New Archbp. of Westminster tomorrow?

Paolo Rodari mentions that the name of the successor of Cormac Card. Murphy-O’Connor to the See of Westminster may be announced tomorrow.

Tutto potrebbe risolversi addirittura questa settimana. O meglio domani, il giorno in cui Benedetto XVI dovrebbe annunciare, dopo settimane di previsioni più o meno verosimili, il nome del successore di Cormac Murphy-O’Connor alla guida dell’arcidiocesi di Westminster.

Rodari mentions some of the rumors about the man to be appointed, including a parish priest of a London parish, whose name is "top secret".

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
35 Comments

Tornielli’s commentary on the Pope’s Letter

The intrepid Andrea Tornielli, who was first to speak in the press of Pope Benedict’s letter to bishops of the workd world about the SSPX excommunications, has a comment on the Holy Father’s gesture.

Damian Thompson posted an English translation.  I touch it up here and there and add here my emphases and comments:

It is an articulated, beautiful, humble and at the same time strong text: the Pope wants to create clarity about the controversy raised by the lifting of the excommunication of the four Lefebvrian bishops and by the Williamson case, and comments upon criticism flared up also and especially within the Church. He does so with a letter sent to all Catholic bishops, recalling that the case "has raised inside and outside the Catholic Church a discussion of such vehemence as had not been experienced anymore for a long time." Benedict XVI recalls the "avalanche of protests" and the accusation made against him of wanting to go back on the Council. "A misfortune for me unforeseeable was the fact that the Williamson case has superimposed itself on the remission of the excommunication. The discreet gesture of mercy towards the four bishops ordained validly but not legitimately, suddenly appeared as something entirely different: as a disavowal of the reconciliation between Christians and Jews, and therefore as the revocation of what in this area the Council had clarified for the way for the Church." The invitation to reconciliation with a group which had separated itself has then been presented as a desire to create new divisions between Christians and Jews. In the words of Pope Ratzinger emerges all the pain that this instrumentalisation has caused to him, given that precisely the reconciliation between Christians and Jews "from the outset had been a goal of my personal theological work." Benedict XVI explains that in future the Holy See will have to pay more attention to news disseminated on the Internet [d’ya think?] (the statements of Williamson were in fact circulating on the Web even before the publication of the revocation of the excommunication) and adds: "I was saddened by the fact that even Catholics who ultimately could have known better how things stand, have thought it necessary to strike at me with a hostility ready to attack. [You can feel this palpably from the Pope’s letter.] Precisely for this reason I thank the more the Jewish friends who have helped to promptly clear away the misunderstanding and to restore the atmosphere of friendship and trust." The Pope then deplores the fact that the revocation of the excommunication itself, "the scope and limits of the measure" were not "set out clearly enough at the time of its publication." [read: it was botched] And he specifies that the excommunication affects persons, not institutions: the withdrawal is a disciplinary act, which is quite separate from the doctrinal area: "The fact that the Fraternity of Saint Pius X does not possess a canonical position in the Church is not based ultimately on disciplinary grounds but on doctrinal ones"  [It is not merely a matter of obedience to the Roman Pontiff, but also doctrinal.  An interesting clarification from the Roman Pontiff.] and its ministers, even if "they were freed from ecclesiastical punishment, do not exercise in a legitimate way any ministry in the Church."

Continuing on this theme, the Pope announces his intention to connect the Ecclesia Dei commission, which deals with the Lefebvrians, with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. [This is interesting. It would have been thought more natural to join it to the Congregation for Divine Worship.  But the fact that it is to be associated with the CDF, indicates that in the Pope’s mind the liturgical matter is settled.]  And speaking of the Council he says: "The magisterial authority of the Church cannot be frozen in the year 1962 – this should be quite clear to the Fraternity. But to some of those who designate themselves as defenders of the Council it must also be recalled to memory that Vatican II brings with it the the whole doctrinal history of the Church. Who wants to be obedient to the Council must accept the faith professed in the course of the centuries and cannot cut the roots of which the tree lives."  [Exactly!]

Benedict XVI – and this is the most moving part of the letter – then answers the critical question that many have asked him in these weeks: was the lifting of the excommunication necessary? Was it really a priority? The Pope replies that his priority as universal pastor "is to make God present in this world and to open to men the access to God. Not to just any god, but to the God who spoke on Mount Sinai, that God whose face we recognise … in Jesus crucified and risen." At a time when God disappears from the horizon of men, we must "have at heart the unity of believers", because their discord and confrontation "calls into question the credibility of their talking about God." [wonderful] Even "small and medium-sized reconciliations" are therefore a part of the priorities for the Church. The "quiet gesture of a hand stretched out" has instead resulted in a great noise, thus becoming "the opposite of a reconciliation." But the Pope explains how on the contrary it is necessary to strive to reintegrate, to prevent further radicalisations, to make efforts to loosen hardenings and to give room to what there is positive. "Can a community leave us totally indifferent" – the Lefebvrians – "in which there are 491 priests, 215 seminarians … 117 brothers, 164 sisters and thousands of the faithful? Should we really leave them to drift away far from the Church?". Benedict XVI does not hide from himself that from the Fraternity for a long time have come "many dissonant things – pride, a patronising know-it-all attitude, unilateralisms etc. For the love of truth I must add that I have also received a series of moving testimonials of gratitude, in which was made perceptible an opening of hearts." But he adds that also in the ecclesial environment dissonances emerged: [Watch this:] "At times – he ends with a pinch of bitterness – one has the impression that our society needs at least one group for which it does not reserve any tolerance; which one can unperturbedly set upon with hatred. And if someone dares to approach them – in this case the Pope – he too loses the right to tolerance and even he may be treated with hatred without fear and restraint." [Very poignant and exactly right.]

Benedict XVI has therefore lifted the excommunication of the Lefebvrian bishops with the eyes of a pastor concerned for the unity of the Church, who stretches out his hand and offers mercy. This quiet gesture does not yet mean full unity, as long as the doctrinal issues are not clarified. The unfortunate negationist interview of Williamson was not known to the Pope when he approved the decree: to read what happened as a change of direction with respect what was determined by the Council in the relations with the Jews was an instrumentalisation, to which even Catholics lent themselves, although the Pope admits that the scope of the measure should have been better clarified. The Church does not go back on Vatican II, but Vatican II does not constitute a fracture, a new beginning, with respect to the two thousand years of Christian history. It is to be wished for that all the bishops, also and especially those who have criticised the Pope, read well the humble and strong words of the Servant of the Servants of God and understand the attitude of a merciful father, which seeks to foster the unity of those who believe in Christ, to bear witness of Him in a world that has made God disappear from its horizon.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments

Benedict’s letter to bishops: a note

I understand that the Frankfurter Allgemeine has a text in German purporting to be the letter His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI sent to the bishops of the world about the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops.

On the website of the Vatican Press Office there is a note about the release of the text in various languages tomorrow.  We will have to make sure the texts match.

I will take a look at the German text and get back to you.

UPDATE 1511 GMT

In the meantime… I was struck by the following:

Ich höre, daß aufmerksames Verfolgen der im Internet zugänglichen Nachrichten es ermöglicht hätte, rechtzeitig von dem Problem Kenntnis zu erhalten. Ich lerne daraus, daß wir beim Heiligen Stuhl auf diese Nachrichtenquelle in Zukunft aufmerksamer achten müssen. Betrübt hat mich, daß auch Katholiken, die es eigentlich besser wissen konnten, mit sprungbereiter Feindseligkeit auf mich einschlagen zu müssen glaubten.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

Pope Benedict to the world’s bishops about SSPX Bp. Williamson

The intrepid Andrea Tornielli has posted (my translation):

At noon on Thursday there will be made public a seven-page letter which Benedict XVI is sending to all the bishops of the Catholic Church to contend with the case of the revocation of the excommunication of the Lefebvrite bishops and the polemics resulting from the Bishop Williamson’s interview denying the gas chambers.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
41 Comments

Who was behind the Connecticut legislation?

I understand that the anti-Catholic legislation introduced in the Connecticut Legislature has been put on hold.

An interesting detail:

The legislation was withdrawn at the request of the one who proposed it.

Interesting, no?

"But Father! But Father!", you might be saying.  "Who proposed this in the first place?"

I’m glad you asked.  Read this closely.

The New Haven Register credits Connecticut attorney Thomas Gallagher as spearheading the bill, and an article by an officer of the dissident Catholic group Voice of the Faithful in the Diocese of Bridgeport stated that Gallagher had been in dialogue with legislators on this issue since 2007.

 

Look at this article, "A proposal: Look to Civil law to reform parishes", in the ultra-lefty dissenters mouthpiece the National Catholic Reporter, which supported the scheme in Connecticut.

The article is by Thomas Gallagher

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
57 Comments

Reese, SJ: middle-ground destroy excess embryos only?

In a Reuters article, Jesuit Thomas Reese, seemingly ready to compromise with the world, has apparently made a suggestion about Pres. Obama’s decision on embryonic stem-cell research.

I am not making this up.  This is what the Reuters article says.  However, note that Reuters does not have a quote.

Father Thomas J. Reese, senior fellow at the Woodstock Theological Center of Georgetown University, suggested several ways the Obama administration could find some middle ground.

Reese’s suggestions include not creating embryos for the sole purpose of research but instead using only excess embryos produced at fertility clinics that are scheduled to be destroyed anyway.

 

I think Fr. Reese should clarify what he means.

UPDATE: 0536 11 Mar

I had a note from the Phil Pullella of Reuters who wrote the article of interest.  He assured me that his reporting was accurate.  He took my own comment, namely, that Reuters didn’t have a quote from Reese, to mean that I doubted that Reese said it and that Pullella got it wrong.

In a sense I both do doubt it and I don’t!  It is hard to believe a priest would make such a recommendation.  Still, it is Reese.  Therefore, on the strength of Pullella’s article I don’t doubt it at all.

My comment about the quote, above, wasn’t meant to cast doubt on the accuracy of the Reuters article.  I want that to be clear.  Pullella is a pro and wouldn’t write something like that if he couldn’t substantiate it.

UPDATE: 1428 11 Mar

I link to an article wherein Reese has his say:

Reese:

… Here are some suggestions.

1. Embryos for research cannot be bought and sold. Embryos should not be created for the sole purpose of research. They should only come from excess embryos produced at fertility clinics that are scheduled to be destroyed anyway.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Reese, SJ: middle-ground destroy excess embryos only?

Tabula delenda est: Fr. Finigan on The Tablet

His Hermeneuticalness has a very good commentary on The Tablet.

Excerpt:

Founded in 1840, the Tablet has been through various different hands, being owned by the hierarchy for several decades, sold to a group of laity by Cardinal Hinsley in 1935, and taken on by “The Tablet Trust” in 1976. Its greatest period was under the Douglas Woodruff who edited the paper from 1936 to 1967. Reading through some back numbers from 1967-1968, it is evident that there was increasing pressure for a change in the Church’s teaching regarding the morality of contraception; but the issue of 3 August 1968 marked the definitive break.

Fr. Finigan concludes:

Tabula delenda est.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

Holy See/Austrian “Convention” signed

According the CNA the Holy See and Austria signed a concordat last Thursday.  It was a "Convention Regulating Patrimonial Relations between the Vatican and Austria".

hmmm…

You don’t suppose …. Could the whole Linz/once Bishop-elect Wagner kerfuffle have been a factor…

nah … no way…  couldn’t have been.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Holy See/Austrian “Convention” signed

Lunchtime

The morning started with some very strong coffee. During Lent it is just coffee for breakfast most mornings.   This week I am using a blend I make from French Roast and Sumata Mandheling.

Lunchtime

For lunch, its a Tomato Basil soup I scratched up and a Grilled Cheese Sandwich (cheddar on rye).   Classic.

Lunchtime

LunchtimeThe birds are at it also!  The finch type birds, here Pine Siskins and Redpolls, with scatterings of the American Goldfinch Eating Team, can drain these thistle-seed socks in a couple days.

Lunchtime

Posted in My View |
22 Comments

WDTPRS: Tuesday 2nd Week of Lent – Post communionem (2002MR)

We continue our project of looking at the Post communions of Lent:

Tuesday – 2nd Week of Lent

POST COMMUNION (2002MR):
Sacrae, nobis, quaesumus, Domine, mensae refectio,
et piae conversationis augmentum,
et tuae propitiationis
continuum praestet auxilium
.

You find this is the 8th c. L.Sac. Engolismensis: Sacrae nobis quaesumus Domine mensae libatio et piae conuersationis augmentum et tuae propitiationis continuum praestet auxilium.

We saw once before that the snipper-pasters of Bugnini’s Consilium changed the more ancient libatio to refectio.  This refectio has been a common element of our Lenten ferial prayers. 

Pius, when applied to God indicates his mercy, but when applied to man it describes our "dutifulness".  Conversatio is not just "conversation", but rather "manner and conduct of life".  You find it fairly often in a monastic spiritual context.  Propitiatio in its fundamental meaning meanings and "an appeasing, atonement,  propitiation".  The dictionary of liturgical Latin Blaise also gives us a view of the word as "favor".  This makes sense.  God has been appeased and rendered favorable again towards us sinners by the propitiatory actions Christ fulfilled on the Cross.   Propitiatio was also in the Collect.  Auxilium has both a military and a medium overtone, as not just "help" but "an antidote, remedy, in the most extended sense of the word".

Continuus, a, um is really interesting.  In the first place it is "a joining, connecting with something, or hanging together, in space or time, uninterrupted, continuous".  Thus is also designates an act that in time immediately follows something, "immediately, forthwith, directly, without delay".  It therefore can mean not just "continuously" but also "speedily, without interval". 

SLAVISHLY LITERAL VERSION:
Let the refreshing of the sacred table be for us, O Lord, we beseech You,
both an increase of our dutiful manner of life,
and the continual/speedy help of
Your propitious favor
.

How are you going to handle continuum here?  Come up with your own, smooth and flawless version.

Posted in LENT, WDTPRS |
3 Comments