Summit on the Church in China

According to the Bollettino, from 30 March – 1 April at the Vatican there will be a summit on important questions concerning the Church in China.

The first session (did we hear much about it?) was 11-12 March, which considered the Pope’s letter to Chinese Catholics.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Bp. Tobin’s “interview” with Pres. Obama

From His Excellency Most Rev. Thomas J. Tobin, Bishop of Providence, RI, in the 12 Feb 2009 Rhode Island Catholic.

My emphases.
      

WITHOUT A DOUBT
My Interview with President Obama

Posted Feb 12, 2009
   
BY BISHOP THOMAS J. TOBIN

(The following is an interview I didn’t have, but can imagine having, with President Obama.)

BISHOP TOBIN: First of all, Mr. President, congratulations on your election and inauguration. They were certainly historic events that inspired a renewed sense of unity and hope for many Americans.

PRESIDENT OBAMA: Thank you, Bishop Tobin. Yes, the goal of my campaign and election was to bring people together, to heal the divisions of the recent past and to inspire new hope for all the citizens of our great country.

TOBIN: I think we’d all agree that your goals of unity and hope are very worthwhile. But for that very reason, many of us were surprised, and even disappointed, that you signed an executive order overturning the so-called “Mexico City Policy” within the first few days of your administration. As you know, your action directs that American tax dollars be used to fund abortions overseas. Why did you have to act so quickly on such a controversial policy?

OBAMA: Well, I believe it was important for me to fulfill the campaign promises I made to Planned Parenthood and other abortion providers. After all, they’re among my biggest supporters and I don’t want to disappoint them.

TOBIN: But the use of tax dollars to pay for abortions is very controversial. It’s a divisive policy. It violates the conscience of millions of Americans who respect life and oppose abortion. Isn’t that completely contrary to your goal of fostering unity in the nation?

OBAMA: Bishop Tobin, let’s be clear. I said in my inauguration speech that with all the problems our nation is facing we have to overcome narrow ideological positions and move beyond childish behaviors.

TOBIN: But, Mr. President, providing tax money to support abortion – isn’t that in itself an ideological position?

OBAMA: No, not in my view.

TOBIN: But do you consider the heartfelt convictions of pro-lifers to be “childish behaviors?”

OBAMA: Well, not exactly, but let’s move on . . .

TOBIN: Is it safe to assume that you consider the use of tax dollars to pay for abortions overseas to be good foreign policy?

OBAMA: I believe that people overseas should have the same rights we Americans have – the right to kill their children and use abortion as a form of birth control.

TOBIN: But shouldn’t we be using foreign aid for more positive reasons – for example, to provide food, clothing, shelter and medicine to impoverished children?

OBAMA: Bishop, obviously you’re missing the point. If you control the population and eliminate the children, you don’t have to worry about giving them food, clothing, shelter and medicine now do you?

TOBIN: Mr. President, during the campaign you said that you wanted to reduce the number of abortions. And yet now you’re providing American tax dollars to encourage abortions overseas. Isn’t that a contradiction?

OBAMA Let me be clear. During the campaign, I was talking about American babies. People in other countries have to make their own decisions about killing their children, and if that’s what they want to do, I’m willing to help them. But let’s move on . . .

TOBIN: Sir, you’ve taken a very strong stance against the use of torture, a decision that’s been widely applauded. But at the same time, some scientific studies have shown that the procedures used in abortion cause terrible pain and suffering for the unborn child. Isn’t that a form of torture too?

OBAMA: Um . . . let me get back to you on that.

TOBIN: Mr. President, there’s a very good chance that during your term in office you’ll have the opportunity to appoint new justices to the Supreme Court. When that opportunity comes, will you use the support of abortion as a litmus test for their appointment?

OBAMA: I don’t believe in litmus tests for court appointments. But you can rest assured that no one who respects the right to life for unborn children will get anywhere near the Supreme Court.

TOBIN: Mr. President, don’t you see the contradiction in what you just said?

OBAMA: No I don’t, but please . . . can’t we just move on?

TOBIN: Alright, then let’s get to the heart of the question. Mr. President, when does life begin?

OBAMA: That question, Bishop, is way above my pay grade.

TOBIN: Mr. President, you have a consistent record of supporting abortion, and you’ve been called the most pro-abortion president ever. In light of your radical pro-abortion stance, can you and your administration give any hope at all to pro-life Americans?

OBAMA: To quote my favorite campaign slogan, “Yes we can.”

TOBIN: Can you be more specific?

OBAMA: No I can’t. But, Bishop Tobin I see that the clock is ticking away and our time is up. Unfortunately we’ll have to wrap-up our interview.

TOBIN: Thank you for your time Mr. President, and happy Presidents Day.

OBAMA: Thank-you, Bishop Tobin. And please extend my appreciation to all my friends in Rhode Island who voted for me.

Catch his follow up piece: Jesus Wasn’t Always Nice.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

What priests should do in the face of the floods

CNA has this story: Record flood causes Catholic Charities North Dakota to call on priests

Fargo, N.D., Mar 27, 2009 / 05:50 pm (CNA).- Flooding has reached ‘code red’ status in parts of Fargo as river levels eclipse a 1897 record, causing Catholic Charities to call on all priests in the diocese to assist with the recovery effort by filling sandbags, assisting with counseling and tending to other vital needs.

By all means…. priests should get involved!

But priests can also do things others cannot:  The priest intercedes with God for the people as a priest, alter Christus.

First and foremost, let the priests be priests.

Father, say Masses for this intention.

Get out there with the Rituale Romanum.

Do all things which the circumstances call for, but don’t forget that special set of tools God gave by ordination.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

NCR: Former Vatican ambassador thinks bishops shouldn’t speak out

From the utra-dissenting National Catholic Reporter… an editorial.  My emphases and comments:

Politicizing Communion harms interests of the church
Mar. 26, 2009
By THOMAS PATRICK MELADY

It was only a few decades ago that no one questioned a fellow Catholic’s decision either to receive or not to receive the Eucharist. This tradition has been slowly and regrettably  [he sets the table here] compromised over the past 20 years. Holy Communion has become, in some circles, a political football.  [Is he reducing the Communion to a political issue?  It sounds like it.]

The trend is unmistakable:

    * The vice president of the United States was told by the bishop of his native city that he should not present himself for Communion there. The full body of the U.S. bishops at its general meeting in November 2007 approved an election guide called “Faithful Citizenship” intended for all U.S. Catholics. However, the bishop of the vice president’s diocese said he did not regard it as “official.”  [Well.. it isn’t… not in the sense that it overrides a bishop’s authority in his diocese.  Bishops have the obligation to guide their flocks and protect them from scandal which public figures act against the clear teaching and discipline of the Church.]
    * A former Republican official is circulating a petition among Catholics urging all bishops to bar Gov. Kathleen Sebelius of Kansas, President Obama’s nominee to head the Department of Health and Human Services, from receiving Communion in every diocese in the country, including Washington.  [Has the Gov. of KS become known for certain positions against the teachings of the Church even though she says she is Catholic?]
    * Most recently, disturbing statements have been made severely criticizing the archbishop of Washington and the bishop of Arlington, Va., because they refuse to politicize the Eucharist. [Yes… Melady is viewing the Eucharist only as a political tool.  That is clearly his dominant hermeneutic.]  A few individuals claiming to be “courageous and dedicated Catholics” have publicly criticized these two fine shepherds for allegedly violating their responsibilities to respect the sanctity of holy Communion. How disappointing it is when there is every appearance that the motives of those criticizing these bishops are political.  [HUH?  Melady is the one reducing this to politics!]

I’ve had some personal experience with those who question the motives instead of the ideas of their political opponents.

In the early stages of the 2008 presidential election, a few of us noticed the bitter tones being used by some Catholics to describe several prominent candidates. They were openly referred to as “baby killers.” A friend and I coauthored a statement on civility, which called on both sides of the partisan aisles to be frank, candid and forceful in their analysis of the candidates, emphasizing, however, that a respectful tone ought to be used in presenting their findings in the public square.

The statement was warmly greeted by many, though my wife Margaret (who authored a book on Pope John Paul II) and I were publicly informed by one rabid partisan that we were “damned to hell” for advocating civility in the discussion of these issues.

I fear that the situation is getting out of control. Many had hoped that once the presidential elections took place, Republicans, especially Catholic Republicans, would practice engagement with the Obama administration and those on the other side of the political aisle [Still filtering this question through the lens of politics….] — that we would present our ideas without the rabid emotionalism that serves only to question the integrity of our opponents. [So… the people he doesn’t like don’t reason, they emote.]  Our role, in the best traditions of a pluralistic democracy, would be that of the loyal opposition.

Pope Benedict XVI modeled this sort of behavior when he met in mid-February with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, a Catholic who favors abortion rights. The Holy Father spoke clearly and candidly in calling the Speaker’s attention to the responsibilities of Catholic public officials to support Catholic teachings on life. There was no mention of not being allowed to receive Communion.  [And she wasn’t there for a Mass, either.  And why should the Holy Father do her bishops’s job for them.  Isn’t that is why there are bishop?  Shouldn’t the Holy Father apply subsidiarity also?]

Likewise, when Benedict visited the United States last year, a few partisan activists wanted the Holy Father to forbid a select few Catholic members of Congress who attended the papal Mass from receiving the Eucharist. That, of course, did not occur.  [Perhaps it should have?]

As a lifelong Republican, I am concerned by the actions of a few party activists who claim that the Republican Party is the only party appropriate for Catholics. Their method has been to involve a few Catholic prelates in criticizing Democratic candidates. [It might be that those people aren’t actually trying to politicize this.] This small group of lay Catholic Republicans is actively campaigning to pressure the bishops with petitions to ban certain high Democratic officials from receiving Communion. This is not their responsibility.  [Well… every Catholic is obliged to try, within the bonds of his vocation and ability, to prevent abuse of the Eucharist.  It is everyone’s responsibility, out of charity, to help prevent people from going to Hell from neglect, from sins of ommission or commission through respect for the principles of fraternal correction.]

Bishops, like all citizens, have the right and duty to engage in public debate on all issues. [Again… when bishops speak about Holy Communion, they are not speaking on a political issue.]  But the activity of a very few is harming the influence of a majority of bishops who are seeking to engage the opposition in a civil manner.  [This sounds like what the Italians call "buonismo".] When these actions are combined with those of a few lay Catholics who use the church’s teachings to achieve political goals, it harms the long-term interests of the church.  [Does it not harm the long-term interest of souls simply to ignore the issue of scandal and defiance of the Church’s teaching on the part of very public Catholic figures?]
 
I suggest that we carefully study and follow the official position of the U.S. Catholic bishops as pronounced in their November 2007 statement on “Faithful Citizenship.”  [Study away!  That document does not limit the rights and duties of bishops.  Let’s avoid the trap of turning the conference into something that it is not.]

Further, I urge all American Catholics to look to the inspiration of Pope John Paul II.  The Holy Father was very clear on the teachings of the church when it came to the life issues and to questions of marriage.  [Pope John Paul II promulgated the 1983 Code of Canon Law, which includes can. 915.] He was, however, never uncivil or negative in describing individuals who were not following the teachings of Christ in these matters.  [Have any of those bishops who have taken steps in regard to pro-abortion Catholics been uncivil?]

He set a high standard for civility and human decency. It is one we should all aim to emulate.

Dr. Thomas Patrick Melady is the former U.S. ambassador to the Vatican. He was also ambassador to Burundi and Uganda. The president emeritus of Sacred Heart University in Fairfield, Conn., he also served in the administrations of three Republican presidents.

 

NCR is only interesting in what a Republican says when he agrees with their positions.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
54 Comments

The Lancet suggests that the Pope is a liar

There was an editorial in The Lancet about the Pope’s remarks on Africa, AIDS and condoms.

My emphases and comments.

Editorial
The Lancet, Volume 373, Issue 9669, Page 1054, 28 March 2009

Redemption for the Pope?
The Lancet

  The Vatican felt the heat from an unprecedented amount of international condemnation [No mention of the support?] last week after Pope Benedict XVI made an outrageous and wildly inaccurate statement about HIV/AIDS. On his first visit to Africa, the Pope told journalists that the continent’s fight against the disease is a problem that “cannot be overcome by the distribution of condoms: on the contrary, they increase it”.
The Catholic Church’s ethical opposition to birth control and support of marital fidelity and abstinence in HIV prevention is well known. But, by saying that condoms exacerbate the problem of HIV/AIDS, the Pope has publicly distorted scientific evidence to promote Catholic doctrine on this issue.
The international community  [WOW!  Everyone everywhere?!] was quick to condemn the comment. The governments of Germany, France, and Belgium released statements criticising the Pope’s views. Julio Montaner, president of the International AIDS Society, called the comment “irresponsible and dangerous”. UNAIDS, the UN Population Fund, and WHO released an updated position statement on HIV prevention and condoms, which said that “the male latex condom is the single, most efficient, available technology to reduce the sexual transmission of HIV”. Amidst the fury, even the Vatican tried to alter the pontiff’s wording. On the Holy See’s website, the Vatican’s head of media, Father Federico Lombari, quoted the Pope as having said that there was a “risk that condoms…might increase the problem”. [You see…. people really do notice when the Holy See tries to change what the Pope obviously said in front of cameras.]
Whether the Pope’s error was due to ignorance or a deliberate attempt to manipulate science [What a stupid thing to say.  Simply to accuse the Pope of purposely lying is over the top.] to support Catholic ideology is unclear. But the comment still stands and the Vatican’s attempts to tweak the Pope’s words, further tampering with the truth,  [Thank you Press Office et al. for making the problem worse!] is not the way forward. When any influential person, be it a religious or political leader, makes a false scientific statement that could be devastating to the health of millions of people, they should retract or correct the public record. Anything less from Pope Benedict would be an immense disservice to the public and health advocates, including many thousands of Catholics, who work tirelessly to try and prevent the spread of HIV/AIDS worldwide.

Okay…. what’s it going to be.   This snarky editorial in The Lancet?  Or what that prof at Harvard said?

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

Stations of the Cross: J. Card. Ratzinger & St. Alphonsus Liguori

It’s Friday in Lent

I have two audio projects of readings of the Stations of the Cross

The Way of the Cross – Joseph Ratzinger (Good Friday – 2005)

Way of the Cross by St. Alphonsus Liguori (voice and with chant)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Stations of the Cross: J. Card. Ratzinger & St. Alphonsus Liguori

USCCB Newsletter from Committee on Divine Worship

The new issue of the Newsletter of the USCCB’s Committee for Divine Worship is out.

Two articles are of greater interest to WDTPRSers.

First, there is "Now is the Time for Catechesis on the Roman Missal".  We must prepare for a good reception of the new translation which is coming!

Let us not forget that while the orations for Masses are not yet finished, the Ordinary of Mass is. 

Change is coming.  Priests and people should prepare for the day when the new Ordinary kicks in.  We need to know and understand what is going on, especially so we can respond to those who will choose to get "stuck on stupid" – those who will stomp their feet and hold their breath not because they don’t understand the texts, but because they do and choose to dislike them.

If we are smart, we will be able to avoid some avoidable problems.  It is important that, when the new translation comes into force, people in the pews are not blind-sided by the changes.

Let’s be smart about what is inevitable and necessary.

Second, there is an article on the training of pastor musicians "Five Questions on the Formation of Music Ministers".

I was amazed to find all sorts of citations of this and that document, some of great authority such as Sacrosanctum Concilium, all talking about wonderful and rich concepts.

There was not a single reference to Latin.

"But Father! But Father!" you are surely exclaiming.  "If this issue is focused on the new translation, why would it talk about Latin?"

Because, dear readers, Latin might be important to the Latin Church’s Latin Rite Catholics participating in the Latin Rite. 

If you are going to cite your favorite bits of Sacrosanctum Concilium once in a while you ought to cite Sacrosanctum Concilium 54 (Cf. Musicam sacram 47), namely, that pastors of souls make sure their flocks know how to sing and speak in both Latin and their mother tongue.

Do you think that maybe Latin might have something to do with the Church’s treasury of liturgical music?

So, what are the questions in the newletter?

1. What does the Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy have to say specifically about the proper training of liturgical ministers?

2. Is there any mention of formation in the General Instruction on the Roman Missal that refers to proper formation for ministry? 

3. How does Co-Workers in the Vineyard of the Lord encourage the formation of music ministers?

4. What does Sing to the Lord: Music in Divine Worship have to say specifically about the formation of music ministers?

5. Has the USCCB Commission on Certification and Accreditation (USCCB/CCA) contributed to encouraging the ongoing formation of music ministers?

I am all for lots of good catechesis!

We must have a good preparation for the new translation.

But do we have to be so obtuse?  So narrow?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

TLMs are not hard for the young… on the contrary

TLMs are not hard for the young... on the contraryWe all know… especially the liberals know… that the young take to the TLM like little ducks to water.

It is amazing how quickly boys can learn the Latin responses with some coaching and a good example.  They like serving the TLM, with its clear structure. 

Taking a cue from the grownups, they know they are doing something important and they revel in it.

A reader sent an interesting note (edited):

While news from South Africa has not been encouraging perhaps you would consider posting this story.
 
While some in SA are finding minor liturgical changes difficult, two young boys from the inner-city have started serving the Traditional Latin Mass. The boys only saw the TLM for the first time recently. But from that time they have been very eager to learn to serve the "old" Mass. Their mother made sure that the boys practiced their Latin at home and very soon they were word perfect.
 
The boys worked very hard never missing a single practice. They are now eager to learn more about the mass, continue with further server training and have even expressed an interest in learning a bit of Latin.
 
It would be a great encouragement to the boys and the cathedral faithful if your readers would send them congratulations and good wishes either in your comment box or at http://unavocesa.blogspot.com/ 

I remember some years ago a reader of my articles in The Wanderer and the blog sent me a book to read… which he wanted back!… a book for boys, actually… about a cadre of altar boys in a parish in, perhaps, the 1930’s – my memory isn’t clear. 

I wish I could remember the title.  It would be perfect for a reprint project.

From what I have seen in parishes on two continents, the TLM and formation of young men in good things, discipline and especially the virtue of religion, are a strong match.

We should give young men a fighting chance to acquire the virtue of religion in this age of the war on boys and manhood.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool, SESSIUNCULA |
33 Comments

Morse SMS

I think there should be an app for creating and sending SMSs on an iPhone using Morse code so that they will still be text when the other person gets them.

Someone should clasp this Morse idea to their bosom and make the app.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Reform of royal succession

Apparently there has been some discussion of reform of royal succession in England.

Reform of royal succession

Posted in Brick by Brick, The future and our choices |
35 Comments