QUAERITUR: Is liturgical dance legitimate?

Liturgical Dance Free ZoneFrom a reader:

I have been Catholic for two and a half years and today I went to theparish I attend to become a RCIA sponser. The subject of LiturgicslDance came up and I was informed that it is a perfectly ligetimatething to do durring the Liturgy. Is this True?

I have been Catholic for two and a half years and today I went to theparish I attend to become a RCIA sponser. The subject of LiturgicslDance came up and I was informed that it is a perfectly ligetimatething to do durring the Liturgy. Is this True?

I would like to see in the rubrics where the dancers are to come in.

Aside from that, I open the floor to the readers to respond.

Let’s keep it above the level of “they are poopy-heads for doing that”.

Along the line, inculturation, continuity, and the rite have to be dealt with.

And let’s leave aside for the moment issues of good taste.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
70 Comments

Wm. Oddie on reception of the new translation

In the UK’s best Catholic weekly, The Catholic Herald, the indomiable William Oddie has comments about the first Sunday Mass with the new, corrected translation.

I like this bit:

Well, the new translation of the Mass is now up and running, and, at least in my parish, its launch seems to have passed off without any awkwardness at all. “And with your spirit” was confidently and (as far as I could see) unanimously declared, as though the congregation had been saying it for years (phone conversations, however, have elicited a certain difficulty elsewhere in remembering to say it. Maybe the most important thing to remember is to keep your eyes on the card). There was a real sense of occasion, I thought. We began, slightly shakily, using James MacMillan’s very splendid setting (used at the beatification last year), and the process of getting people’s heads around it has begun. All in all, it was a great occasion.

As in parishes all over the country, a series of sermons on the new translation, and on the Mass itself, also got successfully underway. I wonder how many priests said for the first time that the people’s response in that opening exchange between priest and congregation does not mean “and the same to you, Father”. “And also with you” can’t really mean much more: indeed, it was the perfect example of how the old translation, from the off, consistently reduced (ah, wondrous past tense) theological meaning in the movement from Latin to English. ….

[…]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
2 Comments

A moment with the psalmist, Pope Benedict, and St. Augustine

Spend a moment in your midday with ….

Psalm 3

The psalm of David when he fled from the face of his son Absalom.

Why, O Lord, are they multiplied that afflict me? many are they who rise up against me.
Many say to my soul: There is no salvation for him in his God.
But thou, O Lord art my protector, my glory, and the lifter up of my head.
I have cried to the Lord with my voice: and he hath heard me from his holy hill.
I have slept and taken my rest: and I have risen up, because the Lord hath protected me.
I will not fear thousands of the people, surrounding me: arise, O Lord; save me, O my God.
For thou hast struck all them who are my adversaries without cause: thou hast broken the teeth of sinners.
Salvation is of the Lord: and thy blessing is upon thy people.

Death of Absalom

From L’Osservatore Romano I picked up the blurb in English about the Holy Father’s General Audience today, during which he spoke of Psalm 3.

The image on the right, with the L’Osservatore Romano summary, is a 12th c. miniature of “The death of Absalom and the cry of King David” (Pierpont Morgan Library).

God who responds
to the cry of man

Dear Brothers and Sisters,

We return today to our series of catecheses on prayer with a consideration of Psalm Three, in which the psalmist cries out to God to rescue him from the enemies who surround him.  Traditionally the psalm is attributed to King David as he flees from the armies of his rebellious son Absalom.  Assailed on every side by foes who seek his life, the psalmist calls on the name of the Lord, filled with faith in the presence and the power of God who alone can save him from the evils that threaten him.  We are reminded of the plight of the just man in the Book of Wisdom, condemned to a shameful death by the wicked, who taunt him by arguing that God will surely come to his rescue.  Our thoughts move on to Calvary, where the passers-by mocked Jesus, saying that God would deliver him from death if he were really who he claimed to be.  And yet, we know that God truly hears the prayers of those who call upon him in faith.  He answers from his holy mountain.  The unseen God responds with great power, and he becomes our shield and our glory.  Even though Jesus appears to be abandoned by the Father as he dies on Calvary, yet for the eyes of faith this is the crowning moment of salvation, the triumph of the Cross, the hour of our Saviour’s glorification.

For St. Augustine, whom Pope Benedict has read deeply, Christ speaks to the Father in every word of the Psalms.  This is a key to reading Augustine reading the psalms.

Sometimes Christ as the Head of the Body is speaking to the Father, sometimes the as the Body, at other times, Christus Totus, Christ Whole, Entire.

St. Augustine of HippoAugustine comments in a sermon on Psalm 3.  Toward the end, he offered this:

9. This Psalm can be taken as in the Person of Christ another way; which is that whole Christ should speak. I mean by whole, with His body, of which He is the Head, according to the Apostle, who says, “You are the body of Christ, and the members.” 1 Corinthians 12:27 He therefore is the Head of this body; wherefore in another place he says, “But doing the truth in love, we may increase in Him in all things, who is the Head, Christ, from whom the whole body is joined together and compacted.” Ephesians 4:15-16 In the Prophet then at once, the Church, and her Head (the Church founded amidst the storms of persecution throughout the whole world, which we know already to have come to pass), speaks, “O Lord, how are they multiplied that trouble me! Many rise up against me;” wishing to exterminate the Christian name. “Many say unto my soul, There is no salvation for him in his God.” For they would not otherwise hope that they could destroy the Church, branching out so very far and wide, unless they believed that God had no care thereof. “But You, O Lord, art my taker;” in Christ of course. […]

10. Each one too of us may say, when a multitude of vices and lusts leads the resisting mind in the law of sin, “O Lord, how are they multiplied that trouble me! Many rise up against me.” And, since despair of recovery generally creeps in through the accumulation of vices, as though these same vices were mocking the soul, or even as though the Devil and his angels through their poisonous suggestions were at work to make us despair, it is said with great truth, “Many say unto my soul, There is no salvation for him in his God. But You, O Lord, art my taker.” For this is our hope, that He has vouchsafed to take the nature of man in Christ. “My glory;” according to that rule, that no one should ascribe ought to himself. “And the lifter up of my head;” either of Him, who is the Head of us all, or of the spirit of each several one of us, which is the head of the soul and body. For “the head of the woman is the man, and the head of the man is Christ.” 1 Corinthians 11:3

[… ]

“I slept, and took rest; and rose, for the Lord will take me up.” Who of the faithful is not able to say this, when he calls to mind the death of his sins, and the gift of regeneration? “I will not fear the thousands of people that surround me.” Besides those which the Church universally has borne and bears, each one also has temptations, by which, when compassed about, he may speak these words, “Arise, O Lord; save me, O my God:” that is, make me to arise. “Since You have smitten all who oppose me without a cause:” it is well in God’s determinate purpose said of the Devil and his angels; who rage not only against the whole body of Christ, but also against each one in particular. “You have broken the teeth of the sinners.”

Each man has those that revile him, he has too the prime authors of vice, who strive to cut him off from the body of Christ. But “salvation is of the Lord.”

Pride is to be guarded against, and we must say, “My soul cleaved after You.” “And upon Your people” be “Your blessing:” that is, upon each one of us.

Posted in Patristiblogging, Pope of Christian Unity | Tagged , , ,
1 Comment

Design for a new cathedral in Raleigh. Great!

Is it possible that the Silly Season of church architecture is coming to an end?

I saw at CMR that His Excellency Most Rev. Michael Burbidge, Bishop of Raleigh, help a presser about the construction of a new cathedral church for the diocese.  CMR has some more links and good comments about architecture.

A rendering:

Raleigh cathedral

It isn’t wierd!  It’s rather nice!  Hey!  It looks like a … a church!

There is a video of the presser here.

WDTPRS kudos to Bp. Burbidge!

Something great for your literal Brick by Brick file.

Remember that the Mystic Monks, traditional Carmelites in Wyoming are building their place.

Wyoming Carmelite Monks new monastery

Not too shabby.

When you buy Mystic Monk Coffee or Tea from these guys you help them build their monastery.  And when you use my link to buy their coffee, you help me too!

How’s your coffee supply?  Coffee could be a nice gift for the priests at your parish!

Help bring the Silly Season to an even swifter end!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick, Fr. Z KUDOS, Just Too Cool, New Evangelization, Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices | Tagged , ,
40 Comments

Praying for rain

In the Extraordinary Form edition of the Missale Romanum there are texts for a Votive Mass ad petendam pluviam… to ask for rain.

COLLECT (1962):
Deus, in quo vivimus, movemur, et sumus:
pluviam nobis tribue congruentem:
ut, praesentibus subsidiis sufficienter adiuti,
sempiterna fiducialius appetamus.

This prayer is pretty old.  It is found in the 8th century Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis.  Catholics have prayed it for a long time.  It remains, though somewhat isolated,  in the 2002 Missale Romanum.

Congruo is an important word here.  It is a combination of the preposition cum (with) and *-gruo which has the same sense as convenio.  We have our English words “congruent” and “convenient” from these Latin words.  Both the Latin words have the sense of “coming together”.  By logical extension they come to mean “fit, appropriate, suitable, congruous, proper.”  Think of the archaic English word “meet”, as in the way the “dignum et iustum” of the Preface was translated: “it is meet and just”.  Something which is congruens is proper in respects to all its elements.  It is at the right time, place, and in the right measure.  All the right factors come together and meet so that what you have is meet.  There are lots of phrases you can think of which express this idea.  You may know someone who has gotten it all together, for example.

WDTPRS SUPER LITERAL VERSION:
O God, in whom we live, move, and exist,
grant us the right amount of rain,
so that, aided sufficiently in present temporal helps,
we may more confidently strive for eternal things.

That subsidium is a military term, the auxiliary or reserve troops stationed in the rear in case of need.  But it means any kind of help or assistance as well.  In classical Latin it can be applied to food, however, as in frumentaria subsidia.   The subsidia in this liturgical context has lost the greater part of the military connotation.  I rendered it as “temporal helps” in order to contrast with the sempiterna that follows in the next line.  But I hear that military tone, as will anyone who knows Latin.  Subsidia jumps to the ear like an urgent trumpet calling for aid.  We are, after all, members of the Church Militant.

Not all your hand missals will have these votive texts.  Here is the translation from the

St. Andrew Daily Missal (1958):
O God, in whom we live and move and have our being,
grant us seasonable rain,
so that our temporal needs, being sufficiently supplied,
we may with greater confidence seek things eternal.

From the very first line we express our absolute dependance on God, even for our very existence.

The prayer would have been far more immediate to people in another time and place, people who don’t have well-stocked grocery stores where things from South American magically appear during winter.  Living closer to the land, closer to subsistence, many factors had to come together during the changes of the seasons so that people could eat now and store up their needed reserves for the fallow times and famine times.

How important is rain?

Ask the Sudanese.

Ask Texans.

Note in our prayer that we do not ask for lavish things or superabundance.  We ask for enough.  The right amount of material things so that we can keep our minds on eternal things.  People who very focused on helping the poor might sometimes be dissidents or even heretics in regard to doctrine, but they have a good instinct: when we are so hungry or afraid that we cannot think of anything else, we can be distracted from heavenly aims.  Sometimes we have to feed the body so that we can be freed enough to focus on God.  Great merit, however, is in keeping our focus on God even in the midst of our great troubles.  We do this by grace, especially, but also elbow grease.  Times of trial are just that: trials, tests, times of purification during which we sinners are being corrected and we are asked to love God more.

WDTPRS suggests to the Catholic bishops and priests in Texas to call for and hold processions, honest-to-goodness old-fashioned processions, to pray for rain.

Get out in the streets.  Get out in the fields and farming community roads with your banners and incense and songs and prayers and beg Almighty God for the right amount of rain.  Then let God’s will be done.  I will also pray for rain for Texas.

In the old Rituale Romanum there is a section concerning the Seven Penitential Psalms and the Litany of Saints.  In the Litany, invocations can be inserted for various needs, including for rain.  As a matter of fact, in a commonly distributed old book, the Altar Prayers, the prayers for rain were the first to be listed.  This section indicates the changes to be inserted into the Litany of Saints when praying for rain. and it gives three collects, including that which we saw, above.  The other two are:

O Almighty God, we beseech Thee,
that we who in our trouble put our trust in Thy mercy
may be strengthened by Thy defense against all adversity.

Grant us wholesome rain, O Lord, we beseech Thee,
and graciously pour forth showers from heaven on the parched face of the earth.
Through our Lord Jesus Christ, Thy Son, Who liveth and reigneth with Thee
in the unity of the Holy Ghost, God, world without end.

Amen.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Our Catholic Identity, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM, The future and our choices | Tagged , , , ,
17 Comments

Our traces on the Moon

I don’t have a Truly and Fantastically Super Cool category, but if I did, this would be in it.

NASA has clear photos of the Apollo 12, 14 and 17 landing sites. The photos show the twists and turns of the paths made when the astronauts explored the lunar surface.  You can see the stuff they left behind.  Some of the photos are interactive.  More here.

Here is one shot.  Click for a larger version.   But definitely go to NASA for more!

NASA Apollo landing site photos

So near and yet so far.  And farther and farther under this present POTUS.

Emily Dickinson wrote:

I watched the Moon around the House
Until upon a Pane —
She stopped — a Traveller’s privilege — for Rest —
And there upon

I gazed — as at a stranger —
[…]

Posted in Just Too Cool | Tagged , , , , ,
12 Comments

QUAERITUR: How to confess past, forgotten sins?

From a reader:

I made a big confession spanning over many years of not going to Confession a few months ago. I thought I had made a good and thorough Examination of Conscience, as it took me close to a month of racking my brain for sins. Sadly, being very ignorant of things like the virtues and vices, seven deadly sins, etc, I left out a litany of sins that I’ve slowly discovered as I learn more. Some might be mortal sins, and some not. I’m not sure, but they do seem little on the graver side than other sins, and I’d like to confess them and get them out there, even if they’re not mortal because I feel pretty guilty and bad about them.

The problem is many of them I’ve left unconfessed for several confessions because I’m not sure how to confess them exactly. Do I just include them with my list of sins, or do I have to specify that they’re leftover from previous confessions? I go to confession bi-monthly, so I’m concerned moving up to the legal-sized list will pose some sort of a red flag to the priest that I had been making bad and insincere confessions previously and he’ll scold me for it.

No priest I know would scold you during confession for something like this.  Priests are impressed with people’s sincerity and courage.

The best way to approach this is to make your regular confession of what you can remember since your last confession and then say something along the lines of this: “Also, Father, after reflecting on my life and learning more, there are some things from my past that I haven’t confessed yet.”, and then just tell them briefly and succinctly.  Don’t dwell on them.  It’ll be fine.  You’ll see.

Keep in mind that when you make a good confession, to the best of your ability, even the sins that you have forgotten are forgiven.  If you remember them later, include them in your confession, by all means.  But don’t worry that you have to have a perfect, machine-like memory.  Just do your best and all your sins are forgiven.

The confessional may be a tribunal in which we ourselves are our own prosecutor, but the confessional isn’t a torture chamber.  Making a confession can be hard, because we really have to look hard at ourselves, but it isn’t a vivisection.

I am glad you want to be so thorough.  But remember that you are a human being, not an angel with an angelic mind which can never forget.  None of us are.

In the meantime, since we live and learn, this is an experience by which you have lived and learned.  Having done this, you won’t have to worry about knowing what to do next time.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , , ,
22 Comments

16 September – England and Wales – Return to meatless Fridays

The Bishops have decided to re-establish the practice that this penance should be fulfilled simply by abstaining from meat and by uniting this to prayer

On 16 September in England and Wales, Catholics are asked by the Catholic bishops to return during the whole year to meatless Fridays.

This is a great initiative for strengthening Catholic identity and for doing penance for the sins members of the Church have committed.   I have written about this here and here.

In a WDTPRS POLL the overwhelming number of votes indicated that in the USA we should return to meatless Fridays.

Download a PDF of Q&A from the Bishops in England and Wales.

Press release – Friday PenanceThe Visit of Pope Benedict XVI evoked for many people the spiritual reality of life and rekindled hope and faith: hope in the goodness that is within people and in our society, and faith in God. Even if it is not easily articulated, a spiritual yearning is to be found within most people. This yearning is found also among Catholics who have lost touch with their faith or whose faith was never deeply rooted in a personal relationship with Christ. Wishing to respond to this yearning but perhaps lacking in confidence in talking about their own spiritual life, many Catholics are asking how they can witness to their faith; what can they do to help introduce their faith in Christ to others in simple and straightforward ways?

The Bishops of England and Wales recognise that simple acts of witness, accompanied by sincere prayer, can be a powerful call to faith. Traditional Catholic devotions such as making the sign of the cross with care and reverence, praying the Angelus, saying a prayer before and after our meals, to name only a few, are straightforward actions which both dedicate certain moments in our daily lives to Almighty God and demonstrate our love and trust in His goodness and providence. If these devotions have been lost or even forgotten, particularly in our homes and schools, we have much to gain from learning and living them again.  [Nicely done.]

The Bishops have looked again at the role of devotions and the practice of penance, both of which can help to weave the Catholic faith into the fabric of everyday life. Our regular worship at Holy Mass on Sunday, [Without a revitalization of our liturgical worship, none of the other efforts of New Evangelization will stick.] the day of the Lord’s resurrection, is the most powerful outward sign and witness of our faith in Jesus Christ to our family, friends and neighbours. Sunday must always remain at the heart of our lives as Catholics.

The Bishops also wish to remind us that every Friday is set aside as a special day of penitence, as it is the day of the suffering and death of the Lord. They believe it is important that all the faithful again be united in a common, identifiable act of Friday penance because they recognise that the virtue of penitence is best acquired as part of a common resolve and common witness.

The law of the Church requires Catholics on Fridays to abstain from meat, or some other form of food, or to observe some other form of penance laid down by the Bishops’ Conference. The Bishops have decided to re-establish the practice that this penance should be fulfilled simply by abstaining from meat and by uniting this to prayer. Those who cannot or choose not to eat meat as part of their normal diet should abstain from some other food of which they regularly partake.

This decision will come into effect from Friday 16 September 2011.

Our friends at Rorate have a great suggestion, by the way.  Post suggestions of meatless recipes for those Fridays in England and Wales!  I am sure they will have some great ideas over there.

If only people were interested in food entries here.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Just Too Cool, Linking Back, New Evangelization, Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices | Tagged , , , ,
25 Comments

The left-wing jihad against Bp. Robert Finn examined

Some of the most vicious attacks I have ever seen on a Catholic bishop from the catholic and the secular left, have been launched at His Excellency Most Rev. Robert Finn of the Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph.

Lately, the Kansas City Star has been calling for the resignation of Bp. Finn.  As far as I can tell, good analysis of the attacks on Finn has been offered by the blog SERVIAM.

Here is an lesson for the readers about how to turn the sock inside out.

My emphases:

Mi-Ai Parrish Should Resign

by RJS | 6th September 2011

The Kansas City Star last week called for the resignation of Bishop Robert Finn.

Again.

The first time was right after the Fr. Ratigan case broke and there was general chaos and confusion and the Star was doing its best (or worst) to avoid all of the facts getting in the way of their desire to rid themselves of someone who is against every liberal moral and political agenda they support.  Now SOME of the facts are beginning to emerge.  An independent report is critical of Bishop Finn in some areas and supportive in others.  The Star latches on to the critical items, mis-reports the supportive ones, ignores other facts of the case and again calls for the bishop’s resignation.

I’m sorry, but since when does the Star have any business calling for the resignation of a Catholic bishop?  Is it now a Catholic publication?  (As much ink as their crusade has cost them, they might as well be.)  The Catholic Church is a private organization representing a whopping 15% of Kansas Citians.  Ironically, that’s about the same as the market penetration of the once proud Kansas City Star.  There was a time when well over 50% of KC households received the Star and it was the voice of the city.  It’s now dropped to circulation levels not seen in decades.  The editorial board has no credibility and doesn’t even try to hide their biases.  The bias and “baggage” of the reporters assigned to cover the Diocese is well-known and the subject of blog conversations among former Star staffers (of which there are hundreds these days).  The newspaper is a shell of its former self, is no longer a credible voice in the community, is dumping people onto unemployment roles, is overcharging for ads no one reads (though they are selling them for less than they did 30 years ago) and has failed in its responsibility to and has hurt the interests of the community and shareholders of which I represent the former.

Therefore, I call for the resignation of the President and Publisher, Mi-Ai Parrish and do so with greater standing than her publication has to call for the resignation of a Catholic bishop.

In fairness, it should be pointed out that Mi-Ai Parrish is new on the job and was not directly responsible for the decline of the Star over the past two decades.  Coincidentally, the vast majority of the recent lawsuits against the Diocese concern allegations that allegedly occurred long before Bishop Finn arrived in KC.  But since that does not concern the Star, her lack of tenure here does not concern me.

Then again, I should be careful… If she resigns I might get stuck with Judy Thomas as publisher.  After all, if history, and knowledge of those in the appointment process is any indication, it’s a good bet that were Bishop Finn to resign, his replacement would make Bishop Finn look like a new-age, pro-abortion socialist.

On the last note, there is no chance whatsoever that I will ever be Bp. Finn’s successor.

WDTPRS Kudos to Serviam.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Fr. Z KUDOS, The Drill, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged , ,
9 Comments

New translation resources for the blind

From CTS:

The CTS worked in conjunction with the Royal National Institute for the Blind to produce an order of Mass for the new English translation in Braille.

This is the first time CTS have produced a Braille book. We sent the text of the new translation of the Mass to the RNIB who converted it into Braille. We hope that this will increase the participation of blind and partially-sighted people in the Mass and allow them to experience and understand the dignity and beauty of the new translation which began to be used this week.

With exactly the same content as the CTS Mass card, this Braille booklet is selling at £2.95 – just enough to cover costs – and we hope that it will prove a valuable resource alongside everything else we have produced, to help with this momentous event in the history of the English-speaking Church. Alongside the Large Print Mass book, and our other large print books, it forms part of our desire to make provision for those with this particular impairment, so that they too have the opportunity to pray and read the scriptures.

The Catholic Church has a long and proud history of provision for the blind and partially-sighted, going back centuries; this is highlighted in Lumen – A Catholic Guide to Civilisation:

“Valentin Haüy (d. 1822), founded the first school for the blind. A student from this school, Louis Braille (d. 1852), simplified their system of raised writing to create the Braille system, which is now used worldwide.”

It is fitting then, that the text of the Mass is now available in a format first devised at a Catholic school. See our website for more details.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes | Tagged ,
8 Comments