Benedict XVI and Chancellor Merkel: telephone tag

Apparently the Holy Father and the Chancellor of Germany have had a chat by phone, at Merkel’s request.

This is in from ANSA.

Shoah: Papa a colloquio con Merkel
Condividono ‘comune e profonda adesione a monito per umanita”’

(ANSA) – ROMA, 8 FEB – Il Papa e Angela Merkel condividono ‘una comune e profonda adesione al monito sempre valido della Shoah per l’umanita”. Benedetto XVI e il cancelliere tedesco hanno avuto un colloquio telefonico richiesto dalla Merkel, che nei giorni scorsi aveva chiesto maggior chiarezza sulla posizione del Papa sulla Shoah. La Merkel era intervenuta dopo la revoca della scomunica ai quattro vescovi lefebvriani, tra i quali il negazionista Richard Williamson.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

SSPX Bp. Williamson: ceased to function as seminary rector

It may be that the obvious shoe has dropped and that Bp. Williamson has been retired so that he won’t be an obstacle.

Rorate has this interesting story.

The Turning Tide:

Four SSPX Bishops send joint letter to the Pope


Spanish blog La Cigüeña de la Torre (the first to report that the decree of removal of excommunications was imminent) reports this evening that a special letter has been received at the Apostolic Palace:
A joint letter of the four Bishops ordained by Archbishop Lefebvre was received in the Apostolic Palace, in which they thank the Holy Father for the lifting of the excommunications.


The letter, written in French, is very affectionate and conciliatory.

La Cigüeña also informs that Bishop Richard Williamson "has ceased [his functions] as director of the Seminary of La Reja [Argentina]". This information has not yet been confirmed.

posted by New Catholic at 10:44 PM

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

QUAERITUR: words of absolution

From a reader:

      I know you are busy but I have a quick question regarding the valid words of absolution in the sacrament of penance.  If the priest says the whole formula starting with God the Father of Mercies, and then at the end says "I absolve you from all of your sin", instead of I absolve you from your sins, does that actually invalidate the confession?  I am just asking because last week I think the priest who seemed extremely faithful but is a foreigner didn’t use the proper words, so now I listen more carefully.  I’m a scrupulous person, so I tend to think that it isn’t a crucial difference, and that it is just me, but hearing so many people say the crucial thing is that "I absolve you from your sins"  makes me question how much the English can change before it is invalid, like sin instead of sins, and of instead of from etc…

 

In your case, I would not worry.  In my opinion, that variation did not invalidate the absolution.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments

New uses for unused confessionals

A reader sent me this photo of a confessional.

New uses for unused confessionals

CLICK the photo to find out how it is being used now!

What signal does this send to people about the importance of the sacrament of penance?

I’m just askin’…

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
94 Comments

WDTPRS: Septuagesima (1962MR)

A few thoughts about Septuagesima and its prayers for Holy Mass, excerpted from articles I wrote for The Wanderer, to which you can subscribe for an online edition.

The Roman Station is St. Lawrence outside-the-walls.

In the pre-Conciliar calendar the time after Epiphany or Season of Epiphany, could be longer or shorter depending on the date of Easter.  When Easter falls early, some of the texts for Sundays Masses after Epiphany are bumped to the end of the year.  The time after Epiphany and the time after Pentecost are both called the tempus per annum, “the time through the year”.  That terminology remained in the Novus Ordo to describe the two parts of “Ordinary Time”. 

This Sunday, however, we begin the Tempus Septuagesimae, "the time of Septuagesima".

In the traditional Roman calendar this Sunday is called Septuagesima, Latin for the “Seventieth” day before Easter.  This number is more symbolic than arithmetical. The Sundays which follow are Sexagesima (“sixtieth”) and Quinquagesima (“fiftieth”). Ash Wednesday brings in Lent, called in Latin Quadragesima, “Fortieth”. 

These pre-Lenten Sundays prepare us for the discipline of Lent, which once was far stricter.

Septuagesima gives us a more solemn attitude for Holy Mass.  Purple is worn on Sunday rather than the green of the time through the year. The pre-Lent Sundays have Roman Stations.  The Alleluia is sung for the last time at First Vespers of Septuagesima and is then excluded until Holy Saturday.  There was once a tradition of “burying” the Alleluia, with a depositio ceremony, like a little funeral.  A hymn of farewell was sung.  There was a procession with crosses, tapers, holy water, and a coffin containing a banner with Alleluia.  The coffin was sprinkled, incensed, and buried. In some places, such as Paris, a straw figure bearing an Alleluia of gold letters was burned in the churchyard.  Somehow that seems very French to me.

The prayers and readings for the Masses of these pre-Lenten Sundays were compiled by St. Gregory the Great (+604), Pope in a time of great turmoil and suffering.  Pre-Lent is particularly a time for preaching about missions and missionary work, the evangelization of peoples. 

With the Novus Ordo there is no more pre-Lent.  A terrible loss.  We are grateful that with Summorum Pontificum the pre-Lent Sundays have regained something of their ancient status.

NB: The antiphons for the first part of Mass carry a theme of affliction, war, oppression.  We hear from 1 Corinthians on how Christians must strive on to the end of the race.  The Tract (which substitutes the Gradual and Alleluia) is the De profundis.

COLLECT:
Preces populi tui,
quaesumus, Domine, clementer exaudi:
ut, qui iuste pro peccatis nostris affligimur,
pro tui nominis gloria misericorditer liberemur.


This prayer, as well as the other two we will see, is in versions of ancient sacramentaries, such as the Gregorian. Our wonderful Lewis & Short Dictionary says ex-audio means “listen to” in the sense of “harken, perceive clearly.” There is a greater urgency to exaudi (an imperative, or command form) than in the simple audi. Clementer is an adverb from clemens, meaning among other things “Mild in respect to the faults and failures of others, i.e. forbearing, indulgent, compassionate, merciful.” We are asking God the omnipotent Creator to listen to us little finite sinful creatures in a manner that is not only attentive but also patient and indulgent.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:
We beseech You, O Lord, graciously to hark
to the prayers of Your people:
so that we who are justly afflicted for our sins,
may mercifully be freed for the glory of Your Name.

The first thing long time readers of this column will note, as well as you who attend mainly the Novus Ordo, is the profoundly different tone of this prayer.  It is just as succinct as most ancient Roman prayers.  It has the classic structure.  But the focus on our responsibility and guilt for our sins is very alien to the style of the Novus Ordo.  For the most part, such direct references to our sinful state were systematically excised from the ancient prayers which survived in some form on the post-Conciliar Missale Romanum.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

What some Catholic Colleges have in their theology departments

This blog, the Journey To A New Pentecost, has posted an editorial printed in the newspaper of the Diocese of Davenport, IA. 

It is by Keith Soko, Ph.D, who is associate professor of moral theology and chair of the theology department at St. Ambrose University.

My emphases and comments.

EWTN offers an outdated view of the church

By Keith Soko
Published:

Wednesday, January 28, 2009 1:25 PM CST

Every day, people switching through their cable and dish TV channels encounter the Eternal Word Television Network (EWTN). The station is Mother Angelica’s, and I give her credit for doing what no one else has done, operate a Catholic cable network.  [People watch what they want to watch.  Keep that in mind as you read.]

Many Catholics have chosen to operate within the mainstream media, such as actor Martin Sheen and producer Father Ellwood Kieser.  But Mother Angelica persevered in taking a small television station and making it a national offering. At best, it offers coverage of the Vatican and the U.S. bishops’ conferences.

[Here is comes…] The problem is it is seen by many as “the Catholic channel.” Unfortunately, it is Mother Angelica’s version of the Catholic Church, and it is an outdated view of what “church” is.  [When they just talk about "church" and not "the Church" you know what sort of low ecclesiology they embrace.]

 EWTN is a complex blend of high technology and outdated theology, promoting a version of Catholicism that no longer actually exists. [At this point you must ask: Who says?  This guy?  What you are hearing is someone who has embraced the "hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture". ] That previous model of the church — hierarchical, clerical, absolute, unchanging — where the laity “pray, pay, and obey,” was abandoned when Vatican II (1962-1965) ushered in a greater role for the laity, male and female, married and single.

Those changes brought Mass in the language of the people, the priest facing the congregation, churches built in a semi-circle with the congregation gathered around the eucharistic table and greater participation by the laity including as eucharistic ministers and readers. [And those have all really helped a lot, right?  He predictably has a shallow understanding of what "participation" means.  It is mainly focused on what people do.]  Later developments brought back the role of the deacon and females were allowed to be altar servers. [Allowed after his friends violated the Church’s law for years.] It’s a model that sees the Catholic Church as the “people of God,” a “community of believers,” a “pilgrim people.”  [Again… he wants you to believe that the Church no longer is any of those other antiquated (=bad) things.  Watch.]

The changes of Vatican II responded to the “signs of the times,” but also looked to the scriptural foundations of the church, with the focus on Jesus, and purged excesses that had developed over history.  [Progressivists always want you to buy the premise that what the Church gained over the centuries is a foreign encrustation, like barnacles and seaweed which slow the ship…  oopps… out dated symbol.  The idea is this the "pristine" is automatically better than what came later.]

The late Cardinal Avery Dulles offered five models of what the church is and should be: [this again?] institution (its organization and structure); sacrament (the church being a visible sign of Christ in the world); a herald proclaiming the good news; a servant (especially to the poor and vulnerable), and a mystical communion (the Body of Christ) or community of believers (disciples). Vatican II emphasized the co-responsibility and collaboration of all Catholics in being church. EWTN focuses only on the first model, the institution, and primarily on the pope, cardinals and bishops. It largely ignores the role of most female religious orders and the laity.  [?!?  Really?  It seems like everytime I turn on EWTN there are lay people on.  And good female religious I know are members of community which are quiet and contemplative, not looking for limelight.  The "hey look at us" orders are probably more to the taste of the writer because they are involved with doing stuff.]

Of course, there is debate today whether the church has actually gone far enough in implementing the vision of Vatican II, or if it is retreating to its pre-Vatican II mode. [This "debate" he mentions is, I think, his actually position.  This is what, for example, Hans Kung thinks:  the Council didn’t go nearly far enough.  Discontinuity is good in that way of thinking.] That mode was insular, removed from the world rather than engaged with it, unresponsive to historical developments and unchanging.  [B as in B.  S as in S.  When was the great explosion of evangelization?  The increase of religious orders?  The building of schools and hospitals which served the whole of society?  Insular?  Risable.]

EWTN operates as a high-tech machine advocating a pre-Vatican II theology. If you have a question, ask Father. [I think the website Q&A section has lay people answering lots of questions.  And is it wrong to ask a priest?] Need some advice, ask Father, or Sister, in full habit. [He has a real problem, this guy.] Answers are absolute, easily memorized. It waxes nostalgia for the time of Father O’Malley, when priests and nuns filled the Catholic landscape. [Obviously that was a bad thing… actually to see priests and religious and recognize them in public.  That there might be a lot of them, rather than the few we have now.  I think this fellow might be anti-clerical.] You wouldn’t know, for example, that most Catholic parishes, grade schools, high schools, colleges and universities, publishers and health care institutions are run by lay Catholics.  [Like many liberals, he assumes people are stupid.] You wouldn’t know that theologians exist, certainly not lay theologians  [Here is the real problem…. it’s all about him.  I wonder if he was recently turned down for a job.  What do you imagine he thinks of Ex cordo Ecclesiae?] — men and women. You wouldn’t know of intelligent discussion, and some dissent, by Catholics on a number of issues.  [Get that connection between "intelligent" and "dissent"?]

You would get the impression that answers to complex questions are black and white, with no nuance or qualification. [Think about it.  When you ask a question about some, for example, moral dilemma, you really want an ambiguous answer which leaves you just as confused as you were before you asked.  Maybe more.  If you don’t believe that there are objective truths and that the Church teaches properly on faith and moral, you wind up thinking that everything has to be nuanced.  As a matter of fact, you convince yourself that you are oh so deep.. so intelligent.   This is the problem addressed in Fides et ratio… the conflict in the modern world between faith and reason… authority and intellect.]  EWTN comes dangerously close to making an idol of “the church” itself, rather than seeing it as a vehicle that leads people to God. The church is seen as something on a pedestal, “out there,” rather than being all of us. That idolatry is a hazard of any religion, and can easily become fundamentalism.  [Pretty condescending, this guy.  Think about this for a moment: all salvation is mediated through the Holy Church which Jesus Christ, God and Savior, established.  But we are not supposed to put the Church on a pedestal.]

Catholic theology today consists of four sources: Scripture, tradition (including church teaching), [tradition includes Church teaching!  nice!] reason (our intellect), and our own human experience. Unfortunately, EWTN promotes a view of church and theology that focuses almost exclusively on tradition with a capital “T.” What’s ironic, though, is that it promotes this top-heavy, clerical model in a time when priestly vocations are dwindling, when educated Catholics are leaving the church, and when more lay men and women, motivated by the spirit of Vatican II and the Gospels, feel called to ministry.

God love Mother Angelica for her endeavor. [What a weasel.] I’m sure that many find some spiritual fulfillment in its offerings. [more condescension] But don’t call it “the Catholic channel.” Far from it, it’s a version of the Catholic Church that has long since passed on. And, it is an oppressive model, to lay men and women, as well as to the clergy themselves. My advice? If you want nostalgia, watch an old Bing Crosby movie. But don’t call it theology, and don’t call it the Catholic Church today.

Bitter, isn’t he?  Such condescension usually comes from disappointment. 

He is the chair of the theology department at Ambrose College.  He teaches moral theology.  Think about it.

Talk show host Al Kresta of Ave Maria Radio took on this fellow on the air.

UPDATE

 

The Catholic Messenger, embarrassed at the editorial of Keith Soko, above, published a different point of view.

persons, places and things: An opinion is an opinion

By Barb Arland-Fye
Published:
Wednesday, February 4, 2009 2:30 PM CST
St. Ambrose University associate professor Keith Soko’s column criticizing the Eternal Word Television Network (EWTN) has provoked numerous responses.

We have received letters via e-mail, U.S. Postal Service and — a first for us — “blog comments” on our new Web site, www.catholicmessenger.org. [heh heh… welcome to the club]

Soko’s contention that many people incorrectly assume EWTN is “the Catholic channel” and that it presents an outdated view of the Catholic Church was offensive and hurtful to a number of readers who responded.

“EWTN is an excellent teaching tool,” say Elmer and Annette Pollpeter of Burlington, who believe that “our bishop, his diocesan paper, our Catholic schools and universities and our parish priests ought to be encouraging these efforts.”

“EWTN is doing what no other Catholic entity has succeeded in doing: bringing Catholic television programming into the home,” says Madelyn Phares of Princeton. “I do not feel that pre-Vatican II theology is being shoved down my throat by EWTN. And if I did, I would just select a different channel, rather than belittle the entire network in the pages of The Messenger.”

Tim Hart of Fairfield, writes, “Mr. Soko says: EWTN promotes ‘an outdated theology … a version of Catholicism that no longer actually exists.’ Wow! A version of Catholicism? I thought the Church was One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic. I didn’t know there were different versions.” (Hart’s full letter will appear in next week’s issue).

One letter writer took on a scolding attitude, exclaiming, “Shame on you!” at the beginning and end of her letter.

Another demanded that Soko retract his opinion column and write an apology in The Catholic Messenger.

Others criticized Soko personally and made disparaging remarks about St. Ambrose University, The Catholic Messenger and the Diocese of Davenport.

Some of the more uncharitable comments were from bloggers, [again… welcome to the club] people who write entries for inclusion in our Web log (“blog” for short), which appears beneath the on-line article. The Catholic Messenger may accept or reject blog comments, and at least a half-dozen have been rejected because they stifled rather than furthered dialogue. 

The first blogger to submit a comment, Sister Dawna Sutton, SFCC, thanked Soko for sharing his opinion. “I could not have said it better. (EWTN) is an outdated view of Catholicism today.”

A friend who e-mails me regularly with gently worded critiques of The Catholic Messenger thought Soko’s reasoning was immature and wondered how often he watches the station and whether he had watched it lately. My friend wished Soko had provided more specific examples of programming he found fault with. I would have to agree with her on that observation.

In responding to my friend and other e-mail writers, I said that the Opinions Page is a place for people to express opinions. Nothing Keith Soko said was blasphemous or denied church teaching.  His opinion piece has generated plenty of thoughtful responses as well as some unconstructive criticism.

It’s a good thing to get Catholics talking about issues that are important to them. In part, that’s what makes The Catholic Messenger a Catholic newspaper.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
110 Comments

Thanks to readers!

Thanks to readers!First of all… thanks for your patience as I battle with the comments problem.

Next, I appreciate the support you are giving to WDTPRS in the Bloggers Choice Awards in the Religious Blog category.  It is a bit of a hassle, since you have to register, but we could really use your help if you haven’t voted. 

My days are instantly brightened when something comes one of your readers who checked out my amazon.com wish list.

Many thanks go out to WM of WI for two books, The Complete Poems and Plays of T.S. Eliot – my copy I had had for years went missing and I am in a literary group reading Eliot.  So… I am very grateful.  WM also sent a book about "the Widow"!  The Widow Clicquot: the story of a champagne empire and the woman who ruled it by Tilar J. Mazzeo.  This should be near and dear to the hearts of all WDTPRSers!

Thanks to readers!A few days back MS of WA sent some USB extension cables.  I mentioned this before, but they are really useful!  The USB hub also changed entirely how I use the laptop I have dedicated at the moment to streaming the Z-Cam.  Also, the birdbath will be great, but I need a heating element for it: I think a block of ice might not be to useful for the birds.  

Thanks to readers!I was delighted to receive from JT of DC DVDs of BSG 4.1!  This is a great series and I will enjoy going back over the episodes.

MG of MN sent several great Italian sausages, which are yummy. 

Also, I am not quite sure who sent it, but a got another bottle of colatura!  This is fantastic stuff.  I had some for lunch today!

A little chopped raw garlic in a bowl with a couple spoonsful of colatura and really hot red pepper.  Let is macerate and cook your superfine pasta, "angel hair" is is sometimes called.  Toss it together and enjoy!

I will also be listening to the music CD of James McMillan’s Seven Last Words.  I am slowly but surely working on a "Seven Words" of my own. It is nice to hear and reflect on different versions and formats.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Thanks to readers!

QUAERITUR: children at Mass

And now a reader is seeking to get me killed by asking about children at Mass.

My wife and I recently attended a TLM for First Friday, and had an unpleasant experience before Mass. Our 1 year old daughter noticed the statue of OL of Mount Carmel, and began to say, not yell, "Baby Jesus" with excitement. After pointing out a few more saints and doing the same, a gentleman from across the aisle turned to us and said loud enough for everyone in the chapel to hear, "Would you please STOP that!"

Thankfully, the priest actually made a shushing gesture toward him, and even came to tell me and my wife that we and our daughter were just fine. This was not the first time someone has commented so rudely about children, be it mine or others, at a TLM.
 
To get to the point: What is your opinion regarding children in Mass? Do they belong even if they misbehave? Of course unruly children ought to be taken out and disciplined, but I have 3 children under 5, so none of them have reached the age of reason as of yet, and none of them perfectly behave. Still, I feel it is important for them to attend Mass. What do you think?

Many people seek out the TLM because, when it is a Low Mass, it is quiet.  

Babies and small children aren’t always quiet.

These days many people must drive a long distance to get to the Mass at the parish they prefer.  For families with children, that means packing everyone up and bringing everyone.  The days of people in cities being able to leave some kids at home while parents went to Mass in shifts is over.

I think another factor is that people like attending Holy Mass as a family.

In any event, this is the third rail for a priest.

 

I will leave you with this story, however.

A baby was fussing loudly during the sermon and the mother started out of the church with the little darling, passing right in front of the pulpit as she headed for the door.

The priest wanted to demonstrate how open he was to noisy children at Mass, no matter how distracting they might be, stopped his sermon and said "Please don’t think you have to leave.  The baby doesn’t bother me."

Over her shoulder she shot back, "You’re bothering the baby!"

I think this little story is a good reminder both that we must be patient with each other, but also be aware that perhaps some people truly are bothered and desire a quiet atmosphere.

It is possible that, at times, parents are not entirely aware of the effect of their small children on others in the church.

It might not be the very best choice to sit in the front pew, far from the door.  It might not be the best choice not to leave when junior is turning purple from the screaming.

At the same time, babies are our future.  This is life, folks.  We all have to be patient with each other.

Oh… another thing… some people who attend TLMs can indeed be a little sour.  If you are one of them… stop being a jerk.

I will now back away from the third rail. 

No… I will run!

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
126 Comments

POLL: Tempus fugit

POLL: Tempus fugitTracking time is how we track change.  It is salutary thing to consider how we are slipping toward the future.

Tempus fugit.

How do you do it?

Do you use a wristwatch?  A clock?  Just your cellphone? 

Sundial?

Just look out the window at the bank’s clock on the corner?

I actually once used an astrolabe for a time, for kicks.

Are you asking people all the time?

Okay… that’s not really the point.

If you use a gadget for telling time, is it digital or analog?

Yah.. yah… my watch has both, but it is mainly analog.

POLL CLOSED

My usual timepiece is …

  • Analog (64%, 499 Votes)
  • Digital (36%, 276 Votes)

Total Voters: 775

Posted in POLLS |
32 Comments

When in Rome… this Sunday… support the Pope

If you are in Rome or anywhere near, please go to St. Peter’s Square for the Holy Father’s noontime Angelus and show your support.

Bring your friends and urge them to bring their families and friends.

Support the Pope.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments