A note for those who want to post comments

ALL: Two things.

If there is going to be discussion here, I ask that it be civil.

My mood today, and the list of things to do I face, are such that I will simply lock people out of the blog for a while if they cause me additional work right now.

Someone today referred to "intellectual fascists", another compared people who don’t want to see the rubrics violated on Holy Thursday to Satan.

I don’t need that sort of garbage.

I want to be edified today, not annoyed.  Really.  Not kidding.

My alternative will be to impose restrictions such as obligatory registration or moderated comments, which I am sure few people want.

o{]:¬( 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on A note for those who want to post comments

What’s sauce for the goose-step…

I am reading stories that "the Vatican" has "rejected" Williamson’s recently issued apology.

Fr. Lombardi said:

…Williamson’s statement "does not seem to respect the conditions" set forth by the Vatican on February 4, when it ordered Williamson to "in an absolutely unequivocal and public way distance himself from his positions" regarding the Holocaust.

I don’t think that any apology SSPX Bp. Williamson may issue about his views on the Holocaust will ever be enough for certain groups, both of Jews and within the Church.  They may have crafted this in such a way that they know he will not do it.

But whatever else may happen with Bp. Williamson, will unambiguous apologies be required now from the more avid pro-abortion Catholic politicians?

If there are concerns that someone would deny that 6 million Jews were killed in WWII, and apologies are demanded from such a person, is there going to be equal concern over those who promote or participate in a far more extensive killing of the innocent?

Will Catholic pro-abortion politicians be required to issue apologies, as unambiguous as that which they require from Williamson… heck any apology at all…. for voting for abortion rights?

I’m just askin’

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
Comments Off on What’s sauce for the goose-step…

The first Roman Catholic bishop in House of Lords since 16th century

From The Times:

Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor set to be first Roman Catholic bishop in House of Lords since 16th century

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
67 Comments

QUAERITUR: Indulgence for Stations of the Cross

QUAERITUR: Indulgence for Stations of the CrossFrom a reader:

Last night the family that I live with recited the Stations of the Cross together in our home. At the end, we prayed for the intentions of the Holy Father and had a discussion about eternal/temporal punishment, indulgences (especially plenary ones), the requirements for obtaining them, and the ability to apply indulgences to the Holy Souls.
 
I decided to do a little research so the children would know about other indulgenced works. I found a great deal of information. Included was information about the indulgence for making the Way of the Cross. In the list of norms to gain the plenary indulgence it says, "The pious exercise must be made before stations of the Way of the Cross legitimately erected".
 
My question: What does it mean to be legitimately erected? Could we, in the house, hang 14 crosses, and make the Way of the Cross by processing with these? Or does this mean that we would need to go to a church and use stations that have been installed and blessed?

First, I am very glad that you have done this with your family.  You are to be commended.  I am reminded of the scribe who brings forth things both old and new.

The Handbook for Indulgences is the book issued by the Holy See containing the norms for indulgences, what some of the prayers and works are and what the conditions are.

A plenary indulgence can be obtained by making the Way of the Cross on Good Friday even through televised participation for the Holy Father’s Stations. 

Otherwise, this devotion at other times must be made before Stations of the Way of the Cross legitimately erected.   That means that a bishop or his delegate is to have established them in the place, usually a church or chapel or perhaps cemetery or other outside place such as a retreat house.  The bishop, etc., then provides a document that this was done.  Usually a document like that, often in Latin, can be found hanging on a wall of the sacristy, unless in ignorance it was taken down. 

When Stations have been duly erected, they are symbolized or "located" with a Cross on the wall or perhaps outside with a standing structure.  There is often a picture or statue group, etc.   There are 14 Stations.  Movement from one station to the next is required when you do them as an individual.  If the Stations are a public event, then just the person leading them needs to move from station to station.

The Handbook indicates that this is also vocal prayer.  By custom some "preces vocales" are added.  I suppose that might only be "Lord Jesus Crucified, have mercy on us."  Also, the Handbook says that there is flexibility about the mysteries considered.

It may be that some people are prevented from going to a church or place where there are legitimately erected Stations.  In that case a person can still gain the indulgence by spending at least one half hour meditating on the Cross and death of the Lord.

Eastern Catholics, who don’t have this custom of the Way of the Cross, can also gain an indulgence according as their respective patriarchs determine.

So… to the questions.

Yes… Stations must be formally set up as I described.  If you were to go to church with your family, you would all together move from station to station…. which would be a beautiful thing to see, actually.   If you were legitimately impeded from going to church, say there was a blizzard or someone at home who was ill who needed care, you have an alternative.

I don’t think "Well, I don’t want to drive for 10 minutes." is legitimately impeded.  But what that means is hard to say.  I tent to be on the lenient side with these things, for surely Holy Church wants people to be able to gain the indulgences without an undue burden.  It must cost us something, of course.  But that will vary.  A young person can get to church easier than an old lady with cane during winter.

Remember also that there are conditions for gaining any plenary indulgence.  In addition to the work performed you must be free of attachment to sin.  Meditation on the Cross and death of the Lord should help this resolve.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

The auxilliary dust up in Linz, Austria – dustier still

The indomitable Raphaela has been busy:

Hello again Father,

Another piece from kath.net, hot off the presses. It seems that the bishop of Linz was called to Rome at short notice, presumably to explain himself. The rest of the Austrian bishops’ conference, which collectively threw auxiliary-designate Wagner to the wolves a couple of weeks ago, seems to have had some time to think and is getting worried either about Rome or about the havoc from "progressivist" pressure at grassroots level possibly spreading to their own dioceses, and is expressing approval of the idea of an Apostolic Visitation.  [It’s an old story.  When they start to realize it might strike at them next, they begin to change their tune.  That is, I maintain, what happened back when the CDW restructured ICEL.  The old-ICEL’s Waterloo was the hideous mistranslation of the rites of ordination.  It seems to me that as long as it was just the Mass, well… toleratur.  When it struck at ordination, they had to act.  Eventually, people in positions of power get concerned that they have let things go too far.]

My (rough, hasty) translation follows.

Raphaela

=====

Bishop of Linz summoned to Rome at short notice!

Linz (kath.net)
Peace and quiet seems unlikely to return too soon to the Diocese of Linz. kath.net was able to ascertain that Bishop Ludwig Schwarz traveled to Rome at short notice on Friday. He cancelled the youth catechesis that was scheduled for Friday evening in Linz. Schwarz has an appointment with the Congregation of Bishops in Rome.

After a statement by Gerhard Maria Wagner saying that his resignation was not voluntary, the bishop of Linz now finds himself under considerable pressure. Even some of his Austrian fellow-bishops are now unofficially expressing criticism of the proceedings. A letter from Gerhard Maria Wagner asking the Pope to reverse his appointment as auxiliary bishop has been received by the Congregation of Bishops. Church sources in the Vatican told kath.net that Pope Benedict XVI has assigned top priority to the issue and will deal with it personally. It is not known when the Pope will make a decision. The Friday bulletin of the Vatican Press Office once again made no mention of the Wagner affair.

An increasing number of people within the Vatican itself are speaking quite openly about an Apostolic Visitation for the Diocese of Linz. [!] kath.net was informed by sources within the Austrian Church that several Austrian bishops have already commented favourably on the prospect of an Apostolic Visitation in the Diocese of Linz. Given the crisis in the diocese, Rome is not excluding the possibility that a coadjutor bishop could be nominated.

I think Bishop Martino could be a good man for the good of Apostolic Visitor.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

“We Are Church” whiners feel “cheated of their aims”!

Get out your hankies.

I received this from the indomitable Raphaela in her translation:

“We Are Church” group faces crucial test

KATH.NET Excluxive: Vatican II texts threaten to drive wedge into movement
 
Munich (kath.net)

The “We Are Church” movement is evidently faced with internal conflict in connection with the “Vatican II Petition”, which is being intensely promoted by the movement. Church representatives describe the true goal of the petition as a campaign against Pope Benedict XVI against the background of the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops. However, even the title of the petition unmistakably calls for the “unqualified acceptance of the decisions of the Second Vatican Council”.

According to well-informed sources, this is where the potential for conflict originates. Former supporters of “We Are Church” now feel cheated of their aims. [awwww] For instance, certain passages from the conciliar constitution “Gaudium et Spes” are absolutely irreconcilable with one of the five basic demands with which the movement was launched in 1995.

In GS 47, the Second Vatican Council describes divorce and premarital sexual relationships as “disfigurements” of the nobility of marriage and also views contraception as a “profanation”. This has nothing to do with the “positive valuation of sexuality” and “responsible decisions of conscience in questions of sexual morality (e.g. contraception)” which the petition for a church referendum included in its list of demands. There are similar discrepancies in other matters.

“One cannot support the aims of the church referendum and call for the recognition of Vatican II at the same time,” a visibly frustrated priest [ROFL!  It finally gets through.  On the other hand, the rupture theologians, such as their icon Kung, have been saying that Vatican II didn’t go nearly far enough.] says in a private communiqué on file with kath.net. Anyone who does so “has never read the texts of the Council.” He said that “We Are Church” should never consider the resolutions to be anything more than simply “voting results”, adding that what was at stake was the “spirit of the Council”, [See?  The "spirit" is a "super-dogma" for these people.] but certainly not the Council itself, which is “completely tied to the old tradition of the Church”.

Poor liberals.  

So out of it. 

So unaware of how far out of it they are.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Some Roman TLMs – great news

A friend sent the following note, very hope-filled:

At San Giovanni in Laterano!! Twice in 5 days! The Pope is prepping up I tell you!

I’ll leave it in Italian.  The point is plenty clear!  The news is from Messa in latino, a very good site.

Mercoledì 25 MARZO 2009 alle ore 10.00
Chiesa di S. Francesco in Tarquinia
S. Messa Pontificale secondo la forma straordinaria
celebrata da S.E. Mgr. William Burke
in occasione dell’Ordinazione Sacerdotale di 5 Frati Francescani dell’Immacolata.

Giovedì 16 Aprile 2009 alle ore 10.00
Basilica di S. Giovanni in Laterano, Roma
in occasione dell’ottavo centenario dell’approvazione della regola di S. Francesco
S. Messa Solenne celebrata da P. Stefano Maria Manelli
Superiore dell’Ordine dei Frati Francescani dell’Immacolata

Martedì 21 Aprile 2009 alle ore 10.00
Basilica di S. Giovanni in Laterano, Roma
S. Messa pontificale celebrata da S. Em. rev.ma il Card. Antonio Canizares Llovera
Prefetto della S. Congregazione per il Culto Divino e la Disciplina dei Sacramenti

My friend includes…

These Franciscans of the Immaculate are great people, they now have a parish at 5 minute-drive form my place and they are introducing TLM. The also have the little Church of the "Annunziatella" in Borgo at Lungotevere Vaticano  and their Saturday TLM is going well, they’re going to have it on Sundays, I am told.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Op-ed supporting Bp. Martino in the Phil. Inquirer

An alert friend saw that former Sen. Rick Santorum (R-PA) a pro-life Catholic politician for a change, had comments about the backbone Bp. Martino of Scranton has been revealing in the public square.

Mr. Santorum writes an op-ed piece in The Inquirer.

Here is an excerpt from the letter with my emphases and comments.

The Elephant in the Room: In praise of Catholic priests who dare to teach and enforce
By Rick Santorum

"[…]Two weeks ago, the Philadelphia native and St. Joseph’s Prep graduate issued a strong statement of disapproval to a local, nominally Catholic college, Misericordia University, that had scheduled a speech on campus by someone advocating same-sex marriage. "The faithful of the Diocese of Scranton should be in no doubt," [Bishop] Martino said, "that Misericordia University in this instance is seriously failing in maintaining its Catholic identity."

Then, last week, Martino took on some more of the biggest guns in the diocese: the Irish clubs that organize the largest public Catholic event of the year, the St. Patrick’s Day festivities. Through a letter from his Irish auxiliary bishop, Martino warned that if any of these groups went ahead with plans that in any way honor politicians who are not pro-life, he would close the cathedral where Mass is usually held prior to the parade, as well as other diocesan churches. He said he would not countenance anything that created confusion about the teachings of the church.

The reason for the letter: Scranton’s St. Patrick’s Day parade last year featured Hillary Clinton.
Many of his brother bishops will look at Martino as they do at other uncompromising defenders of the faith, worrying about the world’s reaction. [RIGHT!  Would that he had been re-elected to that Senate seat.]  As a Philly guy, though, his excellency knows something about being booed. He also knows his job and calling: to be the good shepherd who faithfully leads and protects his flock from those who would lead them astray.

Yes, scores of people are reportedly protesting and threatening to leave the church. In the end, however, people leaving the church because of a bishop who enforces its teachings are a blessing [!] compared with the alternative: people leaving because bishops and their priests don’t teach, much less enforce, those teachings."  [Square on the nail’s head!]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

Bp. Martino instructs Sen. Casey on the Mexico City Policy

Bishop Martino of Scranton is really defining the issue … AGAIN:

Bishop Again Voices Concern Regarding Sen. Casey’s
Mexico City Policy Vote

The following letter has been sent to Sen. Bob Casey:

Dear Senator Casey,

It is a matter of deep concern that your recent vote against the Mexico City Policy  is continually misrepresented by your staff as a pro-life vote intended to promote “contraception and other family planning that avoid unintended pregnancies” (Times-Tribune, February 6, 2009).

The Mexico City Policy is, first and foremost, about abortion, not about family planning. First put in place in 1984, the policy required all non-governmental organizations that receive federal funding to refrain from performing or promoting abortion services abroad. The policy required such organizations to agree as a condition for receiving U.S. foreign aid dollars that they would “neither perform nor actively promote abortion as a method of family planning in other nations.” The policy included exceptions for abortions done in cases of rape, incest or life-threatening conditions.

Furthermore, the Mexico City Policy did not take funds away from family planning; its effect is quite the opposite. Tom McCluskey of the Family Research Council reported the following: “. . .The Mexico City policy halts U.S. family planning funds from going to foreign . . . [NGOs] that perform abortions or ‘actively promote’ abortion as a method of family planning in other countries. . . The effect of President Obama rescinding the Mexico City Policy is that now millions ($461 million in the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2008) of dollars are taken away from family planning groups that do not promote abortions, and delivered into the hands of organizations that are the most militant in promoting abortion as a population-control method—especially in countries that find abortion objectionable on moral grounds” (my emphasis). Contrary to the claims of your staff, the absence of “Mexico City” regulations insures (1) that money is taken away from family planning, (2) that abortion is promoted as a method of family planning, and (3) that countries that have moral and cultural objections to abortion are encouraged to abandon their policies against it.

Finally, it is never permissible to use immoral means such as artificial contraception to achieve a good end, namely, the reduction of unplanned pregnancies. In fact, the mistaken view that artificial contraception may be used to regulate population growth and the size of families has led to countless evils in America and abroad, including the attitude that having and raising children is a burden to be avoided. This attitude has contributed mightily to the acceptability of abortion as a means of contraception both at home and abroad.

My letter of January 30 urging you to rescind your vote on the Mexico City Policy was in no way mistaken regarding the nature and the effect of President Obama’s order to rescind America’s long-standing policy to avoid using U.S. tax dollars to support organizations that promote abortion abroad. It is imperative that this fact be made known to the public.

It is also imperative that there be utter clarity when it comes to the teaching of the Church on matters that pertain to the taking of innocent life and the special responsibilities that fall to you, Senator, as a lawmaker to oppose abortion and other clear evils.

In closing, I refer you to the words of Cardinal Francis George, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, to President Obama urging him to retain the Mexico City Policy.

The Mexico City Policy . . . has wrongly been attacked as a restriction on foreign aid for family planning. In fact, it has not reduced such aid at all, but has ensured that family planning funds are not diverted to organizations dedicated to performing and promoting abortions instead of reducing them. Once the clear line between family planning and abortion is erased, the idea of using family planning to reduce abortions becomes meaningless, and abortion tends to replace contraception as the means for reducing family size. A shift toward promoting abortion in developing nations would also increase distrust of the United States in these nations, whose values and culture often reject abortion, at a time when we need their trust and respect (January 23, 2009).

Sincerely,

Most Reverend Joseph F. Martino, D.D., Hist. E.D.
Bishop of Scranton

 

Is there any question that the Senator in question has been instructed by his bishop?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
52 Comments

Archbp. Vlazny (Portland, OR) on the lifting of the excommunications

His Excellency John Vlazny of Portland, Oregon, has made comments about the lifting of the excommunications of the four SSPX bishops.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

All in the family
By Archbishop John Vlazny
 
The first two weekends of Lent here in the Archdiocese of Portland each year draw our attention to growth in the family of believers. [a good way to start]  Bishop Steiner and I travel around the archdiocese to celebrate what we describe as the Rite of Election. The catechumens who are preparing for Baptism become our elect, those chosen for the Easter sacraments. Those already baptized in other Christian families are welcomed as candidates for continuing conversion on the road to receiving Confirmation and Eucharist with the catechumens at the Easter Vigil. If nothing else happens, at least the elect and candidates are much more mindful of the fact that the Catholic family is much larger than the parish venue with which they have become familiar thus far in the process of initiation.

Church membership is a privilege and a gift, not an accomplishment or entitlement. No one is perfect. We all sin. From time to time we need to seek healing and forgiveness through the sacrament of Reconciliation. The season of Lent reminds all of us that our conversion to Christ is lifelong and ongoing, one that requires our attention, something we can never take for granted.

Church membership brings with it certain expectations
in terms of our beliefs, values and behaviors. Serious sin, we know, excludes us from the full participation in the celebration of the Eucharist. We all learned as children that we must confess mortal sins before approaching the Lord in the sacrament of the Eucharist. We can also choose to walk away from the church, disassociate ourselves from the family’s activities, halt our support for its mission. But once baptized, always baptized. Even when you or I might choose to walk away from the church, the church can’t walk away from us, even though it might penalize us in some way.

A penalty we hear a lot about is excommunication. Excommunication was a word that was bantered about a lot during recent elections because of unseemly behavior on the part of some rather well known Catholic politicians. Should they be excommunicated for supporting abortion rights? If not excommunicated, does that mean they are still welcome at the table of the Lord?
The Catechism of the Catholic Church informs us, “Certain particularly grave sins incur excommunication, the most severe ecclesiastical penalty, which impedes the reception of the sacraments and the exercise of certain ecclesiastical acts, and for which absolution consequently cannot be granted, according to canon law, except by the Pope, the bishop of the place or priests authorized by them.” That’s tough talk.

When a person is excommunicated, he or she may no longer participate in the liturgy in any ministerial capacity and certainly is not allowed to receive the Eucharist or the other sacraments. He or she may be present for the celebration of Mass, [As a matter of fact, the excommunicate still is obliged to attend Mass on Sundays and Holy Days.]  for example, because the excommunication is primarily intended to signal the gravity of the offense and lead the person to conversion from behaviors or statements which are seriously at odds with Catholic values and teachings. A person who has been excommunicated is still considered Christian and a Catholic because the seal of Baptism is indelible. Excommunications are sometimes automatic and at other times they must be declared in a more public way. However the excommunication takes place, it may be lifted by legitimate authority for a good reason.

As most of us are now aware, Pope Benedict XVI recently lifted the excommunication on four bishops of the St. Pius X Society who were ordained by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre. This took place during Christian Unity Week in January, a gesture described by Pope Benedict XVI as “paternal.” It is the Holy Father’s hope that this will be the first step toward reconciliation with these bishops and their followers and their eventual restoration as full members of our Catholic family. But it is only a first step, a reaching out of one hand to another with the hope that beliefs and behaviors will be brought in line with those of our Catholic family.

Reaction to the Holy Father’s “paternal gesture” have been mixed, some quite hostile. Recently I received a letter from an irate couple in the archdiocese who expressed their great disappointment with the Holy Father in this regard and, as a result of this action and others, were strongly considering leaving the church as a protest to this “lack of moral leadership.” [Puhlese… there is more to such a threat than this event.] We also learned that Israel’s rabbinate severed ties with the Vatican as a protest to this decision of the Pope.

Why all this hostility? After news of the lifting of the excommunication was made public, it was learned that one of the four bishops, Richard Williamson, who resides in the United States, [Ummm… not for years.  Is Argentina a type of "United States" also?] had publicly expressed serious doubts about the killing of six million Jews through the Holocaust. Lifting the excommunication was considered a grave violation of the mutual understanding that has grown between the Jewish and Catholic communities during respectful dialogue in recent years. The reaction here in Portland wasn’t so strong but many questions were raised by our Jewish friends.

Back on February 3, the President of our United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Cardinal Francis George, acknowledged publicly that Bishop Williamson’s denial of the Holocaust was “deeply offensive and utterly false.” The Pope’s gesture, he explained, was “an act of mercy and personal concern for the ordained and lay members” of the Priestly Society of St. Pius X.
Pope Benedict, like all pastors of the church, works and prays that one day all Christians will once again be one. Like his predecessor, Pope John Paul II, he is hopeful that the full communion with the Catholic Church of these bishops and their priests will be reestablished. Of course these bishops, like the rest of us, will have to give their assent to all that our church professes, including the teachings of the Second Vatican Council, which is a very neuralgic matter for them. [I would say!]

The outrage over the remarks of Bishop Williamson is certainly understandable. None of us can erase the memory of the Shoah. No Catholic may tolerate expressions of anti-Semitism and religious bigotry. In fact, subsequent to the lifting of the excommunications, the Holy Father himself has said, “May the Shoah show both old and new generations that only the arduous path of listening and dialogue, of love and forgiveness, can lead peoples, cultures and religions of the world to the longed-for goal of fraternity and peace, in truth. May violence never again humiliate man’s dignity.” Undoubtedly it is much easier to welcome the elect and the candidates to the Sacraments of Initiation this coming Easter than it will be to welcome back those who were separated by their denial of fundamental church teachings, like the four bishops of the St. Pius X Society and their followers. [You know… this is a pretty good point.  However, what "fundamental church teaching" have the leadership of the SSPX denied?  I can think of a lot of progressivists who] Lifting an excommunication is not a signal that they have returned home. But it opens the door to the possibility of their return.

In the parable of the prodigal son, Jesus tells us the father rushes out to greet his wayward son long before he reaches home. I see the Pope’s gesture somewhat akin to that one, even though the Pope has done no more than open the door. In no way has he rushed out to welcome these wayward bishops home.  [Not a bad analogy.  We should remember that the father stood watching, waiting for his son to return.] We Catholics pledge to continue doing our best to build bonds of trust and understanding with our elder brothers and sisters in faith, the Jewish people, God’s own people who uniquely journey with us on the road to salvation.

Pretty good, actually!  

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments