More work on an airplane. Reading about the battle of the “ressourcement” theologians with “neo-Thomists”.
I find Chinese music goes well with this sort of thing, don’t you?
Fr. Z’s Podcasts RSS Feed
About this blog…
“This blog is like a fusion of the Baroque ‘salon’ with its well-tuned harpsichord around which polite society gathered for entertainment and edification and, on the other hand, a Wild West “saloon” with its out-of-tune piano and swinging doors, where everyone has a gun and something to say. Nevertheless, we try to point our discussions back to what it is to be Catholic in this increasingly difficult age, to love God, and how to get to heaven.” – Fr. Z
Coat of Arms by D Burkart
YOUR RECENT COMMENTS
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “Sorry; my first paragraph was a quote (of our Reverend host) and should have been in italics.”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “I’ve always been puzzled that in the Vetus Ordo the Nativity of Mary is a feast of lesser weight (2nd…”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “For Eastern Catholics ( Orthodox in communion with Rome), the birthday of Mary. The Theotokos, is the Sunday Divine Liturgy.”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “As I said above…the faithful know it’s Our Lady’s birthday. Regardless of the rubrics, they are aware. They will find…”
- on Consubstantial with His Father. Consubstantial with His Mother.: “I find A Old Historian’s comment extremely moving. I wish Vatican insiders and clergy who are more interested in their…”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “The amount of evidence piling up gives weight to the prescience of the Ottaviani intervention. “… the Novus Ordo represents,…”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “Only in the “Bugnini” Vetus Ordo! before that it was a Double with simple Octave. So trumped the Sunday. It…”
- on Daily Rome Shot 1115: “jaykay: Good eye! Regarding the very place where Julius Caesar was killed we have to move over from the V.…”
- on 8 September – Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary – “The dawn foretelling the day”: “Today’s feast is also, strangely, of lower rank in the Novus Ordo as well. The nativity of John the Baptist…”
- on Daily Rome Shot 1115: “The inscription on the building draws one’s interest. The wonders of the web revealed that it’s at 19-23 Via Monte…”
- on Daily Rome Shot 1115: “Ah, took me a couple minutes. 1. Qf3 threatens the rook on a8, whose only safe square is b8. Moving…”
- on Consubstantial with His Father. Consubstantial with His Mother.: “So I take it this means consubstantial with the Father in his divine nature and with Mary, his mother, in…”
- on Consubstantial with His Father. Consubstantial with His Mother.: ““IT IS ALL IN THERE.” As an altar boy in the mid-1950s, the last reading at mass, the “prologue” of…”
- on YOUR URGENT PRAYER REQUESTS: “Praying that my husband remains free of cancer, and for healing of body and soul for all the family. God…”
ABORTION PILL RESCUE NETWORK
Everyone, work to get this into your parish bulletins and diocesan papers.
Federated Computer… your safe and private alternative to big biz corporations that hate us while taking our money and mining our data. Have an online presence large or small? Catholic DIOCESE? Cottage industry? See what Federated has to offer. Save money and gain peace of mind.
Polls
Loading ...Use FATHERZ10 at checkout for 10% off
Donate using VENMO
GREAT BEER from Traditional Benedictine Monks in Italy
CLICK and say your daily offerings!
A Daily Prayer for Priests
NEW OPPORTUNITY – 10% off with code: FATHERZ10
Fr. Z’s VOICEMAIL
Nota bene: I do not answer these numbers or this Skype address. You won't get me "live". I check for messages regularly.
WDTPRS
020 8133 4535
651-447-6265
This REALLY helps! And it’s great coffee (and tea)
I use this when I travel both in these USA and abroad. Very useful. Fast enough for Zoom. I connect my DMR (ham radio) through it. If you use my link, they give me more data. A GREAT back up.
This blog has to earn its keep!
PLEASE subscribe via PayPal if it is useful. Zelle and Wise are better, but PayPal is convenient.
A monthly subscription donation means I have steady income I can plan on. I put you my list of benefactors for whom I pray and for whom I often say Holy Mass.
In view of the rapidly changing challenges I now face, I would like to add more $10/month subscribers. Will you please help?
For a one time donation...
To donate monthly I prefer Zelle because it doesn't extract fees. Use
frz AT wdtprs DOT comBe a “Zed-Head”!
PLEASE RESPOND. Pretty pleeeease?
Loading ...This is really useful when travelling… and also when you aren’t and you need backup internet NOW! I use this for my DMR “Zednet” hotspot when I’m mobile. It’s a ham radio thing.
If you travel internationally, this is a super useful gizmo for your mobile internet data. I use one. If you get one through my link, I get data rewards.
WDTPRS POLL
Loading ...Fr. Z’s stuff is everywhere
Help support Fr. Z’s Gospel of Life work at no cost to you. Do you need a Real Estate Agent? Calling these people is the FIRST thing you should do!
They find you a pro-life agent in your area who commits to giving a portion of the fee to a pro-life group!
GREAT causes to support
Help Monks in Wyoming (coffee – UPDATED LINK) and Norcia (beer) and the wonderful "Soap Sisters" of Summit, NJ!
Please follow me on Twitter!
Loading ...
You are too much, Fr. Z.! I don’t know what any of that means, but, I have prayed for you & your fellow travelers safe flight.
Irony of the day: St. Thomas himself was a “ressourcement” theologian.
Is this the same Chinese music we hear on some z-chat sessions?
What was the name of the article/book?
Irony of the day: St. Thomas himself was a “ressourcement” theologian.
Comment by arotron theou
Every Thomist has to be ressourcement theologian.
Of course, as JRatzinger pointed out, the problem with the ressourcement theologians is that they conveniently forgot to consider the theology of the Middle Ages.
jbalza007: Not quite the same. This stuff was a little more … challenging.
should read: some of them conveniently forgot to consider the theology of the Middle Ages.
Looks like you’re reading Tracey Rowland’s “Ratzinger’s Faith.”
Sounds like it calls for the soundtrack from a good kung-fu movie!
Father, when will you be doing that long awaited (at least by me and you) only Chinese Opera Z-Chat? I am looking forward to something like that!
A good Thomist will discriminate between what is good and what is not so good in any source of any age for the service of the unchanging yet inexhaustible Truth.
That said, the only good thing about some texts is the very fine printsetting.
Fr. I certainly hope you’re using earphones. I’d hate to hear that they threw you out of the exit doors over what we all know is your “wonderful, ahem” chinese music.
Fr Z, I am starting my dissertation on this topic. Can you tell us what you are reading?
Fr Smith
I would love to know what book you are reading. I am very interested in this topic.
robtbrown and RandomFriar, I agree with you both. The best theologians, regardless of camp or training, love the Truth, always and everywhere. Good Thomists and solid Patristic thinkers both reach the same conclusions about dogmata. Just as neo-Thomism errs if it neglects the Fathers, so Patristic ressourcement fails if it neglects Scholasticism.
In other words, we all need to be good Boethians…
I do think St Thomas is a genius, as regards the Chinese music I may have to listen to some as I may be teaching in a Catholic school in Hong Kong next accademic year.
Fr.
Did you every study Chinese at the U of M? That was where I got my degree in the same lo many years ago.
Two points about St Thomas:
1. What distinguishes the theology of St Thomas, making it unique, is that theology is always primarily speculative, that it is always done primarily to know Truth, not as a plan of action. All theology, even moral theology, is primarily about God (theocentric).
On the other hand, it is never purely speculative–it always has a practical aspect. hat is why implicit in St Thomas’ method is human experience. In fact, a common complaint against the pre Vat II neo-Scholastic theology is that it .
Acc to St Thomas, theology is not primarily about salvation, either of the individual or the community. And so the concepts of dogmatic theology (what someone must believe) and moral theology (what someone must do and avoid) are not adequate as a foundation for theology. Further, Counter Reformation Theology, Liberation Theology, Ecumenical Theology, etc., can never be adequate expressions of theology, only of some aspect of it.
2. In so far as it deals with Relevation, theology must always be grounded in Christ (Christocentric) not on the Church (Ecclesiocentric). I have mentioned before that St Thomas’ Sacramental Theology is a division of his Christology. The Sacraments flow directly from Christ, not from some legislative authority that Christ gave to the Church.
The efforts to reestablish the notion of the Church as Mystical Body began before Vat II (cf Pius XII) and extended into the Council. Unfortunately, certain theologians simply went from a legalistic Ecclesiocentric theology to a sociological one, e.g., the Schillebeeckx disconnection of the priesthood from Apostolic succession.
To paraphrase Forrest Gump, that’s all I’ll say about that.
Contra Forrest, let me add that St Thomas’ concept of theology as primarily speculative, but never purely so means that his method is going to both ascend from the particulars of human experience and descend from universal principles.
For those interested, I highly recommend Garrigou LaGrange’s The One God, especially the introduction where he explains St Thomas’ method and the commentary on Question I of the Summa.
D’oh — when I viewed the display on your iPhone/pod/pad, I thought I saw “Wang Chung.” Now [i]that’s[/i] ressourcement!
… and so much for the BBcode …
Regarding Ressourcement Theology and Thomism, I read Ressourcement Theology, Aggiornamento,and the Hermeneutics of Tradition by Dr. D’Ambrosio at http://www.crossroadsinitiative.com and while this was my first foray into the realm of “Ressourcement Theology” I found it, on it’s face at least, to be a reasonable concept, if not abused. In the article, it is explained that some of the Jesuit theologians from Fourvière were in fact themselves Thomists. What they found, according to the article, is that Aquinas is really more traditional in the mold of the Early Fathers than is neo-Thomism/neo-Scholasticism, once you dig into his writings first-hand. That was just what I gathered from a reading of the article.
I do not agree that there were Thomists in La Fourvière. De Lubac opposed certain Counter Reformation tendencies, but from what I have read, he seems more like a neo-Augustinian than a Thomist.
Father Z is reading Tracey Rowland’s, Ratzinger’s Faith: The Theology of Pope Benedict XVI. He has shown us a glimpse of page 21.
Robtbrown, aside from method, in what do you see the differences between St. Thomas and St. Augustine? Or am I reading too much into your comment about De Lubac, in which I seem (perhaps quite wrongly) to see a disparagement of “neo-Augustinian” ressourcement?
Some of you might also be interested in the Fergus Kerr book called “Twentieth-Century Catholic Theologians,” which does a good job explaining the transition we have seen from Neo-Thomism to Ressourcement theology. I personally think the Church should enthusiastically embrace both Neo-Thomism AND Ressourcement theology. In the end, how can any one theology whether it be Neo-Thomism or Ressourcement theology explain the full Mysteries of God and His relationship with us? Being able to understand the metaphysical proofs for God’s existence (Neo-Thomism) and returing to the study of Scriptures and realizing that God calls us to deep personal communion with Him and all other people (Ressourcement theology) are both equally important and valid approaches to theology.
The SSPX crowd will sometimes say that Neo-Thomism is the only good theology and that new theology is all modernist rubbish. Baloney! On the other hand, the New Theologians will sometimes say that Neo-Thomism is dry and irrelevant. Baloney! The Church needs both Neo-Thomism AND Ressourcement theology. Just as there is legitimate diversity between the expressions of worship in the Western and Eastern Catholic autonomous ritual Churches, so should there also be a healthy legitimate diversity of theologies in the Catholic Church, with each theology helping us to understand better some aspect of the Mysteries of God that another theology might not shed as much light upon.