SSPX Bp. Fellay criticizes Benedict XVI about Assisi meeting

From The Catholic Herald (which has a huge discount right now annual subscriptions to the full digital version):

SSPX leader criticises Pope’s plan to hold inter-religious meeting
By Anna Arco
Vote for Fr. Z!
The leader of the Society of St Pius X has expressed anger at Pope Benedict’s decision to hold another inter-religious meeting at Assisi.

Weeks after Bishop Bernard Fellay said he was feeling optimistic about union with Rome this year, the Superior General of the SSPX?said he was deeply indignant about the Pope’s invitation to religious leaders around the world to join him in Assisi.

Preaching on the Epiphany, Bishop Fellay said: “Yes, we are deeply indignant, we vehemently protest against this repetition of the days at Assisi. [Here’s the thing.  The meeting is quite a way off yet, and he knows that it is going to be a “repetition”?  I, too, am not enthusiastic about this idea, but I am sure that this won’t be a “repetition” of what happened at that first, unfortunate confab.] Everything that we have said, everything that Archbishop Lefebvre had said at the time of the World Day of Prayer for Peace in Assisi in 1986, we repeat in our own name. It is evident, my dear brothers, that such a thing demands reparation. What a mystery![Indeed… it is.  And so, perhaps such a strong condemnation is not entirely fair.]

Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, the founder of the SSPX, complained about the first World Day of Prayer for Peace. He said the Church had never before been “humiliated to such an extent in the course of her history”. He told John Paul II that “the scandal given to Catholic souls cannot be measured. The Church is shaken to its very foundations”.

Pope Benedict told pilgrims at the first Angelus of the year that he would travel to Assisi in October to mark the 25th anniversary of the day.

He said: “I will make a pilgrimage to the town of St Francis, inviting my Christian brethren of different confessions, leaders of the world’s religious traditions and, in their hearts, all men and women of good will, to join me on this journey in order to commemorate that important historical gesture of my predecessor, and solemnly to renew the commitment of believers of all religions to live their religious faith as a service to the cause of peace.[A good motive, and hard to criticize justly.  What remains to be seen is how.]

Benedict XVI is the Pope of Christian Unity.

Bp. Fellay said in his sermon, via our friends at Rorate:

And here modern thinking makes truly bizarre sorts of projections: it pretends that all religions, ultimately, adore one and the same true God. That is absolutely false; it is even in Revelation; we find it already in the psalms, in Psalm 96:5, “All the gods of the Gentiles are devils!” They are devils. And Assisi will be full of devils! This is Revelation, this is the Faith of the Church; this is the teaching of the Church!

Meanwhile, ….

[CUE MUSIC]

When you’ve had a hard day fretting over the upcoming meeting in Assisi, and fuming over the last meeting, when you’ve gotten all worked up and just can’t contain it anymore, why not have a nice hot WDTPRS mug filled with Mystic Monk Coffee?

You know… it is surely Eve’s fault that we run out of patience over most things… but it is our fault if we run out of coffee!

Face it, when it comes to our coffee supply, and the defense of our Faith, don’t be caught short.

Maybe try the Dark Sumatran this time.

Mystic Monk Coffee!

It’s swell!

Posted in Pope of Christian Unity | Tagged , ,
117 Comments

QUAERITUR: Mass “in honor” of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

I have received a few emails asking me (again, this year) if it is appropriate to celebrate Mass (again, this year) in honor of the late Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

I look forward to the day that Masses are arranged by the same people for the intention of the late President Ronald Regan.  how about Susan B. Anthony?

Of course that isn’t going to happen, is it.

Holy Church does not permit Masses in honor of a dead person who isn’t a saint or blessed with an cult approved by Holy Catholic Church. It is not permitted to celebrate Mass on honor of a person who has no official cult.  As a matter of fact most blesseds can’t even be honored at the altar unless there is permission given for that locale or institute.

On the other hand, I think it is entirely appropriate to celebrate Mass to pray for the repose of the soul of someone who is dead.  Surely Dr. King was a sinner, just as well are all sinners.  Prayer for the dead is a work of mercy.  We should pray relentlessly for the dead.

I suppose the Mass formulary they choose for such an occasion could reflect something of important social interests, such as the defense of human life. The late Dr. King would have appreciated that, I believe, given the fact that Planned Parenthood aimed at abortion of as many black children as possible.

Masses for a dead person mustn’t be reduced to a “celebration of someone’s life”.  That is not what Catholics do.  During Mass we pray that God will be merciful to them.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged
25 Comments

Michael Voris about tabernacles and, gasp, liberals!

Michael Voris has another indirect, deeply nuanced reflection, this time touching on issues such as the placement of the tabernacle in churches.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
70 Comments

Miracle attributed to Ven. John Paul II

Andrea Tornielli reports that yesterday the cardinal and bishop members of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints voted to accept a miracle attributed to the intercession of Ven. John Paul II.  This miracle was the healing of a French woman religious of Parkinson’s Disease.

The Congregation will have to present its decree to His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI who will promulgate it, or not, according to whatever schedule he determines is opportune.

Once the decree of the miracle is promulgated it would remain to fix the date of a possible beatification.

Posted in Saints: Stories & Symbols | Tagged , ,
35 Comments

A note about The Tablet

My friend Fr. Ray Blake, the p.p. of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton, posted this about The Tablet (aka The Bitter Pill).

Keep in mind this may be hard to substantiate.

Shops seem to be closing all over Brighton, more of my people are unemployed but there is one good thing about the recession, maybe just one. The Tablet is hemorrhaging money, according to Ttony – thousands of pounds each week according to the latest accounts it has eventually posted. Admittedly the accounts are pre-recession.

It claims it has a circulation of more than 22,000 copies each week, though in common with other British Catholic papers that probably means that is how many are printed whilst in fact only a small proportion are sold or read. Ttony repeats the claim that the Tablet makes that each copy is read by three people, I have never seen how that can be substantiated, it appeals to diminishing niche market.

Unfortunately it has vast resources laid down from when it was a bastion of mainstream Catholicism.

Posted in The Drill | Tagged
11 Comments

What’s in a name? A lot, as it turns out.

Once upon a time a couple liberals got really mad at me when I suggested that a Christian saint’s name might be a good thing for their little stupor mundi, rather than the trendy abstraction with an incomprehensible spelling.

My advice to parents has always been pick a saints name and spell it normally.

This is from The Telegraph:

Pope rails against rise of un-Christian names [Not so sure about that… but read on.]

The Pope has warned parents against giving children celebrity-inspired names and urged them to turn to the Bible for inspiration instead.

While names such as Sienna and Scarlett have become fashionable in recent years, Pope Benedict XVI called for a return to tradition.

During Mass at the Sistine Chapel, he said: “Every baptised child acquires the character of the son of God, beginning with their Christian name, an unmistakable sign that the Holy Spirit causes man to be born anew in the womb of the Church.” He added that a name was an “indelible seal” that set children off on a lifelong “journey of religious faith”. [I didn’t see that quote in the text of the sermon.  And the text of his Angelus address afterward didn’t say that either…  but… that doesn’t change the point: give kids real, Christian names.]

According to the Office for National Statistics, celebrity names such as Ashton – after the actor Ashton Kutcher – and Lily – after the singer Lily Allen – are among the most popular in England and Wales. The names celebrities give their own children can be even more exotic.

Sir Bob Geldof has daughters named Pixie and Peaches, while Victoria and David Beckham called their first son Brooklyn, after the district of New York. Katie Price, the glamour model, named her daughter Princess Tiaamii.

In Italy, the name of a child has particular significance. Children are often named after saints, who are considered a guiding force in their life.

The tradition, however, is increasingly under threat. Francesco Totti, the footballer, recently decided to call his daughter Chanel, while Flavio Briatore, the Formula One boss, named his newborn son Falso Nathan.

Cristina Odone, a former editor of The Catholic Herald who grew up in Italy, said: “There are so many of the church’s traditions which we have come to ignore and which are actually meaningful and have a big spiritual significance. To deprive our children of that sense of having a protecting saint is to rob them of something very significant. Many of today’s names are not just un-Christian but they are also crass and consumerist.” [Parents who do this are selfish.]

According to official statistics, the most popular name for newborns in Britain is Mohammed, after the Islamic prophet. A total of 7,549 newborns were given variations of the name last year. It overtook Jack, which topped the list for 14 years.

Monsignor Andrew Faley, the assistant general secretary to the Catholic Bishops’ Conference, said: “The name is not just a label but it moves us into a deeper significance of what it means to be human as revealed in the person of Jesus Christ.

“Naming children after perfumes, bicycles and countries is putting a limit on their potential. They are not merchandise or commodities.

“When I was a parish priest, if I didn’t agree with the name I’d suggest they should give the second name of a saint.”  [Yah… I’ve done that too.  It doesn’t always go very well.]

In 2008, Italy’s highest court banned a couple from naming their son Venerdi – Friday – saying it was “ridiculous” and would expose him to mockery from his classmates.

Judges from the Cassation Court in Rome ordered that the boy instead be christened Gregorio, after the saint’s day on which he was born. [And another thing!  When the calendar was changed around after the Second Vatican Council, people’s name days were changed!] The parents, from Genoa, had drawn inspiration from Robinson Crusoe’s manservant.

I don’t think the Pope said what is claimed in this article.   That doesn’t make a difference to the point of this, however.

That said, I looked in the Italian text of the sermon.  I didn’t find what the article said the Pope said.  In the English translation you read:

“It is not by chance, in fact, that every baptized person acquires the
character of son from the name Christian, indisputable sign that the
Holy Spirit brings man to be born “again” from the womb of the
Church.”

This is about being called a by the name “Christian” rather than being named with a Christian name.

MY point, however, is still that parents should give saints’ names to their children and, for the love of God, spell them normally.

UPDATE 12 Jan 1428GMT:

Does the Church’s canon law have anything to contribute?

The esteemed canonist Ed Peters has a note about names.  Check it out!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, The Drill, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged ,
126 Comments

Some details of the Anglican Ordinariate revealed

The Catholic Herald, the UK’s best Catholic weekly, has this about the structure of the Ordinariate for Anglicans coming into communion with the Roman Catholic Church.

My emphases and comments.

Church reveals fine details of ordinariate
By Anna Arco

Personal ordinariates for groups of Anglican converts around the world are likely to develop their own missal according to traditional Anglican use, an English Church official has said.

Fr Marcus Stock, the general secretary of the Bishops of England and Wales, said that while an ordinariate in Britain would be likely to follow the Roman Rite, he expected that there an Anglican use of the Roman Rite would be developed.

Fr Stock said: “When we are talking about the ordinariate we’re not just talking about England and Wales but for across the world and I’d be surprised if something isn’t developed for use for all the ordinariates. I don’t think they’ll develop particular ones.

“There will be an Anglican Traditional Use, such as there is in the United States who use the book of divine worship, which again they might simply adapt that for use in ordinariates around the world.”

He said that Anglican patrimony and tradition did not only refer to the missal used in Mass, but also to things like Evensong and Morning Prayer “and a slightly different form of the Breviary than the Roman rite would use and additional funeral rites and marriage rites which might reflect a particular tradition in the Anglican communion”. [Could Latin Rite priests use it?  I wonder.]

“So it will probably be more of a sacramentary than a missal, which will have different rites,” Fr Stock said. “That’s a long-term project.”

The ordinariate in England and Wales, which is due to be established by a decree from the Congregation of the Doctrine of Faith, will have a principal church which is to serve a similar function to a diocesan cathedral.

Fr Stock said: “They will need a place to meet, to have meetings and gather as a group. Not a cathedral as such, but a principal church, it’s called in the constitution, where the members of the ordinariate can gather for the celebration of liturgies and where the ordinary will be based.”

The bishops have been on the look out for a church of sufficient size, capacity and centrality to serve as the principal church for the ordinariate[What is the name of the seminary with the beautiful chapel that is due to close?]

Fr Stock said: “Like any diocesan centre, you want somewhere where people can get to easily, so that’s all being looked into at the moment. And that will hopefully not just have the church, but also accommodation for the ordinary and a bit of luck some additional facilities for social meeting and some offices for the ordinariate.”

While the bishops’ conference has pledged £250,000, which is in a restricted fund of the Catholic Trust for England and Wales at the moment until the ordinariate is actually established, Fr Stock said that funding for the ordinariate has also been coming in from other sources. He cited charities, individuals and communities which have pledged “not insubstantial amounts” to assist the establishment of an ordinariate.

He said that financing the ordinariate would clearly be “a major strategic concern for the ordinary when he is appointed and his council when that is constituted”.

Fr Stock said the rapid ordination of the three former Anglican bishops who were received into the Church on the first of January and will be ordained priests on January 15, was a unique situation.

He said “The pastoral arrangements that have been put at the inception of the ordinariate are to recognise the fact that there is a pastoral need for those men who have been ministering to the congregations hitherto need to be making their journey into the Catholic Church and that’s why these provisions have been put into place. Of course those men who are going to have to be prepared for the Catholic priesthood—things to do with canon law and pastoral practice that they need to get used to and need to learn those things. But it is a recognition that fundamentally we need to keep these groups together to meet their spiritual needs.”

When he was asked whether it was a step forward from the pastoral provision which was granted to former Anglican clergymen in the 1990s thanks to the efforts of Cardinal Basil Hume, Fr Stock said: “I think it’s recognised that that may have been a weakness at the time, that there wasn’t a recognition of the need for their pastors to accompany the people, but any priest who has been parish priest will tell you that after a bit time the priest and people get very close. It’s important sometimes for priests to accompany their people.”

The ordinariate represents a completely new canonical structure which is similar to a military diocese, but allows groups of Anglicans who wish to keep their patrimony to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church.

Members of the ordinariate will be fully-fledged Catholics of the Roman Rite – this means they are not like the Eastern ritual churches which are in communion with Rome. Ordinariate priests will be able celebrate Mass normally in Catholic churches and Catholics attending ordinariate Masses will be able to receive Communion there.

Fr Stock today issued an extensive guide to the ordinariate on behalf of the Bishops of England and Wales.

Benedict XVI is the Pope of Christian Unity.

Posted in Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
39 Comments

Bad news for small-c catholic schools

Could this be the end of small-c catholic institutions?

I found this at The Motley Monk.

The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) told Manhattan College that they are not really a religious institution and therefore they can’t use a religious character to prevent the faculty from unionizing.

The NLRB used Manhattan College’s own literature for this decision.  Apparently, since Manhattan College says it is not trying to promote the Catholic Faith, … well… they can’t hide behind their religious identity.

Bottom line: Nominally Catholic schools which are not serious about their identity may have problems coming.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices |
24 Comments

Te Deum

A biretta tip   o{]:¬)  to Jeffrey Tucker over at The Chant Cafe.

Here is a version of the Te Deum.  It is  the Maîtrise of Notre-Dame in Paris (I have the CD).

If you have headphones on, you will want to turn the volume down.  No… really.

Otherwise, especially if you have big speakers, turn the volume up!

Posted in Just Too Cool | Tagged , , ,
22 Comments

Archbp. Nichols about the upcoming ordination of former Anglican bishops

I found this on the site of The Catholic Herald:

A Statement from Archbishop Vincent Nichols
President of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales

THE ORDINATION TO THE CATHOLIC PRIESTHOOD OF THREE FORMER ANGLICAN BISHOPS AND THE ESTABLISHMENT IN ENGLAND AND WALES OF A PERSONAL ORDINARIATE

On Saturday 15th January, it will be my privilege to ordain John Broadhurst, Andrew Burnham and Keith Newton to priesthood in the Catholic Church. This ceremony will take place in Westminster Cathedral.

On or before this date, I expect the Holy See to announce the establishment of the first Ordinariate for groups of former Anglicans and their clergy who seek full communion in the Catholic Church. The three men ordained on Saturday will be the first priests of this Ordinariate.

This is a unique moment and the Catholic community in England and Wales is privileged to be playing its part in this historic development in the life of the Universal Church.

We offer a warm welcome to these three former bishops of the Church of England. We welcome those who wish to join them in full communion with the Pope in the visible unity of the Catholic Church. We recognise the journey they are making with its painful departures and its uncertainties. We salute their depth of searching prayer and the desire which leads them to seek to live within the community of the Catholic Church under the ministry of the Bishop of Rome. This is the faith we share.

We are deeply grateful for the depth of the relationship which exists here between the Catholic Church and the Anglican Communion. This firm, positive and on-going relationship is the context for Saturday’s important initiative. We are grateful, too, for the sensitive leadership of the Archbishop of Canterbury. He graciously acknowledges the integrity of those seeking to join the Ordinariate and has assured them of his prayers. This is the noble spirit of true ecumenism between the followers of Christ.

Pope Benedict has made clear his own intentions: that the Ordinariate can serve the wider cause of visible unity between our two churches by demonstrating in practice the extent to which we have so much to give to each other in our common service of the Lord. With this in mind he describes this step as ‘a prophetic gesture.’

With great trust in the Lord, we look forward to Saturday, to the new phase of Church life it brings and we ask God’s blessing on its future development.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
7 Comments