Holy See: more on admission of homosexuals to seminaries – “What part of ‘No’ didn’t you understand?”

A friend sent me something from L’Osservatore Romano which you may find very interesting.

What follows was a Rescriptum ex audientia.  This means that someone went in to meet with the Pope, asked a question which was also a written question probably submitted ahead of time, and obtained the response to that question in the meeting.  A rescript was usually something written on the same piece of paper with the query and then sent back, for the sake of brevity.  Simple things are handled simply.  The obvious doesn’t need a complicated process – thus the rescript.

In this case the rescript is a note from the Secretariate of State.  So, someone very high up, perhaps Card. Bertone, goes into the Pope to discuss their usual stack of stuff, and this question comes to the surface.

So what does the rescript say?

Here is the Italian first:

In riferimento al Documento della Congregazione per l’Educazione Cattolica ‘Istruzione circa i criteri di discernimento vocazionale riguardo alle persone con tendenze omosessuali in vista della loro ammissione al Seminario e agli Ordini sacri’, pubblicato dal menzionato Dicastero il 4 novembre 2005, e in seguito a numerose richieste di chiarimento giunte alla Sede Apostolica, si precisa che le disposizioni contenute in detta Istruzione valgono per tutte le Case di formazione al sacerdozio, comprese quelle che dipendono dai Dicasteri per le Chiese Orientali, per l’Evangelizzazione dei Popoli e per gli Istituti di Vita Consacrata e le Società di Vita Apostolica.

Il Sommo Pontefice, il giorno 8 del mese di aprile dell’anno del Signore 2008, ha approvato tale precisazione

Here is my translation:

In reference to the Document of the Congregation for Catholic Education, ‘Instruction Concerning the Criteria for the Discernment of Vocations with regard to Persons with Homosexual Tendencies in view of their Admission to the Seminary and to Holy Orders‘, published by the aforementioned Dicastery on 4 November 2005, and in consequence of numerous requests for clarification which have reached the Apostolic See, it state precisely that the dispositions contained in said Instruction are in force for all the houses of formation for the priesthood, including those which [juridically] depend on the Dicasteries for Oriental Churches, for the Evangelization of Peoples, and for the Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life.

The Supreme Pontiff, on the 8th day of April of the year of the Lord of 2008 approved this clarification.

Interesting no?

What does the rescript really say? 

First, a "house of formation" is basically a seminary.

Obviously some people out there didn’t want to accept the clear meaning of the the document from the Cong. for Catholic Education which says that men with deep seated homosexual tendencies, not just fleeting ideas, etc., should not be admitted to seminary. 

So, they wrote to the Holy See, "But Holy Father! But Holy Father!", I am sure they wrote, "This document from the Congregation can’t possibly apply to uusss!  After all, our seminary isn’t a diocesan seminary.  We have a _________ seminary!" 

Fill in the blank with

1) "seminary for Eastern Catholic priests, run by an eparchy, etc." – which falls under the jurisdiction of the Cong. for Oriental Churches
2) "seminary run not by a diocese, but one for priests destined for missionary service" – under Propaganda Fidei
3) "seminary for a religious order or institute"  – under the Cong. for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life

Basilically, what this clarification from the Pope does is day, there is no seminary in the world where this does not apply.

Homosexuals must not be admitted to any seminary in the world.  Period.

The aforementioned document from the Congregation for Catholic Education must be applied to all seminaries everywhere.  Just do it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
24 Comments

Feeder report

Hurray!

Feeder report

Feeder report

UPDATE:

Behold … the American Goldfinch or Carduelis tristis.

Feeder report

Perhaps he is sad, tristis, because he isn’t an Indigo?

You would think that tristis might a better name for this "blue" Bunting.

I have at least two of these now, both males.  I haven’t seen an females yet. 

Feeder report

Now here we have the orange variant of the House Finch, or Carpodacus mexicanus.

Feeder report

Remember what I said about the Goldfinch Eating Team?

Feeder report

There were six hangning around on the socks a little later, and two on the feeder.

I am going to have to put my donation button on the bird entires just to keep their greedy little beaks busy.

Feeder report

Here is the confirmation that I have at least two male Indigo Buntings.

But I think there is another.  Just after shooting this I went into the kitchen and out of the window I saw another.

Feeder report

Also, I found that Mr. Red-Breasted Grosbeak had taken the Missus out to supper.

Notice how much smaller the sparrow is.

Feeder report

And batting cleanup is the Mourning Dove, Zeniada macroura.

Feeder report

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Benedict XVI in Savona

The Holy Father is celebrating Mass right now in Savona.

Nearly over.

Benedict XVI in Savona

The choir is singing Mozart’s Ave verum Corpus.

Benedict XVI in Savona

Benedict XVI in Savona

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

Benedict XVI in Savona 

NB: Altar Cross in the center and 7th candle right by It. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

PODCAzT 61: Pope Leo I on a post-Pentecost weekday; Fr. Z rambles not quite aimlessly for a while

PODCAzT 61: Pope Leo I on a post-Pentecost weekday; Fr. Z rambles not quite aimlessly for a whileToday is Saturday in the Octave of Pentecost, or at least it ought to be in in the Novus Ordo as it is in the older, Traditional Roman Calendar. 

This is the sixth and final PODCAzT for the Pentecost Octave. 

Sermon 80 of St. Leo the Great (+442), was preached on one of the fast days in the week after Pentecost. It is incredibly short, so we hear it in its entirety in English first and then in Latin.  I give some pointers for how to listen to both the English and what to listen for in the Latin as well.

Please forgive me for a slip… I forget what century we are presently in.  Oh well…

Then,
I just ramble.  More than I usually do, that is.  I wasn’t even going to make this PODCAzT today, but at the last said… what the heck.  So, I look around at the books on my desk and pick things up and just start talking, and creating links between them and what pops into my mind.  This is a bit of an experiment.

For music,
we have Come, Holy Ghost from the Choir of Queen’s College, Oxford, then O, Come Holy Spirit by the King’s Consort, then Veni Creator Spiritus by a whole bunch of Franciscans.  Toward the end we hear Veni Sancte Spiritus again from Queen’s College. To wrap it up, Veni Sancte Spiritus, the whole thing, the Sequence in Gregorian Chant sung by the Norbertines at Sant’Antimo in Italy. 

PODCAzT 61: Pope Leo I on a post-Pentecost weekday; Fr. Z rambles not quite aimlessly for a while

https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/08_05_17.mp3

 

08-05-17 Leo post-Pentecost; Fr. Z rambles

Posted in Patristiblogging, PODCAzT, SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

MINI MOVIE REVIEW: Prince Caspain

I went to see Prince Caspian, the next movie in the Narnia series.

There were good moments.

But there were times when I asked myself if something was going to happen, if it was going to end.

The special effects were great.  However, there were moments when they were very obviously effects.

Also, I really wanted more in WWII England. And didn’t get it.  I feel cheated.

Script: I think the book was Disneyed.

Actors: Well… they had to use the same actors.  I am thinking perhaps we may see Edmund and Lucy again.  I think little Lucy is the most talented of the young people. 

Lucy… light… Dante…. hmmm… I digress.

The sort-of bad guys, Telmarines ("over the far away sea", right?), obviously mislead by a guy with an Islamic sounding name "Miraz", need conversion.  They eventually get it, but… the imagery…  the imagery….

They are dressed sort of like Conquistadors.  Problem, right?  They are Spaniards and with a strong Moorish influence, or so it seemed to me.  They bear a symbol, and 8-pointed star, which could be Christian or Muslim. 

What is going on?  Organized religion gone bad?  Disney intervening?  Dunno.

So, what are we dealing with here: natural religion of happy trees and animals, being "spiritual", as opposed to some religions which is more established?  More organized?

I’m just asking. 

I will be glad to read your own comments on the movie. 

See it if you want.

But if Ironman is showing at the same cinema….

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
47 Comments

Prayer request – ordination

In your kindness please pray for Rev. Mr. Jeffrey Moore, who tomorrow will be ordained a priest.

I would love to have been there, but just couldn’t manage. 

However, as St. Augustine said, where there is charity there are no distances.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

Am I blue? You’d be too … were you a Passerina cyanea

I have caught a better shot of Mr. Indigo, not to be confused with Mr. Indigo Jones of Shakespeare’s time, methinks.  This is Mr. Bunting, Passerina cyanea.

He seems to be object of Mr. Chirping Sparrow Spizella passerina‘s envy.

Am I blue? You'd be too ... were you a Passerina cyanea

Hmmm… about which would Catullus have written, I wonder?

Am I blue? You'd be too ... were you a Passerina cyanea

Also, we have had a visit from Mr. Brown-Headed Cowbird, Molothrus ater, who doesn’t seem to give a damn about anything but eating.

Am I blue? You'd be too ... were you a Passerina cyanea

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

PODCAzT 60: Pentecost customs; St. Ambrose on the dew of the Holy Spirit

PODCAzT 60: Pentecost customs; St. Ambrose on the dew of the Holy SpiritToday is Friday in the Octave of Pentecost, or at least it ought to be in in the Novus Ordo as it is in the older, Traditional Roman Calendar. 

This is the fifth PODCAzT for the Pentecost Octave. 

Thanks to your feedback for the last couple days.  Stats dropped yesterday, so this may be the last one.

Today we will look at some customs associated with Pentecost, very beautiful.  These customs informed the rhythm of people’s lives for centuries.

Then we will drill into the image of the dew of the Holy Spirit (which some bishops sadly think people are too thick to understand and therefore want to eliminate the image from liturgical translations…).  To help we enlist the help of a very wise Bishop, the great Ambrose of Milan (+397) who always tried to explain hard things to his people rather than make them out to be too stupid to get the point.  Ambrose wrote a work On the Holy Spirit in which he explains the dew that descended on Gideon’s fleece in the Book of Judges.  So, we will hear Judges 6 and 7 and then Ambrose allegorical commentary.  Fascinating stuff, I can tell you.

This reading from Scripture and the patristic commentary, gives you a sense of how some of the Father’s worked with Scripture and how their reflections can be useful for us today.

Of course, I have lots of comments along the way.

For music,
we have an antiphon for Pentecost in Gregorian chant, and a bitter sweet song Dancing at Whitsun, a folk song, which speaks of the rhythm of our lives and the challenges we endure.  There is a Fastasia super Kom, Heiliger Geist BWV 651 by J.S. Bach on the pipe organ, which Holy Church recommends above all other instruments.  We hear a haunting Byzantine Communion for mid-Pentecost, in other words this very week and at the end a real change of pace, which you can listen to yourselves.

Again, your the listening stats and your feedback will determine if I make another tomorrow.PODCAzT 60: Pentecost customs; St. Ambrose on the dew of the Holy Spirit


https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/08_05_16.mp3

 

08-05-16: Pentecost customs; St. Ambrose on the dew of the Holy Spirit

Posted in Patristiblogging, PODCAzT, SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Let’s get the famous quote right, please?

I am so tired of people misquoting this famous phrase from Hamlet.

When Hamlet asks his mother Queen Gertrude how she like his play, The Mousetrap, obviously tweeked, she says:

The lady doth protest too much, methinks.
  – Hamlet III, ii, 230

Also, let’s try to use it correctly.  

Say it a few times outloud to yourself, to get it into your ears.

Also, that "protest," here, doesn’t mean "object to".  It means "make a strong claim" about something.  We still have that meaning in English "protestation".

What Gertrude means is not that the lady in Hamlet’s play within the play, is objecting to something or denying something.  Rather, that she is making far too enthusiastic positive statements.

And don’t add useless syllables like "protestest" or "methinketh" or other stupidities. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments

New Sabine guest! Oooo … look at the colors

I have been watching the feeder on an off and had a real surprise!

First, a second pair of Red Breasted Grosbeaks has come around.

This is a rather motely fellow.  He isn’t as well marked.  Perhaps he is young.

I have seen also his Mrs. Motley Grosbeak but I don’t have her photo yet.

New Sabine guest! Oooo ... look at the colors

The House Finch is frequently around.

New Sabine guest! Oooo ... look at the colors
 
Just to show that the Red Bellied Woodpecker does indeed have a red belly.

New Sabine guest! Oooo ... look at the colors

But the big surprise was this very cautious bird I haven’t been able to shoot clearly.

He just turned up this afternoon.  I hope to see him in the morning, when the sun is on the feeder.

When he took off and went into the light, his color was amazing.

New Sabine guest! Oooo ... look at the colors

New Sabine guest! Oooo ... look at the colors

This is, I believe, Indigo Bunting!

I will keep the lens trained.

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments