UPDATE: Archd. of Manila’s “guidelines” on Summorum Pontificum

From a reader:

Just to let you know that the Archdiocese of Manila has apparently pulled out the "guidelines" from H.E. Card. Rosales on Summorum Pontificum.

The link is gone from the main page, and from the page of the Cardinal’s homilies (where it was before), and from the Ministry of Liturgy’s info…

If one runs a search of the site (say "summorum"), one can only find the original 2007 clarifying notes, effective on September of 2007…
The link to these is here.

However, you can still google the guidelines, and it will bring the original document up… so it seems the page administrators removed all links, but the actual page of the document is still active at this link.

In other words, they haven’t been retracted.  They have been buried.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

S. Philly TLM wrap up

The following was in the South Philly Review.

My emphases and comments.

Missa Cantata
by Lorraine Gennaro

In honor of the feast of conversion of its namesake, St. Paul’s celebrated a Latin Mass for the first time since Vatican II introduced the modern Mass some 40 years ago.

Many St. Paul parishioners had tears in their eyes, including the Catholic church’s Business Manager Jim Capaldi. Antoine O’Karma remembers feeling swept away, almost entranced, by the chanting and singing. But perhaps Josephine Zampirro said it best, “I felt like it was a little bit of heaven on earth.” [It is not uncommon to find Porta Caeli inscribed on the doors of churches.]

Beautiful, sacred, awe-inspiring are just some of the words parishioners used to describe Missa Cantata, [The whole point of worship is the experience of awe at transcendence.] one of three types of traditional Latin Mass that were celebrated Jan. 25 at the 808 Hutchinson St. church.

“It was absolutely beautiful,” O’Karma, from the 500 block of Federal Street, who attended with 14-year-old daughter Elizabeth, said.

Zampirro, 67, from the 700 block of Alter Street, added, “The music, the prayers, the reverence. Every time the altar boys brought the priest something they kissed his hand. Everything was done with such reverence.”

The packed house of more than 150 parishioners witnessed history in the making as the Rev. Gerald Carey celebrated traditional Latin Mass (also called Latin Mass) for his first time. [!] For St. Paul, it was the first since Vatican II some 40 years ago introduced Novus Ordo, or the modern Mass, thereby ousting the old and bringing in the new. While the Latin Mass was not banned [good distinction] by Vatican II, it died a quick death — priests embracing the new in an attempt to change with the times. While Vatican II did away with requiring women to cover their heads, often with veils, [I like this writer.  "often with veils".. a good distinction.  However, it was actually the 1983 Code of Canon Law which dropped the prescription.] many females who attended the ceremony at St. Paul returned to tradition. For Zampirro who always wears a hat to services, it was nice to see so many embrace the past ways “in keeping with the old Catholic tradition,” she said.

The decision to resurrect Mass was Carey’s idea to honor the feast of the conversion of St. Paul, Capaldi said.  [Hopefully we will not have to speak in terms of "resurrection" too much longer.]

Carey, a former director of worship for the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, was on vacation and could not be reached for comment.

Archdiocese spokeswoman Donna Farrell did not return a call for comment on St. Paul’s Latin Mass celebration. [Interesting.  You might might that, during the Pauline Year, at a Church named St. Paul, there might be some comment.]

St. Paul is the only church in the area and Center City to celebrate Latin Mass, [that surely means Novus Ordo as well] while Overbrook’s Our Lady of Lords and Tacony’s Our Lady of Consolation offer it weekly.

“There’s nothing in Center City or South Philadelphia on a regular basis,” Capaldi said.  [In a city like Philadelphia…]

Three elements characterize Latin Mass: Parishioners kneel at the altar and receive communion on the tongue [if they can kneel] ­— as opposed to modern Mass where people line up down the aisle, [The manner of Communion is not described in the Novus Ordo.  People could also line up for the older Mass.] approach the altar and have the option of taking the Body of Christ via hand or tongue; the priest celebrates Mass with his back to the congregation, facing the altar, in “ad orientem” — meaning “to the East,” [well… that mitigates the "back to the people" comment] where all altars once faced — as opposed to facing the congregants; and altar servers are male only, not a mix of genders. Heavy use of incense is another component.  [It can be in the NO as well.]

There are three types of this service: Low Mass, which is devoid of music except for maybe an opening or closing hymn; High Mass or Missa cantata, which is Latin for “sung Mass” and celebrated with one priest and schola, or a singer or choir, who chants parts of the service; and Solemn High Mass, which is celebrated with a priest, deacon and sub-deacon and schola.

Last month’s celebration at St. Paul featured its Missa Brevis, the part of the Mass comprised of the Curia, [!] Gloria, Offertory, Communion and Sanctus, by Italian composer Giovanni Palestrinia. In need of those versed in Latin, Carey went out-of-house and hired Robert Hall, who led the 10-member schola and organist Robert Ridgella.

“During the Credo, it brought tears to my eyes. It was just beautiful. The reaction of the people was the same,” Capaldi said.

O’Karma, 43, found the music especially moving.

“I honestly filled with the spirit while I was there. I felt like the music carried me away. I just felt lifted by the music. It was almost hypnotic ­— the chanting,” she said.

Many Catholics clearly remember the Latin Mass, or, as it may be referred to, “the way things used to be.” [The way things are again.]

For Capaldi, 58, who grew up at Sixth and Carpenter streets and was an altar boy in St. Mary Magdalene De Paza [!] parish, which merged with St. Paul in 2000, last month’s service was a taste of nostalgia. [grrr]

“I remember the Latin Mass very well. I served the Latin Mass back in the ’60s before it was changed. It’s more sacred to me. You have more time to pray. The new Mass [priests] are always talking at you. The priest is to offer the Mass. The Mass is a recreation of Calvary. It’s a solemn occasion, not something to be taken lightly,” the Springfield, Delaware County, resident said.

But it’s interaction O’Karma likes with the modern service and, as moving the Latin Mass was, she said she doesn’t think she would like it every Sunday.

“I really do enjoy the modern Mass. I like being part of the Mass,” the lifelong St. Mary Magdalene parishioner said.  [WDTPRSers know how confused this statement is.]

As for Elizabeth, her mother said the teen found the service rather lengthy.  [Attention spans are getting shorter.  Have her go for a year, and then give an opinion.]

“My daughter thought it was extremely long, but it didn’t feel like that,” O’Karma said of the two-hour session.  [Imagine… 2 hours out of a week in a church for God.]

Modern services are about 45 minutes to an hour, depending ­ largely — ask any Catholic — on how long a sermon the priest gives.

Advertised in The Catholic Standard & Times, spread through word-of-mouth and posted on a couple of Catholic blogs by Capaldi, [oh?] the event drew many non-parishioners, as well as members of the Philadelphia Latin Liturgy Association. Those who missed out will have another chance to experience it at St. Paul at the end of June — about the time the feast of Ss. Peter and Paul commences, drawing to a close the year of St. Paul Pope Benedict XVI declared last summer to commemorate the saint’s 2,000th birthday. Beyond that, Capaldi can’t say if Latin Mass [grrrr] will become a regular thing, but he for one would love to see it become so.

“Pope Benedict is very much in favor of this Mass and going back to Catholic tradition” Capaldi said. “To me, it seems that our Catholic identity is gone and I believe our Holy Father is working to restore that. [Sound familiar?] This is a great step in the right direction.”

Posted in Brick by Brick |
18 Comments

What happens when we get out of the way

I am convinced that if we simply follow the liturgical books, say the texts and carry out the gestures properly, in a style continuous with our tradition, the Church’s liturgy has power the capture minds and hearts and transform them.

I starting forming this conviction before I became a Catholic through my experience of Novus Ordo Masses done in an entirely Roman traditional style, closely following the books. 

The late Msgr. Richard Schuler would eventually articulate to me in words what I was experiencing in the church.  "Just do what the Council asked… do what the Church asks."

Why is worship well executed according to the mind of the Church so effective? 

Christ is the true Actor in the sacred action of the Church’s worship.  He makes our hands and voices His own as He raises our petitions and offerings to the Father for His glory and our salvation.

Christ’s Holy Church has determined the way by which we may have this encounter with mystery in the liturgy, be taken up in the sacred action.

Pope Benedict addresses this in his highly ignored Sacramentum caritatis.  He teaches sacred ministers about ars celebrandi, our purpose and comportment.

We must learn to get out of His way.

Although we have the right to our Rite celebrated as the Church desires, liturgy is not about me or us or even you in the pews.

All of this is a preamble to a note sent me by a priest friend overseas (edited):

Fr. Z,  I have a story to tell and I am not bragging at all but my point is simply how good it is just doing things the way they should be done without putting one’s personality in the forefront. 

A lady came to my Sunday Mass just this last Sunday and she stopped by the sacristy to tell me that I say the Mass better than any priest in ____.  We have 7 priests here in total.  I had never seen or spoken to her before so any partiality is non existent.  Also, the Saturday evening before, I said the evening Mass in another town … and after Mass an elderly lady said to me, "What a beautiful Mass.  We’ve never seen such a nice Mass and to think! .. We had to get it from an American!" 

I am not bragging because I didn’t do anything special.  I say Mass soberly and simply preach.  I am truly convinced that less personality is better and is liberating during the Mass except when showing enthusiasm for Catholicity and all its realities during the homily.  I owe a great deal of my formation to you for I learned the Mass on my own and my attitude was formed in a very large part through my disposition and the truths of liturgy that you have taught.

This not a hard formula friends.

All we need to do is what the Church asks.

We just pass on what we have received.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Mail from priests, SESSIUNCULA |
53 Comments

Fr. L … Fr. L… Quid feci tibi…

The esteemed Fr. Longenecker, about whom I have always written kindly in these cyber-pages, has come forth – after a retreat mind you! – with yet another attack on YOU, the readers of WDTPRS.

We will bear this rough treatment, undeserved as it is, with our accustomed restraint. But there a few points to which I – always your advocate gentle readers – must in justice respond.

To wit… his latest offering, here below with my emphases and comments.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Eggplant Priest?
After my two priest fashion posts sporting my biretta there was a deafening silence from King Z. and his supporters. [Silence?  Nooo… we laughed and laughed!  Some probably went "tisk" a couple times for good measure.]

Not a word about the splendid photograph of myself with an army of servers surrounding their hatted priest.   [Sed contra, we did post about Father’s (photoshopped?) biretta on 9 Feb., but under this entry.  Could it be that because he did not see his own name he didn’t notice the large photo of himself and our comments about his head gear?  I’m just askin’.]

No evidence of headgear from the ‘Galloping Gourmet’ of priests, (or shall we dub him the ‘Prandial Priest’ or the ‘Culinary Cleric’?)   [ Fr. Z never has need to demonstrate his readiness for the biretta….   o{];¬)   ]

Instead in this post he tells us how to make eggplant parmesan. (‘eggplant’ is another name for zucchini. [!? *] Perhaps this is why he is called Fr.Z). Anyway, in the closing comments of his post he makes a cryptic comment about my attendance at a ‘non ferraiuolo’ dinner. 

[You see, dear friends?  Quid feci tibi, p. L, responde mihi!  I reveal my openness to inviting Fr. L for a meal, with comments that I would do my best even to improve upon what I had made, and he throws this out.  Very nice!  Very nice indeed!]

Whatever could he mean? Should I be invited to taste one of the good father’s sumptious dinners I would of course appear in my full regalia.  [Despite the indications given in the invitation… oh well.]

Do I have such a ferraiuolo? Do I ever wear it?

Stay tune for photographs that will clinch the contest once and for all…  [In other words, he is trying to borrow one.]

[*] UPDATE: Readers have corrected me: Eggplant is not zucchini. Eggplant is called an aubergine. Zucchini is the same as courgettes. This is one of the problems of being Anglo-American. You say tom ah to and I say tom ay to.

 

By the way… in his post about being on retreat, we read the following from Fr. L about chosing a view:

 

Make sure there’s a couple of trees and some bird life maybe.  

 

Imitation is the highest form of flattery.

And now he has started his own online culinary offerings, though I suspect there may be just a touch of irony involved. 

The things we must bear….

In any event… help WDTPRS in the Blogger’s Choice Awards. 

Fr. L ... Fr. L... Quid feci tibi...

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
39 Comments

Rabbi: left-wing is destroying the Catholic Church

A friend alerted me to this great article from LifeSite!

I ask bloggers, please, to consider posting this on your own sites.

My emphases and comments.

Left Wing of the Catholic Church Destroying the Faith Says Orthodox Rabbi

By Hilary White, Rome correspondent
Wednesday February 11, 2009

ROME, February 11, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – The dissident, leftist movement in the Catholic Church over the last forty years has severely undermined the teaching of the Catholic Church on the moral teachings on life and family, [fantastic!] a prominent US Orthodox rabbi told LifeSiteNews.com. Rabbi Yehuda Levin, the head of a group of 800 Orthodox rabbis in the US and Canada, also dismissed the accusations that the Holy See had not sufficiently distanced itself from the comments made by Bishop Richard Williamson of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) on the Holocaust.

"I support this move" to reconcile the traditionalist faction in the Church, he said, "because I understand the big picture, which is that the Catholic Church has a problem. There is a strong left wing of the Church that is doing immeasurable harm to the faith."  [Peter was Jewish.  Can Rabbi Levin be Pope after Pope Benedict?  Maybe 20 years from now?]

Rabbi Levin said that he understands "perfectly" why the reconciliation is vital to the fight against abortion and the homosexualist movement.  [The man-centered view of the left detaches morals from reality.]

"I understand that it is very important to fill the pews of the Catholic Church not with cultural Catholics and left-wingers who are helping to destroy the Catholic Church and corrupt the values of the Catholic Church." This corruption, he said, "has a trickle-down effect to every single religious community in the world." [What an admission!]

"What’s the Pope doing? He’s trying to bring the traditionalists back in because they have a lot of very important things to contribute the commonweal of Catholicism. [YES YES YES!]

"Now, if in the process, he inadvertently includes someone who is prominent in the traditionalist movement who happens to say very strange things about the Holocaust, is that a reason to throw out the baby with the bathwater and start to condemn Pope Benedict? Absolutely not."

During a visit to Rome at the end of January, Rabbi Levin told LifeSiteNews.com that he believes the media furore over the lifting of the excommunications of the four bishops of the Society of Saint Pius X is a red herring. He called "ridiculous" the accusations that in doing so Pope Benedict VXI or the Catholic Church are anti-Semitic and described as "very strong" the statements distancing the Holy See and the Pope from Williamson’s comments.

Rabbi Levin was in Rome holding meetings with high level Vatican officials to propose what he called a "new stream of thinking" for the Church’s inter-religious dialogue, one based on commonly held moral teachings, particularly on the right to life and the sanctity of natural marriage.

"The most important issue," he said, is the work the Church is doing "to save babies from abortion, and save children’s minds, and young people’s minds, helping them to know right and wrong on the life and family issues."

"That’s where ecumenism and inter-religious dialogue has to go."

Although numbers are difficult to determine, it is estimated that the Society of St. Pius X has over a million followers worldwide. The traditionalist movement in the Catholic Church is noted for doctrinal orthodoxy and enthusiasm not only for old-fashioned devotional practices, but for the Church’s moral teachings and opposition to post-modern secularist sexual mores. [And this is why progressivists will fight their reintegration in the mainstream Church.]  Liberals in the Church, particularly in Europe, have bitterly opposed all overtures to the SSPX and other traditionalists, particularly the Pope’s recent permission to revive the traditional Latin Mass.  [The TLM is the monster under their bed.]

The Vatican announced in early January that, as part of ongoing efforts to reconcile the breakaway group, the 1988 decree of excommunication against the Society had been rescinded. Later that month, a Swedish television station aired an interview, recorded in November 2008, in which Bishop Richard Williamson, one of the four leaders of the Society, said that he did not believe that six million Jews were killed in the Nazi death camps during World War II.

At that time, the media erupted with protests and accusations that the Catholic Church, and especially Pope Benedict XVI, are anti-Semitic.

Rabbi Levin particularly defended Pope Benedict, saying he is the genius behind the moves of the late Pope John Paul II to reconcile the Church with the Jewish community.  [HO HO!  The libs aren’t going to like that suggestion!  They will attack the Rabbi especially on this point, suggesting that it was all JP II and had nothing to do with Card. Ratzinger… who is German, btw.]

"Anyone who understands and follows Vatican history knows that in the last three decades, one of the moral and intellectual underpinnings of the papacy of Pope John Paul II, was Cardinal Ratzinger.

"And therefore, a lot of the things that Pope John Paul did vis-à-vis the Holocaust, he [Benedict] might have done himself, whether it was visiting Auschwitz or visiting and speaking in the synagogues or asking forgiveness. A lot of this had direct input from Cardinal Ratzinger. Whoever doesn’t understand this doesn’t realise that this man, Pope Benedict XVI, has a decades-long track record of anti-Nazism and sympathy for the Jews."

Oh, what a great article.

Share this one around, folks!  E-mail it.  Bloggers!  Highlight it!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
82 Comments

Fr. R. Sirico responds to Freep about Pope Benedict

Fr. Robert Sirico, head of the Acton Institute, responded properly in the Detroit News to a slimy editorial in the Detroit Free Press.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

Vatican’s error doesn’t shift Catholic church’s rejection of anti-Semitism

Tuesday, February 10, 2009
Fr. Robert Sirico: Faith and policy

Pope Benedict XVI has certainly earned his salary these past few days. In his attempt to heal a schism, he inadvertently set off a fire storm.

The pontiff lifted the excommunication of four bishops illicitly ordained in 1988 by the late Archbishop Marcel Lefevbre, whose dissent from the Second Vatican Council drew a small but fervent following. One of these bishops, Richard Williamson, is a Holocaust denier.

To understand the saga, it is necessary to peel back its layers.  [Good phrase.]

Lefevbre’s followers supported him because of a devotion to the traditional form of what is known as the Latin mass. [though WDTPRSers know that term is insufficient…] A smaller number rejected the efforts of Vatican II to account for the modern world by engaging in ecumenical relations and a deepened appreciation for religious tolerance and human liberty. 

Part of their complaint, correctly in my estimation, was that an excessively optimistic outlook that saw everything new as automatically good was wrong and weakened Catholic identity. [This is without doubt correct.  I add that, in addition to the euphoria of the moment (both the composition of the texts and their subsequent distortion) there was deemphasis of the centrality of Christ and over stressing of man in the prime documents concerned with how the Church works in and with the modern world.] This would result in a spiritual malaise and moral mediocrity that would ultimately become unattractive and deadening.

History bears out their insight. But as G.K. Chesterton once observed, "Heresy is truth gone mad."  [Indeed.  Heresies usually rise up from an effort to protect something good.  In doing so, they stray from something else.]

Bishop Williamson, for sometime evidently, has been a marginal character, a fact that the Vatican and the pope admittedly should have known but did not. Some preliminary effort should have gone into uncovering Williamson’s conspiratorialist propensities. An assessment of the communications failure by the Vatican is appropriate.

The bishop now has a choice to make: Paddle farther out into the swamp (the Lefevbrites having already silenced him), or pull back and recant.  [Third option: pull back and then do nothing.] The Vatican has demanded that Bishop Williamson "absolutely, unequivocally and publicly distance himself from his views concerning the Shoah, which were unknown to the Holy Father at the moment he lifted the excommunication."

Unless the bishop comes to see the historical absurdity and moral obtuseness of his assertions, he will have no ministry in the church. [Which is fine.]

As it is, the lifting of the excommunication of the bishops did not re-establish full communion between these men and the Roman Catholic Church. They remain suspended priests, [and bishops] forbidden from practicing their ministry. They will remain so until some resolution is achieved about their full adherence to the authority of the pope, which would include the authority of Vatican II. The lifting of the excommunication begins the discussion, but does not settle it.

Among the documents that Vatican II published is "The Declaration on the Relation of the Church with Non-Christian Religions" that emphatically decries all forms of anti-Semitism. Whether the bishops follow the teaching of this document will be followed carefully.

Certainly the pope, Joseph Ratzinger, knows full well the evil of denying the very evil he witnessed at close range. Ratzinger grew up in a family that resisted the fascists. As a child in his native Germany, he refused to attend the mandatory Hitler Youth meetings. And a cousin with Down syndrome was euthanized by the Nazis as part of their war against the disabled. Ratzinger has spoken out repeatedly and consistently against anti-Semitism as a priest, bishop, cardinal and now pope.

It’s possible that when people are offered the opportunity to come in from the cold, they may learn the lesson of reciprocal responsibility, [good!] which is what civilized life is mostly about. But sometimes they don’t. Some of the reaction to the lifting of the excommunications is justified.

But some of the reaction smacks of opportunism by politicians, theologians and even some bishops who have other axes to grind with Pope Benedict.

For those of us inspired by Pope Benedict’s efforts at the renewal of the church’s liturgy and life, [therefore our identity] it is sad that what might have been an occasion for a spiritual deepening — both for Catholics and with those outside the Church — has instead turned into a political imbroglio.

Father Robert Sirico is president of the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty in Grand Rapids. Send letters to The News at 615 W. Lafayette, Detroit, MI 48226 or (313) 496-5253 or letters@detnews.com.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments

The Nightmare for Progressivists

The post by Mosebach got me thinking about something I have drilled at for a while now.

Libs, progressivists, what ever you call them, are functioning within a blinkered paradigm.

They have raised what they imagine the Council was about to a dogma outstripping all other dogmas, a new beginning, a reemergence from the darkness,.  The SSPX reminds them that the Council is one Council among many and that it can be questioned on some points. 

The Nightmare for ProgressivistsBut going beyond that more intellectual stance, the SSPXers and all those other people, priests and lay within the Church who desired continuity with tradition, defended against the libs something viscerally terrifying:
 
A liturgy focused on MYSTERY… MYSTERY BOTH FEARSOME AND ALLURING.

Mysterium tremendum et fascinans.  For liberals what the older form of Mass proposes is far more dreadful than it is attractive.

It is for them an encounter with the monster under the bed.   They recoil from it.

ALL people recoil from mystery!  It is terrifying!  

But true Catholics with vera fides find that terrifying encounter also profoundly alluring. 

And so people with that Catholic sense draw closer, quaking but inching forward all the same, eyes cast down and nevertheless seeking what may be within, seeking the encounter which will suck them dry but in turn fill them with what they cannot comprehend or attain by any merely human means.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

Three SSPX seminarians killed near Econe

People of good will will note with sorrow that three seminarians of the SSPX, attending the seminary in Ecône, were killed in an avalanche in nearby Nendaz.

I urge you to pray for them and for comfort for their families, friends and fellows. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

“Why the Pope had to do what he did”

The author of the fine  The Heresy of Formlessness, Martin Mosebach, has published in Der Spiegel an essay about the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX Bishops. 

I picked up this English translation here, the Society of St. Hugh of Cluny, based in Norwalk, CT.   You might recall that there is a very sensible priest there.

Let’s see what Mosebach has to say with my emphases and comments.

The Body of the Church
Why the Pope Had to Do What He Did.

By Martin Mosebach

The Catholic Church is experiencing an unprecedented moment in her recent history. A sacerdotal act of the Pope – the removal of the excommunication of four bishops who had been consecrated contrary to the prohibition of his predecessor in the Petrine office – encounters an outraged lack of understanding not only of the non-Catholic public but also of many Catholics and even bishops, who have openly renounced their loyalty to the pope. Forty years after the Second Vatican Council, which attempted an “opening of the Church to the World”, the Catholic Church has been struck dumb – as if she does not recognize any more her own institutions.

What is a Catholic Bishop? Is he a senior administrative official of the Church? Is he a high-ranking politician, who can be subjected to party discipline? This is how non-Catholics (certainly contemporary ones) view the bishop, because they never have been told anything else. For Catholics, the bishop embodies the highest form of the priesthood, connected with the capacity to represent Jesus Christ himself in the giving of the Sacraments. He receives this capacity irrevocably upon his consecration and no pope or council can take it from him. That is the disturbing thing about the episcopal office: even the most unworthy and scandalous bishop always remains a bishop, capable until his last breath of adding new bishops to the line of apostolic succession.

What is excommunication? Exclusion from a political party? That’s how non-Catholics understand it – they like to call exclusion from the communist party “excommunication.” Catholics should know that a complete exclusion from their Church is absolutely impossible. For the Church, a baptized Christian cannot become an untouchable by any deed, however terrible it may be. If the Church, as the most extreme punishment, forbids a baptized Christian from confessing his sins, from receiving the Eucharistic Christ at Mass and from receiving the sacraments at death, she does so always in the hope of soon lifting the excommunication. Ultimately, no spiritual authority wants to accept the responsibility of letting a man die uncomforted. Strictly speaking, he who offends against the unity of the Church excommunicates himself. The cancellation of the excommunication cannot be denied him if he honestly desires to return to this unity.

The use of excommunication as a means of political pressure ( as it was often done in the Middle Ages) has been justly condemned. The Jewish philosopher Simone Weil called such excommunications a mortal sin of the Church. The fact that murderers and child molesters are not automatically excommunicated shows how little excommunication has to do with moral approval. The community that receives again an excommunicated person is a community of sinners.  [Exactly.  We have a Church not of the pure and for the pure alone, but of sinners and those who are in need of purification.]

These are likely to have been the principal considerations of Pope Benedict when he lifted the excommunication of the four bishops who had been consecrated in a manner sacramentally valid but contrary to canon law. For the pope, it must have been a tormenting thought that these bishops, in isolation, could have succumbed to the temptation to perpetuate the schism and consecrate additional bishops. The sacraments form the heart of the Church. The danger that they could be permanently dispensed while in breach of unity must have troubled the pope exceedingly.  [Especially a Pope who in early years had been steeped in St. Augustine and St. Bonaventure.]

Now, in the meantime, the whole world has had the opportunity of hearing on television one of the four bishops, the Briton Williamson, utter the most revolting theses regarding the persecution of the Jews at the time of Hitler. Behind the seemingly dispassionate poker face of the prelate there was revealed a paranoia bordering on madness. This was linked, as had been long known in the Fraternity, to a complete, insane, system composed of similar “secret knowledge.” It is understandable that a general horror prevailed, on seeing that such a man might exercise his office as an official Bishop, reconciled with the pope.

Why, however, did the general public not notice that bishop Williamson specifically cannot exercise his office, because the lifting of the excommunication did not affect his suspension from the office of bishop. [Yes.  All it means is that they are now no longer forbidden to receive those sacraments they can receive.  It doesn’t mean they can dispense the sacraments in the name of the Church.]  Instead, they indulged in conjectures as to whether the Pope after all had a secret inclination to anti-Semitism. This, regarding a Pope, who, leaving aside his addresses in Auschwitz and in the synagogue in Cologne, has tried in his theology – one could say, like no other pope since Peter – to read and understand the Gospel as the work of the Jews. It even extended as far as the laughable report that the pope had set the conditions for the lifting of the suspension of the bishops only under the pressure of public opinion.

No one should deceive himself: this pope does nothing under the pressure of public opinion. [Really? I think he made statements after the Regensburg Address and after this flap in reaction to public opinion.  But he did NOT give the Regensburg Address of lift the excomm’s because of public pressure to do so.  On the contrary!]

The question was posed whether Benedict XVI knew of Williamson’s speeches. To be sure, he can’t help but have noticed the spiritual atmosphere in the SSPX. [The Holy Father has been involved as long as anyone in the Church’s hierarchy in the reconciliation of this group.  I think he must understand them very well.  That is one of the reasons why I think he considered it necessary to move forward in this way.]  Unreality and fanaticism resounded from the many attacks that the bishops of the Fraternity directed against Benedict. And it is very well possible that the knowledge of a growing pathological narrowing of the minds drove the pope to act. [Hmm… hard language.  I tend to think of hardening of positions and the passage of time.  Mosebach sees not just a hardening, but a deepening of a spirit contrary to the Roman Pontiff, etc.  Could be.  If anything, the subsequent actions of at least Bp. Fellay would perhaps somewhat ease one’s conscience in that regard.]

Twenty years ago, as Cardinal and prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, he had already labored with all his strength for a reconciliation with the SSPX. At the time their founder, the legendary Archbishop Lefebvre, still lived. He had participated in the Council and had only become an opponent when the “movement of ‘68” made inroads in the Church and made a revolution out of the reform. Lefebvre refused to give up the traditional, ancient mass rite and Paul VI responded by suspending him.  [Lefebvre also ordained priests without permission back when.]

Cardinal Ratzinger attempted to win over the old man and promised that the pope would name a bishop faithful to tradition for the community. Then Lefebvre’s distrust was aroused – he felt he was being strung along. He broke off the negotiations and consecrated four bishops with whom he was excommunicated immediately thereafter. Had Lefebvre acted rightly by following his hunch? [We shall perhaps never know.  Certainly many in the Curia would have tried to hose the SSPX in the context of that concordat.  But they would have had defenders as well. God knows.  We don’t.]  Cardinal Ratzinger in any case must have been affected by the death of this man in the state of excommunication. [I have a story about that.  One morning I was into the offices of the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei quite early.   I worked there. I was getting everything turned on and opened.  The doorbell rang.  I thought it was the secretary digging for her keys.  I opened the door to find Card. Ratzinger.  With a sad expression he told me he had received a call that Lefebvre had died and wanted to let us know as soon as possible.  He himself had come in early.  So, I got on the  phone and let the Secretary and Cardinal know.  I can attest from how he said it and his expression that Papa was not pleased at the news of L’s death.]  For, unlike most bishops of this time, it was impossible for him to deny any justification to Lefebvre’s struggle. “Whomever these teachings do not please he does not deserve to be a man.” This hymn of liberalism from Mozart’s “Magic Flute” became the maxim of the Church that had become liberal. The SSPX was hermetically sealed off. [And many also hermeneutically sealed themselves off.] It was not permitted to participate in the discussions of a post-conciliar Church so enamored of discussion. [And that is something I sadly fault them for.  They abandoned many of us still fighting and taking wounds in the trenches.]  Its young priests celebrated in basements and garages. One could say that the Fraternity had circled the wagons but around these wagons yawned a void – nobody cared about that.

Every sociologist knows what quickly becomes of small oppositional groups cut off from interaction with reality. That this group was endangered would have been sufficient for a responsible priest to care for it. But more was at stake here: as misfortune would have it, exactly this group had made its mission the preservation of the greatest treasure of the Church.  [Quite a phrase: "the greatest treasure of the Church".  WDTPRSers know what that is!]

Even today it is a difficult undertaking to speak of the importance of the liturgy for the Church. [There it is.] Twenty years ago it was almost hopeless finding a sympathetic ear. It was a foregone conclusion for many clerics that the traditional, over 1500-year old liturgy of the Church was decorative mumbo-jumbo for the nostalgic and for aesthetes. [Today we hear talk of "elitism".] It had the same importance for “emancipated Christians” [not just emancipated… but evolved… superior… mature...] as the string quartets played on occasions of state have for politics. What had been true throughout the entire history of the Latin Church had been forgotten: that liturgy is the visible body of the Church; [GET THAT? "liturgy is the visible body of the Church"] that Church and liturgy are identical. It is the mystic depiction of the whole plenitude of revealed truths.  [It is encounter with MYSTERY.  Sound familiar? ] It is the locus of faith, where subjective conviction and feeling become objective contemplation and encounter. [YES!]  It is this liturgy which carried the Christian faith through the centuries. The success of the mission in the entire world was owed to its sacrality in liturgical language and chant.

The liturgy had soared above the deep divides of European history because it was equally removed from every epoch into which it entered. It is always unseasonable and therefore always an image of the other reality which awaits man. This great form of the liturgy had been softened up by Paul VI’s radical reform of the mass – an intervention unheard of in the entire history of the Church. It splintered into a thousand improvisations. [And put the whole of Western Civilisation in peril.  Save the Liturgy – Save the World.  Change how we pray as a Church and you change the belief and identity of her members.  Those members them behave differently in their own spheres, in the public square.]

But why was Archbishop Lefebvre the only bishop in the entire world who uncompromisingly rejected this attack against the liturgy and thus against the Church? With this no to a process of decomposition so highly dangerous to the Church, Lefebvre entered ecclesiastical history.  [NB: Mosebach is not delving into the other issues of difficulty, more purely theological.  But he doesn’t need to.  The Church’s liturgy is more important in these sense, in theis examination.]What gave him the strength was the milieu, only found in France, of a Catholic laity which had acquired its world view in the struggle against aggressive republican secularism. This was the tragedy of Lefebvre and his movement: they rescued the ancient liturgy but linked it to the struggle of political parties in recent French history.  [As the SSPX Williamson thing started to heat up, and journalists were calling me for background, I reminded them on the French dimension to this and past and contemporary political overtones.] The only refuge that the traditional liturgy had found threatened to become its prison. Pope Benedict had already freed it from this prison with his Motu Proprio and had given it back with its universal claim to the entire Church.

Must he not, however, have felt a sense obligation to the SSPX; that, for all its faults, it had become an instrument for preserving the Holy of Holies of the Church in a time of crisis? Whether the SSPX succeeds in finding a place in the multiplicity of the present day Church remains to be seen. Its historic mission, in any case, has been concluded. [Perhaps this is overstated.  In the time after the Motu Proprio there has been progress, and it is accelerating. There is a long way to go.]

In the last few days it could be heard again and again that the Vatican is incapable of conveying its concerns to the public. It is certainly true that there would have been less excitement among those of good will if, for instance, one had emphasized at the lifting of the excommunications that Bishop Williamson remained suspended until further notice. [All four are still suspended until further notice.]  But one cannot underestimate what black holes of ignorance have been created even in believing Catholics by more than thirty years of neglected religious instruction. These cannot be closed even by the cleverest public relations work. [In other words, you cannot make up for 30 years of devastation of catechesis and liturgical experience by means of a press release.  Or a number of releases or conferences.  Agreed.] Regarding the pope, broad circles know only that he is for human rights and against condoms. It is happily declared that “the Church can’t return to before the Second Vatican Council.” Few, however, think about the contradictions and need for interpretation of the most important texts of this council.

Does anybody notice that the pope has acted exactly in accordance with the theology of the council in his magnanimous lifting of the excommunications? The restoration of the sacral visage of the church must remain for the majority of “worldly” observers foreign and incomprehensible. [Let us not forget frightening.] Probably only later generations will grasp that the restoration of liturgical identity was worth a great sacrifice. Building up is, after all, slower than tearing down. [Brick by brick, friends.]

Naturally, things could reach a point that the state and society lose the taste for tolerating within their borders a corporation, which visibly stands under a different law and defends values other than those of the secular majority. [and maybe soon] The coarseness of a chancellor in an election campaign gives us a foretaste. As was done under Bismarck, the accusation could be made against the Catholics that they are bad citizens of the state because their heart is ultramontane; it clings “over the mountains” to the pope and his authority. [Culture War with higher tech weapons and wider battlefields.]

Ultramontane – this word describes perfectly the Catholic mentality: with a small part of one’s consciousness to be not German, [or American, or English, etc.] not contemporary, [in continuity, not rupture] not cosmopolitan. [not mired in the city of man, but facing toward the city of God.] Despite all distrust, the commonwealth does not have to fare ill with such members – the result of the constant tension between the Pope and the Emperor in the Middle Ages was nothing less than the European idea of freedom.

 

Exquisite points.  Truly thought provoking.

I call your attention back to the core: the connection of liturgy and the Church, our identity.

This is one reason why some people so violently resist the idea of the SSPX reentering the mainstream of the Church.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
59 Comments

Let me make this clear

To those sending me obtuse e-mail filled with indignation that the POPE would rehabilitate a HOLOCAUST DENIER!, I offer these comments. 

To those journalists and columnists out there who are grinding their gears over this issue, please pay attention.

Please read what I and others have written about SSPX Bishop Williamson and try to get the facts clear in your head.

The Pope does not approve of hatred of the Jews or denial of the Holocaust simply because he lifted a man’s  excommunication, incurred for entirely different reasons, reasons entirely internal to the good ordering of the Church herself.

The Pope’s merciful act is not a sign of approval of anything.

When his excommunication was lifted Bp. Williamson did not automatically become thereby a fully functioning and approved bishop of the Catholic Church. 

He was validly consecrated in 1988, but he is forbidden, as are the other three bishops, to function as a bishop or as a priest in and for the Church.  Forbidden. Still.  That hasn’t changed.

Let’s try to keep this simple.

They can now go into a church and go to confession.

When the excommunication was lifted, those four men were from that moment permitted to confess their sins and receive absolution, receive Communion if they are in the state of grace, and receive Last Rites if they are about to die. 

Get it now? 

Don’t let their clothing and titles confuse you.

Lifting the excommunication was a single step in a process of reconciling a wound in the Church’s unity.  It isn’t more than that.  It isn’t a political statement or a judgment on debates or settled matters of history. 

It was an act of kindness for a matter internal to the Church’s unity.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments