Anti-Catholic Catholics attacking the Pope – useful tools

Newsweek posted an op-ed of anti-Catholic religious bigotry on the Guest Spot of "On Faith" written by Robert S. McElvaine, a professor at Millsaps College, associated with the United Methodist Church.

Arter reading this, ou will probably agree that this man’s pastor should deny him Holy Communion until he issued a public statement of apology. 

My emphases and comments.

Impeach the Pope 

By Robert S. McElvaine
Professor of Arts & Letters, Millsaps College

Enough! No–Too much!

Amid all the justified outrage we all feel at Bernie Madoff and the AIG bandits, let us save some intense outrage for Pope Benedict XVI.  [If the writer thinks there is any moral equivalent here, it would be legitimate to ask how he got a doctorate.]

After insulting Muslims by declaring in 2006 that Muhammad had brought "things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached," [Pope Benedict didn’t declare this.  It was a quote of someone else in his Regensburg Address.] after reiterating (through the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith) in 2008 that the subject of the ordination of women is not even open for discussion and declaring that anyone involved with the ordination of women will be automatically excommunicated, [So the Catholic Church doesn’t get to say what the Catholic Church believes?] after lifting in January of this year the excommunication of Holocaust-denier Richard Williamson, [Irresponsibly obtuse: that is not why the excommunication was liften.  And this is a professor writing this.  Tisk.] now Benedict XVI opens a visit to Africa by telling the people of a continent decimated by AIDS that the distribution of condoms "increases the problem" of the spread of AIDS.  [But… it does.]

I am a Catholic [?!] and the idea that such a man is God’s spokesperson on earth is absurd to me.  [This is a Catholic… talking in this manner… in public… in print… about the Pope.]

There are, of course, no provisions in the hierarchical institution set up, not by Jesus but by men who hijacked his name and in many cases perverted his teachings, for impeaching a pope and removing him from office. But there ought to be.  [insert your chosen invective here]

As I detail in my latest book, [Ahhhhh!  NOW we get to what this is a about.  It isn’t about Pope Benedict at all.  This is all about talking about himself and his book!  I am reminded of the false outrage some congressmen display during hearing when they know the cameras are on.] "Grand Theft Jesus: The Hijacking of Religion in America" (Crown), the cardinal sin of the Catholic Church — a literally deadly sin, if ever there was one — is its opposition to birth control. [So, he as called the Church sinful.  And he dissents from Catholic teaching on birth control.] Far from being, as the Church contends, part of its moral doctrine, this policy [Policies can be changed right?  That is why he weasles his way into this language.] is, plainly, the immoral doctrine of the Church. The use of condoms is a pro-life position.  [uh huh]

Why does the Church persist in such a manifestly immoral doctrine? [Now he is starting to sound like a kook.] One suspects that it must be the usual twisted thinking about sex and women. The Church’s opposition to birth control is largely an outgrowth of its all-male composition and those males’ attempts to degrade women’s physical powers  [not just kooky, but maybe not very up to date on what the Church has been teaching for decades]  by asserting that women and the intercourse into which they supposedly tempt men are necessary evils ("It is well for a man not to touch a woman," Paul instructed the Christians of Corinth), the only purpose of which is procreation.

Misogyny may not be "the Church’s one foundation," but it is a major part of the base on which it was constructed.  [Not just kooky, but a also little thick.]

It should be obvious that the sin in an over-populated world [HUH?  He is also a zero-sum disciple of Erlich too?  I wonder if he is a Malthusian or, perhaps, in favor of eugenics.] is not attempting to control birth, but attempting to control birth control.

And now for the pope to go so far as to indicate that condom use worsens the spread of AIDS [Umm… it does.] — there’s an outrage that tops Madoff and AIG! 

Let’s start a movement within the Catholic Church to impeach Pope Benedict XVI and remove him from office. While we’re at it, let’s replace him with a woman.  [Thus confirming the thick element mentioned above.]

He reversed the excommunication of a Holocaust denier. Will he excommunicate me for pointing out that he is a misogyny denier?  [No… worse!  He won’t buy your stupid book, which is really what this is a about, isn’t it.]

If this be heresy, make the most of it.

Robert S. McElvaine is Elizabeth Chisholm Professor of Arts & Letters at Millsaps College. His latest book is Grand Theft Jesus: The Hijacking of Religion in America (Crown).

 

Guys like this are really just flapping their arms around so that you will notice them and maybe.. just maybe… a few people out there will buy their books. 

There is no real need to get overly excited about this fellow.  This is simply a useful exercise in what we are going to be seeing a great deal more of in the next couple years.

Satan has the crowbar in right now and he’s prying hard. 

Progressivists, most of whom don’t a clue what they are talking about but excel at puffing up in indignation about things they label "not fair", will in the manner of Lenin’s useful idiots broaden more and more the scope of the last acceptable social prejudice. 

They will make the true anti-Catholic movement which is coming down the road a lot more acceptable to a lot more people.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
40 Comments

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman’s Missal

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's MissalI received by mail a book from The Continuum Publishing Group of London who have reprinted The Layman’s Missal and Prayer Book originally printed by Burns & Oates.

This is very compact volume which has the texts for Holy Mass and for other sacraments as well as Vespers for feasts.  There are indices of for the readings and hymns, which makes it useful.

It was updated to include the new form of the Good Friday prayer for Jews imposed on the 1962 Missale Romanum by Pope Benedict XVI.

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's Missal

It is leather bound and has three ribbons.

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's MissalThere are some drawbacks.

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's Missal

First the volume as a very tight binding, so much so that after I opened it, it stayed partly open.  It will probably loosen up at bit.  But the text margin is close to the binding.

REVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's MissalREVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's Missal

Also, this is a printing of the pre-1962 Missale Romanum, which is clear from the lack of St. Joseph in the Roman Canon.  A small detail which most people can easily deal with.

WREVIEW: Reprint of The Layman's Missalhile this book follows the pre-Conciliar calendar, when it comes to the table of movable feasts, the original table was printed. 

Thus you can readily check when the date of Easter fell, for example, up until 1980.   I don’t know what problems they might have had with the reprint, but if they updated the Good Friday prayer for Jews, why on earth didn’t they update the table for movable feasts? 

I am scratching my head over that.  

The main advantage to this book is is great portability.

£16.99

Buy it also on Amazon for less.

Posted in REVIEWS, SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

NCR defends a fired parish worker

The ultra-lefty dissenting NCR has a story in defensive of – gasp – someone who seems to be a dissenter. 

My emphases and comments.

Wisconsin parish worker fired for feminist views

Allowed no opportunity for defense nor to face accusers
Mar. 17, 2009

By Mike Sweitzer-Beckman

Madison, WI

Ruth Kolpack, pastoral associate since 1995 at St. Thomas the Apostle Church in Beloit, Wis., was fired earlier this month after a brief meeting with Madison Bishop Robert Morlino. [So, she was in place in that place from the time of former Bishop Bullock, whose ecclesiology was somewhat different perhaps than that ennunciated by Bp. Morlino.]

No specific accusations supporting the dismissal have been publicly made. A news release issued by Kolpack supporters stated that over the past three years, Madison diocese officials received “several accusations” against Kolpack. It added that last January, Fr. Steve Kortendick, pastor of St. Thomas and St. Jude parishes in Beloit, met with Morlino about those accusations. Since then, the release said, Kortendick and the diocesan chancellor, Kevin Phelan, had met in an unsuccessful effort to find a “positive resolution.”

According to the release, the investigation [take note of the vocabulary palates the writers uses in reference to the different parties] shifted to a thesis Kolpack had written for her master of divinity degree that was granted from St. Francis seminary.  [That bastion of firm teaching, under the guidance of former Archbp. Weakland, who "retired" in 2002.]

The thesis, written in 2003, evidently stirred little or no interest from church leaders until lately. Kolpack’s main theme is on inclusiveness, and what she sees as a patriarchal tone in the church’s liturgy, with an implicit exclusion of women from key roles, such as the priesthood.  [umm… there is no implicit exclusion of women from priesthood.  It is an explicit exclusion.]

Brent M. King, director of communications of the Diocese of Madison Mar. 17, in response to an NCR query, issued a statement. It said, in part that, "It is out of respect for the dignity and good reputation of every person involved, in this and all personnel matters, that specifics cannot and will not be discussed. You can be assured that the canonical and civil rights of each individual have been upheld absolutely. The Church takes this very seriously. I cannot make statements regarding Ms. Kolpack, as they could injure her good reputation."

The statement went on to say that church personnel "must uphold the faith and morals of the church" … through what they publicly teach and claim to believe, what they associate themselves with, and by their actions."  [ERGO: If they don’t uphold the Church’s teachings, they cannot work for the Church as an employee.  Reasonable?]

Kolpack said that when she met with her bishop she was given no opportunity to defend herself, [again, note the language used] nor did she have a chance to face or respond to those who had accused her.  [But she had written a thesis, right?]

When she met with Morlino, he stated that her views on the teachings of Jesus were "off base," according to Kolpack. She also said he informed her that he had not read her thesis in its entirety, only "bits and pieces."  [You don’t always have to read a work in its entirety to understand if it is "on" or "off base".  In the case of a thesis, for example, there are moments when you make the position you are advancing pretty clear.]

She said that during the meeting he asked her to denounce the thesis, make a profession of faith, and take an oath of loyalty in order to remain as a pastoral associate at the parish.  [So, there was something in the thesis that was not in keeping with faith or morals as taught by the Catholic Church.]

She said she could not refute the thesis in good conscience, that to dos [sic] so would risk her reputation as a scholar and academician.  [again… not the language… now she is a "scholar and academician".]

After Bishop Morlino’s announcement, I was given no opportunity to discuss any points in my thesis with which we disagreed, nor any of the original accusations made against me," said Kolpack. "In fact, within 10 minutes from the beginning of our meeting, I was fired."  [Imagine a fictitious meeting, entirely theoretical: "BISHOP: On this page you wrote that Jesus did not rise physically from death.  Will you abjure that, put your hand on Scripture and make a profession of the Nicene Creed?  OTHER PERSON: No.  I am a scholar and academician.  BISHOP: On this page you wrote that the Church’s infallible teaching on the impossibilty of ordination of women is false and offensive.  Will you abjure that, give me an indication that you accept the Magisterium of the Church?  OTHER PERSON: No.  I am a scholar and academician.  BISHOP: On this page you state that the community empowers the eucharistic assembly’s presider without the necessity of sacramental ordination.  Will you abjure that, and affirm that you accept what was promulgated by the Council of Trent, the Second Vatican Council and in the Catechism of the Catholic Church?  OTHER PERSON: No.  I am a scholar and academician.  BISHOP: You’re fired." See?  That didn’t even take 10 minutes.  I am not saying that that actually happened.  It is just a scenario.  What might be said in 10 minutes?]

The following Saturday protests were held outside of a Janesville parish where Morlino was meeting. He spoke with the protesters, but declined to give any details of his reasons for firing Kolpack. All he would say was that the action was a “personnel matter” and that the thesis wasn’t the only issue; that a “certain mentality” on Kolpack’s part was “troublesome.” He stressed that he respects her good work at St. Thomas and didn’t want to “hurt her good name.”  [The writer seems to want to take the statement from the diocese and bishop that this is just a dodge.  It could be the truth, too.]

Asked if there was a chance he’d reconsider Kolpack’s firing, the bishop replied, “You never say never, but it would be wrong of me to raise hopes in that regard.”

Kolpack told NCR that one good thing that came out of Saturday’s rally in Janesville: Morlino said he would come to Beloit and talk to the St. Thomas parishioners. “But if he cannot divulge any information because it’s a personnel matter,” Kolpack asked, “(How) will we ever find out? I don’t know."

After communion at Sunday’s Mass, Kortendick spoke briefly to the congregation and then allowed Kolpack to speak. Within minutes many were in tears. Some gathered in a prayer huddle to offer their prayers and blessings. She had served the community for over thirty years.  [Again, note the language.]

"Parishioners are very devastated,” she told NCR. “Sunday was a very bad time. I had people coming up to me after mass crying, hugging, and expressing concern. The big question is, ‘why was I fired?’ Unfortunately, I can’t answer it. People are going to think that if a bishop fires me, then it must be major. But I don’t even know why I got fired. I can’t tell parishioners why I got fired."  [No idea. It must not have anything to do with her thesis.]

Stephanie King Norton, a parishioner for 42 years, echoed the sentiments of many when she said she was “shocked” by the dismissal.

"Ruth played more than just a role there. She was the foundation of all activity at St. Thomas. Ruth even told me she wanted to retire in about five years, but in reviewing her responsibilities, it became clear that they could never find someone that would take on as much responsibility that Ruth has. I don’t know anyone at St. Thomas who would say that Ruth isn’t the foundation, even if they don’t always agree with her.  [hmmm]

"She’s been through four priests, and we always knew she would be there. She’s the heart and soul behind everything that goes on. Our priest is only 40 percent, so she was responsible for sacramental work as well. People converted and were brought back to the Catholic faith were crying because their friend was dismissed. Five- and six-year-olds were crying because they lost their teacher."  [Are you dabbing your eyes yet?  Not that this isn’t a sad situation or that people aren’t sad.  It is just that this article is so shamelessly manipulative.]

Kolpack became a volunteer catechist at St. Thomas in 1971. She attended workshops and conferences to be certified in religious education. In 1983, she was hired as a part-time youth minister and organized a youth ministry program at St. Thomas. She took training at Loyola University, got a bachelor’s degree in 1986 and was hired full-time. She later attended graduate school and earned a master’s degree. Kolpack got involved in diocesan educational programs, did training work and had a leading role in establishing the “Hands of Faith” program in which several churches take turns housing homeless families. She also had a part in establishing a Hispanic Ministry for Beloit’s three Catholic parishes – St. Thomas, St. Jude and Our Lady of the Assumption.

Kolpack wrote a letter to Morlino in which she wrote, “My ministry is my life’s work,” concluding by asking him to reconsider her dismissal.  [I wonder if she will have to modify any of her views, if they in fact are not in keeping with the Church’s teaching.]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

Braga Rite to be celebrated in Providence, RI

I received this from a reader.  Fascinating!

According to the web site of Una Voce Rhode Island, there will be a Procession and Mass in the Rite of Braga.

This will take place on April 5, 2009, Palm Sunday, at 11:00am. The location is Holy Name of Jesus Parish, 99 Camp st., Providence, Rhode Island 02906. Phone 401 / 272-4515  Fax 401 / 272-4616.
 
The parish celebrates the Extraordinary form of the Mass on Saturdays and Sundays.
 
The parish administrator is Fr. Joseph D. Santos, jr. Fr. Santos is a Priest of the Archdiocese of Braga, Portugal.
 
This will be a rare experience.

I think it is interesting that other Latin Rites can be celebrated outside the territory with which they are historically linked. 

I have attended, many years ago, Masses of the Braga Rite.  This would be an interesting experience.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

Former French P.M.: “This Pope is becoming a real problem”

A great story.  I think it defines the sides pretty well.

I reproduce this from Rorate:

Former Prime Minister of France speaks his mind to France Culture about Benedict XVI


Former Prime Minister Alain Juppé (UMP), interviewed Wednesday by France Culture concerning the words of Benedict XVI denouncing condoms, said that "this pope is becoming a real problem" because he is living “in a situation of total autism."

The current mayor of Bordeaux who says he is Catholic "because I was born into it" and because "I am committed to Christian values" assured that, “This pope is becoming a real problem." He cited the reinstatement of Bishops "one of which is the apostle – dare I say – of negationism." Juppé also commented on the excommunication in Brazil and the question of condoms.

In Brazil, "that a nine year old girl who was raped, whose life is in danger, should be – if not herself, then at least her parents and the doctor who helped her abort – excommunicated; that is an extraordinary lack of Christian charity" continued the former head of government.

"To go say in Africa that condoms increase the danger of AIDS is, first of all an untruth and it is inacceptable for the African people and for everyone else," he continued. "There is a real problem, I feel a profound sense of uneasiness all around me" said Mr. Juppe, who has "the impression" that the pope "lives in a situation of total autism.”

Orange

Classy!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

Lack of interest in Africa

My energies and time are rather limited at the moment, so I may not give much space to issues of the Holy Father’s trip to Africa.

Still… the relative lack of interest shown by the secular media is interesting.

I suspect there are a couple factors.

First, they don’t want the Holy Father’s explanations of the dignity of human life and the need for solutions for AIDS, etc., that don’t include condom distribution to get out into public discussion.

Second, they don’t care about Africa.

It occurs to me that if it weren’t for the cute furry animals, most of the intellectual elite wouldn’t care if Africa fell off the face of the earth.  They don’t seem to give a tinker’s dam for the people.  They are not interested in solutions that work, only in projects that fit their ideological bent.

Otherwise how to explain why the wealthy West continues to stand by and watch the terrible suffering and upheaval in many parts of Africa?  How do we explain the left-wing’s imposition of aid tied to particular tools of social engineering?

I’m just askin’

I suspect that will change when they figure our that once China solidifies its ties with African nations, for access to resources.

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
34 Comments

Card. Cordes on the SSPX reaction in Germany

NB: In case you didn’t see it, there is an interesting article about the SSPX controversy and the role of the press by His Eminence Paul Card. Cordes, the German-born President of the Pontifical Council Cor Unum. 

It was published in 13 March, but it is worth going back and reviewing.

It is on the website of The Catholic Herald, and is translated from the German by the splendid and persistent Anna Arco.  It was originally in Der Spiegel.

Card. Cordes focuses on why the reaction to the lifting of the SSPX excommunications was so ferocious in Germany.

Read the article and discuss (meaning, if you are going comment, read the article first).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Penjing Report

I am sure you are dying to know how Penjing is doing.

On a nice warm day Penjing is out catching some rays along with the rosemary, basil, thyme, sage and jasmine trees.

Penjing Report

Posted in My View |
10 Comments

QUAERITUR: making vestments

QUAERITUR: making vestmentsFrom a priest reader:

I’m sure you’ve posted on this, but I cannot recall when…

I’m interested in who you would suggest to make a vestment, particularly a rose one, so it’s just right.

My preference would be either a Gothic style, or if I could see an example, perhaps something like the vestment our holy father wore some time back, which I’d describe as a very ample “fiddleback”—perhaps you recall the one I mean.

The Altar Society wants to donate this, and has $800 to put toward it. A full set with all the parts would probably be out of our reach, but we may be able to get several nice pieces.

 

QUAERITUR: making vestmentsYou know… I think someone once did provide a link to a site with patterns for making vestments.

However, you should also consider purchasing vestments.

I was in the church goods section of Leaflet Missal in St. Paul, MN on Monday and there were a good selection of rose vestments in the so-called Gothic style having a good color, and not the nasty bright pink you sometimes see.  Ask for John in church goods at Leaflet.  Leaflet would be limited in the Roman department.

Remember: "fiddle-back" is a vague and misleading misnomer.  There is a sort of real "fiddle-back" which has Spanish influence I think.

Also, Gamarelli in Rome has the classic Roman cut, with all the necessary pieces.   They do low Mass sets or any number of pieces for whatever level of solemnity.

In the meantime, perhaps someone out there can dig up that site which had the patterns for vestments.

QUAERITUR: making vestmentsThe classic modern Roman cut does have specific proportions for its design and certain details which are to be included, such as the pattern of the galloni or "orphries" or "trim" or whatever you choose to call it.  Sometimes people think that any chasuble with the squared sides is "Roman".  They aren’t.  For example, Roman vestments don’t have a big Cross on the back.

If you are looking for the pattern for the historic vestments, which Gamarelli would call the "taglio filipino", because of St. Philip Neri, I am not sure where you would get the pattern.  I suppose some day I could take the measurements from the vestment I have in that style.  I don’t have dalmatics for it, however. 

Maybe you good readers can help.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
26 Comments

POLL: to chew or not to chew

POLL: to chew or not to chewThere was a very spirited discussion in the last POLL post about Communion in the Hand.  There is also an active combox here.

The overwhelming response of readers of this blog responded that they prefer to receive normally on the tongue.  I applaud them.

I don’t think people who receive on the hand intend irreverence, but I contend that the generalized practice of Communion in the hand has severely damaged the faith of Catholic people in what the Church teaches about the Eucharist.

But there are other issues of reception of Communion which relate to the question of Communion in the hand or on the tongue.

Catholics believe that the Host and all small particles, the Precious Blood and small droplets of It, are the entire Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ.  This is the perfect and infallible teaching of the Church.  Every Catholic is bound to believe this and those who deny it are heretics.

However, we don’t really know how small is small, in the sense of our ability to recognize the accidents of bread and wine which remain after transsubstantiation.

Because we can’t recognize precisely when the accidents of bread or wine cease and the Real Presence of Christ in what remains has ceased, it is entirely reasonable to be cautious and conservative rather than casual and careless about what is a great Mystery.

Another question is how to consume the Host once it is administered by whichever method?

Chew or not?

Allow it to dissolve, soften and then swallow?

Hosts vary in size and consistency.

People have differing abilities to swallow.

Many people of a certain age who attended Catholic were strongly admonished by their teachers, probably sisters, never to chew.  They might have been told that that helps to keep some of the Host sticking to teeth.  They might have even been told by the pious and well-meaning that you hurt Jesus if you chew Him.

Assuming that you are receiving Communion through some normal means, with reasonably normal Hosts and not those ghastly (in my opinion) homemade "substantial bread" things, how do you consume the Host?

It is assumed that the conditions would be a little different if you are consuming by intinction, but you can still answer the question.

POLL CLOSED

How do you consume the Host?

  • Generally avoid chewing and allow It to dissolve or soften before swallowing (63%, 1,374 Votes)
  • Generally chew to some degree and then swallow (37%, 815 Votes)

Total Voters: 2,189

Posted in POLLS |
132 Comments