An evil letter in the New York Times about primacy of conscience

This is a letter to the New York Times from the head of the dissident, pro-abortion group Catholics for Choice.  My emphases and comments.

 

November 22, 2008
Letter
The Catholic Conscience [More and more we will see this word "conscience" misused by dissenters.]

To the Editor:

Re “Protests Over a Bush Rule to Protect Health Providers” (news article, Nov. 18), about the rule that prohibits anyone receiving federal funds from discriminating against providers who refuse to perform abortions for religious or moral reasons:

The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops and the Catholic Health Association may be behind the new rule, but their support does not reflect the fullness of Catholic teaching and the views of Catholics.  [Get that?  The "fullness" of "Catholic" teaching.  Now the writer will attempt to show how his position reflects the "fullness" of Catholic teaching, as if he somehow speaks magisterially.]

Catholic tradition requires Catholics to follow their own well-formed consciences ["well-formed"] even if it conflicts with church teaching. [Here is the problem: a "well-formed" conscience will not conflict with the Church’s teaching.  A "well-formed" conscience adheres to the truth.  I think the problem here rests in the difference between "well-formed" and "well-informed".  There is a difference between having ingested a lot of information and then making a decision about it and, on the other hand, making a decision to adhere to the truth as taught by the Church.  It seems to me that Catholics who desire that their consciences truly be "well-formed" give a logical priority to what the Church has to say, rather than reducing the Church’s teaching to one component, even an important one, among many necessary components.] As the Catechism notes, “a human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience.”  [Folks… get ready.  Mark my words, we will hear more and more about this "primacy of conscience" argument as something that trumps the clear teachings of the Church.  It will be used, by Catholics, as a justification for evil actions.]

Catholic teaching also requires respect for others’ consciences. Doctors and pharmacists cannot dismiss the conscience of the person seeking a medication or a procedure to which they themselves may object. For example, they may not ignore the needs of patients who may not be Catholic, or who have made conscience-based decisions to use contraception.  [So, this writer thinks that a Catholic physician with a "well-formed" conscience, recognizing the absolute primacy of the conscience of another, can then, in "good" conscience perform an abortion.  What he has done is make another person’s conscience the touchstone of your own moral decisions.  Another person’s conscience can "permit" you to do x, y, z.]

One hopes that the bishops are not suggesting that the only well-formed conscience is one that is in lockstep with their own interpretation of Catholic teaching. That would, in fact, be the antithesis of a well-formed conscience.  [The Church does not say that non-Catholics must give consent of mind and will to Catholic teaching.  The Church says that Catholics must give that consent, and that their consciences of Catholics are well-formed when they embrace what the Catholic Church teaches.]

Jon O’Brien
President, Catholics for Choice
Washington, Nov. 18, 2008

 

What Jon O’Brien wrote was evil.

Let us drill into what he used as his foundation, namely, that "A human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience." 

This is the first sentence in the first article in the Catechism of the Catholic Church on "Erroneous Judgment"

Let’s have a look:

IV. ERRONEOUS JUDGMENT

1790 A human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience. If he were deliberately to act against it, he would condemn himself. Yet it can happen that moral conscience remains in ignorance and makes erroneous judgments about acts to be performed or already committed.

1791 This ignorance can often be imputed to personal responsibility. This is the case when a man "takes little trouble to find out what is true and good, or when conscience is by degrees almost blinded through the habit of committing sin." In such cases, the person is culpable for the evil he commits.  [This is why, above, I made a distinction between "well-formed" and " well-informed".  Clearly, many people know lots of facts, but they make the wrong decisions anyway.  Something is missing from their formation.]

1792 Ignorance of Christ and his Gospel, bad example given by others, [here we have the problem of scandal.  Many people see prominent "Catholics" acting in a certain way and they, on their example, follow suit.  This is why Holy Church imposes censures on some people who commit public sins which give scandal.  It is a way for the Church to say "What that person does is not Catholic and he is harming the unity of the Church and endangering souls.] enslavement to one’s passions, assertion of a mistaken notion of autonomy of conscience, [Did you get that?  "Assertion of a mistaken notion of autonomy of conscience".  The writer, above, does precisely that.  As a matter of fact, he goes so far as to say that the autonomous conscience of another person can justify you doing what you, in your autonomous conscience, know is evil.] rejection of the Church’s authority and her teaching, [The Church does have authority to teach on this matter and she has taught.] lack of conversion and of charity: these can be at the source of errors of judgment in moral conduct.

1793 If – on the contrary – the ignorance is invincible, [that is, the person just can’t learn the truth] or the moral subject is not responsible for his erroneous judgment, [for example, he has been completely misinformed, as might be the case in a person brain-washed in a fundamentalist ideology] the evil committed by the person cannot be imputed to him. It remains no less an evil, a privation, a disorder. [There is a distinction between the objectively sinful act and the guilt one has, as the subject who committed the act.] One must therefore work to correct the errors of moral conscience.  [This is a spiritual work of mercy, because it helps that person to edge back from the chasm of evil, the risk of committing scandal, and the ultimate peril of hell.]

1794 A good and pure conscience is enlightened by true faith, [true faith, I think, for Catholics is shaped by the Faith.] for charity proceeds at the same time "from a pure heart and a good conscience and sincere faith."

    The more a correct conscience prevails, the more do persons and groups turn aside from blind choice and try to be guided by objective standards of moral conduct.

Just above this section we read in article 

1785 In the formation of conscience the [1] Word of God is the light for our path, we must assimilate it in faith and prayer and put it into practice. We must also examine our conscience before the [2] Lord’s Cross. We are assisted by the [3] gifts of the Holy Spirit, aided by the [4] witness or advice of others and guided by the [4] authoritative teaching of the Church.

Now go back and read that wicked letter in the NYT:

 

November 22, 2008
Letter
The Catholic Conscience

To the Editor:

Re “Protests Over a Bush Rule to Protect Health Providers” (news article, Nov. 18), about the rule that prohibits anyone receiving federal funds from discriminating against providers who refuse to perform abortions for religious or moral reasons:

The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops and the Catholic Health Association may be behind the new rule, but their support does not reflect the fullness of Catholic teaching and the views of Catholics.

Catholic tradition requires Catholics to follow their own well-formed consciences even if it conflicts with church teaching. As the Catechism notes, “a human being must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience.”

Catholic teaching also requires respect for others’ consciences. Doctors and pharmacists cannot dismiss the conscience of the person seeking a medication or a procedure to which they themselves may object. For example, they may not ignore the needs of patients who may not be Catholic, or who have made conscience-based decisions to use contraception.

One hopes that the bishops are not suggesting that the only well-formed conscience is one that is in lockstep with their own interpretation of Catholic teaching. That would, in fact, be the antithesis of a well-formed conscience.

Jon O’Brien
President, Catholics for Choice
Washington, Nov. 18, 2008

 

More and more we will see some Catholics base their claims on the "primacy of conscience".  Be on guard for their errors.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
50 Comments

Romans: TLM alerts

News flash from our friend John Sonnen of Orbis Catholicus

Monday, Dec. 8
Feast of the Immaculate Conception
10 a.m. Solemn Pontifical Mass
at Ss. Trinita’ dei Pellegrini in Rome
will be celebrated by George Card. Pell of Sydney Australia.

Sunday, Nov. 30
First Sunday of Advent
4 p.m. Solemn Pontifical Mass
at S. Maria degli Angeli e Martiri in Rome
will be celebrated by Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos of the Pont. Com. Ecclesia Dei.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Romans: TLM alerts

Moving the sign of peace in the Novus Ordo

The intrepid Andrea Tornielli has this on his blog (my translation and emphases):

Benedict XVI want "a different placement of the sign of peace during Mass".  The Prefect for the Congregation for Divine Worship, Francis Card. Arinze, announced this in an interview with L’Osservatore Romano.  The Nigerian Cardinal, on Sunday celebrates 50 years of priesthood and who is about to leave his dicastery, explained, "Often the full meaning of this gesture is not understood.  People think it is a chance to shake their friend’s hands.  Instead, it is a way of saying to someone near that the peace of Christ, truly present on the altar, is also with all men."  "To create an more recollected atmosphere to prepare for Communion, it was thought," Arinze revealed, "to transfer the exchange of peace to the offertory.  The Pope asked for a consultation with the whole episcopate.  Then he will decide."  The anticipated sign of peace is a characteristic of the Ambrosian Missal.  In the interview Arinze spoke also of small liturgical changes already decided by the Pope inasmuch as they came out of the Synod of Bishops on the Eucharist celebrated in 2005.  In particular, he said, "in addition to ‘Ite, missa est’, for example, the priest today has at his disposal other formulas, to help the faithful understand better that we are called to live what we have celebrated, in a more dynamic mode, more missionary.  Benedict XVI, after a series of studies conducted by us, without abolishing ‘Ite, missa est’, approved three alternatives: Ite ad Evangelium Domini annuntiandum; Ite in pace glorificando vita vestra Dominum; Ite in pace".

Hmmm…

With due respect, while I understand the biblical foundation for shifting the sign of peace before you bring your gifts to the altar (cf. Matthew 5:23-24), the sign of peace has been where it is in the Roman Rite for a very long time. 

It must also be noted that the invitation for the sign of peace in the Novus Ordo is optional.  It doesn’t have to be done most of the time.  It is not of absolute value.  This move seems to make it something it has never been.

Also, is this not merely an artificial imposition of a change on the structure of Mass?

Actually… that was a rhetorical question.

This is an artificial change, not an organic.

Sure, the sign of peace is in a different place in the Ambrosian Missal. 

So what?

This is the Roman Rite we are talking about.

The upshot of this is that the older, traditional form of the Roman Rite, the TLM, now would seem to be even more, if this goes through, the exemplar of stability.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
74 Comments

Card. Arinze in audience

Card. Arinze in audienceFrom the Bolletino:

LE UDIENZE

Il Santo Padre ha ricevuto questa mattina in Udienza:

 Em.mo Card. Francis Arinze, Prefetto della Congregazione per il Culto Divino e la Disciplina dei Sacramenti, in occasione della presentazione della terza edizione tipica del Messale Romano;

 

This morning the Holy Father received in audience:

His Eminence Francis Card. Arinze, Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments, on the occasion of the presentation of the third typical edition of the Roman Missal.

This might seem unusual to some, since the third edition came out on 2002.

His Eminence celebrates his 50th Jubilee of priesthood tomorrow.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

The future and our choices

We are headed for very hard times.

Huge changes loom, both in the secular level and also the spiritual realm.
 
It is hard to read the times and not come to alarming conclusions.

World leadership has shifted remarkably in a short period of time.

The financial crisis hasn’t even begun to get serious.  Let’s not kid ourselves about how bad things could get.  How bad?  At Fatima the Blessed Mother of God spoke of the annihilation of nations.  Nations can be wiped out, and it doesn’t take war to do the job.

In the USA we are facing the strong likelihood of FOCA, the "Freedom of Choice Act" which will effectively eliminate restriction on abortion and curtail the rights of parents and physicians to exercise their own freedoms and rights. 

Take a look at the video, below.  It is also on YouTube right now… I say "right now, because I suspect it will be pulled because it is pro-life and therefore "hate speech".  For that reason, I also put it on my server. 

"But Father! But Father!", some might object.  "This is just Michael O’Brien stuff you are gabbling now.  Just relax.  Watch!  Things aren’t as bad as you are suggesting. Stop your scaremongering!"

Well… yah, pal!  This is "Michael O’Brien stuff!"  And mark my words the "fairness doctrine" is going to be ushered to the fore again, very soon.  There will be a strong effort to shut down the alternative media, such as the stronger voices in the Catholic blogosphere.  Just you watch.  Just watch as leaders in the Church start to line up on different sides.  Some will apply huge pressure, canonical, financial, psychological, to clerics who decide to stand up and speak an unambiguous message rooted in Catholic teaching.

Actually, this has already begun.

Some will say the video is corny, because of the music from Rocky.

Some will say that it is alarmist, because it speaks in stark terms.

But do you honestly think we are not at an important crossroad?

Catholics had to make choices in 1930’s Germany.

Catholics had to make choices behind the iron and bamboo curtains.

It’s our turn.

Neither this video, nor I, nor any sound Catholic people will advocate violence or uncharitable acts. 

Neither I nor this video suggest or ask for any disrespect to elected officials or defiance of law and order.

What this video asks is that Catholics embrace the teachings of Holy Church and the truth written into our hearts. 

It asks that Catholics practice their Catholic faith, that they be Catholics. 

In no way does being Catholic take us out of the public square or place us entirely out of the sphere of what Caesar justly requires.  We have obligations to the state, as well as rights. 

But our obligation to God and the truth has priority.  Only in our fidelity as Catholics can we offer our special contributions to the common good.  We have a right and duty to participate in the public square.

We can only have something good to contribute if we know who we are as Catholics, if we embrace that identity, and act accordingly according to our vocations in our proper spheres of life.

We must first fight the battle for our Catholic identity before we can make a difference in the world.

We must make choices.

Posted in The future and our choices |
109 Comments

Papal ad orientem alert!

On Sunday, 11 January, His Holiness will say Mass and confer baptism in the Sistine Chapel for the feast of the Baptism of the Lord.

I suspect this will be, again, ad orientem.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

More on Charbel Vestments

More on Charbel VestmentsDo you remember my review of Charbel Vestments?

I received this from fellow who is involved with this new initiative:

Dear Father,
 
Please find some time to visit our new website : http://www.charbelvestments.com/index.html
 
We need a favour from you – Could you write something (a short paragraph or a few lines) for us to post under Customer Testimonials?
 
Business is going very slow – Therefore, our dalmatic, cope, and embroidered St. Philip Neri style Chasuble projects will have to be delayed. So far, customers have been very satisfied with our products, but I guess the brand awareness is still not there.
 
Please help us spread the good word of CharbelVestments; we will be forever grateful.

Their vestments are beautiful, of good materials, and well made.

They are certainly dignified. 

They would cost far less than may other embroidered vestments I have seen.  Far less.

These vestments could be good a good choice for TLM communities getting their start as well as for parishes who want to present the Novus Ordo in continuity with our Roman Tradition.

It strikes me that these folks have very good will, good skills, the right vision, a worthy project and, what is more, they seem truly to love the Church and her liturgy.

I am very happy they will also do the dalmatics and "Philip" cut.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

More from dissident NCRep on Bougeois’s excommunication

More from dissident NCRep on Bougeois's excommunicationThe ultra-lefty National Catholic Reporter presents another exercise in adulation of probably soon to be former Fr. Roy Bougeois, MM.

Bougeois is a longtime professional protester, dissident and now heretical supporter of women’s ordination.

It was especially his active participation in a fake ordination of a woman last August, at which he also spoke, which stirred the Vatican to action.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith will probably send the notice of his excommunication fairly soon.  There remains the question of his continuing in the clerical state and as a member of the Maryknoll Mission priests.  Bougeois was given an opportunity to rethink his favorable position on women’s ordination.  He obstinately and publicly refused to stop supporting what the Church definitively teaches is an impossibility.  Therefore Bougeois has also fallen into contumacious heresy, which he spreads publicly, thus also causing additional scandal.  His political protests were one thing, but this is another entirely.

Let’s have a look at the NCRep‘s latest encomium.  My emphases and comments.

Support, criticism swirl around Roy Bourgeois

By Tom Roberts
Published:
November 20, 2008

Letters, petitions go to Rome about priest threatened with excommunication [I wonder if "promise" wouldn’t have been a better word.]

The news that peace activist Fr. Roy Bourgeois was threatened  [Note how the writer sets up the contrast of "peace" on the one hand, and "threat", on the other.] with excommunication for his support of women’s ordination unleashed a storm of commentary and reaction from various Catholic interest groups and around the blogosphere.

If the issue is settled for Rome, it is still wide open in some Catholic circles. [Roma locuta est, causa disputatur.] In addition to the expected sharp division between those who applaud Bourgeois’ action and those who find it scandalous, people have posed thoughtful questions about conscience, and how and whether the church can force someone to violate his conscience. Others, in what amounts to a fairly robust discussion of the question of women’s ordination, raise issues of history and women’s place in the early church based on an understanding of scripture and archaeological evidence.  [Several points are front loaded here for the article.  First, the writer paints the critics of the Holy See as "thoughtful".  You have already been told that the Holy See is threatening.  Also, placing this in the sphere of "conscience" will probably strike the thoughtful reader as pandering to their usual readership.  These days, conscience is king, regardless of how poorly formed it might be.  Also, there is "robust" discussion.  "Robust" here signals approval.  The (impossibility) of the ordination of women should be talked about and talked about and talked about… until it happens.  "Robust", therefore, is approval, when applied to the "question".   Also, there really is no question about this if you are a faithful Catholic.  Finally, the writer panders a bit more by tossing in the suggestion that women have been mistreated and that, in the finest Da Vinci Code fashion, there is evidence out there which will prove Bougeois and the women to the right after all.]

[Now watch how the issues are confused.] Another thread that runs through much of the commentary asks how the church could act so swiftly against Bourgeois when decades passed before the church even began to investigate cases of sex abuse of children by priests. [On the one hand, priests committed vile sins, which are also crimes, and bishops and religious superiors who shamefully did too little exercised scandalously bad judgment.  On the other hand, Bougeiois is a public heretic, which is a matter of doctrine.  On the one hand there were moral delicts, on the other damage to the Church’s doctrine about a very important teaching and practice.  They are both very serious, but they fall into different categories.  They are not moral equivalents.  However, we can agree that the Holy See didn’t act with the speed we could have hoped.  But in the interest of being consistent according to the call of the NCRep we hope the Holy See will now act to remove from their positions all priests who support the ordination of women together with those who have been proven beyond doubt to have abused children.] Meanwhile, Bourgeois, a Maryknoll priest of 36 years, is trying to meld [another nice word] issues that normally operate in separate spheres by claiming that the ban on ordaining women is as serious an injustice within the church as the injustices he has confronted in the realms of the political and military. [So, the issue of the ordination of women is simply reduced to the "fairness" argument.  What this reflects is a fundamental misunderstanding of what the Church teaches priesthood is all about.  For the NCRep and Bougeios, priesthood is about the functions and about one’s own subjective feeling about them.  If priesthood is only about what people do, then it makes sense that we should chose people who are competent and available to do those tasks, regardless of their sex.  But priesthood is not only about what priests do.  It is about who they are.  Also, the Church calls men to the priesthood, men don’t call themselves.  Whatever feelings or thoughts they have about priesthood are tested and verified by the Church, which also considers many other factors, including the Church’s perennial practice and Tradition and Magisterium.  In the end they are only saying "it’s not fair".]

Bourgeois, who concelebrated an ordination of women in Kentucky in August, responded to the Vatican’s warning that he recant his position or face excommunication with a letter stating that he considered the ban on ordination of women an injustice within the church and that he could not recant what he considered a matter of conscience.  [Conscience is supposed to confirm his own choices.  The Vatican is supposed to accept this.  Imagine. Bougeois: "Women must be ordained because I feel it’s unfair they aren’t".  Vatican: "What part of the Church’s teaching do you not understand?  No."  Bougeois: "I insist." Vatican: "No. And furthermore, stop saying these things or you will be disciplined." Bougeois: "I won’t stop because I really want to do this."  Vatican: "Wellll….. okaaayy…. you win."]

He expects to receive final notice of excommunication from the Vatican in the very near future.

In a homily delivered during the August ordination, Bourgeois declared, “Just as soldiers in Latin America abuse their power and control others, it saddens me to see the hierarchy of our church abusing their power and causing so much suffering among women. Jesus was a healer, a peacemaker, who called everyone into the circle as equals.”  [Bougeois compared the Holy See, the Holy Father and all bishops back through the centuries to brutal soldiers of regimes trying to repress Communists guerrillas, "freedom fighters".]

Roman Catholic Womenpriests, who sponsored the ordination that precipitated the Vatican action against Bourgeois, asked [this is a good one] in a release how the Vatican could “excommunicate women who honor their call to the priesthood and, in the case of Fr. Roy, the men who support them, but not the priest s and bishops who have perpetrated sexual abuse of children?”  ["How could you!  How could you be so mean!"  More seriously, must excommunication the penalty for everything now?  People toss this around so lightly.  Let’s dig for a moment.  First, priests who were proven to be abusive were punished with a serious penalty: dismissal from the clerical state.  What is excommunication for?  It is intended to help people return from their sinful state and to prevent them, to the extent possible, from doing additional damage to themselves and the Catholic faithful.  The Church also uses excommunication for some sins to do its part in underscoring that certain actions are heinous when the state no longer does its part.  I have in mind the case of the American bishops once asking the Holy See to permit the imposition of excommunication on people who sold drugs to minors.  This was eventually rescinded, probably because in the civil sphere there are strong laws in this regard and there is a strong social stigma about that.  Consider the case of abortion.  Abortion carries an excommunication, though with murder does not.  Why?  Probably because states have become callous regarding the unborn and so the Church does her part to underscore the sanctity of human life from its very beginning in the face of a loss of this sense in society, in a culture of death.  To be fair to the argument used above (which is still ridiculous), I think some abuser clerics should also have been excommunicated.  Take for example those priests who were not merely sick and doing sick things in private, but who made a public case for what they did, as in the case of that creep involved with the organization promoting child abuse.  IMO, he should also have been excomm’d because he went beyond the mere acts of abuse, bad as they were.  There are many priests, sadly, who think women should be ordained.  They are not being censured with excommunication because they don’t push it to the point Bougeois did, to real scandal, and harm of the unity of the Church and her doctrine.  Excommunication has to serve a function. That function is not just retribution.  The Church doesn’t apply penalties as retribution.  They are remedies.   Excommunication also states to the Catholic faithful that what the person did is a grave offense against the unity of the Church, that it is not Catholic.  The Church doesn’t excommunicate people just because they are "bad people", as retribution.  I think this is where the people involved with that fake ordination business have gotten the argument wrong, even though there is a grain of truth in the suggestion that some abuser clerics should have been excommunicated.]

In a series of questions, the group also asked why the Vatican continued to ignore “the voice of the community,” citing surveys that regularly show a heavy majority of Catholics would approve of women priests.  [Because majority rule should guide us?]

“Why do you continue to deny the documented archaeological evidence  [This is just DaVinci Code fluff not to be taken seriously.] that supports the spiritual leadership of women as deaconesses, priests and bishops for the first 1200 years of church history?” the group asked.

One of the most high profile clerics to weigh in on the Vatican discipline is Jesuit Fr. James Martin, an author and frequent contributor to America magazine, the weekly Jesuit publication. [He is high profile?  Why?  Because he writes for America.] In a Nov. 11 blog posting, Martin essentially explained the collision course that was inevitable when Bourgeois clearly violated church teaching by participating in the ordination, no matter that on another level, [watch this] he was following his conscience, an inviolable activity. Martin cites several of the powerful references to conscience in Vatican II documents and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, including the line from Gaudiem et Spes: “Conscience is man’s most secret core, and his sanctuary. There he is alone with God whose voice echoes in his depths.”  [Well, that’s fine.  But Bougeois is being censured because of his very public, very defiant, very scandalous heretical statements and his behavior.  We hope the excommunication will eventually prompt him to form his conscience according to the mind of the Church, rather than his own musings.]

Martin tacks a “reflection” to the end `of his entry in which he recounts that the excommunication warning was sent to Bourgeois in October, within three months of the ordination ceremony in August. “Would that the church had acted with equal swiftness against sexually abusive priests. Would that bishops who had moved abusive priests from parish to parish were met with th same severeity of justice.  [Again, excommunication is not retribution.  Furthermore, once the ball did get rolling on handling the abuser cleric cases, the Church did move quickly.  I know one case where a man was dismissed from the clerical state in lightening speed, unthinkable in the years before.]

“Were their offenses of lesser ‘gravity?’” he asked. “ Did they cause lesser ‘scandal?’”  [Well… they were different kinds of scandal, different categories.  Again, I am ready to concede that some of those clerics ought to have also been excommunicated.  At the same time I will point out that not all priests thinks women should be ordained are being warned about excommunication.  Furthermore, let’s ask a practical question: Say Holy Church would have excommunicated, for example, Card. Law of Boston because of how he mishandled clerics.  Because excommunication is a remedy designed to promote repentance for a sin and harm done to the Church, he more than likely would have issued a public statement of sorrow immediately according to the demands of the decree.  In that case, the excommunication would have looked like a sham and the whole purpose of having censures would have been undermined.  I think they same would go for the larger number of cases of abuser clerics.  What would have been the outcome of the censure?  What purpose would it have served?  REMEMBER: excommunication is not for retribution.]

Many people spoke of writing to Pope Benedict XVI as well as Cardinal William Levada, head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican agency that corresponded with Bourgeois.

One long missive that was sent to both the pope and NCR was from Charlotte Therese of Sweden. Near the end of the letter, she states:

[Okay, Charlotte is now going to set everyone straight….]  “I’ve studied all the arguments against women ordinations in detail and I’ve found that none of them is solid enough to build any teachings upon. It’s rather the opposite way — they all fall down like a pile of cards if they’re slightly touched. [Well… that‘s compelling!] I thus hope you will welcome and reopen theological discussions about this in the Vatican, through inviting theologians from all over the world who has (sic) studied the question at depth — both women and men — and both those who based on their studies are positive to change and those who aren’t, and they should all have the right to speak and vote.”  [Right. Because the Church has never really studied this before.]

A respondent on one blog who said he accepts “the stand of those in charge at this time” [at this time] opposed the action against Bourgeois. “Instead of refuting Fr. Roy’s position, they silence his voice. What does this accomplish? Have those in charge not learned the lessons of history?”  [This makes one want to pound one’s forehead on one’s desk.]

Call to Action, the lay reform group that has long supported women’s ordination, was attempting to gather 2,000 signatures [Oooooo…..] on a petition supporting Bourgeois prior to this year’s demonstration at Ft. Benning, Ga.

Bourgeois was founder of the annual event, which attracts thousands and is referred to as SOA Watch after the School of the Americas, the former name of the school at the fort. It was changed in 2001 to the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation. The protest began in 1990, a year after six Jesuits, their housekeeper and her daughter were assassinated in El Salvador by troops that had been trained at the SOA.

On Nov. 20, Bourgeois was preparing for the crowds that were beginning to arrive. Asked in a phone interview about reactions to his impending excommunication, he said he continues to receive calls of support, but said he had heard nothing further from the Vatican.

As for the SOA protest, Bourgeois said happily that he was finished with his organizational duties. He said he was in charge of arranging for portable potties and had just met the crew that delivered them. “I’m finished for the weekend. My work is done. And it’s one of the most important jobs here,” he joked.  [He probably better not quit this day job… now that he has another.]

It is all so sad.

We see the public wreck of a clerical career.  It’s an ugly thing to watch an autopsy, but sometimes it must be done.  We have to keep cutting up these cadaverous articles for the sake of showing people what caused death.

We also see the NCRep‘s sriral around the bowl.  It could do so much good.  In publishing articles like this, it undermines any good it might do otherwise.  Very sad.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
77 Comments

I was sad before… I am irritated now

I am often irritated at how quickly people rush to shout "OFF WITH HIS HEAD!" when it comes to priests and bishops.

It is like a flashback to the 4th century North Africa when the Donatists insisted on a Church of the pure alone.  No coversion.  No room for sinners.  No possibility of future changes.  "Get outta here!"

The fact is that we Christians belong to an ecclesia permixta malis et bonis, a Church mixed through with good and bad people. 

The Lord will sort us out.

But this applies to the whole human race, does it not?  Prescinding from religion, can’t we reasonably recognize that people make mistakes?  Sometimes terrible and evil mistakes?

Do those people then instantly lose any right to dignity or compassion?

Some people think so. 

Non-Catholics… non-Christians also get down into a nasty narrow ditch of presumption and accusation.

I am therefore irritated, but not surprised, by something I read from The Catholic League (my emphases):

ROLL CALL SMEARS INNOCENT PRIEST
 
Catholic League president Bill Donohue today accused the Washington, D.C. newspaper, Roll Call, of smearing Father Daniel Coughlin; the Chicago priest has been the House Chaplain since 2000:
 
“We have always held Roll Call in high regard, but after the hit job on Father Coughlin, we no longer do. What the newspaper did was classic yellow journalism.
 
“Yesterday, Roll Call made a big splash on the Internet with its ‘Breaking News’ story on Father Coughlin. The headline, ‘Chaplain Managed Abusive Priests,’ gave the impression that Coughlin either did something illegal or something immoral. The fact is he did neither.
 
“In today’s print edition, Roll Call discusses how Coughlin ministered to troubled priests in Chicago. For example, it says today that he played the role of ‘caretaker, providing services ranging from room and board to spiritual support and advocacy.’ Coughlin admits to ‘pastoring priests’ and the article mentions that he ‘was not responsible for overseeing the men.’
 
“Now it seems plain that in every segment of the population there will be men and women who go astray. It also seems plain that if the community or organization in which these troubled souls live actually care a whit about them, services will be offered to deal with their malady. Indeed, to do nothing would suggest callous indifference to their fate.
 
“So this is it. Father Coughlin, before being named House Chaplain—a position he earned after considerable controversy that involved me personally — tended to the needs of troubled priests. For this he should be applauded, but that is not the message that Roll Call wants to convey.
 
“Morton Kondracke, the executive editor of Roll Call, needs to extend an apology not only to Father Coughlin, but to the Catholic community as well for exploiting the issue of priestly sexual abuse.”
 
Contact: editors@rollcall.com
 
Susan A. Fani
Director of Communications
Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights
catalyst@catholicleague.org
New York, NY 10123
212-371-3191
212-371-3394 (fax)
 

I agree.  Fr. Coughlin is owed an apology.

Here is what Roll Call wrote:

Coughlin served as the archdiocesan point man for counseling troubled priests, including those accused of sexual misconduct.

But Roll Call tries to leave the impression that Fr. Coughlin was engaged in coddling priest abusers.

Fr. Coughlin had petitioned the release from prison of a priest who had molested children, though that petition was refused.

“I was dealing with priests that had problems themselves and maybe were causing problems on a staff or causing problems in the community,” Coughlin said in an interview with Roll Call on Monday. “And so in that sense I was pastoring priests.”

What have we become if we simply throw anyone who has ever sinned under the bus?

"You SINNED?!?!   OUT WITH YOU into the cooollllld where nobody will ever show you compassion again.  Go DIE now, alone and unloved.  We will prevent anyone from ever helping you get to heaven or preseve any dignity!."

Not only that, we have to spurn and revile anyone who ever tried to help a sinner.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
39 Comments

Alignment of dates: New Prefect of CDWDS?

As you know, His Eminence Francis Card. Arinze, Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship, on 1 November turned 76.   Very often Prefects are called to step down at 75. 

Card. Arinze’s 50th anniversary of ordination of priesthood, his Jubilee, is 23 November.

There has been some talk that the next Prefect may be his Eminence Antonio Card. Canizares Llovera, archbishop of Toledo, the one some have nicknamed "the little Ratzinger".

Alignment of dates: New Prefect of CDWDS?AUDIENCES

VATICAN CITY, 20 NOV 2008 (VIS) – The Holy Father today received in separate audiences:

 – Cardinal Giovanni Lajolo, president of the Pontifical Commission for Vatican City State and of the Governorate of Vatican City State.

 – Cardinal Antonio Canizares Llovera, archbishop of Toledo, Spain.

UPDATE:

This is in from the site of the intrepid Andrea Tornielli (my translation):

Today Benedict XVI received in audience the Archbishop of Toledo, Antonio Card. Cañizares Llovera.  Sunday, 23 November, the Nigerian Francis Arinze, celebrates his Jubilee of priesthood and in the first weeks of December we await the nomination of his successor, who will be Cañizares, called in Spain, "the little Ratzinger.  It is foreseen in the first months of next year, probably before Easter, after the new Prefect will have settled into the Congregation, also a change of the Secretary: the Sri Lankan Archbishop Malcom Ranjith Patabendige Don will be named Archbishop of Colombo (and perhaps cardinal).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments