For when it actually happens?

I’m chillin’ the Widow!

For when it actually happens?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
31 Comments

I’d gladly pay you Tuesday for a poll response today

I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a poll response todaySome say the burger is the perfect food group.

So what’s it gonna be?

A hamburger?  A cheeseburger?

Of course, you can add all sorts of other things, such as lettuce or tomato, or a smear of mustard or mayo.

Call it a "California" Burger.

It can be on a regular bun, or an onion roll, or even open-face, like a patty-melt.

You can have onions raw or grilled or fried or sauteed.

You can have ketchup or … not.

You can even put pickles on it.

But I think the essential difference lies in the addition or subtraction of cheese.

Whatever sort of cheese.

POLL CLOSED

Which sort of burger do you most often choose?

  • Cheeseburger (with or without other stuff) (77%, 950 Votes)
  • Hamburger (with or without other stuff) (23%, 279 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,229

 

Posted in POLLS |
84 Comments

The Remnant: SSPX reconciliation by 2 February?

The traditional Catholic paper The Remnant has a piece by a frequent comment writer here, Brian Mershon, about a possible reconciliation of the SSPX with Rome perhaps by Candlemas, 2 February.

I will not parse Mershon’s whole piece, for it is pretty long-winded and you should in justice visit the Remnant also.  But here are some salient bits:

Brian Mershon
(Exclusive to The Remnant)

…

In fact, Vatican sources have indicated that the full regularization may occur as early as February 2, 2009, the Feast of the Purification of Our Lady and Candlemas, which, if true, would be quite a Christmas present to the Church and especially traditionalist Catholics worldwide!

Vatican Working on Stable Juridical Structure

Monsignor Ignacio Barreiro, chief of Human Life International’s Rome bureau, could not confirm the February 2 date, ["…not confirm…"] but said his Curial source told him that they are currently busy working out the practical arrangements for a fully regularized Society of St. Pius X.

The final solution “cannot depend upon individual diocesan bishops,” [no kidding!] Monsignor Barreiro said, noting the longsuffering many traditionalist Catholics experienced for nearly 20 years under the Ecclesia Dei Adflicta arrangement.

“They would certainly need to have guarantees that where they currently are located, they cannot be touched by the local bishop,” Barreiro said, noting the Society’s chapels being located across the globe, which he described as “de facto parishes.”  Barreiro rightly noted that the Society bishops most likely would not accept any solution that involved jurisdiction by the local territorial Ordinary. [Well… okay.  But the local bishop can’t really be ignored can he?  Even if this winds up being a personal prelature, the local bishop has to have some say.  This will need some creative thinking.  But the Commission has access to some very good canonists.  Very good.]

France’s Seminaries to be Over One-Third Traditionalist

In fact, specific resistance is most prevalent in the dying churches of France with their bishops and priests.  [One French priest I know said Mass attendance in regular churches was about 2%.  In years, he had heard a handful of confessions.  God have mercy.] Upon final regularization, Monsignor Barreiro said, “More than one-third of all seminarians in France will be in traditionalist seminaries.” This would include the SSPX, the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP), the Institute of Good Shepherd and the Institute of Christ the King (ICR) as well as some other lesser known traditionalist priestly groups.

“I expect that some structure like a universal Apostolic Administration may be the only solution,” Monsignor Barreiro said, while cautioning that he did not have direct access to the specific details.

…

Vatican II and All the Councils

“They won’t be asked to accept the Council,” Monsignor Barreiro said. “There is nothing dogmatic regarding faith and morals in the Council documents,” he emphasized. “Many have elevated the Council as if it were a superdogma, when in truth, it was not dogmatic at all.”  ["superdogma" ….  sounds familiar these days…]

…

Vatican Will Not Demand SSPX Swallow the Council

In other words, there will be no demand for the SSPX leadership to accept the “Decree on Social Communication” as an infallible, dogmatic document.  [ACK!  NO!?!  Okay… deal’s off…]

And despite the ruminations of certain bishops, cardinals, priests, Cardinal Kasper and even George Weigel, neither will they be asked to accept the Decree on Ecumenism, the Declaration of Religious Liberty, Nostra Aetate or even Lumen Gentium and Dei Verbum as dogmatic declarations that can stand alone without reading them in light of Tradition.  [Which would be an unreasonable claim, wouldn’t it.  All the Council’s documents must be interpreted in the light of our Tradition.]

…

I know Msgr. Barriero and know him to be a solid and thoughful source.  He has a good canonical view as well.

Folks… let us repeat this even as we pray over the hopeful developments:

People of good will ought to be free to disagree over things which are not crystal clear, over the difficult questions raised in the Council’s documents.

Humility is needed on both sides, on the part of those who represent the Holy See and Pope Benedict and those of the SSPX who will offer their concerns and perspectives.

At all costs the Council, or it’s "spirit" must not be elevated to a "super-dogma", which can never be questioned or challenged.

Neither should the SSPX see themselves as the sole-saviors of the Church, who have all the answers and need not submit to Peter or give assent to the Church’s teachings.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
78 Comments

Are pro-lifers falling into the FOCA Trap?

I received this very interesting note from a staffer of a US Congressman whom I will not identify for obvious reasons.  I have his permission to share this:

My emphases

Fr. Z:

As a Congressional staffer, I am extremely concerned that we pro-lifers are falling into what I am starting to see as the “FOCA Trap.”

If my fellow conservatives in Congress – policy makers who actually know what’s possible and what’s not – were speaking privately, I think they would admit that FOCA doesn’t have a snowball’s chance of ever even getting a committee hearing let alone being passed or signed into law. That is because it’s so radical that even most of the pro-abortion Democrats probably wouldn’t even support it.

Now, all this begs the question: why are all the bishops and most of the pro-life activists singularly focused on it?   [Good question.  Are they falling for a head feint?]

The quick answer is because Obama said at some point that he would sign it into law. Then all the activists, talk radio, the USCCB, etc. all kicked into gear and started on the offense. But is that a good thing?

As I said, anyone serious who knows the Hill knows it will never pass – including Obama. So, while the wagons are all circled around FOCA, Obama, the Democrats and the pro-abortion lobby can pick apart the incremental progress we’ve made over the years on partial-birth, overseas abortion funding, funding for abortions on military bases, embryonic stem cell research, etc. And they’ll do it while we’re all signing post cards in church about FOCA. It’s a brilliant diversion.

[“… a brilliant diversion…”]

Then, one day, Obama will come out against FOCA and say it’s too extreme. Then he’ll be heralded as a moderate, all while our progress is wiped out, and millions more babies are murdered.

Father, unless I’m very wrong, we are falling into the FOCA Trap and we must stop now, protect the gains we have made and fight like mad every time the next Mexico City fight comes instead of just saying “Oh well, we knew he’d do this.”

We need to keep our eyes on the real enemy – and that is not FOCA.

Very interesting!

Calm discussion, please, or I will toss you.

This is too important to clutter with the bone-head stuff that adds nothing of use.

Posted in The future and our choices |
59 Comments

Card. Castrillon: Bp. Fellay recognized Vatican II

The johnny-on-the-spot site Rorate has two good pieces you would do well to look at.

First, there is an entry called Cardinal Castrillón: Relevant declarations to Corriere della Sera   Also check Corriere.

Here is a salient point or two:

The Holy See did not know about SSPX Bp. Williamson’s interview with a Swedish TV station in which he spoke about the Holocaust.

Also… and this is HUGE…. HUGE:

Full communion will come. In our discussions, Bishop Fellay recognized the Second Vatican Council, he recognized it theologically. Only a few difficulties remain…

It is precisely about these difficulties that we must pray.  We must pray that people of good will can disagree about points which are not clear and still remain in unity.

Also check out New Fellay interview: "The eventual separations will be minimal"

Key points:

 

Did you expect, Your Excellency, this removal of the excommunication concerning you?

[Fellay:] I expected it since 2005,…

 

After that he dodges around a little, I think mostly for the hard-line followers, but his intention is clear enough.

It is the beginning of something, which had already begun with the Motu proprio [Summorum Pontificum]. I think that the Pope appreciates the work that we do.

And,

In this development, this movement, some have held that you departed too late. Do you believe today that others, especially inside the Fraternity of Saint Pius X, may hold that you are departing too soon?

I cannot rule out everything, but, in case there are separations, they will be extremely minimal.

And more importantly:

 

[Fellay] Up to now, our roadmap has been to clarify first the doctrinal problems – even if it does not mean settling everything, but obtaining a sufficient clarification – or we risk doing things incompletely. Or it may end up badly.

And do you believe that, beyond Rome, your contacts will intensify?

[Fellay] It is the goal, as I explained in Rome, by saying that the situation, as we propose it, is certainly temorary, but it is pacifying, and that it will allow all souls of good will to catch up. This will thus be done gradually. And this will also depend on the reaction on the other side. But there is no a priori, the only a priori is that of Truth and of Charity.

 

As I have been writing repeatedly for day… people of good will ought to be able to disagree on things which are not absolutely clear and still remain in union.   We need a sufficient agreement, not perfect agreement.

This is one of those situation in which we must not let the perfect be the enemy of the good!

Also, anyone truly interesting in the Truth, must be willing to sit and discuss in Charity.

I am very glad for what I have read here.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Dissenter Leonardo Boff against Pope Benedict on SSPX

And now… another dog bites man story from a washed up dissenter.

This is in from ANSA:

Liberation theologian and dissenter Leonardo Boff has determined that the lifting of the excommunications of the four SSPX bishops was a mistake.

It is obviously part of the Pope’s conservative program and it might lead to a schism on the left!

It is nice to know that Boff agrees with me that Pope Benedict has a program.

I don’t have time or energy to translate this, but some of the highpoints….

  • The concession of the remission is surprising, even scandalous!
  • It’s part of the conservative viewpoint of the Pope who is distancing himself from Vatican II.
  • The Pope is trying to create a mono-political unity in the Church which is not open to dialogue.
  • He was condemned for his theology when Ratzinger was Prefect of CDF and now this!
  • The Pope is trying to revise the Council.
  • This isn’t a pastoral approach.  A pastor should be more prudent.
  • He is weakening the consensus that formed around the Council.
  • And yet he defended the decision about Williamson, who is an isolated voice without significance outside his own fundamentalist world.
  • Williamson should have no impact on the Church outside of what the media stirs.
  • He likes Pres. Obama and thinks Pres. Bush should be tried for war-crimes.
  • Blah blah

» 2009-01-29 21:17
LEFEBVRIANI: BOFF, RATZINGER RISCHIA SCISMA DEI PROGRESSISTI
Di Roberto Cattani

BELEM (BRASILE)- La revoca della scomunica ai vescovi lefebvriani fa parte di un progetto conservatore di Papa Benedetto XVI, che potrebbe portare ad uno scisma in seno alla Chiesa cattolica: lo ha detto all’ANSA il teologo brasiliano Leonardo Boff, uno dei fondatori della Teologia della Liberazione, che partecipa a Belem al World Social Forum. "La concessione del perdono ai lefebvriani è sorprendente, e per molti settori della Chiesa addirittura scandaloso – ha detto Boff -. E’ chiaro che fa parte della logica di Papa Benedetto XVI, che intende unificare la Chiesa conservatrice, tradizionalista, che prende le distanze dal Concilio Vaticano II, e per questo progetto, per lui, i lefebvriani sono alleati naturali". "Così – ha proseguito il teologo francescano – il Papa rafforza le sue posizioni e crea un’unità più monolitica della Chiesa, che non è un’unità aperta al dialogo, un’unità di comunione".

"Posso solo dire – ha aggiunto ancora Boff, che era stato condannato per le sue tesi progressiste da Ratzinger quando questi era prefetto della Congregazione della Fede – che ritengo deprecabile questo passo del Papa, anche perché ho il fondato sospetto che i lefebvriani non si accontenteranno di questa vittoria, passeranno presto ad esigere di più, fino ad arrivare ad una revisione del Concilio Vaticano II. E una cosa del genere, se si dovesse arrivare a tanto, potrebbe portare addirittura ad uno scisma nella Chiesa, perché il Concilio Vaticano II è universale, e una rottura con le sue conquiste è una rottura nel corpo della Chiesa".

E questo nonostante l’appello del Papa ai lefebvriani affinché riconoscano il Concilio. "Ritengo perciò – ha proseguito il teologo, che oggi insegna all’università brasiliana di Petropolis – che si tratti di una politica rischiosa questa che il Papa porta avanti. Innanzitutto non è una prospettiva pastorale, non è prudente, e il pastore dev’essere per forza prudente. E poi indebolisce tutti quelli che vogliono la Chiesa riunita attorno al vero consenso creato di forma ufficiale, che è stato e rimane tuttora il Concilio Vaticano II". Sul vescovo negazionista Williamson, Boff ha invece difeso Benedetto XVI.

 "Quella di Williamson è una coscienza alienata, falsa – ha detto il teologo francescano nell’intervista all’ANSA – D’altronde è stato subito corretto in maniera chiara e inequivocabile dallo stesso Papa, che sull’argomento della Shoah é già tornato più volte senza ambiguità". "Il problema piuttosto è che le assurdità del vescovo inglese sono il segnale più vistoso di un certo livello di fondamentalismo ecclesiastico per il quale non esiste nulla al di fuori della galassia ecclesiale: il mondo finisce con la Chiesa". "Le sparate di Williamson non hanno nessun significato al di là dell’individuo – ha commentato Boff – E’ effettivamente una voce isolata, che non dovrebbe avere nessuna ripercussione al di là del fatto mediatico, non ne vale la pena, mostra solo l’ignoranza della persona, ma non depone certo contro la Chiesa nel suo insieme". Boff ha anche espresso "speranza e fiducia" nel neopresidente americano Barack Obama. "Come teologo a me sembra una figura provvidenziale – ha detto Boff – Sembra proprio che Dio abbia avuto pietà del mondo, dopo gli anni di presidenza di George W. Bush, che invece dovrebbe essere processato per crimini contro l’umanità".

RABBINATO RICEVE RISPOSTA S.SEDE E VALUTA INCONTRO
Segnali di distensione – culminati in uno scambio di lettere – si sono fatti strada tra il Rabbinato di Israele e il Vaticano, dopo le minacce di rottura dei giorni scorsi"Passi avanti" verso la ripresa del dialogo, dicono a Gerusalemme, anche se potrebbero essere necessari "ulteriori chiarimenti". La crisi aperta tra ebrei e cattolici con la revoca della scomunica ai quattro vescovi lefebvriani coincisa con le dichiarazioni negazioniste di uno di questi è una ferita ancora aperta, ma le parole pronunciate ieri dal Papa sulla Shoah, la rinnovata "solidarietà" ai fratelli ebrei e la condanna del negazionismo sono state un balsamo benefico.

 Apprezzate da molti esponenti del mondo ebraico, sono state seguite da uno scambio di lettere tra il Rabbinato di Israele e il presidente del Pontificio consiglio per l’Unità dei cristiani, card.Walter Kasper, e da una serie di dichiarazioni di condanna dell’antisemitismo giunte dal mondo cattolico. Abbastanza per non far prendere troppo sul serio le nuove dichiarazioni negazioniste giunte, stavolta, dall’Italia, dal capo dei lefebfvriani del nordest Don Floriano Abrahamowicz, che restano per gli ebrei e per la stragrande maggioranza dei cattolici, incluso il superiore dei lefebvriani italiani, "inaccettabili" ma che – secondo fonti ebraiche – "non possono e non devono annullare i passi avanti fatti finora nel dialogo tra ebrei e cristiani".

 La lettera inviata da Kasper a nome della S. Sede è stata giudicata dal direttore generale del Gran Rabbinato di Gerusalemme, Oded Wiener, "importante, molto bella e molto seria". "Kasper – riferisce all’ANSA – ribadisce l’importanza che la Chiesa annette al dialogo con noi e chiede che l’incontro fissato per l’inizio di marzo abbia luogo nella data prestabilita". Una richiesta che verrà valutata la prossima settimana in "maniera approfondita".

 "All’inizio della prossima settimana – ha proseguito Wiener – esamineremo la lettera del cardinale Kasper congiuntamente con il testo del discorso pronunciato ieri da papa Benedetto XVI, che pure era molto importante non solo per gli ebrei ma per il mondo intero perché respingeva i negazionisti della Shoah. Quel discorso ha rappresentato un passo avanti per la soluzione della vicenda". Wiener ha aggiunto che è comunque possibile che anche in seguito all’esame di quei documenti il Rabbinato necessiti ulteriori chiarimenti. Del resto, aggiunge Wiener, le esternazioni di Abrahamovicz, secondo il quale le camere a gas "servivano solo a disinfettare", dimostrano "quanto era opportuna la nostra immediata reazione". E chi nega la Shoah "deve essere in carcere, e non fra i leader religiosi". "Da entrambe la parti – ha osservato, riferendosi al mondo ebraico e a quello cattolico – occorre fare ogni sforzo per lottare contro il fenomeno (del negazionismo, ndr) finché è circoscritto, per impedire che il veleno si diffonda". Meno distesi i toni della comunità ebraica tedesca, che ha deciso di interrompere temporaneamente il dialogo con la Chiesa cattolica a causa della revoca della scomunica al vescovo negazionista Williamson, augurandosi "un coro di proteste nella Chiesa contro la decisione del Papa".

La revoca della scomunica viene peraltro criticata anche da duecento sacerdoti e teologi svizzeri, in una lettera aperta alla Conferenza episcopale elvetica. La decisione del Papa viene definita un errore che si iscrive in una serie di decisioni "fortemente regressive" assunte dal Vaticano sotto la guida di papa Benedetto XVI. Della stessa opinione, il teologo della Liberazione Leonardo Boff, secondo il quale l’apertura di credito ai lefebvriani potrebbe condurre addirittura, se fosse messo in discussione il Concilio Vaticano II,ad uno scisma dei cattolici progressisti.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments

A good note from Alcuin Reid on the SSPX development

Several alert readers have sent me the following which I finally tracked down to our friends at NLM.  Go check them out and spike their stats.

The piece says it is from The Catholic Herald, the best Catholic paper in the UK right now, but it must not be published yet. 

This letter is by Alcuin Reid, an editor of solid liturgical resources and author.

Here it is with my emphases and comments.

Let’s thank God for the return of the prodigal sons

Those who wish to cast out the SSPX are like the elder son in Jesus’s parable, says Alcuin Reid

30 January 2009

"I am delighted that you are back. I do not agree with everything you did, but today my heart is filled with joy. You’re back; that is all that now matters." Might not these not have been the sentiments of the father for his prodigal son in the Gospel of St Luke? Might they not also be the sentiments of our Holy Father, Pope Benedict, in lifting the excommunications from the bishops of the Society of St Pius X?

This act is nothing if not an act of paternal love and mercy designed to bring back into the fullness of the family of the Church those who had – at least in one sense – strayed from it. It may also be said to be a true fruit of the bouquet of prayers offered in recent months for this precise intention by members of the SSPX, as well as of the ongoing prayer for Christian unity that is such a feature of the modern Catholic Church.

This is the second major step towards the full canonical integration of the SSPX (the first being the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum). But it is not the last. The four bishops are now "in communion", but as yet they have no canonical mission and they and their clergy still labour under the irregularities that follow from the positions taken since the Seventies, including suspension.  [Right.  So they are on their way back.  In the parable, perhaps they would be at the point where the watchful father has spied them from afar and runs to meet them, but not quite to the point when the father puts rings on their fingers.]

To wave this suspension in the face of returning brethren is hardly in the spirit of the reconciliation that Pope Benedict clearly desires, but it exists and it does need to be addressed, and quickly. This is a delicate period. There is much more to do in preparing for the peaceful integration of the SSPX and that will take time, just as it is taking time to give an appropriate canonical status to the former "Transalpine Redemptorists" in Scotland, reconciled last June.  [To remind people of the suspension is not to "wave" it, in the sense of "waving under a nose".  Many people have misunderstood the lifting of the excommunications as something more than it is: a major step.  And Reid is right that this is a "delicate period".  Not merely are the points of contact thin, not exactly edge-of-knife thin, but at least not wide, there is a time issue involved as well.  It is hard to image a Pontiff better informed and better disposed than Pope Benedict.  also, there is a whole generation of followers of the SSPX who have grown up never having known unity with Rome.  Tick tick tick.]

During the somewhat untidy months ahead, charity and patience are called for – from all perspectives. We ought to note, though, that Rome has been clear for some time that Catholics may attend SSPX Masses out of devotion to the Church’s Latin liturgical tradition, and that they do not thereby commit sin or incur any canonical penalty, so long as they do not do so out of "a schismatic mentality which separates itself from the teaching of the Supreme Pontiff and the entire Catholic Church". Given Pope Benedict’s acceptance of the SSPX’s declaration of its determination to remain Catholic and its acceptance of the Church’s teachings, including the Primacy of the Pope, with filial disposition, it is hard to see how any barrier in simply attending Mass now remains.  [Well… other than the fact that they are not yet in unity with Rome?  I can sure understand this approach, however.  Especially in those many places, in England in particular, where there are so few places a person can easily find celebrations of Holy Mass in the older form, even in inconvenient times and places!]

The issue the validity of the Sacraments of Penance and Matrimony celebrated by SSPX priests (who because of their suspension are unable validly to marry couples or absolve penitents except in danger of death) remains, but we may hope and pray that this is addressed equitably and swiftly.  [Amen and amen.]

Of course, there are other issues involved. That is why Bishop Fellay, while expressing profound "filial gratitude" for Pope Benedict’s "unilateral, benevolent" act has also called it "courageous". The key issue is Vatican II – or certain aspects of it. Archbishop Lefebvre, a Father of Vatican II, signed its Constitutions and Decrees. He lobbied against some of the stances finally adopted, but he nevertheless signed up to them. Later he reacted against their interpretation with what Pope Benedict calls "a hermeneutic of rupture" that was not in continuity with the Tradition of the Church. And the SSPX has continued this reaction – at times intemperately, without making the necessary distinctions between the Council’s pastoral policies and its articulation of Catholic doctrine.  [I hope the discussions can focus on this, rather than the far more difficult issue of whether a overly man-centered (in opposition to God-centered) starting-point made the documents entirely unacceptable.]

Now Bishop Fellay speaks of "reservations" about Vatican II. Reservations are not denials of doctrine, and anyone may have reservations about even an Ecumenical Council’s pastoral policies and be a Catholic in good standing.  [I believe this is precisely what I have been writing continuously over the last few days. People of good will should be free to disagree on very difficult questions arising from documents which are not crystal clear and still remain in unity.]

It is certainly courageous [but not uncharacteristic for Joseph Ratzinger] for the Holy Father to allow bishops who have strong reservations about an event that has so profoundly dominated Catholic life in the past few decades to return to communion with the Church. In doing so he has added to the dialogue about Vatican II – which the Holy Father has himself fuelled – some substantial participants from a very specific perspective. They, too, may be able to contribute to the reading of the Council with that "hermeneutic of continuity" for which Pope Benedict has so famously called.  [Right!  IF both sides can approach the table in humility.]

And then there is Bishop Williamson: it is courageous indeed to welcome back such a prodigal. He is not the first Catholic bishop to espouse untenable positions and he probably won’t be the last. It may help us to retain perspective if we realise that priests and bishops committed to the ordinary use of general absolution, the ordination of women, baptisms using invalid formulae, etc, may – without in any way excusing the extremes of either – seem as beyond the pale to the SSPX as do anti-Semitic holocaust deniers or multi-faceted conspiracy theorists (practically all of the SSPX would reject both).  [Well said!  And in how many places are these abuses tollerated and traditionally minded priests are persecuted?  I can think of a couple.]

It is telling to see Bishop Fellay distancing himself from such positions. Every Catholic bishop is subject to the Church’s discipline, and if Bishop Williamson behaves inappropriately the Holy See may have to act. But the Pope has demonstrated that paternal love and mercy are to be offered even – perhaps especially – to him.

In spite of the difficulties, there is every reason for hope that the SSPX, for their part, truly want and will work for unity. Bishop Fellay has stated that he is "confident" and that he thinks "we will reach a true solution". Their superior in England, Fr Paul Morgan, said when explaining the Holy Father’s act to his faithful last Sunday that the situation is now better than they could ever have expected. This is a tremendous shift.  [I am reminded of Msgr. Perl’s analogy "change of atmosphere" and "climate change".  The former can signal the latter.  I think that is what is going on.]

What has been said hitherto has, at times, been – to put it mildly – somewhat less open. These people are Catholics. They love Christ and His Church and wish to serve her mission. There are also number of small, devout, monasteries and other religious communities who, while not belonging to the SSPX, rely on their bishops for Holy Orders, etc, and who are simply trying to live the Catholic faith as it had been lived for centuries. For the SSPX and these associated communities once again to be in full, unimpeded communion with and under the Bishop of Rome cannot but be for their good and for the good of the Church and of the world.

There were two sons in the parable in St Luke’s Gospel. The older one, who had always remained faithful, felt utterly indignant at the celebration of the return of his profligate brother and stood aloof in disapproval. He was rightly rebuked. Let’s not make the same mistake.

 

Well conceived and well expressed.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

An interesting notion

As I have been writing again and again, people of good will can disagree on really hard questions rising from the Council’s documents on points that are not clear.  We can argue about how to approach ecumenism or religious liberty.

There are somethings we really can’t dispute.

Keep in mind what Bl. John XXIII quoted in Ad Petri cathedram: "In necessary things unity, in doubtful things liberty, in all things charity."

So, I thought a comment of The Recovering Choir Director was spot on.

If the Church can handle Richard McBrien, she can also handle Richard Williamson.

If the Church is accommodating to Remi de Roo, she can also accommodate Bernard Fellay.

Yep.

And it seems as if both Williamson and Fellay both stick to traditional Catholic teaching.

It comes down to discipline, I suppose.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

More from Brisbane’s Fr. Kennedy

More from Brisbane's Fr. KennedyMore from Brisbane on the renegade priest. Fr. Peter Kennedy and St. Mary’s the renegade parish he has distorted.  Check for backgroud here and here and here.

For this last bit of dross, check out Coo-ees from the Cloister.

There is now an audio podcast of the renegade.

Here is some of the analysis from Coo-ees.  You should go to read the rest there and spike the stats.  Tell ’em Fr. Z sent you.

The long podcast is at the site of ABC Brisbane.

But it makes very sad listening. Tragically, Kennedy comes across as the very epitome of all that is wrong with quite a few priests ordained around his time (mid 1960’s), for he sounds in the interview to be theologically incompetent, emotionally damaged, spiritually zonky. He has, as they say, more hang-ups than the cloak-room at an opera theatre. He has hang-ups about clerical dress, clerical titles, clerical identity. He has hang-ups about authority- not just Church authority – and structures. He has hang-ups about Irish piety. And he doesn’t actually seem to believe in very much. Tragically, we’ve all met priests like that.

He says himself in the course of the interview that he doesn’t believe in hell, nor in heaven, nor, in any usual sense, in an "afterlife" at all. He uses the "pre-Vatican II" cliche to describe things he doesn’t like about the Church. He abuses that most abused expression "models of church" by suggesting that the "better" model of Church is the "people of God" model (clearly he has forgotten, if he ever read it, the provisos and subtleties of Avery Dulles’ book) and ascribes to the 2nd Vatican Council a desire to see the Church "run by the people". He quotes "full, conscious and active participation in the liturgy" in support of abandoning approved rites. And all the woolly thinking, unfulfilled searching, illogical thoughts and psychological dysfunctions are couched in terms of "spirituality".

I notice that he avoided going into any detail about the baptismal formula / validity question. That might be TOO easy for the audience to side with "them".

The conversation is peppered with references to this or that person who used to be a priest or used to be a nun. And he is assured by several "scripture scholars" and "priests who are married" in his congregation that his Masses are valid.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

NBC refuses to air CatholicVote.org pro-life ad

I understand that NBC is refusing to air the CatholicVote pro-life ad.

This is in from Free Republic.

According to a Jan. 29 press release from CatholicVote.org, “After several days of negotiations, an NBC representative in Chicago told CatholicVote.org late yesterday that NBC and the NFL are not interested in advertisements involving ‘political candidates or issues.’”

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments