Rosary CD: reflections by Ven. J.H. Newman & Fr. van Straaten

NLM has an interesting entry on a new CD as an aid to pray the Rosary via reflections by Venerable Cardinal John Newman and Father Werenfried van Straaten.

Very cool.

Aid to the Church in Need is selling these to raise money.  A very good cause!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Cork, Ireland – 12-13 July: Fota II International Liturgy Conference

This International Liturgy Conference is going on right now in Ireland.  I wrote about it here.

A friend sent the following report:

A quick note on Fota II.  More to follow.

It was chaired Fota II was chaired by Professor D. Vincent Twomey and divided into three sessions: the first session on Sunday evening explored some of the theological, philosophical and historical sources of the principles outlined by Joseph Ratzinger for sacred art and architecture; the second session on Monday morning continued this exploration with a paper on the importance of the Jewish notion of nuptial covenant for the disposition and decoration of early churches and a paper on Louis Bouyer’s influence on the writings of Joseph Ratzinger.  The third session began with Cardinal Pell’s key note address on the contribution of Jose;h Ratzinger to Christian aesthetics.  He emphasized above all else that contribution was essentially theological and derived from the personal theological synthesis of Joseph Ratzinger.  Turning to the practical application of the theoretical principles outlined in the earlier sessions, Professor Duncan Stroik examined the challenges facing Catholic architects especially when trying to build a church which gives physical expression to the principles mysteries of the Catholic faith.  Dr. Alcuin Reid read a very significant paper on the correct interpretation of "noble simplicity" as understood by the Council Fathers and Sacrosanctum Concilium.  Ethan Anthony of the Boston firm of Cram Ferguson well illustrated the challenges facing parishes which want to build beautiful churches rather than glass boxes or concrete cubes as well as the myriad of possibilities available within the matrix of traditional building desogn and construction methods.  A further practical aspect of providing a proper gathering space for a a modern church was examined by Neil Roy by illustrating the medieval Galilee chapel and its "transitus" character both in terms of entering the sacral from the secular and in tems of entering the heavenly from the earthly.  The conference moved to Cobh Cathedral on Monday morning for the celebration of Mass in the extraordinary form with Cardinal Pell presiding in Cappa Magna.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

WSJ: Robert George – ironic judicial religious test double standard

The hearings on Judge Sonia Sotomayor are occasions to get lots of questions out in to the public square.

One of those issues is the war on religion in the public square.

In the Wall Street Journal there is a piece by William Mcgurn with Robert George

The Catholic Double Standard
Why was Samuel Alito’s Catholicism so much more discussed than Sonia Sotomayor’s?

JULY 14, 2009

By WILLIAM MCGURN

In opening yesterday’s Judiciary Committee hearings on Sonia Sotomayor’s nomination to the Supreme Court, Chairman Pat Leahy (D., Vt.) alluded to the religious prejudice that has too often intruded on the process.

The first Jewish nominee, he noted, had to answer "questions about the Jewish mind and how its operations are complicated by altruism." The first Catholic nominee, he added, "had to overcome the argument that, as a Catholic, he’d be dominated by the pope."

"We are," Sen. Leahy declared, "in a different era."

Maybe. It’s true that if Ms. Sotomayor is confirmed there will be six Catholics on the Court — a higher percentage than almost any Notre Dame starting lineup of the past three decades. It’s also true that notwithstanding a few scattered references to this fact, for the most part the judge’s religion has been greeted, as a USA Today headline put it, with a "yawn."

How different from just a few years ago. Back when the nominee was Sam Alito, talk was about the "fifth Catholic" on the bench. Eleanor Smeal, president of the Feminist Majority, complained that "with Alito, the majority of the Court would be Roman Catholics."

Before that it was John Roberts. In the run-up to his confirmation, the Los Angeles Times ran a piece headlined "Wife of Nominee Holds Strong Antiabortion Views." Though the article conceded that a "spouse’s views normally are not considered relevant in weighing someone’s job suitability," plainly these were not normal times. Mrs. Roberts, the paper pointed out, had worked for a group called "Feminists for Life," and was characterized as an "extremely, extremely devout Catholic."

And let’s not forget Bill Pryor, whose Catholicism came into question when he was nominated for the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in 2003. Back then, Mr. Leahy’s colleague, Charles Schumer (D., N.Y.), put his worries about Mr. Pryor’s faith this way: "His beliefs are so well known, so deeply held, that it’s very hard to believe — very hard to believe — that they’re not going to deeply influence the way he comes about saying, ‘I will follow the law.‘"  [But it is somehow okay for a "wise Latina" to bring her background to the bench.]

It’s possible, of course, that Democrats and their allies in the media and activist community no longer regard Catholics with the suspicion they did back when President George W. Bush’s nominees were up for consideration. More likely, the relatively soft reaction to Ms. Sotomayor’s Catholicism is because of a calculation that when it comes to hot-button issues such as abortion or gay marriage, she doesn’t really believe what her church teaches.  [I am sensing a theme… "Cattolica ma non troppo"]

Robert George, McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton, says the Sotomayor hearings highlight a glaring double standard about how the Catholicism of judicial nominees is treated — and the great irony this treatment exposes.

[NB] "According to one theory of jurisprudence," says Mr. George, "the judge may not bring his own moral beliefs or personal feelings to bear on his rulings on what the law is. This is the view held by people like Scalia and Alito and Roberts."

This means that a judge who is personally pro-life can uphold a pro-choice law — and a judge who is personally pro-choice can uphold a pro-life law. What matters is the law, not the personal feelings. When judges follow this path, they take some of the heat out of culture wars. That’s because those who want to change the law — pro-life or pro-choice — have to do it the way our Founders intended: through their elected representatives.  [The usual depiction of justice we find in the American judicial context is that Justice personified is blindfolded.]

"The other theory of jurisprudence," the professor told me, "holds that the judge has a responsibility to bring his or her moral beliefs to cases. This is famously defended by scholars such as Ronald Dworkin, and practiced by judges such as William Brennan and John Paul Stevens."

"Among the many problems with this view [the second view] is that it leads inexorably to the politicization of the judicial process. If someone expects us to accept this theory as a legitimate judicial philosophy, then he or she has to be prepared to answer questions about what his or her moral beliefs or personal feelings are — and where they come from."

"Yet here’s the irony. The same people who feel no compunction in trying to use the Catholicism of an Alito or Pryor to raise suspicions about their suitability then cry foul when anyone demands to know the basis of the moral convictions and personal feelings of someone that a liberal Democratic president is trying to place on the Supreme Court." [Yes… that is ironic, isn’t it?]

If the indifference to Ms. Sotomayor’s Catholicism were truly a sign of a new respect for the "no religious test" provisions of the Constitution, [and it isn’t] that would be something to celebrate. [but, is isn’t.] But in the unlikely case that this "wise Latina" ever comes to see the legal wisdom of overturning Roe and returning abortion to the democratic process, we’ll be reading a very different story.

Write to MainStreet@wsj.com

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

Austria… atheism on the rise

I picked up from the wonderful and persistent Anna Arco of the Catholic Herald that, according to Die Presse, in Austria the number of atheists has doubled in 10 years.

In Austria… think about that.

I have always understood that one of the things which helped to preserve Catholic Austria from the onslaught of the theological revolt of the Reformation was Exposition of the Blessed Sacrament and Mass coram Sanctissimo.

Maybe it is time to institute Perpetual Adoration in even more places and also return to Holy Mass coram Sanctissimo when possible.

I can tell you from my personal experience of a traditionally celebrated Forty Hours that Mass coram Sanctissimo is a powerful experience.

God save Austria.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

Sending empty envelopes to the White House… receiving one back

The young papist picked up a story I think more people should see.

I added some emphases.  I also blotted out the person’s address on the envelope.

Exclusive: Is the White House mocking pro-lifers?

AmP reader Chris emailed me:

You may remember sometime ago there was an empty envelope campaign where folks on the side of the unborn were encourage to send an empty envelope to the white house, with the message "this envelope represents a life lost to abortion" or something along that line. My wife sent an empty envelope. In our mailbox today, was an empty envelope with the return address "The White House, Washington, DC, 20500." There is no message inside nor on the back. It is hand-addressed to my wife

Here is a picture of the letter she received:

Sending empty envelopes to the White House... receiving one back

She blogs about the experience here (the comments are also interesting). 

I’d be interested to find out if others who sent empty envelopes to the White House received an empty one back. It’s an odd coincidence, to say the least.

If some snarky intern did indeed think this would be a fun way to get back at pro-lifers, I think Chris and his wife are owed a second letter – an official apology.

So…. has anyone had the same experience?  Heard of someone who had that same experience?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

Why I didn’t write on the NYT interview with Justice Ginsberg… um.. I did.

Some of you have been writing to ask why I haven’t written about the interesting interview in last week’s Sunday magazine of the NYT. 

Answer: I did.  And there are 56 comments (as of this writing).

And you can find it here: Justice Ginsberg originally thought Roe v Wade was about control of undesirable populations

I found the interview fascinating, both for what wasn’t asked and for what Justice Ginsberg admitted without being asked.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Young priest, “ars celebrandi”, “gravitational pull”… resistance

Young priests for the most part are interested in the sort of continuity of which our Holy Father Pope Benedict has written and spoken.   They are not chained under the burden of 60’s-80’s seminary "rupture" formation.  They want our whole tradition.

I received the following from a long-time reader/participant of WDTPRS both in print and on the blog, Henry Edwards.

It seems that a young Fr. Shelton, assistant at Our Lady of Fatima in Alcoa, TN, gave some instruction on the Roman Canon using little sermons.  An interesting dimension of these little sermons is that, in them, he also uses the new ICEL translation.  This means he is also helping the people prepare to hear the new translation of Holy Mass. 

This is a tribute also to the pastor of the parish!  They are doing their job and helping people in their fuller and more authentic active participation in the source and summit of our Catholic identity.

Moreover, he, like other young priests, he has been saying Holy Mass, on day’s off, using the 1962MR, as he is free to do under Summorum Pontificum as a priest of the Latin Rite, and groups of lay people are choosing to participate, as they are free to do and members of Christ’s faithful.

That sounds just about right.

I would wager that this priest’s use of the 1962 Missale Romanum has exerted a strong gravitational pull on how he celebrates with the Novus Ordo.  I would further wager that this in turn as exerted an an influence on those who attend his Masses.

Use of the older form of Mass will affect a priest’s ars celebrandi which is precisely what the Synod on the Eucharistic called for and which Pope Benedict desired to foster in Sacramentum caritatis.

Oh yes.. Fr. Shelton has a blog.  You might over there, looks around, and spike his stats.

Let’s see what our WDTPRSer wrote, with my emphases and comments.
 

Father Z,
 
Let me recommend to you and WDTPRS readers a somewhat "different" new blog FatherShelton recently started by the associate pastor of my local parish, Our Lady of Fatima in Alcoa (TN). Fr. Shelton is an altogether remarkable "young priest of the restoration"–Pope Benedict’s restoration, that is.
 
Beyond some of the usual Catholic things, his blog centers on (more notably) the texts of his recent sermonettes at daily and Sunday Mass.[A good use for a blog!]  Each of these "sermonettes" being a polished jewel that takes him just 2 to 3 minutes to deliver and is densely packed with liturgical perspectives rarely if ever heard at Mass. These rare nuggets enhance the liturgy instead of detracting from it. In particular, because no homily of his is ever over half as long as the Eucharistic Prayer, there’s no possibility of the mixed message that can be conveyed by a Mass in which the Holy Sacrifice itself is the shortest part of the whole liturgy.
 
Currently, Fr. Shelton uses only the Roman Canon (EP I) at Mass, [That’s all I use as well.  I figure that as soon as I no longer have anything to learn from the Roman Canon, I will then move on.] and his daily homilies are interpretations of successive parts of this most venerable and explicitly sacrificial canon. [NB] All ten (so far) are collected in the single thread ROMAN CANON that can be browsed in a few minutes, but may reveal more about the Mass than most readers have ever heard. Father illustrates them with quotes from the canon using the new English translation that will (before long, hopefully) expose us all to What The Mass Really Does Say. This translation in the works may be news in some pews, but not in our parish, at least not at daily Mass. Some extracts:
 
Actual participation ( Mysterium Fidei )
"Our participation in the Mass is an experience of Christ’s offering to the Father. If we are in a state of grace during the Mass, then we experience this mystery perfectly and completely. [Well… that’s enthusiastic, and on the right track because he speaks of mystery.  But, no, not perfectly and completely.  It is a mystery, right?] ….. The more we try to plan the Sacred Liturgy, or change our thoughts, feelings and actions within it, the less we look like Heaven. But when we accept that the mystery is already complete, and that even the smallest Catholic child or feeblest Catholic adult participates perfectly [in sense, perhaps, of doing the very best we can] in the Holy Sacrifice simply by his presence while in a state of grace, then we are no longer motivated by ourselves during the Sacred Liturgy, but, rather, by the great, eternal, and complete mystery of faith into which Christ places us. Mysterium Fidei, indeed."
 
Processions and music ( Quam oblationem tu )
"The Church prefers that for the processional parts of the Mass, namely the procession of the Priest at the beginning of Mass, the procession of the faithful at the offering of your sacrifice of bread and wine, and at the procession of the Bride of Christ to receive the Body of the Groom at Holy Communion, we sing a psalm or other text of Sacred Scripture, rather than a hymn of human origin. ….. The Church tolerates hymns when necessary, but hymns at the processional parts of Mass begin in history with a merely human author, and so lack the liturgical dance with time that is liturgical sacrifice."
 
Incense and sacrifice ( Commemoratio pro defunctis )
"The Roman Mass presumes the use of sweet incense, especially in celebrations with a deacon. It is at the points in the Roman Canon we are discussing this week that it seems most certain that the air above the Altar ought to be filled with this holy, moving, living cloud of sweetness. Many today object that incense should be burned only on red-letter days or major feasts of saints, but incense is not about saints or schedules, but about sacrifice, which is the essence of the Holy Mass. Thankfully, our God-given imaginations allow [all our] celebrations to be filled with plumes of incense billowing up and pushing open the doors of Heaven, as our sacrifice, and our dead, rise to the Father."
 
Communion while kneeling ( Supra que )
"The Holy Father wishes to feed the faithful once again as one would a child, and quite literally: by having the priests and deacons place the Lamb of God directly onto the tongues of the faithful. [I bet Father get’s a little flack for that.  However, people should remember that this is the true method of reception and the method on the hand is merely permitted by law.  And it can be curtailed if there is any danger of profanation of the Blessed Sacrament (cf. Redemtpionis Sacramentum).]  God the Father does not reach down to take our gift, but receives our gift born by the hands of his Angel. ….. The present practice [of communion on the hand] is sadly misleading, was introduced illicitly in the 1960’s, resisted by Pope Paul VI–who never permitted it in Rome–and is tolerated today in Church law only as an exception to the traditional norm."  [As I said.]
 
On the tongue ( Hanc igitur )
"When you receive Holy Communion today, imagine the ciborium is the beating Sacred Heart of Jesus, the Host, a drop of his Precious Blood, falling through the wound in his side onto your waiting tongue, as you kneel with the faith of an infant to receive this divine nourishment."  [Sounds familiar.  I recently gave a talk in NYC about the Sacred Heart, and made a connection between the Sacred Heart and the chalice.]
 
The context for all this is that the Diocese of Knoxville has the usual range of lay and clerical attitudes, but is a dynamic and growing diocese with — many thanks to former Bishop Joseph E. Kurtz (now Archbishop of Louisville) — no shortage of vocations, and with a bunch of young priests of the restoration who expect a bright diocesan future under our new Bishop Richard F. Stika.
 
Our parish, despite the horizontal appearance of our church itself, is one with Mass celebrated reverently by the book — especially since the recent pastorate of Most Rev. J. Vann Johnston, now Bishop of Springfield (MO). For instance, the Tabernacle moved back to a central position behind the altar and reverenced appropriately, [Excellent!] communion with patens [good!] held by altar servers in surplice and cassock, beautiful music in both vernacular and Latin [as Sacrosanctum Concilium indicates] (including Sanctus and Agnus Dei), all the usual bells and smells–incense on solemnities and major feasts (including incensing of the elevated species during elevation after the consecration), communion on the tongue not uncommon, etc.
 
But Fr. Shelton’s ars celebrandi goes well beyond these common practices. Beginning when he processes in wearing beautiful Roman vestments and carrying the chalice veiled and topped with burse in the color of the day. In the opening dialogue (with never an extemporaneous word here or at any other time in the liturgy) he faces the people from the celebrant’s chair to the side of the altar. But whenever prayer is addressed to God rather than to the people — e.g., the Confiteor (before which he pauses long enough for everyone to say a silent act of contrition), the Kyrie Eleison, the Gloria, etc., he visibly turns to face the altar instead. The offertory rite is silent until the "Pray brethren … ", although evidently he is praying privately throughout. He says the canon in a quite and measured tone that somehow connotes the fact that he is speaking in the person of Christ rather than with his own personality, and to God rather than to the people, but with an audibly more solemn tone for the Consecration. I’ve never before heard a priest include every "Through Christ our Lord. Amen."  [Actual] that appears in brackets as an option 4 or 5 times throughout the Roman Canon. And all with such precise and solemn gestures–and a visible bow of the head at each mention of the Holy Name–that simple words fail.
 
When he arrived in our parish last fall, Fr. Shelton began a "private" EF Mass one weekday night per week, and latter initiated an "experimental" ad orientem Latinate OF celebration at (only) his Saturday morning Mass. However, [Get this.]  at present he has voluntarily suspended both these initiatives pending further thought on his part about the question of real or perceived "carry over" of traditional practices into regular parish liturgies. Apparently, many new and recently ordained priests have the impression that this "mutual enrichment" of forms may be among the Holy Father’s intentions with Summorum Pontificum, but the issue may not be soon resolved by any single priest, parish, or diocese.
 
Henry Edwards 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

Prayer request from a Legionary of Christ about Visitation

This came from a priest, from a priest of the Legionaries of Christ:

On Tuesday, July 15, the Apostolic Visitation of the Legion of Christ is due to begin (the official statement of the Legion is on the “news” page of the website www.legionariesofchrist.org).

In your charity and kindness, and for the good of the Church and of all the people who are affected by the scandal, please pray for the effectiveness and fruit of the Visitation – that it may bring about whatever is best for all involved, according to God’s plan.

If you think it appropriate, please ask your many readers to effectively help “spike our prayer stats” before God.  Prayers to St. Joseph, St. Paul, St. John the Evangelist, and St Michael the Archangel, would be particularly apropos, as they are the patrons and protectors of the Congregation. [NB…]  (We don’t want to be “protected” from the Visitation, but rather from any internal or external obstacles to the work of the Holy Father’s representatives in helping us live and serve the Church in truth and charity). The Legion is also dedicated to the Sacred Heart and the Mother of Sorrows, so prayers using those devotions would also be appreciated.

If you chose to make this petition public, please keep it anonymous. [As I will always do for priests if they wish.]

Thank you for your charity and prudence in your coverage of this and other priestly scandals – and for a great blog overall!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

Pres. Obama’s pick for Surgeon General

Pres. Obama's pick for Surgeon GeneralSome developments:

Apparently, when Pres. Obama announced his nomination of Dr. Benjamin for Surgeon General, he also pushed his health reform bill. 

Catholic League reported that on 25 June, 19 Democrats, 11 of whom are Catholic, sent a letter to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi saying they will not vote for healthcare reform “unless it explicitly excludes abortion funding” from the plan.

"According to Douglas Johnson of the National Right to Life Committee, the bills being considered ‘contain multiple provisions that would result in federally mandated insurance coverage of abortion on demand, massive federal subsidies for abortion, mandated creation of many new abortion clinics, and nullification of at least some state limitations on abortion.’  So where does Dr. Benjamin come in on all of this? On June 19, the House Committees on Ways and Means, Energy and Commerce, and Education and Labor announced that a new Advisory Committee will decide which services will be covered. And who is in charge of the Health Benefits Advisory Committee? The Surgeon General."  [The plot thickens.]

Catholic League adds: "Dr. Benjamin should not wait until the Senate considers her appointment to let the public know where she stands. As a practicing Catholic, she cannot chair a committee that would support mandated abortion coverage in employer insurance plans."

_________

ORIGINAL POST 13 July 2009 3:42pm

Some interesting news!

As we are about to get Judge Sotomayor on the Supreme Court, we have a new appointee for Surgeon General.

From the Catholic League:

July 13, 2009

SURGEON GENERAL PICK IS EXCELLENT

Catholic League president Bill Donohue praised President Barack Obama for his selection of Dr. Regina Benjamin as the new Surgeon General:

President Obama picked the right person to be the new Surgeon General. Dr. Benjamin is a hero to all those victimized by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Her tireless and selfless efforts are a model for all physicians.

Dr. Benjamin is an African-American Catholic public servant who has been recognized by Pope Benedict XVI: the Holy Father awarded her the Pro Ecclesia et Pontifice medal for distinguished service. When the pope celebrated Mass in Washington, D.C. in 2008, Dr. Benjamin was there to receive his blessing. Moreover, she has also received the National Caring Award, an honor which was inspired by Mother Teresa. “Church was always a very important part of my life,” she told Catholic Digest. “I believe I am carrying on the healing ministry of Christ. I feel obligated to help continue his works.”

So… now we are supposed to give Pres. Obama this appointment high marks. 

And if anyone points out that perhaps the Surgeon General is not quite as important a position as the Sec. of Health and Human Services or a Justice on the Supreme Court, or what he may be doing with the other hand, then we will be criticized. 

They will say, "Look! See?  This is clearly a gesture of ‘common ground’!  See?  The meeting with the Pope really paid off! She got a medal! See? She‘s Catholic! SEE?"

No, my children.  That is not what this is.

Lifesite has an article on her. 

I understand that she has done a great deal of work among the poor.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
73 Comments

QUAERITUR: reserving two ciboria, for TLM and for Novus Ordo

QUAERITUR: reserving two ciboria, for TLM and for Novus OrdoFrom a priest reader:

Firstly, I’ve been a reader of the blog for a long time now, and it’s really fantastic.  Thank you for your efforts.  I have a question:  Is it permissible to reserve in the tabernacle a separate ciborium for the community that celebrates the Extraordinary Form?  Apparently, there is some concern about receiving Communion with hosts consecrated at the Ordinary Form Mass.  I seem to recall that PCED has a position on this, but have been unable to find it, so I turn to you.  Any help you can provide will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks for the nice comment!

I know of no law that would prevent the reservation of one ciborum for Host consecrated with the TLM and one for the Novus Ordo.

However, everything must be done to move the people –  if there are any – in your community away from the error of thinking that the consecration during a TLM is any different in effect from a consecration in the NO.

To that end, I would resist doing this, lest you feed that error any more energy.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
78 Comments