QUAERITUR: which Marian antiphon after Compline?

From a reader:

Compline ends with a Marian antiphon, as you know.  For the Advent and Christmas seasons, the proper antiphon is the "Alma Redemptoris Mater."  After that, you pick up the "Ave Regina Caelorum" through Lent.  This is true in both the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the office.

Here’s the problem–in the older calendar, Christmas season ends on February 2nd (Candlemas).  In the new calendar, it ends on the Solemnity of the Baptism of the Lord.  The latter always comes before the former, usually in mid-January.

What Marian antiphon should be used by someone praying the ordinary form of the office for the period between the Solemnity of the Baptism of the Lord and Candlemas?

If it’s the "Alma…" that would seem to contradict the new end of Christmas season.  If it’s the "Ave…" that would seem to be a rupture with tradition.  Which one wins?

 

The rubric at the end of Compline says:

Deinde dicitur una ex antiphonis Beatae Mariae Virginae … Thereafter there is said one of the antiphons of the Blessed Virgin Mary.

You can freely choose which one you would care to say at the end of the newer form of the office.  In that case you can freely choose to stick to the antiphon traditionally sung according to the older form of the office.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
9 Comments

Gainesville, VA (D. of Arlington): 6 January – Solemn TLM

From a seminarian:

For the feast of the Epiphany, there will be a Solemn High Mass at Holy Trinity parish in Gainesville, VA.  Several local seminarians from the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, the Institute of Christ the King, and St. Charles Borromeo, as well as diocesan priests, will be serving or singing at the Mass.  The parish priests are Fr. Peffley and Fr. Wooton, to whom we are greatly indebted for affording us this extraordinary opportunity to offer this very solemn form of the Traditional Mass.

All are invited and encouraged to witness this magnificent liturgical form of the immemorial Roman Rite.

In Epiphania Domini
Solemn High Mass
Tuesday, January 6th at 7:00 PM

Holy Trinity Catholic Church
8213 Linton Hall Rd
Bristow, VA 20136
www.holytrinityparish.net

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

QUAERITUR: stole over the chasuble

From a reader:

Visiting my grandmother out here in Texas and went to Mass Saturday evening. Saw the priest was wearing his stole on top of the chasuble.

I seriously thought about asking him, politely, if he was aware it constituted a liturgical abuse.

Decided against it in light of his stature as a priest and the mote in my own eye. How would you advise me to act in the future? Obviously I was only visiting, but I was wondering if not pointing out the abuse was a disservice to my brother laymen in the parish.

The stole is to be worn beneath the chasuble.

However, given that you were a visitor there, you probably did the right thing in deciding not to say anything.  If you were going to be there for a substantial period of time, and could get to know the priest a little, then I would bring it up.

Also, perhaps it is not the best thing to ask directly if a priest is aware that he is committing a liturgical abuse.  Be a little more diplomatic.  You might open the question by observing that you haven’t seen a priests generally wear the stole over the chasuble and ask him to explain it. 

Everyone has the responsibility to make sure the liturgy is celebrated properly.  This includes the use of vestments.

However, our approach will count for a great deal… or do a great deal of harm.  We need prudence.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
49 Comments

National Catholic Reporter: undermining your faith yet again

Some years ago I attended in Chicago a meeting of the Catholic Press Association, a left-leaning organization.  Card. George gave a splendid address on the vocation of a Catholic journalist.

His Eminence offered that the role of a Catholic journalist, among other things, was to report on the life of grace.  He added that in order to recognize the life of grace in others the journalists had to be themselves in the state of grace.

They laughed.

It is therefore no surprise that the ultra-lefitist dissident National Catholic Reporter continues to publish rubbish that designed to undermine Catholic faith.

Here is a good example.   The following prompted this brilliant response.

My emphases and comments.

‘With age, my Catholicism holds more uncertainty’

By Rose Murphy
Published:
December 26, 2008

My current, critical reading about religion and my growing disenchantment with the Catholic Church do not proceed without some pronounced unease.  [Good.  You should feel uneasy about this.  You are closer to the end of your life than the beginning and you are allowing your feet to stray from the path Christ gave you to come to salvation.] I feel driven to question beliefs I once held with assured confidence. But am I needlessly cutting off a strong spiritual lifeline by going so rarely to my local church? Am I wallowing in intellectual smugness and neglecting an insistent Catholic tie that goes beyond logic?

It is difficult to stay loyal to a church whose members once unleashed cruel forms of the Inquisition [this old canard again?] on presumably evil non-believers and whose clergy so recently and secretly protected pedophilic priests. [Okay… the Inquisition was… how long ago?] But I am more disillusioned by dogmatic bans on birth control that afflict poor women in developing countries and that too often obscure the core message of Christ’s call for compassion.  [Read: Unless the Church changes her teaching on contraception, the Church is cruel to women.]

Impossible now to recapture that ardent, unquestioning faith I had as a child, and into adulthood [I don’t think "questioning" is a problem, so long as the questioning comes from "faith seeking understanding".] : that Christ was physically present in communion, that I had a special guardian angel, that certain prayers chipped away at Purgatory time. Even after outgrowing those fantasies, [The Real Presence, angels, our connection with the Church Suffering are "fantasies".] I continued to keep a core faith in the larger Church tenets: that Jesus was the Son of God, that he died for my sins, that I was preparing for an afterlife where I would see God and presumably my parents and all those who had gone before me. Today all of that doctrine is hazy to me, not so much rejected as irrelevant. [So, she is not sure that Christ is God or that He died for our sins.] I know now that humans can never penetrate the idea of God; certainty is – and has always been — an illusion. [This is why we speak of faith.]

Intellectually, I can reject much of the Catholic Church, [Because she has a far more penetrating mind than, say, St. Augustine or St. Thomas….] but emotionally it reels me in whenever I wander from it. I am still nourished by certain Mass rituals: [which?] the Prayers of the Faithful (with touching reminders of so much pain among my neighbors), the Sign of Peace and the communal grasp of another hand, the preparations for Eucharist, [not, apparently, including the consecration] and the walk up the aisle to receive communion. Just what am I receiving? I know the act of communion matters to me, feeling the host on my tongue is significant, but I don’t know why.  [This at the same time horizontal and completely self-absorbed.]

But slowly, I am becoming more comfortable with uncertainty and ambiguity. [And Satan has a greater and greater grip.  This is the sort of creeping incrementalism that the Enemy uses to effect.] And I find that meeting the challenge of practicing compassion in this troubled world is much more difficult than showing up for Sunday Mass. More and more, I see Christ as a rebel, an advocate for the poor, an agitator, an outsider who spoke truth to power and paid the ultimate price for it.  [Setting aside the empty buzz words, this is a great example of what Pope Benedict wrote to correct in his first encyclical Deus caritas est.]

His message focused on loving one another, without reservation, not on explaining the Trinity. And whether or not he is the Son of God seems a pointless discussion. [A "pointless discussion"?  Lady… if Christ is not the Son of God, then you and everyone else are probably going to hell.  Also, what circuit is missing from the brains of some lefties that keeps them from understanding that we can love one another and… AND… explain the Trinity?  They are not mutually exclusive.  This is not a zero sum game: either love or explain… you can’t do both.  This so typical of most liberals: you can’t be smart, or intellectual or make distinctions or admit authority and still be nice.]

Such realizations still do not alleviate feelings of restlessness and guilt when I choose a bike ride and coffee on Sunday morning instead of Mass. [Good.] But on those Sundays when I do slip into church, I hear a foreign language all around me, especially when it comes to the Apostles Creed. I cannot dutifully mumble it any longer. I cannot relate to ecstatic utterances about a “personal relationship” with God, because for me such a relationship is impossible. [Though I wonder what sort of parish she is going to…] It smacks too much of a cozy, privileged connection with a physical being who sits among the fluffy clouds and notes all the details of my daily life. I can imagine a spiritual force at work in the universe, something that connects all life, humanity and nature, but I cannot personify it or give it the familial name of “Father” or “Son.”  [Sooo… she is what… a Buddhist?  A pantheist?]

But rather than reject a lifetime spiritual path, perhaps I need to get more comfortable with the idea of metaphor in Catholic doctrine and look beyond the literal pronouncements; [Because her mind is so subtle, she’ll create her own religion to suit her own needs.] then it becomes easier to see Christ as a symbolic son of God, as a presence that helps me find the divine spark (God) within myself, and more importantly serves as a model for truly compassionate living.  [Because, after all, it’s all about her.]

Receiving the spiritual nourishment of communion then becomes a reminder of so many people who lack food or the means to acquire it.  [sigh]

So can I continue to call myself a Catholic? [No.  Not on these terms.  But we hope and pray that you will come back to your Faith.] A friend once framed the dilemma in whimsical language: “I can no more stop being a Catholic than a Navajo could stop being a Navajo.” Ultimately, I think this struggle will always be with me, and that I will come to accept, and perhaps even embrace, a natural state of discomfort. Despite all the ambiguity, I would like to think I am still welcome at the communion table.

Rose Murphy is a writer based in Sonoma, California, who explores current events and also focuses on Irish  culture and history.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on National Catholic Reporter: undermining your faith yet again

A recipe for falling away from the Catholic Church

From Insight Scoop:

… brought to you by National "Catholic" Reporter:

1 cup of growing disenchantment
1/2 cup of some pronounced unease
3/4 cup of rotting historical illiteracy
1 cup of disillusioned with dogmatic bans
3 teaspoons of outgrown child childhood fantasies about the Real Presence, purgatory, and guardian angels (note: can be substituted with a 1/4 cup of ripe theological ignorance)
4 cups of stale, bitter skepticism

Mix all well in a bowl of ambiguity. Pour into a pan of uncertainly. Heat stove of 150 degrees, the preferred temperature for lukewarm spirituality. Cook for whatever length of time feels good to you. Coat with thin layer of sugary, neo-pantheistic frosting. Serve to readers of National "Catholic" Reporter while in a natural state of discomfort, chanting, "I am Catholic. I am Catholic."

Doesn’t this apply here as well?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments

WDTPRS – Sunday in the Octave of Christmas (1962MR)

What is going on in today’s ….

COLLECT – LATIN TEXT (1962MR):
Omnipotens sempiterne Deus,
dirige actus nostros in beneplacito tuo:
ut in nomine dilecti Filii tui
mereamur bonis operibus abundare.

This Collect survived the surgeons of Bugnini’s Consilium to live on  in the 3rd Sunday of Ordinary Time in the Novus Ordo calendar.

In the Lewis & Short Latin Dictionary we learn that beneplacitum means “good pleasure, gracious purpose”.  The preposition in using the ablative case indicates a condition, situation or relation rather than a reference to space where or time when something was occurring.  In the Vulgate beneplacitum translates the original Greek eudokia in, e.g., Eph 1:9; 1 Cor 10:5.  Other phrases are used for eudokia too (e.g., bona voluntas in Luke 2:14, the famous “peace on earth to men of good will” or “peace on earth good will toward men”).  Paul wrote eudokia at the beginning of 2 Thessalonians (1:11-12), rendered as voluntas bonitatis in the Vulgate:

…oramus semper pro vobis ut dignetur vos vocatione sua Deus et impleat omnem voluntatem bonitatis et opus fidei in virtute ut clarificetur nomen Domini nostri Iesu Christi in vobis et vos in illo secundum gratiam Dei nostri et Domini Iesu Christi… we always pray for you, that our God may make you worthy of his call, and may fulfill every good resolve (omnem voluntatem bonitatis) and work of faith by his power, so that the name of our Lord Jesus may be glorified in you, and you in him, according to the grace of our God and the Lord Jesus Christ (RSV).

We can find connections between 2 Thessalonians and our Collect at several points: mereamur in the Collect with dignetur in Paul (both having to do with meriting or being worth of), beneplacitum with voluntas bonitatis, bona opera with opus fidei (good works flowing from lived faith), nomen Filii with nomen Domini Iesu Christi.   Taken in the sense of “gracious purpose” we can make a connection to Paul’s vocatio too, our “calling” or the purpose for which God placed us on this earth with a part of His plan to fulfill.

Abundo means, “to overflow with any thing, to have an abundance or superabundance of, to abound in.”  If we go back to the idea of the preposition in and the ablative indicating place or location in space, (in beneplacito tuo) we have an image of our good works originating in God and, coming from Him, overflowing out from us. 

Some Protestants are under the false impression that Catholics think we can “earn” our way to heaven by our own good works, as if our good works had their own merit apart from God.

Catholics believe, however, that true good works always have their origin in God, but the works are truly our works as well since we cooperate with God in performing them.  Therefore, having their origin and purpose in God, they merit the reward of God’s promises.  Whenever we find a reference to works in these liturgical prayers, do not forget the Catholic understanding of good works.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:
Almighty eternal God,
direct our actions in your gracious purpose,
so that in the name of Thy beloved Son,
we may merit to abound with good works.

ICEL (1973 translation of the 1970MR):
All-powerful and ever-living God,
direct your love that is within us,
that our efforts in the name of your Son
may bring mankind to unity and peace.

The lame-duck ICEL version’s “All-powerful and ever-living God” for omnipotens sempiterne Deus is not so bad.  Quite bad, on the other hand, is their “direct your love that is within us”. 

The Latin clearly connects God’s own purpose for us and the actions that flow from that purpose.  In the ICEL version we have a vague term “love”, rather than the indication of God’s eternal plan. 

Perhaps this is a bit picky, but when I hear “we may merit to abound with good works”, I think we are abounding because of God’s action within us through the good works He makes meritorious.  They overflow from us because of His generosity.  In the ICEL version God’s “love” is in us, but this leads to “our efforts”.  Yes, this can be reconciled with a Catholic theology of works, but it just doesn’t sound right. 

Also, I don’t think that “efforts” to “bring mankind to unity and peace” means the same as us “meriting” by God’s grace to “abound with good works”.    

Please understand: I don’t object to praying for unity and peace, but I think we ought to pray the prayer as the Church gave it to us, what the prayer really says. 

When we feed the hungry and console those who mourn, visit the shut-in and imprisoned and pray for the dead, sure we are building “unity and peace”, but that phrase is so vague as to mean very little to someone in the pew. 

The Latin does not say “conatus nostri genus humanum ad unitatem et pacem inducant”. 

Is it possible that the guitar strumming and all those kumbayas of the 1960’s affected the brains of the ICEL translators? 

We could all stand outside the headquarters of the USCCB and sing, “All we are saying, is give Latin a chance!” while swaying back and forth holding our lighters in the air.

In the meantime… give us our new translation!!

 

Posted in Christmas and Epiphany, WDTPRS |
20 Comments

QUAERITUR: 1 January Mass obligation and SSPX chapel

From a reader:

Does the Mass according to the Traditional calendar for January 1 satisfy the Holy Day obligation for that day?

We are in Belgium and would like to attend a traditional Mass, since the other churches in Belgium are mostly empty and we’re not even sure if Jan 1 in Belgium is a Holy Day or not, so it might be difficult to find a Novus Ordo Mass that day.

We have been to the SSPX church here, and it is full of families and life and reverence, so that is probably where we will go… at home we go to St. Margaret’s in Oceanside, CA.

 

Yes.  According to the 1983 Code of Canon Law you satisfy the Sunday or Holy Day of Obligation when you attend Holy Mass in a Catholic Rite on the day itself or on the evening preceding.

You satisfy the obligation even by attending Mass at a chapel of the SSPX. They clearly celebrate in a Catholic Rite and their orders are valid. 

This isn’t the optimal choice, in my opinion.  Regardless of how nice their chapels can be in some respects, the SSPX is not in clear full unity with the Bishop of Rome or the local bishops.  Going to these chapels regularly remains a bad idea and I don’t recommend Holy Communion at those Masses.  But you do satisfy the obligation by attending Mass in their chapels.

Thus, if you go to a TLM in a chapel of the SSPX or an approved church or chapel, on 1 January or the evening of 31 December, you fulfill any obligation there may be.  I don’t know what the bishops in Belgium have determined about the Holy Day of Obligation.  Since it falls on a Thursday this year, I suspect that the obligation has not been dispensed.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
63 Comments

Massive Mass in Spain for the Family

From a reader:

I’m a regular reader of your blog who lives in Madrid, Spain.  Today there was an outdoor Mass to commemorate the Feast of the Holy Family, which aimed to draw attention to the importance of the Christian family and its values in today’s world, and how these values are being threatened by such forces as anti-life government policies (especially here in Spain).  Despite a cold, overcast, day, an estimated one million people attended!  You can see photo galleries and videos here:

http://www.libertaddigital.com/suplementos/albums/reportajes/misaporlafamilia2008/

http://www.larazon.es/noticia/la-familia-cristiana-sin-complejos

http://www.abc.es/multimedia/fotos/26437.asp

This aerial view (taken from the roof of a skyscraper on one side of Plaza Colon, where the Mass was celebrated) gives you an idea of how huge the crowd was:

http://www.abc.es/multimedia/fotos/26437.asp

The entire area was about as packed as the detail below, throughout the entire Plaza Colon (which is the biggest in Madrid) and the adjacent boulevards feeding into it (note the Spanish flag with a Sacred Heart where the national coat of arms usually goes):

Regardless of how one feels about these kinds of outdoor mega-Masses, the fact that hundreds of thousands of people braved nasty weather (there was even a snow alert on the radio) to witness to their convictions and their faith – in the middle of the Christmas holiday period, when half the city is away on vacation – looks like a positive sign.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Britain from above

Have you seen this?

Amazing photos.

Britain from above

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Boston Globe interviews McBrien

I was alerted to this interesting piece from the Boston Globe.

My emphases and comments.

Boston Globe interviews McBrienA talk with The Rev. Richard P. McBrien
Life as a theologian, commentator – and lightning rod
By Michael Paulson

December 28, 2008

CATHOLICISM IN AMERICA is riven by internal debates – often about gender, sexuality, and authority – and seemingly unending controversies, about politics and parish closings and the handling of sexual abuse. Whenever one of these battles catches the attention of the evening news, one of the likely commentators is the Rev. Richard P. McBrien, a theologian [?] at the University of Notre Dame who is one of the most visible interpreters of Catholicism to the American public.

McBrien has helped translate the arcana of Catholic history [with the help of JND Kelly, I believe] and teaching to an increasingly religiously uneducated America, editing the single-volume Encyclopedia of Catholicism, and penning two popular reference texts, "Lives of the Popes" and "Lives of the Saints."

But McBrien has also become a lightning rod for criticism because of his outspoken support for women’s ordination and married priests and his willingness to sharply criticize bishops and popes. And he has become persona non grata in some quarters – his theology column, which he has written since 1966, is barred from many diocesan papers, and his commentary has won him the ire of many conservatives. The Rev. John T. Zuhlsdorf, a popular conservative blogger, recently referred to McBrien as a "heresiarch," meaning a leader of heretics.

A priest of the Hartford archdiocese, McBrien taught for a decade at Boston College before moving to Notre Dame in 1980. He has just come out with his 25th book, a history of Catholic ecclesiology called, simply, "The Church," and spoke with Ideas during a visit to Boston.

IDEAS: How would you describe your standing in the church now?

McBRIEN: Well, I’m a theologian and a priest in good standing. What more could I say? I’ve been around a long time, and I’m not easily disposed of, put it that way, even though some people would like to have had that done.

IDEAS: Your column is not running in some places that it used to run.

McBRIEN: If I had all the papers that once carried the column, I’d have nearly 50 papers, which is a lot in the Catholic market. Don’t ask me how many I do have, because I never really know, but I have a relative handful of that number.

IDEAS: What happened?

McBRIEN: As the Catholic hierarchy became more conservative under Pope John Paul II, bishops who were open to a diversity of viewpoints in the church either died or retired, and were replaced, in almost every case, by bishops who were more, let’s say, attuned to the desires and intentions of the Holy See. I used to kid, I’d say bishops get points if they drop my column. They get noticed, and then they get promoted eventually, and so forth. [It’s all about him, after all.]  I can give you so many examples. I mean, let’s take Boston. Cushing was a patron of mine. He liked me, and I liked him. He had his foibles, but we all do. I liked Cardinal Cushing very much. But Medeiros was in, and Medeiros once said to me, ‘Richard, what would my mother think if she read your column?’ and I said, ‘Your eminence, I don’t write my column for your mother.’ So then it got dropped.

IDEAS: Have you become more liberal or more outspoken over the years?

McBRIEN: No, I don’t think so. I don’t think of myself in those terms, [But he sure thinks of others in those terms!] although it’s a relative term. I mean obviously I’m liberal if you define liberal stands as being open to the ordination of women, feeling that abortion shouldn’t be a litmus test defining whether one is a good Catholic or not. I’m very much against the policy of a certain handful of bishops to threaten to deny Communion to Catholic Democrats – and they’re always Democrats. I think that’s counterproductive, and I think it’s a mistake, and I also think it’s contrary to the policy of the bishops conference.  [Wow… can you imagine being in conflict with a position of the bishops’ conference?]

IDEAS: Why are you such a lightning rod? Whenever I quote you, I get e-mails, and I see bloggers taking after you.

McBRIEN: That’s a good question. It might be because I have such a public image.  [Which doesn’t include a clear image as a priest.] I regard myself as a broad centrist. [But remember… he doesn’t think in terms of labels…] But to an extreme right-wing person, especially in religion, and within the Catholic Church, a centrist or a center/left person is automatically perceived as an extreme left-wing person, [But he isn’t into labels…  And note that to a lefty progressivist, someone in the dead center seems to be on the extreme right.] bordering on, if not actually in, heresy. But for every e-mail or blog that you would see that would condemn me . . . I can tell you I got a lot of e-mails and letters from Catholics who said that I had given them hope and that their teenage kids who had been alienated from the church said that, "If there were more priests like the guy we were watching on television, I’d still be a Catholic."  [Sure!  And you can continue to do anything you want, without reference to the Church’s teachings, and feel great about yourself!  Isn’t he just a great guy?  sniff … I get all choked up thinking about the wonderful inspiration he has given to so many young people.]

IDEAS: And why don’t you leave?  [This is a good question.  The Anglican communion seems perfect for a fellow who doesn’t want a Bishop of Rome who is Supreme Pontiff, who questions the authority of bishops, who doesn’t want a clear teaching on moral issues.]

McBRIEN: Because it’s my church. [read: my income?] It’s my home. And I was born in it. I’ve been a Catholic all my life. And I have affirmation from so many good people. I feel that I have a responsibility to them to continue working at it and doing the best I can.

IDEAS: You’re so critical of the bishops, but you don’t seem angry.

McBRIEN: I’m critical of the bishops not because I have any gripe against any one of them personally. John Paul II, in the 26 ?? years he was pope, did some good things. [But] the most serious deficiency the late pope had . . . was the poor quality of men he put in the hierarchy. And nowhere was this more obvious than at the height of the sexual abuse scandal in the priesthood. The truth be told, a significant number of bishops . . . including some high-ranking bishops at the time, were gay. I have no problem with people being gay, but the Catholic Church officially does, and it’s constantly making statements that are hostile to gays, and they were compromised. They could not exercise leadership because they could not speak comfortably about issues relating to sexuality, because they were conflicted themselves.  [How was this an answer to the question?  What is the connect between John Paul II and gay bishops?   He is using this moment to introduce a non sequitur because this is what he really wants to talk about.  He is trying to undermine the authority of the bishops and of the Roman Pontiff.  He is trying to undermine the Church’s authority to teach on moral issues.]

IDEAS: Why don’t you wear a collar?

McBRIEN: I only wear a collar when I go to my home parish in West Hartford to say Mass on a Sunday when I’m home. My Roman collar is my television uniform. You don’t see the apostles with Roman collars on. [They didn’t wear neckties either.] It’s a custom. And the custom in the academic world is that most priests who teach in Catholic colleges and universities wear a tie or just have an open sport shirt. 

Michael Paulson covers religion for the Globe

Poor guy.  What a victim.

I wonder how much of the proceedings from his books he dedicates to pro-life charities…. any charity.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
59 Comments