A fictional dialogue

Sandro Magister has posted a marvelous fictional dialogue… and more.

Go check it out.

In the meantime, enjoy this with my emphases and comments:

The text that follows is not a review of the book "Who’s afraid of Vatican II?" But it takes the book’s publication as an opportunity to present – in the form of a dialogue – the questions that today’s Church finds itself facing.

As will be seen, these are questions of capital importance, touching on the foundations of the Christian creed. They are questions answered not only by Vatican II, but before it by the Christological Councils of the early centuries, in Nicaea, Ephesus, Chalcedon.

The author is Francesco Arzillo, 49, from Rome, an administrative judge with rare expertise in philosophy and theology.

A brief dialogue on the Council, between a teacher and student

by Francesco Arzillo

The teacher (T.) is a professor of theology in his sixties, moderately progressive, inclined to dialogue with everyone; he becomes agitated only with those who seem unwilling to appreciate to the full the Council of his youth, which reminds him, among other things, of his tumultuous years in the seminary.

The student (S.) is younger and is not a clergyman; he is a little irreverent, but never toward the ecclesial magisterium; many consider to him to be ultraconservative; but the traditionalists also criticize him because he consults – albeit with caution – the theological writings of Henri de Lubac, and always defends John XXIII and Paul VI.

–––––

T. – Hi! Always with a book in your hand. Let’s have a look at the title of your latest purchase.

S. – Here you go: "Who’s afraid of Vatican II?", edited by Alberto Melloni and Giuseppe Ruggieri.

T. – You surprise me. You’re reading Melloni, and the progressive Catholic theologians you’ve always criticized? I’ve got it: the title of the book made you feel guilty, and now you want to atone.

S. – Well, professor, I see you haven’t lost the habit of putting psychoanalysis before theology. I don’t have any sense of guilt, at least not about this. You know I’ve always accepted Vatican II wholeheartedly. How can you talk about the Church today without "Lumen Gentium?" Or divine revelation without "Dei Verbum?" Or the liturgy without "Sacrosanctum Concilium"?

T. – So what’s the problem?

S. – The problem is in this endless dispute about the Council, in this elaborate conflict of interpretations. Sure, the essays in this book are sophisticated, they have some interesting passages, they go up against the guidelines of Benedict XVI. But…

T. – But?

S. – They remind me – at least in part – of the perspectives, the framework, the clichés of the segment of progressive Catholicism that tends to mythologize the Council. But make no mistake, I’m not trying to label the authors, I’m just using a broad generalization.

T. – The truth is that you say you accept the Council, but with a mental reservation, because you criticize those who fight for the Council.

S. – You see? You’re talking about a battle. This is precisely the point, this overexcitement on the part of some during and after the Council, this atmosphere of constant fighting, this "agitation croissante aux alentours du Concile": not my words, but those of Cardinal Henri de Lubac. And then, this way of presenting the history! The famous "black week"… What does that even mean? What is the explanatory value of that expression? It doesn’t have any! If I read the memoirs of one of Napoleon’s aides-de-camp at Waterloo, I can understand if he talks about a "black day"; but I expect a contemporary historian to take a more calm approach and help me understand. Again, de Lubac, in his book "Entretien autour de Vatican II," published in 1985, talks about a "language historico-manichéen, qui sous un mode mineur s’est assez largement répandu." Or have you lost your taste for de Lubac? You always used to talk to me about him with boundless admiration.

T. – There’s no such thing as neutral historiography.

S. – Yes there is, but you have to at least be calm. Anyway, the overexcitement I’m talking about isn’t just autobiographical and historiographical. It is also, I dare say, philosophical.

T. – What do you mean?

S. – Look, let’s take as an example the problem of the "spirit" and the "letter."

T. – Don’t hand me that story about how the conciliar documents should be read only according to the letter!

S. – Why do you want to trivialize this? It’s true, the letter must always be given its rightful place, but that’s not sufficient for a complete interpretation. The Roman jurist Celsus and Saint Paul agree on that. And that’s enough for me.

T. – Well, then?

S. – It depends on what we mean by "spirit." This is where overexcitement comes into play. Take for example Hegel, in Jena. He was clearly overexcited: in Napoleon, he saw History passing by on horseback… Remember that passage from "Lectures in Jena," the one quoted by the "negativist" Kojève at the beginning of his "Introduction to the Reading of Hegel"? Do you remember the tone? "Gentlemen! We find ourselves living at an important time, in a ferment in which the Spirit has taken a step forward. It has surpassed the previous concrete form, and has taken on a new one…" So, when I read some of today’s theologians and historians, I can’t help but think of that kind of tone.

T. – You insinuate, you allude, but you don’t conclude. This is not at all a question of tone!

S. – It’s not up to me to say to what extent it is simply a matter of tone, or of the legitimate assumption of theoretical elements, or of capitulation to immanentist reasoning. Each author is different from the next.

T. – Let’s get back to the Council. You cite the Roman jurist Celsus, you insist on the text and overlook the event.

S. Another buzzword: event. Hegel? Heidegger? Pareyson?

T. Come on, leave the philosophers alone!

S. – I’m not leaving anything alone! You theologians of today know so little about philosophy, you want to make a theo-logy without "logos," a-philosophical or trans-philosophical. But often it’s just rhetoric. And the worst thing is that you’ve been influenced by Hegel without even knowing it. If Hegel were here with us right now, he’d be surprised by how many intellectual descendants he has, how many children and stepchildren. But you don’t even know how to write textbooks. It’s hard to find one that doesn’t skip from Saint Thomas to Rahner, leaving out everything in between! Today you can get a degree in theology without knowing practically anything about Scotus, Suarez, Melchior Cano, Cajetan. Try it, ask ten new graduates if they’ve ever heard about Scheeben, and tell me if you find more than a couple who say they have.

T. – Now you’re the one who’s exaggerating.

S. You’re right. I’ll calm down.

T. – The event! Think about theology, think about "Dei Verbum": God reveals himself through events and words that are intimately connected to each other…

S. – Of course I think about theology! I think that divine revelation culminates in Christ, in whom God has told us everything. It has been completed, although it has not yet been made completely explicit, as the Catechism recalls in paragraph 66. And then in paragraph 83: tradition "comes from the apostles and hands on what they received from Jesus’ teaching and example and what they learned from the Holy Spirit." It would be wrong to think of historical evolutionism. It’s not that the reality revealed by God is modified or evolves; it is the believing mind that grows through exploration. If this is true, the only Event is Christ, there is no such thing as an age of the Spirit that supersedes that of Christ.

T. – Please, spare me the story of Joachim of Fiore . . .

S. – And why should I? If we really want to look for an epochal event, let’s think about Saint Francis! Who was more epochal than he was, for the entire second millennium? We could all agree about this, conservatives, progressives, even many nonbelievers. But the interpretation of those who saw in Francis the inauguration of the age of the Spirit was rightly rejected. Francis himself would have been stunned by this, he saw only Christ and the Trinity, in everything.

T. – But Franciscan historiography is complex. You have to keep in mind the politics of Saint Bonaventure in narrating the history of the founder . . .

S. – What do you mean, politics! Just the use of this term, in reference to an area that a medieval person would never have described as "political," that annoys me, because it’s the result of bad interpretation. Everything’s political now, so the events of that era – theological, philosophical, legal – it’s all seen through the lens of politics. Nice way to pounce on another time period, for someone who’s always talking about history!

T. – What’s the point, what are you leading up to?

S. – I just want to say that we have to knock it off with this business of "epochal event." There are no epochal events, according to strict logical and theological reasoning. The idea of an epochal event risks becoming simply a good rhetorical tool for "mobilization," a form of crypto-ideology.

T. – What are you hoping for, the eternal return of the same?

S. – No. Augustine demonstrated that pagan cyclicality has been superseded for good. Instead it, it’s a matter of being able to see the Eternal in time, intersecting a point of time, "that" point of time, becoming incarnate.

T. – You’re going backward…

S. – I’m returning to the sources. And to the Source.

T. – But the one Event, does it live again today, or not?

S. – It is fulfilled. The time is fulfilled, look at Mark 1:15. Even though we are still awaiting its full manifestation.

T. – And Vatican Council II? Does it help you in the journey, or not?

S. – Of course it helps me! But it presupposes the one Event, and its dogmatic definition, made irrevocably during the first seven ecumenical Councils. You understand, I can’t consider an event that would "de-Chalcedonize" Christ – that would take away from him what was defined at Chalcedon – for the sake of inculturating him in modernity.  [Excellent.]

T. – But nobody wants that!

S. – Apparently, almost nobody. Certainly Vatican II did not want this, it did not intend to innovate the faith, as the extreme versions of traditionalism and progressivism speculate, with opposite intentions. But I wonder how much Arianism – virtual Arianism, in terms of tendency – there is going around today, with all of these efforts to humanize Jesus. I think, for example, of the critics of "Dominus Iesus," which had to revisit the ABC’s of Christology in 2000. I wonder: who’s afraid of the Councils of Nicaea, Ephesus, Chalcedon?

T. – That’s a clever rhetorical trick. You’re ranking the Councils as a subtle way of undermining Vatican II.

S. – No. but it seems to me that the foundations of the faith are at stake today. So I would appreciate it if the conferences would also give adequate emphasis to Nicaea and Chalcedon, instead of leaving them to a few erudite specialists.

T. – That’s enough, I’m tired. I’m going back home to read something from my favorite book, the "Journal of a Soul" by Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli.

S. – What a coincidence, I’m reading that one too…

Well done!

In the meantime, I repeat:

Everyone is insisting that the SSPX accept Vatican II.

Can we insist that everybody accept Trent?

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

Online petition that Communion be withheld from pro-abortion pols.

The excellent canon law blog of Edward Peters, In the Light of the Law, there is an interesting post about a … well… read it.

Be sure to go to the site and look at comments and the rest. Spike those stats as only you WDTPRSers can!

The Pewsitter Petition on Canon 915

Pewsitter.com has published an on-line petition by which Catholics may call upon bishops to withhold holy Communion from Catholic political figures who gravely disregard Church teaching on certain fundamental life issues. The petition invokes canon law in support of some of its propositions. I know nothing about the organization behind the petition, but I feel confident in commenting on its canonical aspects.

The petition seems to me to qualify under 1983 CIC 212.3 as one way of helping the faithful to express "to sacred pastors their opinion on matters which pertain to the good of the Church and to make their opinion known to the rest of the Christian faithful." I do not think the petition pretends to an expertise it cannot claim, nor does it seem to be violative of basic norms on faith, morals, and reverence toward pastors, etc. It does not impugn the fidelity of those who choose not to sign.

The petition calls for withholding of holy Communion under Canon 915 and in this regard it avoids the highly contentious, and I think erroneous, claim that certain politicians should be subject to excommunication for their actions. Moreover, the petition avoids identifying specific politicians for action under Canon 915, even though a strong case can be made for such action in the case of, say, Nancy Pelosi. Each politician’s situation, as I have said, needs to be examined individually by competent experts; this is by no means an impossible task, but it is not one best conducted in the blogosphere.

The petition highlights the scandal [this is a key] being created under the continued reception of holy Communion by those Catholic politicians who routinely ignore Church teaching on the sacredness of innocent human life; in this respect, the petition seems securely grounded in the arguments of Abp. Raymond Burke whose landmark article on Canon 915 makes correction of scandal a centerpiece of his position.

I would not have offered, however, in the petition any speculation on whether certain politicians need to be ‘reconciled with the Church’, for such language sounds more in the internal forum than the external. Given, however, that the rest of the petition has in view only observable political behavior and demonstrable Church teaching, and calls for action only in regard to one’s external conduct, I am inclined to think that petition language about ‘reconciliation’ is the result of the authors’ unfamiliarity with the nuances of certain phrases used by professionals, and that they intended no judgment of the state of the souls of Catholic politicians. In short, such language, to the degree a bishop might think it approaches an assertion about the internal forum, can and will be simply disregarded.

In the same vein, the petition’s use of the word ‘discipline’, while it is canonically correct, is liable to confusion in the public mind, and I would have avoided it. Canon 915 is a sacramental disciplinary norm (unlike, say, Canon 1331 on excommunication, which is a penal norm) but, to describe a bishop’s action under Canon 915 as a way to ‘discipline’ recalcitrant Catholic politicians seems to imply that some punishment is being inflicted on them. It is not, but it’s a distinction one would not expect lay readers to make. Thus, while the word ‘discipline’ is defendable here, I would have phrased it differently to avoid public confusion on the nature of the action being petitioned.

Interesting!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

You couldn’t make this up!

You couldn't make this up!I was alerted to the following ironic tidbit.

The embattled auxiliary bishop-elect of Linz was assigned the same titular diocese as that which was held by the late Archbishop Jean Jadot.

Zuri
(Titular See)

Zuitanus

Past and Present Ordinaries

    * Franz Joseph Fischer † (19 Dec 1929 Appointed – 24 Jul 1958 Died)
    * Auguste-Callixte-Jean Bonnabel † (13 Feb 1961 Appointed – 7 Nov 1967 Died)
    * Jean Jadot † (23 Feb 1968 Appointed – 21 Jan 2009 Died)
    * Gerhard Maria Wagner (31 Jan 2009 Appointed – Feb 2009 Resigned)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

Fr. Kennedy of Brisbane: See ya!

You know about the weird dissident Fr. Kennedy in Brisbane, who baptizes invalidly and doesn’t believe in the resurrection of Christ.

Now this.

Finally… finally…

Priest fired for unholy communion
Cosima Marriner
February 20, 2009
 
THE first Australian priest to be sacked from his parish for being "not in communion" with Rome has defied the Catholic hierarchy by promising to conduct Mass as usual this weekend.

In a decision that is likely to reverberate throughout the Catholic community, the Archbishop of Brisbane yesterday fired Father Peter Kennedy for unorthodox practices.  ["fired" and "sacked" … well …. translated into secular terms.]

Father Kennedy, of St Mary’s in South Brisbane, allows women to preach, blesses gay couples, denies the Virgin birth and claims the Church is dysfunctional.

It is the first time a priest has been sacked in Australia for breaking ranks with Rome and follows secret filming of unorthodox liturgies at St Mary’s and complaints to the Vatican by arch-conservative Catholics. [You can tell what side the writer is on.]

In his decree, the archbishop said Father Kennedy had "caused harm to ecclesiastical communion in spite of frequent requests from me to do otherwise". And in a statement he said: "This decision brings me no satisfaction as division within the Church is contrary to all that Christ taught."

Father Kennedy said he felt betrayed by the archbishop [incredible!  After the patience he has been shown.] but conceded that the parish he has led for 28 years was out of line with the teachings of the Church. "We have broken liturgical rules," he said yesterday. "We have treated people as adults, we have embraced gay and lesbian people, we have women coming into our community to preach."  [And preached pure heresy, as well.]

He said his liturgies were still valid. [except for those that aren’t] "We celebrate in a way that is relevant to Australian Catholics, rather than toeing the line in Rome."

Father Ken Howell will take over St Mary’s tomorrow as an administrator and has said he wants to work towards healing.

Father Kennedy will not go quietly. He plans to say Mass at 9am on Sunday and expects 1000 people to turn up. But he has backed away from threats that he would form a breakaway church. "I don’t wish to do that. We argue but we are very much within the Catholic tradition."

Instead he will formally appeal the archbishop’s decision, and until the matter is resolved he will continue attending St Mary’s.

Father Kennedy’s supporters were distraught at his sacking and predicted it would destroy the good work he had done.   [One can only hope.]

"People see this as the end of the community as we know it," a spokeswoman for the parish, Karyn Walsh, said.

"The decision about St Mary’s sends a message across all Catholic communities that you cannot have any diversity in relation to liturgy."

The church establishment has tired of Father Kennedy’s questioning of the "single
truths" of Catholicism. He airs conundrums of the faith that many followers wrestle with in private, describes the Virgin birth as "nonsense" and believes there should be a Vatican III to address doctrine for the 21st century.

Bye!

So loooooong!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

Mariawald Abbey: transition to TLM

From a reader:

You might be interested in the fact that, starting next monday, the Trappist abbey of Mariawald, Germany, will begin the transition to the usus antiquor. As can be seen here, daily Holy Mass in the "Tridentine Rite" is being announced. I do not know if this includes the Hours, too.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

BBC: SSPX Bp. Williamson expelled from Argentina

From BBC NEWS:

Argentina expels Holocaust bishop [What a nasty headline]

Argentina has ordered an ultra-traditionalist British bishop who denies the Holocaust to leave the country or face expulsion.

The Interior Ministry said Richard Williamson had been told he had 10 days to leave Argentina.

Earlier this month the bishop was removed from his post as the head of a Roman Catholic seminary in Argentina.  [Notice there is no additional distinction here.]

A row erupted in January after the Pope decided to lift Bishop Williamson’s excommunication on an unrelated matter.  [At least they got that right.]

The Vatican said the Pope had been unaware of Bishop Williamson’s views and had since ordered him to recant.

Outrage

Argentina’s Interior Ministry said on Thursday that Bishop Williamson "has concealed the true motive for his stay in the country" because he said he was an employee of a non-governmental group rather than declaring "his true activity" as the director of a seminary.  [?  So… is this the reason for the expulsion?]

Bishop Williamson’s views on the Holocaust have provoked outrage.

"I believe that the historical evidence is strongly against, is hugely against, six million Jews having been deliberately gassed in gas chambers as a deliberate policy of Adolf Hitler," he said.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
62 Comments

Sides being chosen

Two German Cardinals have spoke up in defense of Pope Benedict against the criticisms from bishops in Germany over the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops.

First, Walter Card. Kasper spoke bluntly with Vatican Radio about the anti-Roman attitude in the criticisms and that the Pope is following the what the Church must do in pursuit of unity.  Attacks on the Pope in this matter have been attacks on the Church herself.

Also, Paul Josef Card. Cordes on kreutz.net has gone after Card. Lehmann and others for criticism of the Pope’s move:  „Daß den Papst ein geistlich krankes Glied am Leib Christi seit Jahren schmerzt, gilt im besten Fall als Alterssentimentalität“ – analysiert Kardinal Cordes.  !

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

Exercises in intimidation: The Tablet attacks Fr. Finigan

UPDATE 2356 GMT 23 Feb.

The Tablet attempts to silence Fr. Finigan’s response.
__________________

UPDATE: 2014 GMT 19 Feb:

His Hermeneuticalness, Fr. Finigan responds.

__________________

I mentioned a while back that the UK’s ultra-leftist weekly, nicknamed "the bitter Pill", but regularly known as The Tablet was probably going to published an attack on Fr. Tim Finigan, P.P. of Our Lady of the Rosary in Blackfen near London.

This week they published a real hit piece.  A reader sent me the text.

Keep in mind that this article was written for no other reason that to discourage and intimidate priests in the UK from implementing Summorum Pontificum in their parishes.  Therefore, in this article, every tactic is used…. as you will see.

Here it is with my emphases and comments. 

That was not my Mass

by Elena Curti

Nearly 40 years ago, that was the comment of the keenest supporters of the Tridentine Rite as the new rite was introduced. Now the sentiment has been reversed in the suburban parish of Blackfen, where a priest’s introduction of traditionalist liturgy has split the parish  [But has it really?  Or is the "split" really a very small splinter group?]

Each Sunday at around 9.45 a.m. a team at Our Lady of the Rosary, Blackfen, in the south-eastern suburbs of Greater London, erects a wooden stepped platform faced in a marble-effect laminate on the altar. On this is placed a gold crucifix, six large candlesticks, vases of flowers and altar cards for the celebration of the old Latin Mass. Welcome to the parish of Fr Tim Finigan, popular blogger and leading light of the Latin Mass Society of England and Wales.

Fr Finigan is in the vanguard of priests determined to restore “tradition” to their parishes [notice the " "] and, step by step, he has introduced elements of the extraordinary form into the liturgy at his church. [So, it wasn’t a sudden imposition.] The centrepiece is the weekly Sunday Tridentine Mass at 10.30 a.m, introduced in the wake of the Pope’s motu proprio allowing wider celebration of the old rite. During his 11 years in charge he has also gradually brought in other traditionalist touches that have split the parish.  [Again, has it been "split"?]

Between 30 and 40 people no longer attend the church and a similar number have taken their place. [Yes… but that happens in the course of events anyway…. but read on.] The row about numbers has become so heated that supporters of Fr Finigan carefully count the numbers attending the Sunday morning old-rite Mass. [Not all that unusual to count in a parish, really.] An auxiliary in Southwark diocese, Bishop Pat Lynch, has been called in to mediate.

In what was once a fairly typical parish, [typical of what?] there are no extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist. [I have spent some time at that parish.  The church is quite small.  Even when full, there is no need for Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion – which is the proper term.  However, some people think they must be employed out of a false sense of the role of laity and active participation.] Altar rails have been installed and the parish priest makes it clear that he prefers communicants to kneel and to receive the Host on the tongue.  [He has the right to express his preference, I believe.] Communion is not usually offered under both species. [So?] At a regular Sunday evening Mass in the new rite, there are no bidding prayers and the congregation is not invited to exchange the sign of peace.  [The sign of peace is an option left to the discretion of the priest.] Fr Finigan says the Eucharistic Prayer with his back to the congregation [No, he doesn’t.  He is facing liturgical East together with his congregation.] with the stepped platform, properly called a gradine, on the altar. [I thought the "gradine" was the stepped part above and behind the altar.  Fr. Finigan must be pretty talented if he says Mass from there.] Unaccompanied hymn-singing has been dropped after the priest complained it was a “torture” to continue to inflict it on the assembly.  [Well….]

Old-rite Masses are also usually celebrated on major feast days including Midnight Mass, and there is a regular Mass in the extraordinary form on Saturday mornings. The ordinary form is used for the Saturday vigil Mass and the Sunday 9 a.m. children’s Mass. Weekday Masses are in the new rite. [Now… does that sound unreasonable?]

But Fr Finigan’s critics fear that their parish is gradually becoming a flagship for the Tridentine Rite. [And this is the REAL point of this whole exercise.  The liberals are terrified down to their spandex liturgical dance togs that the older form of Mass may exercise an influence over the faith of the Catholic people.]  They claim that most of those who welcome the trend are newcomers living outside the parish.  [So?  Liberals never travel to find the Mass they like?]

“Six parishioners wanted the Latin Mass here. I have no objection to them having it once a month or once a week, but it should not be the main Sunday Mass and it should not be imposed over the whole parish,” said Les Thomas, a member of the delegation that went to see Bishop Lynch. [Now… how would Mr. Thomas know that there were six?]

Mr Thomas is one of nine parishioners [6 versus 9!  This is sounding like a fluctus in simpulo.] I met who claim that Fr Finigan’s dedication to “tradition” has hurt the parish. Most of them have served as readers and/or Eucharistic ministers. [I seeee…. and since there is no real need for "Eucharistic Ministers", as the writer incorrectly calls them, they are bent out of shape?  Is the picture starting to come together?] Four say they can no longer bear to attend Mass at Blackfen, the rest doing so under sufferance. [They are free to stay or leave.  Sad, but if they have to go, farewell and come again when it suits you!]

“It is a matter of principle. I won’t be driven out,” [Who is being "driven" here?] says Eddie Sweeney, a former master of ceremonies and scoutmaster who has lived in the parish for 57 years. The group describe feelings of irritation, discomfort and sadness at the changes that have been made. Those who prefer to stand for Communion and receive it in the hand say they feel selfconscious doing so at Fr Finigan’s Masses.  [So.. is this about feelings?  I am getting the sense that it is not about what is right to do liturgically or what the rights of other Catholics may be regarding the Church’s worship.]

Several said their adult children vowed never to go to the church again, such was their unhappiness with the liturgy. “People who have been away from church come back at Christmas and Easter and are totally put off. It is so sad,” [What does that mean, exactly?  "Put off"?  They didn’t like something… their feelings were hurt.  What are they actually expecting in a church, in a Mass, I wonder.  What was their formation at home and in catechesis?] said Jean Gray. A woman who asked not to be named said she had known Fr Finigan for many years and he had been a “rock” supporting her family through some difficult times. But she felt moved to complain after she asked him to celebrate a Mass for her daughter’s favourite aunt who had recently died. She did not realise at the time that it would be entirely in Latin. “My daughter cried through most of the Mass because she could not join in. Afterwards she said: ‘That was not my Mass.’”

[At this point we have to stop.  First, we have the issue of "joining in".  There is a false understanding of "active participation" at work in a statement like that.  Also, the writer has been doing nothing but playing on feelings.  She is trying to tug at the readers emotions in order to plaint Fr. Finigan in a bad light.  You can’t argue with emotions.  That is the whole point here.  You cannot defend yourself from this sort of attack.  Remember that the point of this article is to intimidate other priests.]

Rules introduced include an insistence on silence in the church before and after Mass, which critics said meant there was little opportunity for parishioners to mingle afterwards, losing an important point of contact especially for the elderly. [WHAT?  This is ABSURD!  Again, I have been at this parish.  People mingle and talk outside, in the hall next to the church (which they can reach without going outside or by steps.   I stood outside and in the hall and chatted with people after Mass without problems. There is a parish PUB nearby for crying out loud!  This is a red herring.  Furthermore: churches are sacred spaces for the worship of God.  They are not meeting halls or parlors.]

There were also complaints about their priest’s refusal to support Cafod, [Catholic Agency for Overseas Development… I don’t know what the money goes toward or how it is distributed.  I suspect it is like the older version of the Campaign for Human Development in the US, which had questionable aspects.]  his expenditure on traditional vestments and other clerical garb, the absence of a parish council and failure to account to parishioners how money from the collection plate was being spent. [Okay… this is pretty nasty.  First, there is a usual liberal false dichotomy of "traditional" v. "concern for the poor".  If you have a nice chasuble, you must hate the poor and want to take the bread from their parched lips.  But Curti is now, in a newspaper, suggesting that Fr. Finigan is not using parish funds properly.  That is an underhanded thing to do as a journalist if you don’t have proof.  Also, I don’t know much about Cafod or what Fr. Finigan does or doesn’t do about it, but one time when I was at Blackfen, there was a special clothing drive going on to help children of poor families.  I also remember Fr. Finigan telling me about fixing the roof and doing much needed  brick and mortar work around the place.]

Matters came to a head last October when one parishioner, Bernard Wynne, a retired management consultant, set out his grievances in an email to Fr Finigan and asked for a parish consultation. He copied his message to a number of parishioners and invited them to make their views known.  [So… this fellow who wasn’t a parish trustee or anything other than a parishioner just decided on his own to do this.  I wonder what the real reason was.  Was he too an unnecessary minister of Communion?  Did he have his feelings hurt in some way and was striking back?] The ensuing correspondence resulted in about a dozen people objecting to Fr Finigan’s approach and about the same number supporting him.  [So, he stirred up unhappiness and created a split.  Nice.  I am reminded of Anthony Trollope’s The Warden and Barchester Towers wherein John Bold and Mr Slope stir up the bedesmen to make trouble for the warden, Mr Harding.  In the end, everyone is wounded … and all for nothing.]

In her email Susan Reynolds, a parishioner for 35 years wrote: “I grew up with the Latin Mass and remember sitting watching men and women saying the Rosary, slyly reading the newspaper or making responses they didn’t really understand. The English Mass made us participants and co-celebrants in the sacrifice of the Mass. The instruction to ‘open the windows and doors’ is one of the most liberating things to happen in the Catholic Church. If you listen carefully you can hear them being shut in Blackfen.”  [O brother!]

Fr Finigan’s response was a 35-page essay, in which he set out the thinking behind his use of the “traditional liturgy”. But it is in a lecture to the Latin Mass Society’s training conference at Oxford last year for priests learning how to celebrate the extraordinary form that he set out his strategy. He told the priests they were the “infantry” who need to overcome “real problems and difficulties” in bringing the extraordinary form to their parishes. He said the priest had a responsibility to persevere even in parishes where there were not a large number of people requesting the old rite.

Parish reaction to the introduction of the old rite would find a few “very favourable”, a few “strongly against”, and “the substantial majority who simply wonder what Father is doing now”. [sounds about right] It was, Fr Finigan said, “important not to neglect this majority of our parishioners in deference to a vocal minority”.  [A reasonable point, though admittedly the minority needs attention also.]

When I spoke to Fr Finigan he admitted there had not been a stable group at Blackfen who had requested Mass in the extraordinary form as set out in the motu proprio, [Huh?  Not even three?  That is all there is needed for a coetus. I thought there were six.] but over a period of time he said most parishioners had accepted the liturgy and some, particularly young people, had become very enthusiastic about the old Latin Mass. He pointed out the three Masses in the ordinary form that people could attend on Sundays, adding: “I am not going to be able to please everybody. I would like people to gradually be able to settle down and accept the way things are now.”  [reasonable]

The parish priest rejected the idea of a consultation [Again, the usual liberal line is that everything has to be done by consensus.] or the setting up of a parish council on the grounds that it would be a “bear pit”  and “people would be at each others’ throats”. With regard to the parish’s finances, he said he was arranging to get help so that a summary of income and expenditure could be published for parishioners.  [Okay… so he did in fact respond.]

Fr Finigan put me in touch with five parishioners who support the changes at Blackfen. One was a mother of seven-year-old twins, Wendy Kane, who lives just outside the parish boundary and has been attending Our Lady’s for seven years. She felt delighted with the liturgy and said it had strengthened her faith and that of her family, adding: “The extraordinary form is not what I grew up with and I never experienced it before. I personally find it a beautiful form of worship.”

Another supporter, Julia Jones, a 38- year-old teacher who moved to the parish last summer, said: “I have been very moved by the silence and palpable feeling of devotion, especially during the Eucharistic Prayer. I have gained greatly from the experience in only a few months. I really do believe that I have found ‘the pearl of great price’.”

Bishop Lynch said this week that the whole parish needs to build communion through prayer and social activities. “You need a situation where people respect diversity but can also come together,” he said.

Fr Finigan trained for the priesthood at the English College in Rome and has worked in parishes in south-east London for 23 years. Through his blog, The Hermeneutic of Continuity, which recently had its millionth hit, he has become well known. He is also a visiting tutor in Sacred Theology at St John’s Seminary, Wonersh; and there can be no doubt that he considers bringing the old rite to his parishioners central to his ministry.

Some welcome what Fr Finigan is doing. It is equally clear that some do not. If Fr Finigan is right, and the priest’s responsibility for the liturgy in his parish is absolute, there is nothing parishioners can do about it. And there could be many more Blackfens in the future. [And that, folks, is the real point of this article.]

The progressivists are terrified.

They are afraid that Fr. Finigan might succeed. 

They are attacking him in order to discourage other priests from doing what Fr. Finigan is accomplishing.

They hate what he stands for and they earnestly will work for his failure. 

And not just failure. 

They want him to fail and suffer in his failure.

They will do anything and to anyone to prevent the older form of Mass from resurging.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
119 Comments

Attack on the Pope by a group of European “rupture” theologians

A regular reader/commenter sent the following blurb from the "European Society for Catholic Theology".

Have you ever heard of this group?   Has anyone?

My interlocutor begins with a dry observation.

Joke of the day: "As Catholic theologians working in the service of the Church …. "

I have added my emphases.  Then I will present it again with my added comments.

Extra ET-Newsletter of the European Society for Catholic Theology
17/02/2009

This special ET-Newsletter contains a multilingual statement of the Curatorium of the European Society for Catholic Theology on the current crisis [!] in the Catholic Church.

We, Catholic theologians from 20 countries, gathered together in Ghent for a meeting of the Curatorium (Board) of the European Society for Catholic Theology, are deeply concerned by the current crisis within the Church. We are especially worried that the unconditional lifting of the excommunication of four bishops of the Society of Saint Pius X threatens the internal unity of the Church and the credibility of its witness in the world (Gaudium et spes). This considerably weakens the ability of theologians to dialogue with other disciplines in the academy.

Fundamental issues are at stake with regard to the reception of the Second Vatican Council and must be clearly reaffirmed:

•    The dynamic character of revelation and tradition, Church teaching and liturgy (Dei verbum, Sacrosanctum concilium)
•    The collegial exercise of Church governance (Lumen gentium)
•    Full respect for the freedom of conscience and the freedom of religion (Dignitatis humanae)
•    The active commitment to ecumenical and interreligious dialogue (Unitatis redintegratio, Nostra aetate)

Members of other Christian Churches, with whom we have been in dialogue for several decades, now question whether the Catholic Church will take concrete steps toward fuller communion. Recent events demonstrate that a great majority of Christians have lost confidence that Rome is committed to taking seriously the newness of Vatican II. This crisis of confidence is grave.

As Catholic [?] theologians working in the service of the Church, we hope that every effort will be undertaken to restore confidence in order that the gospel of Jesus Christ may be proclaimed.

Ghent, 15th February 2009.

Okay…. let us go at this again and pull it apart.

First, there is a premise: virtually everyone whom this group likes (basically Protestants) have "lost confidence" in the Church’s commitment to ecumenical dialogue.

What they are really saying is that they don’t like the present trend in dialogue, that is, more and more the Holy See under Pope Benedict is refusing to compromise Catholic teaching for the sake of dialogue.  For example, the CDF put out a document clarifying that the Church doesn’t consider some Protestant groups even to be "churches" in the strict sense, it will be possible to have a group of conservative Anglicans come into communion, and it is possible that the SSPX – with their own views of tradition – might really be Catholics too.

Notice that they focused on the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops as the spark for their "crisis".  

The SSPX has introduced into the internal conversation of the Church the need to clarify what the Second Vatican Council taught about a range of issues have to do with religious freedom and ecumenism.  If the SSPX can have a voice, they will change the way Catholics will read and receive the Council.

Time and time again I have made this point on this blog.  The SSPX represents a terrifying probability that more than one view of the Council is possible, that people can disagree about it and still be Catholic. 

Note also their alarm about liturgy.

So, let’s look at this again.

We, Catholic theologians [It might be hard to reconcile this first claim with the CDF’s document on the ecclesial vocation of the theologian.] from 20 countries, gathered together in Ghent for a meeting of the Curatorium (Board) of the European Society for Catholic Theology, are deeply concerned by the current crisis within the Church. [The "crisis" being that their grip on power is slipping.  The "spirit" of the Council may no longer be a super-dogma.  The "hermeneutic of rupture" may no longer prevail.] We are especially worried that the unconditional lifting of the excommunication of four bishops of the Society of Saint Pius X threatens the internal unity of the Church and the credibility of its witness in the world (Gaudium et spes). [They do not state what the condition might have been, but I am sure it is along the lines of unconditional acceptance of everything these guys think the Council meant, regardless of how our past teaching might seem out of harmony with what they are proposing about the Council.  Note also how the reintegration of a separated group, for them, threatens internal unity!  Just what is their vision of unity?] This considerably weakens the ability of theologians to dialogue with other disciplines in the academy. [This is cowardly. The Pope’s Regensburg Address and what he did at La Sapienza gives the lie to this craven statement.]

Fundamental issues are at stake with regard to the reception of the Second Vatican Council and must be clearly reaffirmed: [This is the important part.  For them, only one reading of the Council, according to the "spirit" they no doubt are privileged to discern, is permitted.]

•    The dynamic character of revelation and tradition, Church teaching and liturgy (Dei verbum, Sacrosanctum concilium)   [They connect doctrine and liturgy and call it dynamic.  But by "dynamic" they mean "changing", in the sense of rupture, not continuity.]
•    The collegial exercise of Church governance (Lumen gentium)  [They don’t believe the Pope should actually have the ability to govern.  They want a reduction of the power of Rome and autonomy for local communities.]
•    Full respect for the freedom of conscience and the freedom of religion (Dignitatis humanae)  [What they mean here is that people’s own determinations, apart from the teaching of the Church or natural law, should have precedence.  They want a man-centered, man-oriented religion.]
•    The active commitment to ecumenical and interreligious dialogue (Unitatis redintegratio, Nostra aetate)  [What they want is to abandon clear expression of Catholic doctrine for the sake of a false unity.  And who are they talking about among these other Christians?  What groups?]

Members of other Christian Churches, with whom we have been in dialogue for several decades, now question whether the Catholic Church will take concrete steps toward fuller communion. [Gratis asseritur, gratis negatur.] Recent events demonstrate that a great majority of Christians have lost confidence [Who says?  These clowns?] that Rome is committed to taking seriously the newness of Vatican II. This crisis of confidence is grave.

As Catholic theologians working in the service of the Church, we hope that every effort will be undertaken to restore confidence in order that the gospel of Jesus Christ may be proclaimed.  [In other words, Pope Benedict, stop doing what you are doing.]

Ghent, 15th February 2009.

Right now the liberal progressivists have sensed, as wolves do, that the Pope has been weakened.  They are therefore striking at him from all sides.

This organization, to which I doubt anyone very serious has ever paid attention, is another example of how these disciples of rupture, worshiping at the ever shifting altar of a man-centered religion, under the aegis of the Doctor Equivocus, Father Rahner, are striking out at the Vicar of Christ.

That means the Pope is doing something right.

I remember years ago in the corridor of the Palazzo del Sant’Uffizio, I asked Cardinal Ratzinger how he took the constant unfair criticism.  I had read that day a terrible article about him in an Italian daily.

He said, "If I don’t read an article like that every week or so, I have to examine my conscience."

If it weren’t so sad and damaging to the faithful, watching them flail around like wounded lampreys might have been entertaining.

 

PS: I wonder if His Eminence Card. Brady wants to appear at the conference this group sponsors.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
40 Comments

TIME: Catholics are worked up for nothing about FOCA

The dreadful Time has a piece about FOCA

My emphases and comments.

The Catholic Crusade Against a Mythical Abortion Bill
By Amy Sullivan / Washington Thursday, Feb. 19, 2009

The U.S. Catholic Church’s crusade [NB: when liberals use the word "crusade", that is a bad word meant to make the Church look bad.] against the Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) has all the hallmarks of a well-oiled lobbying campaign. A national postcard campaign is flooding the White House and congressional offices with messages opposing FOCA, and the Catholic bishops have made defeating the abortion rights legislation a top priority. In the most recent effort to stop the bill, Cardinal Justin Rigali of Philadelphia sent a letter to every member of Congress imploring them to "please oppose FOCA."

There is only one hitch. Congress isn’t about to pass the Freedom of Choice Act because no such bill has been introduced.  [I have wondered aloud if FOCA isn’t just a head feint to keep people focused in the wrong direction while they undermine pro-life legislation in other ways.]

At a time when the United States is gripped by economic uncertainty and faces serious challenges in hot spots around the globe, some American Catholics are finding it both curious and troubling that their church has launched a major campaign against a piece of legislation that doesn’t exist and wouldn’t have much chance of becoming law even if it did. To many critics, it feels like the legislative equivalent of the the Dog That Didn’t Bark. (See 25 People to Blame for the Financial Crisis.)  [This is an echo of the idea that "pro-life" issues are really not as important as other issues.  We should not focus on abortion when we have all these other burning issues to worry about.]

The campaign against FOCA, which would essentially codify the Roe v. Wade decision [and THAT is why Catholics should oppose it] by saying the government can’t place limits on abortions performed before viability, began shortly after Barack Obama’s election in November, at the annual general meeting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB). In a unanimous decision, the bishops voted "to mobilize the resources of the USCCB, dioceses and the entire Catholic community" to oppose the Freedom of Choice Act.

A chain e-mail of unknown origin soon began making its way into Catholic inboxes, warning of an imminent threat to the anti-abortion cause. "For those of you who do not know," it read, "the Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) is set to be signed if Congress passes it on January 21-22 of 2009. The FOCA is the next sick chapter in the book of abortion." The e-mail urged Catholics to say a novena — a devotion of dedicated prayer for nine successive days — beginning on January 11 and ending on Inauguration Day. (See pictures of Pope Benedict XVI’s trip to America.)

When January 22 came and went without a Freedom of Choice Act becoming law, the USCCB’s Committee on Pro-Life Activities announced a nationwide postcard campaign to blanket congressional offices and the White House with appeals to stop FOCA. Anti-FOCA groups on Facebook soon had more than 150,000 members and added thousands more each day. Priests started preaching against the legislation and churches began circulating petitions to oppose its passage.

In the midst of all this activity, the fact that there was no Freedom of Choice Act before the 111th Congress went largely unnoticed and unmentioned.

A Freedom of Choice Act was first introduced in the 108th and 110th Congresses (from ’03 to ’05 and ’07 to ’09, respectively), by Rep. Jerold Nadler, a New York Democrat. It was developed at a time when the future of Roe was in doubt because it was unclear if George W. Bush would have the opportunity to appoint another justice to the Supreme Court. But FOCA had a hard time gaining traction — even under Democratic control of Congress, the bill was not only never voted on but never made it out of committee. [Will anyone have the political will to push it through?] And now abortion rights advocates are breathing easier with Obama in the White House — so much so that when a coalition of 63 organizations sent the Administration its top 15 priorities for reproductive rights and health, FOCA did not even make the list. (See pictures of Barack Obama’s Inauguration.)

Congressional Democrats have also been less than enthusiastic about the proposal. A spokesman for Nadler says that while he expects the legislation will be reintroduced, "it won’t be anytime soon." Even if FOCA is reintroduced in the current Congress, Speaker of the House [pro-abortion] Nancy Pelosi has indicated she has no intention of bringing it up for a vote. And even if she did, there are not enough votes in Congress to pass the bill.

In some respects, President Obama only has himself to blame for the current controversy. As a presidential candidate, the then-Senator himself pointed a spotlight on the legislation he co-sponsored when he told the Planned Parenthood Action Fund in 2007 that "the first thing I’d do as President is sign the Freedom of Choice Act. That’s the first thing I’d do."

But FOCA has also provided ammunition for those on the right who want to paint Obama as "the most pro-abortion president ever." It’s been less than a month since he took office, but so far the President has given social conservatives little evidence to back up that charge. He did repeal the Mexico City policy banning federal funds to foreign family planning organizations that provide abortion referrals or services — but so did Bill Clinton. At the same time, Obama has directed his Presidential Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships to make the issue of abortion reduction one of its top priorities.

Still, FOCA is proving to be the perfect political issue for anti-abortion advocates — and for congressional Republicans, who have taken up the cry as well. Unless and until FOCA is voted on by Congress, they can invoke it as a looming threat. And the longer it remains a dormant issue, the more credit they can take for their own "proactive" efforts to "defeat FOCA," as a letter from House Republicans to Cardinal Rigali on Tuesday put it.

James Salt, director of organizing for the progressive organization Catholics United, thinks the USCCB has been prodded into focusing on FOCA by misinformation from right-wing groups. "These right-wing organizations are deliberatively misleading people in order to stoke the culture war," says Salt. "They’re using this as a fundraising tool, as a way to gin up their relevancy. And unfortunately some of these groups have the ear of certain bishops."

After worried parishioners started contacting Catholics United about the postcard campaign, the group sent out an alert to its supporters telling them that "FOCA is not going anywhere" and urging them to contact their local bishops. "In this time of increasing job layoffs, poverty, and food insecurity across America, we should instead be calling on Catholics to commit increased resources to helping children and families survive the collapsing economy," read the message. 

Some of the USCCB’s own policy staffers are reportedly frustrated by the attention given to FOCA. And a few Catholic officials have even taken the rare step of speaking out to correct misinformation about the issue.

While the USCCB’s literature about FOCA has been generally accurate, the chain e-mail has disseminated a number of false claims, including warnings that the proposal would force Catholic hospitals to shut down and lead to at least 100,000 more abortions each year. Some versions of the e-mail even claimed that FOCA could "result in a future amendment that would force women by law to have abortions in certain situations — and even regulate how many children women are allowed to have."

In response, Catholic News Service — the official news agency affiliated with the USCCB — ran an article that began, "Internet rumors to the contrary, no Catholic hospital in the United States is in danger of closing because of the Freedom of Choice Act." Sister Carol Keehan, president and CEO of the Catholic Health Association, told the news agency that the legislation "has never contained anything that would force Catholic hospitals or Catholic personnel to do abortions or to participate in them." She added, "I don’t believe that FOCA will pass." [Really?]

 

So… what is this article trying to accomplish.  After all… if it is in Time it isn’t just news.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments