National Catholic Prayer Breakfast: President Bush’s remarks – updated

Here are President Bush’s remarks at the National Catholic Prayer Breakfast.  My emphases and comments.

Play video

Washington Hilton Hotel
Washington, D.C.
8:33 A.M. EDT

THE PRESIDENT: Thank you for the gracious welcome. Austin, thanks for your kind introduction. Thanks for giving me this unusual speaking opportunity. I understand that this program builds up to another speech. (Laughter.) It’s not every day you get to be the warm-up act to the Holy Father. (Laughter.) I’m honored to be here. I do thank Austin for his leadership for the Catholic Prayer Breakfast. I thank the Board of Directors for having me. I thank Archbishop Gomez, tejano, for being here. And I want to thank Bishop Finn, [Bp. of Kansas City, KS] members of the clergy. Thank you for serving our country. Thank you for being men of faith.

I’m proud to be here with the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, John Roberts. (Applause.) He’s always looking for a free breakfast. (Laughter.) Proud to be here with members of the United States Senate and Congress. Thank you all for being here. Solicitor General Paul Clement is with us today. (Applause.) Members of my administration, members of the Diplomatic Corps and distinguished guests.

This has been a joyous week. (Applause.) It’s been a joyous time for Catholics — and it wasn’t such a bad week for Methodists, either. (Laughter.) The excitement was just palpable. The streets were lined with people that were so thrilled that the Holy Father was here. And it was such a privilege to welcome this good man to the United States.

For those of you on the South Lawn — who saw the South Lawn ceremony live, it was — what an unbelievable — it was just such a special moment. (Applause.) And it was a special moment to be able to visit with the Holy Father in the Oval Office. He is a humble servant of God. He is a brilliant professor. He is a warm and generous soul.

He is courageous in the defense of fundamental truths. (Applause.) His Holiness believes that freedom is the Almighty’s gift to every man, woman and child on Earth. He understands that every person has value, or to use his words, "each of us is willed, each of us is loved, [and] each of us is necessary." (Applause.)

The Holy Father strongly believes that to whom much is given much is required — and he is a messenger of God’s call to love our neighbors as we’d like to be loved ourselves.

I’ve seen how American Catholics are guided by these truths. One of the blessings of being the President is I get to see firsthand how people are motivated by the fundamental truths articulated by the Holy Father. I’ve watched you live out the Gospel through countless acts of compassion and courage. I’ve joined with you in striving to heed the Scriptures’ noble calling: to see God’s image in all mankind, and to uphold the dignity of each human being on Earth. (Applause.)

Together, over the nearly seven and a half years we’ve worked to uphold the dignity of human life. Over the last — over the last years, my administration has put a stop to U.S. tax dollars funding foreign groups that perform or promote abortions. (Applause.) We’ve worked together to protect unborn victims of violence, and to end the barbaric practice of partial-birth abortion. (Applause.) We have stood fast in our belief that promising medical advances can co-exist with ethical medical practices. (Applause.) Last November, scientists discovered a way to reprogram adult skin cells to act like embryonic stem cells. This is a significant breakthrough, because science — scientists have found a path that can lead beyond the divisive debates of the past — and extend the healing potential of medicine without destroying human life. (Applause.)

Together, we’ve worked to strengthen America’s lifelines of learning — including our nation’s Catholic schools. The Catholic Church has a proud educational tradition dating back centuries, and one of the Holy Father’s priorities has been maintaining this tradition in the United States. Today, America’s Catholic schools serve thousands of students — both Catholic and non-Catholic — in some of our nation’s poorest neighborhoods. They help minority students narrow the achievement gap. They prepare children for lives of character and purpose and success. And yet these schools are closing at an alarming rate: nearly 1,200 Catholic schools have shut their doors since the year 2000.

In my State of the Union address this January, I proposed a new $300 million program called Pell Grants for Kids. And the reason I did so is because I want to help low-income children in underperforming public schools be able to attend a private or parochial school of their choice. (Applause.) I am concerned about the loss of a major national asset, and that is the decline of Catholic schools, particularly in inner-city America. And to this end, next week we’re having a White House Summit on Inner-City Children and Faith-Based Schools. (Applause.) And the purpose of the summit is to highlight the lack of educational options facing low-income urban students. And we’re going to bring together educators and clergy and philanthropists and business leaders, all aiming to urge there to be reasonable legislation out of Congress and practical solutions to save these schools — and more importantly, to save the children. (Applause.)

And some of the people trying to save America’s Catholic schools are here at this prayer breakfast, and I can’t thank you enough for your efforts. (Applause.)

Together, we’ve worked to foster a culture of tolerance and peace. We believe that religion should be a source of understanding and grace — not a source of extremism and violence. On his visit and throughout his time as the Holy Father, the Pope has worked to foster inter-religious dialogue, and to heal the wounds of religious conflict. I strongly support the Pope’s call for religious freedom around the world. I share his concern for Christians in the Middle East, and his desire to see a peaceful and independent Lebanon. I respect his scholarship, which demonstrates that faith and reason can co-exist. And I join him in praying for a world at peace, where Christians and Muslims and Jews, believers and non-believers, can live side by side. And I thank all of you here who work to make this hopeful vision a reality. (Applause.)

Together, we’ve worked to bring comfort to troubled souls. We believe that where hearts are burdened by destitution and disease and despair, we must answer with hope and love and faith. We know that [no] government program can answer the call like our armies of compassion can — but we also know that government programs can support, and must support, their work. And so I’ve been a strong believer in faith-based and community based effort to bring healing and hope to people who wonder whether or not there’s a bright tomorrow.

I don’t know if you really realize this, but in 2006, 3,000 direct federal grants totaling more than $2 billion were made to faith-based organizations — including many Catholic organizations. (Applause.) And the reason why is because Catholic organizations provide shelter to the homeless in very effective and loving ways. They tutor at-risk youth. They help children of prisoners, while at the same time they work tirelessly to help prisoners get back on their feet. These groups seek out our society’s most vulnerable and fulfill Christ’s promise that "the last shall be first."

Abroad, Catholic organizations are a vital part, an integral part of our effort to fight hunger and disease from Latin America to the continent of Africa. In these places, Catholic groups have a hand in what some call the "Lazarus Effect," where whole communities that once lay dying are brought back to life.

Oftentimes people ask me, why is it that you’re so focused on helping the hungry and diseased in strange parts of the world? My answer is, we’re a wealthy enough nation to take care of people at home and to help those abroad; it is in our moral interests that when we find people suffering that we do all we can do to help ease the burden; it’s in our national interests — (applause) — and it’s in our national interests that we defeat the ideologues of hate with an ideology of hope.

During these — as President I’ve seen some of the great wonders of compassion as a result of our Catholic citizens. I’ve seen them here in Washington, with the Little Sisters of the Poor. (Applause.) Laura and I had the honor of visiting with the Little Sisters and, you know, I was struck by how hard they worked to ask [for] money to care for the old and sick, so that the old and sick don’t have to beg for money.

I’ve seen these wonders of Catholic love on the Gulf Coast. I’m struck by the Catholic educators that in the face of unprecedented disaster worked night and day to provide good and stable schools for the children, and provide comfort for, you know, people that were just wondering whether or not there was going to be a good tomorrow.

I’ve seen wonders on the Sea of Galilee during my recent trip to the Middle East. On a recent visit my guides were joyful Catholic nuns who preserve the holy sites for all mankind — even as they struggle with the dangers to the region’s Christian minority.

I’ve seen these wonders in Africa, in an emergency — in a hospital supported by PEPFAR. In February, I saw a 9-year-old girl who is HIV-positive, who had lost both her parents to AIDS. And for the last year, Catholic Relief Services had been paying for the girl to receive treatment at the clinic. I want to tell you what her grandmother said: "As a Muslim, I never imagined that a Catholic group would help me like that." She went on to say, "I am so grateful to the American people." And I am grateful for those who provide love and compassion in America and around the world. (Applause.)

This is a prayer breakfast. And this is a perfect place for me to say how much I appreciate the prayers of the people for me and Laura. I can’t thank our fellow citizens enough for taking time out of their lives to lift us up for prayer. I have finally begun to understand the story of the calm and the rough seas — (laughter) — and I believe — I believe in my heart of hearts that it’s because of the prayers of my fellow citizens.

And today with the trust in the Lord’s wisdom and goodness, I offer prayers of my own: for each gathered in the room, for the safety and success of the Holy Father’s visit, and for God’s continued blessings on our great land. Thank you. (Applause.) 

This address was followed by the fine keynote of Bishop Finn of Kansas City, Missouri. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

NatReview: Kathleen Parker – In praise of criticism

Here is a good piece by Kathleen Parker of National Review, with my emphases and comments.

April 18, 2008, 0:00 a.m.

‘Out of Step’
In praise of criticism.

By Kathleen Parker

Pope Benedict XVI’s visit to the U.S. has afforded the American media and others an opportunity to remind us that the Catholic Church is “out of step” with modern times.

That is both a criticism and compliment — praising with faint damnation. [Very nice!]

What exactly about modern times would compel a pope to change his institutional mind about the fundamental belief in, say, the dignity of all human life?  [It is amazing that some people gripe at the Catholic Church thinking that the Church is going to wake up one day and say, "Hey!  Let’s change our doctrine on the diginity of human life!"]

The central life issue is, of course, abortion, [Maybe so… but I am inclined to think that this is two-fold: it is about abortion insofar as it is about genetic reseach, but also abortion is lumped together with contraception.] about which even a majority of American Catholics (58 percent) differ from the Church’s view. Other related concerns include embryo-destructive research, cloning, and assisted suicide.

The Catholic Church persists in opposing all of the above, insisting that life begins at conception, all life has value, no human being has the right to terminate the life of another. Case closed.  [Not quite.  The Church’s doctrine, though it was made somewhat more circumscribed by John Paul II and Evangelium vitae and the CCC, still allows for capital punishment in some circumstances and still foresees the possibility of a just war, self-defense, etc.]

And, really, who would insist otherwise? In the abstract, few. In practice, millions.

Though we know that life biologically begins at conception, we’ve decided to disagree about when that life becomes “human.”  [If is begins biologically at conception, then what else matters?  What was conceived is human, not a giraffe.]

And, though we sort of believe that all life has value, our actions suggest that we think imperfect life has less value. Increasingly, Down Syndrome babies today are terminated, for instance. [So, people are conditioned to ascribe value to others insofar as they are useful or, at least, not a burden.  But they don’t think in terms of intrinsic value.]

If we quantify human life only according to productivity, then imperfect life inarguably is less valuable. But is it less human? Nazi eugenicists thought so. [Margaret Sanger and Planned Parenthood think so.]  But measuring productivity requires a detached calculation — and, inevitably, bureaucratic enforcement — that defines inhuman.

This is not, by the way, a judgment of people who have made difficult choices. None of us really knows which path we would take until presented with the intersection that forces such contemplations. [True, which is why we must deal with people who have in fact made the wrong decisions, in the tangle of their lives, with compassion.]

Finally, all agree that no human being has the right to take another’s life except in self-defense. [There is it.  Good.] Since most abortions are for reasons other than the mother’s health, our current practices are possible only if the unborn are considered “not human.”  [The problem with this is that when you kill in self-defense, you are killing an aggressor, usually a culpable aggressor.  Babies are not culpable aggressors.]

Keeping that definition alive is the trick. Human or not? Who decides?

A majority of Americans are comfortable with the view that a woman, her doctor, and her God should decide. But what if there were irrefutable proof that a fetus at conception is fully human? Would we then feel that government has a role in protecting unborn life?

These questions are especially tricky for Catholics. For those who side with the pope, [Actually, this goes beyond the Pope.  Popes didn’t make this stuff up.  They clearly articulate the teachings.  They are obvious spokesmen.]  the answer is clear: If life is a gift of the creator, then only the creator can be the ultimate arbiter of conception (though the Church does allow for limiting and spacing babies on the basis of informed conscience, just not through artificial means).

To believe in God’s autonomy over human life, however, is a hard sell. [It wasn’t always.] How does one justify creating more mouths [WE don’t do the "creating".] when so many can’t be fed? My own Catholic grandmother, the youngest of 11 children, was handed over to the nuns at age 4 when her family could no longer feed her.

And yet, the nuns did feed my grandmother. And she did manage to grow up and marry and create my father, who then created me. So.  [We cooperate in the God’s creation, we don’t create.]

Pro-choice [Let’s call it for what it is: pro-abortion.] arguments are, nonetheless, compelling. Privacy from government intrusion, yes. Women’s autonomy over their own bodies, yes. All children wanted, well, of course. But none of those testaments to logic [I don’t think I will accept the premise that those things are entirely logical, not when they wind up the pro-abortion conclusion.] alters the essential truth that life begins [The truly "logical" starting point.] when egg and sperm commingle and that every one of us was at that far end of the life continuum before we were able to dabble in ethics and trifle with electronic keyboards.

The question is how we reconcile what is true with what is merely convenient? That we might choose a path other than the pope’s is the prerogative of a free people — and no one recognizes that freedom with greater consistency than this pope. No one has to be Catholic.

But to ask Benedict to change the church’s rules to suit modern appetites and lifestyles is to ask that he forsake the sanctity of human life for the benefit of earthly delights. Those are not his concerns.

Even for non-Catholics like me, there’s something comforting about a stubborn pope in a world of moral relativity. Like a strong father, he ignores his children’s pleas for leniency knowing that his rules, though tough, serve a higher purpose.

If Benedict were to relent and compromise the value of human life, what would be left to debate? Perhaps only one’s own time to die. And then …

Who decides?

 

There are some holes in the piece, but all in all this is good. 

What I particularly like is the fact that Parker, as a non-Catholic, has taken the time really to think about what it means to have a single figure who can speak authoritatively on a matter of ethics.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

Benedict XVI: deparature address

First, let me say that I don’t know much about US or diplomatic protocol for visits and departures by heads of state, but I thought Vice President Cheney and his wife staying for the until the papal airplane actually pulled away were a class act.

Here is the text of the Holy Father’s departure address.  What a great cap to a marvelous few days.

Mr. Vice-President,
Distinguished Civil Authorities,
My Brother Bishops,
Dear Brothers and Sisters,

The time has come for me to bid farewell to your country. These days that I have spent in the United States have been blessed with many memorable experiences of American hospitality, and I wish to express my deep appreciation to all of you for your kind welcome. It has been a joy for me to witness the faith and devotion of the Catholic community here. It was heart-warming to spend time with leaders and representatives of other Christian communities and other religions, and I renew my assurances of respect and esteem to all of you. I am grateful to President Bush for kindly coming to greet me at the start of my visit, and I thank Vice-President Cheney for his presence here as I depart. The civic authorities, workers and volunteers in Washington and New York have given generously of their time and resources in order to ensure the smooth progress of my visit at every stage, and for this I express my profound thanks and appreciation to Mayor Adrian Fenty of Washington and Mayor Michael Bloomberg of New York.

Once again I offer prayerful good wishes to the representatives of the see of Baltimore, the first Archdiocese, and those of New York, Boston, Philadelphia and Louisville, in this jubilee year. May the Lord continue to bless you in the years ahead. To all my Brother Bishops, to Bishop DiMarzio of this Diocese of Brooklyn, and to the officers and staff of the Episcopal Conference who have contributed in so many ways to the preparation of this visit, I extend my renewed gratitude for their hard work and dedication. With great affection I greet once more the priests and religious, the deacons, the seminarians and young people, and all the faithful in the United States, and I encourage you to continue bearing joyful witness to Christ our Hope, our Risen Lord and Savior, who makes all things new and gives us life in abundance.

One of the high-points of my visit was the opportunity to address the General Assembly of the United Nations, and I thank Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon for his kind invitation and welcome. [I believe this was the first invitation that sparked the visit.] Looking back over the sixty years that have passed since the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, I give thanks for all that the Organization has been able to achieve in defending and promoting the fundamental rights of every man, woman and child throughout the world, and I encourage people of good will everywhere to continue working tirelessly to promote justice and peaceful co-existence between peoples and nations.

My visit this morning to Ground Zero will remain firmly etched in my memory, as I continue to pray for those who died and for all who suffer in consequence of the tragedy that occurred there in 2001. For all the people of America, and indeed throughout the world, I pray that the future will bring increased fraternity and solidarity, a growth in mutual respect, and a renewed trust and confidence in God, our heavenly Father.

With these words, I take my leave, I ask you to remember me in your prayers, and I assure you of my affection and friendship in the Lord. May God bless America!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Benedict XVI: deparature address

Rumination

I am still digesting.

Are you still digesting?

Such rich fare over the last few days.  

Rumination

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

Benedict XVI’s sermon at the Mass in the Bronx

 Here is the text of the Holy Father’s sermon for his Holy Mass in The Bronx, in NYC.  My emphases and comments:
 

Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ,

In the Gospel we have just heard, Jesus tells his Apostles to put their faith in him, for he is "the way, and the truth and the life" (Jn 14:6). Christ is the way that leads to the Father, the truth which gives meaning to human existence, and the source of that life which is eternal joy with all the saints in his heavenly Kingdom. Let us take the Lord at his word! Let us renew our faith in him and put all our hope in his promises!

With this encouragement to persevere in the faith of Peter (cf. Lk 22:32; Mt 16:17), I greet all of you with great affection. I thank Cardinal Egan for his cordial words of welcome in your name. At this Mass, the Church in the United States celebrates the two hundredth anniversary of the creation of the Sees of New York, Boston, Philadelphia and Louisville from the mother See of Baltimore. The presence around this altar of the Successor of Peter, his brother bishops and priests, and deacons, men and women religious, and lay faithful from throughout the fifty states of the Union, eloquently manifests our communion in the Catholic faith which comes to us from the Apostles. [There is no conflict betwee being an American and being a Catholic!]

Our celebration today is also a sign of the impressive growth which God has given to the Church in your country in the past two hundred years. From a small flock like that described in the first reading, the Church in America has been built up in fidelity to the twin commandment of love of God and love of neighbor. In this land of freedom and opportunity, the Church has united a widely diverse flock in the profession of the faith and, through her many educational, charitable and social works, has also contributed significantly to the growth of American society as a whole. [The Church has made a huge contribution in the United States.]

This great accomplishment was not without its challenges. Today’s first reading, taken from the Acts of the Apostles, speaks of linguistic and cultural tensions already present within the earliest Church community.  At the same time, it shows the power of the word of God, authoritatively proclaimed by the Apostles and received in faith, to create a unity which transcends the divisions arising from human limitations and weakness. Here we are reminded of a fundamental truth: that the Church’s unity has no other basis than the Word of God, made flesh in Christ Jesus our Lord. [Not in formulas, or abstractions, but in the Divine Person of the Lord!] All external signs of identity, all structures, associations and programs, valuable or even essential as they may be, ultimately exist only to support and foster the deeper unity which, in Christ, is God’s indefectible gift to his Church.

The first reading also makes clear, as we see from the imposition of hands on the first deacons, that the Church’s unity is "apostolic". It is a visible unity, grounded in the Apostles whom Christ chose and appointed as witnesses to his resurrection, and it is born of what the Scriptures call "the obedience of faith" (Rom 1:5; cf. Acts 6:7).

"Authority" … "obedience". To be frank, these are not easy words to speak nowadays. Words like these represent a "stumbling stone" for many of our contemporaries, especially in a society which rightly places a high value on personal freedom. [Remember the distinctions he made yesterday, with young people, about "freedom".] Yet, in the light of our faith in Jesus Christ – "the way and the truth and the life" [He links authority and obedience to the Lord’s Person.] – we come to see the fullest meaning, value, and indeed beauty, of those words. The Gospel teaches us that true freedom, the freedom of the children of God, is found only in the self-surrender which is part of the mystery of love. Only by losing ourselves, the Lord tells us, do we truly find ourselves (cf. Lk 17:33). True freedom blossoms when we turn away from the burden of sin, which clouds our perceptions and weakens our resolve, and find the source of our ultimate happiness in him who is infinite love, infinite freedom, infinite life. "In his will is our peace".  [This is a quote from Dante’s Divina Commedia, Par. 3.85: E’n la sua volontade è nostra pace]

Real freedom, then, is God’s gracious gift, the fruit of conversion to his truth, the truth which makes us free (cf. Jn 8:32). And this freedom in truth brings in its wake a new and liberating way of seeing reality. When we put on "the mind of Christ" (cf. Phil 2:5),  [I love that.  The Word was clothed in our nature, and we put on Christ.] new horizons open before us! In the light of faith, within the communion of the Church, we also find the inspiration and strength to become a leaven of the Gospel in the world. We become the light of the world, the salt of the earth (cf. Mt 5:13-14), entrusted with the "apostolate" of making our own lives, and the world in which we live, conform ever more fully to God’s saving plan.

This magnificent vision of a world being transformed by the liberating truth of the Gospel is reflected in the description of the Church found in today’s second reading. The Apostle tells us that Christ, risen from the dead, is the keystone of a great temple which is even now rising in the Spirit. [The Rising is continuous in us, the living stones built into the temple!] And we, the members of his body, through Baptism have become "living stones" in that temple, sharing in the life of God by grace, blessed with the freedom of the sons of God, and empowered to offer spiritual sacrifices pleasing to him (cf. 1 Pet 2:5). And what is this offering which we are called to make, if not [in freedom] to direct our every thought, word and action to the truth of the Gospel and to harness all our energies in the service of God’s Kingdom? Only in this way can we build with God, on the one foundation which is Christ (cf. 1 Cor 3:11). Only in this way can we build something that will truly endure. Only in this way can our lives find ultimate meaning and bear lasting fruit.

Today we recall the bicentennial of a watershed in the history of the Church in the United States: its first great chapter of growth. In these two hundred years, the face of the Catholic community in your country has changed greatly. We think of the successive waves of immigrants whose traditions have so enriched the Church in America. [NB: So long as it is authentic inculturation.] We think of the strong faith which built up the network of churches, educational, healthcare and social institutions which have long been the hallmark of the Church in this land. We think also of those [What follows also reprises the Holy Father’s comments yesterday on vocations.] countless fathers and mothers who passed on the faith to their children, the steady ministry of the many priests who devoted their lives to the care of souls, and the incalculable contribution made by so many men and women religious, who not only taught generations of children how to read and write, but also inspired in them a lifelong desire to know God, to love him and to serve him. How many "spiritual sacrifices pleasing to God" have been offered up in these two centuries! [So short in the history of the Church, but having accomplished so much!] In this land of religious liberty, Catholics found freedom not only to practice their faith, but also to participate fully in civic life, bringing their deepest moral convictions to the public square and cooperating with their neighbors in shaping a vibrant, democratic society. [Catholics in the public square is an important point for Pope Benedict.  He is fighting for our voice and striving to reinvigorate our Catholic identity.] Today’s celebration is more than an occasion of gratitude for graces received. It is also a summons to move forward with firm resolve to use wisely the blessings of freedom, in order to build a future of hope for coming generations.

"You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people he claims for his own, to proclaim his glorious works" (1 Pet 2:9). These words of the Apostle Peter do not simply remind us of the dignity which is ours by God’s grace; they also challenge us to an ever greater fidelity to the glorious inheritance which we have received in Christ (cf. Eph 1:18). They challenge us to examine our consciences, to purify our hearts, to renew our baptismal commitment to reject Satan and all his empty promises. They challenge us to be a people of joy, heralds of the unfailing hope (cf. Rom 5:5) born of faith in God’s word, and trust in his promises.

Each day, throughout this land, you and so many of your neighbors pray to the Father in the Lord’s own words: "Thy Kingdom come". [A prayer common to all Christians.] This prayer needs to shape the mind and heart of every Christian in this nation. It needs to bear fruit in the way you lead your lives and in the way you build up your families and your communities. It needs to create new "settings of hope" (cf. Spe Salvi, 32ff.) where God’s Kingdom becomes present in all its saving power.

Praying fervently for the coming of the Kingdom also means being constantly alert for the signs of its presence, and working for its growth in every sector of society. It means facing the challenges of present and future with confidence in Christ’s victory and a commitment to extending his reign. [Not being complacent, perhaps, about non-Catholics?] It means not losing heart in the face of resistance, adversity and scandal. It means overcoming every separation between faith and life, [we cannot separate faith from life] and countering false gospels of freedom and happiness. It also means rejecting a false dichotomy between faith and political life, [as some Catholic politicians do everywhere in the world!  ] since, as the Second Vatican Council put it, "there is no human activity – even in secular affairs – which can be withdrawn from God’s dominion" (Lumen Gentium, 36). It means working to enrich American society and culture with the beauty and truth of the Gospel, and never losing sight of that great hope which gives meaning and value to all the other hopes which inspire our lives.  [He is pressing the issue of the public square very strongly!]

[And now the Vicar of Christ is going to give  specific challenge to the Catholic Church in the USA… to all Catholics]

And this, dear friends, is the particular challenge which the Successor of Saint Peter sets before you today. As "a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation", follow faithfully in the footsteps of those who have gone before you! Hasten the coming of God’s Kingdom in this land! Past generations have left you an impressive legacy. In our day too, the Catholic community in this nation has been outstanding in its prophetic witness in the defense of life, in the education of the young, in care for the poor, the sick and the stranger in your midst. On these solid foundations, the future of the Church in America must even now begin to rise!  [Don’t loose your path!  Maintain continuity!]

Yesterday, not far from here, I was moved by the joy, the hope and the generous love of Christ which I saw on the faces of the many young people assembled in Dunwoodie. They are the Church’s future, and they deserve all the prayer and support that you can give them. And so I wish to close by adding a special word of encouragement to them. My dear young friends, like the seven men, "filled with the Spirit and wisdom" whom the Apostles charged with care for the young Church, may you step forward and take up the responsibility which your faith in Christ sets before you! May you find the courage to proclaim Christ, "the same, yesterday, and today and for ever" and the unchanging truths which have their foundation in him (cf. Gaudium et Spes, 10; Heb 13:8). These are the truths that set us free! They are the truths which alone can guarantee respect for the inalienable dignity and rights of each man, woman and child in our world – including the most defenseless of all human beings, the unborn child in the mother’s womb. [Is this the first explicit mention of the unborn during the visit?  The crowd applauded strongly for the first time in the sermon!] In a world where, as Pope John Paul II, speaking in this very place, reminded us, Lazarus continues to stand at our door (Homily at Yankee Stadium, October 2, 1979, No. 7), let your faith and love bear rich fruit in outreach to the poor, the needy and those without a voice. Young men and women of America, I urge you: open your hearts to the Lord’s call to follow him in the priesthood and the religious life. Can there be any greater mark of love than this: to follow in the footsteps of Christ, who was willing to lay down his life for his friends (cf. Jn 15:13)?  [More applause.

The Holy Father is pressing his message for young people. I am reminded of what the Holy told Peter Seewald in his book long interview about feeling like a grandfather preserving things for his grandchildren, rather than for his children.  There seems to be in his thought a generational leap.  I find that comment from, I think, Salt of the Earth, truly fascinating.  It was made at a time, I think, when Papa Ratzinger was thinking he might retire.  He may have a different perspective now, but it seems to me that this view is still strong.  This isn’t any sort of abandoning of anyone, but rather an special hope for the young who, perhaps, are not burdened with some of the baggage of last generation.]

In today’s Gospel, the Lord promises his disciples that they will perform works even greater than his (cf. Jn 14:12). Dear friends, only God in his providence knows what works his grace has yet to bring forth in your lives and in the life of the Church in the United States.  [Do not be presumptuous, either!] Yet Christ’s promise fills us with sure hope. Let us now join our prayers to his, as living stones in that spiritual temple which is his one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. Let us lift our eyes to him, for even now he is preparing for us a place in his Father’s house. And empowered by his Holy Spirit, let us work with renewed zeal for the spread of his Kingdom.

"Happy are you who believe!" (cf. 1 Pet 2:7). Let us turn to Jesus! He alone is the way that leads to eternal happiness, the truth who satisfies the deepest longings of every heart, and the life who brings ever new joy and hope, to us and to our world. Amen.

* * *

Queridos hermanos y hermanas en el Señor:

Les saludo con afecto y me alegro de celebrar esta Santa Misa para dar gracias a Dios por el bicentenario del momento en que empezó a desarrollarse la Iglesia Católica en esta Nación. Al mirar el camino de fe recorrido en estos años, no exento también de dificultades, alabamos al Señor por los frutos que la Palabra de Dios ha dado en estas tierras y le manifestamos nuestro deseo de que Cristo, Camino, Verdad y Vida, sea cada vez más conocido y amado.

Aquí, en este País de libertad, quiero proclamar con fuerza que la Palabra de Cristo no elimina nuestras [!] aspiraciones a una vida plena y libre, [He seems in this simple way to make their aspirations for freedom and a better life his own, and so subtly.] sino que nos descubre nuestra verdadera dignidad de hijos de Dios y nos alienta a luchar contra todo aquello que nos esclaviza, empezando por nuestro propio egoísmo y caprichos. Al mismo tiempo, nos anima a manifestar nuestra fe a través de nuestra vida de caridad y a hacer que nuestras comunidades eclesiales sean cada día más acogedoras y fraternas.

Sobre todo a los jóvenes les confío asumir el gran reto que entraña creer en Cristo y lograr que esa fe se manifieste en una cercanía efectiva hacia los pobres. También en una respuesta generosa a las llamadas que Él sigue formulando para dejarlo todo y emprender una vida de total consagración a Dios y a la Iglesia, [Applause! And remember the commitment not just God, but the Church… don’t fall away from the Catholic Church!  So many people fall away.] en la vida sacerdotal o religiosa.

Queridos hermanos y hermanas, les invito a mirar el futuro con esperanza, permitiendo que Jesús entre en sus vidas. Solamente Él es el camino que conduce a la felicidad que no acaba, la verdad que satisface las más nobles expectativas humanas y la vida colmada de gozo para bien de la Iglesia y el mundo. Que Dios les bendiga.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
24 Comments

Comments on the Pope’s Mass in the Bronx – updated

I will post some comments on the Holy Father’s Mass as it progresses.  I sincerely hope it will be fruitful for all who follow it!

As soon as the Holy Father finishes his sermon, I will post it in another entry and also add my commentary to it.

2:24
Alas, Shepherd is stumbling a bit on FNC… I think I will shift to another audio.

2:25
The Holy Father has left the "popemobile" and has gone to vest.

2:36
Joan Lewis made a comment on EWTN, about the music being more "Classical" rather than representing multi-cultural values.  I think Classical does represent multi-cultural values.  Also, Raymond Arroyo and Fr Neuhaus commented that this is ore to Benedict’s and Card. Egan’s liking.  I don’t think that is the point, really, though it is undoubtedly true!

2:43
His Holiness, now incensing the altar, seems seriously upbeat.

2:55
Card. Egan gave a greeting which also summarized many points of His Holiness’s visit. 

2:57

The people seemed to handle the Kyrie very well!

2:58
Ah… what a Gloria!  And people participate by listening with interiorly active receptivity!  Wonderful.  Like a cool drink of water in a desert.

3:01
It would be nice he sang the Collect after that nice Gloria!

3:05
The responsorial psalm seems often, musically, to be the weakest moment in the Novus Ordo, I think.

3:08
The English feed of Vatican Radio has cut in with EWTN, and Charles Collins is reading the English for the Spanish of the second reading.

3:12
The Gospel is sung in an adapted Roman tone.  Very nice!  I wish we had a better translation, but this is very good!  The deacon did a good job, and with confidence in a very intimidating situation!

Il Papa parla!

The stadium is so quiet as he speaks.  People are listening! This is what I hoped for.

3:37
Spanish

Now that he is finished with his sermon, I have posted his text, with some preliminary commentary, here.

Long applause!

3:43
The Holy Father intones Credo III and everyone seems to know what to do.  They don’t have to divide it up in that odd, us against them  fashion.  Excellent!

Also, during the Creed there was a good view of the Holy Father bowed at the Et incarnatus.  How I wish we would all kneel everytime the Creed was recited or sung in the Novus Ordo!  This could be a good thing to reintroduce.

3:55
Offertory.  The lines and lines of priests are going to their places.  I had a fleeting image…. well…. more about that later.

3:38
Incense.  Nice thurible.  It doesn’t look like a glob, or early Russian satellite.

4:02
A momentary stumble in singing the dialogue of the Preface.  However, I so prefer the sung intonation, I can handle even drifting from the pitch a bit.  Singing is truly important in the liturgy!  It doesn’t always have to be perfect, even in such a moment. Singing adds something that mere recitation cannot approach.

4:03
I am fine with this Sanctus in this setting today. 

Again.. The Roman Canon!

BELLS for the consecration!  Class!

"For ever und ever"!   I love this guy!

He must be so tired.  And one tends to lose energy faster the closer you get to the end.

4:17
Ego sum!  In Gregorian setting!  Very fine.

During Communion I saw I priests I met in Kansas City.

Sicut cervus by Palestrina.  Folks, if you have a choir that can do this piece, and you have me come for Mass, please do it.  This is one of my great favorites and for many reasons.  It always has a powerful effect on me.

On ETWN Raymond and Fr. Neuhaus are The Bickersons.  o{]:¬)

4:25
Papa look tired now.

Raymond and Father should NOT talk during Panis angelicus.

Was our tenor fighting with the score a little?

Break Bread Together On Our Knees… hmmm.   I think the setting is a little gushy… perhaps a little too show tune.  Was that some Latin at the end?  Laudamus Patrem?

Benediction….. very good.

4:45
And into the dug out he goes!

This gets high marks.  

Well done New York, from beginning to end.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
99 Comments

Msgr. Richard J. Schuler: +20 April 2007 – RIP

One year ago, a pivotal figure for liturgy and sacred music in the American, indeed international Church died.  Msgr. Richard J. Schuler’s first anniversay is today.

I humbly ask that you say a prayer today for the respose of his soul.

Papa Ratzinger knew Msgr. Schuler well, and Schuler was a friend of the Holy Father’s brother Msgr. Georg Ratzinger, who himself was a great Church musician in his day.  Card. Ratzinger would often express interest to me when I would run into him at the Palazzo Sant’Uffizio, where I worked for some years, about the music program at St. Agnes and ask about Msgr. Schuler.

When Msgr. Schuler died, I got a note to Msgr. Ganswein, the personal secretary to His Holiness, to inform the Pope.  I requested a telegram, if deemed opportune.  His Holiness was so kind and sent a telegram to St. Agnes parish in St. Paul in time for Monsignor’s funeral.  How many parish priests get for their funerals telegrams from the Pope?

Here are some links to entries from this blog about Msgr. Schuler:

 

Here is PODCAzT 21, from 22 April 2007:

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Sen. Boxer (D-CA) tried to block resolution to welcome Benedict XVI

From and California Catholic Daily and Sancte Pater where WDTPRS’s photoshopper Vincenzo holds forth, we have news of this stunningly dopey move on the part of a member of the US Senate.

Sen. Barbara Boxer holds up resolution welcoming Benedict XVI because of objections to pro-life content

California Catholic Daily – U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-California, temporarily blocked approval of a resolution welcoming Pope Benedict XVI to the U.S. because she disapproved of a passage referring to the pope’s respect “for each and every human life,” the online political journal Politico reports. [Apparently the Senator from California does not respect each and every human life.]

Boxer and other Democrats objected because they saw the phrase as a reference to abortion. [And perhaps a guilty conscience?  At least I hope so.] “Three Senate Republican aides involved in the issue say that Boxer objected to the ‘life’ language, [death language is preferable, perhaps.   this is a GREAT example of what Pope Benedict spoke of yesterday to young people in NY!] which Democrats see as an implicit reference to the Catholic church’s opposition to abortion,” said Politico. “Senate Democratic leadership offices declined to comment but referred questions to Boxer’s office.”

Boxer spokeswoman Natalie Ravitz told Politico in an email message after the controversy was resolved, "We are very pleased we were able to reach an agreement with Senator Brownback to remove the political language and pass this resolution welcoming Pope Benedict."  [Look what happened! "Life" language is political language!  Superb example of Benedict’s points.]

The resolution welcoming the pope later passed the Senate on a voice vote, but only after its sponsor, Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kansas, agreed to remove any reference to "human life." Politico reported that Brownback, “a devout Catholic,” agreed to drop the language because he “did not want a high profile fight over the resolution.”  [It might have been worse to force the issue and have the resolution fail, but it is really too bad they couldn’t fight it out.]

In fact, reported Politico, the Kansas senator, while attending a papal Mass at Nationals Park, used a hand-held messaging device to communicate to his staff that it was ok to delete the language to which Boxer and other Democrats objected.

"There was some politics involved here, [D’YA THINK?!?]  and the objectionable language has been withdrawn," a senior Democratic Senate aide told Politico.

This is the language to which Boxer objected and which was later removed from the resolution at her insistence: "Pope Benedict XVI has spoken out for the weak and vulnerable, witnessing to the value of each and every human life."  [Pretty bad.  That sort of language, life language, should be kept private, right?  Can’t have that in a chamber where elected officials uphold the Constitution!]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

SSPX refuses to sign an agreement with the Holy See

Several readers yesterday sent me e-mails about something that our friends over at Rorate have finally posted on.

I hesitated to post about this today, but in retrospect, I think it oughtt o be put out there, but with my emphases and comments.

While I urge you to go over to visit Rorate, early and often, for their good work, I am just going to save time and post what they present

The Superior-General of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X (FSSPX / SSPX), Bishop Bernard Fellay, signed his latest Letter to Friends and Benefactors last Monday – and it was published in the current edition of the official newsletter of the Fraternity, DICI, made available today.  [I used that link posted by Rorate, but it took me to a blank page on DICI.  I wonder if DICI didn’t yank it, or perhaps the SSPX is trying to bury this bit of news.   This is one of the reasons why WDTPRS, one the bigger blogs these days, needs to put this out there for "your opportune knowledge".]

This is the heart of the letter:

…
The Motu Proprio which introduced a hope of change for the better at the liturgical level is not accompanied by logically co-related measures in the other areas of the life of the Church.  [We have been saying all along that the issue of the excommunications, liturgical problems, regularizing priests… these are all pretty easily solved.  The deeper issues revolve especially around matters like religious libery and some other points of ecumenism, etc.] All changes introduced at the Council and in the post-Conciliar reforms which we denounce, because the Church has already condemned them, are confirmed. [Right.  I think they must be talking about things like liturgical abuses and distortions of Council documents, etc.] With the difference that, from now on, it is said, at the same time, that the Church does not change…[sic], which means that these changes are perfectly in the line of Catholic Tradition.  [Hmmm… I wonder what the position of some of the SSPXers is on the thought of Ven. John Henry Newman concerning development of doctrine.  I honestly don’t know.  This might be an interesting point of discussion, below, if it can be civil.]

The disruption at the level of concepts joined with the reminder [I sure would like to see the French version.  This seems strange to me.] that the Church must remain faithful to her Tradition may trouble some. Since the facts do not corroborate the new affirmation, it is necessary to conclude that nothing [sic] has changed in the will of Rome to follow the Conciliar orientations, [The SSPX wants, it seems, a total repudiation of the Second VAtican Council?  Partial?  D’ya think that’s going to happen?  Papa Ratzinger has written that perhaps it would have been better for some Councils in the past never to to have been held.   That, however, doesn’t mean that we repudiate them entirely.  We put them in proper perspective and then move on.   But what if your view of the Church and of doctrine doesn’t alow for "moving on" or "development".   This is why I asked that question, above.] despite forty years of crisis, despite the deserted convents, the abandoned rectories, the empty churches. [I agree warmly with this.  Something is dreadfully wrong.  Pope Benedict spoke yesterday of "disappointment" in the wake of Vatican II, did he not?!  I think we must all wake up and smell the incense about this.  However, how we choose to act in light of these hard facts…. well… that is where we begin to distinguish ourselves as Catholics in the modern world.] The Catholic universities persist in their ramblings, the teaching of the Catechism remains unknown at the same time that the Catholic school does not exist anymore as particularly Catholic: it has become an extinct species… [sic]  [I think this is problematic.  The Church and our education institution are not Jurassic Park either.]

[Pay attention to what follows….]

This is why the Fraternity of Saint Pius X cannot "sign an agreement" [ne peut pas "signer d’accord"].  [Read: Non serviamus.  They are determined to resist submitting to Peter, which is a sine qua non for authentic Catholicism.]  It openly rejoices on the papal desire to reintroduce the ancient and venerable rite of the Holy Mass, but it also discovers the resistance, at times brutal, of whole episcopates. [They are probably speaking mostly about the French bishops, but we have seen signs of distain and resistence elsewhere too.]  Without despairing, without impatience, we observe that the time for an agreement has not yet come.  [Because they have not yet gotten their way?] This does not prevent us from continuing to wait, from continuing on the path defined in the year 2000. [This point deserves more attention, if it can be civil.] We continue to ask the Holy Father for the repeal of the decree of excommunication of 1988, because we are persuaded that that would do much good to the Church and we encourage you to pray that it may take place.  [The only problem is that they refuse to offer any sign of submission to his authority!  Isn’t that a real problem?]

But it would be very imprudent and hasty to thrust ourselves unwisely in pursuit of a practical agreement which would not be founded upon the fundamental principles of the Church, particularly on the faith.  [Isn’t it unwise to put your hand in Peter’s face? ]
…

+ Bernard Fellay
Menzingen, April 14, 2008

 

I hold in high regard many of the aspirations of some members of the SSPX whom I have met in years past.  I have know a few very fine priests.

At the same time, I hurt deeply at the thought that these men are not within a truly manifest unity with Rome.  I believe many of them would really like to be, were it not for the serious pratical difficulties I have seen some of them experience when leaving the SSPX in favor of unity with Rome.

This letter raises a lot of good question, worthy of discussion.

The real problem is, of course, they think they can force Peter, the Vicar of Christ, to their will.

I recognize the problems that have been caused by many who work in the Roman Curia and in conferences of bishops.  There is a weird hostility that goes beyond the bonds of reason and charity.  I can see why many in the SSPX would mistrust them. 

I also consider unrealistic what some in the Curia propose, that is, let’s get together right away and hammer out the theological problems later.  No.  The deeper problems have to be seriously addressed and discussed.  That open discussion must begin, in my opinion, yesterday if not sooner. 

What I question at this point is if anyone – also in the SSPX – is really interested in such a discussion.  Are they simply getting to used to being their own Church according to their own lights and without manifest union with the Roman Pontiff?

I hope there can be some good discussion on some of these questions.

However, this time I think I will take a somewhat more draconian approach than usual to the combox.  I would like to leave it open for good and civil discussion.  But if some people dash in and

1) try to dominate the combox
2) ignore the comments of others
3) get nasty (and I am the judge of that)
4) show disrespect to the Roman Pontiff
5) say stupid things about the Council
6) say stupid or hateful things about anyone
7) simply annoy me (and that just might depend on my mood)

I will not only delete comments, I will probably ban the person even from reading the blog by blocking his IP address(es).

I would hope some discussion can drill into these hard questions, but I don’t want this to get out of hand.

Please, people, for the love of Christ and neighbor, be reasonable if you are going to post.

Finally… no "Anonymous" comments please.  Come up with a clever and engaging pseudonym. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
149 Comments

Photos from Card. Castrillion’s Pontifical TLM in Rome

Check out Orbis Catholicus for photos of H.E. Card. Castrillon Hoyos Pontifical TLM in Rome.

A sample or two.

Photos from Card. Castrillion's Pontifical TLM in Rome

Photos from Card. Castrillion's Pontifical TLM in Rome

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments