Have good news?

Give us all some of your good news!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
72 Comments

Check it out!

A great site I have in my RSS feed reader.

Check it out!

Posted in Just Too Cool |
3 Comments

QUAERITUR: a bunch of stuff

From a reader many questions.

General Tip: If you hope for a serious answer, send one question.  After that I start to lose attention and get silly.

Thanks you for your website.  It’s the third thing I read every evening.  You have been beaten out by NOAA Weather and Google News.

HUH?  You read the WEATHER before WDTPRS?  Didn’t the Lord say something about being able to read the weather?

A married man is being ordained to the Catholic priesthood in our diocese (Grand Island, Nebraska) who was an ordained minister in the Christian Church Disciples of Christ and has converted to Catholicism.  I thought that the pastoral provision that allowed married priests was only for Episcopalian priests who converted.  Our parish priest say that permission was granted by the Holy See.  Any idea what is going on here?

It is indeed possible for former clergy of other denominations may be ordained if they covert and they were previously married.   I am aware of a few instances of this.  It is rare, but sometimes the Holy See signs off on it, especially if they bring some of their flock along.

Recently, due to the swine flu scare, our bishop asked that communicants in our diocese receive the Eucharist on their hands (not on their tongues) and that the congregation not hold hands during the Lord’s Prayer.  It was mentioned at this time by our priest that the church actually prefers the hands upheld (orans position) form of prayer.  Though I was glad to hear the prohibition on hand holding, I thought that the orans position  was a priestly posture and its use by congregants contributed to the muddling of the distinction between the priesthood and the laity.  By the way, nothing was said about how to receive the Precious Blood and no change was made in the normal procedure regarding drinking from the chalice.

People can do what they want with their hands… welll… you know what I mean.  The point is that they are not to be instructed to hold hands or raise them, etc.
 

And finally, (I know I said a couple of question) what kind of camera do you have and what focal length lens do you use to get those close-up shots?

Lens?  I have just been sneaking up on them!  There are lens for this?!?

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Moscow …. wait for it… TLM…. !

Our friends at Rorate have the news… which I read twice to be sure…

The next ‘approved’ Traditional Latin Mass will be on May 31 (Pentecost), but usually it is offered every 1st Sunday of the month, at 1700 H (5:00 P.M.) in the basement chapel of the Cathedral (of the Immaculate Conception, Moscow).

The priest who offers the Mass is Fr. Augustyn Dziedziel SDB. Catholic guests of Moscow are most welcome. (Father also speaks some English in addition to Polish and Russian, so confessions are possible before Mass.)

 

I think Satan might particularly hate this one.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
26 Comments

Name that speaker!

What major public figure recently said this:

"At the heart of Paul’s effort in Athens was an appeal to reason. He did not seek to impose his beliefs, nor exploit anxiety or fear. Rather he had learned that his faith in Christ was compatible with the mind’s capacity for reasoned thought. Indeed it complemented it. Some today propose that faith and reason are crudely opposed, with the fervour of faith replacing good reason. This reduction of both faith and reason inhibits not only our search for truth but also the possibility of real dialogue. In contrast, as Pope John Paul memorably said: ‘Faith and reason are the two wings on which the human spirit soars.’ (Fides et Ratio n.1)

This dialogue needs to go beyond the superficial and the slogans. Respectful dialogue is crucial today and I salute all who seek to engage in it. In this the media have such an important part to play, not by accentuating difference and conflict, but by enhancing creative conversation. Let us be a society in which we genuinely listen to each other, in which sincere disagreement is not made out to be insult or harassment, in which reasoned principles are not construed as prejudice and in which we are prepared to attribute to each other the best and not the worst of motives."

 

If you already know for sure…  leave the fun to some others.

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
21 Comments

QUAERITUR: Ascension Thursday Sunday… what to do?

From a priest reader:

I am facing a dilemma.  I live in a part of the country which does not observe the Ascension in a biblical manner – that is, forty days after the resurrection.  Instead, we observe something that has come to be called "Ascension Thursday Sunday". 

My parish offers Mass in both ordinary and extraordinary forms (at least on Sunday). 

For this coming Sunday, am I to use the propers for the Sunday AFTER the Ascension or could I use the propers for Ascension (for the Mass in the Extraordinary Form)? 

I have consulted the Ordo (FSSP), which doesn’t foresee (or address) the dilemma, and it only gives the propers for the Sunday after the Ascension, with no mention of what might be done in my circumstances.  I would again be grateful for any help you can provide in this matter.

 

It seems to me that today is Ascension Thursday and that Sunday is the Sunday after Ascension.  The strange innovation of Ascension Thursday Sunday is not a feature of the older, traditional understanding of the liturgical year.

I would use the formulary for the Sunday after Ascension on the Sunday after Ascension.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
38 Comments

Weigel on L’Osservatore Romano’s “fideist credulity”

My friends – smart people – are angrily scratching their heads over the latest squishy musings in L’Osservatore Romano.

I have posted about this here and here.  In the second case, the editor, who is a fine fellow and doing a pretty good job making the paper into something other than fishwrap, really blew it. 

Here is a piece by George Weigel in National Review online with my emphases and comments.

Parsing the Vatican Newspaper
It doesn’t always speak for the pope.

May 21, 2009, 4:00 a.m.
By George Weigel

The newspaper published by the Vatican, L’Osservatore Romano, has created more than a little mischief recently, featuring essays by ill-informed European journalists who imagine that they understand American history, the American political scene, and the grave moral issues being contested in these United States. [This is a very good observation, and he leads with it.  Having spent a lot of time in Rome, having worked in the curia and lived with curial officials, and having never lived in the American ghetto in Rome, I can attest that most of the people there have their heads in very dark places when it comes to thinking about the USA.] Pro-administration American journalists and activists have leaped with barely concealed glee on several unfortunate articles in this genre, claiming that they demonstrate that “the Vatican” believes the U.S. Catholic bishops overreacted to Notre Dame’s award of an honorary doctorate of laws to President Obama, and that “the Vatican” is taking a wait-and-see, so-far-so-good attitude toward Obama after the horrors of the arch-demon Bush. [That is another piece: this is anti-Bush blow-back. No matter how inane it is, it is a constant in Euro-Think.]

About which, several points must be made.

1. The first thing one learns in Vaticanology 101 is that there is no such thing as “the Vatican.” The Holy See is as complex and confused a bureaucracy as one finds in national governments. Many points of view coexist within the Vatican walls, and there are more than a few curialists who like to talk to reporters. Very few if any of these chatty people count, in terms of expressing the settled judgment of the senior leadership of the Catholic Church. That leadership, when it wishes to make a serious point, does so through its major figures, not through the bureaucratic munchkins and [here it is] not via commissioned essays in a newspaper that, while published by the Holy See, is not taken all that seriously there. The last is a shame, for it suggests yet another facet of the Holy See’s communications problems; but it’s the truth, nonetheless. As for the teaching authority of the Catholic Church, what counts is what is said by the Bishop of Rome, who does not exercise his teaching office through some generic institution called “the Vatican” but in his own unmistakable voice. And he lets you know when he’s doing it. [So… "the Vatican" is not monolithic and L’OssRom is, well, not something to get too worked up about.]

2. In the normal course of events, L’Osservatore Romano does not speak authoritatively for the Church in matters of faith, morals, or public-policy judgment. The exceptions are when a senior churchman offers a commentary on a recent papal document (an encyclical, for instance), or on those exceedingly rare occasions when an editorial in the paper is followed by three dots, or periods, a traditional convention signaling that the opinion being expressed is from “high authority.” No knowledgeable or responsible analyst of Vatican affairs would regard commissioned essays in L’Osservatore Romano, even if they appear on page one, as somehow reflecting an authoritative view from the Holy See or the Pope. The same is true for statements by the paper’s editors or editorials without the dots. [True.  As I have pointed out in the past, unsigned editorials usually have more weight.  And there are some which have clues that they are even more weighty.]

In other words, without those dots, there is nothing here but opinion, to be weighed and judged as any opinion is weighed and judged — on its tether to facts and its argumentation. It is unfortunate that several recent pieces on the Obama administration in L’Osservatore Romano have been both factually questionable and analytically dubious. That is a problem for the senior officials of the Holy See to address, and they ought to address it soon. [D’ya think?  But don’t anyone hold his breath.] Any American commentator trying to spin these articles as a “Vatican” attempt to tell the bishops of the U.S. to “chill out” (as Time’s Amy Sullivan put it recently, in an article whose spin was similar to that of the Washington Post’s E. J. Dionne) is playing political games.

3. It is true, however, that the offices of the Holy See are replete with middle- and lower-level officials who are enamored of Barack Obama.  Why? In most cases, because they are Europeans who share the typical European Obamaphilia and whose sources of information and analysis are manifestly skewed. On the other hand, no one in a serious position of authority in the Vatican can doubt that the Obama administration poses the gravest challenges to the Holy See’s positions on the life issues since the Clinton administration tried and failed to get abortion-on-demand declared a fundamental international human right. The Obama administration will also be at loggerheads with the Holy See when the defense of marriage rightly understood is contested in international institutions.  [Anyone who thinks that Pope Benedict would be on board with Pres. Obama’s approach to abortion is living in a dream world.  The Pope, the Holy See, can perhaps agree or disagree with how best to ameliorate the many problems people face.  Differing approaches are possible.  But on the issue of the sanctity of life from conception to a natural dignified end, there can be no compromise.]

Moreover, several officials at very high levels — men I can say with confidence are not in conversation with E. J. Dionne, Amy Sullivan, or Obama administration fronts like Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good — spoke to me last fall of their deep appreciation for the Bush administration’s positions on the life issues, AIDS prevention in Africa, AIDS and malaria relief, and religious freedom. Indeed, one very senior official told me that, at his level, it was understood that no American administration of the immediate future was likely to be as supportive of Holy See positions as the Bush administration had been — and this, despite the obvious and serious disagreement over the administration’s 2003 decision to enforce the resolutions of the United Nations and depose Saddam Hussein by force.  [Again… it is possible to disgree over "what to do about Iraq".  And the CCC restates that civil authority determines if the conditions for a "just war" have been met.  But Catholics are not free to disagree about the sanctity of life.  That is why Notre Dame’s choice to honor the most aggressively pro-abortion President we have ever seen is seriously wrong.]

It would, of course, be helpful if the newspaper published by the Holy See did not display a sorry ignorance of recent American history (including the history of the civil-rights movement) and a fideist credulity about the magic of Barack Obama. [Great phrase, George…. "fideist credulity".] To assume that [and here is what I have been saying for weeks now…] the pope and his most senior advisers have drunk the Obama Kool-Aid and wish the American bishops would chill out is, however, another story altogether, and not a very credible one — no matter what foolishness finds its way into the pages of L’Osservatore Romano.  [Does anyone seriously believe that this Pope would see Pres. Obama’s position and actions on abortion as acceptable?]

—George Weigel is Distinguished Senior Fellow at Washington’s Ethics and Public Policy Center, where he holds the William E. Simon Chair in Catholic Studies.

 

Posted in The Drill |
45 Comments

Some PR advice for the Holy See

I think nearly everyone will agree that the Holy See needs a serious overhaul of its communications offices.

There is an article in Newsweek which addresses this issue.   You will disagree with some of the writer’s biases.  Move rapidly past those errors of judgment to what is of use in the article.

My emphases and comments.

Lisa Miller
How to Sell a Better Pope
Tips for the holy handlers

Published May 14, 2009
From the magazine issue dated May 25, 2009

I say this with respect: Pope Benedict XVI has a public-relations problem. You need only remember the 2000 visit of John Paul II to Jerusalem—which earned wall-to-wall cable coverage and produced the unforgettable image of the frail pope praying by the Western Wall—to know it’s true. Pope Benedict, by contrast, visited the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial last week and in so doing turned what should have been a moment of transcendent grief into a small international brouhaha because he did not refer to his own German past and appeared to some in the Israeli press to be insensitive to the fates of 6 million Jews. Otherwise, Benedict’s Holy Land visit was largely ignored by the U.S. media. Benedict makes international news only when he does something thoughtless (like "reconciling" with a Holocaust-denying bish-op) [Just move along… nothing to see here folks, move along…. ] or when he fumbles in public, as he did on the plane to Cameroon in March when he awkwardly noted that AIDS "cannot be overcome by the  distribution of prophylactics; on the contrary, they increase it." [Just keep reading…] This remark, though in keeping with his theology, reverberated in the media echo chamber for a week—overshadowing other stops that might have served him better, such as meeting with representatives of Cameroon’s Muslim community and a mass for as many as a million people in Angola. Benedict will never be John Paul, but why don’t he and his people do a better job—to be perfectly crass about it—marketing their message?  [The $64 question.]

Pope watchers answer this question in a number of ways. The pope is old, they say. [I don’t buy that.] "Imagine your grandfather or great-grandfather running a corporation," says James Martin, who works at the Jesuit magazine America. "He’s shy," offers George Weigel, the papal biographer who is also a newsweek contributor. [I don’t buy that.] "He also has a sense that the word of truth should have its own effect." [I the case of what Pope Benedict says and does, from his perspective, I think this is close to the target.] Weigel adds that Benedict’s predilection for scholarly introspection contributes to a management vacuum in which one department does not know what the other is doing; [I don’t think it is only introspection.  He has not chosen the best people to fill certain important positions.] this is exacerbated by the conviction within the Curia that "no news is good news." [Right.] Others criticize the Vatican itself, the structure of which is too entrenched and medieval to react to the realities of the 24-hour news cycle. (The Vatican Press Office closes for the day at 2:30.)  [This is definitely a problem.  A huge problem.]

These explanations may be true, but they’re insufficient. No one makes excuses for Rupert Murdoch because he’s 78. Benedict is the leader of a billion Roman Catholics. For two millennia the Catholic Church has arguably been the single most potent influence on Western culture. It has done great wrong, but it has also given us art and music, theology and philosophy, hospitals and universities, ethical approaches to some of the most complex social problems of our time. Why should a 21st-century pope not run a responsive and transparent communications operation? I asked a number of public-relations experts how they might advise the pope to improve his public image.

[Now we get to concrete ideas.] Get better handlers. This was the recommendation of Richard Wolff, a managing partner at Kreab Gavin Anderson consultants. "Maybe you need a broader and more effective surrogate structure when you have a leader who is less comfortable with the grand stage." Insiders say the head of the Vatican Press Office, a priest named Federico Lombardi, is both overworked (he also runs Vatican Radio) and too removed from the decision makers. Thus he can’t forestall crises—he can only mop up afterward. Rumors abound that Lombardi is about to be replaced; these he deflected in a recent interview with Zenit, a Catholic news service. "I have done this work with good will, and I will do it until they say otherwise," he said.  [This is an important point.  Fr. Lombardi could well have too much on his plate.  I think he also plays a role in the Jesuit curia, but I am not sure about that.  Any one of his roles would be more than a full-time job, frankly.  Who could humanly do that?]

Tell the story of the growing, vibrant global church. ["Tell the story"…] Susan King, who runs communications at the Carnegie Corporation, believes there’s a lot of good news to share: "Africa seems to me to be a story of the future, a story of tomorrow." Don’t make big international trips the occasion for intense cerebral debates, she says. "These are moments to celebrate … These are times to put into the public square the incredible values of the church."  [I can only go so far with that.  "Tell the story" is great advice.  However, I think there must be cerebral debate.]

Reposition the past. It’s hard to get beyond the "God’s Rottweiler" label, but Matthew Harrington, president of Edelman public relations, suggests that the Vatican talk up Benedict’s tenure as a professor at German universities during the 1960s. "He was known as this incredibly dynamic, vibrant, intellectual, open-minded individual." Harrington recommends that the pope convene "an Aspen Institute–like event," in which he shows his openness to opposing points of view.  [Sure!  Good idea.  Anyone who knew Joseph Ratzinger at all before his election know how profoundly stupid those mischaracterizations of him were.  It would be good for people to know who this Pope is.]

Be yourself. [That also means having cerebral debates, by the way…] Benedict got good reviews during his trip to New York City last year largely because he allowed the world to see his best side:  [his handlers allowed it… hey, wait!  There were Americans involved in that… hmmm….] gentle, compassionate and intellectually rigorous. He spoke about the sex-abuse crisis; he had a moving, unannounced meeting with some of the victims. "If people like you better, you can get a hell of a lot more done," [Amen.] says Howard Bragman, a Los Angeles publicist. [Here is what the secular types need to rememer… ] Obviously, being pope is not a popularity contest; Benedict has long seen his job as pastoring the global church, not pleasing the global media. But as recent months show, his indifference to his public image only hurts his cause.  [And that is what the ecclesiastical types need to understand.]

Miller is Newsweek’s Religion Editor.

Interesting points and helpful.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
27 Comments

QUAERITUR: priests extending hands at the time of ordination

From a priest reader:

Fr. Z,

Easter Greetings in the Lord.

I am writing with a question for you, or any other knowledgeable priest, to answer.

Last spring I attended two priestly ordinations.  The first was in the extraordinary form, the celebrant was Cardinal Hoyos, and the priests in attendance, after laying on of hands all congregated on one side of the sanctuary and extended the right hand during the consecratory prayer following the laying on of hands (we were vested in surplice and stole).

The second ordination was in the cathedral of my home diocese ….  It was, of course, in the ordinary form.  During this ordination, after the laying on of hands, the concelebrants similarly congregated in one area of the sanctuary, but during the consecratory prayer, the bishop was the only one who extended hands (in the "orans" position) while we (vested as concelebrants) stood with hands folded – NOT EXTENDED.  A priest acquaintance of mine, a member of the Institute of Christ the King (they who have taken to calling themselves "Canons"), was surprised that we were not extending hands during this moment of the ordination.

I subsequently asked the MC about it and he assured me that such is NOT done in the ordinary form.  For the life of me, I cannot remember what happened at my own ordination, but I am not satisfied with his assurance.

Could you shed some light on what ought to be done?

Timing is of the essence as we are on the cusp of our next priestly ordination.

My my!  It seems as if we have a bit of an emergency on our hands… so to speak!

Frankly, Father, I am not sure about this.  I have a clear recollection of extending my hand also during ordinary form ordinations to the priesthood as the bishop speaks the prayer.

As I am not at home at the time of this writing, and do not therefore have access to my liturgical books, I cannot advise.

Therefore, I call for the help of readers.  Anecdotes are great, but citations are what we really need.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
27 Comments

QUAERITUR: What do you mean by “liturgy” in need of “reform”?

From a reader:

On your take on notredame you kept refering to the "liturgy". In the present catholic church there are 2 different liturgies: the novus ordo and the tridentine. What liturgy are you refering to that needs reforming. The old latin mass doeesn’t need, never did. The novus ordo mass, is that the one that you refer to as needing reforming?

By "liturgy" I and most everyone else understands the rites of Holy Church public worship of God.

Holy Church has many more "liturgies" than two!  The Church has many liturgical Rites.  We must not think that we Latins, or Roman Catholics are alone in the unity of the Catholic Church.

The Church is always in need of reform, not because the divine dimension is in any way flawed or lacking but because we are.  Times and circumstances change and many aspects of the Church – including her worship – also must change.  An Ecumenical Council saw the need for a reform of the older form of the liturgy of the Latin Church.  So, the writer above is apparently wrong.  It did need reform.  Tragically, the reform the Council ordered is not the reform we got.  The Latin Church’s worship was changed by force artificially, creating a rupture.

Pope Benedict is trying to restart the organic development which liturgy requires, the slow discerning and changes which occur by a more natural process.

So… the Novus Ordo very definitely needs reforming… but reforming with an eye to the past, to our Tradition.

The older form of Mass will be reformed along the way as well.   That is what happens over time.

Some of the proponents of worship as "fly in amber" never-to-be-changed, will attempt to drag this entry into their "feverish swamp", as a friend JH recently described it. 

Therefore – some fair warning: My time is rather limited right now and I am also slightly annoyed by a bunch of things.  It will probably be easier for me simply to delete your comments and lock you out if you get weird or go all trad-postal.  And consider that I get to decide what that is, no matter if you think you are being reasonable.  o{]:¬)

This is a good topic to revisit once in a while, but I have no desire to revisit Fever Swamp, and neither do 99% of WDTPRSers.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , , , , ,
125 Comments