volumes), as a supplement to all four volumes.  The 5th volume will offer addtional optional readings for the Office of Reading… optional readings for second reading only, not the first.

I asked Cardinal Arinze about this volume yesterday evening (he was with us for a few days at a group of priests in an annual gathering).  The Cardinal Prefect responded that the Congregation is indeed working on the volume, that progress is being made.  It is very difficult to balance the right variety of readings, suitable for the occasions.  Also, it will be necessary to find the proper critical editions and then be sure the translations of the non-Latin texts are good.  It is a complicated process.

In any event, there is progress with the 5th volume.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
66 Comments

NCReporter: St. Louis Archdiocese videoed women’s ordination rite

Here is an interesting story from the ultra-lefty National Catholic Reporter.

My emphases and comments.

St. Louis Archdiocese videoed women’s ordination rite

By Tom Fox, NCR Staff
Published:
July 9, 2008

Rabbi Susan [I still don’t understand the whole female rabbi thing.]Talve, spiritual leader of Central Reform Congregation in St. Louis, welcomes worshipers for the ordination of two women last November.   (Photo by Karen Elshout)

The archdiocese of St. Louis authorized the video recording of a Catholic women’s ordination ceremony that took place in a synagogue last November. It then used the video, along with photographs apparently taken from the video, as evidence to punish [No… not evidence to punish, but rather evidence in the case of the necessity of any questions that might result.  In this case, questions were raised, a canonical process resulted, and someone was censured.] a Catholic nun who attended the liturgy, according to several people familiar with the case.

————
Update: Rabbi would have denied permission to record ordination
————

Sister of Charity Louise Lears was forced out of all church ministerial roles and banned from receiving sacraments within the archdiocese by an edict of St. Louis Archbishop Raymond Burke announced June 26.  [It’s called "interdict".]

The next day the archdiocese announced that Burke had been reassigned to a position at the Vatican as prefect of the church’s highest canonical court, the Apostolic Signatura.  [A fact which is entirely irrelevant to the case.]

Lears, 58, has been a member of the pastoral team at St. Cronan Parish in South St. Louis for the past three years, and a coordinator of religious education in the archdiocese.

She refused to be interviewed for this article. She is not speaking to the media.

However, several people familiar with the documents, prepared by the archdiocese that made up the case against her, strongly criticized what they called the “surveillance” video-taping.

One of the confidential archdiocesan documents, according to knowledgeable sources, was an affidavit giving permission to an individual to attend the ceremony in order to record it. The record of the ceremony is contained on two electronic discs in Lears’ file.

Rose Marie Dunn Hudson, on left, sings along with fellow womenpriest Bridget Mary Meehan of Pittsburgh, Pa. , center, during Hudson’s ordination at the Central Reform Congregattion last November. (Photo by Karen Elshout)  The file also contains close-up photographs of a name tag Lears was wearing during the ceremony. Her attendance at the November 2007 ordination held at the Central Reform Congregation, headed by Rabbi Susan Talve, was never a secret, according to Lears’ associates.

The ceremony drew some 600 people, among them several dozen women religious, according to people who attended the liturgy. Only Lears, however, was singled out by Burke.  [Perhaps she was the only one who was an employee of an Archdiocesan organization.]

“It was a surveillance video. That’s exactly what it was,” said Sean Collins, a co-pastoral associate of Lears at St. Cronan Parish until he resigned July 2nd, in part, he said, to speak about what he says has been a grave injustice taken against Lears.  [It sounds like there was a canonical process.  So, justice was served.]

“What disturbs me even more is that the video taping was premeditated,” [How else?] he said, referring to the affidavit authorizing it by the archdiocese. Collins did not see the document firsthand, but referred to others who had seen it.

“They clearly selected Louise from a congregation of some 600 people and of those 40 or 50 of them offered blessings,” [Offered blessings?   Waht does that mean, I wonder?] he said. “Of all of those who offered blessings only Louise has been singled out.”

NCR made several unsuccessful attempts to reach [Archbishop] Burke for comment through the archdiocese and the Apostolic Signatura in Rome, but he was unavailable. There is no evidence that Burke knew about or ordered the taping. However, Catholics familiar with the workings of the archdiocese say it would be unlikely it could have happened without his authorization.

John Terranova, executive director of the synagogue where the ceremony took place, said he did not recall the archdiocese asking permission to video the liturgy. “I cannot say we were aware that they were taping. If they chose to do that it was their choice.”

News of the planned ceremony at the time prompted outrage from archdiocesan officials — outrage that was directed both at the women aspiring to the Catholic priesthood and toward the woman rabbi who agreed to host the event.

Before the ceremony Burke wrote to Susan Talve, senior rabbi at the synagogue, urging her to revoke her offer of hospitality. Talve is the founding rabbi of Central Reform Congregation, a former president of the St. Louis Rabbinical Association and herself active in interfaith affairs.

Days before the liturgy Burke, in the archdiocesan newspaper, the St. Louis Review, also wrote a column reiterating the Catholic church’s official position that women cannot be ordained to the priesthood and that participation in any such liturgy would be a gravely sinful act. “Any Catholic,” he wrote, “who knowingly and deliberately assists… risks the eternal salvation of their souls.”

That threat is the apparent reason an archdiocesan affidavit was required to permit someone to attend and video the liturgy.

If Lears were to appeal her punishments through church channels her case could end up at the court that Burke now heads. However, he has said he would recuse himself from cases before the court in which he is involved.

The two Catholic women ordained in the synagogue were part of the Womenpriests movement, efforts by Roman Catholic [?] women to gain equality [NO!  This would be an injustice to them to propose that they can be ordained!  It is not an act of charity to lie.] of ministry within the Catholic church. They were Elsie Hainz McGrath, a retired writer and editor for a Catholic publishing house, and Rose Marie Dunn Hudson, a former teacher.

In March, Burke excommunicated the women.

Many people have speculated why Lears was singled out. Several said the reason might have been because she worked in an archdiocesan parish. Others said that McGrath and Hudson had been members of the St. Cronan Parish.

Tom Fox can be reached at tfox@ncronline.org

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
90 Comments

A word to biters of the consecrated hand

A friend just phoned to tell me about a discussion on a "trad" forum. 

I went there and read for a while.

In this discussion some people were publicly bad mouthing priests who have been celebrating the TLM and denigrating their ministry.

They claim these priests not Catholic enough, not fully or really Catholic.  Not Catholic like they are.

Thus, they who have no authority in the Church, laymen who have no jurisdiction, no credentials other than that they are hobbyists of the older form of the Roman Rite (sincere as their devotion may be), they who have read some encyclicals of popes of yesteryear, some books by authors zealous for Tradition, they who have no authority other than their conviction that no one else can be right or as Catholic as they are, turn with a snarl and bite the consecrated hand that feeds them Christ’s Body and forgives their sins. 

And this about some priests who have probably already forgotten more about liturgy and theology than they will ever know.  Priests who have suffered a great deal in their years of ministry at the hands even of Church officials because of their traditional convictions.

I am at an annual gathering of priests right now.  We have among other things discussed what it is like to minister to people who then turn on you.  How to work with that, with them.

Most of the time we are willing to have you keep bashing us, try to ruin our reputations, running us down.

But it does take its toll.

I say, if you chose to stay on this path, woe to you who raise your hands against the Lord’s anointed.

In taking this negative approach with and about your priests, you will not obtain your objectives.

Don’t expect them to be all warm and open to your suggestions when you do nothing but get in their faces and run them down behind their backs.

Mark my words, folks. 

If any of you have imbibed of this attitude, what I am describing above… mark my words, you are on a spiritually perilous course. 

You are putting your souls in danger of hell and causing scandal to others. 

You could also wind up ruining everything for others who also have your aspirations, but not your lack of prudence. 

Posted in Classic Posts, SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on A word to biters of the consecrated hand

Quiet days

I have been have a few quite days away from the Sabine Farm at a retreat center with quite a few priest friends.  It isn’t really a retreat, however.  It is more like an informal conference.

Each year we get together somewhere for four days, have a guest speaker (or one of us gives a talk). 

This year I gave a presentation on what Pope Benedict was really driving at in his address to the Curia in 2005 in which he used the phrases "hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture" and "hermeneutic of reform".  Pope Benedict is carrying on a bit of a polemic with a particular group of theologians.

Then we had some presentations on an aspect of the Catechism of the Catholic Church: there question/response dynamic built into the texts which, once recognized, helps us to explain the material and make it relevant.

Also, a couple days ago, Francis Card. Arinze joined us.  He’ll be speaking today on his experience of priesthood.

So, our mornings are busy, but in the afternoons and evening some of the guys will find a golf course or simply hang out talking.  

Tonight we are having a big cookout: steaks.

It is a great annual event, and though it isn’t a retreat, it is refreshing.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Quiet days

Your responses to my request for reflections on Summorum Pontificum

For the one year anniversary of the release of Summorum Pontificum, on 7 July, I asked you readers to post some of your own thoughts about what the Motu Proprio has meant to you, what the provisions have done for you, one way or another.

Your response has been generous and rich with interesting comments.

I warmly invite you to go over to that entry and spend some time reading through the responses. 

There are over 140 posted so far.

I am impressed and I think you will be too.

Thanks!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

TLM in Vancouver – follow up

I got this note via e-mail:

Dear Fr Zuhlsdorf,

Since you were so kind as to post a blog entry about the creation of the new personal parish for the traditional Mass in Vancouver, I thought you would be interested to know that we now have a website:  www.holyfamilyvancouver.ca

In the next couple of days we should be posting some photos of the inaugural Mass on the Feast of the Precious Blood, and also the full text of the Archbishop’s decree establishing the parish, which is a grand document showing a clear understanding of the Holy Father’s intentions for the motu proprio.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Watching the death of a Church?

I have to ask….

Is there anyone in the Anglican Communion really thinking that the Church of England, etc., will be taken more seriously if they consecrate woman as bishops?

The theologicai hermeneutic for the Anglican Communion seems to be the latest social trend.

When the next thing comes along…. say… polygamy or blessing pedophilia.  

As the social trends push on them, they cave in and nothing in Scripture in going to hold them back from caving in? 

Is this how they are going?

Like astronomers watching a sta go black, are we watching the death of a Church?

As I muse on these things, I open my mail to see the following from our friend, Fr. Dwight Longenecker:

As a former Anglican priest I am covering the Anglican crisis in some detail on my blog.

I have just posted advice for Anglican priests seeking to convert. I have included a free offer of my book, The Path to Rome–Modern Journeys to the Catholic Church. This is a book of mostly Anglican conversion stories.

To help in this ecumenical and evangelistic endeavor would you please put something about this on your blog? I know a good number of traditionalist Anglicans read your blog and it might offer them some encouragement and help.

Dictum factum.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
93 Comments

Appointments of interest

Today we read that H.E. David L. Ricken, formerly of Cheyenne, WY, is now the new bishop of Green Bay, WI.

Also, as per the rumor reported yesterday, H.E. Angelo Amato, SBD, is now the new Prefect of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints.

Fr. Luis Francisco Ladaria Ferrer, SJ, takes Archbp Amato’s place as Secretary of the Cong. for Doctrine of the Faith.

No word yet on Divine Worship.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments