The deadly Robin!

The early bird gets the worm… right?

Birds get worms at other times… especially when there has been rain.

Here is a good example.

Behold. 

The alert and noble Robin.

Wary and cunning hunter.

The deadly Robin!

Robins don’t eat seeds.  They eat worms, soft fruit and berries.

They move along with great awareness of their surroundings.  They will at times make little dashes around the ground when they spot something likely. 

The deadly Robin!

AHA!  Preeeeeeey! 

The juicy EARTH WORM!

The deadly Robin!

He pulls the worm from the ground with a looooong pull and then cuts it up.

The deadly Robin!

Tossing it around helps to get it into position.

The deadly Robin!

Eventually…. SHHHLUCK… down it goes.

The deadly Robin!

And that’s how it is done.The deadly Robin!

The deadly Robin!

Posted in The Feeder Feed |
28 Comments

STUNNING DVD – The Monks of Le Barroux

The fine monks of Saint Mary Magdalene Monastery in Le Barroux, France are traditional Benedictines in full communion with the Holy See.

They have produced a video DVD on their way of life.  They sent me a copy.

UPDATED ORDER INFORMATION:  HERE.
Here is a PDF the monk sent me with order information in English.

If you are having a hard time figuring out how to order the DVD you can get help via e-mail by writing to Dom Edmund.  vpc [AT] barroux [DOT] org

I must share some of this with you.

First, here is a promo.

I have visited Le Barroux a couple times, though not for many years now.  

It is a truly beautiful place with an amazing Catholic identity. 

At this monastery, all the monks who are priests say Mass only in the older, traditional form.

Watch the video, above. 

Perhaps you might chime in here with comments about whether you might be interested in getting such a DVD. 

The monks contacted me about it and weren’t quite sure about what formats to produce it in.  This might depend on interest.  North America requires a different format, signal, etc., than Europe and the rest of the world.

To sweeten the deal… here are some images from the DVD

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

In the bonus section there are interviews and a great slide show.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

The audio of the DVD is French.

You may select the language for the subtitles.

ENGLISH
GERMAN
SPANISH
ITALIAN
FRENCH

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

The DVD follows the monastic day and shows some important events.

The shots of the Pontifical Mass for Pentecost and images of the acceptance and vesting of a novice are in themselves worthy to get the DVD.

Here are various screen-shots to give you a flavor.

I think you will enjoy what you see.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux    

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

The Rule of Benedict emphasizes both prayer and work, manual labor.

Ora et labora.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux
 
There are interviews.  The monks talk about their past lives, and the choice to embrace this life with its difficulties and joys.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux
 
STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux 

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux 

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux 

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

The monastery is in a truly beautiful location.

The building is both modern and ancient.  Newly constructed and yet centuries old.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

They work at all sorts of jobs.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

But all the work is also prayer.

Nothing, however, compares to the heart of the monastery.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

They wash the hands of visitors.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

Reading during silent meals, without meat.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

Back to work.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

They kiss the feet of novices.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

The whole community kisses the feet of novices….

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

There is recreation, especially the Sunday walk.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux 

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

Vespers comes.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

And Compline at the end of the monastic day.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

There is time to read and pray in…

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

There is a chapter at the end.

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

STUNNING DVD - The Monks of Le Barroux

You get the idea…..

Interested?

Let me know.

The monks will watch this entry for comments, I am sure.

I will let them know you are posting.
 

UPDATE 0709 GMT 10 May

One of the monks wrote to say:

Please note that this DVD has been published in the PAL format.

Check before ordering that your player is compatible.

PAL DVDs, including this one, can also be played on at least some American computers.    Again, check that you have this possibility.

UPDATED ORDER INFORMATION:  HERE.

The title is VEILLEURS DANS LA NUIT.

I can confirm that the DVD plays on my computer.  Again, though the audio of the DVD is French, you can choose various languages for subtitles as you please: English is available.

I can also play it on a DVD player I purchased which can play all regions all formats.   But it did not play on a regular American DVD player.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool, REVIEWS |
122 Comments

Lay ministers offering “blessings-in-lieu-of-Communion” at Mass – Nooooo…..

Prof. Ed Peters, canonist, has been put used his elucubrations to good effect.

He has provided his opinion on why lay ministers of Holy Communion should not attempt "blessings-in-lieu-of-Communion" during Mass.

Frankly, I don’t think the time of Holy Communion is the time for individual blessings.  That is not a hill I would die on, of course.  And if requested for a blessing I stop and give it.  But that is not the moment.

But Peters is dealing with the question of lay people, who should be attempting to do what priests properly do.

Here is a bit of his piece, which you should read at his place.  And tell him Fr. Z sent you!  o{]:¬)

Lay ministers of holy Communion should stop offering "blessings-in-lieu-of-Communion" at Mass

Concerns about swine flu have prompted many parishes to discontinue the routine administration of the Precious Blood. Okay, fine.* But there’s another Communion rite practice that should also cease if only out of concerns for public health. This time, however, it’s a practice that (unlike distribution from the Cup) is an abuse per se, namely, that of lay ministers of holy Communion purporting to confer "blessings-in-lieu-of-Communion" on every Tom, Pat, and Harriet who comes up in line.

Lay ministers of holy Communion (by definition, extraordinary ministers thereof), in response to people approaching them without the intention to receive Communion (maybe such folks are non-Catholics** or are Catholic kids prior to First Communion), currently do one of three things: they (1) speak and gesture a sign of the cross over such folks, [The usual] or (2) lay hands on such persons’ heads or shoulders while voicing a blessing, or (3) waive the Eucharist over them while purporting to confer a blessing. I think all three actions are liturgical abuses.

Let’s consider them in order of gravity:  [I will just include the usual one you see.  Read the others at Peters’ blog.]

…

3. Ministers of holy Communion have, I suggest, no authority by their office*** to confer any sort of blessing on anyone. Neither the General Instruction on the Roman Missal nor the Book of Blessings (which later source makes provisions for laity to administer certain blessings) authorizes ministers of Communion to confer blessings during Mass. Given that lay persons serving as extraordinary ministers of holy Communion have no liturgical duties besides the administration of Communion, the introduction of a mini-blessing rite to be performed by them seems to me a plain violation of Canon 846. This practice should, I think, be halted pending a study of its liceity by qualified persons and, if appropriate, its authorization by the competent authority (1983 CIC 838, 1167).

…

+ + +

…

*** Clergy enjoy a spiritual authority over their people, as do parents over their children. Such figures may and should extend blessings to their charges at appropriate times (1983 CIC 1167-1169). But what authority do extraordinary ministers of holy Communion have over the faithful? None. Who put extraordinary ministers of holy Communion in charge of anything besides distributing holy Communion? No one. Liturgical experts should explore whether the Communion procession ought to be allowed to morph into a "blessing procession" in the first place but, even if "blessings-in-lieu-of-Communion" during Mass are found licit, surely they should be conferred only by priests or deacons.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
86 Comments

The puzzling editorial in L’Osservatore Romano

A lot of people have written to me with links and asking me to comment on the signed editorial in L’Osservatore Romano on the first 100 days of the administration of President Obama.

Quite a few people are worked up about this.

I admit that it left me scratching my head.

But I have a couple observations.

First, and most importantly, in the world of L’Osservatore Romano a signed editorial like this has the least weight.  You might be able to say that an editorial signed by the actual editor might have more… but it wouldn’t be nearly as weighty as an unsigned editorial.

Second, I know the editor of L’Osservatore Romano a little.  He is trying to give the paper a new direction and role.  I think he is trying to bring in a few more voices here and there and open it to being also a journal of discussion, to engage the world.  To this end, he is bringing pieces from various writers, including non-Catholics. 

Fiorentino is a staffer of L’OR and it might have sounded like an official position of the paper, but it wasn’t.  I would not be in the least surprised it some of the Euro-progressivists in the Secretariat of State weren’t in favor of this editorial, but it wasn’t unsigned.

Also, a spy tells me that the scholars of the Pontifical Academy for life were rather miffed about this.

Also, a friend noted:

Read the recent address of Mary Ann Glendon to the Holy Father (and the Pope’s speech to the Academy).  You can tell what she is alluding to. Michael Schooyans’ lecture for the plenary session was dedicated to Obama’s messianism and was NOT laudatory.  Fiorentino’s article was not bereft of good points and observations.  But the general sense of it was totally off base. The author seems to believe his own spin on reality. He totally ignores important facts of the ideology at work with Obama’s administration and covers it with the fig leaf of "moderation".  The adminstration only shows moderation when it is forced on them by the system and the vocal – unexpected – opposition of so many bishops and believers, Catholic and non-Catholic alike. I wonder if Fiorentino knows anything of the debate in the U.S. hierarchy  (and the U.S. at large) aside from what he reads in the headlines of La Repubblica.

You might want also to read this piece on Lifesite, paying attention to my friend Msgr. Barreiro’s comments on Ostpolitik.

Today I made a reference to Ostpolitik in my examination of the slimy editorial in America.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

America Magazine… climbing the invisibile ladder

When you see a person drowning, you will note common traits during their panic.  Sometimes they seem to be trying to climb an invisible ladder.  Their arms flail and their head is pushed lower into the water. 

It is a sad and horrible sight.

In the Jesuit run America Magazine there is an editorial: 

Before you read, consider this:

sec⋅tar⋅i⋅an
   
–adjective
1.     of or pertaining to sectaries or sects.
2.     narrowly confined or devoted to a particular sect.
3.     narrowly confined or limited in interest, purpose, scope, etc.
–noun
4.     a member of a sect.
5.     a bigoted or narrow-minded adherent of a sect.

Now for the editorial with my emphases and comments.

Sectarian Catholicism
The editors  MAY 11, 2009

 The clouds roll with thunder, the House of the Lord shall be built throughout the earth, and these frogs sit in their marsh and croak—‘We are the only Christians!’” So wrote St. Augustine about the Donatists, a perfectionist North African sect that attempted to keep the church free of contamination by having no truck with Roman officialdom. In the United States today, self-appointed watchdogs of orthodoxy, like Randall Terry [I was pretty disappointed in what he did with the Archbp. Burke interview.] and the Cardinal Newman Society, [Note how they lump them in with Terry, as if they were even remotely similar?] push mightily for a pure church quite unlike the mixed community of saints and sinners—the Catholic Church—that Augustine championed.  [This is slithery.  Augustine did not "champion" a Church mixed with saints and sinners.  He described the reality of the Church in those terms.] Like the Circumcellions of old, they thrive on slash-and-burn tactics; ["Slash and burn"…. riiiight.  An online petition, letter writing campaign, praying the Rosary, peaceful protests.  I suppose Martin Luther King and Gandhi were slashers and burners too.  This hyperbole is a perfect example of how the editors of America are failing around in the water as they drown.] and they refuse to allow the church to be contaminated by contact with certain politicians.  [The editors just called those who have uphold the right to be born "terrorists".  Circumcelliones (derived from circum cellas) were late 4th and early 5th century N. African extremists who lurked with clubs in gangs about the tombs or shrines of martyrs.  They would attack Catholics and those who left Donatism for Catholicism.  People were terrified of them. They were associated in respects with the Donatists, but this wasn’t a wholly Donatist movement.  What is worse, however, is the attempt to present Augustine as a defender of error.  Augustine extends toleration to sinners but not to sin. Augustine’s use of the biblical image of wheat and tares was his way of defending toleration of sinners in the Church but not of sin.]

For today’s sectarians, [Watch what happens…] it is not adherence to the church’s doctrine on the evil of abortion that counts for orthodoxy, [The writer has claimed to be the proper interpreter of the Church’s teaching.  He now goes on to politicize the issue.  The editor of America will try to persuade you that those who oppose pro-abortion Catholics are doing so from political motives rather than doctrinal.  They have already called them terrorists.] but adherence to a particular political program and fierce opposition to any proposal short of that program. They scorn Augustine’s inclusive, forgiving, big-church Catholics, who will not know which of them belongs to the City of God until God himself separates the tares from the wheat. Their tactics, and their attitudes, threaten the unity of the Catholic Church in the United States, the effectiveness of its mission and the credibility of its pro-life activities.  [I think the real object of their attack is the group of American Bishops who have made public statements of opposition to Notre Dame.  They want people who think that it is wrong to bestow an honor upon a pro-abortion President at a Catholic school simply to shut up.  Otherwise they are terrorists.   Hey wait….  I love the way the left cites Augustine when convenient.  Remember how Speaker Pelosi and then Sen. Biden tried to cite Augustine in favor of their pro-abortion stance?  Liberals have discovered Augustine!  Perhas should read him.   Start with City of God V, 26.  Augustine applauds Ambrose for denying Holy Communion to the Emperor Theodosius.  And Augustine himself tells us that he denied Communion to more than one member of his congregation.  Slash and burn, right?  If you are going to refer to Augustine, refer to all of Augustine.  I think that America chose to cite Augustine because the POPE cites Augustine so often.  That would be a typical move by a post-modern Jesuit.]

The sectarians’ [So… people who oppose the America/Kmiec/Obama/Reese/DNC agenda are "sectarians".] targets are frequently Catholic universities and Catholic intellectuals who defend the richer, subtly nuanced, broad-tent Catholic tradition. [Those who oppose them are stupid bigots.] Their most recent target has been the University of Notre Dame and its president, John Jenkins, C.S.C., who has invited President Barack Obama to offer the commencement address and receive an honorary degree at this year’s graduation. Pope Benedict XVI has modeled a different attitude [Nice buzzzz language … "modeled an attitude".  What America is doing, however, is remodeling Pope Benedict into Fr. Hesburgh.] toward higher education. In 2008, the pope himself was prevented from speaking at Rome’s La Sapienza University by the intense opposition of some doctrinaire scientists. The Vatican later released his speech, in which he argued that “freedom from ecclesiastical and political authorities” is essential to the university’s “special role” in society. He asked, “What does the pope have to do or say to a university?” And he answered, “He certainly should not try to impose in an authoritarian manner his faith on others.”  [Problem.  La Sapienza is not a Catholic University.  The analogy doesn’t stand up under scrutiny.  In the one case, a Catholic leader was invited by a civil university to engage in dialogue.  On the other, a civil leader was invited by a Catholic university to receive a distinctive honor.]

The divisive effects of the new American sectarians have not escaped the notice of the Vatican. [I should think not.  Nor has this sort of editorial.  Right, Fr. Reese?] Their highly partisan political edge  [Again, they are trying to say that people who are resisting the reduction of abortion to merely one of many social issues are doing so for political reasons.] has become a matter of concern. That they never demonstrate the same high dudgeon at the compromises, unfulfilled promises and policy disagreements with Republican politicians as with Democratic ones is plain for all to see. It is time to call this one-sided denunciation by its proper name: political partisanship. [The writer is right… but he should look in the mirror.]

Pope Benedict XVI has also modeled a different stance toward independent-minded politicians.  [Okay… so this is the sort of "nuance" they hold up as an ideal.  Speaker Pelosi, Sens. Kennedy and Kerry are "independent-minded".] He has twice reached out to President Obama and offered to build on the common ground of shared values. [This is weasel language.  Just what is it that Pope Benedict is eager to accomplish with the Obama Administration?  Also, what do they mean by "reached out".  The Pope sent a congratulatory telegram to the President for his election.  Is that reaching out?  Ridiculous.  He would do that for any president.] Even after the partially bungled visit [This is supposed to be a little handful of dirt.  But what is really going on here?  I have an acquaintance who was at that same audience.  He got the CTV DVD because he had a chance to speak with the Pope afterward.  He reports that even in paning the crowd of dignitaries present, there was no film of Speaker Pelosi.  If it was "bungled", it wasn’t "bungled" by the Holy See.  She met the Pope and the Pope told her off.  There is not a single photo of them that she could use as false propaganda or claim his approval because they met.] of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi with Pope Benedict, Vatican officials worked quickly to repair communication with her. [Oh?  How was that?] Furthermore, in participating in the international honors accorded New Mexico’s Governor Bill Richardson in Rome last month for outlawing the death penalty (See Signs of the Times, 5/4), Pope Benedict did not flinch at appearing with a politician who does not agree fully with the church’s policy positions. [Did the Pope give him an honor?  Popes regularly during Wednesday audiences spend a minute with public personages on the other side of a barrier.] When challenged about the governor’s imperfect pro-life credentials, Archbishop Michael Sheehan of Santa Fe responded on point, “We were able to help him understand our position on the death penalty…. One thing at a time.” Finally, last March the pro-choice French president Nicolas Sarkozy was made an honorary canon of the Basilica of St. John Lateran, the pope’s own cathedral.  [Again… this is not useful for defending what ND has done with Pres. Obama.  The French head-of-state has had a right to be a canon of the Lateran since the 16th c.  What’s happening at ND is entirely different.]

[Here is what thinkers of America consider necessary…]

Four steps are necessary for the U.S. church to escape the strengthening riptide of sectarian conflict and re-establish trust between universities and the hierarchy. [In other words, head off the possibility that Ex corde Ecclesiae might be implemented.   Wait a minute.  Doesn’t Ex corde Ecclesiae say that the local bishop monitor the local Catholic colleges and universities?  That sounds like one of the cherished liberal principles of subsidiarity.  They ought to be able to act without interference from, for example, the Vatican!] First, the bishops’ discipline about speakers and awards at Catholic institutions should be narrowed to exclude from platforms and awards only those Catholics who explicitly oppose formal Catholic teaching. [In other words it is okay to honor non-Catholic pro-abortion figures.  Remember people like Pelosi and VP Biden etc. said that, though they may be Catholic, they can’t impose their views on the rest of the country.  This point reflects that attitude.  It is little more than an echo of the schooling of Drinan, Cuomo, etc.] Second, in politics we must reaffirm the distinction between the authoritative teaching of moral principles and legitimate prudential differences in applying principles to public life. [Fine!  On the surface this is good and everyone will agree.. so long as there are basic principles.  People can disagree about how to deal with poverty, or immigration, or hunger or third world debt, etc.  But there are some things which the Church has made clear are not matters of compromise. ]  Third, all sides should return to the teaching of the Second Vatican Council [Oh… this is really slimy.  In other words… if you are one of these sectarians who don’t think that abortion can be pushed under the carpet, then you are against the Second Vatican Council, which by the way, explicitly condemns abortion.] and Pope Paul VI that in politics there are usually several ways to attain the same goals. [Just as John Paul II showed when he abandoned Paul’s VI’s Ostpolitik!] Finally, church leaders must promote the primacy of charity among Catholics who advocate different political options. For as the council declared, “The bonds which unite the faithful are mightier than anything which divides them” (“Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World,” No. 92).  [Stop.  Charity is based on truth.  There are limits to charity.  One cannot in true charity pass over a moral evil.  No one today would appeal to charity as a reason for excusing support of the Hitler regime by German Catholics.  What editor of America is really saying is that Catholics ought to be able to believe anything and their opponents should just shut up.  This what Pope Benedict meant by the dictatorship of relativism.]

There is so much wrong with this piece that we could nearly go line by line.

But let’s refocus on a couple of things you must take away from this dreadful editorial.

The most important is that this is the panic of someone who drowning.  Go back and read it again: you can nearly see the arms flailing… hear the gurgling, gulping.  

They are trying to climb the invisible ladder.

Now dig into one of America‘s objectives.

They say that the Pope has reached out to the President.

The Pope sent a telegram of congratulations for the election, etc.  That is reaching out.  They are hinting that it might even be seen as a subtle approval of President Obama’s policies, at least in the nuanced way America and Kmiec Catholics see social issues.  

In any event, we can stipulate that Pope Benedict is reaching out. 

That is what Popes do
.

Pope John Paul II met with Yassir Arafat and Fidel Castro. 

Paul VI met with Idi Amin Dada.

What America is trying to do is draw a parallel between a Pope reaching out to a world leader at odds with the Catholic Church and what is happening at Notre Dame.

That doesn’t work.

If you want to try to make an analogy out of this, then we have to look at what Notre Dame ought to have done, not what they actually did.

It is acceptable for a Catholic University to reach out and invite President Obama to speak at some function. 

It is not acceptable to bestow a prestigious honor on him. 

Final thoughts.

When the Prefect of the Apostolic Signatura comes to Washington, DC and delivers a crystal clear manifesto which entirely guts the America/Kmeic/Pelosi/Biden stance, don’t think he doesn’t have the blessing of the Holy Father.

Will that fact may be lost on the editors of America?

Lastly, America doesn’t like that American bishops are criticizing Notre Dame.  They want someone put that to a stop.

"But Father! But Father!", you are by now saying.  "Go above the heads of the bishops?  Above the head of the metropolitan?  Above the conference?  They want bishops to be corrected?  What happened to subsidiarity?  The primacy of the local Church?  Isn’t it a cherished liberal principle that bishops should not be interfered with by the Vatican?"

Strangely America seems only to promote subsidiarity when it suits them.

Why let principle get in the way of partisanship?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
42 Comments

Nutty attacks on Pope Benedict… hysteria

From Newsmax with my emphases and comments.

Obama Adviser: Catholic Church Insulting Jesus

Friday, May 8, 2009 3:06 PM

By: Rick Pedraza

 Harry Knox, an adviser to President Barack Obama’s Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships, accuses Pope Benedict XVI of "insulting Jesus" in statements about condom use.

Knox, a homosexual-rights activist and director of the Human Rights Campaign’s Religion and Faith Program, says the leader of the Roman Catholic Church is “hurting people in the name of Jesus” and sending the message that “violence and human rights abuses against LGBT people are acceptable.”  [Read: Catholic teaching is violence.]

Knox posted his remarks on the Human Rights Campaign’s Web site, which the group says was created to “call out those who maliciously use lies and misinformation to interfere with the [lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender] community’s path to equality.”

Knox published a statement on the Web site in March accusing Pope Benedict of “morally reprehensible” behavior in spreading “blatant falsehoods,” according to CNS News.

“The Pope’s statement that condoms don’t help control the spread of HIV, but rather condoms increase infection rates, is hurting people in the name of Jesus,” Knox later told the Associated Press.

“On a continent where millions of people are infected with HIV [Africa], it is morally reprehensible to spread such blatant falsehoods,” he said.

“The Pope’s rejection of scientifically proven prevention methods is forcing Catholics in Africa to choose between their faith and the health of their entire community. Jesus was about helping the marginalized and downtrodden, not harming them further.”  [This guy sounds like a hysterical and hateful loon.]

Knox’s criticism of the Pope is nothing new. In April 2007, he accused the Catholic Church of behavior that was “immoral and insulting to Jesus,” saying the Church’s positions include “spiritual and emotional violence.”  [Is this man actually considered useful in the present Administration?]

In December, Knox and the Human Rights Campaign criticized the Church for not signing on to a United Nations resolution that called for decriminalizing homosexuality and equating all sexual orientations. [Right.. the Catholic Church is going to do that.]

“As faith leaders, we were shocked by Vatican opposition to this proposed initiative,” Knox says on the campaign’s Web site.  [These people use use such over the top language actually are useful to those who also have agendas.]

“By refusing to sign a basic statement opposing inhumane treatment of LGBT people, the Vatican is sending a message that violence and human rights abuses against LGBT people are acceptable. Most Catholics, [For people like this polls matter more than truth.] and indeed most Catholic teachings, tell us that all people are entitled to live with basic human dignity without the threat of violence. [Except for those teachings that say that homosexuals actsacts are evil.  The Church doesn’t say that the people are evil.  It teaches that the are.] The Catholics we know believe that Scripture asks us to be our brother and our sister’s keeper. [And what does Scripture say about homosexuality?  I think they should show some appreciation for the Church’s clearly compassionate teaching!] Many are speaking out against this immoral stance in the name of religion,” he Web statement says.  [Nutty stuff.]

White House spokeswoman Jen Psaki declined to comment on whether Obama agrees with Knox’s statements that the Pope is a “discredited leader” or whether Knox should apologize.  [Of course.  But… the silence means something.]

At a news conference Wednesday, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D.-Calif., said she was unaware that Knox refers to the Pope as a “discredited leader.”

“I’m so sorry. I’m just totally unaware of that statement,” Pelosi told CNS News.

“I really don’t know about that. But certainly, His Holiness is the head of an organization [Remember… Speaker Pelosi is a "devout Catholic"… er um… devout member of an organization…] that has done more to alleviate poverty, eradicate disease, and is now addressing climate change issue [ROFL!] and the rest. I am just not familiar with the statement and the circumstance.”

 

This is like something straight out of a Michael O’Brien book!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Nutty attacks on Pope Benedict… hysteria

Star Trek

I went to see the new Star Trek movie yesterday afternoon.

It was rollicking good fun with lots of foreshadowing insider jokes and a few surprises.

Since this is a reimagining of Star Trek for the 21st century they did a few things that I found… well… strange.

I am going to leave the combox open… but please note that there may be SPOLIERS.

So… I will make this clear. 

THERE MAY BE SPOILERS in the comments.

Again…, if you don’t want to have the movie’s surprises SPOILED for you, then DON’T READ THE COMMENTS.

Clear enough?

First piece of advice for the movie…. don’t sit too close.  I recommend that you watch this one farther back in the theatre.

Be a good Catholic… come early and get a seat in back.

Finally… yes, we all know that Star Trek started off with an atheistic foundation.  Ho hum… blah blah… spare us.  WE KNOW.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
69 Comments

9 May: St. Isaiah, prophet

Many people don’t realize that Holy Church considers some Old Testament figures to be saints with their own feast days.   We don’t celebrate them at the altar, but they have a day.

Actually, if there were no other saint in the liturgical calendar taking precedence, we are told that we indeed could take a saint from the Martyrology.  But I digress.

Today is the commemoration of the 8th c. St. Isaiah, the prophet of the Old Testament.

The Martyrologium Romanum has an entry for him.

1. Commemoratio sancti Isaiae, prophetae, qui, in diebus Oziae, Iotham, Achaz et Ezechiae, regum Iudae, missus est ut populo infideli et peccatori Dominum fidelem et salvatorem revelaret, ad implementum promissionis David a Deo iuratae. Apud Iudaeos sub Manasse rege martyr occubuisse traditur. … The commemoration of saint Isaiah, the prophet, who, in the days of Ozias, Jotham, Achaz and Ezechias, kings of Judah, was sent in order to reveal to the unfaithful and sinful People the faithful Lord, the Savior, for the fulfillment of the promise made by God to David.  It is said that he sank into death among the Jews under King Manasse.

Posted in Saints: Stories & Symbols |
13 Comments

Bishops disciplining “visitors” from other dioceses

[uc]

I am reposting this after having deleted ALL the comments.

____________

We have heard from time to time that the ordinary of one diocese will not discipline (e.g., deny Holy Communion) to publicly prominent pro-abortion Catholics if they are there in that diocese as visitors.

Canonist Ed Peters has an interesting entry at his excellent blog In The Light Of The Law.  Here are excerpt with my emphases.  Read the whole entry there.

A response to Abp. Wuerl’s claims that canon law supports his inaction in regard to Nancy Pelosi

Abp. Donald Wuerl of Washington DC continues to defend his refusal to withhold holy Communion from Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi in a number of ways, but his recent claims that canon law supports his inaction attract my attention. I think the prelate’s canonical claims are wrong.

First, Wuerl claims that "there’s a question about whether [Canon 915] was ever intended to be used to bring politicians to heel . . . I stand with the great majority of American bishops and bishops around the world in saying this canon was never intended to be used this way.”

…

Are Catholic politicians not bound by, say, the canons on the Sunday obligation (cc. 1246-1248) or the laws of fast and abstinence (c. 1252)? Are they exempt from the canons on marriage (c. 1108) or from the duty to educate their children in the Catholic faith (cc. 1136, 1366)? Do Catholic politicians (of all people!) not have the responsibility "to imbue and perfect the order of temporal affairs with the spirit of the Gospel and thus give witness to Christ" (c. 225)?

If, as I feel sure, Wuerl would not regard Catholic politicians as exempt from any of these canonical requirements, where does he find an exemption for them (or for anyone else) from Canon 915? The answer is, he cannot: there simply is no "politician" exemption from Canon 915.

If Wuerl wants to argue that Pelosi has not acted in a way as to make herself liable to consequences under Canon 915, he’s free to make his case. (I think he’d lose that argument, but he’s free to make it.) But he cannot gratuitously assert that Canon 915 was never "intended" to apply to the Pelosis of this world and leave the matter thus. Canon 915 unquestionably applies to all Roman Catholics regardless of their civil status or secular profession.

Second, [… and this is something I have wondered about…] Wuerl asserts, "Pelosi, as a San Franciscan, isn’t part of my flock!"

Wuerl is the chief shepherd over the territory assigned to him (cc. 369, 372, 381) and chief presider over the Eucharist celebrated therein (c. 835 and Catechism of the Catholic Church 1142, 1369, 1561). Canons on sacramental discipline are universally applicable to Roman Catholics (cc. 12, 915). None of these norms is thwarted by the fact that a specific member of the faithful might have a "foreign" domicile, quasi-domicile, or residence if that individual is acting within the territory of the arch/bishop.

Consider moreover, by way of analogy, that if Pelosi’s actions in Washington were canonically criminal (that is not my claim here), Canon 1412 would authorize Wuerl to take penal action against her regardless of her "foreign" status. Now, if Wuerl is authorized to take the harsher route of penal action against someone based only on the fact that his or her actions occurred within his territory, it is difficult to see how he is suddenly forbidden from taking merely disciplinary action against anyone who is acting contrary to sacramental law in his territory.

There is, I conclude, simply no question but that an arch/bishop is authorized by canon law to take the steps necessary to protect the sacraments (especially the Eucharist, cc. 897-898) from unworthy administration in his territory and his people from the danger of scandal that might be given by such reception.

The only question I see here is whether, and if so when, Wuerl will take that action. +++

A final note: The ultimate solution to this problem is, of course, for Nancy Pelosi to give up her unrelenting campaign against unborn babies, or, in default of that, at least to refrain from approaching holy Communion (c. 916). Unless she takes either step, however, I see no choice for Abp. Wuerl but to order enforcement of Canon 915 against her. In the meantime, however, I must say, nothing gives the forces of darkness greater pleasure than to see those committed following Christ at serious odds with one another. Such disputes must, in a fallen world, arise, but we should strive to resolve them correctly as quickly as possible and, once settled, to go on more united than ever toward the next struggle. There is no place for brooding over one another’s failures, or for gloating over one another’s corrections.

I always enjoy reading Prof. Peter’s comments.

I have a question for him and other canonists…. I am not talking about the peanut-gallery, but real, working canonists.

If a person spends the majority of his time in a place, at what point does he become a subject of the local bishop?

There are different levels of domicile. A congressman/woman spends a large number of the days of the year in Washington DC or living in a nearby diocese such as Arlington.

So?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Get yourselves ready

A horde of opposition will now align itself in real fury against Archbishop Burke.

If I were you, I would really get familiar, if you weren’t before, with the issues and the arguments.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments