Pro-life commercial from CatholicVote.org

From Catholic Vote (catholicvote.com becoming catholicvote.org).

This is their first commercial.

Posted in The future and our choices |
29 Comments

FSSP reacts to the lifting of the SSPX excommunications

When the late Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre decided to consecrate four bishops without the permission of the Holy See back in 1988, some of his priest broke away.  Seeking unity with the Bishop of Rome, the Pope, they formed the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter.  Rome confirmed their status and they have functioned ever since in union with Rome and Catholic bishops, hopefully providing an alternate to the SSPX.

They reacted today to the news of the lifting of the excommunications of the found SSPX bishops.

Press release of the FSSP following upon the Decree of the Congregation for Bishops

Fribourg (Switzerland), Saturday, January 24th, 2009 – www.fssp.org

The Congregation for Bishops, having made public today the decree lifting the excommunication declared in 1988 regarding the four bishops ordained without pontifical mandate by Archbishop Lefebvre, The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter wishes to express its joy at the news of this step forward towards unity.

Since its foundation, the Fraternity of Saint Peter has not ceased to witness to its double attachment to the Seat of Peter and to the Tradition of the Church, praying constantly that a reconciliation could be achieved between the Holy See and the Society of Saint Pius X.

Today the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter unites itself completely to the hope of the Holy See, desiring “that this step be followed by the prompt accomplishment of full communion with the Church of the entire Fraternity of Saint Pius X, thus testifying true fidelity and true recognition of the Magisterium and of the authority of the Pope with the proof of visible unity”. (Decree of the Congregation for Bishops, 21 January 2009)

The Fraternity of Saint Peter would like to express its profound gratitude to the Sovereign Pontiff. It sees in this magnanimous gesture a call to unity for all Catholics in order to spread in the world, faced with all the contradictions of our day, the Reign of Christ.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

50th Anniversay of the Convocation of Vatican II

On 25 January 1959 Bl. Pope John XXIII, at the Basilica of St. Paul outside-the-walls, called for a reform of the Code of Canon Law, a Roman synod and … a Council.

50 years ago… tomorrow.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

MISCONCEPTIONS: What the “lifting” of the SSPX excom’s means for people

I am seeing a lot of confusion in the wake of the lifting of the excommunications of the bishops of the SSPX.

Let’s get some things clear.

VERY LITTLE HAS CHANGED JURIDICALLY except in the status of those four bishops.

I hope that this has helped to change the "atmosphere" surrounding these problems. 

The "lifting" of the excommunications is a first step in the long process that still remains.

Q: Is the SSPX now legitimate?

Not in a juridical sense, no.  The SSPX still does not have the approval of the Pope or of a diocesan bishop.  It is still a separated group, though these days many prefer not to speak of "schism".

Q: Is it okay for the SSPX bishops to ordain now?

No. The bishops of the SSPX are validly consecrated bishops, but the fact remains that they were illicitly consecrated.  That hasn’t changed.  They are still not reconciled with the Bishop of Rome.  They are still suspended a divinis.  They still have no permission to exercise ministry in the Church.  They may not licitly ordain.  They have no authority to establish parishes, etc.

Q: Are the chapels of the SSPX okay now?

Not in a juridical, legal sense, no.  Many good things can happen in one of those communities, but the SSPX chapels are not, because of the lifting of the excommunications, suddenly made legitimate.  They are not reconciled by this move. 

Q: Are the priests of the SSPX in good standing now?

Not yet they aren’t.  The priests of the SSPX are still suspended a divinis.  They say Mass validly, but without the permission of the Church, either from a faculty of the Holy See or the local bishop.  They do not have the necessary faculties to hear confessions and give sacramental absolution except in danger of death.

Q: Is it okay to go to chapels of the SSPX for Mass?

Yes and no.  It is still not "okay" to go to chapels of the SSPX if you are doing so out of contempt for the Holy See or Holy Father, etc.  If are are deeply attached to the older form of Mass, and it is very hard on you to go without it, yes, you can attend these Masses our of devotion.  You can fulfill your Sunday obligation still, because the 1983 Code of Canon Laws says you do. 

But the fact remains that these are still chapels separated from unity with the local bishop. 

In my opinion, it is not a good idea to go to these chapels exclusively except perhaps in very rare circumstances wherein there really is no acceptable alternative.

Q: Is it okay to receive Communion at an SSPX Mass?

Yes and no.  Yes… if you would otherwise have to go without the Eucharist for a long time because you are morally or physically impeded from receiving in a licit way.  No… if you are doing so because of contempt for the Pope, bishop, Holy See, etc. 

I don’t think it is a good idea to frequent and receive Communion often in the chapels of the SSPX.  I think that undermines a person’s sense of unity with the Holy Father and the local bishop.

Remember: The lifting of the excommunications was a necessary step on the way to something better.

In his letter to followers of the SSPX, Bp. Fellay reminded everyone that they prayed that the older form of Mass would be derestricted, and it was with Summorum Pontificum.  He said there was a Rosary campaign to aid the lifting of the excommunications.  That happened today.  Bp. Fellay now says that we must pray that the necessary talks with the Holy See can begin soon about theological questions.  Amen.  Let us pray.

So… folks… don’t suddenly get it into your head that all the problems with the SSPX have suddenly been removed.  Nothing has changed about their status.  What changed was the status of the four bishops: they are no longer excommunicated, but they are still in a state of separation from clear and manifest unity with the Holy Father.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
75 Comments

SSPX leader writes to their supporters: new prayer petition

The SSPX has sent out a letter of explanation to their followers.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

SSPX leader writes to their supporters: new prayer petitionLetter of the Superior General of the Priestly Society of Saint Pius X

Dear faithful,

As I announce in the attached press release, “the excommunication of the bishops consecrated by His Grace Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, on June 30, 1988, which had been declared by the Congregation for Bishops in a decree dated July 1, 1988, and which we had always contested, [I am trying not to take this as a "neener neener" sort of comment.  The word "contested" raises in my mind the question of whether or not they finally got a canonical process to review the situation.] has been withdrawn by another decree mandated by Benedict XVI and issued by the same Congregation on January 21, 2009.” It was the prayer intention I had entrusted to you in Lourdes, on the feast of Christ the King 2008. Your response exceeded our expectations, since one million seven hundred and three thousand rosaries were said to obtain through the intercession of Our Lady that an end be put to the opprobrium which, beyond the persons of the bishops of the Society, rested upon all those who were more or less attached to Tradition. [I welcome such a petition, and I wouldn’t be sorry to see yet another initiative like this.  There are a lot of people out there who have suffered a great deal because of their attachment to the Church’s Tradition and they don’t get a spotlight!]  Let us not forget to thank the Most Blessed Virgin who has inspired the Holy Father with this unilateral, benevolent, and courageous act to. Let us assure him of our fervent prayers.  [Nicely expressed.]

Thanks to this gesture, Catholics attached to Tradition throughout the world will no longer be unjustly stigmatized and condemned for having kept the Faith of their fathers. [I hope that is true, but I think it is overly optimistic.] Catholic Tradition is no longer excommunicated. [Hrumph.  This is nice flourish, but Catholic Tradition was never excommunicated.  These four bishops were excommunicated, not "Tradition".  And… sorry… these men are not the human embodiment of Tradition. ] Though it never was in itself, [better] it was often excommunicated and cruelly so in day to day events. [Amen.  I agree entirely.]  It is just as the Tridentine Mass had never been abrogated in itself, as the Holy Father has happily recalled in the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum of July 7, 2007.  [Again… a statement like this harks to the idea that perhaps they were pressing for a process to determine if there was ever an excommunication in the first place.  But.. that is a moot point now.]

The decree of January 21 quotes the letter dated December 15, 2008 to Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos in which I expressed our attachment “to the Church of Our Lord Jesus-Christ which is the Catholic Church,” re-affirming there our acceptation of its two thousand year old teaching and our faith in the Primacy of Peter. I reminded him that we were suffering much from the present situation of the Church in which this teaching and this primacy were being held to scorn. And I added: “We are ready to write the Creed with our own blood, to sign the anti-modernist oath, the profession of faith of Pius IV, we accept and make our own all the councils up to the Second Vatican Council about which we express some reservations.”  ["up to"  And including?  I have no problem with "reservations".  I don’t think Pope Benedict would have problems with "reservations" either, considering what he wrote about some of the Council’s documents and his own "reservations" expressed about Gaudium et spes.  "Reservations" aren’t the real obstacle, in the final analysis, though it is necessary to determine what they are and how deeply they run.] In all this, we are convinced that we remain faithful to the line of conduct indicated by our founder, [This is a pep talk for the supporters.] Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, whose reputation we hope to soon see restored.  [Remember that the Vatican Decree is not "retroactive" for the late Archbishop.]

Consequently, we wish to begin these “talks” [ALLELUIA!  May they begin SOON!  Please God.  This would be a good prayer intention.] – which the decree acknowledges to be “necessary – about the doctrinal issues which are opposed to the Magisterium of all time. We cannot help noticing the unprecedented crisis which is shaking the Church today: crisis of vocations, crisis of religious practice, of catechism, of the reception of the sacraments… [There have been bad times in the Church before.. but okay.] Before us, Paul VI went so far as to say that “from some fissure the smoke of Satan had entered the Church”, and he spoke of the “self-destruction of the Church”. John Paul II did not hesitate to say that Catholicism in Europe was, as it were, in a state of “silent apostasy.”  [Not so silent anymore!] Shortly before his election to the Throne of Peter, Benedict XVI compared the Church to a “boat taking in water on every side.” [Remember his stunning Stations of the Cross while the late Pope was dying?] Thus, during these discussions with the Roman authorities we want to examine the deep causes of the present situation, and by bringing the appropriate remedy, achieve a lasting restoration of the Church.  [If something could be worked out with the SSPX to formalize unity, I would stand shoulder to shoulder with them.  In a  sense, we already do, but in a very imperfect way.]

Dear faithful, the Church is in the hands of her Mother, the Most Blessed Virgin Mary. In Her we place our confidence. We have asked from her the freedom of the Mass of all time everywhere and for all. We have asked from her the withdrawal of the decree of excommunications. In our prayers, we now ask from her the necessary doctrinal clarifications which confused souls so much need. [YES!]

Menzingen, January 24, 2009
+Bernard Fellay

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments

Bishop Baker’s Birmingham Brick By Brick Building

A nice note came from a reader about the expanded use of the so-called "Benedictine Arrangement" of a versus populum altar, that is, placing the candles in a straight line, three and three, and the Crucifix in the center with the Corpus toward the priest.  When the local bishops is celebrating, there can be a 7th candle at the center.

Pope Benedict, before becoming Pope, wrote about the important of ad orientem worship stressing the significance of the people with the priest facing the liturgical (not necessarily geographical (East).  Something of the impact of this orientation of worship is accomplished by placing the Crucifix between the people and priest so that IT, not the priest or congregation, remains the focus.

 

Today, January 17th, 2009, Bishop Robert Baker of the Diocese of Birmingham, Alabama held a pro-life Mass at the Cathedral of St. Paul in Birmingham.  There was a march shortly thereafter.  I could not help but notice that on the altar, there were six candles and a Crucifix in the center.  Next to the Crucifix was the seventh candle.  I took some photos from before and after the Mass and would like to give them to you.

 

Bishop Baker's Birmingham Brick By Brick Building

Brick by brick!

Thank you Bishop Baker!

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

UPDATE: Fr. Reginald Foster

Fr. Reginald Foster, famous American Carmelite Latinist who works for the Holy See, is still in the hospital, but he is doing much better.  He has visitors who write with the latest news and they sound positive.

Fr. Foster was told about your prayers and, as one source reports,he "indicated his opinion of the Internet (eyes rolling and humorous exasperation quite plain)".  Furthermore,

I told him many people all over the world were praying for him, many in Latin and some even in Hebrew and he indicated that he was honored, joking how the prayers were obviously better because of the ancient languages.

 

Will you continue to say prayers for him?   Those who read the blog and visit him are sure to mention that you are storming heaven for his recovery.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Will Pres. Obama lift the “Mexico City language” today?

I had a note from someone with irritating news.

I think [Pres.] Obama is going to lift the Mexico City language today, probably around 3 or 4. Classic Clintonesque news dump late on a Friday afternoon.  [It’s called "take out the trash day".]

President Bush reinstated that policy … it was the [perhaps] first thing he did as president on the very first day he was in office.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

Bp. Fellay responds to the Swedish TV re: Bp. Williamson’s interview

My friend Fr. Ray Blake, PP of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton, has found a response by Bp. Fellay of the SSPX to the Swedish TV station which broadcast the inflammatory interview with the SSPX bishop Williamson.

Click to enlarge.

Bp. Fellay responds to the Swedish TV re: Bp. Williamson's interview

The letter is dated 21 January.

The signing of the Holy See’s Decree lifting the excommunications was 21 January.

Coincidence?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

Some thoughts about the SSPX, Rome, and unity

People of good will can differ on theological points and still remain in unity. 

People of good will can attain unity even when they disagree on matters which are by no means clear.

The history of the Church’s great Councils underscores this fact.  Time and time again, Fathers of this Council and that Council or Synod would affix their signatures to creeds or symbols which contained carefully worked out compromises of expression.  Both sides would have to give here and there until the language was acceptable to both sides.  Slowly but surely, brick by brick, Council after Council the Church’s doctrines on the hardest questions became clearer.

I call to mind also the situation of the late Fr. Leonard Feeney, SJ, and his "wildcat group" the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary.  They took a black and white position on the Church’s true teaching that "outside the Church there is no salvation".  This got them in hot water with the Holy See.  Eventually an understanding was hammered out.  The so-called "Feeneyites" were able to be in union with the Church but without having to abjure their position about extra Ecclesiam nulla salus.

The theological problems the SSPX has with the Second Vatican Council or the Holy See or anything else, don’t necessarily need to be the absolute obstruction to unity.  Questions of the role of the Church in the modern world or religious liberty are really hard.  There is room for debate and disagreement.  It is possible for people of good will to disagree about whether or not the fruits of Vatican II were all wonderful.  It seems to me that there is a precedent for closer union even when we consider the theological concerns some SSPXers might be harboring.

Moreover, last September in Rome at a conference held in honor of the first year of Summorum Pontificum, the Vice-President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei made an astute observation applicable to what has happened with the SSPX and these excommunications.  He said that Pope Benedict and Summorum Pontificum there has been a change in the "atmosphere".  We hope, he continued, that a change in the "climate" will follow.  Our weather changes rapidly and can vary in this place or that place, even if they are close.  But climate is a larger concept.  We hope that gestures such as Summorum Pontificum, request of Bp. Fellay that the followers of the SSPX pray the rosary for the lifting of the excommunications, the exchange of Bp. Fellay and Card. Castrillon last June, and now the lifting of these sanctions indictate not just a shift in the atmosphere, but also the whole climate.

The liturgical issues can be, in fact were already to a great extent, solved with the stroke of a pen.  Sure some study went into Summorum Pontificum, but before it was really just a signature that was lacking.  The lifting of the excommunications was preceded by some study and reflection, but it was in the end a signature or two that completed the act.  Regularizing the canonical state of the bishops and priests of the SSPX, or the Society itself, is a matter of a stroke of a pen. It’ll take some planning, of course, but the actual acts will be simple.  Hammering out the theological difficulties to the point where there can be some sort of Protocol will take some elbow grease on both sides, but in the end it will be a matter of signing something and then moving on. 

What it all depends on, to my mind, is the attitude of both sides, the Holy See and the SSPX leadership.  If they really want unity, then they must make these concrete gestures, such as that which we saw today, and then get into the same room, roll up the sleeves, and work things out.  They have to open their minds and hearts and keep in mind that we don’t have to be in lock step about the putative glories of Vatican II, or the efficacy of the Novus Ordo, etc.  It is time to let go of the Council or its "spirit" as some sort of super dogma. 

It is also time to start obeying the Roman Pontiff and tone down the language. 

There is a whole generation of young people who have grown up in these SSPX chapels, listening to their parents and priests, for whom a state of conflict with Rome, with the bad feelings and attitude of superiority and intractability is normal.  They have never known union with Rome and the local bishop.  A clear path for walking this division back to real and clear union with Rome is going to become weedier and narrower and harder to find if this goes on much longer.  The clock is ticking.

In effect, people on both sides have to stop behaving like jackasses and get to work… if they really want union.

I sure do.  I can hardly wait to hear about SSPX priests regularly attending deanery meetings and having a voice on presbyteral councils.

So let the arguing begin in earnest civility. 

In both Rome, and in chanceries and in the rank and file of the SSPX people must open their hearts and not just their minds.

It is possible for people of good will to disagree on very hard questions and still be in union.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
56 Comments