Robby George on the murder of George Tiller

On William Bennett‘s excellent weekday morning talk-radio show today, Morning in America, I heard Dr. Bennett read a quote from Robby George of Princeton on the murder of the late-term abortionist George Tiller.

You will remember Robby George’s informative and civil "discussion" with Doug Kmiec which I posted the other day.

Here is the quote from Robby George:

"Whoever murdered George Tiller has done a gravely wicked thing. The evil of this action is in no way diminished by the blood George Tiller had on his own hands. No private individual had the right to execute judgment against him. We are a nation of laws. Lawless violence breeds only more lawless violence. Rightly or wrongly, George Tilller was acquitted by a jury of his peers. "Vengeance is mine, says the Lord." For the sake of justice and right, the perpetrator of this evil deed must be prosecuted, convicted, and punished. By word and deed, let us teach that violence against abortionists is not the answer to the violence of abortion. Every human life is precious. George Tiller’s life was precious. We do not teach the wrongness of taking human life by wrongfully taking a human life. Let our "weapons" in the fight to defend the lives of abortion’s tiny victims, be chaste weapons of the spirit."

It looks like Morning in America picked this up from National Review Online.

BTW… Bill Bennett has perhaps the greatest name for a blog ever: Nota Bennett

Posted in Fr. Z KUDOS, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices |
31 Comments

Brazen squirrel

Sancte Pater has this….

AP PORT HURON, Mich. (May 31) — Squirrel. Thief. Patriot.

A brazen squirrel has been grabbing small American flags placed in a Port Huron, Mich., cemetery and carrying them up to its nest, which now looks as if it’s bedecked in bunting.

Every Memorial Day, volunteers place the flags next to the graves of nearly 1,000 veterans buried at Mount Hope Cemetery about 55 miles northeast of Detroit. The flags were undisturbed during a Mass held Monday.  [I should think not!]

The Times Herald reports that workers at the cemetery on Tuesday noticed several flags had been torn off their wooden staffs, which were still in the ground.

The mystery was solved in front of superintendent Ron Ceglarek’s eyes. He watched a squirrel detach a flag stapled to a staff and carry it up a tree to the nest.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

terms: pro-life v anti-abortion

I wonder about these terms… which we will be hearing and reading often in the coming days.

What is the difference of impact between

pro-life

and

anti-abortion

What do these terms really say?  What are people trying to convey by them… choosing the one over the other.

I was spurred to ask this in light of an article I read on FoxNews, which I fisked here.

Discuss with good manner and think about what you might want to post.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill |
56 Comments

FoxNews: “Pro-Life Groups Fear Backlash After Tiller Murder”

From AP via FoxNews:

My emphases and comments:

Pro-Life Groups Fear Backlash After Tiller Murder
Many anti-abortion groups condemned the killing of Tiller, a prominent abortion provider who was shot dead at his church in Wichita, Kansas. But they expressed concern that abortion-rights activists would use the occasion to brand the entire anti-abortion movement as extremist.  [Isn’t that what the Department of Homeland Security did in a memo?  Along with military veterans?]

NEW YORK — Anti-abortion leaders voiced concern Sunday that the Obama administration and other Democrats may try to capitalize on the murder of Dr. George Tiller to defuse the abortion issue in upcoming Supreme Court confirmation hearings. [It might go beyond that.]

Many anti-abortion […] groups condemned the killing of Tiller, a prominent abortion provider who was shot dead at his church in Wichita, Kansas. But they expressed concern that abortion-rights activists would use the occasion to brand the entire anti-abortion movement as extremist.

They also worried that there would now be an effort to stifle anti-abortion viewpoints during questioning of Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor. Her exact views on abortion aren’t known, but conservatives fear she supports abortion rights. 

Said the Rev. Patrick Mahoney, an anti-abortion activist: "No one should use this tragedy for political gain."   [Not a "pro-life" activist.  We can discuss different terms in another entry.]

Tiller, one the few American doctors specializing in late-term abortions, had been the target of repeated protests and harassment for many years, and he was wounded by gunfire from an anti-abortion activist in 1993.

"It is abhorrent that once again, individuals who oppose the right to choose have used violence to try to advance their extreme anti-choice agenda," said Vicki Saporta, president and CEO of the National Abortion Federation.  ["extreme anti-choice agenda"]

"We condemn this lawless act of violence. The foundational right to life that our work is dedicated to extends to everyone. Whoever is responsible for this reprehensible violence must be brought to justice under the law," said Americans United for Life President and CEO, Dr. Charmaine Yoest, in a statement.

While many anti-abortion leaders swiftly issued statements condemning the shooting, their expressions of dismay were not echoed by Randall Terry, a veteran anti-abortion activist whose protests have often targeted Tiller.

"George Tiller was a mass murderer and we cannot stop saying that," Terry said. "He was an evil man — his hands were covered with blood."

Terry said he was now concerned that the Obama administration "will use Tiller’s killing to intimidate pro-lifers into surrendering our most effective rhetoric and actions."  ["most effective rhetoric" does not in my mind include murdering abortionists.]

A month ago, Terry was arrested protesting President Obama’s appearance at the University of Notre Dame commencement. The president’s graduation speech was dominated by abortion issue — and an appeal for the nation to seek common ground instead of vitriol.

Mahoney said he had been conferring with other anti-abortion leaders about how to deal with any backlash to the Tiller killing that might undercut their cause at a time when they are trying to challenge Obama’s support for abortion rights.

"I’d hope they wouldn’t try to broad-brush the entire pro-life movement as some sort of extremist movement because of what happened in Wichita," Mahoney said. "That’s really important — don’t use this personal loss for a political gain."  [But… isn’t that what that memo of the Dept. of Homeland Security did?]

He noted that abortion is likely to be one of the most contentious issues at Sotomayor’s confirmation hearings, and expressed hope that the Tiller murder would not be raised there.  [Well… it is part of the background buzz now, one way or other.]

Abortion rights leaders reacted to the killing with shock and determination

Nancy Keenan, president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, said the murder would "send a chill down the spines of the brave and courageous providers" offering abortion to American women.

"Violence and murder will never end the need for abortion," said Dr. Suzanne T. Poppema, board chair of Physicians for Reproductive Choice and Health. "With great sadness and discouragement we call on the government to reactivate its protection system for our nation’s abortion providers."  [Are pro-life groups justified in being worried?]

Kim Gandy, president of the National Organization for Women, said Tiller was aware of the dangers he faced, "yet he continued to protect his patients and provide safe and legal abortions to women in often-desperate circumstances."

She and other activists urged that Monday be observed as a national day of mourning for Tiller, as well as a day of commitment to the cause of abortion rights.

According to the National Abortion Federation, Tiller was the eighth U.S. abortion provider murdered since 1977, and 17 others had been targeted with attempted murder.

 

This is going to heat up.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill |
20 Comments

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon – rose petals falling through the oculus

Here is an oldie post.   Take a look also at what my friend John Sonnen post over at his place Orbis Catholicus here and here.

_________

In Rome on Pentecost, in the Pantheon, now a minor basilica called S. Maria ad martyres there is a beautiful custom.

Rose petals are dropped through the circular oculus opening at the top of the dome, which is the widest is all of Rome, for all its antiquity.  The petals fall to the crowds below, reminiscent of the coming of the Holy Spirit like tongues of flame.

I posted photos taken over two different years here.  Some show the event from the inside of the Pantheon, and some show the mechanics from the outside.  My room in room is perfectly situated to see the dome of the Pantheon.

Here is how they get it done!  Notice the fire truck parked in front of the Pantheon.

 

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

 

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

The firemen, waiting on top of the dome, for the signal to drop the flower petals…

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

The moment arrives!

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

From within…

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

Oldie Post: Pentecost at the Pantheon - rose petals falling through the oculus

This is one of those lovely customs which we have only in Rome. 

UPDATE:

Fr. Longenecker found this YouTube piece:

Play video

 

Posted in Linking Back |
19 Comments

A few thoughts about the Tiller murder

I await with anxiety the inevitable capture of the person who shot George Tiller to death.

Tiller will now be lifted up in mockery of authentic martyrdom.

I hope to God his murderer is not Catholic.

I am supposing he will be identified ad nauseum as a "right-wing anti-women’s rights extremist" and a member of "radical anti-social groups", perhaps even the Catholic Church.  "See!", they will crow. "Homeland Security was right to issue that memo about so-called ‘pro-life’ groups?"

I am just cynical enough to wonder if he will not be identified as Catholic even if he isn’t.  I just bet that most news outlets will try to tie this act to the Catholic Church’s teachings and the protests of a handful of extremists who protested … well.. you get the idea.

As despicable as Tiller was, his murder will result in harsh payback against pro-lifers. 

Just as bad as the harsh payback will be the adoption of a cool and patient stance on the part of, for example, the Obama Administration – taking a soft and reasonable tone offering opportunities for more dialogue, etc.

Those Catholics who are soft on protesting abortion in strong terms will now be energized.  They will claim that, yes, their way is better after all.  We have lost the debate on abortion in the public square and now we must adopt a moderate tone and hope to get a little of what we would like to achieve.  Stubbornness and litmus-tests only create a cycle of violence, after all.

On this Pentecost Sunday remember that when the Apostles broke out of their room into the public square they did not go forth into safety or comfort.  Filled with the Holy Spirit and focused on the mission Christ gave them, they went out with a clear identity into the public square at the risk of life and limb and nearly all of the Apostles died as martyrs.

I think we need to get our heads into the right mental places right now so that we can see clearly and bear what the future will bring and God in His providence will permit.

I will leave the combox open… for now.

If people can discuss this and the surrounding issues with measured civility, demonstrating the ability to self-edit, I will leave it open.

Knuckle-heads will be banned from the blog.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
124 Comments

Late-term abortionist George Tiller murdered at his church

All… the NYT has this story. 

The infamous late-term abortionist Dr. George Tiller was shot and killed today in his church.

WDTPRS deplores this violence. 

Furthermore, this will bring horrific blow-back down on the entire pro-life movement.

Late-term abortionist George Tiller murdered at his churchAbortion Doctor Shot to Death in Church

By MONICA DAVEY and JOE STUMPE
Published: May 31, 2009

George Tiller, a Wichita doctor who was one of the few doctors in the nation to perform late-term abortions, was shot to death on Sunday as he attended church, city officials in Wichita said.

Dr. Tiller, who had performed abortions since the 1970s, had long been a lightning rod for controversy over the issue of abortion, particularly in Kansas, where abortion opponents regularly protested outside his clinic and sometimes his home and church. In 1993, he was shot in both arms by an abortion opponent but recovered.

He had also been the subject of many efforts at prosecution, including a citizen-initiated grand jury investigation. In the latest such effort, in March, Dr. Tiller was acquitted of charges that he had performed late-term abortions that violated state law.

The shooting occurred at around 10 a.m. (Central time) at Reformation Lutheran Church on the city’s East Side, Dr. Tiller’s regular church.

Wichita police said that the shots were fired from a handgun in the church lobby during the morning service. The authorities gave few details, but said they were searching for a powder blue Taurus made in the 1990s that had been seen leaving shortly after the shooting. They said witnesses had described seeing a white man departing.

“This is going to be a larger search than maybe just Wichita,” said Brent Allred, a police captain, who said that the FBI and state police had been called to the scene. By noon, few parishioners remained at the church, a modern, red brick facility that seats about 500 people. Police cars surrounded the building.

 

UPDATE 2000 GMT

AP has this: 

 

WICHITA, KAN – Nearly four hours after abortion doctor George Tiller was gunned down and killed in his Lutheran Church, Johnson County police pulled over a car matching the description of the suspect vehicle. The Associated Press reports police have the suspect in custody.

Tiller, 67, was shot just after 10 a.m., at Reformation Lutheran Church where he was a member of the congregation.

See a locator map of the crime.

According to Wichita media, police described the suspect as a white male in his 50’s or 60’s with gray hair that is balding in the middle. He is about 6’1" and about 220 pounds and was wearing a white shirt and dark pants. He was last seen in a light blue Ford Taurus, possibly an early 1990’s model. It has a K-State vanity plate and a Kansas license plate number 225 BAB.

 

Read more at that AP site….

Posted in The future and our choices |
65 Comments

Philadelphia: Solemn TLM – 28 June

From a reader:

A traditional Latin Missa Cantata (Mass in the Extraordinary Form) has been scheduled for 3:00 PM on Sunday, June 28, 2009 in anticipation of the Feast of Sts. Peter and Paul at the Church of St. Paul, on Christian St. between 9th and 10th Sts. in South Philadelphia.

Parking will be available across the street from the church. The church, which is very close to the 9th St. Italian Market, is readily accessible via SEPTA.

The music director for this TLM will be Nicholas Beck who is Music Director at Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ. Robert Ridgell will be the organist.
Father Gerald Carey, the Pastor of St. Paul Parish, will celebrate the Mass. The proper of the Mass will be sung in Gregorian chant. The Mass setting will be the familiar Missa de Angelis sung by the choir and the congregation.

Special polyphonic motets will be sung at the Offertory and at Holy Communion.

Our Sovereign Pontiff Pope Benedict XVI has made available a Plenary Indulgence for those who celebrate this Jubilee Year of St. Paul by participation in such a solemn celebration in connection with the Feast of Sts. Peter and Paul.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

More on the issue of the traditional Ambrosian Rite

I wrote about the letter of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei about the use of the traditional form of the Ambrosian Rite.

Now there is an article in Il Giornale about the issue.

More on the issue of the traditional Ambrosian Rite
n. 131 del 2009-05-31 pagina 4

«La messa antica si può celebrare anche a Milano»
di Andrea Tornielli

LA MISSIVA Una lettera del Vaticano: la decisione liberalizzatrice del Papa vale anche per il rito ambrosiano

Il motu proprio «Summorum Pontificum» con il quale Benedetto XVI nel 2007 ha liberalizzato l’uso dell’antico messale preconciliare «vale per gli altri riti latini, incluso il rito ambrosiano». Lo scrive in una lettera datata 22 maggio il vicepresidente della Pontificia commissione «Ecclesia Dei», monsignore Camille Perl, in risposta a una domanda rivoltagli per iscritto all’inizio dell’anno dal vicerettore del collegio Papio di Ascona, padre Jeffry Moore.
La lettera del Vaticano è stata resa nota ieri dal sito www.newliturgicalmovement.org.
Come si ricorderà, dopo la promulgazione del documento papale, la Curia ambrosiana aveva precisato per iscritto che il motu proprio non era applicabile nella diocesi di Milano, dato che il pontefice citava espressamente soltanto il rito romano, mentre per la liturgia ambrosiana il capo-rito è l’arcivescovo Dionigi Tettamanzi.
Non condividendo questa impostazione, un gruppo di sacerdoti e di laici tradizionalisti, lo scorso 7 gennaio si era recato a Roma ed era stato ricevuto dal cardinale Darío Castrillón Hoyos, presidente della Pontificia commissione Ecclesia Dei, che si occupa per mandato papale del mondo tradizionalista, chiedendo un parere sulla questione.
Tra i sacerdoti c’era anche don Jeffry Moore, che esercita il suo servizio in una chiesa di Ascona, nella diocesi di Lugano, il cui territorio è per metà di rito romano, per l’altra metà di rito ambrosiano. Don Moore celebra per un gruppo di studenti la messa in rito antico romano, ma fino a oggi aveva avuto problemi a farlo per gli studenti di rito ambrosiano.
«Lei esprime il desiderio di ricevere il conforto di un assenso – scrive monsignor Perl al sacerdote – alla possibilità che anche gli studenti ambrosiani che lo richiedono possano usufruire dei benefici garantiti dal Sommo Pontefice nel motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum”».
«Mentre è vero che il motu proprio del Santo padre non cita esplicitamente il rito ambrosiano – continua nella lettera il vicepresidente di “Ecclesia Dei” – non esclude nemmeno gli altri riti latini; se la volontà del Sommo Pontefice vale per il rito romano, considerato il superiore in dignità, di conseguenza, tanto più per gli altri riti latini, incluso il rito ambrosiano».
Insomma, la volontà liberalizzatrice del Papa si intende, secondo quanto scrive il vicepresidente della commissione vaticana, estesa a tutti i riti latini.
Va ricordato che nella diocesi di Milano, oltre alla messa domenicale in rito ambrosiano antico nella chiesa del Gentilino (concessa a suo tempo dal cardinale Carlo Maria Martini), dallo scorso ottobre esiste un’altra celebrazione secondo la liturgia preconciliare, promossa dal Movimento liturgico benedettiano, che si svolge a Legnano.
A quasi due anni dalla pubblicazione del motu proprio si attende ancora l’istruzione che dovrebbe precisare le condizioni applicative

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Funny conversation I must share about “dogma” theme Sundays

From a skype conversation with one of my witty interlocutors:

"[08:31 AM] … : Next week in the Novus Ordo is Trinity Sunday.  We hate these dogmatic "theme" Sundays.  People could care less about dogma.  I wish the Novus Ordo had "Why Humanae Vitae is Infallible Sunday" and "Why Women Should Take Their Proper Place in Church Governance Sunday – None – and Why Sunday".  How about, "Why People Do Go to Hell Sunday" and "Surprise!  God Does Speak Through the Magisterium Sunday"?  People would come flocking to listen to those homilies!"

 

 

Posted in Lighter fare, Mail from priests |
20 Comments