A little humor…

From America Magazine with my emphases and comments.
I have a "modest proposal" at the end.
The piece was written by Fr. Michael G. Ryan, Rector of St. James Cathedral in Seattle, WA. Here is something about him from the site of the Cathedral:
Father Michael G. Ryan was born in Seattle … He attended the North American College in Rome, completed his graduate theological studies at the Gregorian University there and, on December 17, 1966, was ordained a priest at St. Peter’s Basilica in the Vatican. … In 1977 Archbishop Raymond G. Hunthausen appointed him as Chancellor for the Archdiocese of Seattle and Vicar General. He served in those capacities until 1988 when the same Archbishop appointed him Pastor of St. James Cathedral where he continues to serve. … Father Ryan has served on many church governing boards, including the Board of Directors of The National Catholic Reporter, …
Let’s see what he has to say.
What If We Said, ‘Wait’?
The case for a grass-roots review of the new Roman Missal
Michael G. Ryan | DECEMBER 14, 2009It is now 45 years since the Second Vatican Council promulgated the groundbreaking and liberating document on the sacred liturgy, Sacrosanctum Concilium. As an eager and enthusiastic North American College seminarian at the time, I was in St. Peter’s Square on the December day in 1963 when Pope Paul VI, with the world’s bishops, presented that great Magna Carta to the church. [So, the writer is of a certain age, and his formation was in those heady days, as it were.] The conciliar document transcended ecclesiastical politics. It was not just the pet project of a party but the overwhelming consensus of the bishops of the world. Its adoption passed overwhelmingly: 2,147 to 4.
Not in my wildest dreams would it have occurred to me then that I would live to witness what seems more and more like the systematic dismantling of the great vision of the council’s decree. But I have. We Catholics have. [I would ask Father to point out, in the Council’s documents, in Latin, what is being dismantled.]
For evidence, one need look no further than recent instructions from the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments that have raised rubricism to an art form, or the endorsement, even encouragement, of the so-called Tridentine Mass. [I don’t know what that instruction would be. Anyone? The only "Instruction" I can think of would be the 2004 Instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum which was aimed mostly at liturgical abuses. Unless one is involved in liturgical abuses, I can’t see why that Instruction would be troubling. The notion that RS promotes "rubricism" – in the sense meant by the writer – is simply risible. However, he seems truly distressed that Catholics who have more traditional liturgical sensibilities than he might actually have rights. But there it is.] It has become painfully clear that the liturgy, the prayer of the people, is being used as a tool—some would even say as a weapon—to advance specific agendas. [And liberals never used liturgy as tool for their agenda! However, consider that the way we pray has a reciprocal relationship with what we believe (lex ordandi lex credendi). The key here, it seems to me, is to determine if the writer is situated more in the hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture camp, or on the other hand in the continuity side of things. We shall see as we read on!] And now on the horizon are the new translations of the Roman Missal that will soon reach the final stages of approval by the Holy See. Before long the priests of this country will be told to take the new translations to their people by means of a carefully orchestrated education program that will attempt to put a good face on something that clearly does not deserve it. [So, that’s a "no" vote for the new translation.]
The veterans who enthusiastically devoted their best creative energies as young priests to selling the reforms of the council to parishioners back in the 1960s [Livin’ in the past, are we, Father?] will be asked to do the same with regard to the new translations. Yet we will be hard put to do so. [Poor fellows. How my heart goes out to them. Or would… if I didn’t remember immediately the things that they did to the liturgy and the Catholic people over the last 40+ years.] Some colleagues in ministry may actually relish the opportunity, but not those of us who were captivated by the great vision of Vatican II, [Please, Father, show us in the Council documents something that shows that the new translation is a violation of Council documents.] who knew firsthand the Tridentine Mass and loved it for what it was, but welcomed its passing because of what full, conscious and active participation would mean for our people. [I would like Father to tell us what he thinks "active participation" means.] We can see the present moment only as one more assault on the council and, sadly, one more blow to episcopal collegiality. [Oh brother. But note what he is doing: He is taking the line of Bp. Trautman expressed in the last plenary of the USCCB when it came to discussion of the approval of the translation of antiphons. Is the writer really a parrot of Bp. Trautman?] It was, after all, the council that gave to conferences of bishops the authority to produce their own translations (S.C., Nos. 36, 40), to be approved, it is true, by the Holy See but not, presumably, to be initiated, nitpicked and controlled by it. Further, the council also wisely made provision for times of experimentation and evaluation (S.C., No. 40)—something that has been noticeably missing in the present case. [Thanks be to God.]
This leads me to pose a question to my brother priests: What if we were to awaken to the fact that these texts are neither pastoral nor ready for our parishes? What if we just said, “Wait”? [I think what he is really saying is that he hopes for disobedience. But that is just a guess.]
Prayer and Good Sense
I know it might smack of insubordination to talk this way, but it could also be a show of loyalty and plain good sense—loyalty not to any ideological agenda but to our people, whose prayer the new translations purport to improve, and good sense to anyone who stops to think about what is at stake here. [Let’s not kid ourselves here, Father. Your opposition to the new translation is exactly "ideological". It stems from your particular understanding of the Council.]
What is at stake, it seems to me, is nothing less than the church’s credibility. [Oh, brother.] It is true that the church could gain some credibility by giving us more beautiful translations, but clumsy is not beautiful, and precious is not prayerful. ["Precious"?] During a recent dinner conversation with friends, the issue of the new translations came up. Two at the table were keenly—and quite angrily—aware of the impending changes; two were not. When the uninformed heard a few examples (“and with your spirit”; “consubstantial with the Father”; “incarnate of the Virgin Mary”; “oblation of our service”; “send down your Spirit like the dewfall”; “He took the precious chalice”; “serene and kindly countenance,” for starters), the reaction was somewhere between disbelief and indignation. [But this was your circle, right?]
One person ventured the opinion that with all that the church has on its plate today—global challenges with regard to justice, peace and the environment; nagging scandals; a severe priest shortage; the growing disenchantment of many women; seriously lagging church attendance—it seems almost ludicrous to push ahead with an agenda that will seem at best trivial and at worst hopelessly out-of-touch. [And that would be a pretty stupid argument, wouldn’t it. That would be the argument of someone who doesn’t see how liturgical worship is at the heart of who we are as Catholics and therefore has ramifications for every other aspect of our Catholic lives. That would be the argument of someone who doesn’t think we can walk and chew gum at the same time.]
The reaction of my friends should surprise no one who has had a chance to review the new translations. Some of them have merit, but far too many do not. Recently the Archdiocese of Seattle sponsored a seminar on the new translations for lay leaders and clergy. Both the priest who led the seminar (an accomplished liturgical theologian) and the participants gathered there in good faith. [It would be interesting to know who that is.] When passages from the proposed new translation were soberly read aloud by the presenter (I remember especially the phrase from the first eucharistic prayer that currently reads “Joseph, her husband,” but which in the new translation becomes “Joseph, spouse of the same virgin”), there was audible laughter in the room. I found myself thinking that the idea of this happening during the sacred liturgy is no laughing matter but something that should make us all tremble. [Then use Latin.]
There’s more: the chilling reception the people of the dioceses of South Africa have given the new translations. In a rare oversight, the bishops of that country misread the instructions [uh huh] from Rome and, after a careful program of catechesis in the parishes, introduced the new translations to their people some months ago. The translations were met almost uniformly with opposition bordering on outrage. [And? I seem to recall that many people who felt outrage at the changes the writer applauds were pretty much ignored. They were just expected to shut up and conform.]
It is not my purpose here to discuss in detail the flawed principles of translation [The writer wants you to accept the premise that the principles of translation are flawed.] behind this effort or the weak, inconsistent translations that have resulted. Others have already ably done that. Nor do I want to belabor the fact that those who prepared the translations seem to be far better versed in Latin than in English. [So, an ad hominem attack too.] No, my concern is for the step we now face: the prospect of implementing the new translations. This brings me back to my question: What if we just said, “Wait”? [Do you get the feeling that he is advocating disobedience? This is the rector of a Cathedral church. Do his views echo those of his local bishop? This man is in charge of the liturgy for the bishop in the bishop’s own church.]
What if we, the parish priests of this country who will be charged with the implementation, were to find our voice and tell our bishops that we want to help them avert an almost certain fiasco? What if we told them that we think it unwise to implement these changes until our people have been consulted in an adult manner that truly honors their intelligence and their baptismal birthright? [What would that entail, this "consulting our people"? Would that mean, what… having our people do the translation? Would it involve, what… voting?] What if we just said, “Wait, not until our people are ready for the new translations, but until the translations are ready for our people”? [How would that work, exactly?]
Heeding Our Pastoral Instincts [Two really precise terms there!]
The bishops have done their best, [But apparently, they did a pretty bad job of it, according to the writer. Maybe "our people" can do a better job of making these decisions. Right! The bishops shouldn’t decide! "Our people" should decide! Down with the bishops! Up with "our people"! UNITE! Crush the IMPERIALIST…. er um… okay… sorry…. I digress….] but up to now they have not succeeded. Some of them, led by the courageous and outspoken former chairman of the Bishops’ Committee on the Liturgy, Bishop Donald Trautman of Erie, Pa., [ROFL! You knew his name would pop up, right!] tried mightily [What a Hercules, he! What a David! What a … er… um…. sorry….] to stop the new translation train but to no avail. The bishops’ conference, marginalized and battle-weary, allowed itself slowly but steadily to be worn down. [By those wicked new translation loving types! DOWN WITH THEM!] After awhile the will to fight was simply not there. Acquiescence took over to the point that tiny gains (a word here, a comma there) were regarded as major victories. Without ever wanting to, the bishops abandoned their best pastoral instincts and in so doing gave up on the best interests of their people. [The writer is pretty worked up.]
So the question arises: Are we priests going to give up, too? Are we, too, going to acquiesce? [HELL NO! WE WON’T GO! … HELL NO! WE WON’T GO!…] We do, of course, owe our bishops the obedience and respect that we pledged to them on the day of our ordination, but does obedience mean complicity with something we perceive to be wrong—or, at best, wrongheaded? Does obedience mean going against our best pastoral instincts [But… you are asking the bishops who approved the translations to go against their best pastoral instincts (whatever that means). Am I wrong? Or do men who become bishops no longer have "best pastoral instincts"?]in order to promote something that we believe will, in the end, actually bring discredit to the church and further disillusionment to the people? I do not think so. And does respect involve paying lip service to something to which our more instinctive reaction is to call it foolhardy? Again, I don’t think so.
I offer the following modest proposals. [ subtitle: "HELL NO! WE WON’T GO!"]
What if pastors, pastoral councils, liturgical commissions and presbyteral councils were to appeal to their bishops for a time of reflection and consultation on the translations and on the process whereby they will be given to the people? [The first thing that leaps to my mind when reading that is "community organizer". Hey! They could get ACORN to help!] It is ironic, to say the least, [Watch this…] that we spend hours of consultation when planning to renovate a church building or parish hall, but little or none when “renovating” the very language of the liturgy. [Yah… because no one bothered to consult when putting the new translation together, nossiree! Not a single meeting or consultation. It just took them half a dozen years to scramble around without a plan looking for that top hat they pulled the drafts from.]
What if, before implementing the new translations, we do some “market testing?” What if each region of bishops were to designate certain places where the new translations would receive a trial run: [Right… because that whole experimentation thing worked back the SIXTIES when everything was GROOVY.] urban parishes and rural parishes, affluent parishes and poor parishes, large, multicultural parishes and small parishes, religious communities and college campuses? What if for the space of one full liturgical year the new translations were used in these designated communities, with carefully planned catechesis and thorough, honest evaluation? Wouldn’t such an experiment yield valuable information for both the translators and the bishops? And wouldn’t such an experiment make it much easier to implement the translations when they are ready? [Hard to say. But I think the bishops, working from their "best pastoral instincts" have chosen another path.]
In short, what if we were to trust our best instincts and defend our people [!] from this ill-conceived disruption of their prayer life? What if collegiality, dialogue and a realistic awareness of the pastoral needs of our people were to be introduced at this late stage of the game? [Oh, brother.] Is it not possible that we might help the church we love avert a debacle or even disaster? [Frogs falling the the sky! LOCUSTS!] And is it not possible that the voices [voices?] in the church that have decided that Latinity is more important than lucidity [Oh, for heaven’s sake!] might end up listening to the people [HELL NO! WE WON’T GO!] and re-evaluating their position, and that lengthy, ungainly, awkward sentences could be trimmed, giving way to noble, even poetic translations of beautiful old texts that would be truly worthy of our greatest prayer, worthy of our language and worthy of the holy people of God whose prayer this is? (If you think the above sentence is unwieldy, wait till you see some of the new Missal translations. They might be readable, but border on the unspeakable!) [JUST SAY NO! USE LATIN!]
“What If We Just Said No?” was my working title for this article. “What If We Just Said, ‘Wait’?” seems preferable. [I am not sure there is a difference.] Dialogue is better than diatribe, as the Second Vatican Council amply demonstrated. So let the dialogue begin. Why not let the priests who are on the front lines and the laypeople who pay the bills (including the salaries of priests and bishops) have some say in how they are to pray? [And how would that work, exactly?] If you think the idea has merit, I invite you to log on to the Web site www.whatifwejustsaidwait.org and make your voice heard. If our bishops know the depth of our concern, perhaps they will not feel so alone. [HELL NO! WE WON’T GO!]
Rev. Michael G. Ryan has been pastor of St. James Cathedral in Seattle since 1988 and serves on the board of the national Cathedral Ministry Conference.
I wish I had a draft card to burn.
A modest proposal of my own.
If you don’t like the new translation which is going to be put into use sooner or later, I say
RISE UP for your people!
Don’t let yourselves BE OPPRESSED!
USE LATIN!
USE LATIN NOW!
Save your flocks, I IMPLORE YOU!
JUST SAY NO!
LaTIN! … LaTIN! … LaTIN! … LaTIN! ….
From a reader:
Dear Father,
allow me to bring to your (and your readers’) attention a Solemn High Mass (EF) to be celebrated this Sunday, Dec. 6, 2:00pm, at Holy Spirit Church in Lantana, FL. This will be the first such celebration of the Mass in the area in over 40 years (and the first ever for the Diocese of Palm Beach, which was established in 1984). The main celebrant will be Fr. Kevin Nelson, Pastor of Holy Spirit, assisted by Fr. Brian Campbell and Fr. Brian King, and with six servers, three of whom are from our homeschool group that meets at St. Therese in Wellington.
Fr. Nelson has been offering an EF low Mass every Sunday at 2:00 since the beginning of September. The Florida Catholic article announcing it is attached. Fr. Campbell, Parochial Vicar at St. Patrick since his ordination this spring, also offered his first EF low Mass there at Holy Spirit in October, with Fr. Nelson assisting in choro.
A reader sent the following:
Could you be so kind as to take one minute and send an email card (see below) to the men and women serving our country? It’s so difficult being away from home anytime but especially during the holidays like Christmas.
If you go to this web site, www.LetsSayThanks.com you can pick out a thank you card. Xerox will print it and send it to a soldier who is currently serving in Iraq. You can’t pick out who gets your card, but it will go to a member of the nation’s armed forces. It is FREE and it only takes just 10 seconds. It’s a wonderful way to say thank you.
Thanks for taking to time to support the men and women in our military!
On the site of National Public Radio there is an audio story about the fact that strong Catholic bishop are beginning to regain their voice in the public square.
My emphases and comments:
On Social Issues, Bishops Flex Political Muscle
by Barbara Bradley Hagerty
Pope Benedict XVI is known for his conservative theology, but it’s his predecessor’s legacy that is playing out in U.S. politics today. [In the first sentence the writer brings in the theme of "politics".] A generation of U.S. Catholic bishops who were selected by John Paul II is conservative on social issues, and they are willing to mix it up in the public square to push their views. [That is a fair statement, despite the use of "politics" in the first line.]
Exhibit A: the health care overhaul. On Nov. 6, the night before the House of Representatives voted on heath care, Speaker Nancy Pelosi received some visitors. One was Rep. Bart Stupak of Michigan, an anti-abortion Democrat, [Nearly a contradiction in terms. But let’s make this into "authentic Catholic Democrat".] who wanted to amend the House bill to permanently strip federal funding for abortion. Critics say that would make it harder for all women to pay for abortions. Stupak brought with him two representatives of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, who said they would not support any bill without that amendment. [That implies that Stupak brought two bishops with him. I don’t think he did.]
As Stupak later put it, "We want to send a message: If you start messing with abortion and health care, you’ve got a problem."
The meeting was a turning point. Pelosi allowed a vote on the amendment the next day. It passed.
Stance Criticized
Connecticut Democrat Rosa DeLauro, a pro-choice Catholic, [No. She is a pro-abortion Catholic, which is to say "pro-abortion ‘Catholic’".] says she was dismayed that the bishops seemed to be elevating abortion over every other issue, including the health care needs of the poor. [She pits the bishops against the poor. Does that sound even slightly plausible? Perhaps DeLauro doesn’t have a clue for what she is talking about. Or, if she does, then is she mendacious?]
"In their quest to push on the issue of abortion," she says, "they failed in the church’s mission. [And she is an expert on the Church’s mission, while the bishops are not?] They really act like a bunch of lawyers who are instructing members how to vote on arcane House rules." [And she is acting like a servant of Satan, abetting the killing of the innocent. She is also giving public scandal to Catholics by her actions, which indicate that she sets her Catholic faith at lesse than her support of something that is objectively and intrinsically evil.]
DeLauro says the bishops are rejecting the tradition established by John F. Kennedy that Catholic politicians vote according to their conscience, not the dictates of Rome. [Do you see anything wrong with this? Let’s start with her premise: That what JFK did in Dallas during his election bid was acceptable. In fact it was not. But I guess in ancient Carthage there was also a traditional of sacrificing babies to Moloch…. so….]
"The activity that the Catholic bishops have engaged in implies that the church will determine and dictate public policy," DeLauro says. [DeLauro is just plain dumb if she thinks this. And if she doesn’t then she is being deceptive. Does any serious person think that the Catholic bishops want to dictate public policy? The want a voice in public policy to be sure. But dictate? DeLauro, you’re duplicity is showing!]
‘Moral Issue’
But John Myers, the archbishop of Newark, N.J., says bishops have every right to lobby Congress and influence laws.
"I don’t think it was improper because what we talked about is moral issues, and if anyone has the responsibility and the right to speak out on moral issues, it is religious leaders," Myers says. [Unless you are like pro-abortion Democrats like DeLauro, who believes that religious leaders should be seen and not heard, that they have fewer rights than the rest of Americans. I wonder if she thinks it is okay for Catholic clergy to vote. Someone should ask her.]
He says bishops are becoming more assertive because they feel the country is reaching a moral tipping point: Abortion remains legal, President Obama lifted a ban on stem cell research, and a few states are allowing same-sex marriage.
Watershed Moment
The bishops’ frustration seemed to boil over in May when the University of Notre Dame awarded an honorary degree to Obama, who supports abortion rights. [No. Pres. Obama does not "support" abortion rights. He aggressively promotes abortion and would even withhold medical assistance to a child who survived an abortion so that he or she would die.]
Prominent church leaders criticized the university for the invitation. The local bishop, John D’Arcy, boycotted the event.
"Some would call that a betrayal of Catholic teaching and of the church to which Notre Dame is attached," he told a local radio station. "And I would agree with that."
Cardinal Francis George, the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, called the invitation "an extreme embarrassment," while Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York said it was "a big mistake."
"I think the Obama visit to Notre Dame was a real watershed moment," says Father James Martin, an editor at the Catholic magazine America. "That really drove the bishops to distraction, [What a curious way to put that. It is as if Martin is implying that they had a "hissy fit" or a "case of the vapors".] and I think that really prompted a lot of them to be more vocal than they would have been 20 to 30 years ago."
The Legacy Of John Paul II
Martin says the bishops are irked by the new political landscape. And there’s another factor: These bishops are part of the John Paul II generation, elevated in part because they shared the late pope’s conservative theology.
"I think what you’re seeing is people that are much more likely to be outspoken about social issues that they consider important to the Catholic Church," says Martin. " [And surely he is right.] And you’re also seeing a new president who’s a Democrat and with whom many of these bishops disagree. So I think all these things are coming together to form a kind of perfect storm."
And now those bishops are flexing their [long atrophied] muscles. They told Catholics in Maine to vote against a law allowing same-sex marriage. It was overturned last month. In Washington, D.C., the archbishop announced that Catholic Charities may have to cancel contracts with the city to provide services to the poor if a similar law passes this month.
Holy Communion
And then there is the battle between Bishop Thomas Tobin of Providence, R.I., and his parishioner [his subject], Democratic Rep. Patrick Kennedy. Because of Kennedy’s support of abortion rights, Tobin suggested to him, privately, that he refrain from taking Holy Communion. After Kennedy made the exchange public, the bishop took to the airwaves. [I am glad that that was reported well. At first this was all private. Kennedy made it public.]
"The point is that for any Catholic in public office, his first commitment has to be to his faith," Tobin told MSNBC’s Chris Matthews. "Not just for a Catholic, but for a member of any religious community. No commitment is more important than your commitment to your faith, because it involves your relationship with God." [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]
George Weigel, a conservative Catholic analyst at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, and author of several books about the popes, says it’s about time the bishops stood up and acted as "boundary guards" of Catholicism. [That is actually a pretty good description. There is a lot of room under the Catholic umbrella. But at a certain point you stray from under its protection.]
"Bishop Tobin finally broke through this tribal reluctance to criticize the Kennedy family and said, ‘No. Excuse me, I’m the guy when it comes to defining Catholic identity in Rhode Island, not you.‘ " [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]
But DeLauro says the bishops are using Holy Communion as a political weapon, and that makes her and her fellow Catholics on the Hill uncomfortable. [I bet it does. That is because she and her pro-abortion "Catholic" crowd are guilty of something terrible, and she knows it.]
"I think every Catholic member of this body who walks into a church to receive the sacrament of the Eucharist has at the back of their mind that they could be potentially denied," she says. ["At the back of their mind…". Hey DeLauro! That’s called your conscience.]
Now, Catholic senators will have to consider that issue as they vote on their version of health care overhaul. The bishops have sent a letter, saying they will oppose any bill that contains funding for abortion.
His Hermeneuticalness, the great Fr. Finigan, who would be a very good choice as a bishop, posted this about the resignation about his own ordinary, Kevin McDonald, Archbishop of Southwark.
The Holy Father has accepted the resignation from the pastoral government of hte Archdiocese of Southwark (England) presented by His Grace Kevin McDonald, in conformity with canon 401 § 2 of the Code of Canon Law.
Here is the Press Release issued by the Archdiocese of Southwark:
At 11am (GMT) The Holy Father accepted the accepted the resignation of Archbishop Kevin McDonald of Southwark in accordance with Canon 401 §2. The Archbishop submitted his resignation to the Holy Father having taken account of medical advice. The Archbishop has had a triple heart bypass and also suffers from severe osteo arthritis. This has already necessitated surgery and the Archbishop envisages further surgery in 2010.
Archbishop McDonald said,
“I feel great sadness at having to relinquish my post as Archbishop of Southwark. Although I have had to contend with illness over the last three years, this appointment has been a great grace. It has been a privilege to lead this great Diocese and I have received a wonderful response to everything I have tried to do. I have also been very appreciative of the prayers of so many people while I have been ill. The Diocese will continue to be very much in my thoughts and prayers in the time ahead.”
A Diocesan Administrator will be appointed soon and he will be in charge of the Diocese, until a new Archbishop takes possession of the Diocese.
Please remember Archbishop McDonald in your prayers. He has recently undergone much suffering and physical pain which he has borne with great spirit.
If anyone were to ask me, I think Fr. Finigan is available for the job.
An alert reader noticed the following on the Vatican’s website:
24 Thursday
Solemnity of the Birth of Our Lord
Vatican Basilica, at 22.00
CAPPELLA PAPALE
Midnight Mass
Interesting.
From CNA with my emphases and comments:
St. Louis Archbishop responds to gay rights protest outside cathedral
St. Louis, Mo., Nov 30, 2009 / 06:17 pm (CNA).- In a statement Monday, Archbishop Robert J. Carlson of St. Louis responded to a demonstration held outside the city’s cathedral by a gay rights group protesting the use of archdiocesan funds to defend traditional marriage in Maine. [Imagine the effrontery! The Catholic Church daring to be involved in a moral issue! Imagine, a Catholic bishop chosing to defend… wait for it… marriage. OH the humanity!] Catholics have an obligation to “carry out Christ’s teachings, whether in the privacy of our own home or in the public square,” stated the prelate on the Archdiocese of St. Louis website. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]
On Sunday, gay rights organization Show Me No Hate [The Catholic Church’s teaching on marriage is not a demonstration of "hate" toward anyone. Undermining God’s design, however, is not charity toward anyone.] protested the donation of $10,000 that the Archdiocese of St. Louis made to the “Yes on 1” campaign in Portland, Maine earlier this year. The initiative, which supported traditional marriage between a man and a woman, was voted on and passed during the mid-term elections.
According to The Vital Voice, Show Me No Hate has accused the Archdiocese of St. Louis of misusing the funds, saying the Church has neglected the poor, sick and homeless in the city by donating the money to a campaign against gay “marriage.” [Hey wait… that sounds familiar: "Then one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, he that was about to betray him, said: ‘Why was not this ointment sold for three hundred pence, and given to the poor?’ Now he said this, not because he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and having the purse, carried the things that were put therein" ( John 12:4-6).] The organization plans to rally outside the cathedral every Sunday for the duration of the season of Advent. [Too bad it doesn’t get very cold there.]
“Following Christ’s teaching on marriage does not mean we neglect the poor,” stated Archbishop Carlson in response to the accusations. [How tedious it must be to have to explain that sort of obvious point.] “In fact, no other private institution in the world does as much for the sick and poor as the Catholic Church.”
Archbishop Carlson explained that the funds used for the “Yes on 1” campaign were discretionary, provided by private gifts and sent in response to the request of the Archdiocese of Maine. The archbishop also mentioned that “Yes on 1” succeeded despite the fact that same-sex “marriage” supporters had outraised the campaign by almost $2 million. [Nice touch.]
The Church “always tries to follow the teachings of Jesus in welcoming all people,” and “does not believe in discrimination” said the archbishop in his statement on Monday. He then made reference to the fact that the Archdiocese of St. Louis is currently the largest private contributor to Doorways, an organization that provides services for those living with HIV/AIDS. [I wonder if the protesters will protest that too?]
The archbishop explained, however, that this “does not mean we can change Christ’s teaching on the nature of marriage” [Because Catholics are not so arrogant as to think they can edit the Word of God or distort God’s will. We don’t claim such authority] and added that Catholics have the obligation to “carry out Christ’s teachings, whether in the privacy of our own home or in the public square.” [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]
“Separation of church and state means that the government cannot favor a particular faith,” continued the prelate. “It does not mean that faith-filled people lose their right to speak out publicly and engage in the political process.” [Do I hear another "Amen!"? Well done.]
When it comes to serving the poor and supporting traditional marriage, Archbishop Carlson added that “it’s not an either/or choice when it comes to Christ’s teachings. As Catholics, we are called to live and teach them all.”
"… live and teach them all."
There really is no such thing as a picking and choosing "cafeteria Catholic", is there. Catholics embrace all of it. If you don’t… then you have real questions of identity.
Something unexpected came from the site of The Catholic Spirit of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis.
What works: St. Matthew’s School increases enrollment by 30 percent
By Julie Carroll
Thursday, 03 December 2009While most inner-city schools continue to struggle in a difficult economy, one school — St. Matthew’s in St. Paul — has been experiencing unprecedented growth.
Last year, enrollment at the school increased 30 percent. This year, despite the worst recession since World War II, enrollment continues to grow.
What’s the secret? It depends on whom you ask.
Like other urban schools, St. Matthew’s had been losing students at an average of 10 to 15 per year. When the kindergarten-through-eighth-grade school’s enrollment dipped down below 140 students, principal Doug Lieser realized he needed to find a way to increase enrollment and financial support if the school was to survive.
The first thing Lieser did was conduct a survey asking parents why they chose St. Matthew’s for their children. Their answers surprised him.
“We have two mobile computer labs, we have a great lunch program, a great curriculum. . . . But that’s not why they’re choosing us,” Lieser said. “The three primary reasons that we found for our families choosing St. Matthew’s were that we were small, we were Catholic, and we provided a safe environment.”
Lieser took that information and designed a marketing campaign around it that included yard signs, newspaper advertisements and word of mouth.
Around the same time, alum Jerry Sexton worked with Lieser and Father Steve Adrian, pastor of St. Matthew’s, to form an Alumni and Friends group. Sexton used his experience in publishing to create a school newsletter for alumni, parents and donors.
‘Communication is key’
While every urban school is unique, one common problem many of them share is poor communication, Sexton said. “Communication is key. . . . You raise money for tuition support and then you publish the fact that you have tuition support money.”
The newsletter is filled with success stories to show how St. Matthew’s is making a difference in students’ lives and in the community.
“You love God by loving your neighbor, and that is what we’re about at the school,” Sexton said.
Another reason St. Matthew’s has succeeded in recent years, according to Father Adrian, is its focus on serving families with limited financial means.
“There are just tons of people who never ever thought of a Catholic education because they assume they could never afford it,” he said. “So what we have done is rather successfully gotten the word out that money cannot be the issue, that we will find the money and you’re welcome in the school. And people come.”
Ninety percent of families with children at St. Matthew receive financial aid, Lieser said.
The school is able to provide scholarships through support from the archdiocese; FOCUS, a nonprofit organization Sexton helped found to raise funds for urban Catholic schools; and assistance from other organizations and donors.
Since it was formed in 2007, Alumni and Friends has raised an additional $270,000 for the school, Father Adrian said.
Being a ‘good Samaritan’
To those who might question why St. Matthew parish directs so much of its resources toward education, Father Adrian responds: “What we say to our donors is that the commitment on the part of St. Matthew’s is to seek to be the ‘good Samaritan’ on the banks of the Mississippi River, and part of that mission is the educating of kids.”
He points out that a majority of children attending St. Matthew’s are Hispanic.
“We all know that the Catholic population in the United States is growing largely because of Spanish-speaking immigrants, and that it’s not too far down the line when those folks are going to be making up, if not the majority, at least a very significant chunk of what the church is, and it’s out of those folks that the future leadership is going to come,” Father Adrian said.
“If we don’t invest in the education of the kids of Latin background today, we’re missing the opportunity to provide new, fresh, well-prepared Catholic leadership a generation from now.”
All of St. Matthew’s efforts — the marketing campaign, the newsletter, the Alumni and Friends group, and the focus on mission — have shown impressive results.
In 2007, enrollment at St. Matthew’s was 136. This year, 192 students attend the school, two classes have waiting lists and the retention rate is 95 percent.
“The future of the school is strong,” said Father Adrian. “And it’s growing.”
And their advice?
How Catholic schools can replicate St. Matthew’s success
- “Be clear about who you are, what your message is,” principal Doug Lieser advises. “In our case, we did it through a survey. Other schools might do that in a different way. But be clear about it and make sure people know it.”
- “Make it a group effort,” Lieser said. St. Matthew’s owes its success to its pastor, alumni, donors, volunteers and a host of people acting together toward a common goal.
- “Put together a handful of people who are really committed to turning the school around and who have financial resources,” said Father Steve Adrian, pastor. “Then trust upon the good instincts and the energy of those folks.”
- “Get the word out as clearly as you can that everyone’s welcome,” he added.
- “I found that alumni will respond to the raising of dollars when you can say and you can demonstrate that because of their gift you were able to welcome ‘X’ number of new students into the school,” Father Adrian said.
- Expand your school’s mission to improving the community, Father Adrian added. In addition to educating children, St. Matthew provides a child care center, it’s a St. Mary’s Clinic and Loaves and Fishes site, the rectory is a Catholic Worker House, etc.
- “Take a look at your communications,” suggested St. Matthew’s alumnus Jerry Sexton. Make sure you’re communicating far and wide the good things that the school does.
Today we welcome St. Francis Xavier, SJ (+1552) who speaks to us from a letter he wrote to his superior, friend, mentor and fellow Basque, St. Ignatius of Loyola, founder of the Jesuits.
On his feast day, we St. Francis’ feelings on finding a group of unformed Christians in India. I think this is relevant to our situation today, and I expand on that.
Also, we have another installment of stories about the fictional don Camillo Tarocci, (+ A.D. … ?) parish priest of “The Little World”.
Some time ago, I began a to read stories from The Little World of Don Camillo by Giovanni Guareschi. There is a Don Camillo tag you can use to find the others easily.
![]()
These delightful pieces are set in post-war Northern Italy.
They blend brilliant insight into the human condition with solid applied Catholic Faith.
Today we hear the story:
https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/09_12_03.mp3