Women religious in discontinuity

A reader contacted me about a longish piece on religious life written by a Sr. Sandra Schneider, IHM, who recently has kicked up a fuss about the apostolic visitation of women religious.

My correspondent wrote:

It’s an article indicative of just why we need the Visitation in the first place, in my opinion.

He was kind enough to send a synopsis of this article, which I share with you here with my emphases and comments.

Sister Sandra is looking at data on religious life and interpreting it, and in so doing draws some conclusions.  Primary among her conclusions is that Vatican II has established vowed religious as an entirely new way of Religious Life in the Church.  She writes, "we (and many Congregations like us) are in the process of becoming, or already have become, a new form of Religious Life that has emerged since Vatican Council II."  She says that  because of Vatican II, "We are a Religious Congregation. But, as we will discuss in the next major section, our life also involves some very significant discontinuities with earlier understandings of enough of the constitutive dimensions of that life that it is really a new form in relation to traditional apostolic Congregations."  [A least she is up front about "discontinuity".] She then goes on to refer to Canon Law’s references to the various forms of religious life, and says that her IHM sisters and others like them are emerging as a new form of Religious Life just as the mendicant orders did centuries earlier. [Perhaps… but they sought approval for their way of life.] The term “new form of Religious Life” would have been used, for example, of the mendicants when they became recognizably distinct from the monastics.  Both forms were forms of Religious Life; the mendicants were simply, as a form, younger or newer. We are probably becoming, or have already become, a new form in this sense, i.e., a new form of Religious Life." 

Now, here comes what I thought was the most interesting part, and what shows her true disdain for the Church.  She makes the explicit claim that they are not bound to the institutional Church and that their mission and ministry is their own, not the hierarchy’s.  [Winner winner chicken dinner!  You knew that had to follow as the night the day.] She writes, "Religious Life, as a charism or gift of the Spirit, has a prophetic identity and role in the Church. [Ahhhh…. that’s their excuse.  They’re prophets!  They don’t have to be bound by law, or even the vows they took.] That role is not an office or official task assigned to us by the hierarchy and governed by them. This is important, especially in regard to ministry. Although we are public persons in the Church in virtue of our public profession and the approval of our Constitutions, we are not, as Religious, agents of the institutional Church. That is part of the job description of the ordained." [And, perhaps that means they are not at the service of the Church.  Also, if they do have some relationship to their Constitutions, don’t those Constutitions still describe an purpose for their institutes or orders?  Don’t they still describe an apostolate?  A reason to exist?]

Despite her claim of discontinuity, she then goes on to claim that the modern religious are actually part of an organic development of religious life, and she compares the mobility of the early mendicants, the new form of Religious Life, with the modern day women religious, who live in apartments instead of convents, and so forth.  She also goes on to interpret canon law (and she admits perhaps outside of the intent of the writers of the 1983 code) so that it permits her desire not to wear the habit.  She says that by the 1983 canon placing the regulation of habit in the hands of "proper law," i.e. the law of the Order, that it is perfectly justified that they simply wear a gold ring on their wedding finger to represent their vows.

Anyway, if you’d like I can prepare you a more detailed synopsis of the document, but it’s pretty much along these lines.  She attempts to prove her view of Religious Life as being in continuity with the 2,000 year teaching of the Church while at the same time explicitly admitting that she is seeking to establish a new order in total discontinuity with the Church.

No one can deny that religious life in the Church is in flux and that in every age new forms rise while older forms perhaps change or dissolve.

But this sounds entirely wacky to me.

This sort of thing is a good indicator of why there ought to be a thorough review, by proper authority, of women religious in the USA.  Get to the bottom of what is going on one way or another.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Penzai

Penzai

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Why does Pope Benedict talk about Humanae vitae in the new encyclical?

In Caritas in veritate there is a reference to Humanae vitae.

Remember that the Pope is addressing himself ad intra and ad extra, to the Church herself and to the world at large.

15. Two further documents by Paul VI without any direct link to social doctrine — the Encyclical Humanae Vitae (25 July 1968) and the Apostolic Exhortation Evangelii Nuntiandi (8 December 1975) — are highly important for delineating the fully human meaning of the development that the Church proposes. It is therefore helpful to consider these texts too in relation to Populorum Progressio.

The Encyclical Humanae Vitae emphasizes both the unitive and the procreative meaning of sexuality, thereby locating at the foundation of society the married couple, man and woman, who accept one another mutually, in distinction and in complementarity: a couple, therefore, that is open to life[27]. This is not a question of purely individual morality: [The Holy Father is waging a battle against relativism.] Humanae Vitae indicates the strong links between life ethics and social ethics, ushering in a new area of magisterial teaching that has gradually been articulated in a series of documents, most recently John Paul II’s Encyclical Evangelium Vitae[28]. The Church forcefully maintains this link between life ethics and social ethics, fully aware that “a society lacks solid foundations when, on the one hand, it asserts values such as the dignity of the person, justice and peace, but then, on the other hand, radically acts to the contrary by allowing or tolerating a variety of ways in which human life is devalued and violated, especially where it is weak or marginalized.”[29] …

…

[27] Cf. nos. 8-9: AAS 60 (1968), 485-487; Benedict XVI, Address to the participants at the International Congress promoted by the Pontifical Lateran University on the fortieth anniversary of Paul VI’s Encyclical “Humanae Vitae”, 10 May 2008.

[28] Cf. Encyclical Letter Evangelium Vitae (25 March 1995), 93: AAS 87 (1995), 507-508.

[29] Ibid., 101: loc. cit., 516-518.

What to take away from this?

This is what I think is going on.

Benedict XVI is obviously going to make a reference to this vastly important part of the Paul VI’s magisterium, since the whole encyclical looks back to him. 

Benedict is also offering a challenge to those who think that they can diminish the important of human life and its dignity and the natural act by which human life is conceived when considering how we approach social ills.

He is reminding the world … and Catholics within the Church! … that you cannot diminish these elements, explained in Humanae vitae, and honestly think that you are for true justice.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
34 Comments

Canadian Non-Catholic PM and a consecrated Host

Biretta tip  o{]:¬)   to Lifesite for what follows.

Canadian Non-Catholic PM Says he Did Consume Communion after Offered, Will Meet Pope Saturday

By John-Henry Westen

OTTAWA, July 7, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – Prime Minister Stephen Harper is in hot water over a video that caught him taking Holy Communion in a Catholic Church, despite being a non-Catholic Christian.  To make matters worse, the video shows him walking away without consuming the host. 

LifeSiteNews.com spoke with Harper’s spokesman Dimitri Soudas who explained that the Prime Minister was offered Communion and therefore "accepted it and consumed it." He said, "Any allegation that he put it in his pocket is absurd and ridiculous."   [If he didn’t put It in his jacket pocket, what did he do with It?  Drop It on the ground?  Consume it?]

When questioned about the video showing the PM walking away without consuming the Host, Soudas replied: "He was holding a program in his hand and he went to put the program down and then consumed it." That took place, he said, after the camera stopped following the PM. 

Asked why the PM as a non-Catholic would receive Communion, which in Catholic teaching is reserved for Catholics and even only those Catholics who are properly disposed to receiving Communion, Soudas replied: "Who is the Prime Minister to judge once Communion has been offered to him?"

Soudas added, "It is a well known fact that he’s a Christian." Soudas then turned to the Prime Minister’s upcoming meeting with Pope Benedict XVI Saturday. "He’s very much looking forward to his audience with the Pope this Saturday," said Soudas. He would not state if the PM had any agenda for that meeting,  but did acknowledge that Mr. Harper would be accompanied by his wife and children. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

John L. Allen of NCR on the restructuring of the PCED

My friend the nearly ubiquitous John L. Allen, normally fair-minded former Rome correspondent for the dissenting National Catholic Reporter has an article on the restructuring of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei".

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

Pope removes officials seen as responsible for Holocaust-denying bishop row [I hope the editor gave the title to the piece, because this is unworthy of Mr. Allen’s high standards.]
By John L Allen Jr
Created Jul 08, 2009

Rome

In what could be seen ["could be" works, I am sure, for the editors and readers of the lefty-NCR, but it "shouldn’t be seen"…] as another piece of fallout from Benedict XVI’s January decision to lift the excommunications of four traditionalist bishops, including one who is a Holocaust denier, the pope today restructured the Vatican office that handles relations with the traditionalist world — and, in effect, gently fired the officials who presided over the earlier fiasco. 

[Stop the presses.  Let’s qualify a few things, such as "fiasco".  I agree that the way the Holy See handled news of the lifting of the excommunications was a "fiasco".  But the actual lifting thereof, despite the controversy, was not a "fiasco".  This was a necessary step for the project of securing ecclesial unity, something which even the NCR should want.  Also, no one was "fired", gently or otherwise.  Card. Castrillon turned 80 years old on 4 July.  At 80 it is usual that curial cardinals step down.  It was time anyway, and this was a perfect transition point.  Also, we don’t know that Msgr. Perl won’t be involved.  In any event, he came from the Cong. for Divine Worship with Card. Mayer, the PCED’s first President.  Moreover, the restructuring of the PCED was a necessary and logical next step in the project with the SSPX.  All officials of the Curia serve at the pleasure of the Holy Father.  Restructuring doesn’t equate with firing.  The change was not punitive, it was logical.]

As a result of a document issued by the Vatican today, titled Ecclesiae unitatem, Colombian Cardinal Dario Castrillon-Hoyos, who had served as President of the Ecclesia Dei Commission since 2000, and Italian Monsignor Camille Perl, the number two official at Ecclesia Dei, are both out of work.  [Again, Card. Castrillon turned 80 on 4 July and we don’t know where Msgr. Perl may go.  I suspect he will go back to the CDW.  Even so, Msgr. Perl isn’t a young man, and he has served in the Curia for a long time now.  Men do retire.] The Ecclesia Dei Commission was created by the late Pope John Paul II in 1988 to manage relations with the Society of St. Pius X founded by the late French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre.

Both men played key roles in the decision to lift the ecxcommunications, [sic] including that of Bishop Richard Williamson, the traditionalist prelate who denied in an interview with Swedish television that the Nazis had used gas chambers and that six million Jews had died in the Holocaust.  [This is the really important issue for NCR, not that of ecclesial unity or the Pope’s generosity.]

The so-called “Lefebvrites” rejected many of the reforms associated with the Second Vatican Council (1962-65). Most prominently, traditionalists clung to the pre-Vatican II Mass in Latin, [One tends to "cling" to what one loves and thinks important.] but many also have voiced objections to the council’s teachings on ecumenism, inter-faith dialogue and religious freedom.

In broad strokes, the restructuring announced today is seen by most observers as a sign that the Vatican intends to take a more careful, and perhaps a bit firmer, hand in its dealings with traditionalist Catholics.  [HUH?  Who are these "most observers"?  I don’t buy that at all, unless they are observers who don’t really understand what is going on.  "Bystanders", perhaps.  Most "observant observers" observe this as the next logical step in the ongoing process with the SSPX.]

Issued as a motu proprio, meaning an exercise of the pope’s personal authority under canon law, Ecclesiae unitatem brings the Ecclesia Dei Commission under the supervision of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican’s top doctrinal agency. That means ultimate responsibility for the church’s relationship with the traditionalists will belong to American Cardinal William Levada, prefect of the doctrinal congregation.  [No…. the ultimate responsibility is the Pope’s.  As the Pope has said again and again, he has the responsibility in the Church to foster the unity of Christians.]

The Vatican also announced today that the new head of the Ecclesia Dei Commission will be Italian Monsignor Guido Pozzo, 57, [About whom we wrote on 24 June] formerly an official in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and deputy secretary of the International Theological Commission, an advisory body to the doctrinal congregation. [Thus, a man well-positioned for the doctrinal discussion which the PCED will spearhead for the CDF.]

Levada released a statement today stipulating that as far as the Lefebvrite movement is concerned, “the doctrinal questions remain open. Until they’re clarified, Levada’s statement said, the ‘Society of St. Pius X’ cannot enjoy any canonical status within the church, and its ministers do not exercise in a legitimate way any ministry within the church.”  [Let’s not get too excited about that, as if it were a new "hard line" with the SSPX.  That statement from Card. Levada merely repeated what the Pope wrote in Ecclesiae unitatem.]

Although the Vatican issued a similar statement at the time of the controversy surrounding Williamson, today’s repetition from Levada [from the Pope] makes clear anew that the lifting of the excommunications in January does not mean that the Lefebvrite bishops are fully “rehabilitated.”  [Old news, but I guess it doesn’t hurt to repeat it.]

The Society of St. Pius X includes almost 500 priests worldwide, and claims to have a total following of roughly one million.

Castrillon-Hoyos, 80, who was once touted as a candidate to become pope, is widely seen as a doctrinal conservative who had hoped to engineer the full readmission of the traditionalist movement into the Catholic church. [Yes… that was his job description as President of the PCED.] When the controversy over Williamson erupted, many Catholic insiders [the same crowd as those bystanders, above?] pointed the finger of blame at Castrillon-Hoyos and his staff, suggesting that if anyone in the Vatican should have known William’s track record, it was the Ecclesia Dei Commission.  [Well… indeed they should have.  But the real problem was not the knowlege of the bizarre views of SSPXer Williamson.  Those views had nothing to do with the censure of excommunication.  That point should be made in this article, but it wasn’t.  The impression is being offered that the wierd views of Williamson were somehow relevant to the reason for the excommunication.]

In early February, the Vatican spokesperson, Jesuit Fr. Federico Lombardi, appeared to single out Castrillon for responsibility in an interview with the French daily La Croix, although Lombardi later said that Castrillion-Hoyos couldn’t be expected to know the thinking of everyone in the Lefebvrite movement. 

Today’s Vatican statement expressed Benedict XVI’s gratitude to Castrillon-Hoyos and Perl, as well as the pope’s “paternal solicitude” for the traditionalists, “with the aim of overcoming the difficulties that still remain in order to reach full communion with the church.”

This article was tendentious, I think.  Mr. Allen is a good journalist, and he has my continued good will and friendly admiration.  But this was a stumble.
 

Posted in Ecclesiae unitatem, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM, The Drill | Tagged , ,
40 Comments

QUAERITUR: words for the Precious Blood twice, none for the Body

From a reader:

This Sunday, … at the time of the Consecration, the priest accidentally used the words of consecration for the Cup both when he was holding the Cup and when he was holding the Host. He never said "This is my Body" but said "This is my Blood" twice. Was the Consecration valid? Was the Mass? I received Communion anyway, but wasn’t sure whether or not I was receiving the Real Presence. I thought about trying to attend a later Mass to make sure that I had fulfilled my obligation, but as this was the last Mass at that parish and I was unfamiliar with other churches in the area and didn’t have internet access during my vacation, I didn’t know of any later options. If I ever encounter this in the future (I hope not), what’s the right thing to do? Should I try to attend Mass again if possible, or was this Mass valid?

 

Well…

The priest did not consecrate the Body of Christ.  For there to be a Mass, in the strict sense, there must be the two-fold consecration of the Body and of the Blood of Christ.  It is precisely in the two-fold consecration that the "separation" of Christ’s Body and Blood take place in a sacramental way so that Mass is a Sacrifice.

Also, you may have received Communion with a Host that was consecrated at another Mass.

That said, yes… you fulfilled your Sunday obligation.  Whatever happened there happened through no fault of your own doing or negligence. Don’t worry about that.  And don’t worry about receiving at Communion time, either.  You don’t have to confess this or try to find another Mass.

These things happen from time to time.  We are humans, after all, we make mistakes.  Don’t fret in any way.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
44 Comments

A note bout PCED Sec. Msgr. Camille Perl

I implore you, fellow writers… if you are going to write about the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei and its Secretary Msgr. Camille Perl, get a fact straight.

The National Catholic Reporter, in its own "wishful thinking" article (which I will drill on later) called Msgr. Perl an Italian.

Robert Moynihan of Inside the Vatican identified Msgr. Perl as Belgian.

Folks… the long suffering and long serving Msgr. Camille Perl is from Luxembourg.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

The Next Logical Step: the Pont. Comm. “Ecclesia Dei” RESTRUCTURED

Because of the good progress of the last few years with the SSPX, His Holiness has now taken the next, logical step.

Pope Benedict has now implemented what he said he would do concerning the ad hoc Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei".  He has fused it into the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, making the Prefect of the CDF, ex officio, the Commission’s President and retaining the office of a Secretary and giving it also staff.

The Pope did this by means of a new Motu Proprio, Ecclesiae unitatem, signed on the anniversary of the establishment of the PCED in 1988. 

This was the next and logical step in a long process. 

Keep in mind that Cardinal Castrillon sent a letter to SSPX Bishop and Superior Bernard Fellay enumerating various point that the SSPX had to adhere to before any further dialogue could take place.  The SSPX effectively signed off on those points.  This signaled an attitude toward continuing dialogue. The next step could be taken. 

The Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum (which was right to issue regardless of the existence of the SSPX) was gesture of good will concerning a division over liturgy.  This was a relatively easy thing to do, despite the controversy, because it merely expanded the rights priests should have already clearly enjoyed. 

The Holy Father then did another relatively easy thing in lifting the excommunications incurred with the four SSPX bishops in accepting illicit consecration in 1988.  Censures are meant to remedy a problem.  The problem wasn’t being remedied.  It was clear that something else had to be done to remedy the situation.  Thus, despite the controversy, this was a relatively easy thing to do.

Once those relatively easy things were done, the really hard part begins.  The doctrinal discussions.  The Holy Father has now provided a structure in the Curia, in the proper dicastery, for those doctrinal discussion.

Keep in mind that no one in the Curia has a better handle on the issues surrounding the SSPX and their concerns than Joseph Ratzinger, now Benedict XVI.

Here is my fast translation of Ecclesiae unitatem, released in Latin and Italian only, with my emphases and comments.  I worked mainly from the Italian text, since surely that was the language of composition, checking against the Latin.  Thus, I included the papal "We" from the Latin (not the Italian) because … well… I like it.

Apostolic Letter
Ecclesiae Unitatem
of the Supreme Pontiff
Benedict XVI
given Motu Proprio

1.The task of guarding the unity of the Church, with the concern for offering to all the aids for responding in an opportune way to this vocation and divine grace, pertains in a particular way to the Successor of the Apostle Peter, who is the perpetual and visible principle and foundation of the unity both of Bishops and of the faithful[1]. The supreme and fundamental priority of the Church, in every age, of leading men towards an encounter with God must be promoted through the undertaking of attaining the common witness of faith of all Christians.

2. In adherence to this mandate, subsequent to the act by which Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, on 30 June 1988, illicitly conferred episcopal ordination on four priests, Pope John Paul II, of venerable memory, instituted, on 2 July 1988, the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei "with the task of collaborating with the bishops, with the dicasteries of the Roman Curia and with the circles concerned, in order to facilitate full ecclesial communion of priests, seminarians, communities or individual religious men and women until now in various ways connected to the Fraternity founded by [Archbp.] Lefebvre, who would wish to remain united to the Successor Peter in the Catholic Church, preserving their spiritual and liturgical traditions, in light of the Protocol signed on 5 May, last, by Cardinal Ratzinger and Mons. Lefebvre"[2]. [This was the Protocol which spoke of a canonical status for the SSPX and which said they could have a bishop.  That same night, Archbp. Lefevbre, for whatever reason, repudiated the Protocol and determined to consecrated bishops himself.  Pope Benedict is citing this old Protocol as a signal.  It is a reference to a moment when the Church and SSPX were very close to pulling the pieces together.]

3. In this way, adhering faithfully to the same task of serving the universal communion of the Church in her also visible expression and fulfilling every effort so that to all those who truly have the desire for unity it might be made possible to remain in it or to find it anew, We (Lat. voluimus) desired to widen and update, with the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, the general indications already contained in the Motu Proprio Ecclesia Dei concerning the possibility of using the Missale Romanum of 1962, through more precise and detailed norms[3].

4. In the same spirit and the same effort of fostering the overcoming of every break and division in the Church and to heal a wound felt in an ever more painful way in the ecclesial fabric, We desired to remit the excommunication of the four Bishops ordained illicitly by Mons. Lefebvre. With such a decision, We intended to take away an obstacle which could have jeopardized the opening of a door to dialogue and in this way invite the Bishops and the "Fraternity of Saint Pius X" to regain the path towards full communion with the Church. As We explained in the Letter to the Catholic Bishops of 10 March, last, the remission of the excommunication was a provision in the sphere of ecclesiastical discipline in order to free those persons from the burden of conscience represented by the gravest ecclesiastical censure.  But the doctrinal questions, obviously, remain and, so long they are not clarified, the Fraternity does not have a canonical statute in the Church, and its ministers cannot in a legitimate way exercise any ministry. [Again, the canonical status of the priests of the SSPX and the bishops has not changed.]

5. Precisely because the problems which must now be treated with the Fraternity are of an essentially doctrinal nature, We have decided – twenty-one years after the Motu Proprio Ecclesia Dei, and as We had planned to do[4] – to rethink the structure of the Commission Ecclesia Dei, joining it more closely with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

6. Consequently, the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei will have the following configuration:

    a) The President of the Commission is the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

    b) The Commission has its own staff structure, comprising a Secretary and Officials.

    c) It will be the task of the President, aided by the Secretary, to present the principle cases and questions of a doctrinal nature to the study and discernment of the ordinary instances of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, as well as to submit the results to the superior dispositions of the Supreme Pontiff.  [So… this seems to restrict the mandate of the PCED.  There will probably be some other document, probably not released to the public, which specifies the Commission’s mandate.]

7. With this decision, We have desired, in particular, to display our parternal solicitude to the "Fraternity of Saint Pius X" in order to regain full communion with the Church.  We address a pressing invitation to all to pray to the Lord without ceasing, through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary, "ut unum sint".

Given in Rome, at Saint Peter’s, on 2 July 2009, the fifth of Our Pontificate.

BENEDICTUS PP. XVI
__________________________
1. Cfr Conc. Oecum. Vat. II, Const. dogm. de Ecclesia, Lumen gentium, 23; Conc. Oecum. Vat. I, Const. dogm. de Ecclesia Christi Pastor aeternus, c. 3: DS 3060.

2. Ioannes Paulus II, Litt. ap. motu proprio datae Ecclesia Dei (2 Iulii 1988), n. 6: AAS 80 (1988), 1498.

3. Cfr Benedictus XVI, Litt. ap. motu proprio datae Summorum Pontificum (7 Iulii 2007): AAS 99 (2007), 777-781.

4. Cfr ibid. art. 11, 781.

Again… and this cannot be repeated often enough… this was the next logical step.

The PCED is now the the tip of the CDF’s spear for the doctrinal discussions with the SSPX. 

I suspect that because that in this new Motu Proprio the Holy Father was silent about the liturgical dimension of the work of the PCED, silent about its ability to reconcile individual priests and religious or resolve liturgial questions, the PCED may retain those functions for the time being.

Let us not forget that Summorum Pontificum states in its provisions that the PCED is the dicastery of competence in the Curia when there are problems in the implementation of its provisions.

I suspect that, in time, the liturgical dimension of the PCED’s work will be teased out of its mandate and given to the Congregation for Divine Worship.  Whether the reconciliation of priests and religious go to the respective dicasteries, I can’t guess at.  That is far more problematic.  In any event, the CDF is nearly always involved with those cases at some stage anyway.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , , ,
14 Comments

Fr. Z with Al Kresta today

FWIW… I should be on Al Kresta’s radio program today at 3:40 EDT.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

CNA: Maltese editor on Kmiec’s proposed ambassadorship: “somewhat of a poisoned chalice”

With my emphases and comments, this from CNA:

Maltese newspaper editor comments on Kmiec’s proposed ambassadorship

Valletta, Malta, Jul 8, 2009 / 12:14 am (CNA).- The editor of a Malta newspaper has commented on President Barack Obama’s choice of Prof. Doug Kmiec as ambassador to Malta, describing the appointment as “somewhat of a poisoned chalice” and noting the controversies concerning Kmiec and his campaign to elect Obama to the American presidency.  [And Kmiec is now an apparatchik whose paycheck will come from SecState Hilary Clinton.]

Noel Grima, editor of the Malta Independent Online, said that though Kmiec was a Catholic and a pro-life person he has “fallen foul” of some Catholic leaders for his public stances on abortion and other pro-life issues.

Noting Kmiec’s past as a law school dean, a law professor, and a member of the Reagan and George H.W. Bush presidential administrations, Grima then discussed Kmiec’s transformation into a supporter of President Barack Obama, an open proponent of abortion rights. [NB: "transformation"]

Kmiec had said he was convinced that then-Senator Obama wanted to alleviate social conditions that correlate with abortion. Though describing himself as a Republican and a Catholic who believes in traditional marriage and the beginning of life at conception, he said he believed as president Obama would respect and accommodate opposing points of view.

Grima noted that a priest denied communion to Kmiec at a Mass for a California chapter of Legatus, a Catholic businessman’s group. The priest was forced to apologize to Kmiec by Archbishop of Los Angeles Roger Cardinal Mahony. [Big surprise there.]

“The amount of hatemail and hate comments about him is simply unbelievable,” Grima wrote.  [So… a perfect choice to send as an ambassador.]

However, Kmiec has also become an ardent defender of the Obama administration.

Listing Kmiec’s defense of Obama’s embryonic stem cell policy, the president’s pro-abortion appointees, and his recent proposal to end state recognition of marriage, Grima also noted that the nominated ambassador has engaged in controversies with several Catholic prelates.

According to Grima, Kmiec has criticized Archbishops Raymond Burke and Charles Chaput and Bishop Joseph Naumann for saying Catholics who support abortion should be denied Communion. Kmiec has called this denial a form of “intimidation.”

Kmiec also labeled as “intrusive” Pope Benedict XVI’s comments to pro-abortion rights Nancy Pelosi, a Catholic and Speaker of the U.S. House. His defense of President Obama’s embryonic stem cell research policy also brought criticism from Cardinal Justin Rigali, chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Pro-Life Activities.

 

Remember that Kmiec will be a company man, a paid apparatchik of the Obama Administration sent to advance the Administrations agenda… with Malta.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
25 Comments