A very sad Fr. Z and the promise of a Mass

Today, at the top of the hour (1600 UK – 1700 Rome – 1100 NYC) I will say Holy Mass with the 1962 Missale Romanum for the repose of the soul of Fr. Dan Schuh.

I never met this priest.  I had never heard of him until just a few minutes ago when I read something that filled me with profound sadness.

Friends, take to heart what I wrote about the need for a return to black vestments and a proper sense of what a funeral is for.  We must pray for the dead.  Let us not canonize them or ourselves.

Read this and weep.

Priest’s funeral a celebration

St. Susanna flock says goodbye

By Sheila McLaughlin
smclaughlin@enquirer.com

MASON – Father Harry Meyer tried to imagine God’s reaction when St. Susanna pastor Dan Schuh appeared in heaven.

Probably, he said, it was the same as the teenaged skier who witnessed the 50-something priest tumble head over skis down the slopes one winter night at Perfect North Slopes.

"Awesome, dude!" Meyer told the 1,500-plus parishioners and priests who gathered for Schuh’s funeral Mass Wednesday morning.

Schuh, who was diagnosed with ALS – Lou Gehrig’s disease – last year, [poor man] died Friday, only six weeks after handing over most of his church administrative duties to an associate pastor and hours after attending a staff meeting. His death caught many by surprise.  [The more reason to be prepared.  This will come to all of us.]

Wednesday’s funeral was more of a celebration of Schuh’s life as a widower, father, grandfather and former Kroger manager turned Catholic priest than a solemn affair.  [Because the "solemn", which in this case probably means something like "somber/focused/serious" would actually call upon those present to have an encounter with mystery.  Instead, most people want to be distracted from what St. Augustine calls "our daily winter".]

The presence of more than 80 priests in cream-colored vestments and Cincinnati Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk set it apart from the usual service.

The music was upbeat. The message was hopeful and light, often drawing chuckles from the crowd.

Meyer, St. Susanna’s pastor emeritus, referred to the 57-year-old Schuh as "Father Father" because of his dual role as father to his family and his church.

He joked about how Schuh – a hefty 280 pounds until ALS rendered him thin and frail – would certainly enjoy some of the benefits of heaven.

"Rich food and fine wine," Meyer quipped. "So, big Billy Pork Chop will no longer have to raid the refrigerator or be parched."  [Yah… that’s the sort of elevating rhetoric we need during the funeral of a priest.]

In the end, Pilarczyk prayed over the casket, dispersing incense as he asked God to "open the gates in paradise for your servant."  [Thanks be to God for that prayer.]

He thanked all who had cared for Schuh in his last months.

Then, the archbishop and the priests led Schuh’s draped casket through the vestibule of the church, to the hearse waiting outside for the trip to Calvary Cemetery in Dayton, Ohio.

The procession passed easels with hundreds of photographs of a usually smiling Schuh in every facet of his life, even as a young baseball player for the 1959 Fort Thomas All Stars.

It passed poster boards of farewell messages from students at St. Susanna School.  [Fine. There is plenty of room for that, too.  There is a time for celebration and the sentiment.  In. Its. Time. And. Place.]

"I will miss Fr. Dan," one boy scrawled in purple crayon alongside a stick-figure drawing of him and Schuh.

"And, I am happy that he is in heaven."  [And we hope… and pray that he is.  But let us first pray that God will show him mercy.]

I beg you, dear readers… for the love of God… If I have ever done anything to merit your attention, if ever you hear that I have died, please pray for me.  FOR me.

Priests, so much under attack, need your prayers, especially in death.

Why does this account bother me so much?

Let’s drill.

Christ’s death is a mystery, because mysteries reveal something hidden. They show us something unknown, something outside our experience.  In this case we are considering death as a mystery. 

This mystery’s allure and repellence come from the fact that we all must die. 

We instinctively flee from this reality. 

Consequently, we arrange our worlds so as to avoid the fact of death and distract ourselves from it. 

We look for way to occupy out time, shuttling from activity to activity.  We surround ourselves with noise.  We kill time with television, or the internet, or sports or endless forms of play, or even our work, noble though it may be. 

Silence and solitude are shoved aside so that we are less likely to confront the terror. 

That terror is death. 

What terrifies us about the mystery of Christ’s death is not just that He died, but rather that we still have to die even though He died and rose for us. 

We can’t avoid death.  We cannot control death.  We don’t understand death and we fear what we don’t understand.  Fear, at its root, is a result of the Fall.  Death and fear are inseparable, as cause to its effect. 

This is why, I think, so many funerals today are as described above.

Death’s mystery is supremely confronted in Holy Mass, and in its deepest way during the Requiem.    Perhaps this is why funerals tend to reveal the worst of our tendencies toward illicit liturgical creativity and bad taste.  Corruptio optimi pessima.

Holy Mass must be celebrated in such a way that it leads us into the mystery of Christ’s death, and our death.  Mass is therefore like the Cross.  It is a mystery.  It thus will allure and repel, reveal that things are hidden and demand faith in what is unseen, or rather seen only darkly as if through a glass.

We mustn’t dodge the reality of death.  We shove death aside, or paint it over with bright colors and candy music, at our peril.   So many funerals are arrange so that people can get through another hour or so without having confronted anything either frightening or meaningful.  We avert our gaze from what Christ did for us and from what we must yet experience.  

If Holy Mass is reduced to the banal it becomes merely another worldly distraction.  It becomes a show.

But Mass is a sacrament, in the sense of its being a mystery.  It prepares us for death, Christ’s and our own.  What other reason is there to go to any Mass, much less a funeral Mass?

The elements of solemnity, the focus, and the confrontation which characterize the older form of Requiem Mass, are a fearsome challenges to 21st century man. They are precisely what we need to train the soul for an encounter with mystery.  They purify us of our over-attachment to the immediate, to the easily and instantly comprehensible. 

The soul grows in faith, hope and charity only in contact with a reality so far beyond itself, so transcendent, that it cannot be grasped or controlled. 

The soul stands back in awe, in fear and wonder at what it cannot understand and yet knows somehow to be deeply true and necessary. 

Holy Mass necessitates our own sacrifice, deprivation, self-emptying, even unto death.  In this earthly life we are waiting for the Lord, watching for Him to come to fulfill His promises in us.  We are waiting for Him to save us from our incessant fear of death, which St. Augustine called “our daily winter” (ep. 38). 

Only by detachment from the merely worldly and through an interior movement of the soul upward, can the seeker come to “awe at transcendence” (William James), the experience of mystery.  Awe at transcendence, which is the very object of religion, cannot be induced by empty spectacle or too much manipulation of those very elements which draw us to mystery, or, above all, the removal of those elements. 

It must instead be promoted by a purification from distractions, from a measure of deprivation, of hunger, of longing for that which we glimpse only through the cleft in the rock, through the dark glass, through the mystery of the Cross.

Rest in peace, Fr. Schuh.  At least one Mass will be said for your soul’s repose.

A very sad Fr. Z and the promise of a Mass

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
98 Comments

Alaskans, take note!

WDTPRS is quite interested in translations.

Here is something from the usually amusing Engrish worthy of the old incarnation of ICEL:

Special delivery for Sarah Palin…

Alaskans, take note!

Um, you’re gonna need a lot more cheese…

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Statement for WDTPRS from the Spokesperson for H.E. Card. Schönborn

I received this statement from Erich Leitenberger, the spokesman for His Eminence Christoph Card. Schönborn, Archbishop of Vienna.

This regards the entry here, where a video of the Mass in question is posted.  Discussion is there.

Dear Father Zuhlsdorf,

regarding Your blog on the celebration of His Eminence in Wolfsthal I would like to beg you to publish my communiqué of yesterday for the orientation of your public.

Kind regards
Erich Leitenberger
Spokesperson for H.E. Card. Schönborn

The statement:

Some people have taken serious offense in the Holy Mass for young people which was celebrated by the Viennese Cardinal Christoph Schönborn on the 16th of November in Wolfsthal, a village close to the Austrian-Slovakian border.

In contrast to the presumption, due to the in many ways amateurish und unrealistic recorded broadcasting by Gloria TV, it must be clearly stated that in this celebration in no way any kind of liturgical specifications have been violated.

The Eucharistic bread was unleavened and its shape strictly followed the shape which has been used in the Middle East since the 1st century. The “flat cake” is similar to that form used in Mossul in these days – this is the metropolis located at river Tigris where Christians still testify the truth of Jesus with their own blood.

Werner Pirkner, the spiritual councillor for the oly Mass in Wolfsthal, and Stephan Bazalka, coordinator of the Catholic Youth, paid highest attention to the fact that when breaking the bread no tiny little piece of bread ever touched the floor.

Those who have dared, tempted by a fragmentary news coverage, to bring forward accusations against the archbishop of Vienna, may contemplate, repent and ask God for his forgiveness. Let us pray all together for the Holy Church!

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Statement for WDTPRS from the Spokesperson for H.E. Card. Schönborn

Former Sen. Daschle (D-SD) as Sec. of Health and Human Services?

I heard that former Senator Tom Daschle (D-SD) is being considered for a cabinet level position in the new administration.  He is thought to be the next Secretary for Health and Human Services.

Here is an editorial I wrote back in July 2001 (slightly edited) originally posted on the Catholic Online Forum:

Gladiator, Daschle and the leash

In the evening, after a long day of cyber-pastoral work, I like to settle into a comfortable chair and watch a movie, something serious but soothing, like Gladiator, or other blood sports such as cable news and baseball.

This week we witnessed the President of the United States going to the G8 meeting. Great sport that, especially if you are a protester… or Senator Tom Daschle, of South Dakota.

As President Bush stepped off the airplane, the Democrat Senate Majority Leader was slipping a few finely whetted daggers into the absent Chief Executive’s back.

Foul play, that. I am reminded of how the evil Emperor Commodus in the aforementioned film slipped a stiletto into the restrained Maximus’ side before their supposedly fair duel.

Senator Daschle has been on the news a great deal of late. And every time I see him, I can’t help but think about what a man of his convictions he truly is.

For example, I think of the time when Daschle, purportedly Catholic, came to the heel of the Bishop of Sioux Falls, South Dakota.

Go back to 1998. There was a GOP backed bill before the Senate which intended to ban the use of the procedure called "partial-birth" abortion except when a woman risks death by continuing a pregnancy.

Daschle, who supports abortion and indeed partial-birth infanticide, eventually changed his position and voted in favor of the ban. Immediately after the vote, the oh-so-brave Senator excoriated the Roman Catholic Bishops, and Bishop Robert Carlson in particular, on the floor of the Senate.

Daschle said, "Their harsh rhetoric and vitriolic characterizations, usually more identified with the radical right than with thoughtful religious leadership, proved to be a consequential impediment to the decision I have made today."

Daschle might have been practicing the cuts he would later use on the absent President Bush.

I think we can reconstruct with some certainty what happened.

Pretty clearly, Bishop Carlson had been dialoguing with the errant Senatorial sheep for some time. Eventually it came down to a choice: vote like a Catholic or be denounced publicly. Dare we hope that the Bishop promised excommunication? I do.

At any rate, Daschle was up for re-election the next year. Hmmmm….

This would explain why our hero blasted His Excellency on the floor of the Senate, where Bishop Carlson could not respond. This would explain why some of Daschle’s colleagues were perplexed at his decision.

Daschle had tried to propose his own amendments to the bill which would have banned abortions of "viable" babies who could live outside the womb on their own (unless of course the woman’s health…. blah blah blah…). But then the pro-baby-death President Clinton was vetoing anything even slightly resembling a restriction of any kind of abortion at all that came within reach.

So, Daschle’s efforts at a compromise were really no efforts at all. As a matter of fact, Bishop Carlson and other pro-lifers regarded Daschle’s effort as "phony".

Even the president of Planned Parenthood was puzzled at his midstream switch. "If he believed in his own bill, why in the world did he vote for this one?" she asked.

The GOP backed bill needed a large majority that indicated the willingness of the Senate to override an executive veto. With Daschle’s favorable vote, the ban passed 64-36, three short of the 67 needed to override the veto Clinton was sure to hurl down upon it.

The Senator could have voted against the bill: if it passed he knew Clinton would veto it and there would not be enough votes to overturn the veto!

In an interview, Bishop Carlson said it was "unfortunate that the senator has … labeled my actions as those of the radical right." He went on to say, "While I am pleased with the ultimate vote … it still causes me concern that the senator has difficulty voting against a procedure described by some of his pro-choice Democratic colleagues as much closer to infanticide than abortion."

His Excellency explained further that South Dakota has laws identical to the federal bill." So, "I have put some pressure on him because I am concerned about the way he votes," the bishop said.

You would think that the Senator representing South Dakota, which has laws like the bill in question, would be willing to vote according to the will of his own constituency. 

No?

So, what happened?

The bishop whistled and Daschle came to heel.

When faced with defending his convictions, Daschle caved in completely.

He should have been able in good conscience to vote as a Catholic believer should.

But then, not believing as a Catholic should, he then went against his own non-Catholic convictions.

He knew that the Catholic bishop indeed would stand upon his convictions during the senate race the following year.

Daschle even went against the conviction of the people in his home state who elected him. So, the senator caved and then used his congressional bully pulpit to blast his bishop.

Brave, no?

The fact remains, however, that Daschle is capable of doing anything, to anyone, anywhere for his own selfish reasons.

God bless the Bishop of Sioux Falls for helping us to see that.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
27 Comments

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

Four and a half months after the Battle of Gettysburg, on the afternoon of Thursday 19 November 1863, President Abraham Lincoln delivered a "few appropriate remarks" at the dedication of the cemetery for fallen soldiers.

After a 13,607 word speech by Edward Everett, the President’s address consisted of 10 sentences in 272 words.

The Gettysburg Address is one of the greatest pieces of public oratory in history.

I recently visited the Battlefield and the Cemetery. Here are a few images.

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

19 Nov. 1863: The Gettysburg Address

 

Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.

Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure. We are met on a great battle-field of that war. We have come to dedicate a portion of that field, as a final resting place for those who here gave their lives that that nation might live. It is altogether fitting and proper that we should do this.

But, in a larger sense, we can not dedicate — we can not consecrate — we can not hallow — this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us — that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion — that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain — that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom — and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

WSJ on the Synod on Scripture

From the Wall Street Journal

My emphases and comments.

NOVEMBER 14, 2008, 5:19 A.M. ET

A New Counter – Reformation Starts at the Vatican
By DAVID GIBSON

For most of October, more than 200 Catholic bishops, along with sundry theologians and experts, met at the Vatican to figure out how to get Catholics to read the Bible — a project easily dismissed by Protestants and some Catholics as too ambitious and about 500 years too late. After all, wasn’t it Rome’s fears about letting mere lay people consult Holy Writ that stoked the Reformation?  [a canard] And Catholics don’t want to read the Bible anyway, right? They’re all about the Mass and the sacraments.  [Real Catholics are "about" all of it.]

The first supposition has some merit, though the truth is a good deal more complex, and the Reformers — pace, Martin Luther — a good deal less enlightened on that score than is generally assumed. And, yes, Catholics continue to be sacramentally centered Christians who find the "summit and source" of their spiritual nourishment in the Eucharist.

But a funny thing happened on the way to modernity: The Catholic Church opened itself to the Word in a way it hadn’t done before. [When was the Church not open to the Word?]  In the process, it fostered a balanced culture of biblical exegesis and devotion (at least among most scholars and clerics) that many in sola scriptura Protestantism might envy. [Not many… those who do eventually become Catholics.]  Especially in light of trends in mainline denominations that foster a radical deconstruction of biblical texts on the one hand, or, on the other hand, a blinkered literalism that appeals to many conservative pew-sitters.

The revolution in Catholic scholarship really began in 1943, when Pope Pius XII issued a key encyclical called "Divino Afflante Spiritu" ("Inspired by the Divine Spirit"). Pius did not give an unqualified imprimatur to using secular historical criticism on sacred texts, but he did welcome close readings of the Bible that spurred a renaissance in Catholic exegesis. Father Raymond Brown, [grrrrr] the widely respected scriptural scholar, would later call the encyclical the "Magna Carta for biblical progress."

The Second Vatican Council (1962-65) expanded on Pius’s initiative in the document "Dei Verbum" ("Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation"), which firmly placed Scripture at the center of Catholic life alongside the Eucharist [hmmm… sounds like Mass…] and noted that the church and its leaders are at the service of the Word, not the other way around. The council encouraged biblical scholarship by experts and easy access to the Bible for the faithful.

Liturgical changes after the council then transformed the experience of going to Mass, as worshipers heard and read more biblical texts than ever before — including, for the first time, passages from the Old Testament — and in their own language. Catholic scholars, meanwhile, emerged as among the best in the field. Even Pope Benedict XVI, a theologian by trade, has drawn on his love of Scripture to write a well-regarded book, "Jesus of Nazareth."

So what’s the problem? Why did the pope call leading churchmen from around the world to a three-week "Synod on the Word"? For one thing, the Catholic Church — at least in the U.S. — is in no position to claim a high level of biblical literacy among its members. In fact, no church can. Almost all American homes have at least one Bible (93%), and about two-thirds of Americans claim to read it with some regularity. Yet in recent polls only half of U.S. adults could name a single Gospel, and most didn’t know that the first book of the Bible is Genesis. Six in 10 Americans can’t name five of the Ten Commandments. Few can distinguish literary forms like epistles, prophecy and history, and too many confuse inerrancy and literalism.

While the numbers don’t quantify the difference between Catholics and Protestants, a 2000 survey did show that 60% of evangelicals thought Jesus was born in Jerusalem, not that "little town of Bethlehem." And there are indications that Catholics are open to more literary and metaphorical readings of the Bible, especially the Old Testament stories, than many Protestants.

Indeed, a Vatican document prepared for the synod called biblical literalism a dangerous kind of "fundamentalism" that is "winning more and more adherents . . . even among Catholics." It "demands an unshakable adherence to rigid doctrinal points of view and imposes, as the only source of teaching for Christian life and salvation, a reading of the Bible which rejects all questioning and any kind of critical research." Moreover, despite the riches in the treasury of Catholic biblical study, too many Catholics do treat Mass as one-stop shopping for spiritual uplift, contenting themselves with receiving Communion and listening to a homily that may — or may not — refer to the readings that worshipers may — or may not — have paid attention to.

Did the Vatican meeting change that dynamic? The attention at the top is certainly welcome and can tap into a genuine curiosity about the Bible that is too often satisfied by questionable archaeological "discoveries" or cable-television glosses.

But the synod’s 55 final recommendations to the pope (he will likely approve most of them in a document of his own next year), while filled with lovely language about better homilies, could have used a greater focus on small-group bible studies outside the liturgy.  [Uh huh.  Let’s get a whole bunch of people together to spit in the bucket, slosh it around, and interpret Scripture.  To be fair: parish Scripture study groups can be good, but they need close surveillance by someone who really know what is going on.  I was in one parish where there was a very good group.  They used good Catholic resources and it was organized by faithful Catholics who helped to keep things in check.] Living biblically [is a good start, especially if we remember that the Scriptures describe that the Lord established the sacraments and gave His own authority to Peter and the Apostles, and that not everything is contained in Scripture.] is hard to do if you don’t understand the Bible or, worse, if you are afraid of what you might find there. The message of the Bible is simple, in a sense. But even Christ spoke with human words, which were related by human followers and preached by human beings through the centuries. That means the Scriptures are complex, and challenging.

It is no coincidence that the most popular Catholic Bible study program in the U.S. remains the Little Rock Scripture Study, [I don’t know this series.] which was begun in 1974 as a way for Catholics in central Arkansas to hold to their faith amid the region’s dominant Bible-quoting Protestants. The response was overwhelming, and today the program has been used in more than a third of U.S. parishes. But much more needs to be done to promote a Catholic version of the kind of small-group Bible study that is a staple of American Protestantism — and a draw to Catholics who don’t find that kind of engagement in their own church.

In fact, one of the most concrete suggestions at the synod — for "a clear and direct guide that would highlight the rich and useful methods of the Church for reading and sharing sacred Scriptures" — came from Cardinal Daniel DiNardo of Galveston-Houston. He noted that in the Bible Belt, as elsewhere in the U.S., Bible studies are often the locus of grass-roots ecumenical contact, as church-going Catholics and evangelicals often find their passion for issues in the public square coincides with an interest in exploring their respective beliefs. But then they are at odds over Bible and doctrine. That contact becomes a spur to Catholics to learn the Bible but also a challenge to the Catholic Church to equip them with resources that are "totally ecclesial and Catholic."

Unfortunately, the cardinal’s recommendation did not make the final cut. Still, the tools are there, and besides, most reformations start from below. Only this time, perhaps Catholics can lead the way.

Mr. Gibson is a religious affairs writer and author of "The Rule of Benedict: Pope Benedict XVI and His Battle with the Modern World."

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on WSJ on the Synod on Scripture

Bp. D’Arcy on the new translation

A kind reader alerts us to this:

Please find below a statement from my diocesan bishop, His Excellency the Most Rev. John M. D’Arcy [of the Diocese of Fort Wayne – South Bend] regarding the recently-approved new translations of the propers of the season.  He describes the Mass as ineffable!  The excerpt is below and the issue of the diocesan newspaper in which it appears is attached.

So here is the piece, with my emphases and comments.

A new translation

We also approved, after intense discussion, and a number of amendments, many prayers to be included in the new missal. [It must go to the Holy See for approval.]  Our readers may wonder why the church is, once again, looking to change the prayers at Mass, which we have been praying now for many years. Let me say, that I am entirely supportive of this change. [Wise.] The new translations restore a certain sacredness to the words in these prayers.

My old friend and former colleague, Archbishop Al Hughes, served on a commission in Rome, where he goes several times a year, called “Vox Clara” (“Clear Voice”). The archbishop, like myself, graduated from Boston College High School, but I dare say he is a much better Latinist than I am. Remember, the church has very little experience with Mass in modern languages. [Good point.  It is really an unheard of aberration.] For 500 years, the text of the Mass of the Roman rite was Latin, which at one time was almost a universal language.

The effort was to protect the sacredness of the text, and also to protect sound theology. An excellent job has been done, and we expect within a few years there will be a whole new translation of the Mass. I am not anxious about that change. I welcome it and support it.

Surely, there will be a serious pastoral responsibility, especially on the part of priests and bishops to work hard to prepare our people for this change. But I have always found
that if we catechize and teach properly, if we explain the reasons for it and show that this is better and more beautiful, our people will rally behind it. It is a pastoral task, which we can face together. 

Also, the Mass is not something that we make up. [Amen and amen.] We receive it as a gift, an enormous and ineffable gift from Christ through the church. This translation would be better English, more sacred, and will help us to pray. It is a change, which is foundational and helpful and will require the collaboration of all of us. 

Also, this is favored by the Holy See, and a keen obligation of the bishop is always to be in communion with the successor of Peter.

WDTPRS kudos to Bp. D’Arcy.

Also, on p. 16 check out the good commentary on posture for Mass during the Our Father.  There are commonsense observations about holding hands, etc.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Dominican Rite in Anchorage, Alaska

From The Catholic Anchor, the paper of the Archdiocese of Anchorage, Alaska.

Remember that the Latin Church has more than one Latin Rite!

Also… take this away with you, you Dominicans:

The Western and Eastern Provinces of the Dominican order are planning instructive conferences for its friars in the Dominican Rite. The first takes place August 2009 at St. Albert’s priory in Oakland.

My emphases and comments.

Dominican rite aims to shine from the ‘dark ages’ 
Ancient Mass comes to Anchorage

Ethereal chant, incense and perhaps even an ostrich-feathered liturgical fan will soon waft through Holy Family Cathedral in Anchorage.

Beginning Dec. 6, the ancient Dominican rite Mass will be celebrated in Latin every first Saturday of the month at noon.

The successful emergence of the Dominican rite locally is keeping tradition alive, and perhaps fueling organic development of the liturgy into the future.  [Someone may have been reading WDTPRS!]

By early 2009, the Anchorage Archdiocese is also hoping to provide regular celebrations of the Tridentine Latin Mass, which was the standard Roman Catholic liturgy before the Second Vatican Council (1962-65).

Within the universal Catholic Church, there are 22 different rites, such as the Roman, Byzantine and Coptic, that incorporate different traditions into the Mass.

When it comes to forms of the Mass, “often we think of the Masses as ‘pre-Vatican II’ and ‘post-Vatican II,’ and it was more complicated than that,” said Father Vincent Kelber — a Dominican priest at Holy Family Cathedral, where he is preparing to celebrate the Dominican rite.

In 1570, the Council of Trent codified the Tridentine Mass as “the Mass for all time,” he explained. It then served as the main form of the Mass for the Latin Church until the Second Vatican Council.

The Council of Trent, however, allowed for the celebration of those rites which, at the time, had been in existence for at least 200 years, Father Kelber said.

That meant the Dominican order and others like the Carthusians, Cistercians and Carmelites could continue celebrating their own rites, alongside the principal Tridentine Mass.

Father Kelber explained that by the 1200s, it was clear that the Dominicans needed a common liturgical expression for the order’s many priests who preached and celebrated Mass in varied communities across Europe. Thus, the Dominican rite was established.

While the Tridentine Mass is sometimes criticized for being antiquated, it is actually pretty new compared to the medieval Dominican rite, noted Father Kelber. The Tridentine is really “the beginning of the modern era,” he said.

Ancient is new again

Those familiar with the Tridentine Mass will find similarities in the Dominican rite. Both are celebrated in Latin, which for centuries was the sacred liturgical language of the Catholic Church, Father Kelber said.

Additionally, in both the Tridentine and Dominican rites, priests face the same direction as the congregation — toward the altar.   [Thank you for avoiding the cliche, "back to the people"!]

The point is to be “oriented towards the one God,” said Father Kelber. The Eucharist is always central, he added.

Priests also wear special vestments in the Dominican rite, but since the Dominicans “pre-date lace,” explained Father Kelber, they are not as ornate as those in the Tridentine rite.

Catholics may also notice that the Dominican rite contains many signs of reverence, such as bowing, Father Kelber explained.

A penitential prayer, which the priest leads at the start of the Mass, is said before he enters into the sanctuary, “the holy of holies,” Father Kelber said. Also, communicants receive Communion kneeling.

“Every movement in the Mass is purposeful and prayerful; it is embodied worship,” he said.

‘Rite’ for the times

While Vatican II ushered in many needed changes, the continued use of the Dominican rite helped provide stability amid the flux.

“We realize now and Pope Benedict realizes that some of the changes of the Second Vatican Council were good, but some of them were too fast, some weren’t explained, some were poorly implemented and some weren’t according to the documents,” Father Kelber said.

The ancient Masses “helped people to cope,” he added. [Interesting way to put it.]

As part of the patrimony of the church, the ancient Mass is worth preserving, Father Kelber continued.

“It’s okay to have this kind of diversity,” he said.

Father Kelber said it is especially important to appreciate the “ethos” of a pre-reformation tradition, such as that of the Dominicans.

“There is a lot that the medieval times can offer,” he said. “They weren’t in the dark ages at all. [Exactly!] They lived a life that we can see today is something worth emulating in many ways, because it was before the busy-ness of the modern world. They knew what contemplation was, they knew what silence was, and we don’t.”

In the 1980s interest in the Dominican rite grew among the young friars of the Dominicans’ Western Province, said Father Kelber. Interest “bloomed again in a new way” with friars, such as Father Kelber, who were ordained in the late 1990s and early 21-century.

With no formal training on how to celebrate the ancient Mass, Father Kelber said he read about the Mass and worked with other priests familiar with it.

“Preservation work is personal,” he said. “It has to be handed-down. It can’t be just gotten out of a book.”

Now, given the growing interest in the Dominican rite, the Western and Eastern Provinces of the Dominican order are planning instructive conferences for its friars. The first takes place August 2009 at St. Albert’s priory in Oakland.  [Interesting!  I would love to hear more about this.]

Here in Anchorage, with permission from his provincial director and Anchorage Archbishop Roger Schwietz, Father Kelber has been perfecting his practice of the Dominican rite on his days off.

“There are people all over the United States and the world excited about the old rite — excited about Gregorian chant,” he said. “It’s not just one person here saying ‘Well, I miss the old days.’ It’s not just something looking back, but something looking forward and a gift for these crazy times.”

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

A good view of the Greenville controversy

This is from The Catholic Thing and is written by Robert Royal.

My emphases and comments.

The Catholic Thing
Monday, 17 November 2008 
De-forming Consciences  
By Robert Royal    

“Voting for a pro-abortion politician when a plausible pro-life alternative exists constitutes material cooperation with intrinsic evil, and those Catholics who do so place themselves outside of full communion with Christ’s Church and under the judgment of divine law. Persons in this condition should not receive Holy Communion until and unless they are reconciled to God in the Sacrament of Penance, lest they eat and drink their own condemnation.”

Who wrote these words? You might guess Joseph Ratzinger, before he became Benedict XVI, on several occasions, not only about voting for pro-abortion politicians, but about those politicians themselves, if they claim to be Catholics. In fact, the words were written by Fr. J. H. Scott Newman, pastor of St. Mary’s Church in Greenville, South Carolina, and inserted into the parish bulletin last Sunday. Fr. Newman was merely expressing the widespread, longstanding, and clear moral understanding of the Church. No good deed, as we know, goes unpunished. Fr. Newman did so good a deed that he’s been rebuked, [a familiar pattern] not only by the usual media suspects, but by the Charleston diocesan administrator.

I have known Scott Newman since his freshman year at Princeton and would personally vouch for his every word. The managing editor of the magazine I ran back then identified him as a promising new student within days of his arrival on campus. He wrote some unusually mature and perceptive articles. I was not wholly surprised when he later decided to become a Catholic, and I was honored to be his sponsor. Scott subsequently worked in the Caribbean under Bishop Sean O’Malley, before going to Rome, where he became president of his seminary class – also not much of surprise.

He’s not only smart, holy, gifted in working with people, but humble. When the controversy arose, he received 5000 emails, “Most of the people who wrote seem to regard me as either a mighty champion of reform or an evil tool of the devil, and I am naturally hesitant to accept either title. In truth, I am but a useless servant of the Lord Jesus trying, despite my frailty, to be a faithful witness to Him Who is the Way, the Truth, and the Life.” He also pointed out that he had not named any particular candidates in the original statement or, as was misreported by the Associated Press, “denied” anyone Communion.  [Right.  The MSM played a role in this, and not a positive one.]

A shrewd man, Fr. Newman put things in writing. After the bulletin appeared, The Greenville News asked him: “Are you saying that you’ll administer a no-communion policy unless Obama voters partake in penance?” He wrote in reply:

"I cannot and will not refuse Holy Communion to anyone because of his or her political opinions or choices, even as I continue to teach what the Church teaches about the necessity of being in full, visible communion with the Church before receiving the sacraments. Only those who believe what the Catholic Church teaches and who seek to live according to that teaching should even be interested in receiving the sacraments of the Church, and on the question of the intrinsic and grave evil of abortion, there is and can be no doubt about what the Church teaches."  [Therefore… If you voted for a candidate because he supports abortion though you know what the Church teaches, you should rexamine receiving Communion.]
 
That “cannot” reflects Fr. Newman’s proper recognition of the Church’s teaching and his overall reply should have put an end to the matter.

The Catholic Thing has noticed how the national media have taken it upon themselves to reinterpret or ignore hard facts this election season – and now beyond. The AP story was an outrage, by simple journalistic standards, and the fact that the “priest denies Obama voters Communion” story was picked up by ABC and other outlets shows how uncritical our media have become. (Recall, in recent weeks, two young bloggers – Eitan Gorlin and Daniel Mirvish — created a fictional adviser to the McCain campaign, [Incredible but true, but most journalists have their heads filled with cotton, hay and rags.  Couple that with the desire to see your name in the byline and you have disaster.] Martin Eisenstadt, and fabricated a story, widely picked up by sympathetic media, that Sarah Palin did not know Africa was a continent.) But the Newman story was not more of an outrage than several dozen others about religion and politics over past months.

What was truly unusual about Fr. Newman’s case was that his own diocese, trying to clarify the situation, has actually furthered confused American Catholic laity, precisely on the crucial matter of conscience. The administrator of the Charleston Diocese, Msgr Martin T. Loughlin, wrongly construed the case from faulty news reports ["from faulty news reports"] and publicly repudiated Fr. Newman. He quoted from The Catechism of the Catholic Church that we have the right to act freely in conscience. True enough. But he then went on to say: “Christ gives us freedom to explore our own conscience and to make our own decisions while adhering to the law of God and the teachings of the faith. Therefore, if a person has formed his or her conscience well, ["well" is the important word here] he or she should not be denied Communion, nor be told to go to confession before receiving Communion.”

Technically true, but saying this in an America where everyone already has an inflated sense of his right to his or her own opinion – without a very strong warning that a well-formed conscience means serious prayer and study that will take the average American Catholic a good distance from our popular ethos – translates in public as the Biden-Pelosi school of theology, a Catholic Church accepting of the notion of the sovereign self and, in consequence, moral relativism. Like it or not, that’s how our fellow citizens understand such statements. In other words, they’ve now had their consciences further de-formed.  [And it is the fault of clergy whose duty it was to form them properly.]

Fr. Newman’s parishioners came to Mass in large numbers this weekend and applauded so long when he began his homily that they only quieted down when he turned and knelt to the Blessed Sacrament. If you want to know what properly formed consciences are like and what they do, that’s the real story – which you won’t hear about from the AP or ABC.  [But you will hear it here.]

Robert Royal is editor-in-chief of The Catholic Thing, and president of the Faith & Reason Institute in Washington, D.C. His latest book is The God That Did Not Fail: How Religion Built and Sustains the West.

Thank you Dr. Royal!

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
91 Comments

From a priest about the collection for CHD

From a priest reader regarding the collection for the Campaign for Human Development in Catholic parishes.

I want to keep this anonymous.

FYI, the CCHD is a mandatory collection in my diocese ….

However, after the ACORN fiasco I do not feel that, in good conscience, I can take up the collection in my parish. We pitched the envelope and I will send a check for $50 to the chancery. I expect to catch some heat for this, but this is the only way things will really change.

FWIW

What does the CHD collection really say?

UPDATE: 20 Nov 1337 GMT

 

It the interest of balance, at least one diocesan ordinary has issued a statement about the CCHD collection.

"IMPORTANT FACTS ABOUT THIS SUNDAY’S
CATHOLIC CAMPAIGN FOR HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
(CCHD) COLLECTION AND ACORN RUMORS"
 
Date:  November 14, 2008
To:    All pastors and parish administrators
From:  Most Reverend Archbishop John C. Nienstedt
Re:    Important Facts about this Sunday’s CCHD Collection and ACORN Rumors
 
Some parishes and parish administrators have alerted us to an organized campaign by
misinformed individuals intent on discouraging contributions to this weekend’s Catholic
Campaign for Human Development Collection (CCHD).  These individuals are contending that
CCHD still has ties to ACORN, the organization that has been identified with, among other
things, voter registration fraud.
 
Until last June, 2008, CCHD had contributed to the good works of ACORN such as preventing
home foreclosures, creating job opportunities, raising wages and addressing crime and
improving education.  Because of some financial improprieties discussed in June, all financial
support ceased.  Therefore, there was no CCHD monies involved in any of the alleged voter
fraud.  It would be most unfortunate to "punish" CCHD which provides so much help to the
poor.
 
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.  If you have questions, or would like a
copy of the question and answer document about this ACORN issue prepared by the USCCB
Communications, please contact Dennis McGrath, the Archdiocese’s Director of
Communications at 651-291-4412 or email him at mcgrathd@archspm.org.
 
[Link to Morin’s report and the USCCB website link included here]

Here is something from the USCCB’s subcommittee on this:

REPORT OF BISHOP ROGER MORIN, CHAIRMAN
SUBCOMMITTEE ON CATHOLIC CAMPAIGN FOR HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ON CCHD and ACORN
November 11, 2008

For nearly forty years, the Catholic Campaign For Human Development has practiced what the Church teaches about the option for the poor, subsidiarity and solidarity in helping people living in poverty defend their dignity and work for greater justice. Local CCHD-funded groups have made real differences on safer neighborhoods, better schools, decent wages, affordable housing, and immigrant rights. Because the mission of CCHD is so important, the Bishops work very hard to promote it and protect it by careful review and monitoring of CCHD grants to make sure they comply with CCHD’s guidelines and Catholic teaching.

This report covers the steps CCHD and our Conference have taken and are taking to address our serious concerns regarding controversies involving the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now, known as ACORN. In the past, CCHD has funded proposals from local organizations affiliated with ACORN when those activities conform to the CCHD guidelines and when the local diocesan CCHD director and the local diocesan bishop explicitly approve the proposal. Many of these local ACORN groups have done impressive work preventing home foreclosures, creating jobs opportunities, raising wages, addressing crime and improving education.

Last June, CCHD cut off funding to all ACORN groups when we learned about a major case of embezzlement eight years ago that was covered up by ACORN staff leadership. This theft and cover-up raised serious concerns about national ACORN’s financial accountability, transparency, governance and organizational integrity. Even though CCHD was only funding local ACORN organizations, and not these national structures, we felt it was necessary to cut off CCHD funding and review support of all ACORN groups.

More recently, the Subcommittee also became concerned about widespread reports of ACORN involvement in alleged voter registration fraud and political partisanship. As a result of the cut-off earlier this year, no CCHD funds were involved in any of these activities. However, the allegations intensified our questions and problems around ACORN’s organizational integrity, competence and non-partisanship. Therefore, we extended the cut off of CCHD funding of any ACORN organizations.

The Bishops’ CCHD Subcommittee met November 8-9 and reviewed this matter at length and discussed it in depth. The Bishop members of the Subcommittee voted unanimously to reaffirm, extend and formalize the decision to end CCHD funding of ACORN organizations because of serious concerns about financial accountability, organizational performance and political partisanship. While not all the specifics can be known, we simply had too many continuing questions and concerns about these serious matters to permit CCHD funding of ACORN groups. Dioceses have told us about the good work done by local ACORN affiliates and we regret that they will not be able to receive CCHD support. We simply could not be absolutely sure that CCHD resources would be used in a manner consistent with our criteria and funding guidelines. This cut off means that no CCHD grants were given to ACORN groups this year (using funds from the 2007 CCHD collection) and no funds from the coming collection (to be taken up in on November 23-24  in many dioceses) will go to ACORN in any place or at any level.

In addition to this funding cutoff, the CCHD Subcommittee and staff have taken a number of other steps:

I chair a special working group within the Bishops’ CCHD Subcommittee to monitor and act on this continuing situation.

CCHD and the USCCB have secured the services of specialists in forensic accounting to help determine if any CCHD money was taken or misused. This investigation is thorough and ongoing.

CCHD, USCCB staff and I have met with ACORN leaders to express our serious concerns and to seek answers to specific questions.

We continue to consult with our CCHD Diocesan Directors to seek their guidance.

The Subcommittee also voted that CCHD should work with others to assist low-income community organizations to adopt and model best practices in areas of financial accountability, organizational management and effective governance. The Subcommittee believes that these efforts can help community organizations and CCHD to carry out more effectively our essential mission of empowering and assisting low-income communities in pursuing economic and social justice.

CCHD’s current criteria and guidelines prohibit partisan activity and funding of any group that engages in activities contrary to Catholic moral teaching, whether or not those activities are funded by CCHD.  These criteria are actively enforced and have led CCHD to deny funding to many groups and to quickly terminate any group that violates these prohibitions. The Bishops’ CCHD Subcommittee and staff are reviewing these existing CCHD’s policies, grant agreements, and other safeguards in order to reaffirm and strengthen our protections in areas of Church teaching, financial and organizational accountability, and partisan political activity. We are also examining ways to affirm and articulate the continuing efforts of CCHD in language clearly reflecting the principles of Catholic social teaching, which are at the heart of our mission.

Supporters of CCHD can be reassured for the way CCHD has responded to these challenges and take pride in the impressive and creative ways CCHD carries out the values of the Gospel and the principles of our Catholic faith in rural communities and urban neighborhoods across our nation. Everyday countless numbers of our brothers and sisters are able to say they have been lifted from the scourge of poverty and are able to achieve self sufficiency.

CCHD is fully committed to protecting and carrying out our essential mission “to bring good news to the poor, liberty to captives, new sight to the blind and to set the downtrodden free” (Luke 4). That was Jesus’ mission on earth and that is CCHD’s mission today.

 

Posted in Mail from priests |
48 Comments