Bp. Williamson reflects on poetry… a good niche?

SSPX Bp. Williamson is using his blog to think aloud about the poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins.

This is a good occupation for him.

He concludes his entry:

Could weary men but once more find their way
To God, how light and fresh would dawn the day!

 

I hope in the long run he is able to made lemonade from lemons.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

QUAERITUR: Communion if I missed the Gospel because of 3 yr old

QUAERITUR: Communion if I missed the Gospel because of 3 yr oldFrom a reader:

Hi Father, here is my question:  my wife and I regularly attend the TLM.  During Mass we share looking after our rather energetic 3-year old. This often leads one of us to be outside of the church (in the entrance way for example) with our little boy during the Mass, and it is not unusual for one of us to miss the proclamation of the Gospel either in Latin or English or both. 

So, if I do not hear the Gospel can I go to Communion? 

Is privately reading the Gospel enough if I’ve missed the proclamation?  Are the rules different at the NO as opposed to the TLM?   I have asked two priests about this and have received two different answers.  Thank you.

 
Thank you for being interested and desiring to do the correct thing.

I cannot imagine why the "rules", if there were hard and fast rules, should be different for the TLM or the Novus Ordo.  I suppose the clearly great rigor, the more demanding nature of the TLM suggests a greater or deeper response of participation from the faithful.

But there are no hard and fast rules about this matter.  There has been discussion forever about "how much of Mass is enough".  Let’s not get too far into that.

The fact is, in your case as you describe it, you are present there at Mass at least in your moral intention.  You are trying to be there. You are indeed there but for that little necessary interlude. 

If you step out with your squeaker for a few minutes, for the love of God, your neighbor and liturgical decorum, then you are not "leaving Mass".   You would still be morally present, unless I suppose you decided to head across the street to the local pub for a pint and a cigarette, junior being an excuse to leave Mass… if you get my drift.

Another point: it is possible to be physically present at Mass and have your mind a thousand miles away.  People can even be seen to be going through the motions or even singing and yet internally they are hardly participating at Holy Mass.  Rather, they are thinking about getting their car washed or wondering about the baseball game …. which … come to think of it might itself be holy and liturgical.  But I digress.

Taking the howler out will help others participate at Holy Mass.

I note that you also mention going back and reading the Gospel on your own.  Good.

So… my answer is YES…  in the circumstances you offered here you may go to Communion if you took the little darling out to the vestibule and missed the Gospel.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
37 Comments

Der Spiegel: great interview with SSPX Bp. Fellay

A kind reader sent me a translation of the interview Der Spiegel did with SSPX Bp. Fellay, their superior.

My emphases and comments.

Williamson Apology ‘A Step in Right Direction’

Bishop Bernard Fellay, head of the Society of Saint Pius X, has told SPIEGEL
that his organization has "clearly distanced itself" from Bishop Richard
Williamson
. Nevertheless, he says the bishop’s apology for his Holocaust
denial is a step in the right direction.

SPIEGEL: Bishop, weeks ago you gave your colleague Richard Williamson a book
so that he can read up on the Holocaust. Last week he published an apology
which falls short of the Vatican’s demand that he retract his Holocaust
denial. Does Williamson’s statement suffice in your opinion?

Fellay: It is definitely a first plea for forgiveness and, therefore, an
important step in the right direction.  [read: 1) no, or 2) I’m not saying.] One can always hope for better phrasing. [Not better content?] At least the plea for forgiveness is honest, and the withdrawal of his words is genuine. [I think that is reasonable.] 

SPIEGEL: That hope seems unfounded. After his arrival in London, Williamson
surrounded himself with people who have openly denied the Holocaust, such as
the historian David Irving. Do you know why?  [A fair question.]

Fellay: I have the impression that Bishop Williamson is being used by these
people
. Information was deliberately fed to the media here. We’re working
against that as well as we can. I am totally against these connections. [Is Williamson that naive?  I would like to think so.]

SPIEGEL: But your influence on Williamson seems to be weak. [Direct!  Well done, Spiegel.]

Fellay: We are in contact, he is in a priory of the society in London for
the time being. But he is also a free human being. Sure, he has a superior,
but he is free in his decisions. But he has to bear the consequences for
that.

SPIEGEL: Will he return to his full duties?  [Great question.]

Fellay: That is impossible under the current circumstances. He has damaged
us and hurt our reputation
. [!] We have very clearly distanced ourselves. He was
not ordained as a bishop for his own personal purpose [?  I profoundly hope that it true.] but for the common good of the church, to spread the revealed truth.

SPIEGEL: So why don’t you exclude Williamson from the society?  [Again, good question.  Though you can hear the hostility within it.]

Fellay: That will happen if he denies the Holocaust again. [!!] It is probably
better for everyone if he stays quiet and stays in a corner somewhere. I
want him to disappear from the public eye for a good while.  [Isn’t this EXACTLY what I have been saying all along?]

SPIEGEL: The Vatican could reinstate the excommunication because he has not
made a retraction.

Fellay: I doubt that. [So do I.] Denial of the Holocaust, as serious as it is, isn’t
part of Canon Law
— so an excommunication isn’t possible. It isn’t just we
who say that, it is canons, legal experts. The problem is that his comments
have been linked to his office
.   [Exactly.  Some people have a hard time making distinctions, for lack of knowledge or lack of will.]

SPIEGEL: Regensburg’s Bishop Gerhard Ludwig Müller has denied the German
Pius seminary in Zaitzkofen permission to ordain more priests. Will you
adhere to the ban
?  [Did they ever have permission from the local bishop?  I rather think not.  I would like to know for sure.  A formal reminder for the sake of a canonical procedure down the line?]

Fellay: That was unnecessary and inappropriate. [Well.. yes, unecessary.  "Inappropriate"… a matter of perspective.]  All these events definitely
are a setback for us. It throws us back by 10 years. But ordinations will
continue to happen
.  [grrrr]

SPIEGEL: In Germany politicians fear that schools run by the society don’t
share the values of the German constitution
. Are you concerned that there
will be inspections?

Fellay: I’m not worried about that at all. We are normal people. We observe
the rules, and that includes the state order
. [The state‘s rules, at least.]  Even if one voice said something wrong. It is expressly written in the epistles of the Saint Paul
that we honor authority and pray for it.

SPIEGEL: So Williamson is someone who has gone astray and criticism of the
society is a big misunderstanding?

Fellay: Now we’re the world’s scapegoat, [pretty nearly true!] and every wrong step immediately turns into a scandal. But mistakes that need to be corrected are made all
the time and everywhere.

SPIEGEL: Why did you respond so late to Williamson’s crude theses?

Fellay: I confess that I didn’t take the situation seriously enough.

Interview conducted by Stefan Winter.

A few things.

First, there is a question naïveté.  Was Williamson so gullible about whom he chose to meet in London?  Was Bp. Fellay really that innocent about the press and about the state of the culture war, especially in Europe.

Second, it seems that, now, Williamson will remain out of the public eye.  This is exactly what I hoped he would do.  This is exactly what had to happen.

Third, it seems that they really are taking steps to deal with this serious problem.  To that extent, what happened may turn out to be positive.

Fourth, I regret that they will simply ordain as usual.  Chosing to submit in some way to the local bishop and/or Holy See in ordinations could be very helpful.  Other factors will override that, of course.

Fifth, the SSPX has a base which the leadership must check and keep on their side.  It these difficult times they will feel the obligation to keep their support, also financial support, close.

I will keep the combox closed, lest the weak find this an occasion of sin and post seriously knuckle-headed comments.  You can e-mail me and I will receiew what I receive and post what is worthy of your attention.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Der Spiegel: great interview with SSPX Bp. Fellay

WDTPRS: Monday 1st Week of Lent – Post communionem (2002MR)

We continue our project of looking at the Post communions of Lent:

Monday 1st Week of Lent

This prayer is ancient, found in the Veronese Sacramentary in the month of July.   It is in the Liber sacramentorum Engolismensis and Gellonensis, variations of the Gelasian.

POST COMMUNIONEM (2002MR):
Sentiamus, Domine, quaesumus,
tui perceptione sacramenti,
subsidium mentis et corporis,
ut, in utroque salvati,
de caelestis remedii plenitudine gloriemur
.

We have sensing verbs: sentio… perceptio.

Perceptio, (from the verb percipio) is basically a “a taking, receiving; a gathering in, collecting.”  It is also, by extension, “perception, comprehension”.   I "perceive" that you "gather" what I am saying.

St. Ambrose in his Commentary on Luke 4, 15 uses this noun with “frugum fructuumque reliquorum… a gathering of the produce of the earth and of the remaining fruits”.  At the time of his Holy Communion in the 1962MR the priest says (now in the 1970MR in a shortened version): "Let not the partaking (perceptio) of Your Body, O Lord Jesus Christ, which I, unworthy, presume to receive turn out to be unto my judgment and condemnation: but by Your goodness, may it become a protection of soul and body (mentis et corporis) and remedy to be received (percipiendam).…”

We had subsidium also in the PC of Ash Wednesday.  The verb subsideo gives us the substantive subsidium originally meaning, “the troops stationed in reserve in the third line of battle (behind the principes), the line of reserve, reserve-ranks, triarii.” By extension it also means “support, assistance, aid, help, protection.”

Glorior is deponent… passive in form and active in meaning.

LITERAL VERSION:
May we sense, O Lord, we beseech You,
by this taking in of the Sacrament,
the support of mind and body,
so that, having been saved in both,
we may vaunt in the fullness of the heavenly remedy.

What pops out for me is that stark in utroque salvati… saved in both body and soul.

There are also a couple prominent currents in the language.

First, there is the medicinal.  The prayer feels like a plea for healing.  We want to be saved by a remedium.

Then there is the military.  The sacramentum has overtones of the military oath taken by soldiers, which comes to be used in Latin to express Greek mysterion.   Subsidium is a line of troops in support of those in the front lines.  We seek protection of mind and body and glory at the end. 

In another sense it could be agricultural/economic, I suppose.  Think of the gathering and fullness notions which save mind and body.  I don’t think anyone hasn’t heard about "subsidies" these days.  But I digress.

Our Lord took our full nature into a bond with His Divinity so that both might be saved.  Our Lenten discipline, our spiritual warfare, isn’t just a physical matter.  It is mental, spiritual, emotional.  We seek to mortify body for the sake of the soul.  We seek to challenge the mind so that the body will follow.  We will be attacked by the Enemy on both fronts.  The battlefields of the Lenten discipline will affect both dimensions, because… as the theology of the body developed in the last decades reminds us, we are out bodies.  We are not angels. 

Wound or heal the one and you affect the other.

Your Lenten project should be well-defined and smart.  Keep a clear eye on what you are doing for Lent.  Remember that mortifications have effects that reach beyond what you immediately sense.

The prayer reminds us also of the role of the sacraments and sacramentals in this battle.
>

Posted in LENT, WDTPRS |
2 Comments

Prayers requested

Please pray for His Eminence Francis Card. Arinze as he leads the Lenten days of reflection for the Holy Father and the Curia.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

iTunes PODCAzT feed – problem?

Are any of you having trouble with the iTunes feed for the latest PODCAzT?

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
8 Comments

POLL: The Sunday Meal

POLL: The Sunday MealA question has popped up in several ways during these last few days which prompts this poll.

I was watching part of a cooking show recently with the English chef Gordon Ramsay.  Vocabulary aside, he is promoting a laudable project through one of his TV shows.  He want to revive the Sunday Meal.   He goes to a home, finds out what they do on a Sunday, and then shows them what they might be able to cook so as to get people, family and or friends, around the table to sit together for a while and enjoy the repast and company.  He even changes their dining room furniture to help make the experience easier and more pleasant.

A big Sunday meal – call it supper – call it dinner – whatever.

It could perhaps even be "out".  I think many people have a regular practice for going for Sunday "brunch", for example after Mass.

In Rome at a church entrusted to the Chinese community, people have a big "pot luck" meal together after Mass before they go their separate ways.

There is something about meals together.  The Lord used meals for important moments in his ministry, both at Cana and the upper room.  

I have good memories of, for example, the Sunday meal at the rectory of my home parish.   After the Masses were over, the priests, and usually some seminarians and others, would enjoy a formal meal together taking us up to the time for Vespers and Benediction, sung each Sunday in the church in Gregorian chant.  The meals were always cordial, leisurely, and packed with interesting and wide ranging conversation.  These meals expressed a culture in the house and also shaped that same culture.  One of the only places I have ever seen Presbyterorum ordinis actually lived in important respects.

Alas… that has been eliminated there and in so many other places … much to the harm of the bonds of society, whether that society is a family, a rectory community or larger society.

The bonds of society are important.  Pull them apart and barbarity ensues.  This is in large part what Dante was dealing with in his Inferno of the Divina Commedia.  The souls in hell were being punished in proportion to how during life they had attacked or torn apart the bonds of society.

So all this is rattling around in my head.

Then a friend called this morning and actually suggested this as a question for a poll.

Here we are.

I am talking about doing this regularly, not just occasionally.  I don’t know how often regular might be, but I know it when I see it.

There are people out there, on the Dies Domini, eating apart – even in families – when they might eat together and both strengthen each other and the bonds of charity.  (cf. Dies Domini 72-73)

Vote and post about what you do for your Sunday Meal.

POLL CLOSED

Do you generally have a Sunday meal with others?

  • Yes (65%, 833 Votes)
  • No (35%, 455 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,288

Posted in POLLS, SESSIUNCULA |
84 Comments

BENEDICT XVI’s PRAYER INTENTIONS FOR MARCH

Two very fine intentions from the Holy Father this month.

Remember: When you are asked, or are required to pray for the Holy Father’s intentions, when, for example, you are seeking to gain an indulgence, you are to pray for the intentions the Holy Father designates.  You are not just praying for the intention of the Holy Father, that is for him (though that is a great idea!).

Also, you don’t have to know specifically what his designated intentions are, you can just pray for them.

BTW… below you will see "Popular" Republic of China.  That is a transliteration from Italian "Repubblica Popolare".  The person who wrote the English text was asleep at the switch this time, but you know what is meant.

BENEDICT XVI’s PRAYER INTENTIONS FOR MARCH

Pope Benedict’s general prayer intention for March is: "That the role of women may be more appreciated and used to good advantage in every country in the world".

His mission intention is: "That, in the light of the Letter addressed to them by Pope Benedict XVI, the bishops, priests, consecrated persons and lay faithful of the Catholic Church in the Popular Republic of China may commit themselves to being the sign and instrument of unity, communion and peace".

 

May God help China.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
34 Comments

PODCAzT 79: Augustine on your solidarity with Christ; your voicemail

This PODCAzT, the first in a while, is a bit of a blast from the past.  I am going back, on this 1st Sunday of Lent, to the topic of the very first PODCAzT I made.

It seems appropriate.

I am learning to use new hardware, a wonderful new microphone sent by a reader from the amazon wishlist, together with new software on a different computer!  Therefore, I had to find all new settings and balances and… well… everything.

Also, I have started to think through what I really want to do with these PODCAzTs… Where do I want them to go?   I would like to build them in such a way that they could be used by others more easily.

Anyway, day I pick up the Liturgy of the Hours and drill into St. Augustine’s take on a couple verses of Ps. 61… 60 in Augustine’s day.

Then I offer some of your messages left on my skype voicemail.

Some of the sound levels might not be quite on target here.  Again, I am re-learning everything!

Still, in realistic humility about my own capabilities and in appreciation for so many of you who have been asking me for more PODCAzTs….. here you are!

PODCAzT 79: Augustine on your solidarity with Christ; your voicemailFinally, I think the iTunes feed is working.

Posted in Classic Posts, Linking Back, Patristiblogging, PODCAzT | Tagged , , , ,
12 Comments

Card. Mahony on the “Tridentine” Mass

His Eminence Roger Card. Mahony of Los Angeles shares his view of the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite and, consequently, of the decision two Popes made to emancipate the older, pre-Conciliar form of Holy Mass.

The setting: On Friday, February 27, 2009 [NB: There is a typo on their site indicating "2008", but this is a 2009 chat, from the 2009 Religious Education Congress.] , at 11:15 a.m. PST,  ChurchWerks.com hosted an online chat session with Cardinal Mahony, live from the main Exhibit Hall at the Religious Education Congress in Anaheim, Calif.

Ann Scolari: What are your thoughts on the Trindentine mass?

CardinalMahony: Ann:  The Tridentine Mass was meant for those who could not make the transition from Latin to English [or other languages] after the Council.  But there is no participation by the people, and I don’t believe that instills the spirit of Christ among us.

 

Could not make the transition?   What are they, stupid?  Have they been lied to?

No participation by the people?  What are they doing there? 

Doesn’t instill the spirit of Christ?   What is going on there, Your Eminence? 

Are Eastern Catholics stupid or not participating or not instilling the Spirit of Christ if they attend the Divine Liturgy in their sacral liturgical language and their mode of participation, shut out by a screen and forced to listen?

WDTPRSers, I put it you now:
 
Imagine that a bishop, any bishop, might say things about a highly charged topic during a media interview.

Imagine that during Q&A he grossly mischaracterizes something dear and sacred to a group of people, something that touches on their very identity.  

Imagine that this imaginary bishop states, in the media, things which are clearly false, even contrary to the teachings of the Church in the Vatican Council and subsequent legislation of Popes. 

This imaginary bishop really believes his position to be true, but his statements – however sincerely believed – are deeply offensive to a interested group who have in the past been marginalized and mistreated.

Even people who do not prefer to attend Holy Mass in the older form should be offended by what Card. Mahony said to the world in this online chat. 

He slapped our ancestors, Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI, and everyone who loves our Church’s Holy Mass and Divine Liturgy in all its beautiful, meaningful, sacred and legitimate forms.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Card. Mahony on the “Tridentine” Mass