MUST READ: Ed Peters on Bp. Galantino about “expressionless persons praying rosaries outside abortion clinics”

I wanted everyone to see this.

You remember the remarks made about those “expressionless” people reciting Rosaries outside abortion clinics by the Secretary of the Italian Bishops conference, His Excellency Most Rev. Nunzio Galantino.  I wrote about that HERE.

Ed Peters, who has no combox, weighed in, at his blog, which you should visit:

About those embarrassing pro-lifers

Even though, as a general rule, the leadership of national episcopal conferences is elected by member bishops (c. 452), in Italy (long story made short) the pope personally appoints conference leaders. Pope Francis appointed Bp. Nunzio Galantino as Secretary General of Italian bishop’s conference a couple months ago.

Galantino is calling for a “taboo-free discussion” of priestly celibacy, administration of holy Communion to divorced-and-remarried Catholics, and homosexuality (sic: homosexual acts?). His call for a ‘taboo-free discussion’ of these topics suggests, of course, that, till now, their discussion has been hindered by taboos, or at least, that Galantino thinks they have been discussed only amid taboos. I suggest the first implication is false; the second, necessarily, mistaken. Passing familiarity with the Catholic literature that each of these topics has generated over the centuries should be enough to dispel allegations of “taboos” in their regard except perhaps in the minds of some who dislike the Church’s position on one or more of these topics.

But it is Galantino’s gratuitous remark about “expressionless persons praying rosaries outside abortion clinics” that attracts my attention. I worry when ranking prelates disparage the simple and prayerful piety that some lay faithful show even before the Gates of Death.

I prayed my first rosary outside an abortuary in 1978. I don’t recall what my expression was, but I doubt I was smiling. I have prayed many rosaries outside of many abortion mills since then, have picketed them, side-walk witnessed at them, passed out literature around them, and even drove two women (who had showed up for abortions) to pro-life agencies where they sought assistance toward sparing their babies from abortion. I probably smiled on those two days.

At the same time—even though usually things are quiet (deathly quiet) outside an abortion chamber—I have nevertheless also been screamed at by clinic personnel, cursed at by passers-by, drenched in the rain, had a brick tossed over a wall at me, and once watched a driver gesture the ‘trigger finger’ at me. But even if I had the presence of mind to rejoice at these insults borne for the sake of the least of His children, I’m pretty sure I did not show it on my face. I wonder, does every feeling need to be shown? And what exactly should one feel outside a death chamber?

In any case, if my expressionless demeanor at prayer outside an abortuary has ever embarrassed anyone, I apologize. It’s just that I am still fazed at the very thought that, hardly 20 paces from where I stand, a baby is being sliced to ribbons. + + +

Update: Well put, John Smeaton.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, HONORED GUESTS, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged , , , , ,
51 Comments

ASK FATHER: Gifts for new deacons and priests

‘Tis the season for ordinations!

I am getting lots of questions about what to give the newly ordained.

First and foremost, cash and gift cards are always welcome. It doesn’t seem very personal, but unless you are pretty close to the ordinand, well… I’ll put this delicately… we don’t mind one little bit.

For my next ordinations… as if that’s going to happen!… I’ll take ammo.  Thanks in advance.

If you are looking for a book, try The Spirit of the Liturgy by Joseph Ratzinger, though there is a strong chance that he’ll have it already.  Another thought is something I have been reading during the last few days.  I think it is going to be a great go-to tool in the future, as it provides excellent arguments, responses, and quotes.  ASK FATHER: Gifts for new deacons and priestsI am already thinking about how I can mine it for upcoming talks. Non-Negotiable: Essential Principles of a Just Society and Humane Culture by Sheila Liaugminas.  It is new, so it is unlikely that he’ll have it.

If you go for books, and one link will lead to another, please use my amazon search box.

A gift certificate for your local clerical/religious goods store could work.  He is going to have to buy some clerical stuff along the way.

You can perhaps do something collectively. A small group could give something larger, such as a set of Roman vestments or a 1962 Missale Romanum, the missal of St. John XXIII.

If you are in doubt, if you don’t know where a shop is, if you have no idea what you are doing, and even though you may in fact have a good clerical shop near where you live, in these USA you can always get good help from John in church goods at Leaflet Missal Company in St. Paul, MN.  He is as traditional as you would ever want, and he can get his hands on just about anything and ship it.   You can waste time running around wringing your hands, looking for a place, or you can make a few calls and get the job done.  And the people at Leaflet are super.  They even give seminarians jobs during the summer if they need them.

And there are always 5 pound packs of Mystic Monk Coffee and other things from their swag store.  HERE  And there is my swag store too!  HERE

Perhaps the readers would like to chime in to say what they have recently, or no so recently, given to the newly ordained.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests, Priests and Priesthood, Seminarians and Seminaries | Tagged , ,
25 Comments

Your Sunday Sermon Notes

It’s back! My not so subtle way of poking you to pay close attention to the sermons you hear on Sunday, so that when there is a good point, you can relate it to others succinctly.

So.

Was there a good point in the sermon you heard during the Mass that fulfilled your Sunday obligation?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

My View For Awhile: Bye for now, KC

It was a quick trip, too quick, but duty calls.

20140517-185328.jpg

As I leave Kansas City, I thank my amiable hosts, whose son was, today, ordained a deacon.  They always try to provide the best for the weary clerical guest.

20140517-162501.jpg

Thanks to Fr. Fongemie of the FSSP at St. Rose Philippine Duchesne on the Kansas side.  They gave me a great tour of their “new” church, which was a recovered Lutheran church.

20140517-162529.jpg

A wonderful rescued altar from a church in Scranton.

20140517-162542.jpg

Then some of us did some shooting, which was a gas.

20140517-162620.jpg

This was my first time to give a couple 1911s a try.  I also enjoyed very much the Uzi, on full auto.  

Later, we got out a real AK-47, an older one with the fully cast lower, and… the greatest pleasure of the day, an M1 Garand, Korean War vintage!  When I heard that distinctive “ting” at the end, I said a prayer for vets who put their lives at risk overseas and hauled this rifle around over hill and dale, in bitter cold and savage heat, in boredom and terror, to protect our freedom and the lives of so many strangers. I want more time with that one someday.

A friend showed me a sampling of his collection of rescued relics.  Astonishing.

20140517-185459.jpg

20140517-185510.jpg

And…

20140517-185433.jpg

Oppps… sorry. That last one was at my other friend’s house. Got in there by accident.

This is what I wanted to post. One of St. John Vianney’s amices, which I once wore for Mass.

20140517-185531.jpg

At the ordination, I had the pleasure of talking for a while with His Excellency Most Rev. Robert Finn, Bishop of Kansas City-St. Joseph.  He is a real father to the seminarians and the younger priests of the diocese, who are growing in number.  Very good men.  I was impressed with them.  In his sermon, Bp. Finn reminded the men never to doubt the power of supernatural graces as they fulfill their mission in the Church.  Also, he told them that defilement and avarice are tantamount to the worship of a false god.

Bp. Finn was in good spirits after the ordination. We chatted about a mutual acquaintance, and had a chuckle or two.

20140517-162704.jpg

The new deacon, and two cold war warriors from the Compuserve days of the COL Forum!

20140517-190238.jpg

Finally, because everyone wants to know…. yes… BBQ!

The best I have ever had.

20140517-162605.jpg

You can’t beat a sign like this:

20140517-185418.jpg

I look forward to my next stop in KC!

Posted in On the road, Priests and Priesthood, Seminarians and Seminaries, SESSIUNCULA, What Fr. Z is up to | Tagged , , , , , ,
9 Comments

WDTPRS 5th Sunday of Easter (2002MR) – eternity and sempiternity are different

Sunday’s Collect for the Ordinary Form was not in a previous edition of the Roman Missal. A precedent is found in the Sacramentarium Bergomense.

COLLECT:
Omnipotens sempiterne Deus,
semper in nobis paschale perfice sacramentum
ut, quos sacro baptismate dignatus es renovare,
sub tuae protectionis auxilio multos fructus afferant,
et ad aeternae vitae gaudia pervenire concedas.

LITERAL VERSION:
Almighty eternal God,
perfect in us always the paschal mystery,
so that those whom You deigned to renew by means of sacred baptism,
may under the aid of Your protection bear many fruits,
and that You will grant them to attain unto the joys of eternal life.

OBSOLETE ICEL (1973):
Father,
may we whom you renew in baptism
bear witness to our faith by the way we live.
By the suffering, death, and resurrection of your Son
may we come to eternal joy
.

CURRENT ICEL (2011):
Almighty ever-living God,
constantly accomplish the Paschal Mystery within us,
that those you were pleased to make new in Holy Baptism
may, under your protective care, bear much fruit
and come to the joys of life eternal
.

Perfice as the imperative “perfect” has the force of “bring to completion”. It could be perceived as “perfect” in an instant of time, by a sudden and all embracing act, or it could be construed as being an ongoing process of perfection, of bringing to completion. In a way the Paschale Mystery itself (remember that mysterium and sacramentum are pretty much interchangeable in these contexts) reflects this same problem of our perception of time and God’s work in time, or outside of time, or beyond time. The Paschal Mystery is both completed and not completed. Our redemption is “already” completed, but “not yet” completed. As Christians we live in this pilgrim life, this earthly continuum, in a constant state of “already but not yet”.

We have some time to look at the word sempiterne.

This is a vocative form of sempiternus, a, um. In philosophy and theology (mostly indistinguishable in ancient times through late antiquity) there has been constant effort to figure out time and God’s relationship to time. In this prayer sempiternus is simply the equivalent of aeternus, “eternal”. Scripture has innumerable references to God being aeternus and it is associated with God’s unchanging nature. There are some 50 or so prayers in the Ordinary Form missal which begin with today’s formula and many that start with aeterne Deus.

Even though the words are pretty much interchangeable in our prayers, eternity and sempiternity are really different concepts.

Eternity can be thought of different ways.

First, eternity can be completely independent of time. Something eternal in this sense is entirely outside of time. St. Augustine, who was a Neoplatonist in this sense, thought of God this way.

Another eternity is everlastingness. It has no beginning or end. This is what we call sempiternity. That is to say, it exists at “all points in time”.

This is a great simplification of a millennial discussion, but it can give you a quick glimpse into this language of prayer.

The Greeks, from Parmeides to Plato to Plotinus all wrote about eternity. Christian ideas of eternity were explored by authors like St. Augustine (+430), Boethius (+c.526), Eriugena (+c.877), St. Anselm (+1109), St. Thomas Aquinas (+1274).

When we say in these prayers that God is sempiternus we do not thereby believe as Catholics that God is “everlasting” in the sense of being in time, that is all points of time, but without beginning or end. God is eternal in the sense of being beyond time, entirely transcending time.

Finally, there is in this prayer a reference to John 15:16:

“Non vos me elegistis sed ego elegi vos et posui vos ut eatis et fructum adferatis et fructus vester maneat ut quodcumque petieritis Patrem in nomine meo det vobis… You have not chosen me: but I have chosen you; and have appointed you, that you should go and should bring forth fruit; and your fruit should remain: that whatsoever you shall ask of the Father in my name, he may give it you.”

By the way, in the 1970 editio typica of the Missale Romanum the Collect is:

Deus, per quem nobis et redemptio venit et praestatur adoptio,
filios dilectionis tuae benignus intende,
ut in Christo credentibus
et vera tribuatur libertas et hereditas aeterna.

In other words, the Collect was changed for the 2002 edition.

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, WDTPRS | Tagged ,
8 Comments

Samuel Gregg on two manifestations of Walter Card. Kasper

I direct the readership’s attention to a good piece by my friend Samuel Gregg in which he takes a close look at Walter Card. Kasper’s newest book about mercy.

Kasper’s book is not, apparently, what one might assume it is.

However, Kasper is sending contradictory messages out through the mainstream media, in interviews, talks, etc.

How to reconcile these two, seemingly disparate Kaspers?  Gregg has some ideas.  I think he is on to something.

HERE

Posted in One Man & One Woman, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged , , ,
35 Comments

Of Masses Pontifical (D. Providence) and Solemn (D. Sacramento)

It will not be stopped.

This is a little late in the posting, but I thought you would like to see a couple success stories.

First, my friend Fr. Jay Finelli, “iPadre”, sent photos of a Pontifical Mass celebrated by Bp. Matano of Rochester at the request of Most Rev. Thomas Tobin, the local bishop, in the Cathedral of Providence.  Fr. Finelli writes:

We had our Solemn High Pontifical Mass yesterday. All went well. The cathedral holds 1,500 people and it was almost packed tight. … I was deacon of the Mass. Far from perfect, but Bishop’s Gelineau and Mulvee told me I did a fine job. [Let us not make the perfect the enemy of the good!] Thanks to my week at St. John Cantius. [Aren’t they great?] I could not have done it without that week.

Of Masses Pontifical (D. Providence) and Solemn (D. Sacramento)

Of Masses Pontifical (D. Providence) and Solemn (D. Sacramento)

More on Flicker HERE

Also, after the West Coast Marian Procession there was a Solemn Mass with the Missale Romanum of St. John XXIII.

A multitude of Catholic faithful from all over California and other states participated at the 6th Annual Great Marian Procession West Coast last May 3, 2014. The three mile processional walk started at the East Lawn Memorial Park and ended at the Cathedral of the Blessed Sacrament in downtown Sacramento, California where a Solemn High Mass in the Extraordinary Form was celebrated with His Excellency, Auxiliary Bishop Myron J. Cotta, in choro. The Mass was sung by the Choir and Choristers of St. Stephen the First Martyr Parish, which has been entrusted as a personal parish to the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP). The next Annual Marian Procession West Coast will take place on May 2, 2015. For future updates, be sure to visit http://www.BringMary.com.

Attached are few photos taken from the event. The rest can be viewed on our blog post, which includes full-length videos of both the Procession and Solemn High Mass

Of Masses Pontifical (D. Providence) and Solemn (D. Sacramento)

Everyone… WORK WORK WORK!

Fr. Z Kudos to the good people in Providence and Sacramento.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick, Fr. Z KUDOS, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Mail from priests, One Man & One Woman, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , ,
14 Comments

Fishwrap supports coalition of heretics asking Pope to apologize

Fishwrap supports coalition of heretics asking Pope to apologizeThe catholic Left will turn on Pope Francis when they finally realize that he is not going to conform to their liberal and heretical notions and agenda.   The cracks are already appearing.  Most liberals have been gushing about him since his election, because they took his folksy style and lack of papal decorum as a sign that he is a fellow traveller.   But this Pope is not going to, for example, give approval to the ordination of women.  He is not going to smile on gnostic ravings.  He is not going to give the nod to moving beyond Jesus.

And so today we read in at the Fishwrap (aka The National Schismatic Reporter) that a coalition has formed asking Pope Francis… get this… to apologize to the LCWR and to Sr. Elizabeth Johnson!

And the Fishwrap is supporting this.

My emphases:

Coalition calls for papal apology to U.S. sisters
Brian Roewe

An open letter to the pope has asked for an apology to U.S. women religious and an intervention on their behalf in their ongoing reform discussions with the Vatican’s doctrinal congregation.
It was with “respect and gratitude” but also “concern and dismay” that The Nun Justice Project, a coalition of 16 progressive U.S. Catholic organizations, wrote Pope Francis Thursday regarding recent comments from Cardinal Gerhard Müller to the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. The organization, representing more than 90 percent of U.S. congregations of Catholic women religious, is currently under a reform mandate from the Müller-headed Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

[…]

In addition to the letter, the coalition has asked supporters to sign an online petition. As of Thursday afternoon, more than 800 people had signed. The Nun Justice Project also urged people to Tweet “We stand with the Sisters” to the pope, as well as mail him copies of their letter and Spanish copies Johnson’s books Consider Jesus and Quest for the Living God.

The coalition includes the American Catholic Council; Association of Roman Catholic Womenpriests; Call To Action; DignityUSA; FutureChurch; National Coalition of American Nuns; New Ways Ministry; Voice of the Faithful; and Women’s Ordination Conference.

The full Nun Justice Project letter is as follows:

Dear Pope Francis
We write with respect and gratitude for your extraordinary leadership in our Church.

Fishwrap supports coalition of heretics asking Pope to apologizeSadly, we also write with concern and dismay at the behavior that Cardinal Gerhard Müller recently exhibited toward women leaders of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (LCWR) and especially toward Dr. Elizabeth Johnson CSJ.

Cardinal Müller’s preemptive public criticism of LCWR leadership and Dr. Johnson, one of the most beloved and respected theologians in the world, [HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA!] eclipsed any opportunity for public dialogue.

This communicates that faithful Catholic female leaders are disrespected and discounted in our Church.

On numerous occasions you have expressed a desire to expand leadership opportunities for women. We respectfully suggest that the place to begin is to listen to faithful women who are already exercising leadership.

We ask you to personally [split infinitives] intervene with Cardinal Müller and Archbishop Sartain and remove the unjust mandates imposed on LCWR over two years ago.

In addition, a public apology to Dr. Johnson and LCWR leadership would speak volumes about the institutional Church’s intent to truly listen to women and honor their voices.

In closing, we express our love and solidarity with you as together we joyfully proclaim the rich diversity revealed in the Good News of Jesus Christ, a message ever ancient yet ever new.

Sincerely yours,

The Nun Justice Project
American Catholic Council
Association of Roman Catholic Womenpriests
Catholics Speak Out / Quixote Center
Call To Action
CORPUS
DignityUSA
Federation of Christian Ministries/RCFCC
FutureChurch
National Coalition of American Nuns
New Ways Ministry
Pax Christi Maine
RAPPORT
Roman Catholic Womenpriests – USA
Southeastern Pennsylvania Women’s Ordination Conference
Voice of the Faithful
Women’s Ordination Conference

I think it is interesting that the Fishwrap is giving its support to those organizations in a contumacious attempt to make the Vicar of Christ apologize for the defense of Christian doctrine.

Remember: They will settle for nothing less than the ordination of women.  That’s their unholy grail… cup… thing.

Fishwrap supports coalition of heretics asking Pope to apologize

Posted in Francis, Magisterium of Nuns, Our Catholic Identity, Women Religious | Tagged , , , , ,
64 Comments

My View For Awhile: KC Edition

I am on my way to Kansas City, where everything is up-to-date.

20140515-124058.jpg

It is ordination season, and the son of a friend, whom I have know since he was about knee high to a boll wevil… just gettin’ into the mood… is to be raised to the dignity of the diaconate by the laying on of the hands of His Excellency Most Reverend Robert Finn, by the grace of God bishop of the place.

No, there will not be a blognic. This is a quick trip and my “free” time, isn’t.

UPDATE:

Second leg.

20140515-143239.jpg

I was pleased to find a Chick-fil-a (sp?) near my gate. Their plain sandwich is great!

UPDATED:

Having arrived at the house, preprandial libations are for the mixing and shaking together.

I haven’t had this sort of this before. I am somewhat more conservative. But it seems interesting.

20140515-175439.jpg

20140515-175527.jpg

It’s Fleet Week!

20140515-180835.jpg

Posted in On the road, Seminarians and Seminaries, What Fr. Z is up to |
21 Comments

Wherein Fr. Z thanks Michael Sean Winters for support of all Pope Francis says

I’d like to thank Michael Sean Winters of the National Schismatic Reporter (the journal of record for all things schismatic, aka Fishwrap) for summarizing some points I made recently about the Holy Father’s remarks to a UN delegation, including his comment about “legitimate redistribution of economic benefits by the State”.  HERE

For Winters, everything the Pope says is to be taken seriously (= accepted).  As MSW wrote:

Where to begin? Yes, Fr. Zuhlsdorf, many of us continue to take the Holy Father seriously on this and every topic.

I am gratified to read this from one of Fishwrap’s most prolific contributors!

I am delighted that MSW accepts and is ready to defend what Pope Francis wrote to Archbp. Marchetto:

I once told you, dear Archbishop Marchetto, and today I wish to repeat it, that I consider you to be the best interpreter of the Second Vatican Council. I know that this is a gift from God, but I also know that you made it bear fruit.

I am glad that MSW throws his considerable weight in to support, against all naysayers, what Pope Francis wrote to Card. Brandmüller, that is, His Holiness’ explicit endorsement of Benedict XVI’s “hermeneutic of continuity”:

Harking closely to the same Spirit, Holy Church in this age renews and meditates on the most abundant doctrine of the Council of Trent. In fact, the “hermeneutic of renewal” which Our Predecessor Benedict XVI explained in 2005 before the Roman Curia, refers in no way less to the Council of Trent than to the Vatican Council. To be sure, this mode of interpretation places under a brighter light a beautiful characteristic of the Church which is taught by the Lord Himself: “She is a ‘subject’ which increases in time and develops, yet always remaining the same, the one subject of the journeying People of God” (Address of His Holiness Benedict XVI to the Roman Curia offering them his Christmas greetings – 22 December 2005).

Far from “explaining away” what Pope Francis wrote, above, MSW will now adopt Francis’ positions as his own.  How could he do less after writing:

[I]t is precisely the fact that Pope Francis does not need a translator, that his meaning is quite clear, that it cannot be explained away, is what has the right all concerned.

Welcome aboard, MSW!

UPDATE:

Check out Breitbart HERE.

Posted in Francis, Liberals, Lighter fare, Linking Back, Reading Francis Through Benedict | Tagged ,
6 Comments