WSJ: notes from Fr. Sirico on “Caritas in veritate”

In today’s Wall Street Journal Fr. Robert Sirico of Acton Institute has a comment on the Pope’s new "social" encyclical Caritas in veritate.

My emphases and comments.

The Pope on ‘Love in Truth’
Anyone seeking a repudiation of the market economy will be disappointed.

By ROBERT A. SIRICO

In his much anticipated third encyclical, Caritas in Veritate (Love in Truth), Pope Benedict XVI does not focus on specific systems of economics — he is not attempting to shore up anyone’s political agenda. He is rather concerned with morality and the theological foundation of culture. [Culture precedes politics and economic theory.] The context is of course a global economic crisis — a crisis that’s taken place in a moral vacuum, where the love of truth has been abandoned in favor of a crude materialism. The pope urges that this crisis become "an opportunity for discernment, in which to shape a new vision for the future."

Yet [pay attention] his encyclical contains no talk of seeking a third way between markets and socialism. Words like greed and capitalism make no appearance here, [I did a search in the English version… not a single appearance of "capitalism".] despite press headlines following the publication of the encyclical earlier this week. People seeking a blueprint for the political restructuring of the world economy won’t find it here. But if they look to this document as a means for the moral reconstruction of the world’s cultures and societies, which in turn influence economic events, they will find much to reflect upon.

Caritas in Veritate is an eloquent restatement of old truths casually dismissed in modern times. The pope is pointing to a path neglected in all the talk of economic stimulus, namely a global embrace of truth-filled charity.

Benedict rightly attributes the crisis itself to "badly managed and largely speculative financial dealing." But he resists the current fashion of blaming all existing world problems on the market economy. "The Church," he writes, "has always held that economic action is not to be regarded as something opposed to society." Further: "Society does not have to protect itself from the market, as if the development of the latter were ipso facto to entail the death of authentically human relations."

The market is rather shaped by culture. "Economy and finance . . . can be used badly when those at the helm are motivated by purely selfish ends. Instruments that are good in themselves can thereby be transformed into harmful ones. But it is man’s darkened reason that produces these consequences, not the instrument per se. Therefore it is not the instrument that must be called to account, but individuals, their moral conscience and their personal and social responsibility."

The pope does not reject globalization: "Blind opposition would be a mistaken and prejudiced attitude, incapable of recognizing the positive aspects of the process, with the consequent risk of missing the chance to take advantage of its many opportunities for development." He says that "the world-wide diffusions of prosperity should not . . . be held up by projects that are protectionist." More, not less, trade is needed: "the principal form of assistance needed by developing countries is that of allowing and encouraging the gradual penetration of their products into international markets." [trade… the market… will help relieve poverty and help peoples develop]

The encyclical doesn’t attack capitalism or offer models for nations to adopt. "The Church does not have technical solutions to offer," the pope firmly states, "and does not claim ‘to interfere in any way in the politics of States.’ She does, however, have a mission of truth to accomplish, in every time and circumstance . . ." Benedict is profoundly aware that economic science has much to contribute to human betterment. The Church’s role is not to dictate the path of research but to focus its goals. "Economic science tells us that structural insecurity generates anti-productive attitudes wasteful of human resources. . . . Human costs always include economic costs, and economic dysfunctions always involve human costs."

He constantly returns to two practical applications of the principle of truth in charity. [1] First, this principle takes us beyond earthly demands of justice, defined by rights and duties, and introduces essential moral priorities of generosity, mercy and communion — priorities which provide salvific and theological value. [2] Second, truth in charity is always focused on the common good, defined as an extension of the good of individuals who live in society and have broad social responsibilities. As for issues of population, he can’t be clearer: [a "life" point…] "To consider population increase as the primary cause of underdevelopment is mistaken, even from an economic point of view."

Several commentators have worried about his frequent calls for wealth redistribution. Benedict does see a role for the state here, but much of the needed redistribution is the result of every voluntary and mutually beneficial exchange. [NB:] To understand such passages fully and accurately, we do well to put our political biases on the shelf.

This encyclical is a theological version of his predecessor’s more philosophical effort to anchor the free economy’s ethical foundation. Much of it stands squarely with a long tradition of writings of a certain "classical liberal" tradition, one centered on the moral foundation of economics, from St. Thomas Aquinas and his disciples, Frederic Bastiat in the 19th century, Wilhelm Roepke, and even the secular F.A. Hayek in the 20th century. It also clearly resonates with some European Christian democratic thought. 

Caritas in Veritate is a reminder that we cannot understand ourselves as a human community if we do not understand ourselves as something more than the sum or our material parts; if we do not understand our capacity for sin; and if we do not understand the principle of communion rooted in the gratuitousness of God’s grace. Simply put, to this pope’s mind, there is no just or moral system without just and moral people.

Father Sirico is president and co-founder of the Acton Institute.

 

A good propaedeutic article for your reading of the encyclical.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
47 Comments

From the Martyrologium Romanum

From the Martyrologium Romanum:

1. Romae, sanctorum martyrum Felicis et Philippi in coemeterio Priscillae, Vitalis, Martialis et Alexandri in Iordanorum, Silani in Maximi, et Ianuarii in Praetextati; quorum coniuncta memoria gaudet Ecclesia Romana, quae una die tot glorificatur triumphis, quia cum multiplici exemplo multiplicata intercessione munitur.

 

Honorable mention to

3. In Sabinis, sanctarum Anatoliae et Victoriae, martyrum.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

The Tablet gets something right on Ecclesia Dei

It is not often that you have seen me write something like this, but in the new number of The Tablet, Robert Mickens has written a pretty fair blurb about the restructuring of the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei. 

Here is an example of The Tablet being fairer than NCR, with my emphases and comments.

The anticipated motu proprio to reorganise the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei” finally came out this week. It’s called “Ecclesiae Unitatem” and, as expected, it makes the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith the commission’s president by statute. The commission was set up in 1988 after Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and another bishop illicitly ordained four men to the episcopacy for the renegade Society of St Pius X (SSPX). They all incurred excommunication. The original purpose of “Ecclesia Dei” was to help bring the priests and lay people loyal to the SSPX back into full communion with Rome. [Along with a couple other things, but that was a main part of the mandate.] Several priests immediately took up the offer and started the Priestly Fraternity of St Peter (FSSP).  Others over the years have used the commission to found new religious groups exclusively devoted to the [so-called] Tridentine Mass. But the SSPX itself has never been interested in returning to “modernist” Rome because of the “unacceptable” changes it accepted following the Second Vatican Council. The stalemate did not show signs of ending until Benedict XVI was elected Pope in 2005. The new Pope displayed greater interest in concerns voiced by the SSPX. His first step was to issue the motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum” in 2007, which restored the pre-Vatican II liturgy’s place in the universal Church. And in January the Pope lifted the SSPX excommunications. But before the Lefebvrists can be readmitted to full communion with Rome, they have to show they accept Church teachings from Vatican II to the present. [It remains to be seen what sort of acceptance that will be, however.] It will be “Ecclesia Dei”, now under the guidance of Cardinal William Levada, that will verify that. [Or at least organize it.]

Posted in Ecclesiae unitatem, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , , ,
12 Comments

What will Pres. Obama give the Pope when he is admitted to His Holiness’s presence?

When heads of state come to visit other heads of state, they bring gifts.

What will Pres. Obama bring when the Pope admits him into the papal presence?

My emphases and comments in this CNA story.

The stole of St. John Neumann that the president will present to Pope Benedict.

Baltimore, Md., Jul 9, 2009 / 03:10 pm (CNA).- When President Barack Obama visits the Holy Father tomorrow, he will present a stole worn by St. John Neumann, a 19th century Redemptorist priest who is the patron saint of sick children and immigrants.

“It’s a delight that something of one of our Redemptorist saints would be given to our Holy Father,” said Very Rev. Patrick Woods, provincial of the Redemptorists’ Baltimore Province. “We’re delighted as Americans that our president is visiting the Holy Father, and delighted that something belonging to our province would be given to him.”

The Redemptorists, founded by St. Alphonsus Liguori in 1732, are priests who minister to the needs of the faithful, particularly the poor and the spiritually abandoned.  Currently there are 300 Redemptorist priests serving in the United States alone.

Fr. Woods further explained that the stole was an appropriate gift for the Pope as a symbol of the priesthood because that was “at the heart of St. John Neumann’s life as a Redemptorist.”

In light of Neumann’s extensive service to immigrants, Woods said the gift was also symbolic of the new wave of immigration occurring in the United States, [It is?] and his order’s continued service to these often marginalized and over-looked groups.

The stole was discovered by Louis DiCocco, president of the St. Jude Shops and the St. Jude Liturgical Arts Studio, who was contacted by the Obama administration for assistance in finding a gift for Pope Benedict.

“They wanted to find an antique chalice, but I suggested it was important to get something more personable,” DiCocco said. “I told them about this stole that was something that belonged to an immigrant who was so instrumental in serving immigrants and building Catholic schools. What better than the stole that represents the priest?”

St. John Neumann was born in 1811 in Bohemia, but traveled to New York to become a missionary priest.  After his arrival, he was sent to Buffalo where he lived off bread and water and joined the Redemptorist order until he was elected Bishop of Philadelphia in 1852.

As bishop, John Neumann built 50 churches and nearly 100 schools.  He died suddenly on January 5, 1860.

He was canonized by Pope Paul VI in 1977 and is the patron saint of sick children and immigrants.

For more information about the Redemptorists of the Baltimore Province, visit www.redemptorists.net.

 

UPDATE 10 July 0401 GMT:
What will Pres. Obama give the Pope when he is admitted to His Holiness's presence?

I just got a very interesting e-mail from a priest friend and must share it:

I am not sure, but it seems that something is odd with this gift that the President is living to the Holy Father. It is said to be a stole that “belonged to” John Neumann, something of ‘great historical significance’ – but when you look at the photo of the stole here, it is obvious that it is an Almy special, [ROFL!  Absolutely right!  I didn’t really look at the photo too closely in the other article, but though that it was, at first glance, in pretty good shape!  But… really!] and then as you read further, you begin to pick up the fact that it really was only put on the body of the saint in 1989 and removed a few yeas later to be replaced with something that was more authentic to the period in which he lived.
            One has the impression that with an Ipod to the Queen and some CDs to the Prime Minister of England and now and Episcopalian-made ‘sash (as one report puts it) being given to the Pope, the Obama White House just does not have the protocol of gift giving to Heads of State down.
            I can hardly wait to see what Mrs. Obama wears to the audience.

ROLF!  Excellent…. excellent….

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
95 Comments

Liberal gushing over the upcoming meeting of Pope and President

Some liberal gushing over the upcoming meeting of the President and the Pope.

Obama-Benedict meeting ‘no mere photo-op‘
By Dennis Coday
Created Jul 09, 2009

Just off the phone with a teleconference called by the [squishy Kmiec] Catholic Democrats. They had [Catholic pro-abortion] Congresswoman Rosa L. DeLauro of Connecticut [a member of the Congressional Pro-Choice Caucus] and [Catholic pro-abortion] Congressman Jim McGovern of Massachusetts [solidly pro-abortion, backed by NOW] speaking about Pope Benedict XVI’s encyclical Caritas in Veritate and about tomorrow’s meeting between the pope and President Obama.

The big question (asked by Michael Paulson of The Boston Globe) was about tomorrow’s meeting. Is it symbolism or is it significant? [Symbolic is significant.]

The representatives were both adamant that this was no mere photo-op.  [Based on….?]

McGovern said, "In the past there have been symbolic meetings that amounted to no more than photo-ops and nice press releases. [For example?] But my sense of President Obama is  [Get ready for the gushy part…] that he doesn’t do symbolism. [ROFL!  Doesn’t he?]  He is not going through the motions. This is man who ran for president with a deep desire to change the world for the better. He is a man with a mission."  [And no symbolism was involved.]

"I believe that [Obama] really wants to change things,"  [So do I.] McGovern said. "And I think this pope, with the encyclical that he has issued has put forward a framework not just for the Untied States to follow but for the rest of the world to follow. …  [I he suggesting that the Pope Benedict’s teaching in Caritas in veritate and Pope, er um, President Obama’s agenda are in harmony?]

"I have high expectations for this meeting. … I believe this meeting has the potential to have a lasting impact, to help not only inspire but to provide — quite frankly — [get this…] the political cover in some cases to move forward in some of these areas that up to this point have been difficult for politicians to deal with." The difficult issues he cited were peace in the Middle East, extreme poverty and hunger. [I would add African issues, too.  But, I suspect that these pro-abortion Dems mean something else as well.]

"My expectation and my hope for this meeting tomorrow is that it will be about real things and about results," he said.  [Do these well-informed pro-abortion politicans understand that the meeting will be about 15 minutes long, minus the photos?]

DeLauro agreed with this sentiment and with the idea that Benedict has given the world a road map for the global economy. 
[Pope Benedict also stressed the importance of defense of human life.] Benedict, she said, "is very clear about what are the moral consequences and the economic consequences of what we do and how that affects people. He is trying, in a very thoughtful way, to address very serious issues. … President Obama has demonstrated this equal kind of deep thinking on these very, very serious issues, and he isn’t afraid to take on these very serious deep issues which cause tension in our society." [NB: The pro-abortion politician is drawing a close equivalence between the Holy Father’s Magisterium and Pres. Obama’s "magisterium".  As I have been saying, some Notre Dame, Pres. Obama is the new Pope of America.]

"He has taken on issues that not too many political figures want to take on," she said. He did this during his campaign on the issue of race,
[wait for it…] at Notre Dame on abortion and in Cairo on Islam.

"This is not a photo op. This is not, excuse me, posing for holy pictures. [PUHLEEZE.  Does this person understand what is going on at all?  But try to plumb the depths of the next phrase or two…]  There is a reality and a difficulty about the serious issues that face all of our societies."  [wowwww]  The issues are complex with no easy answers, DeLauro’  [gosh!] said, but Obama and Benedict are saying, "let’s find the common ground [ooooo] and let’s see what we can pull out of this to try and move the dialogue forward."  [Yah.. ’cause its dialogue that’s going to get it done.]

"That is the kind of leadership that we need in the world," she said. 
[Ummm… whose, exactly?]

I’ll blog a bit later on DeLauro’ and McGovern said about Caritas in Veritate.


Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Penjing

Penjing

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Linz excom hijinz… er… comjinx … er… hijinx

Interesting things continue in Austria.

From Catholic Church Conservatism:

Linz excom hijinz... er... comjinx ... er... hijinxExcommunicated Female "Bishop" seizes Communion

In haste, late at night from the Upper Austrian News.

The Sunday worship celebration in the Parish of St. Peter in Linz did not make the excommunicated "Bishop" Christine Mayr-Lumetzberger as happy as she would have wished. Bishop Ludwig Schwarz refused her communion with the Host. Then she took the wafer herself. [God helps those who help themselves, to…. sacraments,… other stuff….]

400 people joined the celebration of Mass in the Parish of St. Peter on 28June.. It was held in honour of the church’s patron, St. Peter. Among them, high-ranking politicians. But few noticed what happened during the Communion.  [Why does it seem that politicians are involved in stuff like this these days.  Is it my imagination?]

Christine Mayr-Lumetzberger was dressed as a Bishop when she appeared at the Mass in official dress with a large pectoral Cross. [ROFL!]  During the Communion she chose, consciously or unconsciously, the row in which the Diocesan Bishop Ludwig Schwarz distributed communion. The bishop suggested to her that she should not come, because he could not give her Communion. But Mayr-Lumetzberger would not stop. When it came to her, she was not given the Host. According to ecclesiastical law, someone excommunicated may not receive communion.

Mayr-Lumetzberger took the host herself from the ciborium. "I was there for all men and women in a similar situation in life," she says in discussion with OÖN. [Ahhh… so self-sacrificing!] Is it normal to receive the Host like this? "There are different models of the Communion," she says.  [Whatever that means.  I think she means that she is in Communion regardless of what the Church says.  Yep, that’s pretty much it.] What did she feel? "In the first moment, nothing. But now [that I have had time to figured out best to get the press to pay attention] I feel hurt and angry, like a woman who has been beaten for the first time by a man, "says Mayr-Lumetzberger.  [PUHLEEZE]

Had she expected to receive Communion?" Yes. The Gospel is a higher authority than canon law. [Convenient.] "Mayr-Lumetzberger is excommunicated since according to Canon Law ordination of priestesses is prohibited. It had however never happened that she did not receive the Host. The Church of St. Peter is her home parish. "I know Christine a long time. For me, she has never come for Communion. She knows what situation this would put me in "says Parish Priest Franz Zeiger. This Sunday, she came dressed as a Bishop to the Mass.

Do she wish to provoke and did she want to attract attention? [D’ya think?] "I cannot judge. But dress codes, I cannot enforce on anybody, "says Pastor Zeiger. Did he understand the attitude of Bishop Ludwig Schwarz? "Yes. in canon law he cannot. " [But she is above canon law!] Observers had the impression that the situation during the Mass was painful for Bishop Ludwig Schwarz.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
56 Comments

Abortion clinic taunts Catholic demonstrators

Soooo…. Now what do you think about my post The Problem With Toning Down the Rhetoric – And Why We Probably Won’t Do It ?

A biretta tip  o{]:¬/   to the young papist…. who got something from Lifesite.

My emphases and comments:

Abortion Employee Runs into Pro-Lifer, Keeps Going at Bizarre Rockford Abortuary

By Kathleen Gilbert

ROCKFORD, Illinois, July 7, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The pattern of abuse at a Rockford abortion facility has continued after an employee allegedly struck with his car a homeless man praying with pro-life protesters, and drove away, according to witnesses at the scene.

Abortion clinic taunts Catholic demonstratorsThe vehicle reportedly struck Scott Griffin on Wednesday as it drove into the driveway of the abortion facility, where pro-lifers say workers frequently drive recklessly in an apparent attempt to intimidate those praying and handing out pro-life literature.

"The dark colored SUV the clinic worker was driving hit Scott Griffin with the mirror on the passenger side so hard the mirror was slammed back into the vehicle and Mr. Griffin was stunned and bruised," Rockford pro-life veteran Kevin Rilott said. 

"After the clinic worker hit him she didn’t slow down or stop to see how he was – she just kept going."

Another witness, George Lambert, said the female clinic worker "really nailed the guy hard – I couldn’t believe she didn’t even stop to see how he was."

City Attorney Kerry Partridge refused to comment on whether any suspects had been questioned or charged, saying only that the case is still under investigation.

Abortion clinic taunts Catholic demonstratorsLifeSiteNews.com (LSN) has previously reported on the bizarre behavior of the owner and a local abortion supporter at Rockford’s Northern Illinois Women’s Center. Pro-life protesters have been regularly harassed and grotesque displays remain in the abortion mill’s windows, including rubber chickens hanging from nooses, a crucified rubber chicken, a nun doll in a miniature coffin and displays with crucifixes and the words "Jesus loves you a**holes."  [“First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.”]

One of the most recent additions to the facility’s displays is a hand-written sign that reads "NIWC 50,000; JC 50," which indicates the number of abortions performed at the Northern Illinois Women’s Center in comparison to 50 saved from abortion by "J.C." – or Jesus Christ.

In March, LSN reported that two young African-American men persuaded their female companion not to abort her child after they were horrified by the rubber chickens hanging by nooses in the abortion facility windows, which pro-lifers at the scene pointed out to them.

The recent Rockford incident continues a rash of violence against pro-life protesters and sidewalk counselors across the country in recent weeks. Last week a man was arrested after he pulled a gun on a woman offering him pro-life literature in front of a Phoenix abortion mill. Another vehicular assault occurred in June at a Chico, CA abortion clinic, where a pro-life protester was nearly run down by an SUV.  Witnesses report the driver was enraged by the graphic abortion image the woman carried. [Back to the incredibly thorny graphic image issue.] The suspected attacker was subsequently arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices | Tagged , ,
28 Comments

Justice Ginsberg originally thought Roe v Wade was about control of undesirable populations

With a tip of the biretta   o{]:¬/   to Sancte Pater, I present this from Worldnet Daily.

I was amazed… amazed to read this.

LAW OF THE LAND

Ginsburg: I thought Roe was to rid undesirables
Justice discusses ‘growth in populations that we don’t want to have too many of’

Supreme Court Justices Pose For Class Photo

In an astonishing admission, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg says she was under the impression that legalizing abortion with the 1973 Roe. v. Wade case would eliminate undesirable members of the populace, or as she put it "populations that we don’t want to have too many of."  [The legacy of Margaret Sanger.]

Her remarks, set to be published in the New York Times Magazine this Sunday but viewable online now, came in an in-depth interview with Emily Bazelon titled, "The Place of Women on the Court."

The 16-year veteran of the high court was asked if she were a lawyer again, what would she "want to accomplish as a future feminist legal agenda."

Ginsburg responded:

Reproductive choice has to be straightened out. There will never be a woman of means without choice anymore. That just seems to me so obvious. The states that had changed their abortion laws before Roe [to make abortion legal] are not going to change back. So we have a policy that affects only poor women, and it can never be otherwise, and I don’t know why this hasn’t been said more often.

Question: Are you talking about the distances women have to travel because in parts of the country, abortion is essentially unavailable, because there are so few doctors and clinics that do the procedure? And also, the lack of Medicaid for abortions for poor women?

Ginsburg: Yes, the ruling about that surprised me. [Harris v. McRae – in 1980 the court upheld the Hyde Amendment, which forbids the use of Medicaid for abortions.] Frankly I had thought that at the time Roe was decided, there was concern about population growth and particularly growth in populations that we don’t want to have too many of. [?!?!?]  So that Roe was going to be then set up for Medicaid funding for abortion. Which some people felt would risk coercing women into having abortions when they didn’t really want them. But when the court decided McRae, the case came out the other way. And then I realized that my perception of it had been altogether wrong.

There is more of this…. go read it at Worldnet Daily and the NYT.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices, What are they REALLY saying? |
57 Comments

A quick note about Msgr. Perl

After the restructuring of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei", there was a question about whether or not the position of Vice-President had been retained and whether Msgr. Perl might remain part of the Commission.

I have clarified the situation in the simplest way: I asked Msgr. Perl.

The long-suffering, long serving, Msgr. Perl has retired!

I sincerely wish him well.  He worked in an unenviable position for over two decades years.  He is also one of the kindest people I know in Rome.  Certainly one of the kindest clerics!

Msgr. Perl remains a Canon of St. Peter’s Basilica and so he will remain for the time being in Rome.

I sincerely wish Msgr. Perl a happy retirement!

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments